Neuroimaging in Amyotrophic Lateral Sclerosis

Summary

Amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS) is a motor neuron disease characterized by progressive degeneration of upper motor neurons (UMN) and lower motor neurons (LMN). While LMN dysfunction can be confirmed by electromyography (EMG) and muscle biopsy, UMN involvement is more difficult to detect, particularly in the early phase. Objective and sensitive measures of UMN dysfunction are needed for early diagnosis and monitoring of disease progression and therapeutic efficacy. Advanced magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) techniques, such as diffusion, perfusion, magnetization transfer imaging, functional MRI, and MR spectroscopy, provide insight into the pathophysiological processes of ALS and may have a role in the identification and monitoring of UMN pathology. This article provides an overview of these neuroimaging techniques and their potential roles in ALS.

Electronic supplementary material

The online version of this article (doi:10.1007/s13311-010-0011-3) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

INTRODUCTION

Amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS), also known as Lou Gehrig’s disease, is a fatal neurodegenerative disorder affecting upper motor neurons (UMN) in the motor cortex as well as lower motor neurons (LMN) in the brain stem and spinal cord. Patients with ALS suffer from a progressive paralysis of the skeletal muscles, resulting in loss of voluntary movement, ability to speak and eat, and eventual loss of respiratory function [1]. The motor function phenotypes of ALS are highly heterogeneous and determined by three primary independent attributes: body region of onset; relative mix of UMN and LMN involvement; rate of progression [2]. Phenotypes that predominantly affect specific body regions are associated with extremes of disease progression; for example, patients with bulbar onset are typically associated with a more rapid decline [2, 3]. The cause of ALS is generally unknown, although approximately 2% of cases are due to mutations in the superoxide dismutase gene [4]. The disease is incurable and until now only one drug, riluzole, has been shown to be somewhat effective in prolonging the life span of patients with ALS [4].

The classical neuropathological features of ALS include loss and degeneration of the large motor neurons in the gray matter of the spinal cord, brainstem, and cortex, as well as degeneration of the corticospinal tract (CST) that contains axons of the cortical UMN. Other extramotor systems are also involved to various degrees. About 2–3% of ALS cases are accompanied by frontotemporal dementia [5, 6], while in approximately 50% of cases cognitive impairment can be observed [7].

The diagnosis of ALS is currently based on clinical features, electromyography, and the exclusion of other diseases with similar symptoms. LMN dysfunction can be confirmed by electromyography and muscle biopsy, whereas UMN involvement is more difficult to detect, particularly in the early phase [1, 4]. Objective and sensitive measures of UMN dysfunction are thus needed since delayed diagnosis may lead to the loss of motor function, which might not be corrected by therapeutic interventions [7]. Furthermore, longitudinal studies will be required to monitor the disease progression and treatment efficacy.

In the search for the UMN markers, several neuroimaging modalities, especially diffusion tensor imaging (DTI) [8–16], proton magnetic resonance spectroscopy (¹H-MRS) [14, 15, 17–20], perfusion imaging [21], magnetization transfer imaging [22] (MTI) and functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) [23–25], have been used with varying success. This article presents an overview of these neuroimaging methods and their potential roles in ALS.

CONVENTIONAL MRI

In patients with ALS, conventional MRI is used principally to exclude other pathologies, such as cerebral lesions, skull base lesions, cervical spondylotic myelopathy, other myelopathy, conus lesions, and thoracolumbar/sacral radiculopathy [7, 26, 27]. Once diseases mimicking ALS are ruled out, subtle neuroimaging signs that are supportive of ALS are looked into.

Several studies have reported abnormal findings on T1-weighted, T2-weighted, proton-density, and fluid-attenuated inversion recovery images in patients with ALS [28, 29]. Consistent features that are indicative but not specific for the diagnosis of ALS include hyperintensity in the CST, hypointensity in the motor cortex, and brain atrophy.

Hyperintensity along the corticospinal tracts

Hyperintensity along the CST on T2-weighted or fluid-attenuated inversion recovery images is most readily identified in the posterior limb of the internal capsule (PLIC) and may also be seen in the centrum semiovale and ventral brain stem [26, 27]. However, some of these findings have also been reported in normal controls [26]. The frequency of hyperintense lesions in the CST of patients with ALS varies significantly in different studies and does not correlate with clinical scores [26, 28].

