Abstract
We consider the inverse boundary value problem in two dimensions of determining the coefficients of a general second-order elliptic operator from the Cauchy data measured on a nonempty arbitrary relatively open subset of the boundary. We give a complete characterization of the set of coefficients yielding the same partial Cauchy data. As a corollary we prove several uniqueness results in determining coefficients from partial Cauchy data for the isotropic conductivity equation, the Schrödinger equation, the convection–diffusion equation, the anisotropic conductivity equation modulo a group of diffeomorphisms that are the identity at the boundary, and the magnetic Schrödinger equations modulo gauge transformations. The key step is the construction of novel complex geometrical optics solutions using Carleman estimates.
Main Result
Let Ω⊂R2 be a bounded domain with smooth boundary
, where γk,
, are smooth closed contours, and
is the external contour. Let
be an arbitrarily fixed nonempty relatively open subset of ∂Ω. Let ν be the unit outward normal vector to ∂Ω, and let
. We set
and identify x = (x1, x2)∈R2 with z = x1 + ix2∈C, and by
we denote the complex conjugate of z∈C.
We consider a second-order elliptic operator:
![]() |
[1] |
Here, g = g(x) = {gjk}1≤j,k≤2 is a positive definite symmetric matrix in Ω, and Δg is the Laplace–Beltrami operator associated to the Riemannian metric g:
![]() |
where we set {gjk} = g-1. Throughout this paper, we assume that
, and (A,B,q),
, j = 1, 2 for some α∈(0,1), are complex-valued functions. We set
![]() |
We define the set of partial Cauchy data by
![]() |
where
is the conormal derivative with respect to the metric g.
The goal of this paper is to determine the metric g and coefficients A, B, q from the partial Cauchy data
. In the general case, this is impossible. There are the following main invariants of the Cauchy data in the problem.
-
Conformal Invariance. Let
be a strictly positive function. Then, 
[2] This follows because the Laplace–Beltrami operator is conformal invariant in two dimensions:
- Gauge Transformations. It is easy to see that the set of partial Cauchy data of the operators e-ηL(x,D)eη and L(x,D) are the same provided that η is a smooth complex-valued function such that

[3] - Diffeomorphism Invariance. Let
be a diffeomorphism such that
. The pull back of a Riemannian metric g is given as composition of matrices by
where DF denotes the differential of F, (DF)T denotes its transpose, and ∘ denotes matrix composition. Moreover, we introduce the functions:
[4]
. Then, 
[5]
We show the converse; namely, a complete list of invariants of the problem. We have
Theorem 1.
Suppose that for some α∈(0,1), there exists a positive function
such that
. Then,
if and only if there exist a diffeomorphism
,
satisfying
, a positive function
, and a complex-valued function η satisfying 3 such that
where
Calderón’s Problem and Other Applications
Calderón’s Problem.
The question proposed by Calderón (1) is whether one can determine the electrical conductivity of a medium by making voltage and current measurements at the boundary.
In the anisotropic case, the conductivity depends on direction and is represented by a positive definite symmetric matrix {σjk}. The conductivity equation with voltage potential f on ∂Ω is given by
![]() |
We define the partial Cauchy data by
![]() |
[6] |
It has been known for a long time that
does not determine σ uniquely in the anisotropic case (2). Let
be a diffeomorphism such that F(x) = x for x on
. Then,
where F∗σ is given by 4.
In the case of full Cauchy data (i.e.,
), the question of whether one can determine the conductivity up to the above obstruction has been solved in two dimensions for C2 conductivities in ref. 3, Lipschitz conductivities in ref. 4, and merely L∞ conductivities in ref. 5. See also ref. 6. The method of proof in all these papers is based on the reduction to the isotropic case using isothermal coordinates (7).
We can prove the uniqueness for Calderón’s problem with partial Cauchy data:
Theorem 2.
Let σ1,
with some α∈(0,1) be positive definite symmetric matrices on
. If
, then there exists a diffeomorphism
satisfying
and
such that
For the isotropic case, this result was proven in ref. 8 and in fact follows from Theorem 1 in the case where g = I and A = B = 0. We mention that ref. 9 has proven a similar result for general Riemann surfaces in the case where g is not the identity but fixed.
