The tympanic membrane displacement analyser for monitoring intracranial pressure in children

Abstract

Purpose

Raised intracranial pressure (ICP) is a potentially treatable cause of morbidity and mortality but tools for monitoring are invasive. We sought to investigate the utility of the tympanic membrane displacement (TMD) analyser for non-invasive measurement of ICP in children.

Methods

We made TMD observations on normal and acutely comatose children presenting to Kilifi District Hospital (KDH) at the rural coast of Kenya and on children on follow-up for idiopathic intracranial hypertension at Evelina Children’s Hospital (ECH), in London, UK.

Results

We recruited 63 patients (median age 3.3 (inter-quartile range (IQR) 2.0–4.3) years) at KDH and 14 children (median age 10 (IQR 5–11) years) at ECH. We observed significantly higher (more negative) TMD measurements in KDH children presenting with coma compared to normal children seen at the hospital’s outpatient department, in both semi-recumbent [mean −61.3 (95 % confidence interval (95 % CI) −93.5 to 29.1) nl versus mean −7.1 (95 % CI −54.0 to 68.3) nl, respectively; P = 0.03] and recumbent postures [mean −61.4 (95 % CI −93.4 to −29.3) nl, n = 59) versus mean −25.9 (95 % CI −71.4 to 123.2) nl, respectively; P = 0.03]. We also observed higher TMD measurements in ECH children with raised ICP measurements, as indicated by lumbar puncture manometry, compared to those with normal ICP, in both semi-recumbent [mean −259.3 (95 % CI −363.8 to −154.8) nl versus mean 26.7 (95 % CI −52.3 to 105.7) nl, respectively; P < 0.01] and recumbent postures [mean −137.5 (95 % CI −260.6 to −14.4) nl versus mean 96.6 (95 % CI 6.5 to 186.6) nl, respectively; P < 0.01].

Conclusion

The TMD analyser has a potential utility in monitoring ICP in a variety of clinical circumstances.

Introduction

Raised intracranial pressure (ICP) complicates both traumatic and non-traumatic encephalopathies [1–3]. It causes impaired cerebral perfusion leading to brain ischaemia and may result in death due to global ischaemia or herniation of brain tissue [4]. In chronic conditions associated with perturbations of cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) flow dynamics such as idiopathic intracranial hypertension (IIH) [5] and hydrocephalus, it may cause disabling headaches, damage to the optic nerve and inner ear [6] and brain atrophy.

Timely recognition and management of raised ICP may improve outcome [7]. However, the standard tools for monitoring ICP are invasive, require a high level of expertise and have clinically significant risks including haemorrhage, infection and probe displacement [4]. Non-invasive tools could circumvent these limitations, allowing for detailed investigations and life-saving management of diverse raised intracranial pressure syndromes throughout the world.

The tympanic membrane displacement (TMD) analyser (MMS-11^TM, Marchbanks Measurement Systems) was designed for non-invasive monitoring of ICP. It makes use of the communication between the subarachnoid space and the inner ear through the cochlear aqueduct, allowing for transmission of ICP to the perilymphatic space (Fig. 1) [8]. The resulting changes in perilymphatic pressure cause alterations in the kinematics of the middle ear ossicles causing measurable displacements of the tympanic membrane. An air displacement sensor probe sealed into the external auditory meatus detects fluctuations in the volume (in nanolitres) of the external auditory meatus due to these displacements.

Fig. 1.

A schematic representation of the communication between the subarachnoid space and the inner ear through the cochlear aqueduct

Acoustic stimulation of the stapedial reflex with a 1,000-Hz sound stimulus through the ear probe results in contraction of the stapedial muscle, causing movement of the tympanic membrane. The direction and amplitude of movement are determined by the resting position of the stapes footplate within the oval window, which is in turn dependent on the perilymphatic fluid pressure and therefore ICP. Raised ICP causes inward motion (negative measurement) of the tympanic membrane, low ICP causes outward motion and normal pressure results in outward or bidirectional motion (Fig. 2). The size of the displacement is quantified by measuring the area under the resulting curve of motion, providing TMD baseline pressure measurements [9].

