Dietary nitrite and nitrate: a review of potential mechanisms of cardiovascular benefits

Abstract

Purpose

In the last decade, a growing scientific and medical interest has emerged toward cardiovascular effects of dietary nitrite and nitrate; however, many questions concerning their mode of action(s) remain unanswered. In this review, we focus on multiple mechanisms that might account for potential cardiovascular beneficial effects of dietary nitrite and nitrate.

Results

Beneficial changes to cardiovascular health from dietary nitrite and nitrate might result from several mechanism(s) including their reduction into nitric oxide, improvement in endothelial function, vascular relaxation, and/or inhibition of the platelet aggregation. From recently obtained evidence, it appears that the longstanding concerns about the toxicity of oral nitrite or nitrate are overstated.

Conclusion

Dietary nitrite and nitrate may have cardiovascular protective effects in both healthy individuals and also those with cardiovascular disease conditions. A role for nitrite and nitrate in nitric oxide biosynthesis and/or in improving nitric oxide bioavailability may eventually provide a rationale for using dietary nitrite and nitrate supplementation in the treatment and prevention of cardiovascular diseases.

Introduction

Scientific and medical interest in cardiovascular health benefits of fruit- and vegetable-rich diets has grown exponentially in recent years, due to compelling epidemiological evidence showing that consumption of fruits and vegetables might reduce the risk of cardiovascular diseases [1–3]. Understanding the precise factors in these foods that account for cardiovascular protection is a major focus of experimental and clinical research for many years. Over the past two decades, several factors in these foods have been identified to have favorable effects on cardiovascular health, although many questions concerning their relevant contribution remain unanswered [4–6]. Of late, there is great interest in the nitrite and nitrate content of these foods in improving cardiovascular health due to improved understanding of the role of endogenous nitrite and nitrate in the maintenance of vascular homeostasis [7–13]. Over the past decade, several in vitro and in vivo animal model studies [14–26] and a few human studies [15, 27–30] have provided evidence that the nitrite and nitrate content of the fruits and vegetables could contribute to their cardiovascular health benefits, although many questions concerning their mode of action(s) remain unanswered. The major focus of this paper will be to provide a review of mechanisms that might account for the potential cardiovascular beneficial effects of dietary nitrite and nitrate. These include enhancement in nitric oxide bioavailability in the vasculature, dilation of the vasculature (vasodilator effects), and inhibition of platelet aggregation. In addition, this paper briefly discusses data from animal and human studies investigating the effects of nitrite and nitrate supplementation in the treatment and prevention of myocardial ischemia and hypertension.

Sources of nitrite and nitrate

Endogenous nitrite and nitrate originate from two potential sources [7–13]. First, oxidation of NO produced in vivo in biological fluids and cells. NO is synthesized in vivo from the amino acid l-arginine by the nitric oxide synthase (NOS) enzymes in the presence of molecular oxygen (O₂) and several cofactors. These cofactors include nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide phosphate (NADPH), flavin mononucleotide (FMN), flavin adenine dinucleotide (FAD), tetrahydrobiopterin (BH₄), and calmodulin and calcium. Three isoforms of NOS have been identified: endothelial (eNOS), neuronal (nNOS), and inducible (iNOS). Initially, eNOS was generally considered as the sole (major) source of NO in the vasculature. NO is labile with a short half-life in biological fluids [31]. Once synthesized, NO gets rapidly oxidized to nitrate by oxyhemoglobin and to nitrite in the plasma in a reaction catalyzed at least in part by the copperstorage plasma protein ceruloplasmin [32, 33]. Indeed, l-arginine-eNOS pathway has been reported to contribute to ~70% of plasma nitrite [34–36]. Second, diet is also the major potential source of endogenous nitrite and nitrate. For the average population, the range of dietary nitrite intake has been reported to be 0–20 mg per day, whereas for dietary nitrate, it ranges from 53 to 300 mg per day [37]. Most dietary nitrate (80–95%) exposure comes from plant foods (mostly vegetables and a few fruits), whereas most dietary nitrite comes from nitrite food additives and added nitrite in processed, cured meats (~39%) and baked goods and cereals (~34%) [13, 37]. In addition, drinking water can also contain considerable amounts of nitrate (usually <10 mg/L in the absence of bacterial contamination), although in many countries the levels are strictly regulated. On the other hand, systemic nitrite can also be derived from the reduction of nitrate, originated either from NO oxidation or from the diet, to nitrite by two sources. First, nitrate can be reduced to nitrite by commensal facultative anaerobic bacteria present in the oral cavity (i.e., mouth) and possibly in the gastrointestinal tract [38–40]. For instance, in a recent cross-over designed study involving seven healthy human volunteers, rinsing the mouth with antibacterial mouthwash has been shown to abolish conversion of nitrate into nitrite in saliva and to markedly reduce increase in plasma nitrite following a dietary nitrate load (10 mg/kg of sodium nitrate dissolved in water) [40], suggesting that oral bacteria plays a critical role in nitrate reduction into nitrite, and, conversely, contributes to systemic nitrite levels. Indeed, it has been known for several years that bacteria use nitrate as an alternative electron acceptor to oxygen during respiration and a fraction of the nitrate anions present in saliva is converted in the mouth to nitrite under the influence of bacterial enzymes [38, 39]. Second, but only recently recognized, possibility for systemic nitrate reduction to nitrite is nitrate reductase enzymes present in the tissues such as lung, liver, heart, and kidney [41]. For instance, in a recent study, Jansson et al. [39] demonstrated that mammalian tissues reduce inorganic nitrate to nitrite and that this effect is significantly inhibited by allopurinol [41], suggesting that molybdenum-based oxidoreductase enzymes such as xanthine oxidase present in mammalian tissues may catalyze, at least in part, the nitrate reduction to nitrite and, conversely, contribute to systemic nitrite levels.

