Skip to main content
. 2012 Jul 26;4(8):841–858. doi: 10.3390/nu4080841

Table 3.

Assessment of validity of included RCTs reporting zinc intake and serum/plasma zinc in children (adapted from the Cochrane Handbook [43]).

Author, Year Adequate Sequence Generation Allocation Concealment Adequate Blinding Adequate Dropouts Adequate and Outcome Data Complete Funder Adequate Lack of other Potential Threats to Validity Overall Risk of Bias
Mahloudji, 1975 [23] Unclear Yes Unclear Unclear Yes Unclear High
Hambidge, 1979 [24] Unclear Unclear Yes Unclear No Unclear High
Walravens, 1983 [25] Unclear Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Moderate
Gibson, 1989 [26] Unclear Yes Yes Yes No Yes High
Cavan, 1993 [27] Unclear Yes Yes Unclear Yes No High
Friis, 1997 [28] Unclear Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes High
Rosado, 1997 [29] Unclear Yes Yes Unclear Yes Yes High
Ruz, 1997 [30] Unclear Yes Yes Unclear Yes Yes High
Sandstead, 1998 [31] Unclear Unclear Yes Unclear No No High
Clark, 1999 [32] Yes Yes Yes Unclear No Unclear High
Smith, 1999 [33] Unclear Unclear Unclear Yes Yes Yes High
Muñoz, 2000 [34] Unclear No Yes Yes Nor Yes High
Lopez de Romana, 2005 [35] Unclear Unclear Unclear Yes Yes Yes High
Silva, 2006 [36] Unclear Unclear No Yes No Yes High
Sandstead, 2008 [37] Yes Yes Yes Unclear No Yes Moderate
Wuehler, 2008 [38] Yes Unclear Yes Yes Yes Yes Low
de Oliveira, 2009 [39] Unclear Unclear No Unclear No Yes High
Uckarde, 2009 [40] Unclear Yes Yes Yes No Yes High