Case Where the Principal Part Is the Laplacian.
In the rest of this section, we assume that the principal parts of second-order elliptic operators under consideration are the Laplacian: g = I ≡ {δjk}.
For the case when A1 = A2, B1 = B2, and full data, this result was proven by Bukhgeim (10).
Theorem 3.
If
, then
[7] and in the domain Ω we have
[8]
[9]
Corollary 4.
The relation
holds true if and only if there exists a function
satisfying
such that
[10]
Proof of Corollary 4.
We only prove the necessity because the sufficiency of the condition is easy to check. By 8 and 9, we have
. This equality is equivalent to
Applying Lemma 1.1 (p. 313) of ref. 11, we obtain that there exists a function
in the domain Ω0 that satisfies
[11] [h]|Σk are constants,
![]()
and
Here, Ω0 = Ω∖Σ is simply connected where
, Σj∩Σk = ∅ for j ≠ k, Σk are smooth curves that do not self-intersect and are orthogonal to ∂Ω. We choose a normal vector νk = νk(x),
to Σk at x contained in the interior
of the closed curve Σk. Then, for
, we set
, where (·,·) denotes the scalar product in R2. Setting
, we have
Therefore, by 8,
[12] The operator L1(x,D) given by the right-hand side of 10 has the Laplace operator as the principal part, the coefficient of
is
, the coefficient of
is
, and the coefficient of the zero-order term is given by the right-hand side of 12. By 7, we have that
and
, where the function
is equal to a constant on each connected component of
. Let us show that the function η is continuous. Our proof is by contradiction. Suppose that η is discontinuous, say along the curve Σj. Let the function u2∈H1(Ω) be a solution to the following boundary value problem:
[13] Assume, in addition, that u2 is not identically equal to zero on Σj. Let
be one connected component of the set
and
. Without loss of generality, we may assume that
. Indeed, if
, we replace η by the function
. Because the partial Cauchy data generated by the operators L1(x,D) and L2(x,D) are the same, there exists a solution u1 to the following boundary value problem:
[14] Then, the function v = e-ηu2 verifies
Because
on
, we have that v ≡ u1. On the other hand, u1∈H1(Ω) and v are discontinuous along one part of Σj, and we arrive at a contradiction.
Let us show that
. Suppose that there exists another connected component of
of the set
such that
. Assume that u1, u2 satisfy 13, 14.
Then, the function v = e-ηu2 verifies
Moreover, because
on
, we have that
The uniqueness of the Cauchy problem for the second-order elliptic equation yields v ≡ u1. In particular, v = u1 on
. Because u1 = u2 on ∂Ω, this implies that
. We arrived at a contradiction. The proof of the corollary is completed.
Next, we apply Theorem 3 to several cases and state our results on the unique identifiability, modulo the natural obstructions, of some important inverse boundary value problems with partial Cauchy data arising in mathematical physics.
The Magnetic Schrödinger Equation.
We consider the case of the magnetic Schrödinger operator.
Denote
, where
are real-valued,
, rot
. The magnetic Schrödinger operator is defined by
![]() |
Let us define the following set of partial Cauchy data:
![]() |
Theorem 3 implies the following corollary.
Corollary 5.
Let real-valued vector fields
,
and complex-valued potentials
,
with some α∈(0,1), satisfy
. Then,
,
on Ω and
on
.
We mention that this result was not known even in the case of full data. In this case, ref. 12 proved a uniqueness result assuming that both the electric and magnetic potentials are small. Still in the case of full data, ref. 13 proved a uniqueness result for a special case of the magnetic Schrödinger equation, namely the Pauli Hamiltonian.
Laplace Equation with Convection Terms.
Another application of Theorem 3 is to the Laplace equation with convection terms. For real-valued a, b, and complex-valued q, we define the following set of partial Cauchy data:
![]() |
Then, we have the following corollary.
Corollary 6.
Let α∈(0,1),
, and
. If
, then (a(1),b(1)) ≡ (a(2),b(2)).
This corollary generalizes the result of ref. 14, where the uniqueness was proved assuming that the measurements are made on the whole boundary.
