Quarantine and thermal screening got the thumbs down at an international SARS conference in Winnipeg, but the take-home message was that Canada is ready if SARS returns.
Canada's preparedness lies in its “heightened state of vigilance,” said Dr. Frank Plummer, scientific director general of the National Microbiology Laboratory in Winnipeg. “We know how the disease is spread. We know what measures we need to put in place to control it.” Those measures include new guidelines (CMAJ 2004;170 [1]:26), 2 teams of emergency-response disease experts who can be deployed anywhere in the country within 3 hours, and federal plans to equip health workers with new surgical masks and eye protection.
But measures won't include wide-scale quarantine. “The bulk of the evidence [indicates that] people who are asymptomatically infected do not transmit. So there really is not the need for widespread quarantine,” Plummer said at Health Canada's Current Science of SARS symposium in December.
Of 80 813 cases quarantined worldwide, only 21 or 0.03% were probable SARS cases, said Dr. David Bell, a communicable diseases consultant with WHO and a senior medical officer with the US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC).
Nor was thermal screening at airports found to be effective. Of the 10 million travellers who were thermally screened not one was found to be positive for SARS.
The value of questionnaires, signs, travel advisories, and videos to control the spread of SARS, “is hard to quantify,” said Bell.
The real question though, is whether it will return at all. Some say no (CMAJ 2004; 170[1]:68), but others, including Plummer, say it isn't quite that clearcut. “At this point, it appears to be in remission, but it continues to exist in an animal reservoir. It could jump to the human population again as it did in early 2003,” he said. The animal reservoir is comprised of civet cats and raccoon dogs consumed as delicacies in parts of China.
Meanwhile, Americans are questioning whether they are prepared. A report commissioned by the CDC states that an “otherwise containable epidemic may spread rapidly,” due to a lack of SARS specialists and cuts to health budgets. The study recom mends increasing hospital capacity for quarantining more people and improving public health education and communication. — David Square, Winnipeg

Figure. Ten million travellers underwent thermal screening; not one was detected with SARS. Photo by: Canapress, A. Harris
