Skip to main content
The BMJ logoLink to The BMJ
. 2004 Apr 17;328(7445):961.

Ten Minutes for the Family: Systemic Interventions in Primary Care

Iona Heath 1
PMCID: PMC390230

Ten minutes seems a ridiculously short time in which to attempt to tackle the always complex health problems of a single individual. To use the same allotted time to take on the interacting and compounding problems of a whole family might seem absurdly ambitious. Yet any general practitioner knows the astonishing amount of suffering, endurance, and meaning that can be revealed and contained within a single consultation of this length. Three of the four authors of this book have substantial experience of working in UK general practice, where 10 minute appointments are standard. This deliberately pragmatic book is full of practical wisdom that can be taken straight off the page and into the consulting room.

Figure 1.

Figure 1

Eia Asen, Dave Tomson, Peter Tomson, Venetia Young

Routledge, £16.99, pp 224 ISBN 0 415 30189 0

Rating: ★★★

The book is grounded in systemic theory and an understanding that the symptoms of illness are not to be found confined within individuals but are generated and expressed in the space between them, within family myths, and the ritualised interactions between different family members. All of us grow up with a number of family stories, which are told repeatedly and which come to represent the family's image of itself. The process by which such stories are selected from the multitude of different events happening each day in the life of a family has much to tell about the relationships within the family. Some of the stories can become rigid, constraining, and damaging. By seeking to enrich the bare bones of the family myths that often dictate recurring patterns in family behaviour, the clinician can help to reveal new possibilities and different ways of seeing the same events.

For the authors the key clinical attribute is curiosity, with the stream of questions that it engenders and its power to stimulate the commitment of doctors. Circular and reflexive questions elicit a series of answers that open up new possibilities, not only for the clinician, but also, more importantly, for the patient and his or her family. Triadic questions seek to draw out information about how a third person sees the relationship between two others; they provide a means whereby absent family members can be brought into the consulting room to offer new insights.

The book is packed with schematic but convincing case stories, which demonstrate the scope of questioning. The reader is given a whole range of suggested wordings that can be used with individuals, couples, and whole families. The choice of words is always intensely individual and many of those suggested will seem awkward to some readers, but the enthusiasm of the authors is infectious and their encouragement to select and try just two or three is persuasive.

Ten Minutes for the Family also demonstrates the use of simple visual techniques, such as genograms and family circle drawings, that provide the basis of further questions and yet more opportunities for understanding and change. I finished reading at the weekend; by Wednesday I had drawn two genograms for patients that I have known for many years and I had asked at least three triadic questions. Not a revolution, but I understand more and, more importantly, the patients seemed to find it helpful.


Articles from BMJ : British Medical Journal are provided here courtesy of BMJ Publishing Group

RESOURCES