Whole-Genome Survey of the Putative ATP-Binding Cassette Transporter Family Genes in Vitis vinifera

Abstract

The ATP-binding cassette (ABC) protein superfamily constitutes one of the largest protein families known in plants. In this report, we performed a complete inventory of ABC protein genes in Vitis vinifera, the whole genome of which has been sequenced. By comparison with ABC protein members of Arabidopsis thaliana, we identified 135 putative ABC proteins with 1 or 2 NBDs in V. vinifera. Of these, 120 encode intrinsic membrane proteins, and 15 encode proteins missing TMDs. V. vinifera ABC proteins can be divided into 13 subfamilies with 79 “full-size,” 41 “half-size,” and 15 “soluble” putative ABC proteins. The main feature of the Vitis ABC superfamily is the presence of 2 large subfamilies, ABCG (pleiotropic drug resistance and white-brown complex homolog) and ABCC (multidrug resistance-associated protein). We identified orthologs of V. vinifera putative ABC transporters in different species. This work represents the first complete inventory of ABC transporters in V. vinifera. The identification of Vitis ABC transporters and their comparative analysis with the Arabidopsis counterparts revealed a strong conservation between the 2 species. This inventory could help elucidate the biological and physiological functions of these transporters in V. vinifera.

Introduction

The ATP-binding cassette (ABC) protein family is one of the largest and most diverse protein families in plants. These genes encode integral membrane proteins that translocate a wide range of solutes across membranes [1]–[6]. ABC proteins can act as importers, exporters, receptors, and channels [2]. Members of this protein family are involved in diverse cellular processes, including cell division, nutrient uptake, lipid trafficking, antigen processing, drug efflux from cancer cells, and pathogenesis [1]–[4]. ABC proteins have been conserved between prokaryotes and eukaryotes.

A functional ABC protein contains a core unit of 2 transmembrane domains (TMDs) and 2 nucleotide-binding domains (NBDs). The TMD contains 4–6 transmembrane α-helices that are involved in translocating and possibly binding the substrate. The NBD contains highly conserved motifs of Walker A and Walker B boxes and an ABC signature, the H loop and the Q loop [7]. The ABC signature is situated between 2 Walker boxes. The sequences of the TMDs are highly variable compared with those of the NBDs, which contain the evolutionarily conserved Walker A and B consensus motifs for nucleotide binding [8], [9].

The domain organizations of ABC transporters are almost as varied as their function [10], [11]. In many prokaryotes, the NBDs and TMDs are encoded as separate subunits; however, in eukaryotic ABC proteins, the domains are fused to form a single polypeptide [2], [10], [12], also known as full-size ABC proteins, which contain 2 NBDs and 2 TMDs either in forward (TMD1-NBD1-TMD2-NBD2) or reverse orientation (NBD1-TMD1-NBD2-TMD2). The ABC transporters that have 1 NBD and 1 TMD are known as half-size ABC proteins.

Eukaryotic ABC proteins can be classified into 8 major subfamilies (A–H) according to domain organization, the presence of additional domains, and whether the protein is a half-size or full-size transporter, although some subfamilies contain both full-size and half-size transporters [13]. The subfamily H genes have been reported to be absent in plants [13]. Plant ABC subfamilies are usually named after their human or microbial prototypes (e.g., pleiotropic drug resistance (PDR) and multidrug resistance-associated protein (MRP), etc.) as described by Sanchez-Fernandez et al. (2001), while Garcia et al. (2004) used the ABC systems: information on sequence, structure, and evolution (ABCISSE) system of nomenclature for rice ABC proteins.

Several ABC transporters have been characterized in plants. The complete inventories of plant ABC transporters are available for Arabidopsis, rice, and Lotus japonicus [3], [14]–[16]. The Arabidopsis genome contains 131 open reading frames (ORFs) encoding ABC genes, including 54 full-size transporters [3], [14]. However, the physiological roles of these transporters remain to be determined. In the rice genome, 45 sequences encoding putative full-size ABC transporters have been identified [17], while the Lotus genome contains 91 putative ABC proteins with 43 full-size, 40 half-size, and 18 soluble proteins [16]. In plants, the best-characterized subfamilies are the multidrug resistance (MDR), MDR-associated proteins (MRP), pleiotropic drug resistance (PDR), and white-brown complex homolog (WBC) subfamilies. ABC transporters in plants can be regulated by a broad range of external signals. For example, PDR-type ABC transporters have been reported to be involved in the response to pathogens [18] and to be regulated by salinity, cold, and heavy metals [19]–[21]. The PDR/ABCG subfamily of plant ABC transporters is able to transport terpenoids [19], [22]. It has been also reported that AtPDR12/ABCG40 functions as a plasma membrane abscisic acid (ABA) uptake transporter and plays a role in the response to ABA [23].

The functions of 4 members of the WBC subfamily have been reported. AtABCG12 and AtABCG11 are required for wax export and elaboration of the cuticle [24]–[27]. AtABCG19 confers antibiotic resistance [28]. AtABCG25 has been shown to be responsible for ABA transport and involved in the ABA signaling pathway [29].

Multiple members of the MDR subfamily are involved in the transport of auxin [30], one of the most important hormones for cell differentiation and response to environmental signals [31]. MRP subfamily members have roles in detoxification and in the vacuolar transport of compounds, including glucuronides and chlorophyll catabolites, and they also show cadmium resistance when expressed in yeast [3], [32].

The recent sequencing of the whole genome of Vitis vinifera [33] makes analyses on a genomic scale possible. Here, we describe the first complete analysis of the ABC protein superfamily from the updated 12-fold sequencing and assembly of the grapevine genome. Using these databases, we characterized all members of the ABC protein superfamily of V. vinifera and carried out a phylogenetic analysis in comparison with members of Arabidopsis ABC superfamily. We employed in this report the nomenclature of human ABC proteins [34], which is commonly approved by the Human Genome Organization (HUGO).