Fig. 2.

TMD baseline pressure measurement patterns. a shows a positive deflection of the TMD curve representing a low ICP pressure pattern while b shows a negative deflection indicating a raised ICP pattern. c A bilateral deflection indicating normal ICP. The area shaded in blue is the area under the curve over the duration of the stapedius reflex response. Calculation of this area is done by the machine software with the user indicating the most negative deflection of the curve and the end of reflex response

In this report, we present our experience with TMD baseline pressure measurements in normal and acutely comatose children presenting to Kilifi District Hospital (KDH) at the rural coast of Kenya, and TMD measurements in children followed up for IIH at Evelina Children’s Hospital (ECH), in London UK.

Methods

Setting

We conducted these studies at two sites of different resource status: the paediatric high dependency unit (HDU) and outpatient departments (OPDs) of KDH in Kilifi, a malaria-endemic area in the rural coast of Kenya, and the acute neurology service of ECH in London, UK.

Study population

At the paediatric HDU of KDH, between November 2007 and September 2009, we evaluated children aged between 6 months and 13 years presenting in acute coma (inability to localise painful stimuli, persisting for longer than 30 min after correction of hypoglycaemia or treatment of a seizure) [10]. We excluded children known to have sickle cell disease, epilepsy or developmental delay. At the KDH OPD, we evaluated normal children (aged 2 to 13 years) presenting for consideration for recruitment into a study on moderate malnutrition but found not to be eligible because they were well nourished, between August and September 2009. We excluded children who had abnormal middle ear function as determined by tympanometry and those with signs and symptoms of neurological illnesses. The Kilifi studies were approved by the Kenya Medical Research Institute Ethics Committee (SCC no. 1249).

At ECH, we evaluated children aged below 16 years with an established or suspected diagnosis of IIH, with at least 6 months neurological and ophthalmological follow-up. We excluded children with ventriculomegaly, CNS mass lesions or venous sinus thrombosis on neuroimaging. The Evelina study was approved by the Guys and St. Thomas’ Research Ethics Committee (ref. 99/09/14).

Standard procedures

The Kenyan children admitted to the HDU were managed according to the standard guidelines for sick children [11, 12]. We classified these children as having cerebral malaria (CM) based on the WHO definition: coma in a child with falciparum malaria parasitaemia in the absence of evidence for an alternative explanation for cause of illness [13]. We considered a diagnosis of acute bacterial meningitis (ABM) when bacteria were isolated on CSF culture, gram staining or bacterial antigen testing, or when there was a CSF leucocyte count of at least 10 per microlitre and the blood-to-CSF glucose ratio was less than 0.67 [14]. Children who had blood culture-confirmed bacteraemia in the absence of any indication of ABM were assumed to have sepsis. We classified children who did not have any history of trauma and no indication of CM, ABM or bacteraemia, as unknown encephalopathy. Beyond screening for the study, Kenyan children at OPD did not undergo any extra laboratory or radiological procedures. Children at the ECH were seen during routine clinic visits for treatment for IIH. Management for IIH was guided by the standard published guidance [5, 15].

Study procedure

Upon obtaining informed consent from the children’s parents or guardians, we carried out tympanometry on the KDH children. Thereafter, we made TMD measurements on these children in both semi-recumbent (approximately 30°) and recumbent postures. If a child became stable, lumbar puncture (LP) manometry was performed.

For ECH children, tympanometry was not done prior to TMD measurements. TMD measurements were similarly done in semi-recumbent and recumbent positions. LP manometry was performed under controlled conditions to standardise for awake carbon dioxide levels as previously described [16], during the TMD observations as part of the management. LP manometry measurements were classified as normal if below 25 cm of water or raised ICP if at or above 25 cm of water.

