Table 1. Selected works studying gray matter lesions in MS and their diagnostic and prognostic relevance (physical and cognitive disability).
Study | Patients | Follow up | Parameters Evaluated | Main outcome |
---|---|---|---|---|
Filippi et al. 2010 |
80 CIS |
4 y |
CLs, T2-WM lesions, Gad+ lesions |
The accuracy of MRI diagnostic criteria for MS is increased when considering the presence of CLs on baseline scans from patients at presentation with CIS suggestive of MS. |
Calabrese et al. 2012 |
86 patients with CIS. |
3 y |
CL and WM lesion number, new MRI activity, CSF examination. |
The association of intrathecal Ig synthesis and CLs is highly predictive of an earlier CIS conversion to MS as well as of a higher disease activity. |
Popescu et al. 2011 |
One RRMS. |
Case Report |
MRI, CSF and histological examination. |
Pathologic evidence of RRMS patient presenting with inflammatory solitary cortical enhancing lesion. |
Calabrese et al. 2009 |
4 RRMS |
Case Report |
CLs and T2-WM lesions |
CLs were observed by DIR before the MRI evidence of inflammatory lesions in the white matter |
Absinta et al. 2012 |
32 patients with migraine, 15 RRMS, 20 healthy controls. |
Cross-sectional |
T2-WM lesion and CL count and volume. |
No CLs identified in migraine patients. The application of DIR imaging seems to be useful in the diagnostic workup of patients with WM hyperintensities of unknown etiology, including those with migraine. |
Giorgio et al. 2011 |
15 radiologically isolated syndrome. |
Cross-sectional |
T2-WM lesion and CL count and volume, normalized brain and cortical volume |
CLs are identified in subject with RIS (40%) and are frequent in subjects with IgOBs and dissemination in time. CLs are therefore associated with important markers of evolution to MS. |
Popescu et al. 2011 |
19 autopsied NMO patients |
Cross-sectional |
Histological examination. |
Lack of cortical demyelination in patients with NMO is a feature that might help distinguishing NMO from MS. |
Calabrese et al. 2012 in press |
30 NMO patients, 30 RRMS patients, 30 healthy controls. |
Cross-sectional |
CL and T2-WM lesion count, global and regional cortical thickness. |
No CLs identified in patients with NMO and no significant differences found in cortical thickness between NMO a controls. MRI analysis of the cortex may be a potential diagnostic tool, especially in ambiguous cases. |
Absinta et al. 2011 |
24 pediatric and 15 adult MS. |
Cross-sectional |
WM lesions and CLs number and volume, GM and WM volumes. |
CL are rare in patients with MS in comparison with adult patients. |
Calabrese et al. 2010 |
76 RRMS, 31 SPMS |
3 y |
CL and T2-WM lesion number and volume, T2-WM lesion volume, GM volume |
CL volume correlates with EDSS and EDSS changes over time and it is an independent predictor of EDSS accumulation and GM volume change in SP and RRMS patients. |
Calabrese et al. 2009 |
48 benign MS, 96 early not disabling RRMS. |
1 y |
CL and T2-WM lesion number and volume, |
Benign MS have lower CL number compared with early RRMS patients. At one-year follow-up a significant increase of CL number and volume is observed only in early patients with RRMS. |
Calabrese et al. 2012 |
35 pediatric and 57 adult MS |
3 y |
CL and T2-WM lesion number and volume, GM volume |
Focal (CLs) and diffuse (atrophy) GM damage are strictly associated with the biologic onset of MS, and proceed linearly and partly independently of WM pathology. |
Calabrese et al. 2012 |
32 RRMS with epilepsy, 60 RRMS without epilepsy. |
3 y |
CL and T2-WM lesion number and volume, regional cortical thickness, new CLs and WM lesions; neuropsychological evaluation |
Cortical pathology, psysical and cognitive decline are more severe and evolving in MS patients with epilepsy compared with patients without epilepsy. |
Roosendal et al. 2009 |
9 RRMS, 4 SPMS, 7 healthy controls |
3-y |
CL and T2-WM lesion number and volume, neuropsychological evaluation |
CLs increase significantly over a 3 y time period, are most frequent in SP patients and are associated with cognitive impairment. |
Mike et al. 2011 |
20 RRMS, 20 SPMS |
Cross-sectional |
CLs number and volume, T2-WM volume, EDSS, cognitive testing. |
Routinely detectable cortical lesions were related to physical disability and cognitive impairment better than T2-WM lesions |
Calabrese et al. 2009 | 70 RRMS | Cross-sectional | CL and T2-WM lesion number and volume, GM volume. neuropsychological evaluation | Cognitively impaired patients have a higher CL number and volume, decreased normalized cortical volume compared with cognitively preserved patients. |
Abbreviations: CLs, cortical lesions; CSF, Cerebro-spinal-fluid; DIR, Double inversion recovery; Gad*, gadolinium enhancing lesions; GM, gray matter; IgGOB, IgG oligoclonali bands; MRI, magnetic resonance imaging, MS, Multiple Sclerosis; NMO, Neuromyelitis optica; RIS, radiologically isolated syndrome; RRMS, relapsing remitting multiple sclerosis; SPMS, secondary progressive multiple sclerosis; T2-WM, T2 white matter; WM, white matter