In an earlier column (November 2001), I noted a distinction between the sorts of people who are committed to saving animals from death, “hoarders” (or “collectors”) and rescuers. Hoarders mindlessly collect as many animals as they can, even when they lack the space or resources to care for them. A hoarder may have 100 cats, many of which are sick, in an excrement-littered apartment and be unable to afford veterinary care. The situation described this month, however, is closer to the other end of the spectrum. We are told that the animals are well fed and appear healthy and that scrupulous attention is given to treating disease and calling for veterinary attention when needed.
Plainly, we are not dealing with the question of whether a terrible life is better than no life, nor are we working with an economically impossible situation or with a mentally ill person. The people in this case seem to be morally motivated, all the more so because they provide homes for allegedly unadoptable animals, spending whatever is necessary.
What is most problematic about this situation is that it could be made better with relatively little expenditure. For example, one could easily build access to the outdoors for these animals; ideally, a set-up in which they could go in and out at will. The owners probably do not realize that noise is a physical stressor and has even been shown to increase the incidence of mammary tumors, though it is also a problem wherever one keeps a group of dogs, even in expensive boarding kennels.
Your job, as veterinarian in this situation, is to share your expertise with the owners to the benefit of the animals. You might suggest ways to improve the housing and husbandry, so as to provide exercise and outdoor access and alleviate boredom to cut down on self mutilation and some kinds of lick granuloma. You might also discuss methods of muffling the sound. You could propose a way to ration the animals' diets, and you should advise on sanitation and disease control. And you can help to determine if the animals are, indeed, “unadoptable.”
Equally important, you can assist the owners in assuring the authorities (and their neighbors) that the situation here is not pathological but, rather, is the case of an elderly couple trying to fill a void in their lives by doing something to help others.
Finally, I am not sure what “unadoptable” means or that anyone should presume to have that knowledge, a priori. I am familiar with people who adopt physically and mentally disabled children, blind and geriatric dogs, and aggressive dogs. “Unadoptable” is not a judgment to be made in the absence of attempts to adopt, which may have been limited in this case.