Pharmacokinetics of nitrite and nitrate

An important factor influencing the interpretation of the biological effects of nitrite and nitrate is their systemic concentration. Emerging data from human and animal studies suggest that nitrite and nitrate derived from both endogenous (i.e., oxidation of endogenously produced NO) and exogenous (i.e., dietary intake) sources contribute to steady-state systemic nitrite and nitrate concentrations [7–13]. In general, plasma concentrations obtained of nitrite and nitrate range between 0.01 and 0.6 µM and 20–40 µM, respectively [7–13, 32, 42–44]. The concentrations of nitrite in rat vascular tissue (10 ± 1 µM) have been reported to be much higher than that observed in the plasma [45]. Dietary nitrate is readily absorbed from the stomach and proximal small intestine into the blood and mixes with NO-derived nitrate. Although much of the nitrate ingested (65–70%) is excreted in the urine, part of it (~25%) accumulates greatly in saliva after active uptake by the salivary glands [38, 46– 48]. This nitrate is rapidly reduced to nitrite by bacteria in the mouth, and part of nitrite then formed is absorbed in the gut and enters the systemic circulation [39, 48]. Bartholomew and Hill [47] demonstrated that urinary nitrate reaches a maximum concentration in 4–6 h after ingestion of nitrate and returns to the baseline value within 24 h. Similar results were also reported by Pannala et al. [49]. Pannala et al. demonstrated that high dietary nitrate (< 3.65 mg/kg body weight or ~ 250 mg nitrate) intake leads to a ~4 to sevenfold increase in plasma, urinary, and salivary nitrate content in healthy human volunteers. In this study, nitrate intake increased urinary nitrate excretion from 53 ± 4 mg on day 1 (low-nitrate day) to 223 ± 13, 241 ± 15, and 243 ± 16 mg on days 2, 3, and 4, (high-nitrate days), respectively [49]. Interestingly, in the later study, high dietary nitrate intake also increased nitrite concentration in urine (~23 µg pre-intake to ~39 µg post-intake) and saliva (0.27 mM pre-intake vs. 1.8 mM at 2 h post-intake) but not in the plasma (78 ± 4 nM pre-intake vs. 90 ± 3 nM post-nitrate intake) [49]. In contrast, in a recent study, Kapil et al. [28] demonstrated that plasma nitrite concentration was significantly elevated at ~1.5 h, peaked at ~2.5 h (increased from ~0.5 µM to ~1.5 µM), sustained to 6 h, and remained elevated than baseline values at 24 h after potassium nitrate (KNO₃ capsules, 24 mmol) supplementation. This study also demonstrated that plasma nitrate concentrations peaked at 3 h and steadily decreased thereafter but remains significantly elevated than baseline values at 24 h after ingestion of 24 mmol KNO₃. In this study, plasma nitrate concentration elevated above baseline by ~35-, 27-, and 7-fold after administration of 24, 12, and 4 mmol of KNO₃, respectively. Furthermore, Kapil et al. [28] also demonstrated that plasma nitrate concentrations were elevated much sooner than plasma nitrite concentrations after ingestion of KNO₃ (30 min vs. 1.5 h), reflecting the use of bacterial reduction of nitrate to nitrite in the oral cavity.

