A Comparison of Ice Cold Water Pretreatment and α-Bromonaphthalene Cytogenetic Method for Identification of Papaver Species

Abstract

The plants belonging to many species in genus Papaver are very similar and have very small chromosomes that make identification very difficult. The study aimed to compare the effects of α-bromonaphtalene and ice cold water pretreatment to identify chromosomes of Papaver species collected from different areas of Iranian West Azerbaijan and Turkish Van, Agri and, Hakkari provinces. The seeds were germinated in Jacobson trays at 24°C under continuous light. Thereafter, roots from 1.5 cm long plantlets were pretreated with α bromonaphtalene for 15, 30, and 45 min or at 0°C in ice cold water for 24 h before fixing, hydrolyzation, and feulgen staining. The ice cold water pretreatment was more appropriate and easy to determine chromosomes. Seeds from seven samples did not germinate. Sixty samples out of the rest of 62 samples were identified as P. pseudo orientale, one sample was identified as P. bracteatum, and another as P. orientale. This is the first study that used ice cold water to determine the chromosomes in papaver species. It is hoped that it will also facilitate to determine chromosome number and identify other papver species.

1. Introduction

Papaver pseudo-orientale (2n = 6x = 42), P. bracteatum (2n = 2x = 14), and P. orientale (2n = 4x = 28) are three important species belonging to the section Oxytona, which resemble very closely. These species were first brought to Europe in the early eighteenth century by Tournefort and were introduced as “oriental poppy” [1].

P. pseudo-orientale grows at an altitude of 1600–2200 m at moist places in Iran and Turkey [1], which is used as an ornamental plant because of its beautiful and attractive flowers. P. pseudo-orientale displays erect flower buds with orange-red petals with or without basal marks. It is rich in isothebaine [2], macranthaline, orientalidine, and salutaridine, which makes it an important medicinal plant [3] of pharmaceutical importance. Concentration of these alkaloids varies in capsules, leaves, stems, and roots. The alkaloid spectrum and content also differ during plant growth and development. Thebaine is the most important alkaloid obtained from this group of plants.

Identification of the plant species is difficult, which is generally done after consultating taxonomic keys to be sure that specimen is identified correctly. However, phenotypic appearance of the three species P. pseudo-orientale (2n = 6x = 42), P. bracteatum (2n = 2x = 14) and P. orientale (2n = 4x = 28) is very similar and there is every likelihood that plants are identified erroneously. Therefore, another important way to determine the plant species is to determine the chromosome numbers, which are a concrete feature to remove any ambiguity among the three species of section Oxytona [1, 4]. The ploidy level provides clear delimitation of species in this section. According to a systematic study by Goldblatt [1], the hexaploid P. pseudo-orientale (2n = 42) is regarded as transient form between (or an allopolyploid hybrid of) the diploid P. bracteatum (2n = 14) and the tetraploid P. orientale (2n = 28).

Cytogenetic analyses reveal formation of multivalents at diakinesis, in the polyploid species like P. pseudo-orientale and in its hybrids with diploid species. This finding demonstrates the autoploid nature of P. pseudo-orientale and proves that P. bracteatum is as its ancestor. Similarly, the similarities found in isozyme variation and in chloroplast DNA restriction patterns between and within the three species of section Oxytona also strongly indicate the autoploid nature of this section [5, 6].

Producing good somatic metaphase spreads is hindered by combined difficulties of obtaining large number of dividing cells and of spreading and staining the chromosomes well. The thickness and length of chromosomes are other important factors that affect visibility of chromosomes during metaphase. It is also important to catch the best view at appropriate stage before fixation of chromosomes. Over the years, many methods have been developed for preparing somatic chromosomes, and they are generally made up of four stages: first, the seed is germinated and the actively growing root tip is collected; second, a pretreatment using ice cold water for a definite period of time or 8-Hydroxyquinoline, Colchicine, Paradichlorobenzene, or α-monobromonaphthalene for a definite period of time prior to fixation to inhibit spindle formation, preventing the congression of chromosomes to the metaphase plate; third is fixation in any of a large range of solutions; fourth, preparation of the root tips by hydrolysis, followed by staining.

Most studies pertaining to chromosome counts in P. pseudo-orientale make use of α-monobromonaphthalene as pretreatment. This study aimed to compare the effects of α-monobromonaphthalene and 0°C water pretreatment for 24 hours on chromosome visibility of Papaver species, which is an important method for observing cereal chromosomes, where this pretreatment is preferred over other methods when chromosomes of a large number of plants are to be studied.

2. Materials and Methods

2.1. Plant Material

The study included 69 different populations of Papaver section Oxytona collected from Van, Hakkari and Agri provinces of Eastern Anatolian Turkey and two samples of Iran origin, collected from West Azerbaijan Province of Iran. The seeds were germinated between moist sandwiched filter papers on Jacobson trays at 24°C under continuous light. Thereafter, when the plants increased to lengths of 1, 1.5, 2, and 3 cm, they were collected for preparation of preparates in the laboratory. At least 5 preparates were made from each sample unless specified.

