Asthma and metabolic syndrome: Current knowledge and future perspectives

Abstract

Asthma and obesity are epidemiologically linked; however, similar relationships are also observed with other markers of the metabolic syndrome, such as insulin resistance and dyslipidemia, which cannot be accounted for by increased body mass alone. Obesity appears to be a predisposing factor for the asthma onset, both in adults and in children. In addition, obesity could make asthma more difficult to control and to treat. Although obesity may predispose to increased Th2 inflammation or tendency to atopy, other mechanisms need to be considered, such as those mediated by hyperglycaemia, hyperinsulinemia and dyslipidemia in the context of metabolic syndrome. The mechanisms underlying the association between asthma and metabolic syndrome are yet to be determined. In the past, these two conditions were believed to occur in the same individual without any pathogenetic link. However, the improvement in asthma symptoms following weight reduction indicates a causal relationship. The interplay between these two diseases is probably due to a bidirectional interaction. The purpose of this review is to describe the current knowledge about the possible link between metabolic syndrome and asthma, and explore potential application for future studies and strategic approaches.

Core tip: Asthma is a complex syndrome that encompasses multiple phenotypes. The relationship with obesity has been addressed in the past; however, the underlying mechanism of such a relationship seems to be more complex, and not explained by the body weight alone. The metabolic syndrome carries a condition of systemic inflammation that could potentially explain the influence on asthma onset and severity. This is a rather unexplored area that could potentially open new scenario in the diagnostic algorithm and in the strategic approach, with a more comprehensive assessment of the disease.

INTRODUCTION

Asthma is among the most common chronic diseases worldwide. The disease is poorly controlled despite available therapies in a large proportion of patients[1], with long-term impairment and disability[2-4]. Among factors impairing the control of symptoms and the lack of response to treatment, obesity is to be taken into account, as stated by recent guidelines[5].

It is well recognized that obesity and asthma are epidemiologically linked[6-9]. This relationship is also observed between asthma and other markers of the metabolic syndrome, such as insulin resistance and hypertension that cannot be accounted for by increased body mass alone[9-12]. The World Health Organization has reported that obesity has dramatically increased during the last few decades. In 2009-2010, more than one-third of United States adults (35.7%) were obese[13]. In this scenario, an estimated 300000 deaths per year are directly attributable to obesity, mainly due to heart diseases, diabetes, cancer, obstructive sleep apnea syndrome (OSAS), arthritis, and psychological disturbances, leading to the concept that obesity represents a risk factor for several pathologies in different clinical conditions[14]. In this regard, overweight and obesity have been demonstrated to be associated in a dose-dependent fashion with the risk of having asthma[15], and obesity appears to be a predisposing factor for the asthma onset, both in adults and in children, as assessed by several cross-sectional studies[16]. In addition, obesity could make asthma more difficult to control and to treat; interestingly, weight-loss interventions in overweight severe asthmatic patients have shown substantial improvements in the clinical status, lung function, symptoms, and overall asthma control[8,17,18]. However, the mechanism linking obesity and asthma is still a controversial issue.

The obese-asthma phenotype is characterized by a paucity of airway inflammation. Although obesity may predispose to increased Th2 inflammation or tendency to atopy, other mechanisms that are independent of inflammatory infliltrates need to be considered, such as hyperglycaemia, hyperinsulinemia and dyslipidemia in the context of metabolic syndrome. Metabolic syndrome is defined as a syndrome that involves three of the following characteristics: dyslipidemia (high levels of apoB lipoproteins and triglycerides, and/or low high density lipoprotein cholesterol), an impaired fasting glucose metabolism, hypertension or central obesity[19-21]. Metabolic syndrome is directly involved in the increased prevalence of coronary heart disease, atherosclerotic diseases, and diabetes mellitus type 2[20-22]. Other metabolic abnormalities have been reported in patients with metabolic syndrome (chronic proinflammatory and prothrombotic states, liver disease and sleep apnea)[20-22]. In the literature, some authors consider that the aforementioned criterion is a combination of risk factors rather than a specific syndrome[23]. On the other hand, epidemiological data reveals that there is a high prevalence of metabolic syndrome in both childhood and young adulthood, and pattern seems to be related to several inflammatory diseases including asthma[22].

