Prediction of diabetic retinopathy: role of oxidative stress and relevance of apoptotic biomarkers

Abstract

Diabetic retinopathy (DR) is the foremost cause of blindness in working-aged worldwide; it is characterized by vascular and neuronal degeneration. Features of DR include leukocyte adhesion, increased vascular permeability, neovascularization and neuronal cell death. Early diagnosis and intervention are important to prevent or at least ameliorate the development of DR. Recent reports indicate that pathophysiological mechanisms leading to diabetic retinopathy include oxidative stress and retinal cell death cascades. Circulating biomarkers of oxidative stress such as malondialdehyde (MDA), thiobarbituric acid reacting substances (TBARS), conjugated diene (CD), advanced oxidation protein products (AOPP), protein carbonyl, 8-hydroxydeoxyguanosin (8-OHdG), nitrotyrosine, and F(2) isoprostanes and pro-apoptosis molecules (caspase-3, Fas, and Bax) are associated with increased susceptibility to develop DR in diabetic subjects. Thus, identification of oxidative stress and cell death biomarkers in diabetic patients could be in favor of predicting, diagnosis, and prevention of DR, and to target for novel therapeutic interventions.

Diabetic retinopathy is a vision-threatening disease characterized by neurodegenerative features associated with extensive vascular changes. It remains unclear how these pathologies relate to each other and their net contribution to retinal damage. There are multiple biochemical pathways which contribute to the development of the neurovascular injury in DR. As a result, biomarkers which reflect different pathways are released locally and into the circulation. Early identification of these biomarkers could be in favor of predicting and efficient management of DR. Among these biomarkers are the ones related to inflammatory response, oxidative stress and retinal cell death. Diabetes increases oxidative stress, which plays a key regulatory role in the development of its complications [1, 2]. Hyperglycemia-induced reactive oxygen species (ROS) generation is considered a causal link between elevated glucose and the pathways of development of diabetic complications [3]. Oxidative stress may lead to cell death [4] via apoptotic means. Apoptosis of retinal neurons particularly ganglion cells [5–7] has been demonstrated in diabetic retinopathy as demonstrated by profound retinal abnormalities, evaluated by electroretinography, and potential visual changes evoked before the onset of the first vascular change is detectable in the diabetic retina [8, 9]. Retinal capillary cells also undergo accelerated apoptosis, which precedes the detection of any histopathological changes characteristic of diabetic retinopathy [10]. The current review discusses the markers of oxidative stress and retinal cell death associated with DR.

Oxidative stress and diabetic retinopathy

Chronic hyperglycemia plays a crucial role in the pathogenesis of diabetic retinopathy (DR). The mechanism of hyperglycemia-induced retinal damage is still to be elucidated. However, the oxidative stress which represents an imbalance between excess generation and/or impaired removal of reactive oxygen species (ROS) have been suggested to be the key events in the pathogenesis of diabetic retinopathy. The high content of polyunsaturated fatty acids, oxygen uptake and glucose oxidation make the retina more susceptible to oxidative stress than other tissues [11]. ROS are produced continuously in all cells to support normal cellular functions. However, excess production of ROS, or inefficient removal of ROS, could result in pathological conditions. In addition to ROS, reactive nitrogen species (RNS) are also a part of normal physiological function, and have great potential to contribute to oxidative stress [12]. In the presence of superoxide, nitric oxide spontaneously forms peroxynitrite. Peroxynitrite is much more reactive than superoxide and nitric oxide and can exert direct oxidative modifications through one- or two- electron oxidation processes [13, 14]. Thus, excessive abundance of ROS and RNS with concurrent dysfunction of antioxidant defense systems, which includes reducing enzymes such as superoxide dismutase (SOD), catalase and glutathione peroxidase (GSH) contributes to oxidative stress in diabetic retina. Chronic oxidative stress causes damage to DNA, lipids, proteins, and carbohydrates and disruption in cellular homeostasis resulting in many disease processes of clinical interest [15]. Accumulation of damaged molecules and ROS that are not easily removed contributes not only to the pathogenesis of DR but also to the resistance of retinopathy to reverse even after good glycemic control is reestablished- the metabolic memory phenomenon [16].

Sources of ROS in diabetic retina

Chronic exposure of retinal cells to hyperglycemia causes overproduction of ROS by activation of different enzymatic pathways which more likely interact to create the retinal damage seen in DR (Fig. 1). These sources include but not limited to NADPH oxidase, mitochondrial electron transport chain (ETC), formation of advanced glycation end products (AGEs), aldose reductase/polyol pathway, protein kinase C (PKC) activation and uncoupling of endothelial nitric oxide synthase (eNOS).

Fig. 1.

Hyperglycemia inhibits antioxidant enzymes (superoxide dismutase (SOD), catalase, glutathione (GSH)) and induces generation of reactive oxygen species (ROS) and reactive nitrogen species (RNS) from different sources such as mitochondrial electron transport chain (ETC), NADPH oxidase, cycloxygenase (COX2), advanced glycation end products (AGEs), protein kinase C (PKC), polyol pathway and nitric oxide synthase (NOS). Hyperglycemia-induced generated ROS and RNS, cause lipid peroxidation and oxidative damage of protein and DNA resulting in production of biomarkers such as lipid peroxides and nitrotyrosin. Lipid and protein modification by hyperglycemia-induced oxidative stress leads to upregulation of VEGF and activation of NFκB. VEGF and NFκB-dependent signaling pathway causes retinal vascular and neuronal damage associated with diabetic retinopathy such as hyperpermeability, leukostasis, apoptosis and angiogenesis

