Phil. Trans. R. Soc. A 370, 1166–1184 (Published 30 January 2012) (doi:10.1098/rsta.2011.0306)
In this note, we correct an error in the first two paragraphs of §2b of the paper by Ashwin et al. [1]. This section attempts to generalize sufficient conditions for R-tipping in the linear model [1, equation (2.1)] with steady drift in §2a to the case of time-varying rates r(t). Starting with [1, equation (2.3)] and noting that |eMuv|≤∥eMu∥|v|, we have the upper bound
![]() |
If M is stable, then
| 1.1 |
for some real c,β>0 [2], and so
Hence, one can guarantee that [1, equation (2.1)] avoids R-tipping by time t if
| 1.2 |
If M is scalar, then we can choose c=1, β=−M, and (1.2) reduces to [1, equation (2.9)]. On the other hand, if M is a matrix, then we need a good choice of c and β in (1.1) to make the tipping condition (1.2) optimal, but this depends on the matrix structure and not simply the norm; see, for example, the text by Hinrichsen & Pritchard [2] and the elegant estimates of Godunov [3, equation (13)]. Incidentally, we remark that within the unnumbered equation between [1, equation (2.1)] and [1, equation (2.2)] there should be a minus sign before the integral, though this is corrected in the rest of the paper.
The converse condition [1, equation (2.10)] is not correct, but can be corrected as follows. From the formula between [1, equation (2.3)] and [1, equation (2.4)] recall
![]() |
where we define
![]() |
Note that
in the case of constant drift, while in the more general case, the expression for
includes an additional term depending on M and the history of the rate of change of drift. Because
, one can guarantee that an R-tipping occurs before time t if
Acknowledgements
We thank Jan Sieber, Stuart Townley and Rowen Learoyd for conversations that helped us to clarify these points.
References
- 1.Ashwin P, Wieczorek S, Vitolo R, Cox P. 2012. Tipping points in open systems: bifurcation, noise-induced and rate-dependent examples in the climate system. Phil. Trans. R. Soc. A 370, 1166–1184 10.1098/rsta.2011.0306 (10.1098/rsta.2011.0306) [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 2.Hinrichsen D, Pritchard AJ. 2011. Mathematical systems theory I: modelling, state space analysis, stability and robustness, vol. 48 (corrected 3rd edn.). Berlin, Germany: Springer [Google Scholar]
- 3.Veselić K. 2003. Bounds for exponentially stable semigroups. Linear Algebr. Appl. 358, 309–333 10.1016/S0024-3795(02)00393-2 (10.1016/S0024-3795(02)00393-2) [DOI] [Google Scholar]