Hypointensity in the motor cortex

Hypointensity in the motor cortex on T2-weighted images has been observed in a fraction of patients with ALS. The observed hypointensity may be due to a T2 shortening effect from excessive iron deposition [30], fibrillary gliosis, and/or macrophage infiltration [28, 31]. Theoretically, the presence of paramagnetic or ferromagnetic materials at a high enough concentration will cause susceptibility effects. Similarly, the presence of a tissue with low water content will also lead to hypointensity. However, such a change is neither sensitive nor specific to ALS pathology.

Brain atrophy

The voxel-based morphometry (VBM) approach is an automated statistical technique that has been used to detect regional differences in brain tissue density and tissue amount [32, 33]. It has been validated as a powerful tool for analyzing changes in gray or white matter (WM) volumes in the brain [32, 34]. VBM studies in ALS patients suggest that the regional gray matter loss is not only confined to the motor cortex, but extends to the frontal, temporal, parietal, and limbic regions [34–37]. The frontal regions have been reported to have the most severe atrophy in patients with ALS and frontotemporal dementia [37]. Several studies have also reported regional WM loss in ALS, including that in the corpus callosum, cerebellum, frontotemporal, and occipital regions in ALS [5, 34]. However, global brain atrophy in ALS is relatively mild [35].

DIFFUSION TENSOR IMAGING

Basic physics

Diffusion imaging probes the self-diffusional movement of water molecules, which can be detected by the attenuation of MRI signal using a diffusion weighted sequence [38]. When unimpeded, water molecules move in a random manner (isotropic diffusion). However, the presence of obstacles, such as axonal membranes and myelin sheaths in WM fiber tracts, hinders this molecular motion in a particular direction, resulting in anisotropic diffusion. Diffusivity of water is generally higher in directions along fiber tracts than in the perpendicular direction [38]. This process of diffusion can be mathematically described by a diffusion tensor ellipsoid, which is characterized by its three eigenvectors and the corresponding eigenvalues (λ₁, λ₂, and λ₃). The eigenvector associated with the largest eigenvalue denotes the predominant orientation of fibers in a given imaging voxel.

The most commonly used indices for estimating diffusion are mean diffusivity (MD) and fractional anisotropy (FA) [39], which can be calculated according to Eqs. (1) and (2), respectively

1

2

where denotes the mean of the three eigenvalues.

MD is a measure of the directionally averaged magnitude of diffusion and is related to the integrity of the local brain tissue. FA represents the degree of diffusion anisotropy and reflects the degree of alignment of cellular structure [39].

DTI techniques also allow interregional fiber tracking, known as diffusion tensor tractography, which allows tracking of the major WM tracts [16, 40, 41]. This process can be carried out with a wide variety of algorithms. The commonly used streamline tractography is generally performed using a line propagation technique, which uses continuous number fields [41, 42] and multiple regions of interest (ROIs) [16, 41]. Tracking is typically launched from a "seed" voxel from which a line is propagated in both retrograde and antegrade directions according to the major eigenvector at each voxel. Tracking propagates in the direction of the eigenvector that is associated with the largest eigenvalue. The propagation terminates when it reaches a voxel with FA lower than a specified FA threshold or when the angle between two principle eigenvectors is greater than a specified angle threshold.

Probabilistic tractography is a relatively novel approach in which probabilistic maps of fiber connectivity between brain regions are generated. The value of each voxel in a map indicates the likelihood that the voxel is included in the diffusion path between two ROIs [40, 43]. Diffusion tensor tractography has been shown to be helpful in guiding the placement of ROIs on the CST [15, 44].

Clinical application

DTI can provide important measures of UMN dysfunction. Changes in tissue structure can lead to alterations in the diffusion characteristics, which can in turn be reflected by the changes in FA and MD values. Both ROI-based approaches and tractography studies have demonstrated significant changes in diffusion parameters along the CST in the brains of ALS patients [8–10, 12, 13, 15, 45]. The most common finding is a reduction of FA in the CST, which is thought to be due to the neuronal degeneration of UMN. Increased MD along the CST has been reported by some investigators [9, 12, 45, 46]; however, no such changes were observed in another study [10]. In one of these studies, Sage et al. [45] spatially interpolated FA and MD over the course of CST. FA decrease could be demonstrated at nearly all levels of the CST, with the most significant reduction in the PLIC. MD showed a more constant course over different levels of the CST and tended to be elevated at the cranial level of the CST (FIG. 1). Significant correlations of diffusion parameters with measures of disease severity and duration have been established in a number of studies [9, 10, 15], but these correlations could not be confirmed in other studies [8, 12].