2.2. α-Monobromonaphthalene Method

The roots of selected plants of sample number 414 were pretreated with α-monobromonaphthalene for 15, 30, and 45 min at room temperature followed by rinsing of pretreated roots with distilled water for 4-5 min.

2.3. Fixation

Thereafter, in order to fix or stop the chromosomes at the desired stage of cell division, the roots were treated with Carnoy's solution consisting of 1 part glacial acetic acid and 3 parts ethanol (95 to 100%). This fixative was prepared fresh each time. The material was kept in the fixative for 30 minutes at room temperature followed by rinsing with bidistilled water.

2.4. Hydrolysis

Then roots were hydrolysed for 8 minutes in 1 N HCl at 60°C followed by washing with bidistilled water.

2.5. Staining

Hydrolyzed specimens were stained with Feulgen for 30 minutes under darkness at room temperature followed by washing with bi-distilled water before making preparates.

2.6. Making Preparates

The roots were quickly transferred into 45% acetic acid dropped on a microscopic slide previously. Then 2-3 mm-long meristematic (well stained) sides of roots tips were cut discarding remaining portions of the roots. The well-stained root tips were carefully sliced using a sharp blade (Gillette) dropping 45% acetic acid little by little to avoid the escaping of sliced tissues from the blade and preventing drying of the acetic acid. These tissues were mixed up to get a homogenous liquid using a needle and closed slowly beginning from one side to another side by a coverslip. Thereafter, the surplus liquid was absorbed using blotting paper. To avoid the slipping of coverslip over the slide, it was kept firmly held using thumb and was carefully knocked using bottom of a pencil to flatten the cells, avoiding chromosome diffusion and facilitating easy observation of chromosomes without overlapping. Air bubbles created between glass slide and coverslip were eliminated by dropping 45% acetic acid at the edge of each coverslip. The extra-acetic acid was absorbed using blotting paper. The preparates were observed using a Nikon microscope to count and distinguish chromosomes.

2.7. Pretreatment Using Melting Ice (Melting Ice Method)

Germination and selection of the plants was done as suggested previously. However, the roots were pretreated by placing the selected plants at 0°C in the melting ice, inside a refrigerator at 4°C without cutting them for 24 hours.

2.8. Fixation

Thereafter, the roots of the plants were cut and treated with Carnoy's solution 1 consisting of ethanol-acetic acid (3 : 1) for 30 min at room temperature followed by washing with distilled water.

It was followed by hydrolysis for 8 min in 1 N HCl, at 60°C, staining with Feulgen for 30 min at room temperature, washing with bidistilled water, and preparation of slides, as described above.

3. Results and Discussion

3.1. Using α-Monobromonaphthalene Method for Chromosome Determination

A good experimental procedure has to show clear and sharp chromosomes that were not possible when α-monobromonaphthalene method was used. The analysis of root tip slides prepared from 1, 1.5, 2, and 3 cm long plants of P. pseudo-orientale using sample number 504 K collected from Yuksekova Dibekli koprusu, Turkey, showed that the species exhibited lower and blurred expressions (Figure 1). The chromosomes were difficult to count, unrecognizable, and dim. Moreover, the treatment resulted in more diffusion of chromosomes. Using α-monobromonaphthalene method for chromosome determination was not helpful. Martens and Reisch [7] observed that the influence of the time of sampling in the activity of cell mitosis is very important. It is thought using α-monobromonaphthalene method for chromosome analysis may have negatively affected the roots tips during pretreatment with monobromonaphthalene causing some internal rearrangements in the root tips that caused difficulty in observing and counting the chromosomes at the time of mitotic division of root cells. It also decreased the quality of the studied chromosome. It seemed as if α-bromonaphthalene method was incompetent and encountered problems in chromosome counting.

Figure 1.

2n = 6x = 42 chromosomes belonging to sample 504 K of P. pseudo orientale collected from Dibekli koprusu, Van Turkey pretreated with α-monobromonaphthalene for 45 minutes.