Mechanisms by which nitrite and nitrate could improve cardiovascular health

When considering how nitrite and nitrate can improve cardiovascular health, it is important to consider recent insights into the pathophysiology of the cardiovascular system. The human cardiovascular system is composed of the heart, the blood vessels (or vasculature), and the cells and plasma of the blood. The walls of blood vessels consist three distinctive layers (from inside to outside): tunica intima (made of endothelial cells), tunica media (made of vascular smooth muscle cells), and tunica adventitia (made of connective tissue). The endothelial cell layer, referred to as the endothelium, separates rest of the vessel wall from the circulating blood. The endothelium plays an important role in the maintenance of vascular homeostasis, achieved through release of a variety of local vascular mediators [50–56]. Among these mediators, endothelium-derived NO is essential for the maintenance of vascular homeostasis due to its actions on both smooth muscle cells and circulating blood cells (platelets, monocytes, etc.) [50–56]. Endothelium-derived NO has been reported to control vascular tone, smooth muscle cell proliferation and growth, platelet activity and aggregation, leukocyte trafficking, expression of certain adhesion molecules, and inflammation [50–56]. Thus, alterations in endothelium-derived NO bioavailability can result in endothelial dysfunction, broadly defined as a failure of the endothelium to perform its physiological functions, leading to impaired vascular homeostasis and thus to the pathogenesis and clinical expression of a variety of cardiovascular diseases. Indeed, studies over the past two decades have suggested that cardiovascular risk factors including hypertension, diabetes mellitus, physical inactivity, postmenopausal state, smoking, aging, inflammation, dyslipidemia, and hypercholesterolemia are all associates with endothelial dysfunction due to reduced NO bioavailability in the vasculature [50–56]. Thus, restoration of or improving NO bioavailability in the vasculature has become a major goal of therapy in cardiovascular disease states. On the other hand, endothelial dysfunction causes a decrease in dilation of the vasculature, favors platelet adherence and activation leading to thrombosis, and increases vascular inflammation and proliferation of smooth muscle cells (hypertrophy), all of which could act to increase the risk of cardiovascular events. Prospective studies over the past two decades have shown that treatment modalities that can target one or more of the manifestations of endothelial dysfunction are likely to improve cardiovascular health. Beneficial changes to cardiovascular health from these interventions might result from promotion of vascular relaxation, inhibition of vasoconstriction, inhibition of platelet aggregation, reduction in the production of free radicals, or other mechanisms that protect the endothelium from the injury [50–56]. Relevant to the current review, there is increasing evidence that nitrite and nitrate in the diet can improve NO bioavailability in the vasculature, exert vasodilation, inhibit platelet aggregation, and conversely, improve cardiovascular health.

Improving NO bioavailability in the vasculature

Most studies to date have demonstrated that the protective effects of nitrite were attenuated or prevented by NO scavengers such as carboxy-PTIO and hemoglobin, suggesting that the beneficial effects of nitrite and nitrate were mediated at least in part, if not fully, by improved NO bioavailability. Emerging data suggest that the nitrite and nitrate in the diet could improve NO bioavailability through several mechanisms (discussed below) and, conversely, improved NO bioavailability could well contribute to the ability of nitrite and nitrate to improve cardiovascular health. When discussing the effect of nitrate, the results must be considered in relation to nitrite (i.e., nitrate should be viewed as a precursor of nitrite), because nitrate is first reduced to nitrite before entering the systemic circulation [38–41].

