The mTOR Pathway and the Role of Energy Balance Throughout Life in Colorectal Cancer Etiology and Prognosis: Unravelling Mechanisms Through a Multidimensional Molecular Epidemiologic Approach

Abstract

Timing of exposure to lifestyle factors that influence energy balance may differentially affect colorectal cancer (CRC) risk and prognosis. Caloric restriction in youth and short stature, as markers of early-life exposures, have shown to decrease CRC risk, whereas large body size and low physical activity levels in adulthood are established risk factors for CRC. Regarding prognosis, overweight, sarcopenia, and their co-occurrence (sarcopenic obesity) may negatively influence the health and quality of life of CRC survivors. There is mechanistic support for disruption of the mammalian target of rapamycin (mTOR) pathway as an underlying mechanism possibly driving these associations, because mTOR integrates signals from growth factors, nutrients, mutagens, and hormones to induce cell proliferation, resistance to apoptosis, and autophagy. However, epidemiologic evidence connecting mTOR to energy-balance-related CRC throughout the lifespan is scarce. This perspective proposes how multidimensional molecular epidemiologic studies can shed light on the etiology and prognosis of energy-balance-related CRC.

Introduction

During the course of the past century, epidemiological studies have been invaluable for advancing our knowledge about modifiable risk factors for cancer. The influence of indicators of energy imbalance, such as a high body mass index and physical inactivity, on colorectal cancer (CRC) risk has been some of the most convincing evidence to emerge from such research [1]. Interestingly, increasing support also is emerging for the importance of energy balance throughout the lifespan for both cancer risk and prognosis [2••, 3].

A challenge of contemporary epidemiology is to determine the common molecular processes through which risk factors operate [4]. There is now strong evidence to suggest that the mammalian target of rapamycin (mTOR) plays a critical role in human health and aging; a number of chronic diseases are associated with disrupted mTOR signaling, including type 2 diabetes, obesity, metabolic syndrome, and several types of cancer, including CRC [5, 6••, 7••].

The mechanisms of mTOR signaling are well described, and animal studies have offered mechanistic insights supporting a role of mTOR in the association between energy balance and cancer development. However, epidemiologic data regarding the connection between mTOR and CRC are scarce, because few studies are large enough to consider small subgroups or do not yet have information on molecular and genetic endpoints in tumors. As more and more studies around the world are reaching the potential to gather this data, we offer a perspective of how future research could proceed, ideally by combining a number of research questions in one study. Considering the association between energy balance and CRC risk in a multidimensional fashion may not only shed light on the etiology and prognosis of CRC, but also on shared mechanisms underlying both CRC and other diseases. This can be accomplished by accounting for multiple indicators of energy exposure, including the timing of this exposure throughout the lifespan, as well as molecular and genetic characteristics of the tumor with respect to mTOR.

Lifestyle Factors Throughout the Lifespan that Influence CRC Incidence and Prognosis

Energy balance refers to the relationship between energy expenditure and energy intake. Energy imbalance resulting from more energy intake than expenditure, as reflected through overweight and obesity, is known to increase the risk of CRC [1, 8–14]. In contrast, physical activity, which can normalize this type of energy imbalance, has been shown to decrease the risk of CRC [1, 15–21]. There is no doubt that intra-abdominal (visceral) fat increases inflammatory responses and circulating estrogens, and decreases insulin sensitivity [22]. As a proxy measure for visceral adiposity, a high waist circumference has been associated with CRC risk in epidemiologic studies, independent of body mass index (BMI) [10, 23, 24]. Unique data from periods of reduced food availability, such as the Dutch Hunger Winter and World War 2 [25–32], support animal studies suggesting that caloric restriction, which can induce negative energy balance (less energy intake than expenditure), is one of the most potent interventions for preventing cancer [33–37]. Furthermore, timing of exposure to factors relating to energy balance may be important for modifying cancer risk.

Individuals who experienced caloric restriction in childhood and adolescence have a decreased risk of CRC later in life compared to those who did not experience it [27, 29, 31, 32, 38]. In contrast, body fatness during childhood [39] and adult-attained height, as a proxy measure for environmental and nutritional exposures that occurred in utero and in early childhood [40], are associated with an increased risk of CRC and/or colorectal adenomas [1, 10, 23, 39, 41].