3.2. Using Ice Cold Water Method for Chromosome Determination

Optimization of method for chromosome counts was made using sample number 419 K collected from Dogubayezit-Igdir Road location, and using ice cold water method for chromosome determination was very helpful. The preprates were initially pretreated in ice cold water. The chromosomes were shorter and thicker. The results also showed better staining and separation of chromosomes, so that they were visible and countable. This elevated the opportunity of observing and counting the chromosomes easily. Irrespective of seedling length, the method could easily help in helping the chromosome counts. The chromosomes were recognizable and clear and had high expression. Moreover, they were not difficult to count under the microscope, yet the initial experiments showed that out of the plants that increased to a length of 1, 1.5, 2, and 3 cm, 1.5 cm long plants were the best suited for chromosome determination (Figure 2). This showed that the plant material assayed in this study to determine the chromosome numbers Papaver species was most active at this stage of growth showing active mitotic division for easy chromosome count. The roots tips were hydrolyzed by incubation in 1 N HCl at 60°C for 8 min followed by rinsing in distilled water for 2-3 min. to catch metaphase. This time (8 min) in hydrolyzing procedure is necessary for elimination of membrane cytoplasm. Hydrolyzed specimens were best stained with Feulgen for 30 minutes followed by washing with bi-distilled water before making preparates. Acetic acid was used to dissolve the fatty acid and waxy secretions, facilitating the penetration of the fixative. The observed chromosomes number is in agreement with previous studies showing the chromosome number of 42 in P. pseudo-orientale. Once the method was optimized, it was used to identify the rest of 68 samples.

Figure 2.

(10 × 40), 2n = 6x = 42 chromosomes belonging to sample 419 K of P. pseudo orientale collected from Dogubayezit-Igdir Road and Agri province, Turkey, pretreated with 0°C melting ice for 24 hours.

Therefore subsequent experiments used 1.5 cm long plants for determination of chromosomes and identification of species.

A total of 69 samples were investigated. Their sample codes, subregion/region from where they were collected, period of germination (days), Germination (%), and species that were identified are given in Table 1.

Table 1.

Sample code, sub region/region, number of days to germinate seeds, germination percentage, and the identified Papaver species from the samples collected from various regions of Turkey and Iran.

Number	Sample code	Sub-region/region	Period of germination (day)	Germination (%)	Species
1	414	Kayak T./Agrı	8	30	P. Pseudo-orientale
2	415	Kayak T./Agrı	8	30	P. Pseudo-orientale
3	416	Kayak T./Agrı	8	10	P. Pseudo-orientale
4	417	Kayak T./Agrı	7	90	P. Pseudo-orientale
5	419 K	Igdır yolu/Agrı	7	90	P. Pseudo-orientale
6	421	Hamur-Tutak/Agrı	6	60	P. Pseudo-orientale
7	423	Hamur-Tutak/Agrı	6	80	P. Pseudo-orientale
8	424	Hamur-Tutak/Agrı	10	60	P. Pseudo-orientale
9	425	Hamur-Tutak/Agrı	10	2.38	P. Pseudo-orientale
10	426	Hamur-Tutak/Agrı	—	0	Nil-
11	427	Hamur-Tutak/Agrı	8	40	P. Pseudo-orientale
12	428	Hamur-Tutak/Agrı	8	30	P. Pseudo-orientale
13	429	Hamur-Tutak/Agrı	11	10	P. Pseudo-orientale
14	430	Hamur-Tutak/Agrı	11	10	P. Pseudo-orientale
15	431	Hamur-Tutak/Agrı	11	10	P. Pseudo-orientale
16	432	Hamur-Tutak/Agrı	8	15	P. Pseudo-orientale
17	434	Hamur-Tutak/Agrı	7	70	P. Pseudo-orientale
18	435	Hamur-Tutak/Agrı	—	0	Nil-
19	437	Hamur-Tutak/Agrı	7	50	P. Pseudo-orientale
20	440	Hamur-Tutak/Agrı	9	70	P. Pseudo-orientale
21	441	Hamur-Tutak/Agrı	7	30	P. Pseudo-orientale
22	442	Hamur-Tutak/Agrı	—	0	Nil-
23	444 K	Safak cesmesi/Agrı	6	40	P. Pseudo-orientale
24	445	Caldıran So guksu/VAN	8	80	P. Pseudo-orientale
25	446	Caldıran Gulhisar/VAN	10	25	P. Orientale
26	448	Bahcesaray/VAN	8	60	P. Pseudo-orientale
27	449	Bahcesaray/VAN	8	70	P. Pseudo-orientale
28	450	Bahcesaray/VAN	6	90	P. Pseudo-orientale
29	451	Bahcesaray/VAN	7	2.38	P. Pseudo-orientale
30	452	Bahcesaray/VAN	7	90	P. Pseudo-orientale
31	453	Bahcesaray/VAN	8	90	P. Pseudo-orientale
32	454	Bahcesaray/VAN	8	90	P. Pseudo-orientale
33	455	Bahcesaray/VAN	8	90	P. Pseudo-orientale
34	456	Bahcesaray/VAN	6	80	P. Pseudo-orientale
35	457	Bahcesaray/VAN	7	90	P. Pseudo-orientale
36	458	Bahcesaray/VAN	7	90	P. Pseudo-orientale
37	459	Bahcesaray/VAN	8	90	P. Pseudo-orientale
38	462 K	Baskale Guzeldere/VAN	7	90	P. Pseudo-orientale
39	463	27 km to Baskale/VAN	7	80	P. Pseudo-orientale
40	465	Alan vadisi-Cesme yanı/HAKKARI	8	90	P. Pseudo-orientale
41	466	Alan vadisi-Cesme yanı/HAKKARI	8	70	P. Pseudo-orientale
42	468	Alan vadisi/HAKKARI	7	90	P. Pseudo-orientale
43	469	Alan vadisi/HAKKARI	8	70	P. Pseudo-orıentale
44	470 K	Alan vadisi/HAKKARI	7	70	P. Pseudo-orientale
45	472	Alan vadisi Karakol/HAKKARI	8	50	P. Pseudo-orientale
46	473	Alan vadisi Karakol/HAKKARI	8	60	P. Pseudo-orientale
47	475	Alan vadisi Karakol/HAKKARI	9	Very Low	P. Pseudo-orientale
48	476	Alan vadisi Karakol/HAKKARI	9	Very Low	P. Pseudo-orientale
49	477	Alan vadisi Karakol/HAKKARI	8	90	P. Pseudo-orientale
50	478	Alan vadisi Karakol/HAKKARI	—	0	Nil-
51	479	Alan vadisi Karakol/HAKKARI	10	90	P. Pseudo-orientale
52	480	Alan vadisi Karakol/HAKKARI	7	80	P. Pseudo-orientale
53	481 K	Alan vadisi Karakol/HAKKARI	7	90	P. Pseudo-orientale
54	486	Semdinli/HAKKARI	10	15	P. Pseudo-orientale
55	490	Yuksekova Semdinli/HAKKARI	8	50	P. Pseudo-orientale
56	491	Yuksekova Semdinli/HAKKARI	8	Very Low	P. Pseudo-orientale
57	492	Yuksekova Semdinli/HAKKARI	8	40	P. Pseudo-orientale
58	493	Yuksekova Semdinli/HAKKARI	—	0	Nil-
59	494	Yuksekova Semdinli/HAKKARI	7	70	P. Pseudo-orientale
60	495	Yuksekova Semdinli/HAKKARI	—	0	Nil-
61	496	Yuksekova Semdinli/HAKKARI	12	20	P. Pseudo-orientale
62	497	Yuksekova Semdinli/HAKKARI	13	10	P. Pseudo-orientale
63	500	Yuksekova Copluk/VAN	6	80	P. Pseudo-orientale
64	501	Yuksekova Copluk/VAN	8	70	P. Pseudo-orientale
65	503 K	Yuksekova kopru yanı/VAN	8	70	P. Pseudo-orientale
66	504 K	Dibekli Koprusu/VAN	8	90	P. Pseudo-orientale
67	7	Qushju Iranian province of West Azerbaijan, Iran	8	70	P. bracteatum
68	F1 (P.b × P.o)	Ankara University, Turkey	—	0	Nil
69	9	Qushju Iranian province of West Azerbaijan, Iran	9	90	P. Pseudo-orientale