We also mention that Theorem 3 implies that partial Cauchy data on arbitrary
uniquely determine any two coefficients of the triple (A,B,q). A particular case is the following corollary.
Corollary 7.
For j = 1, 2, let
for some α∈(0,1) be complex-valued. We assume either A1 = A2 or B1 = B2 in Ω. Then,
implies (A1,B1,q1) = (A2,B2,q2).
Sketch of Proof of Theorem 3
The key of the proof is the constructions of families of τ-parameterized solutions u1 = u1(τ)(x) and v = v(τ)(x) with τ∈R satisfying L1(x,D)u1 = 0, u1|Γ0 = 0 and L2(x,D)∗v = 0, v|Γ0 = 0. Here, L2(x,D)∗ is the adjoint to L2(x,D) and
. By u2 we denote the solution to L2(x,D)u2 = 0 with u2|∂Ω = u1|∂Ω (we assume for simplicity that there is a unique solution of the boundary value problem). Then, the coincidence of the partial Cauchy data yields ∇u1(τ) = ∇u2(τ) on
. Therefore, integration by parts gives
![]() |
[15] |
Then, the proof relies on the constructions of suitable u1 and v, which are complex geometrical optics (CGO) solutions.
CGO Solution. We look for the geometrical optics solution u1 of the form:
| [16] |
The Phase Function. Let the holomorphic function Φ = φ + iψ satisfy
![]() |
[17] |
where
. The critical points of the function Φ play an important role in the proof. The following proposition shows that the union of the sets of critical points of the functions satisfying 17 is dense in Ω.
Proposition 8.
Let
be an arbitrary point in Ω. There exists a sequence of functions {Φϵ}ϵ∈(0,1) satisfying 17 such that there exists a sequence
, ϵ∈(0,1), and
Moreover, for any j from
we have
Let
be a tangential vector field to ∂Ω. In order to prove 7, we use the phase function Φ given by the following lemma.
Proposition 9.
Let
be an arc oriented clockwise with left endpoint x- and right endpoint x+. For any
there exists a function Φ(z) that satisfies 17, ImΦ|∂Ω∖Γ∗ = 0 and
all the critical points of ImΦ from the set
are nondegenerate, and the left or the right derivative of ImΦ of order seven is not equal to zero at x±.
The functions
,
are defined by
in Ω,
,
in Ω,
. The amplitudes are of the forms
,
, where a is a holomorphic function and d is an antiholomorpic function such that
on Γ0. Here and henceforth, if ∂za(z) = 0, then we call a antiholomorphic.
Let
be some fixed point from
. In addition, the functions a and d have the following properties:
![]() |
We introduce the operators
and
and the operators
![]() |
Here,
,
,
,
,
, ζ = ξ1 + iξ2.
Denote
,
, where M1(z) and
are polynomials such that
![]() |
Thanks to our assumptions on the regularity of A1, B1, and q, the functions g1, g2 belong to
.
The function a1(z) is holomorphic in Ω and
is antiholomorphic in Ω and
![]() |
Construction of the Correction Term u11. Let
![]() |
where
and
are polynomials such that
![]() |
Let e1(x), e2(x) be smooth functions such that e1 + e2 ≡ 1, e2 vanishes in some neighborhood of
, and e1 vanishes in some neighborhood of ∂Ω.
The function u11 is given by
![]() |
Construction of the Correction Terms a2,τ(z) and 
Observe that the following asymptotic formulas hold true for any point on the boundary of Ω:
![]() |
where σ1,
, m1, and
are some smooth functions,
,
,
, and
,
satisfy
![]() |
We define the functions
and
satisfying
Let
![]() |
Here, M5(z),
are polynomials such that
. Let a holomorphic function a2,0 and an antiholomorphic function d2,0 satisfy
![]() |
Finally, we set
![]() |
Construction of the Correction Term u12. We look for the function u12 in the form u12 = u-1 + u0. The function u-1 is given by
![]() |
We set φ = Re Φ and Oε = {x∈Ω; dist(x,∂Ω) ≤ ε}. For the construction of u0, first we consider the following boundary value problem:
| [18] |
Lemma 1.