EPIDEMIOLOGICAL LINK BETWEEN ASTHMA AND METABOLIC SYNDROME

In obese individuals, the risk for asthma in overweight and obese individuals is increased and does not differ with gender[24,25]. In a recent report, Dandona et al[26] showed that in obese asthma patients, with or without type 2 diabetes, there is an increased expression of pro-inflammatory mediators. Following gastric bypass surgery and weight loss, the expression of the aforementioned mediators and plasma metabolites fall significantly suggesting that the pro-inflammatory effect of obesity can be downregulated upon adipose tissue reduction. Assad et al[27] recently showed that BMI predicts asthma in women more than metabolic sybndrome[28], however, Agrawal et al[29] suggested that calculation of parameters was conducted on entirely different scales, thereby limiting comparison of strength. In another study, Brumpton et al[11] evaluated the associations of metabolic syndrome with the cumulative incidence of asthma in adults in 23245 individuals after an 11 years follow up (Nord-Trøndelag Health Study 1999-2008), showing that metabolic syndrome predisposes to. In a large mendelian randomization study, Granell et al[30] recently found that higher BMI increases the risk of asthma in non-atopic (1.90, 95%CI: 1.19-3.03) and atopic children (1.37, 95%CI: 0.89-2.11).

PATHOPHYSIOLOGICAL MECHANISMS

Obesity-associated asthma is characterized by the presence of neutrophilic airway inflammation, increased morbidity, and resistance to corticosteroids. The mechanisms underlying the relationship between metabolic syndrome and asthma are yet to be fully understood[31]. In the past, these two conditions were believed to occur in the same individual without any pathogenetic link. However, the improvement of in asthma symptoms following weight reduction implies a causal relationship between obesity and asthma[32,33]. The interplay between these two diseases could be based on a bidirectional interaction. For example, obese asthmatics are at higher risk of metabolic syndrome as opposed to obese individuals who do not suffer from asthma, suggesting that asthma per se can increase the risk of developing metabolic syndrome[34]. Similarly, metabolic syndrome has been demonstrated to increase the severity of asthma[35,36]. Recently, changes in the expression of pro-inflammatory mediators such as leptin, IL-6, TNF-α, C-reactive protein and adiponectin have been demonstrated in obese asthmatics[37], implying their potential role in the pathogenesis of obesity-associated asthma. However, due to the paucity of available literature in this area, it appears difficult to draw definite conclusions until additional experimental and epidemiological data are collected.

A cross-sectional study published by Bruno et al[38] recently analyzed the influence of BMI on asthma control in subjects with severe forms of the disease, demonstrating that the optimal state of asthma control is lower in obese than in normal weight and in overweight severe asthmatics and the number of asthma exacerbation episodes are significantly higher in obese than in normal or overweight severe asthmatics. These results may be explained with the inflammatory cascade that the adipose tissue generates. Indeed, the obese state is characterized by the so-called low-grade systemic inflammation[38]. Subcutaneous fat is the major source of fatty acids for the liver, and of free fatty acids in the circulating plasma[39,40]. Subcutaneous fat is related to insulin resistance and to visceral adipose tissue[39,40]. Abdominal subcutaneous fat from obese subjects has been reported to be an inflamed adipose state characterized by tissue macrophage accumulation. This pathologic tissue has been associated with impaired local vasodilatation, peripheral hyperinsulinemia, and insulin resistance[39-41]. Macrophage presence in the tissue is associated with an increase of plasma high-sensitivity C-reactive protein (hsCRP) levels and local amounts of TNF-α[39,40]. The precise mechanism of this event remains to be elucidated; however, adipokines have been proposed as important endocrine mediators since they are related to adipose tissue function and modulation. The following proteins are listed as adipokines, which are envisaged as markers of fat body mass and distribution, as well as tissue function: (1) leptin; (2) adiponectin; (3) ghrelin; (4) vaspin; (5) retinol binding protein 4; (6) apelin; (7) progranulin and MCP-1; (8) omentin; (9) resistin and chemerin; and (10) fetuin[42,43]. Adipose derived hormones may represent molecular links between asthma and inflammation. For example, adiponectin is known to exert anti-inflammatory effects, by inhibiting the eosinophil functions. Indeed, pre-treatment with adiponectin has been demonstrated to diminish the eotaxin-mediated chemotactic responses, by binding the adiponectin receptors AdipoR1 and AdipoR2 that are expressed in human eosinophils[44,45]. In addition, adiponectin has been shown to act as a protector to human bronchial epithelial cell that are involved in the pathogenesis of asthma[46].