With the aging of the population, the number of individuals living with a diagnosis of CRC (CRC survivors) is increasing. However, the role of energy balance in determining the prognosis and quality of life of survivors, an increasingly aging population, is still understudied [42]. The favorable effect of physical activity on quality of life in cancer survivors, including those with CRC [43], suggests that energy balance is relevant for healthy survivorship in this group as well. Although evidence is slowly accumulating for body fatness (usually assessed at or before diagnosis, but rarely after treatment) to have detrimental effects on survival, recurrence, and comorbidities in cancer survivors [44••, 45], the influence of lean body mass, especially loss of skeletal muscle mass (sarcopenia), on the health and quality of life of CRC survivors remains underinvestigated. Considerable variability in the body composition of CRC survivors has been noted, especially with respect to cachexia and sarcopenic obesity, i.e., muscle wasting without loss of adipose tissue [46, 47]. Sarcopenia leads to muscle function impairments, physical activity limitations, and restrictions in societal participation. Besides tumor-related hypermetabolism (increased resting energy expenditure, muscle protein catabolism) and inflammation, the balanced process of muscle protein turnover chiefly depends on nutrition and physical activity [48]. Both low-energy input (food intake, mainly low-protein nutrition) and output (physical inactivity, mainly few strength-training-type activities) contribute to progressive muscle wasting.

The mTOR Pathway in Energy-Related CRC

In a recent review, Chen identified multiple signaling pathways involved in obesity-associated cancer, and ultimately postulated that mTOR activity could be the key to unlocking the signal pathway changes that occur in the development of such cancers [49]. mTOR is a highly evolutionary conserved serine/threonine kinase that controls cell growth and metabolism in response to nutrients (e.g., amino acids), growth factors (e.g., insulin, insulin-like growth factor (IGF)-1, acting through phosphatidylinositol 3-kinase (PI3K)), cellular energy (ATP acting through inhibition of adenosine monophosphate-dependent protein kinase (AMPK)), and stress (e.g., hypoxia and DNA damage) [7••, 50]. mTOR is at the interface between growth and starvation. It positively regulates anabolic processes, such as transcription, protein synthesis, ribosome biogenesis, nutrient transport, and mitochondrial metabolism. At the same time, mTOR negatively regulates catabolic processes, such as mRNA degradation, ubiquitin-dependent proteolysis, autophagy, and apoptosis. It also has been shown that sirtuin-1 (SIRT-1), which regulates energy efficiency during caloric restriction, may negatively regulate mTOR in response to nutrients and cellular stress [51].

The PI3K-protein kinase B(Akt)-mTOR signaling pathway includes several established proto-oncogenes (e.g. PI3K, v-akt murine thymoma viral oncogene homolog 1 (AKT1)) and tumor suppressor genes (e.g. phosphatase and tensin homolog (PTEN)) [7••, 52]. The PTEN protein antagonizes PI3K function and negatively regulates Akt/mTOR activity [44••]. Epidemiological data suggest that sporadic mutation or deregulation of PI3K, Akt and PTEN are among the most prevalent alterations in human cancer [7••, 54]. Recently, Gulhati et al. reported that activation of PI3K-Akt is linked to growth and progression of CRC [55], which supports their previous finding that mTOR kinase can regulate CRC tumorgenesis [56].

A plausible mechanistic link between energy balance, mTOR, and CRC development is insulin-like growth factor 1 (IGF-1) upstream from mTOR [57]. Evidence from animal models supports the idea that reduction in circulating free IGF-1 is associated with the anticancer effects of caloric restriction [33, 58]. Epidemiological research has shown that hyperinsulemia, which decreases IGF-1 binding protein 3 (IGFBP3) and consequently increases circulating IGF-1, and diabetes both increase the risk of CRC [59–61]. Activation of mTOR has emerged as a critical event in rendering insulin receptor substrate (IRS)-1 and IRS-2 unresponsive to insulin and IGF-1 [62]. Therefore, proper regulation of the PI3K-Akt-mTOR signaling pathway is critical for the prevention of insulin resistance. Further evidence supporting this link is that excess body fat is associated with both high serum levels of IGF-1 and enhanced induction of the PI3K-Akt-mTOR signaling pathway, whereas caloric restriction is associated with reduced signaling as a result of decreased circulating levels of IGF-1 [34, 63].

