Modified Hodge test: A simple and effective test for detection of carbapenemase production

Abstract

Background and Objectives

Resistance among bacterial isolates is the leading cause of increased mortality and morbidity worldwide. Carbapenems once thought to be effective are becoming ineffective mostly due to the emergence of carbapenemase. This study was designed to determine in vitro efficacy of Modified Hodge test for detection of carbapenemase production in Gram negative rods.

Material and Methods

The study was done in the Department of Microbiology, Armed Forces Institute of Pathology Rawalpindi Pakistan from January 2010 to December 2010. A total of 200 Gram negative rods from different clinical samples were taken. Those isolates which showed intermediate or susceptible zones i.e 16mm-21mm on disc diffusion were included in the study. These isolates were then subjected to Modified Hodge test.

Result

Out of 200 isolates, 138 (69%) were positive for carbapenemase production by Modified Hodge test. Out of 138 MHT positive organisms, the frequency of E. coli was 38%, followed by Pseudomonas aeruginosa (30%), Klebsiella pneumoniae (17%), Acinetobacter baumannii (12%), Citrobacter diversus (2%) and Enterobacter agglomerans (1.4%).

Conclusion

Modified Hodge test is a simple test which can be performed in the routine lab for detection of carbapenemases in isolates showing intermediate or sensitive zone diameter on disc diffusion.

INTRODUCTION

Infections with resistant bacterial isolates are emerging as an important challenge in health care facilities. Antimicrobial resistance is associated with adverse outcomes, including increased mortality, hospital stay and costs. In addition, a delay in institution of effective therapy, inferior definitive therapy and greater virulence of some resistant strains are responsible for antimicrobial resistance (1, 2).

After methicillin resistant staphylococcus and extended spectrum beta lactamases, another beta lactamase causing resistance among Gram negative organisms is carbapenemase enzyme. This is an enzyme that hydrolyses a group of antibiotics called carbapenems (3, 4). Carbapenems are famously stable to AmpC β-lactamases and extended-spectrum-β-lactamases (5). This group is considered treatment of choice for infections caused by resistant strains of Gram negative bacteria. Unfortunately, resistance to carbapenems in enterobacteriacae is difficult to detect by routine disc diffusion method used by many microbiology laboratories.

Carbapenemases were formerly believed to be derived only from classes A, B, and D, but a class C carbapenemase (CMY) has been described. These enzymes fall into three of the Ambler classes of beta-lactamases A, B and D (6).

Detection of carbapenemases is difficult. It can be detected by phenotypic as well as genotypic methods (7). Among phenotypic tests, MHT is a relatively easy and simple test to be performed in a laboratory.

The study is being undertaken with a view to generally screen the Gram negative rods for the production of carbapenemase as these enzymes do not always produce resistant breakpoints for carbapenems using standardized susceptibility testing methods. The isolate may thus be reported as sensitive while still harboring carbapenemase enzyme resulting in potential treatment failure and dissemination of the resistant isolates.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

This study was conducted in the Department of Microbiology, Armed Forces Institute of Pathology Rawalpindi Pakistan, from January 2010 to December 2010. A total of 200 Gram negative rods recovered from different clinical samples including pus, pus swabs, urine, tissue cultures and bronchoalveolar lavage were taken. The samples were cultured and the organisms isolated were identified by standard microbiological techniques. The antimicrobial susceptibility to carbapenems was done by disc diffusion method. Zone sizes were measured according to CLSI recommendations. The isolates which showed intermediate or susceptible zones for imipenem, i.e 16mm-21mm, were tested for carbapenemase production by Modified Hodge test, as CLSI recommends the MHT to be performed before reporting carbapenem susceptibility results if a clinical isolates has an elevated but susceptible carbapenem MIC (8).

A 0.5 McFarland dilution of the Escherichia coli ATCC 25922 in 5 ml of broth or saline was prepared. A 1:10 dilution was streaked as lawn on to a Mueller Hinton agar plate. A 10 µg meropenem or ertapenem susceptibility disk was placed in the center of the test area. Test organism was streaked in a straight line from the edge of the disk to the edge of the plate. The plate was incubated overnight at 35±2°C in ambient air for 16–24 hours.

Quality control of the carbapenem disks were performed according to CLSI guidelines. Quality control of the following organisms MHT Positive Klebsiella pneumoniae ATCC1705 and MHT Negative Klebsiella pneumoniae ATCC1706 were run with each batch of the test.

After 24 hrs, MHT Positive test showed a clover leaf-like indentation of the Escherichia coli 25922 growing along the test organism growth streak within the disk diffusion zone. MHT Negative test showed no growth of the Escherichia coli 25922 along the test organism growth streak within the disk diffusion as shown in Fig. 1.

Fig. 1.

The MHT performed on a Muller Hinton Agar plate. (1) MHTpositive result (2) MHT negative result; and (3) a clinical isolate, positive result.