FIG. 1.

Graphs of the interpolated fractional anisotropy (FA) (a) and mean diffusivity (MD) (c) values of the mean corticospinal tract (CST) in patients (green) and controls (blue). Values are shown as the mean ± standard error (SEM). Interpolated z-coordinates (or slices) are shown on the x-axes. The y-axes represent values of FA and MD (10⁻³ mm²/s). Slices in which FA is significantly decreased or in which MD is significantly increased in patients compared to healthy controls are indicated by double arrows and a red asterisk. (b) A reconstructed mean CST with colors according to color encoding of DTI-based color maps overlaid on an anatomical image (flipped to match the x-axes of the graphs) is shown for anatomical reference, together with a vertical bar in white indicating the anatomical structures. MO = medulla oblongata; P = pons; CP = cerebral peduncle; PLIC = posterior limb of the internal capsule; CR = corona radiata; SWM = subcortical WM. Reprinted with permission from Sage et al. [45]. (High resolution version of this image is available in the electronic supplementary material.)

Voxel-based analysis of DTI data has been used to evaluate the WM integrity in ALS [11, 45, 46]. Recently, a hybrid approach, known as tract-based spatial statistics (TBSS) [47], which attempts to combine the best of voxel-based and tract-based analyses is being increasingly used in ALS [48, 49]. A significant advantage of the TBSS approach is that it allows statistical changes to be projected on the skeleton of WM structures. Several studies have reported a significant reduction of FA not only in the CST but also in extramotor regions, including the corpus callosum, frontal and parietal WM as well as the hippocampal formation and insula [36, 45, 48, 49]. Using a different methodology, Agosta et al. [50] recently reported increased axial diffusivity of the uncinate fasciculus in ALS patients and suggested that uncinate fasciculus involvement may be related to the behavioral symptoms of patients with ALS. The results of these studies support the view that ALS is a multisystem degenerative disease in which abnormalities of extramotor areas play an important role in its pathophysiology.

PROTON MR SPECTROSCOPY

Basic physics

MR spectroscopy provides biochemical information on the tissue from a selected ROI. The MR spectrum is a spectral graph in which the x-axis denotes the unique chemical composition of a metabolite in parts per million (ppm) and the y-axis reflects the concentration of that metabolite. Although the MR spectrum can be generated from any element in the periodic table that has an odd number of protons, biological MR studies are generally confined to those involving the ¹H, ³¹P, ¹³C, ²³Na, and ¹⁹F protons. Of these, the most commonly studied is proton (¹H) nucleus due to its abundance in biological tissue (water and fat) and high sensitivity. Only freely mobile small molecules are detected in the in vivo MR spectrum; the signals from membrane-bound larger molecules, such as proteins, are not observed. As the tissue water concentration is about 70 molar, in comparison to the millimolar concentration of metabolites, it is critical to suppress the water signal to detect the small amount of important metabolites. This suppression of the water signal is typically achieved through the use of chemical shift selective water suppression radiofrequency pulses. Similarly, in the brain, the extra-cranial lipid (fat) signals are suppressed using outer-volume suppression techniques. In order to adequately resolve the individual metabolite resonances, it is necessary to optimize the magnetic field homogeneity within the ROI. This is achieved using a procedure called “shimming” in which the magnetic field is iteratively adjusted along the orthogonal axes of the magnet [51].

The MR spectrum in vivo can either be acquired from a single voxel using the single-voxel spectroscopy (SVS) technique or using a chemical shift imaging (CSI) method, in which multiple voxels can be studied simultaneously [27]. The SVS method requires less time than the CSI technique and provides reliable measures of metabolites from the specified ROI; however, it is limited as only a small region of the brain is interrogated at one time. The CSI method takes longer than the SVS method, as it provides spectra from an array of voxels, a single section, or multiple sections. Recently, echo planar CSI has been successfully implemented to further increase the region covered by spectroscopy studies as this technique provides metabolite distribution maps from almost the whole brain with sufficient spectral quality [52, 53]. This technique also allows spectra to be acquired from regions that generally suffer from poor spectral quality on the SVS and CSI methods, such as the brain stem.

The major brain metabolites detected by ¹H MRS are N-acetyl aspartate (NAA), choline (Cho), creatine (Cr), myoinositol (mI), lipid, lactate, and glutamine+glutamate. It is generally accepted that NAA is a marker for neuronal integrity; Cho, a marker of membrane turnover and cell proliferation; Cr, a marker of tissue energy state; mI, an astrocytic marker; lipid signals, indicators of tissue destruction and necrosis; lactate, an indicator of hypoxia; glutamine+glutamate, excitatory markers [51].