NADPH oxidase

Recent studies demonstrated that NADPH oxidase is a major source of ROS in diabetic patients and animals and retinal endothelial cells treated with high glucose [17–20]. ROS production by NADPH oxidase has been linked to the early signs of DR, including increases in ROS generation, vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF) expression, leukostasis and vascular permeability[17, 21]. Additionally, increased NADPH oxidase activity and expression of its catalytic subunit NOX2 has been correlated to increased VEGF expression and retinal neovascularization in a mouse model for ischemic retinopathy [22]. Phagocyte NADPH oxidase consists of two membranous subunits, large catalytic subunit gp91phox (NOX2) and small p22phox as well as cytosolic regulatory subunits, p40 phox, p47phox and p67phox, and the low molecular weight G protein Rac-1 [23, 24]. Phosphorylation of p47phox is crucial for the assembly of the complex [25], while P67phox subunit mediates binding of the complex with activated Rac [26], both are critical for NADPH oxidase activation. Vascular endothelial cells express the same subunits as well as two NOX2 homologues, NOX1 and NOX4 [20]. Previous studies in animal and tissue culture models have shown that NOX2 is expressed at low levels in normal retinas and in retinal endothelial cells maintained under control conditions, but is substantially increased in retinal vessels of animals with diabetic or ischemic retinopathy and in retinal endothelial cells exposed to high glucose or hypoxia [17, 22]. During diabetes other cells in addition to endothelial cells become activated and become sources of NADPH oxidase derived ROS formation. For example, leukocytes are suggested to regulate retinal edema, ischemia and angiogenesis [27] and shown to be activated [28–30]and to become source of oxidative stress [31, 32].

Mitochondrial Electron Transport Chain (ETC)

Mitochondria are the principal endogenous source of superoxide. Hyperglycemia disrupts the normal ETC electron flow leading to electron leak and superoxide generation which induces mutations in mitochondrial DNA resulting in defective subunits of the electron transport complexes causing increased superoxide production at physiological concentrations of glucose [2, 33]. Moreover, mitochondrial ROS suppresses the antioxidant defense mechanisms through inhibition of SOD and GSH leading to enhanced sensitivity of retinal cells to oxidative stress since they cannot scavenge ROS effectively [34–36]. The critical role of mitochondrial superoxide in DR has been demonstrated by recent studies using transgenic mice that overexpress mitochondrial SOD. Overexpression of mitochondrial SOD protected the diabetic retina from oxidative damage and capillary degeneration [36]. This indicates that hyperglycemia-induced oxidative stress can modulate mitochondria function, thus contributing to the development of DR.

Endothelial Nitric Oxide Synthase (eNOS)

eNOS uncoupling is an additional source of superoxide generation in diabetic retina. This occurs, when there is limited amount of its substrate L-arginine or its co-factor tetrahydrobiopterin. Uncoupled eNOS use molecular oxygen as a substrate producing superoxide instead of nitric oxide (NO) [37–39]. Several studies demonstrated the role of eNOS uncoupling in vascular dysfunctions associated with diabetes which reversed by supplemental L-arginine treatment [40, 41]. The role of eNOS in DR has been also demonstrated in human as certain eNOS polymorphism are associated with DR [42].

Polyol pathway

The polyol pathway involves the conversion of glucose into sorbitol by aldose reductase. Sorbitol is then oxidized to form fructose by sorbitol dehydrogenase. Increased polyol pathway in diabetes causes depletion of NADPH. Since NADPH is required for regenerating the intracellular antioxidant, GSH, increased polyol pathway in diabetes enhances oxidative stress [43]. The role of this pathway in the development of DR has been reported in animal model of experimental diabetes and high glucose-treated endothelial cells [44, 45].

Advanced glycation end products

The AGEs are produced from strong glycating dicarbonyl compounds such as methylglyoxal and glyoxal [46]. Chronic hyperglycemia favors glycation reactions and nonenzymatic glycation leading to cross-linking of proteins and in turn alterations in their function, activity, and physical properties. Diabetes, increases production of AGE and its receptor, RAGE, in the retinal microvasculature which becomes irreversible In the late stages of DR [47]. Interaction of AGEs with RAGE activates PKC-δ and subsequently NADPH oxidase to enhance oxidative stress in diabetic retina [48]. ROS generation by AGEs leads to the activation of nuclear transcriptional factor, NF-kB, [49] which has been linked to retinal capillary cell apoptosis [50] vascular inflammation [51, 52] and neovascularization [53, 54].

Protein kinase C activation

Activation of PKC is also considered as a major pathway implicated in the pathogenesis of diabetic retinopathy [55, 56]. High glucose levels increase the release of ROS and the synthesis of diacylglycerol (DAG) increasing the activity of PKC [57]. Activated PKC has been implicated in changes characteristic of diabetic retinopathy such as increased vascular permeability, neovascularization, endothelial proliferation and apoptosis, and regulating the action of VEGF [58–60]. There are cumulative evidences supporting the role of PKC in ROS-mediated diabetic complications. For example, diabetes-induced oxidative stress has been shown to be prevented by PKCβ specific inhibitor (LY53331), and in mice lacking PKCβ isoform [61–63].

Oxidative stress and vascular changes in diabetic retinopathy

Diabetic retinopathy is associated with alterations in the structure and function of retinal microvasculature. For example, basement membrane thickening, pericyte and endothelial cell loss, acellular capillary formation [64, 65], microaneurysm, altered blood flow, leukocyte adhesion, hyperpermeability and neovascularization. Many of these changes have been linked to the oxidative stress-induced biochemical changes. ROS mediate these changes by both direct and indirect mechanisms which include increases in the transcriptional activation of VEGF expression [66], inflammatory mediators [67, 68], AGEs formation on collagen which results in basement membrane thickening [69] and modulation of vasoactive effector molecules such as endothelin-1 and NOS which contribute to changes in blood flow and vascular permeability [70, 71]. VEGF, a proangiogenic factor, is known to play a pivotal role in the development of vascular changes associated with diabetic retinopathy [72, 73]. Hyperglycemia-induced oxidative stress plays a role in mediating both the expression and pathological effect of VEGF [17, 74, 75]. For example, our subsequent studies demonstrated the implication of NADPH oxidase-derived ROS in the development of vascular dysfunctions in ischemic retinopathy. We reported abrogation in ROS formation, retinal expression of VEGF and new vessel formation in mouse model of ischemic retinopathy when treated by NADPH oxidase inhibitor [22]. Further studies on experimental diabetes demonstrated decreased ROS formation, VEGF expression leukostasis, and vascular permeability by NADPH oxidase inhibitor or deletion of its catalytic subunit, NOX2, [21]. Other studies have reported the beneficial effect of antioxidants such as N-acetylcysteine in preventing pericyte loss and endothelial/perivascular cell changes occur early in the pathogenesis of DR [76]. Moreover, PEDF, an essential antiangiogenic factor that produced by different retinal cells has been reported to prevent neuronal derangements, vascular hyperpermeability and leukostasis and VEGF expression in diabetic retinopathy via inhibition of ROS formation [77]. Taken together, these findings confirm the crucial role of ROS in the development of vascular dysfunction in DR.