Materials and Methods

Identification of ABC Transporter Genes in the V. vinifera Genome

The Arabidopsis Information Resource (TAIR) database was first used to retrieve Arabidopsis ABC protein sequences. V. vinifera putative ABC transporters were searched performing a BLASTP analysis (http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/blast) [35] against the V. vinifera proteome 12× database (http://www.genoscope.cns.fr/externe/GenomeBrowser/vitis) using Arabidopsis ABC transporter protein sequences as queries. Scores higher than 400 with an “E” value over e-120 were assigned as significant [15]. The sequences of polypeptides corresponding to V. vinifera ABC transporters were then analyzed in the Conserved Domain Database (CDD) at NCBI (http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/Structure/cdd/wrpsb.cgi) and PROSITE (http://prosite.expasy.org/) for the presence of ABC signature motifs [36], [37]. In addition, the NCBI non-redundant protein database was screened with each sequence in order to independently validate the automatic annotation.

Sequence Analysis and Phylogenetics

The deduced amino acid sequences of the putative ABC proteins were aligned using CLUSTAL W and subjected to phylogenetic analysis by both the maximum parsimony and distance with neighbor-joining methods with 1000 bootstrap replicates [38], [39]. The phylogenetic tree was visualized using MEGA5. Because similar results were obtained with both methods, only the single tree retrieved from the distance analysis is discussed in detail.

For ABC protein subfamilies from both V. vinifera and A. thaliana, multiple sequence alignment was performed using the multiple sequence comparison by log-expectation (MUSCLE) alignment tool (http://www.ebi.ac.uk/Tools/msa/muscle/) [40] with default program options, and the phylogenetic analysis was performed using a neighbor-joining method with 1000 bootstrap replicates. The phylogenetic trees were constructed with MEGA5 software [41]. The protein theoretical molecular weight and isoelectric point were predicted using compute pI/MW (http://au.expasy.org/tools).

Orthology Analysis

Orthology analysis was performed using the PHOG web server (http://phylofacts.berkeley.edu/orthologs/) [42]. The sequences that have similarity over 70% and an “E” value of 0.0 were selected. The selected sequences were used in a BLASTP search against the V. vinifera protein sequence database, and the best hits were annotated as putative orthologous sequences [43].

Expressed Sequence Tags Database

The sequences of all of the ABC transporters that were identified were used to query the V. vinifera expressed sequence tag (EST) database (http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/dbEST) for ESTs. The positives sequences were then confirmed by alignment with the query ORF.

Results/Discussion

Identification of ABC Transporters in Vitis vinifera

Systematic BLAST searches of the grapevine genome proteome 12× database with the amino acid sequences of the ABC transporters from A. thaliana as queries identified 135 ORFs encoding putative ABC transporters in V. vinifera that contained at least 1 ABC signature (Table S1). Using the presence of TMDs followed by nucleotide-binding folds (NBFs) as criteria for ABC transporters, the V. vinifera genome possesses 135 ORFs encoding ABC transporters with 1 or 2 NBFs. Of these, 120 encode intrinsic membrane proteins and 15 encode proteins without TMDs (Table S2). The V. vinifera ABC transporter family consists of 79 full-size molecules and 41 half-size transporters.

Phylogeny of V. vinifera ABC Transporters

All predicted protein sequences were aligned using ClustalW [39], and a phylogenetic tree was generated by the MEGA5 program and maximum parsimony and distance with neighbor-joining methods [38]. One thousand bootstrap replicates were performed for each analysis. Using the MEGA5 program, we built a phylogenetic tree of 135 sequences, which is presented in Fig. 1.

Figure 1. Phylogenetic tree of Vitis ABC proteins.

The amino sequences of all Vitis ABC proteins were aligned using the ClustalW program and were subjected to phylogenetic analysis by the distance with neighbor-joining method. The reliabilities of each branch point, as assessed by the analysis of 1000 computer-generated trees (bootstrap replicates), were in excess of 90%, except for those discussed in the text. The Human Genome Organization (HUGO) nomenclature was used, and the abbreviations of ABC proteins are as follows: ATH, ABC-two-homolog; ATM, ABC transporter of mitochondria; GCN, general control non-repressible; MDR, multi-drug resistance; MRP, multi-drug resistance–associated protein; NAP, non-intrinsic ABC protein; PDR, pleiotropic drug resistance; PMP, peroxisomal membrane protein; RLI, RNase L inhibitor; SMC, structural maintenance of chromosome; TAP, transporter associated with antigen processing; WBC, white-brown complex. ATH belongs to the ABCA subfamily; MDR, TAP, and ATM belong to the ABCB subfamily; MRP belongs to the ABCC subfamily; PMP belongs to the ABCD subfamily; RLI belongs to the ABCE subfamily; GCN belongs to the ABCF subfamily; and WBC belongs to the ABCG subfamily, as described in the text.

Plant ABC proteins can be divided into 13 subfamilies on the basis of protein size (full, half, or quarter molecules), orientation (forward or reverse), the presence or absence of idiotypic transmembrane and/or linker domains, and overall sequence similarity [14]. The V. vinifera genome contains all 13 subfamilies of ABC proteins. The members of each subfamily clustered together more closely with bootstrap values of at least 90% (Fig. 1). The members of most subfamilies grouped more tightly with each other than with members of other subfamilies. MRPs, PDRs, and general control non-repressible proteins (GCNs) grouped within their respective subfamilies. The VvABCG (WBC) subfamily clusters tightly, with the exception of VvABCG15, VvABCG20, and VvABCG22, which clustered closely with the main WBC cluster. The VvABCF (GCN) subfamily is composed of 5 members, and the 5 members cluster within the same clade.