(a) Let ε > 0 be small such that
, f∈Lp(Ω) with p > 2 and
. There exists a solution of 18 satisfying
(b) Let f∈L2(Ω) and q = 0. There exists a solution of 18 satisfying
Here, C1 > 0 does not depend on the choices of τ, f, q.
Let
. Observe that the function
can be represented as a sum of mj(τ,·) where
![]() |
and
Moreover,
. Then, the correction term u0 can be constructed using Lemma 1.
Carleman Estimate. Lemma 1 is derived from the following Carleman estimate with a degenerate weight function.
Lemma 2.
Suppose that Φ satisfies 17. Then, there exist τ0 and C independent of u and τ such that
[19] for all
and all |τ| > τ0.
CGO for the Adjoint Equation. The operator L1(x,D)∗ has the form of the operator L1(x,D) with different coefficients for the first- and zero-order terms. Similarly to u1, we construct the CGO solution
Here, the functions
,
satisfy
,
in Ω,
, and
,
. The smooth holomorphic function b(z) and the antiholomorphic function
have zeros of order five on
, are not equal to zero at
, and satisfy the boundary condition
on Γ0.
Using the phase function Φ constructed in Proposition 9, we compute the right-hand side of 15 up to the terms of order
:
![]() |
Here, F0 and F1 are independent of τ. This immediately implies 7. Moreover, the equation F1 = 0 implies that there exist a holomorphic function
and an antiholomorphic function
such that
| [20] |
and
| [21] |
Computing the asymptotic formula of the right-hand side of 15 with an error up to the order
and using 20, 21, we have
![]() |
[22] |
where
,
, and
are some constants independent of τ.
Let η be a smooth function such that η is zero in some neighborhood of ∂Ω and
. Observe that the partial Cauchy data of the operator L2(x,D) and the operator e-sηL1(x,D)esη are exactly the same. Therefore, we have the analog of 22 for these two operators with
and
replaced by
and
. The coefficients A1, B1 should be replaced by
,
. The functions
will not change. The function q1 should be replaced by
. This immediately implies that
. By Proposition 8 we construct the set of functions Φϵ satisfying 17 such that the union of the sets of the critical points of these functions is dense in Ω. This finishes the proof of 8 and 9. The proof of the theorem is completed.
Sketch of Proof of Theorem 1
For simplicity, we restrict ourselves to the case that Ω is simply connected. Suppose that the two operators
![]() |
generate the same partial Cauchy data. Multiplying the metric g2, if necessary, by some positive smooth function
, we may assume that
![]() |
[23] |
Observe that without loss of generality, we may assume that there exists a smooth positive function μ2 such that g2 = μ2I. Indeed, using isothermal coordinates we make a change of variables in the operator L2(x,D) such that g2 = μ2I. Then, we make the same changes of variables in the operator L1(x,D). The partial Cauchy data for both operators obtained by this change of variables are the same.
Let ω be a subdomain in
such that Ω∩ω = ∅,
, and the boundary of the domain
is smooth. We extend μ2 in
as a smooth positive function and set
in ω. By 23,
.
There exists an isothermal mapping χ1 = (χ1,1, χ1,2) such that the operator L1(x,D) is transformed to the following form:
![]() |
[24] |
where μ1 is a smooth positive function in
, and C1, D1, r1 are some smooth complex-valued functions. Consider a solution to the problem
of the form 16 with the holomorphic weight function Φ1. Then, the function u1(x) = w(χ1(x)) satisfies
Because the partial Cauchy data for the operators L1(x,D) and L2(x,D) are the same, there exists a function u2 such that
![]() |
[25] |
Using 23 and 25, we extend u2 on
such that
| [26] |
Let φ2 be the harmonic function in
such that
![]() |
We claim that
| [27] |
Thanks to the Carleman estimate (19) there exists τ0 = τ0(ϵ) such that
| [28] |
where C0 = C0(ϵ) is independent of τ and δϵ → 0 as ϵ → 0. On the other hand,
. Here,
,
,
. Then, by 26, the following holds true:
![]() |
[29] |
This equality implies 27 immediately. Indeed, let for some point
from ω
| [30] |
Then, there exists a ball
such that
| [31] |
Let us fix positive ϵ1 such that
and 2δϵ1 < α′. Form 29 by 28 and 31 we have
![]() |
where τ > τ0 if
and τ < -τ0 if
. The above inequality contradicts 30.