Markers of oxidative stress

Oxidative stress induces biochemical changes in the serum and target organs of diabetic patients including severe lipid peroxidation, protein oxidation, and oxidative DNA damage and changes in their antioxidant status (Fig. 1). Thus, identification of the by-products induced by oxidative stress in serum, vitreous body, aqueous humor, fibrovascular tissue on the retinal surfaces and urine of diabetic patients could be in favor of predicting, diagnosis and prevention of microvascular complications of diabetes such as retinopathy and nephropathy. Oxidative stress parameters include malondialdehyde (MDA), thiobarbituric acid reacting substances (TBARS), conjugated diene (CD), advanced oxidation protein products (AOPP), protein carbonyl, 8-hydroxydeoxyguanosin (8-OHdG), nitrotyrosine, and F(2) isoprostanes. Several studies demonstrated a marked increase in these products in serum/retinas of diabetic patients or experimental animals and significantly higher in patients or animals with DR than in diabetic patients/animals without DR. Additionally, amelioration of the antioxidant status plays a crucial role in development of DR.

Lipid peroxidation

Lipid peroxidation of cellular structures, an oxidative stress-induced activity, is thought to play an important role in complications of diabetes mellitus, especially in diabetic retinopathy. Measurement of TBARS, MDA or CD provides a convenient assessment of lipid hydroperoxide (LHP) concentration in serum. CD is the initial formation of lipid peroxide while MDA is a decomposition product of peroxidized polyunsaturated fatty acids. The elevated levels of Poly Unsaturated Fatty Acids (PUFAs) and increased rate of glucose oxidation in diabetes make the retina susceptible for oxidative stress and lipid peroxidation. Increased lipid peroxides has been demonstrated in serum of diabetic patients with vascular complications [78–85]. Lipid peroxidation increases also in retinas of diabetic animals and mouse model of ischemic retinopathy [17, 22]. Compared with healthy subjects, diabetic patients demonstrate significantly higher levels of lipid peroxidation products [86–90]. Additionally, patients with features of DR are found to have much more lipid peroxidation products compared with those without DR [85, 86]. Studies by Armstrong et al., demonstrated a statistically significant correlation between the increasing serum lipid peroxidation levels and prevalence of retinopathy in diabetic patient [91] and reduction in retinal cell number in streptozotocin (STZ)-induced diabetic rat model [92]. Similar results have observed by Augustin et al. [93, 94] in patients with PDR where they demonstrated a significant increase in lipid peroxidation in the vitreous and epiretinal membranes.

In addition to the previous markers of lipid peroxidation several studies have demonstrated the role of oxidative stress-induced modification of low density lipoprotein in the pathogenesis of DR [95–97]. Fredrikson et al. [98] reported that patients affected by retinopathy had significantly higher levels of autoantibodies against apolipoprotein B peptides than patients without retinopathy. Thus, autoantibodies against oxidized LDL antigens might also reflect disease severity and the risk of developing vascular complication of diabetes including DR.

A major step regarding the measurement of lipid peroxidation products came with the discovery of F₂-isoprostanes [99, 100]. The F₂-isoprostanes are a family of PG (prostaglandin)-like compounds produced by non-enzymatic peroxidation of arachidonic acid. Of these, (also known as or 15-F_2t-isoprostane) has received most attention because it has been shown to possess certain adverse biological activities [101–104]. Circulating is mainly present bound to phospholipids in situ and is released by the action of phospholipase A₂ [105] and has proved a reliable marker of oxidative stress in human body. However, the quantification of urinary has been proposed as being superior to the measurement of circulating levels, as it is believed to represent a more accurate systemic index of oxidative stress [106]. In their study on human retinas obtained from healthy donors Nourooz-Zadeh and Pereira provided the first direct evidence for free-radical-catalyzed peroxidation of AA in retinal tissue by detecting esterified F(2)-IPs in human retina. Thus they proposed analysis of F(2)-IPs for studying the implications of oxidative injury in various diseases of retina, including diabetic retinopathy and age-related macular degeneration [107].

Biomarkers of DNA and protein oxidative damage

8-hydroxydeoxyguanosine (8-OHdG)

ROS can cause DNA damage and base modifications. 8-OHdG, an oxidized nucleoside of DNA, results from oxidation of guanine residues and is frequently used as DNA lesion marker. Higher levels of 8-OHdG were observed in the mononuclear cells, urine, pancreatic islet and mitochondrial DNA from diabetic patients [108–112] and in kidney tissues of streptozotocin-induced diabetic rats [113]. Moreover, the content of 8-OHdG in the urine, serum and mononuclear cells of patients with type 2 diabetes with either retinopathy or nephropathy were much higher than those in patients without complications. [86, 114, 115]. Therefore, the contents of 8-OHdG in serum could act as a sensitive biomarker for the diabetic retinopathy.

Carbonylated proteins

Proteins can also be modified and become cytotoxic by ROS and RNS, thus contributing to the development of DR. There is association between the elevated biomarkers of protein oxidation with aging and different diseases such as Alzheimer’s, diabetes mellitus and cancer [86, 116, 117]. Protein carbonylation and nitration have attracted a great deal of attention due to its irreversible and unrepairable nature which may serve as an important biomarker in DR.