High serum levels of resistin have been recently documented in asthmatic children[47]. More important, an in vitro study showed that the resistin production strongly increases in obese patients with severe persistent asthma[48], providing support to the notion that resistin can be depicted as a pro-inflammatory cytokine mainly in severely obese asthmatics. Conversely, high leptin levels are associated with a more severe disease and this even in non-obese asthmatics[49,50]. Leptin can upregulate systemic inflammation and may lead to an impairment in lung function[51]. Increased expression and secretion of pro-inflammatory cytokines such as TNF-α, IL-6, and IL-12 were detected when exposed to leptin[52]. Also, the systemic inflammation may contribute to drive insulin resistance, endothelial dysfunction and high blood pressure conditions. The results of a survey confirmed that leptin levels were highly associated with asthma especially in premenopausal women independent of BMI[51]. Guler et al[53] also suggested that serum leptin concentrations were a predictive factor for asthma in boys, even after adjusting for obesity. Previously, leptin-mediated increased bronchial hyperactivity in obese mice models had been documented[32].

The changes in the adipose tissue in metabolic syndrome favour the production of mediators that modulate the transcription factors. When they are activated by their ligands, they are able to control genes that are involved in intermediate metabolism[54]. In this regard, peroxisome proliferator-activated receptors (PPAR)-gamma agonists may attenuate the upper airway allergic inflammation by induction of T_reg cells and inhibiting the proliferation of effector T cells[55].

Diet-induced dyslipidemia may affect the trafficking of immune cells to the lung in diseases such as asthma[56]. In pulmonary physiology, circulating low density and high density lipoproteins (LDL and HDL) are both taken up by specific receptors, and consequently block local cholesterol biosynthesis[56]. Alveolar cholesterol homeostasis has been demonstrated to affect surfactant synthesis in normal lung physiology[56]. Conversely, HDL promotes surfactant production, and lung fibroblast growth. Adipose tissue reduction by diet or surgery, modulation of cholesterol, or glucose metabolism, has an important effect in asthmatic patients. The apolipoprotein E (ApoE)-low density lipoproteic receptor pathway appears to be involved in the pathogenesis of a murine model of allergic asthma[1]. However, the mechanism by which this protein modulates asthma pathogenesis has never been fully elucidated. ApoE has been hypothesized to as negatively modulate the degree of airway hyperresponsiveness[57]. Perhaps, this mechanism can also apply to humans. Low levels of serum HDL were found to be associated with an increased risk for asthma in adolescence[58], and a recent analysis on 85555 adults demonstrated that high triglycerides and low HDL were associated with wheezing, supporting their role as markers of inflammation[59]. Recently, the association between LDL and asthma was investigated by Scichilone et al[60], who found that in mild asthmatics, the least pro-inflammatory LDL (LDL-1 and LDL-2) are lower than in healthy subjects, whereas the most pro-inflammatory (LDL-3 and LDL-4) are higher. In addition, the serum concentrations of LDL-3 (most pro-inflammatory) were negatively associated with lung function, suggesting their contribution to the occurrence of the inflammatory changes of the airways[60]. Insulin excess can also directly alter lung cellular physiology and this would represent a fundamental common molecular link between asthma and metabolic syndrome[61]. There is substantial data that mechanistically links insulin and insulin like growth factor-1 to lung development and function. It is conceivable, although not proven, that hyperinsulinemia may lead to development of lung disease, particularly asthma[62]. Experimental studies that directly address this possibility are strongly advocated.