Nitrite and nitrate reduction to NO in the vasculature

Nitrite and nitrate can improve NO bioavailability in the vasculature by their reduction to NO in mammalian tissues including blood [7–13]. NO generation from one-electron reduction of inorganic nitrite was first described in stomach in 1994 [57, 58]. Protonation of inorganic nitrite in acidic gastric juice to form nitrous acid (HNO₂), which then decomposes to NO and other nitrogen oxides, has been implicated in NO generation from inorganic nitrite [57, 58]. Soon after the discovery of gastric NOS-independent NO generation, Zweier et al. [59] showed that NO can also be generated in ischemic and acidic heart by direct reduction of nitrite to NO, providing the first evidence for NOS enzyme-independent production of systemic/vascular NO. In subsequent studies, numerous pathways that can catalyze nitrite and nitrate reduction to NO in vivo have been identified and the list is growing fatter. These include deoxyhemoglobin [29], deoxymyoglobin [60], xanthine oxidoreductase [61], cytochrome P₄₅₀ enzymes [62], mitochondrial respiratory chain enzymes [63], aldehyde oxidase [64], carbonic anhydrase [65], acidic disproportionation [57, 58], and reducing agents (e.g., ascorbate, polyphenols) [66, 67]. These pathways have previously been reviewed [68], and a detailed discussion of these pathways is beyond the scope of this review. However, at this point of time, the relative contribution of each individual pathway to NO release from nitrite and nitrate is poorly understood. To our knowledge, so far only one study has addressed this issue [69]. In addition, whether or not all these pathways catalyze physiological NO generation from nitrite and nitrate is still a topic of debate due to their increased activity in the presence of very low pH and O₂ (i.e., ischemic) environment. Nevertheless, their participation in the states of hypoxia/ischemia and acidosis is now well recognized and supported by a number of studies [7–13, 20, 68, 70]. While the controversy exists, several studies measuring arterial-to-venous gradients for nitrite suggest that nitrite is also metabolized to NO across physiological pH and oxygen gradients, as evidenced by large arterial-to-venous gradients for nitrite anions across human forearm circulation [29, 32, 71]. For example, Cosby et al. [29] demonstrated increased NO formation in the blood, as measured by the rate of formation of ironnitrosylated hemoglobin (HbNO), during nitrite infusion at rest and under exercise stress. On the other hand, emerging data show that NO generation from nitrite and nitrate is indeed an alternative source of bioactive NO in vivo in addition to that released from the endothelium and plays a key role in the maintenance of steady-state physiological NO levels [21, 22]. For example, nitrite supplementation (50 mg/L, 1 week in drinking water) has recently been shown to restore impaired NO homeostasis in eNOS-deficient mice [21]. However, at this point in time, there have been no direct experimental measurements in vivo of the amount of NO generated through nitrite and nitrate reduction.

Nitrite and nitrate as substrate to eNOS

Classically, endothelium-derived NO is synthesized from the amino acid l-arginine by the eNOS enzyme. This reaction requires the presence of molecular O₂, and thus, eNOS-derived NO synthesis would be expected to cease to exist when the molecular O₂ levels falls below the threshold levels (e.g., myocardial ischemia). Indeed, impaired endothelial NO production has been described in ischemic tissues [72, 73]. However, recent experimental data suggest that eNOS can generate NO in the absence of molecular O₂ by utilizing nitrite as substrate, indicating that NO generation from nitrite and nitrate by eNOS could well contribute to improved vascular NO bioavailability in hypoxic/ischemic conditions [74, 75]. For example, using recombinant eNOS holoenzyme and its oxygenase domain, Gautier et al. [74] demonstrated that eNOS reduces nitrite ions to NO under anoxia. In this study, the release of NO from nitrite at physiological pH is observed electrochemically as well as with optical and electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) spectroscopy. In another study, Vanin et al. [75] demonstrated that immortalized murine microvascular endothelial cells release significant quantities of NO under anoxic conditions. In this study, by utilizing multiple experimental approaches including pharmacological inhibition of eNOS and estimation of nitrite levels, the authors confirmed that the NO is released from nitrite reduction by eNOS. The later study also demonstrated that the magnitude of the anoxic NO production was significantly higher than basal normoxic yield, suggesting that the nitrite reductase activity of eNOS is relevant for fast NO delivery in hypoxic vascular tissues.