Clinical application

Most of the ¹H-MRS studies in ALS have demonstrated that either NAA concentrations [54, 55] or ratios of NAA/Cr, [15, 18, 19, 56] NAA/Cho [15, 17, 55], and NAA/(Cr+Cho) [57] are reduced in the motor cortex (FIG. 2). Because NAA is present primarily in neurons, these metabolic changes reflect a loss or dysfunction of motor neurons. A decreased NAA/Cr and NAA/Cho ratio along the CST with the most pronounced reduction in the precentral gyrus and corona radiata has been shown in patients with ALS [58]. Similarly, a reduction in NAA from the pons and upper medulla has also been reported in ALS patients who have prominent UMN or bulbar signs [59].

FIG. 2.

Magnetic resonance (MR) images and spectra from 2-dimensional chemical shift imaging (CSI) spectroscopy of the motor cortex in a patient with amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS) (a–c) and a control subject (d–f). Transverse T2-weighted (4000/85) MR images show the grid and volume of interest (rectangle) for the CSI study in the patient (a) and control subject (d). Representative spectra of the motor cortex from the (ALS) patient (b, c) demonstrate reduced NAA/Cr and NAA/Cho ratios compared with the control subject (e, f). NAA = N-acetyl aspartate, Cho = choline, Cr = creatine. Reproduced with permission from Wang et al. [15]. (High resolution version of this image is available in the electronic supplementary material.)

The degree of NAA reduction varies significantly from one study to another, probably due to differences in spectral acquisition techniques, the severity of disease, definition of patient, control populations [15, 18, 56], among other factors. There is no consensus on which metabolite ratios accurately reflect UMN involvement [18, 19, 56]. While some studies have reported NAA/Cho ratios as the most sensitive indicator of neuronal loss, others have concluded that NAA/Cr ratio is the most optimal parameter in the diagnosis of ALS [18, 19, 56]. A moderate correlation between NAA concentration from the motor cortex and clinical manifestations (disease severity [15, 60], UMN signs [20], and maximum finger tapping rate [57]) has been reported in some studies. Bulbar-onset patients have lower NAA from the motor cortex compared with those of limb-onset patients [61]. Furthermore, patients with a lower NAA/Cho ratio showed reduced survival [62].

In addition to decreased NAA, increased Cho has been reported in the PLIC in patients with ALS [56]. Increased mI has also been found in the motor cortex in ALS patients [17, 18]. Using a higher field magnet (3 Tesla), Kalra et al. [63] reported that the NAA/mI ratio provided both better sensitivity and specificity for detecting ALS than individual metabolites and demonstrated the strongest correlation with disease severity.

In ALS, decreased NAA is not only restricted to the motor cortex and CST, but this reduction is also observed in premotor regions, the primary sensory cortex, and extramotor frontal regions with relative sparing of the parietal lobe [64]. A recent study demonstrated that alterations of NAA and Cho in ALS are correlated with each other [65]. This correlation is consistent with new pathological findings that diverse membrane proteins which give rise to increased Cho may contribute to motor neuron death [66].

MR spectroscopy can also be used to monitor treatment response. An increased NAA/Cr ratio in the motor cortex has been observed in some studies after a short course of treatment with riluzole [67, 68]. However, no effect was seen after treatment with gabepentin [69]. Thus, it can be concluded that NAA has the potential to serve as a surrogate marker for therapeutic efficacy.

PERFUSION IMAGING

Basic physics

Perfusion is defined as the volume of blood that passes through a mass of tissue per unit time. Brain perfusion, also termed cerebral blood flow (CBF), is expressed in units of milliliters per gram per minute. All perfusion measurements require a diffusible or nondiffusible tracer whose transport in the blood can be measured. Perfusion imaging was pioneered with nuclear medicine techniques using positron emission tomography and single photon emission CT [70, 71].

The two most common methods for measuring tissue perfusion by MRI in the brain are dynamic susceptibility contrast-enhanced imaging, in which a bolus of a gadolinium-based contrast agent is injected and the response is observed in the form of a transient decrease in T2/T2*-weighted MRI signal, and arterial spin labeling (ASL), which utilizes arterial blood water as an endogenous diffusible tracer for measuring CBF. In ASL, CBF is measured by magnetically inverting the magnetization of water protons in the inflowing arteries and collecting the signal after the labeled blood water flows into the imaging region and diffuses into brain tissue. Because this method is entirely noninvasive and can be repeated rapidly, it has been widely used in assessing blood flow in patients with neurodegenerative diseases.