Analysis

We analysed the data using Stata software version 11.0 (StataCorp LP, TX, USA). We explored continuous data graphically using histograms and by applying the Shapiro–Wilk test to check for violations of the normality assumption. We applied the Student’s t test for comparison of normally distributed continuous data and Kruskal–Wallis equality of populations test for non-normal data. We examined for association between categorical data using chi-square and Fisher’s exact tests as appropriate. We assessed for statistical significance at the conventional 5 % and where appropriate reported results as odds ratio and 95 % confidence intervals (95 % CI), or as medians and inter-quartile ranges (IQRs).

Results

At KDH HDU, we recruited 63 children out of an eligible 113 children (Fig. 3). They had a median age of 3.3 (IQR 2.0–4.3) years and 27 (43 %) were female. Thirty-two had cerebral malaria, 7 bacterial meningitis, 4 sepsis and 20 unknown encephalopathies (Table 1). Eighteen (29 %) of them died and six (10 %) had gross neurological deficits at the time of discharge. At the KDH OPD, we recruited 24 children. They were of median age 5.6 (IQR 4.6, 6.7) years and 16 were female.

Fig. 3.

Study flow chart of patients admitted in coma and recruited at the Kilifi High Dependency Unit. Six patients were eligible for recruitment but the study clinician was not aware at the time of their admission

Table 1.

Baseline characteristics of Kilifi patients

Characteristic	Inpatient (n = 63)	Outpatient (n = 24)
Age (years)	3.3 (2.0–4.3)	5.6 (4.6–6.7)
Sex
Male	36	8
Female	27	16
Systolic blood pressure	98 (89–104)	–
Diastolic blood pressure	60 (50–66)	–
Axillary temperature	38.5 (37.6–39.0)	37.2 (36.7–37.8)
Abnormal motor posturing
Opisthotonous	4	–
Decerebrate	8	–
Decorticate	7	–
Papilloedema	3	–
pH	7.39 (7.28–7.43)	–
Partial pressure of CO2 (kPa)	4.0 (3.2–4.8)	–
Partial pressure of O2 (kPa)	7.2 (5.2–14.9)	–
Haemoglobin (g/dl)	8.7 (6.8–10.3)	–
Diagnosis
Normal child	–	24
Cerebral malaria	32	–
Acute bacterial meningitis	7	–
Sepsis	4	–
Unknown encephalopathy	20	–
Died	18	–

Summary of the baseline characteristics of the patients recruited at Kilifi District Hospital. Data for inpatients and outpatients were provided side by side for convenience and not for comparison as the two groups of children were different by design

HDU children admitted in coma had higher (more negative) TMD baseline pressure measurements than OPD normal children in both the semi-recumbent (P = 0.03) and recumbent postures (P = 0.03) (Fig. 4). Among the HDU patients, there were no differences in TMD measurements between those who died and those who survived, in both the semi-recumbent [mean −83.5 (95 % CI −162.7 to −4.3) nl versus mean −52.4 (95 % CI −86.6 to −18.2) nl, respectively; P = 0.39] and recumbent postures [mean −68.4 (95 % CI −132.2 to −4.6) nl versus mean −58.8 (95 % CI −97.4 to −20.2) nl, respectively; P = 0.79]. Among the survivors, there were no differences in measurements between those who had neurological sequelae and those who survived in both semi-recumbent [mean −35.8 (95 % CI −82.7 to 11.0) nl versus mean −54.9 (95 % CI −94.2 to −15.7) nl, respectively; P = 0.71] and recumbent positions [mean −36.7 (95 % CI −90.4 to 17.0) nl versus mean −62.3 (95 % CI −106.9 to −17.7) nl, respectively; P = 0.64]. No association was noted between TMD measurements and diagnosis, partial pressure of carbon dioxide and haemoglobin level. There was no difference between semi-recumbent and recumbent TMD baseline pressure measurements [mean −39.7 (95 % CI −71.8 to −7.6) nl compared to mean −41.8 (95 % CI −74.7 to −9.0) nl, respectively; n = 76, P = 0.88].

Fig. 4.