There are two functionally and structurally distinct complexes which contain mTOR: mTOR complex 1 (mTORC1), which is rapamycin sensitive, and mTORC2, which is rapamycin insensitive. Although both are relevant for carcinogenesis, mTORC1 is thought to be influenced by energy balance, specifically energy restriction [2••, 7••]. Molecular mediators involved in muscle wasting likely include disruption of the mTORC1 pathway. This energy balance-related pathway is a crucial regulator of protein synthesis in response to energy input (nutrient intake) and output (physical activity). Downregulated mTORC1 signaling results in reduced protein translation and promotes protein breakdown via autophagy [7••, 64]. Decreased levels of circulating amino acids, glucose, insulin, and IGF-1 reduce mTORC1 signaling. Research on sarcopenia underscores that probably both essential amino acid availability, especially leucine, and resistance exercise counteract sarcopenia through acute regulation of mTORC1 signaling [7••, 48, 65–67]. It also is noteworthy that metformin, the initial glucose lowering therapy for type 2 diabetic patients, has been associated with a significantly lower risk of CRC in type 2 diabetic patients in a recent meta-analysis [68]. The mechanism of action of metformin is believed to be through activation of AMPK and hence inhibition of mTORC1 signaling. Tissue specificity of mTORC1 signaling has yet to be determined. It is plausible that epigenetic changes, such as methylated IGFBP genes in CRC, may disrupt mTORC1 signaling in CRC cells.

Toward a Multidimensional Molecular Epidemiologic Approach

We propose a multidimensional molecular epidemiologic approach to further unravel the role of the mTOR signaling pathway in energy-balance-related CRC etiology and prognosis throughout life (Fig. 1). Ideally, simultaneous investigation of a range of exposures and their joint effects, the timing of exposures, and diverse molecular biomarkers of the mTOR pathway is considered in future studies.

Fig. 1.

A multidimensional molecular epidemiologic approach to studying the role of mTOR and energy balance throughout the lifespan in colorectal cancer etiology and prognosis

Consider a Range of Exposures and Their Joint Effects

In general, it is difficult to account accurately for energy balance in epidemiological studies, because energy balance is maintained by a complex system involving multiple pathways and is dependent on genetic factors. The variables used in epidemiological studies, such as BMI, waist circumference, caloric intake, and physical activity status, are not sufficient on their own to describe overall energy balance status [58]. Considering joint effects can help paint a more comprehensive picture than considering single variables in isolation. Both BMI and waist circumference have been reported to show interactions with physical activity levels in relation to CRC [10, 69, 70]. Such joint effects, which have not yet been investigated systematically, can reveal associations that may remain masked when focusing on just one aspect of energy balance.

In addition, investigating both ends of the exposure spectra throughout the lifespan can reinforce our knowledge of underlying pathways. As reviewed earlier, both caloric excess and caloric restriction, as well as sarcopenic obesity in CRC survivors, are associated with either cancer risk or prognosis, respectively, in part through their influence on mTOR signaling. Therefore, with respect to untangling the role of mTOR in the association between energy balance and CRC, and in terms of creating prevention strategies, it is most informative to consider joint associations between exposure variables within studies if possible or otherwise consider literature from different exposure spectra.

Consider the Timing of Exposures

Studying the timing of exposure can shed valuable insights into cancer etiology. Epidemiological studies have shown that timing of exposure, both in terms of the life phase during which exposure occurs [27, 29, 31, 32, 38, 39], and in terms of changes in exposure over time [71], may be important for modulating CRC risk. Examples from animal models of other cancer types support this idea with respect to mTOR signaling [72, 73].