Among the members of the VvABCI (NAP) subfamily, VvABCI1, VvABCI2, VvABCI3, and VvABCI4 clustered with structural maintenance of chromosome proteins (SMCs) within the same clade, whereas VvABCI5 grouped with VvABCAs (ATH) in the same clade, and VvABCI6 was closely related to the VvABCF (GCN) subfamily. The lack of coherence within the ABCI (NAP) subfamily was to be expected since this heterogeneous group of proteins lack contigous transmembrane domains and grouped together by their lack of any systematic resemblance to previously defined ABC proteins [14]. Similarly, in Arabidopsis, some NAPs did not group with each other or within other subfamilies with high confidence [14]. All of the VvABCB (MDR) subfamily members grouped together with bootstrap values of 90% with the exception of VvABCB16, which was distributed close to the transporter associated with antigen processing (TAP) subfamily. The only member of the ABCA (AOH) subfamily, VvABCA1, grouped with the members of the VvABCA (ATH) subfamily (Fig. 1). The peroxisomal membrane protein (PMP) subfamily contains only 1 member, and it is classified as a half-size transporter. Three members of the VvABCA (ATH) subfamily grouped within the same clade with bootstrap values up to 100%, whereas 1 member, VvABCA5, clustered within the VvABCB (MDR/TAP) clade. In accordance with our results, in Arabidopsis, none of AtATHs grouped within any of the other subfamilies with the exception of AtATH12 which grouped within the MDR/TAP/ATM clade [14]. The VvABCE (RLI) subfamily contains only 1 member, VvABCE1, and it clustered within the VvABCF (GCN) clade. The VvABCB (ATM) subfamily has only 1 member, and it grouped within the TAPs/MDRs/ATH clade.

ABCA subfamily

The plant ABCA subfamily consists of full-size and half-size proteins. Only 1 full-size ABCA gene (AtABCA1), also known as the ABC one homolog (AOH), is present in the Arabidopsis genome, whereas no homolog has been identified in the rice genome [14], [17]. In the Lotus genome, 1 ABCA member similar to AtABCA1 has been found [16]. The Arabidopsis genome contains 11 half-size ABCA genes, also known as ABC two homologs (ATH) [14], [15], while the Lotus genome has at least 2 half-size members of the ABCA subfamily [16].

The Vitis genome harbors only 1 ORF (VvABCA1) with high resemblance to AtAOH1, a full-size transporter in the forward orientation [14]. VvABCA1 is one of the longest ABC transporter proteins located on chromosome 8 with 2001 amino acid residues including a putative regulatory domain that is interrupted by a hydrophobic segment in the central region of the molecule (Table S1), which is similar to the human protein and AtAOH1. Its mammalian counterpart, ABC1 is localized to the plasma membrane and Golgi complex and is responsible for Tangier disease [44], [45]. The function and the localization of AtAOH1, the Arabidopsis homolog, remains unknown, and it is speculated that it may play a role in lipid accumulation during seed maturation or lipid mobilization during seed germination [19]. At present, the representation of VvABCA1 in EST databases (6 ESTs) is observed in leaves, berries, flowers, and roots tissues (Table S4), and no cDNA corresponding to VvABCA1 has been isolated.

The ATH subfamily, which has 4 members in the Vitis genome, is the half-size transporter category with 723–958 amino acid residues (Table S1, Fig. 2), whereas the Arabidopsis genome contains 11 ORFs. VvABCA2 and VvABCA3 are located on chromosome 17 and share 23% similarity. Twenty-two plant orthologs from different species have been found using an orthology analysis program for this subfamily (Table S3). The human orthologs are involved in Stargardt disease or fundus flavimaculatus [46], [47]. The expression of AtATH14 and AtATH15 in Arabidopsis is regulated in response to salt stress [48]. We identified 20 ESTs corresponding to Vitis ATH subfamily members in various tissues (Table S4).

Figure 2. Phylogenetic relationship of Arabidopsis and Vitis ABCA (ATH) proteins.

The amino acid sequences of all Arabidopsis ABCA (ATH) proteins and those of Vitis vinifera were aligned using the MUSCLE program and subjected to phylogenetic analysis by the distance with neighborjoining method using MEGA5 programme. Accession numbers for Arabidopsis sequences are AtABCA2 (NP_190357.2), AtABCA3 (NP_190358.2), AtABCA4 (NP_190359.4), AtABCA5 (NP_190360.2), AtABCA6 (NP_190361.2), AtABCA7 (NP_190362.2), AtABCA8 (NP_190363.3), AtABCA9 (NP_200981.1), AtABCA10 (NP_200982.1), AtABCA11 (NP_200977.1) and AtABCA12 (NP_200978.1). AtSKD1 (AEC08019.1) and VvSKD1 (XP_002266534.1) were used as outgroups.

ABCB subfamily

The ABCB subfamily consists of full-size members, which are conventionally named MDR or PGP, and half-size members such as TAPs and ATMs. In the Arabidopsis genome, 22 full-size members (MDR) and 6 half-size members (3 TAPs and 3 ATMs) are present [14], [15], whereas the rice genome contains 24 full-size (MDR) and 4 half-size (3 TAPs and 1 ATM) proteins [15]. In total, the number of Lotus ABCB proteins is estimated as 15, which implies 12 full-size MDR-type, 2 TAP-like, and 1 ATM-like protein [16]. The Vitis ABCB subfamily consists of 19 MDR-type, 5 TAP-like, and 1 ATM-like proteins.

With 19 members, the MDR subfamily represents the fourth largest full-size molecule ABC transporter subfamily in V. vinifera (Table S1, Table S2). All of the identified ORFs were named VvABCB1 through 19; they contain 2 TMDs and 2 NBDs in the forward orientation and range from 814 amino acids (VvABCB18) to 2405 amino acids (VvABCB12) in length (Table S1). Members of the Vitis MDR subfamily show 22–79% identity to each other. The VvABCB17 amino acid sequence shows 84% similarity with AtABCB1, and VvABCB4 shows 88% similarity with AtABCB19 from A. thaliana. VvABCB17 shares between 84.5% and 89.6% similarity to the MDR members from A. thaliana, Oryza sativa, and Ricinus communis (Table S3). The similarity between VvABCB17 and its homolog AtABCB1 and between VvABCB4 and AtABCB19 was confirmed in a phylogenetic tree that was constructed with all of the Arabidopsis members with bootstrap values of 100% (Fig. 3). Similarly, the phylogenetic analysis of V. vinifera and A. thaliana MDR subfamilies confirmed the orthologs of VvABCB8/AtABCB20/AtABCB6, VvABCB13/AtABCB20, and VvABCB14/AtABCB3/AtABCB11/AtABCB12/AtABCB21 (Fig. 3).

