Table 1.
The list of traditional medicine (TM) journals searched in reporting quality review
| Journal title (Abbreviation) | ISSN | Website | Reference to general editorial policies a | Reporting guidelines specific in instructions to authors b |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| The Journal of Korean Oriental Medicine (J Korean Orient Med) | 1010-0695 | http://www.jkom.org/ | ICNJE | nr |
| Korean Journal of Acupuncture (Korean J Acupunct) | 2287-3368 | http://www.kjacupuncture.org/ | ICNJE | nr |
| Korean Journal of Oriental Physiology & Pathology (Korean J Orient Physiol & Pathol) | 1738-7698 | http://www.hantopic.com/kjopp/KJOPP.htm | nr | nr |
| The Korea Journal of Herbology (Korean J Herbology) | 1229-1765 | http://www.herbology.or.kr/ | ICNJE | nr |
| Journal of Oriental Sports Medicine (J Orien Sports Med) | N/A | http://sskm.tistory.com/ | nr | nr |
| Journal of Korean Traditional Oncology (J Korean Tradit Oncol) | 1229-2621 | http://www.koreanoncology.or.kr/ | ICNJE | nr |
| Journal of Pharmacopuncture (Pharmacopuncture) | 2093-6966 | http://www.journal.ac/ | nr | nr |
| Journal of Acupuncture and Meridian Studies (J Acupunct Meridian Stud) | 2005-2901 | http://journalams.com/00_Main.html | ICNJE | nr |
| The Korean Journal of Oriental Preventive Medicine (Korean J Orient Prev Med) | 1226-7066 | http://www.prehan.com/mainnew/main.html | ICNJE | nr |
| The Journal of Korean of Medical GI-GONG Academy (J Korean GG) | N/A | http://gigong.or.kr/index.php | nr | nr |
| The Korean Journal of Joongpoong (Korean J Joongpoong) | 1598-1843 | http://www.kmstroke.or.kr/v2 | nr | nr |
| Journal of Korean Acupuncture and Moxibustion Medicine Society (J Korean Acupunct & Mox Med Sci) | 1229-1137 | http://www.acumoxa.or.kr/ | nr | CONSORT, STARD, STROBE, QUOROM, MOOSE, STRICTA |
| The Journal of Korean Oriental Internal Medicine (J Korean Orient Intern Med) | 1226-9174 | http://www.oim.or.kr | nr | nr |
| The Journal of Oriental Obstetrics and Gynecology (J Orient Gynecol Obstet) | 1229-4292 | http://www.oobgy.or.kr/ | nr | nr |
| The Journal of Korean Oriental Pediatrics (J Korean Orient Pediatr) | 1226-8038 | http://www.akop.or.kr/ | ICNJE | nr |
| Journal of Oriental Neuropsychiatry (J Orient Neuropsychiatry) | 1226-6396 | http://www.onp.or.kr/ | ICNJE | nr |
| The Journal of Korean Oriental Medical Ophthalmology and Otolaryngology and Dermatology (J Korean Orient Otolaryngol Dermatol) | 1738-6640 | http://ood.or.kr/ | ICNJE | nr |
| Journal of Oriental Medical Thermology (J Orient Med Thermol) | 1598-592X | http://www.komt.or.kr/ | nr | nr |
| The Journal of The Korea Institute of Oriental Medical Diagnostics (J Korean Orient Med Diagn) | 1226-5241 | http://www.bmpomd.or.kr/ | ICNJE | |
| The Korean Journal of Oriental Medical Prescription (Korean J Orient Med Prescription) | 1229-1218 | http://www.ompak.okdanche.com/ | nr | nr |
| The Journal of Korean Medical Classics (J Korean Med Classic) | 1229-8328 | http://www.wonjeon.org/ | nr | nr |
| The Journal of The Society of HyungSang Medicine (J Sci HyungSang Med) | 1229-8328 | http://www.hyungsang.or.kr/ | nr | nr |
| Journal of Sasang Constitutional Medicine (J Sasang Constit Med) | 1226-4075 | http://www.esasang.com | nr | nr |
| Journal of Somun Oriental Medical Society (J Somun Orient Med) | 1975-2407 | http://www.somun.or.kr | nr | nr |
| The Journal of Korea CHUNA Manual Medicine for Spine and Nerves (J Korea CHUNA Med Spine & Nerves) | 1598-1630 | http://www.chuna.or.kr | ICNJE | |
| The Journal of Korean Medical History (J Korean Med Hist) | 1229-6147 | http://www.medicalhistory.or.kr/ | nr | nr |
| Journal of Society of Korean Medicine for Obesity Research (J Sci Korean Med Obes Res) | 1976-9334 | http://www.obesity.or.kr/ | ICNJE, Helsinki Declaration, NIH Guide for the Care and Use of Laboratory Animals | |
| Journal of Oriental Rehabilitation Medicine (J Orien Rehabil Med) | 1229-1854 | http://www.ormkorea.org/ | ICNJE | nr |
| Oriental Pharmacy and Experimental Medicine (Orient Pharm Exp Med) | 1598-2386 | http://www.opem.org/ | nr | nr |
| Journal of East-West Nursing Research (J East-West Nurses Res) | 1226-4938 | http://society.kisti.re.kr/~ewnri/ | nr | nr |
| Integrative Medicine Research (Integr Med Res) | 2213-4200 | http://www.imr-journal.org/ | ICNJE | |
| Journal of Ginseng Research (J Ginseng Res) | 1226-8453 | http://www.ginsengsociety.org/eng/ | ICMJE, COPE, Good Publication Practice for Medical Journals Uniform Requirements for Manuscripts Submitted to Biomedical Journals: Writing and Editing for Biomedical Publication, Helsinki Declaration, AEC | |
| Natural Product Sciences (Nat Prod Res) | 0253-3073 | http://www.ksp.or.kr/ | nr | nr |
| Korea Journal of Pharmacognosy | 0253-3070 | http://journal.ksp.or.kr/ | nr | nr |
| Korean Journal of Medicinal Crop Science (Korean J Med Crop Sci) | 0252-9777 | http://www.medcrop.or.kr/ | nr | nr |
| International Journal of Genuine Traditional Medicine (Int J Genuine Trad Med) | 2233-8985 | http://www.e-tang.org/journal.do?method=journalintro&journalSeq=J000027&menuId=&introMenuId=0101 | nr | nr |
AEC: Institutional Animal Ethical Committee; COPE: Committee on Publication Ethics; CONSORT: Consolidated Standards of Reporting Trials; ICMJE: International Committee of Medical Journal Editors; MOOSE: Meta-analysis of Observational Studies in Epidemiology; nr: not reported; QUOROM: Quality of Reporting of Meta-analyses; STARD: Standards for Reporting of Diagnostic Accuracy Studies; STROBE: Strengthening the Reporting of Observational Studies in Epidemiology; STRICTA: Standards for Reporting Interventions in Clinical Trials of Acupuncture.
aReference to general editorial policies: whether the journals mentioned to general editorial policies.
bReporting guidance specific in introduction to authors: whether the ‘introduction to authors’ section of a journal provided any reporting guidance.