Martens and Reisch [7] observed that the influence of the time of sampling in the activity of cell mitosis is very important. It is thought using ice cold water method for chromosome determination may have positively affected the roots tips during pretreatment ice cold water that helped in easy determination of chromosome counts at the time of mitotic division of root cells. It also increased the quality of the chromosome studies.

A review of the Table 1 shows that out of 69 samples, the seeds that belonged to seven samples (coded as 426, 435, 442, 478, 493, 495 and F1 (P.b × P.o) did not germinate and their chromosomes could not be counted (Table 1). Rest of the 62 samples except sample number 25 coded as 446 collected from Caldıran Gulhisar/VAN locations and sample number 67 coded as 7 collected from Iranian province of West Azerbaijan had chromosome number of 28 (Figure 3) and 14 and were identified as as P. bracteatum and P. orientale, respectively.

Figure 3.

(10 × 40), 2n = 6x = 42 chromosomes belonging to sample 419 K of 446 P. pseudo orientale collected from Caldıran, Gulhisar, and Van provinces, Turkey, pretreated with 0°C melting ice for 24 hours.

The P. pseudo-orientale seeds collected from different locations took 6–13 days to germinate. Whereas, the seeds of P. bracteatum took 8 days, P. orientale seeds took 10 days to germinate. Germination percentage of P. pseudo-orientale seeds was 2.38–90%, the seeds of P. bracteatum had seed germination percentage of 70%, and P. orientale had germination percentage of 25%.

Results of this chromosomal study have proven useful in plant taxonomy and phylogenetic analysis. In this sense, our results are helpful in identifying and separating P. pseudo-orientale species collected from Hakkari, Van, and Agri, and they noted no differences among them in terms of chromosome numbers. The results are in agreement with morphological features of the plants collected from these locations and previous studies by Goldblatt [1].