Figure 3. Phylogenetic tree of ABCB (MDR) protein sequences from Arabidopsis and Vitis vinifera.

The amino acid sequences of all Arabidopsis ABCB (MDR) proteins and those of Vitis vinifera were aligned using the MUSCLE program and subjected to phylogenetic analysis by the distance with neighborjoining method using MEGA5 programme. Accession numbers for Arabidopsis sequences are AtABCB1 (NP_181228.1), AtABCB2 (NP_194326.2), AtABCB3 (NP_192091.1), AtABCB4 (NP_182223.1), AtABCB5 (NP_192092.1), AtABCB6 (NP_181480.1), AtABCB7 (NP_199466.1), AtABCB8 (NP_683599.1), AtABCB9 (NP_193539.6), AtABCB10 (NP_172538.1), AtABCB11 (NP_171753.1), AtABCB12 (NP_171754.1), AtABCB13 (NP_174115.1), AtABCB14 (NP_174122.1), AtABCB15 (NP_189475.1), AtABCB16 (NP_189477.4), AtABCB17 (NP_189479.1), AtABCB18 (NP_189480.1), AtABCB19 (NP_189528.1), AtABCB20 (NP_191092.1) and AtABCB21 (NP_191774.1). AtSKD1 (AEC08019.1) and VvSKD1 (XP_002266534.1) were used as outgroups.

The ABCB proteins were first characterized in mammalian cells because their overexpression confers a multidrug resistance phenotype [49]. One member of this subfamily in Arabidopsis, AtMDR1, also known as AtPGP1, was reported to confer herbicide tolerance when it was overexpressed in plants [50]. Multiple members of the ABCB/PGP/MDR subfamily are involved in the transport of auxin [30], suggesting that the ABCB subfamily probably plays an important role in auxin transport. Recently, it was proposed that both ABCB14 and AtABCB15 in Arabidopsis promoted auxin transport, and reduced auxin transport was correlated with a mild disruption in vascular development [31]. All 19 identified ORFs encoding MDR proteins are transcriptionally active. We identified 177 ESTs corresponding to the members of Vitis MDR subfamily (Table S5). The BLAST analysis of ESTs revealed their expression in various tissues such as flowers, roots, tendrils, berries, buds, and leaves (Table S5).

Five ORFs (VvABCB21 through VvABCB25) were identified that encoded putative TAP-like proteins with high similarity with 3 TAPs from A. thaliana (Table S1). Vitis TAP-like proteins and their orthologs from A. thaliana grouped into the same clade and shared strong similarity (70–80%) with each other. Vitis TAP-like transporters encode half-size proteins in the forward orientation. VvABCB24 and VvABCB25, which are located on chromosome 14, contain 658 and 1265 amino acids, respectively (Table S1). VvABCB21 shares 71% similarity with VvABCB24, and VvABCB22 shares 73% similarity with VvABCB25. Based on phylogenetic analysis, 3 ortholog pairs between 2 species were identified: VvABCB21/AtABCB26 (80% similarity), VvABCB22/AtABCB27 (75% similarity), and VvABCB23/AtABCB28 (70% similarity) (Fig. 4). Orthology analysis by the PHOG program reveals that only VvABCB21 shares more than 80% identity with TAPs from Populus trichocarpa, A. thaliana, and R. communis (Table S3).

Figure 4. Phylogenetic tree of ABCB (TAP) protein sequences from Arabidopsis and Vitis vinifera.

The amino acid sequences of all Arabidopsis ABCB (TAP) proteins and those of Vitis vinifera were aligned using the MUSCLE program and subjected to phylogenetic analysis by the distance with neighborjoining method using MEGA5 programme. Accession numbers for Arabidopsis sequences are AtABCB26 (NP_177218.3), AtABCB27 (NP_198720.2) and AtABCB28 (NP_194275.2). AtSKD1 (AEC08019.1) and VvSKD1 (XP_002266534.1) were used as outgroups.

The function of AtABCB26, 27, and 28 remain to be determined. While the function of the yeast TAP homologs, MDL1 and MDL2 [51], as well as that of the Arabidopsis homolog are unknown, mammalian counterparts participate in peptide secretion and translocation across endoplasmic reticulum (ER) membranes [52]. The size of the Vitis TAP subfamily seems to be larger than that of Arabidopsis, which contains 3 TAP-like genes. Four of the 5 ORFs encoding Vitis TAP-like proteins are represented in the EST (67 ESTs) database (Table S5) and are expressed in different tissues such as leaves, roots, fruits, flowers, berries, and buds. No ESTs have been identified for VvABCB23, suggesting that it is not transcriptionally active.

The Vitis genome contains only 1 ORF encoding an ATM-like protein, and this ORF is located on chromosome 6 (Table S1). This subfamily is composed of a half-size transporter of 726 amino acids with the forward orientation that is named VvABCB20. To date, 11 ESTs corresponding to VvABCB20 have been described (Table S5). The ATM subfamily from Arabidopsis, which includes 3 ORFs, is larger than that of V. vinifera. The Arabidopsis ATM homolog, AtATM3, has been implicated in the biogenesis of iron-sulfur proteins [53] and has a crucial role in molybdenum cofactor (moco) biosynthesis [54]. AtATM3 was also reported to be involved in heavy metal resistance [55]. The deficiency of AtATM3 causes dwarfism and chlorosis [53], [56]. A barley half-size TAP-like protein, ID17, was identified as an iron deficiency–induced gene [57]. The biochemical roles of plant half-size TAP proteins of subfamily B have not yet been determined.