TMD baseline pressure measurements at Kilifi District Hospital. Semi-recumbent (A) TMD baseline pressure measurements were greater (more negative) for HDU children (inpatient coma) (mean −61.3 (95 % CI −93.5 to −29.1) nl, n = 63) than for OPD normal children (mean −7.1 (95 % CI −54.0 to 68.3) nl; n = 24, P = 0.03). Recumbent (B) measurements were similarly greater for HDU children (mean −61.4 (95 % CI −93.4 to −29.3) nl, n = 59) than for OPD children (mean −25.9 (95 % CI −71.4 to 123.2) nl; n = 17, P = 0.03). HDU children showed much less variation with a mean clustered around −60 nl

Only seven of the HDU children were stable enough to undergo lumbar puncture manometry with corresponding TMD measurements. None of them had an LP manometry measurement above 25 cm of water (range 5–21.5 cm of water). The opening LP manometry measurements did not significantly correlate with semi-recumbent TMD measurements (r = 0.49, P = 0.32) or recumbent measurements (r = 0.30, P = 0.52).

At ECH, we recruited 14 children with headache who were being followed up for IIH (median age 10 (IQR 5–11) years). Five had raised ICP (range 25–65 cm of water) on initial LP manometry while the rest had lumbar CSF pressure measurements ranging from 6 to 24 cm of water. We successfully measured TMD in 12 children in the semi-recumbent posture (five with raised ICP) and seven in the recumbent position (two with raised ICP). Semi-recumbent (A) TMD baseline pressure measurements were greater (more negative) for ECH children with raised ICP (mean −259.3 (95 % CI −363.8 to −154.8) nl, n = 6) compared to those with normal ICP (mean 26.7 (95 % CI −52.3 to 105.7) nl; n = 10, P < 0.01). Recumbent measurements were also similarly greater for children with raised ICP (mean −137.5 (95 % CI −260.6 to −14.4) nl, n = 4) than for those with normal ICP (mean 96.6 (95 % CI 6.5 to 186.6) nl; n = 7, P < 0.01) (Fig. 5). There were no significant differences in TMD measurements between normal HDU outpatients and ECH patients with normal ICP, for both semi-recumbent (P = 0.61) and recumbent measurements (P = 0.33) (Figs. 4 and 5).

Fig. 5.

TMD baseline pressure measurements at Evelina Children’s Hospital. Semi-recumbent (A) TMD baseline pressure measurements were greater (more negative) for ECH children with raised ICP (mean −259.3 (95 % CI −363.8 to −154.8) nl, n = 6) compared to those with normal ICP (mean 26.7 (95 % CI −52.3 to 105.7) nl; n = 10, P < 0.01). Recumbent measurements were also similarly greater for children with raised ICP (mean −137.5 (95 % CI −260.6 to −14.4), n = 4) than for those with normal ICP (mean 96.6 (95 % CI 6.5 to 186.6) nl; n = 7, P < 0.01)

In one ECH patient, follow-up measurements of corresponding TMD and LP manometry measurements were taken. The initial TMD measurement was −252 nl and the corresponding LP manometer reading was 40 cm of water. The subsequent TMD measurements were −197 and −45 nl corresponding to LP manometer readings of 36 and 10 cm of water, respectively (Fig. 6).

Fig. 6.

Comparison between TMD and LP manometry measurements in a 5-year-old child. Corresponding TMD and LP manometry measurements in a 5-year-old child with IIH taken at three separate occasions

Discussion

In the Kenyan arm of the study, we observed higher (more negative) TMD measurements in HDU coma patients compared to normal children reviewed at the hospital’s OPD. Only seven of the comatose Kenyan children underwent LP manometry, and in all of these, the ICP was less than 25 cm water. There was no significant correlation between these measurements and TMD measurements. Although there was no significant difference in TMD measurements between HDU patients who survived and those who died, the study was clearly not powered to examine for such differences in clinical outcomes. At ECH, we observed greater negative TMD measurements in patients with raised ICP compared to those with normal ICP. Although measurements of OPD normal Kenyan children were similar to British patients with normal ICP, we do appreciate that these are two different population groups and are not ideal for comparison.