Improving endothelium-derived NO bioavailability (endothelial function)

An important mechanism of impaired NO bioavailability in the vasculature is endothelial dysfunction [50–56]. Although the cause of endothelial dysfunction remains unclear, increased production of reactive oxygen species (ROS) represents the primary problem [50–56]. ROS, in particular superoxide anions, rapidly react with NO released from the endothelium to form peroxynitrite, leading to reduced bioavailability of endothelium-derived NO. Mitochondria are an important source of ROS overproduction in cardiovascular pathological states [76–78]. Nitrite has been shown to inhibit mitochondrial ROS generation, achieved through S-nitrosation of mitochondrial respiratory chain complex I enzyme [23, 24]. Attenuation in mitochondrial ROS generation may well contribute to improvement in endothelial function. In this regard, mitochondria-targeted antioxidants such as MitoQ10 have been demonstrated to improve endothelial function [78]. Nitrite inhibition of ROS production could also lead to preservation of NO production from the classical eNOS-l-arginine pathway because ROS can readily oxidize BH₄, an essential cofactor for eNOS, into dihydrobiopterin (BH₂) [79, 80]. Relative BH₄ deficiency is a significant contributor to endothelial dysfunction and can be specifically rescued by restoration of BH₄ in relation to eNOS function. Indeed, in a recent study, dietary nitrite ingestion (50 mg per liter of sodium nitrite in drinking water) has been reported to increase BH₄ levels in mice fed with high-cholesterol diet [16]. In this study, nitrite administration also increased BH₄-to-BH₂ ratio (evidence for inhibition of BH₄ oxidation) in high-cholesterol-fed mice indicating that nitrite is actually antioxidant rather than prooxidant. On the other hand, in a recent study, dietary nitrite ingestion (150 mg per liter of sodium nitrite in drinking water) has been shown to attenuate microvascular inflammation in high-cholesterol-diet-fed mice [16]. Emerging data suggest that inflammation, as evidenced by increased expression of pro-inflammatory cytokines such as C-reactive protein (CRP), associates with endothelial dysfunction [81, 82]. Putting together, these findings suggest the possibility that the ability of nitrite and nitrate to modulate systemic inflammation may contribute at least in part to improvement in endothelium-derived NO bioavailability (i.e., endothelial function).

Vasodilation

Vasodilation refers to the opening of the blood vessels resulting from relaxation of smooth muscle cells within the blood vessel wall. Vasodilation plays a key role in regulation of blood flow and blood pressure, and thus in the control of cardiovascular system. Therefore, abnormal vasodilation would contribute to development and progression of cardiovascular events. Indeed, impaired dilation of the blood vessels (vasculature) has been demonstrated in a number of cardiovascular disease states including hypertension and atherosclerosis [50–56]. In addition, pharmacological agents such as calcium channel blockers and angiotensin-converting enzyme inhibitors have been suggested to achieve cardiovascular protection through improving vasodilation [83, 84]. Substantial data now demonstrate that nitrite and nitrate relax vascular smooth muscle both in vitro and in vivo [7–13, 15, 25, 27, 29], indicating that vasodilation might contribute at least in part to cardiovascular beneficial effects of dietary nitrite and nitrate. For example, infusion of inorganic nitrite (400 nM, at 1 mL/min for 5 min) has been shown to significantly increase fore-arm blood flow in healthy humans at rest and during exercise stress [29]. In another study, inorganic nitrite inhalation (300 mg in 5 mL buffered saline for 20 min) was found to exert potent and selective vasodilation of pulmonary circulation in newborn lambs [25]. Indeed, the vasodilatory properties of pharmacological doses of exogenous nitrite have been known for more than half a century [85, 86]. The mechanisms underlying smooth muscle relaxant effect of nitrite and nitrate remain unclear, but appear to involve their reduction to NO and thus activation of soluble guanylyl cyclase (sGC) in smooth muscle cells (classical NO/sGC/cGMP pathway) or direct activation of sGC in smooth muscle cells (at higher concentrations) [87, 88]. For instance, Laustiola et al. [88] demonstrated that sodium nitrite induces vascular smooth muscle relaxation in rat mesenteric arteries via stimulation of cGMP production, and this effect was augmented in the presence of exogenous guanosine triphosphate (GTP). In addition, in the mid-1970s and early 1980s, supra-physiological concentrations of nitrite were shown by Arnold et al. [89] and Gruetter et al. [90] to activate sGC and vasodilate vascular smooth muscle preparations. An additional potential mechanism for the vasorelaxant effect of nitrite is the release of cyclooxygenase (COX)-derived products from the endothelium. In this regard, Pinder et al. [91] demonstrated that nitrite-induced relaxation in endothelium-intact vessels, but not endothelium-denuded vessels, was inhibited significantly by the nonspecific COX inhibitor indomethacin. On the other hand, substituting endotheliumderived NO with organic nitrates (e.g., nitroglycerin) that release NO to cause vasodilation has been an important strategy in the pharmacotherapy of cardiovascular diseases for more than a century. However, the development of nitrate tolerance and increased formation of peroxynitrite under oxidative stress limits their continuous clinical application. In 1908 and 1930, two studies have investigated the effects of inorganic nitrite on the development of tolerance and compared it with nitroglycerin [92, 93]. These studies demonstrated that repeated oral administration of nitrite (150 mg to 300 mg, 2–3 times a day) similarly lowered systolic blood pressure over a period of 6 days, indicating that nitrite does not induce tolerance. Consistent with these findings, in a recent study, Dejam et al. [15] also reported that the vasodilatory effects of inorganic nitrite are not susceptible to tolerance, which sets this anion apart from the organic nitrates.