Let Ξ = χ1,1 + iχ1,2. Using the Cauchy–Riemann equations, we construct a harmonic function ψ2 such that the function Φ2 = φ2 + iψ2 is holomorphic in
. Moreover, we take the function Φ1, which may be holomorphically extended to some domain
such that
. Observe that Φ2 = Φ1∘Ξ in ω. Then,
in ω. The function Ξ may be extended up to a single-valued holomorphic function
in
such that
and
.
In Ω, consider the new infinitesimal coordinates for the operator L1(x,D) given by the mapping
. In these coordinates, the operator L1(x,D) has the form
![]() |
[32] |
Because
, the partial Cauchy data for the operators L2(x,D) and
are exactly the same. The operators L2(x,D) and
are particular cases of the operator 1. Because
, the Cauchy data
and
are equal. We multiply the operator
by the function
and denote the resulting operator as
. Therefore, by Corollary 4, there exists a function η that satisfies 3 such that
. The proof of the theorem is completed.
Footnotes
The authors declare no conflict of interest.
*This Direct Submission article had a prearranged editor.
References
- 1.Calderón AP. On an inverse boundary value problem; Seminar on Numerical Analysis and Its Applications to Continuum Physics; Río de Janeiro: Sociedade Brasileira de Matematica; 1980. pp. 65–73. [Google Scholar]
- 2.Kohn R, Vogelius M. Identification of an unknown conductivity by means of measurements at the boundary. In: McLaughlin D, editor. Inverse Problems: SIAM–AMS Proceedings; Philadelphia: Society for Industrial and Applied Mathematics–American Mathematical Society; 1984. pp. 113–123. [Google Scholar]
- 3.Nachman A. Global uniqueness for a two-dimensional inverse boundary value problem. Ann Math. 1996;143:71–96. [Google Scholar]
- 4.Sun Z, Uhlmann G. Anisotropic inverse problems in two dimensions. Inverse Probl. 2003;19:1001–1010. [Google Scholar]
- 5.Astala K, Lassas M, Päivärinta L. Calderón’s inverse problem for anisotropic conductivity in the plane. Commun Part Diff Eq. 2005;30:207–224. [Google Scholar]
- 6.Astala K, Päivärinta L. Calderón’s inverse conductivity problem in the plane. Ann Math. 2006;163:265–299. [Google Scholar]
- 7.Ahlfors L. Lectures on Quasiconformal Mappings. Princeton, NJ: Van Nostrand; 1966. [Google Scholar]
- 8.Imanuvilov O, Uhlmann G, Yamamoto M. The Calderón problem with partial data in two dimensions. J Am Math Soc. 2010;23:655–691. [Google Scholar]
- 9.Guillarmou C, Tzou L. Calderón inverse problem with partial data on Riemann surfaces. arXiv:0908.1417.
- 10.Bukhgeim A. Recovering the potential from Cauchy data in two dimensions. J Inverse Ill-Pose P. 2008;16:19–34. [Google Scholar]
- 11.Temam R. Navier-Stokes Equations: Theory and Numerical Analysis. Providence, RI: American Mathematical Society; 2001. [Google Scholar]
- 12.Sun Z. An inverse boundary value problem for the Schrödinger operator with vector potentials in two dimensions. Commun Part Diff Eq. 1993;18:83–124. [Google Scholar]
- 13.Kang H, Uhlmann G. Inverse problems for the Pauli Hamiltonian in two dimensions. J Fourier Anal Appl. 2004;10:201–215. [Google Scholar]
- 14.Cheng J, Yamamoto M. Determination of two convection coefficients from Dirichlet to Neumann map in the two-dimensional case. SIAM J Math Anal. 2004;35:1371–1393. [Google Scholar]


























































































