ABCC subfamily

ABCC subfamily proteins are full-size ABC transporters also known as MRPs, which contain an N-terminal extension of the TMD. This subfamily consists of 15 members in the Arabidopsis genome and 17 members in the rice genome [14], [15]. With 26 members, the ABCC (MRP) subfamily represents the third largest subfamily of V. vinifera full-size ABC transporters, which is larger than that of A. thaliana (15 members). ABCC (MRP) subfamily members are full-size molecules in the forward orientation containing (TMD-NBD)₂ and ranging in size from 759 amino acids (VvABCC19) to 2772 amino acids (VvABCC8) (Table S1). The members of the MRP subfamily in the Vitis genome share 29–95% similarity with each other. Among them, 7 ORFs that share strong similarity (76–85%) are localized on chromosome 2 (Table S1). Similarly, VvABCC2, VvABCC3, VvABCC4, VvABCC5, VvABCC6, and VvABCC26 show between 73% and 95% similarity with each other with bootstrap values of 99% (Fig. 5). Interestingly, these 6 ORFs are located on chromosome 19 in tandem regions (Table S1). Four other ORFS (VvABCC17, VvABCC18, VvABCC19, and VvABCC20) displaying between 69% and 77% similarity with each other are located on chromosome 10. The phylogenetic analysis of MRP subfamilies from V. vinifera and A. thaliana reveals that these subfamilies can be classified into 5 major groups (Fig. 5). A first group contains MRPs mostly from V. vinifera and includes 6 ORFs located on chromosome 2, while a second group presents the A. thaliana orthologs of VvABCC21, AtABCC4, and AtABCC14. VvABCC21 is 74% and 76% identical to its A. thaliana orthologs, AtABCC4 and AtABCC14, respectively (Table S3), by phylogeny analysis (Fig. 5). The other groups include protein sequences from both species. By phylogeny analysis, we also identified orthologs of Vitis MRPs in Arabidopsis such as VvABCC17/AtABCC1/AtABCC2 (76 and 78% similarity), VvABCC22/AtABCC5 (78% similarity), and VvABCC21/AtABCC14 (75% similarity) with strong bootstrap values (99–100%). VvABCC9 shares 80.2% identity with its homolog from Arabidopsis (NP171908) on the basis of orthology analysis, which is confirmed by the phylogenetic analysis of the same sequences (Fig. 5, Table S3).

Figure 5. Phylogenetic tree of ABCC (MRP) protein sequences from Arabidopsis and Vitis vinifera.

The amino acid sequences of all Arabidopsis ABCC (MRP) proteins and those of Vitis vinifera were aligned using the MUSCLE program and subjected to phylogenetic analysis by the distance with neighborjoining method using MEGA5 programme. Accession numbers for Arabidopsis sequences are AtABCC1 (NP_174329.1), AtABCC2 (NP_181013.1), AtABCC3 (NP_187915.1), AtABCC4 (NP_182301.1), AtABCC5 (NP_171908.1), AtABCC6 (NP_188762.3), AtABCC7 (NP_187917.3), AtABCC8 (NP_187916.3) AtABCC9 (NP_191575.2), AtABCC10 (NP_191829.1), AtABCC11 (NP_178811.7), AtABCC12 (NP_174331.2), AtABCC13 (NP_174330.3), AtABCC14 (NP_191473.2) and AtABCC15 (NP_191656.2). AtSKD1 (AEC08019.1) and VvSKD1 (XP_002266534.1) were used as outgroups.

MRPs consist of 3 additional subfamily-specific structures: a 200–amino acid hydrophobic N-terminal extension (TMDO) containing 5 putative transmembrane spans, a linker (L) domain contiguous with NBF1 and rich in charged amino acid residues, and a hydrophilic C-terminal extension [58]. Interestingly both AtMRP11 and AtMRP15 lack the TMDO characteristic of many members of this subfamily [14], [59]. Human MRP1 and MRP2 can transport glutathione S (GS)-conjugates, whereas their orthologs from Arabidopsis are able to transport materials other than GS-conjugates. This structural divergence was also determined within this subfamily among human and yeast MRP transporters [58], [60]. The ABCC subfamily is also involved in the detoxification processes. These proteins have a role in vacuolar transport and confer cadmium tolerance in yeast [3], [61]. To date, none of Vitis MRP homologs have been cloned or characterized. However, 435 ESTs were found for this subfamily in various tissues in response to stresses (Table S6). The ESTs for all of the MRPs have been identified (Table S6).

ABCD subfamily

The ABCD subfamily contains predominantly half-size proteins that are conventionally designated as PMPs, which are localized at the peroxisome. The members of this subfamily homodimerize and heterodimerize to form transporters that are responsible for the import of fatty acids into the peroxisome.

The Arabidopsis and rice genomes contain 1 and 2 half-size ABCD members, respectively, in addition to 1 half-size protein for each plant [14], [15]. In the Lotus genome, 4 and 3 fragments have similarity to half-size and full-size ABCD proteins, respectively [16]. The Vitis ABCD subfamily consists of 1 member of the PMP type, which is named VvABCD1 (Table S1). VvABCD1 has orthologs from O. sativa, R. communis, A. thaliana, and P. trichocarpa with up to 93.8% similarity (Table S3).

In Arabidopsis, full-size ABCD proteins also known as peroxisomal ABC transporter (PXA1), peroxisome defective (PED3), and comatose (CTS) or AtPMP2 are involved in the peroxisomal import of acyl-CoA esters [62]–[64]. These mutants have defects in germination, fertility, and growth [65], [66]. There are 8 ESTs found in the Vitis genome (Table S7).

Soluble ABC Proteins

ABCE subfamily

The members of the ABCE subfamily have 2 NBDs but no TMD, and they are also known as RNase L inhibitors (RLI) [67]. In the Arabidopsis and rice genomes, there are 2 members of this subfamily, and the Lotus genome has at least 1 member [16]. The Vitis genome contains only 1 ORF encoding an RLI-like protein, VvABCE1, which has 2 NBDs but no transmembrane spans (Table S1). RLI1 contains N-terminal “ferrodoxin” (4Fe4S-type) motifs. These motifs have been shown to interact with nucleic acids [68]. On the basis of sequence identity, VvABCE1 shares more than 90% identity with its orthologs from Arabidopsis, O. sativa, and Triticum aestivum (Table S3). The Arabidopsis ABCE protein AtRLI2 has been shown to suppress RNA silencing [69]. Nine ESTs have been identified for this subfamily in V. vinifera (Table S7).