Carbonylated proteins are marked for proteolysis by the proteasome but can escape degradation and form high-molecular-weight aggregates that accumulate with age. Such carbonylated aggregates can become cytotoxic and have been associated with a large number of diseases and age-related disorders, including Parkinson’s disease, Alzheimer’s disease, cancer, cataractogenesis, diabetes, and sepsis [118, 119], for review see [120]. The implication of protein carbonylation in reflecting the severity of diabetes and its complication has been investigated by many researchers [86, 121, 122]. There is a positive correlation between protein carbonylation and the clinical severity of DR. For example, compared to healthy individuals diabetic patients have significantly increased levels of carbonylated proteins. Furthermore, patients with DR show higher level of protein carbonylation more than in diabetic patients without DR [86, 123].

Protein nitration

Nitrotyrosin is additional marker for oxidative damage of protein that disrupts its normal functions. Several studies have demonstrated that diabetes increases protein nitration in retinas of experimental animals [17, 124, 125]. Nitrotyrosine is an oxidative protein modification which formed from the reaction of free or protein-bound tyrosine with reactive nitrogen species such as free radical nitrogen dioxide [126] and peroxynitrite [127] and has been used as a marker of oxidative stress in retina of experimental animals [17, 124]. Although tyrosine nitration has been associated with development of diabetic and ischemic retinopathies little is known about the targets of tyrosine nitration in retina and the role nitration may play in the pathophysiology of diabetic retinopathy. Recently, Zhan et al. identified some proteins that are nitrated in diabetic rat retina and in rat retinal Müller cells grown in high glucose which could be linked to retinal neovascularization[125]. Additionally, subsequent studies by El-remessy et al., have shown that peroxynitrite-induced tyrosine nitration correlates with accelerated retinal endothelial cell death, breakdown of the brain-retinal barrier, and accelerated neuronal cell death in models of experimental diabetes and neurotoxicity and human diabetes [124, 128–130]. Recent reports demonstrated that accumulation of nitrosylated protein in peripheral blood monocyte of diabetic patients is an emerging marker that reflects oxidative stress-induced protein damage. [131, 132]. Julius et al., 2009 reported that diabetic subjects accumulate significant amount of nitrosylated protein in peripheral blood monocyte and this is positively correlated with the severity of diabetic microangiopathy such as nephropathy and retinopathy [132]. Thus, targeting tyrosine nitration represents potentially effective therapeutic strategy in attenuating retinal vascular neurodegenerative diseases.

Advanced oxidation protein products (AOPP)

Serum level of AOPP is also a novel protein oxidation marker which has been described by different investigators [133–136]. They are elevated in patients with renal insufficiency and diabetes mellitus [137–139]. Additionally, the level AOPP in diabetic patients with features of DR was reported to be significantly higher than in diabetic patients without DR [86, 136].

In addition to the previous markers of oxidative damage of protein and DNA in diabetic patient, mass spectrometric quantification of amino acid oxidation products and glutathionylated hemoglobin has been proposed to serve as markers for the oxidative stress in diabetic patients, in particular those with complications such as DR [140, 141].

Antioxidant status

The antioxidant status of diabetic patient plays a crucial role in producing oxidative stress and development of vascular complications. ROS generation is inhibited by an intracellular enzymatic system composed mainly of glutathione peroxidase (GPx), SOD and catalase (CAT). All serum antioxidants are usually measured together as total antioxidant status (TAS). The reports about the status of antioxidants and antioxidant enzymes in diabetic patients are very contradictory, both increases and decreases of antioxidant activity have been reported [142–145]. Generally, TAS has been shown to be significantly lower in patients with proliferative retinopathy than in diabetics not developing retinopathy [146]. Antioxidants SOD and vitamin C decrease with the progression of the disease, however GPx tends to increase in the later part of the disease [147]. Kesavulu et al., in their study they found that among the erythrocyte antioxidant enzymes, CAT activity was significantly increased in all the diabetics compared to controls, however, there was no difference in the CAT activity between the diabetic patients with or without microvascular complications (MVC) such as diabetic retinopathy or nephropathy. In contrast, GPx activity was significantly decreased in the diabetic patients compared to controls, and further decreased in the diabetics with MVC compared to those without the complications. The SOD activity in diabetic patients was not much different from that of non diabetic controls, but a significant decrease in SOD activity was observed in diabetic patients with MVC compared to those without these complications [85]. The total thiol level as a marker of antioxidant status in diabetics has also shown to be significantly decreased in patient with DR than those without DR [136]. An inverse relation between the level of GSH and HbA1c was also reported in diabetic patients indicating reduction in the antioxidant status in poorly controlled diabetics [141]. Additionally, nonenzymic antioxidants such as vitamin C, vitamin E, and β-carotene that exist biologically for the regulation of redox homeostasis are also depressed by diabetes [148]. Therefore, the level and activity of specific antioxidant enzymes compared to other enzymes that do not match to development of DR could be predictive for the susceptibility to develop DR in diabetic patients.

Oxidative stress related gene polymorphism

There are several studies showing that vascular complications of diabetes develop only in genetically susceptible patients [149–151] and hyperglycemia by itself is not sufficient for the development of diabetic vascular disease. There is tendency to have familial clustering of diabetic nephropathy and coronary vascular disease (CVD). Additionally, there is a significant ethnic difference in the incidence of CVD in subjects with diabetes that could not be explained by differences in conventional cardiovascular risk factors (UK Prospective Diabetes Study Group 1998). Various candidate genes that affect the oxidative stress such as manganese mitochondrial superoxide dismutase (Mn-SOD), endothelial nitric oxide synthase (eNOS), angiotensin-converting enzyme, glutathione peroxidase, superoxide dismutase and haptoglobin demonstrate functional polymorphisms which correlated with the increased susceptibility to vascular diseases and diabetes [152–156].