Childhood obesity is now a major health concern, but the long-term consequences of being obese during this critical phase of growth and development remain largely undetermined. To our knowledge, no study has investigated the role of indicators of energy balance early in life and the effect of mTOR signaling in cancer later in life. However, evidence from a rat study investigating radiation exposure early in life supports that early life environmental exposure may have mechanistic implications for mTOR. In this study, Kokubo et al. [72] assessed the risk of renal cell carcinoma in rats irradiated at various time points in the gestational and postnatal period. At 27 weeks of age, kidneys were examined for proliferative lesions. Compared with unirradiated controls, adenoma and adenocarcinoma development were evident in perinatally irradiated kidneys. Furthermore, these malignant changes were associated with mTOR activation in tumors, suggesting that early life environmental exposure has implications for mTOR signaling.

With respect to changes in exposure over time, a recent study by De Angel et al. [73] investigated the impact of weight normalization in ovariectomized female mice on breast cancer development. Mice were fed a control diet, a calorie reduced (CR) diet, or an obesity inducing (DIO) diet. At 17 weeks, the mice on the obesity-inducing diet were switched to a control diet, resulting in obese mice decreasing to a similar weight to the controls by week 20. Relative to controls, CR mice had decreased, and DIO mice had increased serum IGF-1 and phosphorylation of Akt/mTOR pathway components. Of relevance to the point at hand is that weight normalization in obese mice did not immediately reverse tumor progression or Akt/mTOR activation. If replicated in humans, this finding could have implications for prevention strategies.

Consider Diverse Molecular Biomarkers

Biomarkers of Exposure

Assessing exposure in large-scale, prospective, epidemiologic studies is a major challenge and assessing early life-time exposures is even more challenging. Biomarkers related to altered energy balance during different phases of life could lend support to observed associations between indicators of energy balance and CRC in epidemiological studies. Multiple cancer risk factors have been identified in relation to obesity, including increased blood levels of insulin, IGF1, estrogen, proinflammatory cytokines, adipokines, and other inflammatory markers [4, 49, 60, 61, 74–76]. As reviewed by Chen [49], animal studies have shown that such factors exert their effects by activating multiple signaling pathways, including PI3K-Akt and IGF signaling pathways, which in turn lead to the activation of mTOR.

Exciting developments and opportunities should be monitored for potential application in epidemiologic studies. For example, gut microbial enterotypes have recently been associated with long-term dietary patterns, specifically protein and animal fat (Bacteroides) versus carbohydrates (Prevotella) [74]. In a study comparing the fecal microbiota of children living in Europe and rural Burkina Faso, where the diet is high in fiber content, significant differences in gut microbiota between the two groups were observed, for example, with an abundance of Prevotella bacteria in the children from Africa [75]. These studies are just emerging and need to be replicated, but the composition of gut microbiota may be an interesting future tool to fingerprint early-life and long-term exposures, including the diet, and their role in pathways, such as the mTOR pathway to CRC cancer.

Biomarkers of Outcome

One of the most exciting developments in modern epidemiology is the emergence of the field of molecular pathological epidemiology. As Ogino et al. describe, a strength of this type of research is that germ line genetic variants and molecular alterations in the tumor can be studied simultaneously, and as such, the specificity of the relationship between genetic variants and tumor molecular alterations can provide additional evidence to support a causal effect of the putative cancer susceptibility allele [76]. In addition, the molecular signatures of tumors can be viewed as fingerprints of prior internal and external exposures, because the timing of molecular events in carcinogenesis are known to differ, with epigenetic changes occurring relatively early in carcinogenesis. In the Netherlands Cohort Study on diet and cancer, early-life exposure to energy restriction was inversely associated with CRC risk according to the degree of promoter hypermethylation in a number of cancer-related genes [38]. This result suggests that exposure to severe malnutrition during youth can protect from persistent epigenetic changes that later influence CRC development.

Biomarkers of Susceptibility

Genetic variants can be viewed as time-independent biomarkers of pathway involvement [77]. Selecting genetic variants from pathways related to mTOR signaling and investigating their interaction with determinants of energy balance in relation to CRC is thereby another promising avenue for molecular epidemiologic research in this area.