ABCF subfamily

Genes in the ABCF subfamily, which have 2 NBDs and no TMD, are also conventionally known as the GCN subfamily. Both the Arabidopsis and rice genomes have 5 members of this subfamily [14], [15]. The Vitis genome contains 5 members of ABCF/GCN subfamily that have 2 NBDs but no TMDs (Table S1). The members of the ABCF/GCN subfamily share 24–79% identity with each other and are distributed on various chromosomes (2, 6, 7, and 18) (Table S1). They also show 76–84% similarity to 5 ORFs that correspond to the GCN-like proteins in Arabidopsis (Fig. 6). Four members of the Vitis ABCF/GCN subfamily (VvABCF1, 2, 3, and 4) share 80.5–94.8% similarity with their orthologs from various plants (Table S3). At least 125 ESTs have been identified for all of the Vitis ABCFs (Table S8).

Figure 6. Phylogenetic tree of ABCF (GCN) protein sequences from Arabidopsis and Vitis vinifera.

The amino acid sequences of all Arabidopsis ABCF (GCN) proteins and those of Vitis vinifera were aligned using the MUSCLE program and subjected to phylogenetic analysis by the distance with neighborjoining method using MEGA5 programme. Accession numbers for Arabidopsis sequences are AtABCF1 (NP_200887.1), AtABCF2 (NP_196555.2), AtABCF3 (NP_176636.1), AtABCF4 (NP_567001.1) and AtABCF5 (NP_201289.1). AtSKD1 (AEC08019.1) and VvSKD1 (XP_002266534.1) were used as outgroups.

ABCG subfamily

The ABCG subfamily is a large group of half-size transporters with the reverse orientation (NBD-TMD) and is also known as the white-brown complex (WBC) subfamily. This subfamily has 29 and 30 members in the Arabidopsis genome and the rice genome, respectively [14], [15]. Since AtWBC15 and AtWBC22 were reassigned as AtABCG15 according to new nomenclature in the Arabidopsis Information Resources (TAIR), 28 ORFs were subjected to phylogenetic analysis.

Thirty ORFs showing strong similarity with the 28 Arabidopsis WBC-like proteins were identified (Fig. 7) and shared 17–99% similarity with each other. They have been named VvABCG1 through 30 and are half-size transporters with the NBD-TMD organization (Table S1). Among the identified ORFs encoding putative WBCs in Vitis, the VvABCG2 amino acid sequence shares 99% similarity with VvABCG5 (bootstrap values of 100%). The main difference between these 2 nucleotide sequences was found in some single nucleotide polymorphisms and in the 3′ untranslated region (UTR). Interestingly, VvABCG2 and VvABCG5 are located on different chromosomes, unknown and 7, respectively (Table S1). Similarly, VvABCG2 and VvABCG4 are located on unknown chromosomes and share 86% similarity with each other. In addition, VvABCG4 shows 84% similarity with VvABCG5. VvABCG12 displays 84% similarity with VvABCG13. The phylogenetic analysis of Vitis putative WBC transporters and those of Arabidopsis reveals that this subfamily is divided into 3 main groups with bootstrap values up to 90% (Fig. 7). The members of the Vitis ABCG/WBC subfamily are distributed almost equally in all 3 subclasses with their homologs from Arabidopsis. Finally, the phylogenetic analysis of V. vinifera and A. thaliana WBC proteins allowed us to identify several orthologs in the 2 species (Fig. 7) such as VvABCG7/AtABCG7 (76% similarity), VvABCG11/AtABCG26 (76% similarity), VvABCG17/AtABCG5 (74% similarity), VvABCG18/AtABCG22 (76% similarity), VvABCG21/AtABCG2 (74% similarity), VvABCG21/AtABCG20 (75% similarity), VvABCG24/AtABCG3 (80% similarity), and VvABCG29/AtABCG14 (79% similarity) that were grouped into the same clade and shared 74–80% similarity with each other. In addition, VvABCG19 showed 95.3% identity to its ortholog from R. communis by orthology analysis (Table S3).

Figure 7. Phylogenetic tree of ABCG (WBC) protein sequences from Arabidopsis and Vitis vinifera.

The amino acid sequences of all Arabidopsis ABCG (WBC) proteins and those of Vitis vinifera were aligned using the MUSCLE program and subjected to phylogenetic analysis by the distance with neighborjoining method using MEGA5 programme. Accession numbers for Arabidopsis sequences are AtABCG1 (NP_181467.1), AtABCG2 (NP_181272.1), AtABCG3 (NP_850111.1), AtABCG4 (NP_194305.1), AtABCG5 (NP_178984.1), AtABCG6 (NP_196862.1), AtABCG7 (NP_178241.1), AtABCG8 (NP_200098.1), AtABCG9 (NP_194472.2), AtABCG10 (NP_175734.1), AtABCG11 (NP_173226.2), AtABCG12 (NP_175561.1), AtABCG13 (NP_175557.1), AtABCG14 (NP_564383.1), AtABCG15 (NP_188746.2), AtABCG16 (NP_191069.2), AtABCG17 (NP_191070.1), AtABCG18 (NP_191071.1), AtABCG19 (NP_191073.1), AtABCG21 (NP_189190.2 ), AtABCG22 (NP_568169.1), AtABCG23 (NP_197442.1), AtABCG24 (NP_175745.4), AtABCG25 (NP_565030.1), AtABCG26 (NP_187928.2), AtABCG27 (NP_190799.1) and AtABCG28 (NP_200882.4). AtSKD1 (AEC08019.1) and VvSKD1 (XP_002266534.1) were used as outgroups.

The yeast genome harbors only 1 WBC homolog (ADP1) of unknown function [51], and the human genome contains 5 homologs, which participate in the transport of sterols and possibly other lipids [70]. Drosophila ABCG proteins are required in eye pigment formation, while human ABCG transporters are involved in sterol transport [71], [72]. Plant WBC homologs have been recently cloned. AtABCG11 and AtABCG12 were reported to be involved in the transport of cuticular wax, and AtWBC19 confers kanamycin resistance in Arabidopsis [24], [28]. It has been reported very recently that AtABCG25 is responsible for ABA transport and is involved in the ABA signaling pathway [29]. There are at least 198 ESTs for all members of this subfamily from V. vinifera (Table S9), but none of the ESTs have been cloned or characterized.