RESULTS

Out of a total 200 isolates which were showing intermediate or susceptible zone i.e16mm-21mm for imipenem, 138(69%) were positive for carbapenemase production by Modified Hodge test.

Carbapenemase producing organisms were E.coli 38%, followed by Pseudomonas aeruginosa 30%, Klebsiella pneumoniae 17%, Acinetobacter baumannii 12%, and Citrobacter diversus 2% and Enterobacter agglomerans were 1.4% (Table 1).

Table 1.

Bacteria showing positive results in Modified Hodge test (n=138).

Sr. no.	Name of organism	Number of isolates
1	Escherichia coli	52 (38%)
2	Pseudomonas aeruginosa	42 (30%)
3	Klebsiella pneumoniae	23 (17%)
4	Acinetobacter baumannii	17 (12%)
5	Citrobacter diversus	3 (2%)
6	Enterobacter agglomerans	2 (1.4%)

DISCUSSION

For more than 2 decades carbapenems have been considered the treatment of last resort for managing multidrug resistant infections caused by Enterobacteriacae. Carbapenemases, which hydrolyzes carbapenems and renders them inactive, have been increasingly reported in Asia and Europe, and more recently have been detected in Canada and the United States (10–14).

In 1996, the first isolate of Klebsiella pneumoniae Carbapenemase (KPC) producing organism was isolated in a clinical specimen from a hospital in North Carolina involved in the Intensive Care Antimicrobial Resistance Epidemiology (ICARE) surveillance program. KPCs were infrequently isolated until 2001, when KPC-producing Enterobacteriaceae were reported in several extended outbreaks in different hospitals of New York and New Jersey (15–17). KPCs have also been found in K. oxytoca (18), Escherichia coli (19), Citrobacter spp (20), Pseudomonas aeruginosa (21), Salmonella spp (22), Serratia marcescens (20), as well as Proteus mirabilis (23).

The Modified Hodge test as it is described today is a modified version of Hodge test which was used some years ago. Even the original Hodge test was evaluated utilizing the PCR confirmed IMP-1 and VIM-2 Metallo β-lactamase (MBL) producing isolates. The original Hodge test utilized imipenem 10µg disc which gave fairly good results as it detected 67% cases of MBL producing Pseudomonas aeruginosa and Acinetobacter spp. The other 13 cases which gave initially equivocal or negative results were retested and were declared positive using imipenem discs containing zinc sulphate (24).

In another study done at Centers for Disease Control and Prevention in Atlanta GA in 2007, 45 isolates (26 of K. pneumoniae, 9 of K. oxytoca, and 10 of E. coli) were evaluated by Modified Hodge test and all of them were validated by PCR for the detection of KPC activity with 100% sensitivity and specificity (25). This shows that Modified Hodge test is a very sensitive and reliable test for detection of carbapenemases.

A study was carried out in Greece in 2007 to evaluate different laboratory tests for detection of MBLs in Enterobacteriacae. Modified Hodge test detected 98% cases keeping PCR as the gold standard while only 0.03% was detected as false positive (26).

Recently a study done in Pennsylvania revealed that out of 85 ertapenem intermediate or resistant isolates, 75% were KPC (Klebsiella pneumoniae carbapenemase) positive tested by Modified Hodge test and further confirmed by PCR (27). While in our study out of 100 isolates which were carbapenem intermediate or sensitive, 69% showed the presence of carbapenemase by Modified Hodge test only.

Recently a latest version of carbapenemases, New Delhi metallo-β-lactamase-1(NDM-1) is making headlines all over the world (28). Though the definite diagnosis of NDM-1 rests on PCR but Modified Hodge test can be a very useful screening test for suspecting such cases for epidemiological purpose.

In many healthcare facilities around the world, bacterial pathogens that express multiple resistance mechanisms are becoming rampant, complicating treatment and increasing both human morbidity and financial costs. This necessitates the need for detecting the resistant bacteria so that unnecessary use of broad spectrum antimicrobials can be avoided. The significant finding of our study was the fact that quite a large percentage i.e 69% of our isolates which showed intermediate or susceptible zone sizes on disc diffusion were detected positive by MHT indicating the huge importance of this simple test. Hence majority of such patients would be prescribed carbapenems which would be disastrous on two accounts, firstly the patient would end up in treatment failure and secondly unnecessary usage of carbapenems would further expose this antimicrobial with potential for more resistance.

In conclusion, Modified Hodge test is an easy and simple test to be performed to detect carbapenemases producing bacteria. There is a very high percentage of carbapenemases producing Gram negative rods in our setup. It is imperative that all isolates showing intermediate or sensitive zone diameter on disc diffusion be tested for production of carbapenemases by Modified Hodge test to avoid treatment failures and development of resistance due to unnecessary use of this class of antibiotic.