Inhibition of platelet aggregation

Platelet adhesion and aggregation are important events in the pathogenesis of cardiovascular diseases. For instance, abnormal platelet activation and adhesion can result in thrombosis and thus vessel occlusion within the coronary artery leading to myocardial infarction. Therefore, inhibiting platelet aggregation is an important strategy in the prevention and treatment of cardiovascular diseases. A growing weight of evidence suggests that nitrite and nitrate reduce platelet aggregation [26, 30, 94], indicating that inhibition of abnormal platelet aggregation may contribute at least in part to cardiovascular benefits of dietary nitrite and nitrate. For instance, a single bolus supplementation with 2 mM (10.1 mg) potassium nitrate has been demonstrated to inhibit platelet aggregation by up to 70% [94]. In another study, acidified sodium nitrite has been demonstrated to significantly inhibit platelet aggregation in a dose-dependent manner in cat platelet-rich plasma [26]. Indeed, in a recent study, modest dietary supplementation with nitrate (beetroot juice) has been shown to inhibit ex vivo platelet aggregation in healthy volunteers [30]. The precise mechanism(s) of this inhibition has still to be clarified. However, it is hypothesized that NO generated from nitrite and nitrate in the acidic stomach will be absorbed systemically, by nitrosating thiol groups which in the acidic stomach will be mainly in the reduced form, and exert an inhibitory effect on platelet aggregation [95]. Nevertheless, the above studies have shown that nitrite and nitrate have inhibitory effects on platelet activation which may actively contribute to cardiovascular health promoting properties.

Cardiovascular protection by nitrite and nitrate: human and animal studies

The usage of inorganic nitrate for the treatment of cardiovascular conditions (angina and digital ischemia) has been harnessed since medieval times as evidenced by a translation of medieval Buddhist manuscripts [10]. However, it is perhaps only in the last decade or so that interest in the cardiovascular effects of inorganic nitrite and nitrate ions has grown enormously. Over the past several years, a wealth of investigations, ranging from clinical and animal model studies to in vitro analyses, have examined the cardiovascular effects of nitrite and nitrate. These studies, mostly from animal models, in general indicate that exogenous nitrite and nitrate ingestion may have beneficial effects on cardiovascular health, most notably in the treatment and prevention of myocardial ischemia and hypertension.