In addition to half-size ABC transporters, plant genomes contain a large group of full-size ABCG subfamily transporters in the reverse orientation (NBD1-TMD1-NBD2-TMD2), which are also PDR. In the Arabidopsis and rice genomes, 15 and 21 PDRs have been identified, respectively [14], [15].

The PDR subfamily in V. vinifera is the largest ABC transporter subfamily and includes full-size ABC transporters that are encoded by 33 ORFs, namely, VvABCG31 through VvABCG63 (Table S1). Its size is larger than that of the A. thaliana PDR subfamily, which contains 15 members [14], [73]. The PDR subfamily is characterized by the presence of NBDs and TMDs in the reverse orientation and is only found in fungi and plants [51], [74]. The sequence analysis of ORFs encoding V. vinifera putative PDR subfamily members revealed the presence of (NBD-TMD)₂ in the reverse orientation (Table S1). Five PDR subfamily members are located on chromosome 4, 4 members on chromosome 13, 5 members on chromosome 6, 2 members on chromosome 11, 1 member on chromosome 5, 1 member on chromosome 8, 1 member on chromosome 14, and 14 members on chromosome 9 (Table S1). Most PDR subfamily members are distributed on chromosome 9. Members of the Vitis PDR subfamily share up to 92% similarity between each other and contain between 804 (VvABCG61) and 3142 (VvABCG46) amino acid residues (Table S1). The phylogenetic tree analysis of V. vinifera and A. thaliana subfamilies reveals that these proteins can be classified into 3 major groups (Fig. 8). The phylogenetic analysis of V. vinifera and A. thaliana PDR subfamilies identified 5 ortholog pairs that included VvABCG31/AtABCG32 (77% similarity), VvABCG37/AtABCG35 or AtABCG36 (73% similarity), VvABCG37/AtABCG29 (76% similarity), VVABCG53/AtABCG34 or AtABCG39 (76% similarity), and VvABCG46/AtABCG40 (73% similarity) with bootstrap values up to 75% (Fig. 8).

Figure 8. Phylogenetic tree of ABCG (PDR) protein sequences from Arabidopsis and Vitis vinifera.

The amino acid sequences of all Arabidopsis ABCG (PDR) proteins and those of Vitis vinifera were aligned using the MUSCLE program and subjected to phylogenetic analysis by the distance with neighborjoining method using MEGA5 programme. Accession numbers for Arabidopsis sequences are AtABCG29 (NP_190919.1), AtABCG30 (NP_566543.1), AtABCG31 (NP_193258.2), AtABCG32 (NP_180555.2), AtABCG33 (NP_180259.1), AtABCG34 (NP_181265.1), AtABCG35 (NP_181179.2), AtABCG36 (NP_172973.1), AtABCG37 (NP_176196.1), AtABCG38 (NP_190916.1), AtABCG39 (NP_683617.1), AtABCG40 (NP_176867.2), AtABCG41 (NP_173005.1), AtABCG42 (NP_680692.1), AtABCG43 (NP_680693.5) and AtABCG44 (NP_680694.2). AtSKD1 (AEC08019.1) and VvSKD1 (XP_002266534.1) were used as outgroups.

Members of this family confer resistance to various biotic and abiotic stresses [20], [21], [75]–[77]. The first plant PDR gene identified, SpTUR2, is regulated in response to abiotic stress [73], [78]. Another plant PDR, OsPDR29 from rice, participates in the abiotic stress response [79]. It was recently shown that NpPDR1 plays a role in plant defense responses [80], while AtPDR12 is a plasma membrane ABA uptake transporter in guard cells and is involved in resistance to lead [20], [23]. We identified 543 ESTs corresponding to 32 members of the Vitis PDR subfamily (Table S9). No ESTs have been identified for VvPDR31, suggesting that it is not transcriptionally active. Among the ORFs corresponding to the PDR subfamily in Vitis, 32 are transcriptionally active, but none of them have been cloned in their entirety and characterized.

ABCI Subfamily

The ABCI subfamily consists of ABC proteins with a single NBD that has similarity to prokaryotic soluble ABC proteins and is designated as non-intrinsic ABC proteins (NAPs). The Arabidopsis genome contains 15 members of this subfamily, whereas the rice genome has 10 members [14], [15]. Recently AtNAP8 and AtNAP15 were reassigned to AtABCB and AtABCE subfamilies, respectively in TAIR In addition, both AtNAP5 and AtNAP12 were identified as fragments of AtABCC and AtABCG subfamilies, respectively [15].We identified 6 ORFs showing the strongest similarity to the 11 putative NAPs from A. thaliana (Fig. 9). Members of the NAP subfamily in the Vitis genome contain only a single NBD and range from 329 to 511 amino acid residues (Table S1). The members of the NAP subfamily in Vitis share 1–18% similarity with each other and are distributed on different chromosomes (Fig. 9, Table S1). We identified orthologs for 4 of the Vitis NAPs with more than 80% identity from different plant species (Table S3).

Figure 9. Phylogenetic tree of ABCI (NAP) protein sequences from Arabidopsis and Vitis vinifera.

The amino acid sequences of all Arabidopsis ABCI (NAP) proteins and those of Vitis vinifera were aligned using the MUSCLE program and subjected to phylogenetic analysis by the distance with neighborjoining method using MEGA5 programme. Accession numbers for Arabidopsis sequences are AtABCI8 (NP_192386.1), AtABCI21 (NP_199224.1), AtABCI17 (NP_176961.1), AtABCI19 (NP_563694.1), AtABCI7 (NP_564404.1), AtABCI6 (NP_187678.1), AtABCI20 (NP_195847.1), AtABCI1 (NP_176516.1), AtABCI13 (NP_564850.1), AtABCI10 (NP_195072.2) and AtABCI11 (NP_196914.1). AtSKD1 (AEC08019.1) and VvSKD1 (XP_002266534.1) were used as outgroups.