Clinical application

Previous studies using positron emission tomography or single photon emission CT demonstrated reduced regional cerebral metabolism or perfusion throughout the brain in patients with ALS [70–72]. The involved areas were not only limited to the sensormotor cortex, but also included extramotor regions, such as the premotor, prefrontal, cingulate, putamen, insular, and parietal cortex regions [70–73]. In contrast, patients with progressive muscular atrophy appeared to have normal or near-normal cerebral metabolism and CBF [74, 75]. A recent study in ALS showed similar findings using ASL perfusion [21]. These authors also found regional areas where increased ALS severity correlated with decreased gray matter perfusion, suggesting that measurement of brain perfusion may be another useful tool for monitoring disease progression and assessing treatment effects in ALS (FIG. 3).

FIG. 3.

Correlation between the ALS functional rating scale (ALSFRS) and ASL. The figure shows voxel clusters in red where ALSFRS has a positive correlation with ASL perfusion. The images were individually oriented so that the left brain was ipsilateral to the side of the more significant weakness seen clinically. Voxels were only included if they were in clusters of at least 100 voxels (p < 0.001). The images in (a) project these voxels onto a 3-dimensional rendering of the Montreal Neurological Institute atlas. The images in (b) display these same data as a maximum intensity projection on a transparent "glass brain." The dashed lines indicate the extent of the brain that was covered by the ASL perfusion images. Reproduced with permission from Rule et al. [21]. (High resolution version of this image is available in the electronic supplementary material.)

MAGNETIZATION TRANSFER IMAGING

Basic physics

Magnetization transfer imaging (MTI) is based on the exchange of magnetization between protons in free water and protons that are bound to macromolecules. The magnitude of the effect depends on the relative water and macromolecular concentration, surface chemistry and biophysical dynamics of macromolecules and may be quantified by measuring the MT ratio (MTR). MTR can be calculated according to the following equation:

where M₀ is the measured signal intensity from images without the magnetization transfer pulse, and Ms is the measured signal intensity with the magnetization transfer pulse [76]. In the brain, macromolecules contributing to the MT effect include the cholesterol component of myelin, cerebrosides, and phospholipids. MT imaging can be used to determine the local tissue status by assessing MTR values from representative ROIs or by performing MTR histogram analysis of the whole brain. Typically, a low MTR indicates damage to myelin or to the axonal membrane.

Clinical application

MTI has been shown to be able to detect the pathology of the CST in ALS. Da Rocha et al. [22] reported hyperintensity on T1-weighted spin-echo magnetization transfer contrast images along the CST in 80% of patients with ALS. Some studies have also demonstrated a reduction in MTR from the internal capsule in patients with ALS [77, 78], implying the presence of tissue damage in these areas. The results of these studies suggest that MTI facilitates the detection of CST degeneration.

FUNCTIONAL MRI

Functional MRI provides high-resolution, noninvasive estimates of neural activity. When a neural event occurs in a region of the brain, despite the increase in oxygen consumption, there is a subsequent increase in local blood flow that paradoxically results in a decrease in the concentration of deoxygenated hemoglobin in the local microvasculature of the activated region. Since deoxyhemoglobin is paramagnetic, it alters the T2*-weighted magnetic resonance image signal. Therefore, this change leads to an increase in the fMRI signal that has been called the blood oxygenated level-dependent effect [23, 79].

A general pattern of cortical reorganization was found for motor function in patients with ALS when compared with that seen in normal subjects [24], with increased activation of the contralateral sensorimotor cortex, supplementary motor area, basal ganglia, and cerebellum demonstrated on fMR images during motor tasks [24, 25, 80, 81]. Increased sensorimotor activation has also been reported in the brain ipsilateral to the movement [80]. In addition, reduced activation in the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex has been observed, providing further evidence for the existence of frontal lobe function deficits in patients with ALS [81].

CONCLUSIONS

Advanced MRI techniques, such as DTI, MRS, perfusion, MTI and fMRI, are increasingly being used to investigate the anatomic and functional changes in ALS. These novel imaging modalities provide insight into the pathophysiological process in ALS and may play a role in accurate identification of UMN pathology in ALS. Further investigation is needed to determine and to compare the relative utility of these various neuroimaging techniques. New acquisition schemes and analysis procedures require standardization and optimization.