Myocardial ischemia

The health of cardiovascular system depends on structural and functional integrity of the heart and blood vessels. Limited supply of the blood to the heart muscle (myocardium) leads to myocardial ischemia (MI). Reperfusion therapy, the procedure that allows the rapid return of blood flow to the ischemic zone of the myocardium, is the most effective strategy for reducing the size of myocardial infract and improving the clinical outcome in these patients. However, reperfusion after extensive ischemia may lead to further damage to the myocardium, referred to as myocardial ischemia–reperfusion (IR) injury. Therefore, strategies that can limit the extent of infarction during ischemia and reperfusion are of great clinical importance in MI patients. Several studies over the past decade have demonstrated that nitrite and nitrate administration can ameliorate myocardial IR injury [17–19]. Effects of exogenous nitrite against myocardial IR injury have now been studied in a variety of in vitro and in vivo models. For example, Webb et al. [19] investigated the protective effects of exogenous nitrite (10 and 100 µM) against the damaging effects of IR injury using a Langendroff isolated heart model. In this study, Webb et al. [19] demonstrated that perfusion of hearts with nitrite before and during the IR insult reduced infract size by >60% with corresponding improvements in recovery of left ventricular function. In another study, using mice subjected to left coronary artery occlusion (model for myocardial ischemia), Duranski et al. [18] reported that nitrite administered at near physiological blood concentrations (2.4–960 nM) exerted dose-dependent protective effects against cellular necrosis and myocardial IR injury. This study also demonstrated that the nitrite-mediated protection of heart from IR injury was dependent on NO generation and independent of eNOS and hemeoxygenase-1 enzyme activities. Moreover, in a recent study, Gonzalez et al. [17] revealed that nitrite dosing during the last 5 min of a 120-min occlusion period reduced myocardial infarction size from 70 to 36% in a canine model. In another study, the eNOS-deficient mouse has been used to investigate the effect of nitrite supplementation (50 mg/L, in drinking water) on steady-state nitrite and NO metabolite levels and on severity of myocardial IR injury [21]. This study found that nitrite supplementation restored impaired NO homeostasis in eNOS-deficient mice and protected against myocardial IR injury. On the other hand, inorganic nitrate has been used to treat digital ischemia for centuries [10]. However, unlike the case with nitrite, the effect of nitrate on IR injury has not been studied extensively. In a recent study, mice fed with nitrite- and nitrate-deficient diet have been used as animal models to investigate the effects of nitrite and nitrate on the severity of myocardial IR injury [22]. In this study, dietary nitrite and nitrate insufficiency led to exacerbated myocardial IR injury and post-myocardial infarction morbidity rates in mice. Collectively, these studies clearly indicate that exogenous administration of nitrite and nitrate could limit the extent of myocardial injury following ischemia and reperfusion.

Hypertension

Hypertension is a chronic medical condition in which the arterial blood pressure is elevated (systolic >140 mm Hg, diastolic >90 mm Hg). It affects health of millions of people worldwide and remains the most common risk factor for cardiovascular morbidity and mortality. Several studies over the past decade have studied the effects of dietary nitrite and nitrate ingestion on blood pressure in animal models and in humans [27, 28, 30, 96, 97]. The results of these studies suggest that ingestion of dietary nitrite and nitrate can reduce blood pressure in both healthy and hypertensive conditions. For example, in Nω-nitro-l-arginine methyl ester (L-NAME)-induced hypertensive rat model, co-administration of nitrite with L-NAME was found to significantly attenuate blood pressure increases [96]. In another study, oral nitrate administration (at a dose of 0.1 mmol per kg of body weight per day for 3 days) has been shown to lower diastolic and mean arterial blood pressures in young normotensive subjects [27]. Indeed, a picture is now emerging showing that nitrite and nitrate contribute significantly to blood pressure reduction associated with fruit- and vegetable-rich diet intake, since these foods are rich in nitrite and nitrate content. For instance, in a recent study, Sobko et al. [98] demonstrated that consumption of vegetable-rich diet (traditional Japanese diet, 18.8 mg of nitrate per kg body weight per day) for 10 days greatly increased plasma nitrite and nitrate levels and lowered diastolic blood pressure by an average of 4.5 mm Hg compared to Western-style diet in healthy volunteers. In another study, Webb and colleagues [30] demonstrated that ingestion of nitrate load (beetroot juice, 500 mL, ~0.3 mmol nitrate per kg) reduced both systolic and diastolic blood pressures in healthy human volunteers, an effect that correlated with peak increases in plasma nitrite concentrations. Collectively, these studies clearly indicate that exogenous administration of nitrite and nitrate could reduce the blood pressure in both healthy and hypertensive conditions.