Manganese superoxide dismutase (MnSOD) polymorphism

Hovnik et al, 2009 investigated polymorphic markers in genes encoding enzymes regulating production of reactive oxygen species in association with diabetic retinopathy (DR) or diabetic nephropathy (DN) in one hundred and twenty four patients with type 1 diabetes and matched for sex, age and duration of diabetes. A positive association of MnSOD genotype Val/Val with diabetic retinopathy but not with diabetic nephropathy was demonstrated [157]. Moreover, the association of diabetic retinopathy with single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) on MnSOD was investigated and a statistically significant association of MnSOD Ala16Val polymorphism with diabetic retinopathy was found compared with the diabetic control. Additionally, the Ala(-9)Val [156] and VV genotype of the V16A [155] polymorphism of the Mn-SOD gene are also reported to be significantly higher in patients with DR retinopathy in Chinese and Caucasians type 2 diabetic patients respectively.

Haptoglobin polymorphism

Haptoglobin (Hp) is a hemoglobin-binding serum protein. It is found at levels of 30–300 mg/dL in normal human serum [158]. However, serum level of Hp shows 3- to 8-fold increase during the acute phase reaction and in response to injury [159]. Free hemoglobin (Hb) is considered as an extremely potent pro-oxidant agent which catalyzes various oxidative and peroxidative reactions [160]. Haptoglobin (Hp) plays an essential role in capturing free Hb, thus preventing oxidative tissue damage mediated by free Hb. For example, Hp has been demonstrated to inhibit Hb-induced linolenic acid and low-density lipoprotein (LDL) oxidation [161]. Additionally, Hp knockout mice have shown to be more prone to oxidative tissue damage such as renal damage and endothelial dysfunction [162]. Recent reports demonstrated that a polymorphism in the haptoglobin (Hp) gene is an independent risk factor for diabetic vascular disease [153, 154]. In man, there are two alleles for Hp, denoted 1 and 2, giving rise to three major phenotypes. Individuals homozygous for the 1 allele express the Hp1-1 phenotype at the protein level. Individuals homozygous for the 2 allele express the Hp2-2 phenotype, whereas heterozygotes express the Hp2-1 phenotype. Nakhoul et al., 2000 have observed a marked decrease in the prevalence of diabetic retinopathy in patients with Hp1-1 phenotype compared with patients with the Hp2-1 and Hp2-2 phenotypes [163]. Hp1-1and Hp1-2 types have been found to have significantly higher levels of serum vitamin C [164], lower serum iron, and lower circulating oxidized LDL (oxLDL)/LDL ratios compared with those with the Hp2-2 [165, 166]. Thus, antioxidant therapy may be more beneficial in diabetic patients with the Hp2-2 phenotype as compared with those with the Hp1-1 phenotype. Furthermore, a highly significant increase in retinal capillary basement membrane thickness was observed in mice with streptozotocin-induced diabetes with the Hp 2 genotype. These data provide important support for association studies done in humans showing an increased prevalence of diabetic retinopathy in individuals with the Hp 2 genotype [167].

eNOS gene polymorphism

Polymorphisms of eNOS gene have been reported to be associated with multiple health conditions including DR, hypertension, nephropathy, and cardiovascular diseases in several ethnic groups. Several studies demonstrated the association between certain eNOS polymorphism with DR in human [42, 168, 169]. For example, the eNOS 4b/b [42] or 4a/b [168] polymorphism demonstrate increased eNOS expression and activity and associated with sever DR. On the other hand, homozygous deletion of eNOS 4a/a causes reduction in eNOS expression and activity and susceptibility to DR [170].

Inflammation related markers

In addition to oxidative stress related biomarkers, generation of ROS in diabetic patients is known to initiate a cascade of signaling pathways responsible for the inflammatory component of DR. This includes activation of NFκB and up-regulation of genes responsive to inflammatory processes such as adhesion molecules [21, 52, 171, 172]. Golubnitschaja et al., 2005 have studied the alteration in inflammatory related genes in mononuclear blood cells (MBCs) isolated from diabetic patients with and without active retinopathy. They found significant increase in the expression of recoverin in diabetic patients compared to the control group. “Real-Time”-PCR showed that recoverin levels were positively correlated with the stage of DR and with the activity of serum matrix metalloprotinases (MMPs) [173]. Thus, identification of inflammation related biomarkers in isolated MBCs and serum of diabetic subjects may be helpful for the prediction of active proliferative retinopathy in diabetics.

Neuronal death and diabetic retinopathy

The preceding section of this chapter describes the complex vascular changes that accompany diabetic retinopathy. For many years, the disease was considered primarily vascular in nature. Beginning in the late 1990s, however, information about the neuronal components of diabetic retinopathy emerged. Several excellent reviews published in the last decade have summarized the evidence that neurons, particularly retinal ganglion cells, are vulnerable and die in diabetic retinopathy [5–7, 174, 175]. Loss of color [176, 177] and contrast [178, 179] sensitivity are early signs of neural retinal dysfunction in humans that occur within 2 years of diabetes onset. Bresnick proposed that diabetic retinopathy is a primary neurosensory disorder that precedes vasculopathy by many years [8, 180]. It is noteworthy that as early as the 1960’s Wolter [181] and Bloodworth [182] described loss of retinal neurons in diabetic patients. However, owing to the more easily recognizable vascular features as viewed via ophthalmoscopy, these observations were largely overlooked. More sophisticated electrophysiological studies using macular or focal ERG (FERG), which can detect electrical responses of ganglion cells, showed ganglion cell dysfunction early in diabetes [183]. Though FERG is not used widely clinically, important information has been forthcoming from several studies. Greco et al. [184] used FERG in prepubescent diabetic children and found that ganglion cell function was significantly impaired, while other cells such as photoreceptors appeared unaffected. Others have reported similar findings, including ganglion cell dysfunction in IDDM patients without vasculopathy [185, 186]. Other investigations using ERG, dark adaptation, contrast sensitivity, and color vision tests have provided convincing functional evidence that neural retina function is compromised oftentimes before the onset of vascular lesions in humans [187–192].