These transporters have not yet been functionally characterized in plants. However, AtNAP1 (alias LAF6) is known to be a component of the plastid “mobilization of sulfur” system that is responsible for the biogenesis and repair of iron-sulfur clusters [81]. An interaction between AtNAP1 and AtNAP7 has been demonstrated [81], [82]. There are currently 70 ESTs for all of these transporters in various tissues in V. vinifera (Table S10).

SMC Subfamily

SMC proteins are not ordinarily classified as ABC proteins because they lack an ABC signature motif between the Walker A and the Walker B motifs. Both the Arabidopsis genome and the rice genome have 4 members of this subfamily [14], [15]. The Vitis genome contains 3 ORFs that encode putative SMC proteins with strong similarity to the 4 putative NAPs from A. thaliana (Fig. 10; Table S1), and they all contain an ABC signature motif between the Walker A and the Walker B motifs. Vitis SMCs have orthologs from P. trichocarpa and R. communis with more than 80% similarity (Table S3). The SMCs have functions in chromatin condensation, gene dosage compensation, and sister chromatin adhesion [83]. There are currently 13 ESTs for all of the Vitis SMCs in various tissues (Table S11). There is no report on the functions of SMC proteins in plants.

Figure 10. Phylogenetic tree of SMC protein sequences from Arabidopsis and Vitis vinifera.

The amino acid sequences of all Arabidopsis SMC proteins and those of Vitis vinifera were aligned using the MUSCLE program and subjected to phylogenetic analysis by the distance with neighborjoining method using MEGA5 programme. Accession numbers for Arabidopsis sequences are AtSMC1 (CAB77587), AtSMC2 (CAB61972.1), AtSMC3 (BAB10693.1), AtSMC4 (BAB11491.1). AtSKD1 (AEC08019.1) and VvSKD1 (XP_002266534.1) were used as outgroups.

This work represents the first complete inventory of ABC transporters in V. vinifera. The identification of Vitis ABC transporters and their comparative analysis with the Arabidopsis ABC transporters revealed a strong conservation between the 2 species. In this report, we identified 135 ORFs encoding ABC proteins in V. vinifera using a bioinformatics approach. One of the most remarkable characteristics of the V. vinifera ABC proteins is its size. It is the largest family of ABC proteins reported to date with 135 members. Another remarkable characteristic of the Vitis ABC protein inventory is its large group of full-size transporters, including ABCB, ABCC, and ABCG subfamily members. This inventory could help elucidate the biological and physiological functions of these transporters from V. vinifera.

Supporting Information

Table S1

Summary of the Vitis ABC proteins. The identified open reading frames (ORFs) are classified into 13 subfamilies, whose nomenclature is represented according to both Sanchez-Fernandez et al. (2001) and Verrier et al. (2008). The chromosomal (Chr) locations of the ORFs, the total number of ORFs for each category on each chromosome and in the whole genome, and the total numbers of full-size molecule and half-size molecule transporters and proteins lacking contiguous transmembrane domains (TMDs) (“soluble” proteins) are shown.

(DOC)

Table S2

Detailed inventory of Vitis ABC proteins and their genes. Columns 1–16 contain the protein acronym (Name), topology (number and orientation of nucleotide-binding folds [NBFs] and transmembrane domains [TMDs]), coding sequence (CDS), Vitis proteome 12× ID, GenBank ID, chromosome location (Chr), gene length, number of introns and exons, open reading frame (ORF) length, protein length, estimates of molecular weight, and pI of the protein for each gene are given.

(DOC)

Table S3

Orthologs of Vitis ABC proteins identified in diverse plant species. Columns 1–6 contain the protein name represented according to both Sanchez-Fernandez et al. (2001) and Verrier et al. (2008), Vitis proteome 12× ID, GenBank ID, species, percentage identity (%ID), UniprotKB ID.

(DOC)

Table S4

Expressed sequence tags (ESTs) identified for the ABCA (ATH and AOH) subfamily in Vitis vinifera . The protein name, Vitis proteome 12× ID, GenBank ID, EST name, cultivar/tissue type, and development stage are given for each gene.

(DOC)

Table S5

Expressed sequence taqs (ESTs) identified for ABCB (MDR, TAP and ATM) subfamily in Vitis vinifera . The protein name, Vitis proteome 12x ID, GenBank ID, EST name, cultivar/tissue type, and development stage are given for each gene.

(DOC)

Table S6

Expressed sequence taqs (ESTs) identified for ABCC (MRP) subfamily in Vitis vinifera . The protein name, Vitis proteome 12x ID, GenBank ID, EST name, cultivar/tissue type, and development stage are given for each gene.

(DOC)

Table S7

Expressed sequence taqs (ESTs) identified for ABCD (PMP) and ABCE (RLI) subfamilies in Vitis vinifera . The protein name, Vitis proteome 12x ID, GenBank ID, EST name, cultivar/tissue type, and development stage are given for each gene.

(DOC)

Table S8

Expressed sequence taqs (ESTs) identified for ABCF (GCN) subfamily in Vitis vinifera . The protein name, Vitis proteome 12x ID, GenBank ID, EST name, cultivar/tissue type, and development stage are given for each gene.

(DOC)

Table S9

Expressed sequence taqs (ESTs) identified for ABCG (WBC and PDR) subfamily in Vitis vinifera . The protein name, Vitis proteome 12x ID, GenBank ID, EST name, cultivar/tissue type, and development stage are given for each gene.

(DOC)

Table S10

Expressed sequence taqs (ESTs) identified for ABCI (NAP) subfamily in Vitis vinifera . The protein name, Vitis proteome 12x ID, GenBank ID, EST name, cultivar/tissue type, and development stage are given for each gene.

(DOC)

Table S11

Expressed sequence taqs (ESTs) identified for SMC proteins in Vitis vinifera . The protein name, Vitis proteome 12x ID, GenBank ID, EST name, cultivar/tissue type, and development stage are given for each gene.

(DOC)

Funding Statement

No current external funding sources for this study.