Other blood vessel-related conditions

Peripheral vascular disease and cerebrovascular ischemia (i.e., stroke) are often characterized by narrowing or blockade of the blood vessels supplying blood from or to the heart, leading to defective vascular perfusion, and, conversely, to decreased oxygen supply to tissues (i.e., ischemia). Emerging evidence supports the view that nitrite therapy could be of clinical utility in the treatment of these conditions. For instance, using left common femoral artery ligation method, Kumar et al. [99] recently demonstrated that sodium nitrite increases the percentage blood flow in ischemic hind limbs by day 3 of the ligation, which progressively increased by day 7. In another study, Jung et al. [100] investigated whether nitrite therapy limits ischemic injury in brain using adult male rats subjected to middle cerebral artery occlusion. The results of the later study demonstrated that early (30 min before ischemic surgery) intravenous infusion of low doses of sodium nitrite (48 and 480 nmol) protects brain against IR injury. An attractive possibility to explain the beneficial effects of nitrite and nitrate in the treatment of the above conditions is their ability to improve the blood flow, coupled at least in part to their vasodilator and/or antiplatelet effects (discussed in Sects. 4.2, 4.3). In addition, inhibition of superoxide anion production (discussed in Sect. 4.1.3), which promotes cellular damage by forming peroxynitrite via its reaction with NO, may also explain the beneficial effects of nitrite and nitrate in the prevention of cerebrovascular ischemia [100].

Toxicity of nitrite and nitrate

Interestingly, nitrite and nitrate have for long been considered as unwanted carcinogenic residues in the diet because several earlier studies (1970s and 1980s) have demonstrated that nitrite-derived reaction products in stomach may nitrosate dietary amines leading to the formation of N-nitrosamines, a class of carcinogenic substances that could cause tumors by reacting with nucleic acids [46, 101, 102]. However, several lines of experimental and epidemiological research failed to show any causative link between nitrite and nitrate intake and development of cancer [103–106]. For instance, a multiyear dose escalation study in rats and mice found no evidence of carcinogenicity by nitrite and nitrate in either species [103]. In addition, in healthy volunteers, high dietary nitrate (< 3.65 mg/kg body weight or ~250 mg nitrate) intake has been demonstrated to have no significant effect on both protein-bound (1.31 ± 0.14 ng/mg dry protein pre-intake vs. 1.39 ± 0.2 ng/mg dry protein postnitrate intake) and free (5.44 ± 1.19 nM pre-nitrate intake vs. 5.26 ± 1.54 nm post-nitrate intake) plasma 3-nitrotyrosine concentrations [49]. On the other hand, there are also reports showing association between nitrite and nitrate in meats with increased risk of bladder, prostate, and colorectal cancer [107, 108]. However, most associations in these studies were relatively weak (relative risk in most cases < 2) and should not be used for public policy recommendations according to the US National Cancer Institute [109] (Figs. 1, 2).

Fig. 1.

Schematic presentation of nitric oxide (NO) generation and metabolism in the body. NO is generated from the classical nitric oxide synthase (NOS)-l-arginine pathway and from the reduction of systemic nitrate (${\text{NO}}_3^{-}$) and nitrite (${\text{NO}}_2^{-}$). Systemic ${\text{NO}}_3^{-}\text{ and }{\text{NO}}_2^{-}$ originates from the oxidation of NO in biological fluids and from the diet. ${\text{NO}}_3^{-}$ undergoes reduction to ${\text{NO}}_2^{-}$ and then to NO. Possible ${\text{NO}}_3^{-}\text{ and }{\text{NO}}_2^{-}$ reduction pathways to NO in the body are depicted

Fig. 2.

Schematic presentation of potential mechanisms by which dietary nitrite and nitrate could modulate cardiovascular health

Conclusion

At present, it seems that dietary nitrite and nitrate have cardiovascular protective effects. As discussed in this review, the effects of nitrite and nitrate to enhance NO bioavailability, to improve endothelial function, to cause vasodilation, and to inhibit platelet aggregation may at least partly mediate their cardiovascular beneficial effects. Considering the fact that reduced bioavailability of endothelium-derived NO (i.e., endothelial dysfunction) is a cause of, or is associated with cardiovascular diseases, a role for nitrite and nitrate in NO biosynthesis and/or in improving NO bioavailability could provide a rationale for using dietary nitrite and nitrate supplementation in the treatment and prevention of cardiovascular diseases. Taking the data presented above together with the failure of recent studies to show significant correlation between nitrite and nitrate exposure and cancer, we suggest that the benefits of dietary nitrite and nitrate will strongly outweigh any potential risks, particularly for cardiovascular disease patients.