Markers for apoptosis in human tissues

The relevance of this functional evidence of neuronal degeneration in diabetic retinopathy has been borne out by molecular and biochemical analyses of the retinas of human patients. Barber et al. used post-mortem tissues from human patients with diabetic retinopathy and reported for the first time that ganglion cells die in this disease and do so via an apoptotic mechanism [193]. Subsequent studies by Abu El-Asrar used eyes from human diabetic patients and confirmed the expression of several pro-apoptosis molecules (caspase-3, Fas, and Bax) emphasizing the vulnerability of these cells [194]. They also found strong immunoreactivity for ERK1/2 in the inner nuclear layer of diabetic retinas as well as the nerve fiber and ganglion cell layers. This group extended their findings by examining additional anti- and pro-apoptotic markers in humans and showed that ganglion cells in diabetic and non-diabetic retinas express the anti-apoptotic molecules Cox-2, Akt, and Mcl-1. Retinal ganglion cells express the proapoptotic molecule Bad in response to diabetes-induced neuronal injury; diabetic retinas also show upregulation of the mitochondrial proteins cytochrome c, and AIF (Fig. 2) [195]. Human tissue from diabetic patients has also been shown to express connective tissue growth factor (CTGF), CD105 and gelatinase B, and ganglion cells and microglia were the sites of immunoreactivity [196]. Other investigators have provided additional support that the death of neurons in human diabetic retinas is mediated via mitochondria- and caspase-dependent cell-death pathways [197].

Fig. 2.

Table depicting biomarkers of neuronal death that have been reported in human patients with diabetic retinopathy and in rodent models of this disease

These data collected from human tissues provide strong evidence that neurons die in diabetic retinopathy and that they do so via an apoptotic mechanism, however no comprehensive reports are available indicating specific markers that predict neuronal cell death in human subjects. By definition, biomarkers should reflect a change in expression or state of a protein that correlates with the risk or progression of disease, or with the susceptibility of the disease to a given treatment. The field of biomarker research is just emerging and the published reports on biomarkers for neuronal cell death, especially in humans with diabetic retinopathy, are limited.

Model systems to investigate biomarkers of neuronal death in diabetic retinopathy

To understand genes/proteins whose expression is changed in diabetic retinopathy, investigators have relied extensively on the use of model systems including in vivo animal models and in vitro systems. Much of the work has focused on ganglion cells since they are vulnerable in human diabetic retinopathy. Schmidt and colleagues postulate that ganglion cells are particularly susceptible to neurodegenerative disease because of their high metabolic rate [198]. They note that ganglion cells have very long axons extending from the cell soma, through the lamina cribrosa (LC) and beyond. Moreover, unlike many neurons they are unmyelinated from the retina to the LC and only thereafter become myelinated. This reversed myelination pattern leads to an impedance mismatch that consumes considerable energy.

Studies in diabetic rats

Animal models of diabetic retinopathy include the well-characterized streptozotocin-induced diabetic rat. In rats, diabetes accelerates retinal neuronal cell death and inhibits neurite regeneration via an apoptotic mechanism that involves upregulation of Bax, a pro-apoptotic gene [199]. In the rat model, a number of inflammatory markers have been shown to be upregulated concomitant with ganglion cell death. These markers include interleukin (IL)-18 [200], IL-1β [124, 200], vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF) [124], tumor necrosis factor-α (TNF-α) [124, 200], activated p38 MAP kinase [124]. Related to these observations are the data showing a significant ∼30% increase in glucosylceramide levels in diabetic rats compared to controls [201]. These investigators were the first to demonstrate that augmented glycosphingolipid metabolism may contribute to the neuronal pathology of diabetic retinopathy and may serve as an important and relevant biomarker in human patients. Nakazawa et al have shown that anti-inflammatory agents (statins) can prevent ganglion cell death in ischemic/reperfusion rat models [202]. Zhang and co-workers observed an increase in the receptor for erythropoietin, a glycoprotein hormone that controls erythropoiesis in diabetic rats [203]. Another interesting molecule whose expression is decreased in the diabetic rat retina is SERPINA3K, an extracellular serine proteinase inhibitor (Fig. 2) [204]. This observation is noteworthy because SERPINA3K prevents intracellular calcium overload and calcium is well known to trigger neuronal death. Several groups have demonstrated that insulin mediates a pro-survival pathway in retinal neurons. It has been demonstrated that insulin receptor signaling diminishes with increased diabetes-induced apoptosis [205]. Very recently Fort and colleagues have applied complementary proteomic and genomic techniques and discovered that the proteins of the crystallin superfamily are increased dramatically in early diabetic retinopathy [206]. Their data suggest that the changes observed in crystallins are greater than other changes described so far in diabetic retinopathy. The work also emphasizes the power of the ‘omic’ approaches (genomic, proteomic, etc) to uncovering biomarkers for diabetic retinopathy.

As data are accumulated about molecules whose expression changes in diabetic retinopathy it is tempting to target them as a means to protect against deleterious consequences of diabetes. However, caution must be exercised regarding this strategy. A case in point is VEGF. VEGF plays key role in vasculogenesis and has been an anti-angiogenic target in treating a number of blinding diseases [207]. Recently VEGF-A has been recognized as an important neuroprotectant in the central nervous system [208]. Nishijima and co-workers used a model of ischemia-reperfusion injury and found that VEGF-A exposure resulted in a dose-dependent reduction in retinal neuron apoptosis [209]. Indeed, chronic inhibition of VEGF-A function in normal adult animals led to a significant loss of retinal ganglion cells yet had no observable effect on several vascular parameters. Their findings have important implications for both neural pathologies and ocular vascular diseases, particularly diabetic retinopathy.