Communication between the intracranial space and the inner ear has consistently been demonstrated in a number of studies [8]. The questions are whether the pressure so transmitted is further altered by pressure dynamics and kinematics in the inner and middle ear, perhaps unique in every individual, and which technique is best suited to measure this relationship and provide an accurate index measure of ICP. Previous studies have indicated a significant correlation between baseline TMD and direct ICP measurements in individuals with patent cochlear aqueduct [17–21]. However, there appears to be significant inter-subject variability in this relationship, with consistency in the magnitude of association being observed only within an individual [19, 21]. In one study, TMD baseline pressure measurements revealed very wide predictive limits of ICP, indicating that TMD measurement could not be used as a reliable surrogate for ICP measurement [19]. Such inter-subject variability has been attributed to differences in elasticity of the annular ligaments or in the anatomical relations between the pyramidal eminentia, stapes, stapedial tendon and incudo-stapedial joint [22]. Inter-subject variability could also be due to intracranial anatomical differences which may alter intracranial compliance, perhaps indicating why some individuals appear to suffer clinical symptoms at mildly increased ICP while others are asymptomatic at relatively higher ICP levels. Shimbles et al. (2005) studied a wide patient age range of 4 to 92 years (median of 35 years), whereas our own study was restricted to children of age of 16 years or less [19]. We think that this helps to reduce the inter-subject variability since a number of the above factors are age dependent.

Indeed, in the British arm of our study, we observed correspondence between serial TMD and LP manometry measurements in one individual. We did not demonstrate a consistent pattern of correlation between TMD and ICP measurements in both the British and Kenyan arms of the study, in part because many Kenyan children were too ill to have invasive measurements of ICP by conventional lumbar puncture manometry. However, the ability to simply distinguish between patients with raised and normal ICP, and discern those who are severely unwell from those who are normal, suggests a potential utility albeit not yet well understood. It appears possible to have initial concurrent ICP and TMD measurements to define the relationship between the two variables within an individual, before using subsequent TMD measurements to guide management for the individual. It has also been possible to demonstrate pathophysiological patterns in ICP using the TMD analyser and LP on continuous manometry to monitor the continuous relationship between the cardiac cycle arterial pressure and respiratory pressures during positive-pressure ventilation which can give a measure of the dynamics of intra-cerebral compliance [23]. However, this was not possible under conditions prevailing at the KDH HDU and further evaluations within an intensive care unit need to be undertaken.

Our study had a number of limitations. In both arms of the study, the sample sizes involved were too small to enable us make firm conclusions and clearly discern the relationships between TMD measurements, ICP and clinical parameters. The validity of TMD baseline pressure measurements is dependent on normal middle ear function, confirmed using tympanometry [24], which was not consistently done in ECH patients. When taking measurements on younger children who found lying still over a long duration difficult, it was not always possible to obtain measurements in two different postures. This difficulty would also apply in mildly encephalopathic children of all ages. A smaller headset would enable easier use of the TMD analyser with younger age groups.

Nevertheless, the TMD analyser appears to have a potential utility in ICP or intra-cranial compliance measurement, at a minimum aiding in the simple detection of raised ICP. It could potentially facilitate better monitoring of children with coma in sub-Saharan Africa and other resource poor areas where lack of resources and technical knowhow limit optimal management and outcome of severely ill children. The TMD analyser is convenient and can be used in a variety of other settings, including situations of increased bleeding tendency, increased susceptibility to infection and zero-gravity settings [25]. It could allow for trials in the management of diverse conditions ranging from fluid replacement in diabetic keto-acidosis, cerebral malaria treatment, to management of IIH. With such potential utility in mind, it appears reasonable to conduct more studies, incorporating imaging and other real-time physiological monitoring modalities, include greater patient numbers and examine other modes of TMD measurements.