In 2009, Slattery et al. proposed the “convergence of hormones, inflammation, and energy-related factors” (CHIEF) pathway, to provide a mechanistic explanation for the convergent effects of inflammation, hormones, and energy-related factors, such as obesity, physical activity, and energy intake on colorectal carcinogenesis [4]. Supported by molecular and epidemiological evidence, there are two major arms of the pathway, one of which contains mTOR. Using data from the Northern California Kaiser Permanente Medical Care Program (KPMCP) and the Twin Cities Metropolitan area of Minnesota, Slattery et al. investigated genetic variation in the CHIEF pathway and showed that variation in mTOR altered the risk of CRC, even after adjustment for multiple comparisons [78]. Intriguingly, when molecular tumor markers were taken into account, the strongest associations for mTOR were observed for tumors characterized by microsatellite instability (MSI). This suggests that through the CHIEF pathway, mTOR may influence risk through epigenetic changes, and shows the importance of considering both the genetic and molecular characteristics of the tumor.

The benefit of studying gene-environment interactions can be seen in a recent case-control study by Lin et al. [70], in which the association between energy balance and risk of bladder cancer was investigated in 803 cases and matched controls by assessing the joint effects of genetic variants in PI3K-Akt-mTOR pathway genes with indicators of energy balance. Although several, large, population-based studies have reported genetic variability of the mTOR pathway with respect to cancer risk [52, 78, 79], to our knowledge, the study of Lin et al. is the only study to date to consider energy balance additionally in this equation. To explore how unfavorable genotypes in the mTOR pathway may modify the association between energy balance and cancer risk, the authors created a sum of unfavorable genotypes to conduct a stratified analysis (0–4 unfavorable genotypes, 5–6 unfavorable genotypes, and ≥7 unfavorable genotypes). Those subjects with the worst “energy balance” category (high caloric intake, low physical activity, high number of unfavorable genotypes) had a significantly higher risk of bladder cancer compared with those individuals with the most favorable energy balance category (low caloric intake, intensive physical activity, low number of unfavorable genotypes). Intriguingly, this effect was stronger than when caloric intake and physical activity were considered independently from each other.

Conclusions

Although with small sample sizes it may be a challenge for individual cohorts to combine our suggested considerations into one study, there is emerging potential to pool data from multiple studies utilizing a molecular pathological epidemiology approach to research [80, 81]. Furthermore, besides increased statistical power when data from multiple studies are appropriately combined, the findings from such pooled cohorts will have increased generalizability and external validity. Such collaboration and cooperation will serve to advance population science and public health [81]. It also is intriguing to speculate about how future studies could simultaneously focus on multiple diseases that are interlinked through the mTOR signaling pathway and shared risk factors. For example, energy imbalance is a risk factor for several types of cancer in addition to CRC, which also have been shown to demonstrate impaired mTOR signaling. These include breast cancer [34, 73, 82], bladder cancer [70, 79], and renal cell carcinoma [53]. One may hypothesize that despite the different tumor types, a similar underlying mechanism is at play. Therefore, to find out how molecular and genetic aspects of mTOR signaling pathway genes modify the association between energy balance and cancer, it may be informative and statistically more powerful to consider cancer as a single endpoint comprised of a number of specific cancers that may share etiology, such as obesity-related cancers. Furthermore, as noted earlier, dysregulated mTOR signaling is associated with several diseases that are associated with CRC, such as metabolic syndrome and type 2 diabetes [5, 6••, 7••]. A truly multidimensional approach, and one that would shed valuable insight on etiology, would be to simultaneously consider these related diseases so that the pathway to disease is being investigated rather than individual disease endpoints.

In conclusion, defects in mTOR signaling may be the key to unlocking the reported associations between overweight, obesity, caloric restriction throughout life, and CRC. We have presented a perspective of how future epidemiological studies could proceed to glean the most mechanistic information about such biological pathways. Considering genetic and molecular aspects of the mTOR signaling pathway in conjunction with indicators of energy balance at different periods of life will result in a better understanding of CRC etiology and prognosis, which is necessary for fine tuning prevention strategies.