Studies in diabetic mice

Mice constitute a powerful model system for understanding disease mechanisms, particularly the influence of genetic mutations on the progression of pathology. The field of diabetic retinopathy is no exception and a number of mouse models have proven informative with respect to gene/protein changes that occur in this disease. One of the most useful models is the Ins2^Akita/+ mouse model, which has proven relevant to and useful for studies of diabetic retinopathy [210–214]. The Ins2^Akita/+ mouse has a point mutation of the Insulin2 gene leading to hypoinsulinemia and hyperglycemia in heterozygous mice by ∼4 weeks [215]. Homozygosity for the mutation is embryonically lethal. Over a period of several weeks (∼10–25 weeks), heterozygous mice demonstrate marked retinal alterations including ∼20–25% reduction inner plexiform layer thickness, a ∼16% reduction of inner nuclear layer thickness and a ∼25% reduction in the number of cell bodies in the RGC layer [211, 212, 214]. The cell death appears to occur via apoptosis as evidenced by data from TUNEL assays [214] and detection of active caspase 3 [211]. Oshitara and colleagues have utilized the Ins2^Akita/+ mouse to examine the role of ER stress in diabetic retinopathy [174]. ER stress refers to the phenomenon whereby misfolded proteins aggregate in the ER lumen activating the unfolded protein response (UPR). The aim of the UPR is to alleviate ER stress, restore ER homeostasis and prevent cell death. Activation of the response is mediated by GPR78 (BiP, binding protein), which dissociates from three resident proteins: inositol requiring ER-to-nucleus signal kinase (IRE)1, activating transcription factor (ATF) 6 and soluble-stranded RNA-activated kinase (PKR)-like ER kinase (PERK) [216]. Studies of the Ins2^Akita/+ mouse demonstrated that ER stress is involved in the death of both retinal neurons and vascular cells in diabetic eyes as manifested by increased expression of BiP as well as PERK, ATF6, IRE1 (Fig. 2) [174]. These data are particularly interesting to our group because of our work showing that (+)-pentazocine, a ligand for sigma receptor 1 (σR1), affords profound neuroprotection in the Ins2^Akita/+ mouse [214]. σR1 is a molecular chaperone protein that resides at the ER-mitochondrial membrane and interacts with BiP. We are currently examining the expression of ER-stress related genes and our preliminary data suggest that expression of PERK, ATF6 and IRE1 as well as downstream effectors CHOP, BCL2 are increased in the diabetic retina, but expression returns to normal upon sustained treatment with (+)-pentazocine (manuscript in preparation). ER stress genes/proteins may prove to be important additional biomarkers of neuronal death in diabetic retinopathy and reducing or blocking ER stress may be a potential therapy for preventing the onset and the progression of this disease.

Other mouse models, in which diabetes occurs endogenously, have demonstrated neuronal degeneration as well. The retinas of hyperglycemic, hyperlipidemic (HGHL, apolipoprotein E(−/−) db/db) have been examined for advanced glycation endproducts (AGE) and receptors for these endproducts (RAGE) [217, 218]. The mice demonstrate early inner retinal neuronal dysfunction, manifested by prolonged latencies of the oscillatory potentials and b-wave as well as acellular capillaries and pericyte ghosts. The investigators found AGEs in the vitreous and associated with the inner limiting membrane formed by the Müller cell endfeet. They noted that attenuation of the RAGE axis with soluble RAGE ameliorated neuronal dysfunction and reduced the development of capillary lesions in these mice. The KKAY mouse is another model that is useful for studies of Type 2 diabetes. As with the Ins2^Akita/+ and the db/db mice, the KKAY mouse develops retinal neuropathy and microangiopathy [219], and hence should prove useful for analyses of biomarkers especially in determining whether there are differences in gene expression associated with this model of Type 2 diabetes versus those that more closely mimic Type 1. Other groups have induced diabetes in mice using streptozotocin and examined effects on neuronal function [220]. When the mice are not maintained on insulin, which is known for its neuroprotective properties [205, 221, 222], death of ganglion cells has been documented [220]. Using this model Kurihara and colleagues examined the relationship of the rennin-angiotensin system (RAS) with synaptophysin, a synaptic vesicle protein [222]. They examined the streptozotocin-induced mouse model have examined synergistic effects of diabetes neuronal activity in streptozotocin-induced diabetic mice by ERG. Using a variety of molecular and biochemical approaches they found that diabetes was associated with a significant increase in retinal production of angiotensin II and AT1R together with ERK activation. They observed ERG changes and a reduction in the level of synaptophysin protein (but not mRNA levels). Based on these observations, they treated the diabetic mice with the angiotensin II type 1 receptor (AT1R) blocker telimsartan or valsartan and found that they could reverse the ERG changes and the decreased synaptophysin. Other studies have used and other genetic defects. For example, mice with a defect in the cystathionine-β-synthase gene develop hyperhomocysteinemia [223]. Increased levels of homocysteine are implicated in several ocular diseases including diabetic retinopathy [224–226] and glaucoma [227, 228]. In the cbs+/− mutant mice, retinal ganglion cells die by apoptosis [229] and diabetes accelerates the retinal neuronal loss in these mice [230].

Studies in cell lines and purified ganglion cells

While in vivo models are critical for advancing our understanding of biomarkers in neuronal death associated with diabetic retinopathy, there is a place also for studies using a single cell type. Indeed initial screenings to detect biomarkers and postulate therapies are well-served by the availability of appropriate in vitro model systems. Fortunately, the field of diabetic retinopathy research has several models to exploit for these purposes.

The rat R28 retinal precursor cells, immortalized with the 12S, nontumorigenic portion of the adenovirus E1A gene, provide researchers with an inexhaustible supply of cells for studying structural and functional differentiation in the retina. The R28 cells were developed in the laboratory of Dr. Gail Seigel and have been used extensively to analyze mechanisms of diabetes-induced neuronal cell death [231]. Notable among the studies are discoveries of several biomarkers for retinal neuronal cell death that may have implications for diabetic retinopathy including sphingolipids [201], p44/p42 mitogen-activated protein kinase [232], glucosamine-induced PERK activation [233], hexosamines [233], advanced glycation end products (AGE) [234], IL-1β [235], and glutamate receptor/calcium homeostasis [236] to name a few.

Useful also for studies of retinal neuronal cell death is the RGC-5 cell line. In 2001, Krishnamoorthy and colleagues published the development of the RGC-5 cell line [193]. It was reportedly derived by transforming postnatal day 1 rat retinal cells with ψ₂ E1A virus [237]. Recent re-characterization of the RGC-5 cell line suggests that it is actually of mouse origin [238]. When originally described, the RGC-5 cells expressed Thy-1.2, Brn-3C, neuritin, NMDA-R1 and GABA receptors, which are neuronal markers characteristic of intact ganglion cells. RGC-5 cells do not express glial fibrillary acidic protein (GFAP) a marker of glial cells. In early passage, the cells were sensitive to glutamate (5 mM) and that sensitivity could be increased if the cells were treated with succinyl concanavalin A (S Con A) [237]. Interestingly, recent studies by Van Bergen and co-workers showed that RGC-5 cells no longer express the ganglion cell marker protein Thy 1.2, whether differentiated using S Con A or not [238]. Our laboratory obtained this cell line shortly after it was first available in 2001 and our stock continues to express Thy1.2, however the sensitivity to homocysteine, glutamate and oxidative stress is diminished [239]. There are over 100 papers published since 2001 using the RGC-5 cells. Many studies explore alterations of genes/proteins associated with diabetic retinopathy. Indeed, in the last 12 months, there have been over 30 publications using these cells for such analyses. Many of these reports used the RGC-5 cell to determine gene/protein alterations or therapeutic intervention strategies under conditions intended to mimic diabetes. For example, Osborne et al. exposed the cells to retinal ischemia and oxidative stress to determine effects of latanoprost acid [240]. Other studies have examined the PI3-kinase/Akt pathway [241], 5-S-GAD as a neuroprotectant [242], bevacizumab toxicity [243], the ERK1/2 pathways [244], and tafluprost [245].

The RGC-5 cell lines proliferate quickly and are not neuronal in appearance. However, when incubated with the protein kinase inhibitor staurosporine, a more neuronal phenotype is achieved. RGC-5 cells treated with 316 nM staurosporine express neurites, become postmitotic and nonapoptotic, and alter their kinase phosphorylation patterns [246, 247]. In addition, they are positive for a number of neuronal markers including Thy 1.2 [246]. Staurosporine-induced differentiated RGC-5 cells are sensitive to oxidative stress induced by hydrogen peroxide, ischemia, glucose deprivation and plasminogen activators [248, 249]. Recent studies in our lab examined the susceptibility of these differentiated RGC-5 cells to homocysteine. We observed that when differentiated, the cells increase expression of active caspase-3, which is not observed in non-staurosporine-treated cells [239]. The staurosporine-treated cells were not susceptible to homocysteine until applied in exceedingly high dosages. Thus, RGC-5 cells are a useful neuronal model, but data must be interpreted cautiously acknowledging the limitations of the in vitro system.

A more labor-intensive method to study proteins/genes in ganglion cells that are affected by diabetic retinopathy is to purify the cells from the intact animal. Our laboratory has adapted methodology from the Barres laboratory [250] to immunopan ganglion cells from neonatal mice [251]. The cells are viable for 22 days when maintained in a supplemented neurobasal media [251]. They extend neurite processes characteristic of ganglion cells. Using these cells we have been able to demonstrate exquisite sensitivity to oxidative stress, a factor implicated in diabetic retinopathy, that leads to upregulation of the xCT protein component of the glutamate-cystine exchanger system x⁻_c [251]. Owing to the role of this exchanger in generation of the antioxidant glutathione, it likely represents a mechanism to enhance ganglion cell survival under stress. The primary ganglion cell cultures are sensitive to physiologically-relevant levels of glutamate and homocysteine; they die by an apoptotic mechanism when exposed to these excitotoxins, a phenomenon that is inhibited by treatment with the σR1 ligand (+)-pentazocine [252]. We have preliminary evidence that when primary ganglion cells are treated with the oxidative stressor xanthine:xanthine oxidase, numerous pro-apoptotic genes are upregulated including Bad, Bak, Fas-L and Trail [Ha et al., manuscript in preparation]. These data are noteworthy since xanthine oxidase is involved in free radical production in type 1 diabetic human patients [253]. We have used the primary ganglion cells to explore expression of a number of genes/proteins and found them to reflect the expression in intact mouse retina faithfully [254–257]. Studies are underway to explore ER stress genes whose expression is altered as a consequence of factors associated with diabetic retinopathy.

In Summary, diabetic retinopathy in human patients is characterized by neuronal and vascular alterations that can ultimately lead to devastating vision loss. Oxidative stress is crucial in mediating vascular dysfunctions associated with DR via modification of retinal lipids, proteins and DNA. This effect is associated with switching on various signaling pathways that include but not limited to upregulation of angiogenic factors, activation of NF-kB and production of inflammatory mediators. Therefore, early detection of the biochemical effect of oxidative stress such as by-products of lipid peroxidation, DNA and protein oxidative damage in diabetic patients could serve as biomarkers which may be effective in early prediction and treatment of DR. Interestingly, variations in oxidative stress related genes among diabetic patients plays also a role as an additional risk factor that makes some patients more vulnerable to develop DR than others. Thus, gene polymorphism could be also used as predictive marker for increased susceptibility to develop DR in diabetic patient. There is strong evidence from analysis of human tissue that retinal ganglion cells are particularly susceptible in diabetic retinopathy. Investigators are using a variety of model systems, both in vivo (rat and mouse) and in vitro (ganglion cell lines and primary cultures) to determine key genes/proteins whose expression is changed under diabetic conditions with the aim of uncovering the most promising targets for successful intervention. Using relevant in vitro models and confirming the data in relevant in vivo models should pave the way for important biomarkers to be identified and targeted in treating this disease.