Recent observations seem to focus on the mitochondrial dysfunction as main mediator of the pathogenetic link between metabolic syndrome and asthma. Defective mitochondrial biogenesis in the adipose tissue is well documented in metabolic syndrome[63-66]. However, the involvement of mitochondria alterations among the risk factors of metabolic syndrome and asthma is unknown[67-72].

Oxidative stress on both pulmonary and extra-pulmonary inflammation in obesity may play a major role[73,74]. Oxidative stress is characterized by increased reactive oxygen species (ROS), which induce functional changes of the airways. On this basis, increased oxidative stress may be recognized as a potential mechanism by which obesity results in increased asthma severity. In this regard, the renin angiotensin aldosterone system, a potent inducer of oxidative stress, is often activated in patients with metabolic syndrome, and results in increased levels of angiotensin II. Angiotensin II seems to be able to determine bronchial hyperresponsiveness[75] and airway remodelling[76]; however, the mechanisms by which this occurs are not yet fully understood.

CURRENT AND FUTURE DEVELOPMENTS

Figure 1 describes the temporal and causal relationships between asthma and features of metabolic syndrome. The role of lipoproteins in the pathogenesis of asthma pathogenesis supported the use of statins in asthmatic patients[77-83]; however, there are still some controversies[84-86]. Even though the aim of statin use in asthmatic patients is related to cholesterol metabolism, most of the reports have highlighted the anti inflammatory properties[77-79,86,87]. An in vitro study showed that lovastatin attenuates the differentiation and proliferation of asthmatic bronchial fibroblasts[85], airway smooth muscle cells[86]. Both simvastatin and atorvastatin treatment reduce inflammatory cells in sputum[86]. The mevalonate-dependent and-independent pathways have been identified as potential opportunities for novel treatments with statins in asthma develop new treatments for asthma[78]. Even though statin therapy could be beneficial for a subgroup of asthmatic patients that are either overweight or obese, similar important advantages can be obtained by diet and exercise[20,26]. Biphosphonates could have a beneficial effect in asthmatic patients; alendronate has been shown to have a protective effect by decreasing eosinophil airway inflammation by chemokine secretion, eotaxin, and down-regulating cytokine secretion induced by Th2 and Th17 cells[88]. Retinoic acid[89], retinoids[90] and fenretidine[91] appear to have a beneficial effect on the inflammatory asthmatic response by decreasing the inflammatory milieu. As a consequence, signal transduction pathways inhibition by these compounds could decrease the occurrence of bronchial constriction. Further studies are required to ascertain the possible beneficial effect of new therapeutic elements to control hypertension and endocrine disorders in asthmatic patients with metabolic syndrome. In patients with severe uncontrolled or non responding asthma[92,93], biological therapies seem to be relevant. Interestingly, chemokines and chemokine receptors, CCR3 and CCR4, have been involved in adipose tissue mass increase and insulin resistance[94,95]. Thus, therapy involving chemokines or chemokine receptor inhibition could potentially provide beneficial effects on asthmatic patients with metabolic syndrome[96]. Finally, a therapeutic option in asthmatic patients with diabetes could be represented by thiazolidinediones, oral diabetes medications that selectively activate PPAR receptor gamma, which have potent anti-inflammatory properties thus reducing the number of exacerbations[97,98].

Figure 1.

Relationships between asthma and features of metabolic syndrome. The different conditions are divided into “before” and “after” to explain which occurred earlier, implying a causal association. The green arrows describe the temporal evolution and the time when the diseases occurred. Arrow 1 sets asthma as a risk factor for systemic hypertension due to the chronic use of corticosteroids. Arrows 2 and 3 depict the role of dyslipidemia and hyperinsulinemia as risk factors for asthma, due to the abnormalities of the lipoprotein pattern and the influence on the M2 receptors, respectively. Arrow 4 shows the bidirectional association between asthma and obesity. Arrow 5 summarizes the influence of the above-described associations, showing the tight relationship between metabolic syndrome and asthma. Also see text for the explanation.

CONCLUSION

The scope of the current review is to explore the possible link between metabolic syndrome and asthma. Early endocrine disturbances seem to predispose to severe or difficult to treat asthma. Hypertensive and diabetic patients should be screened for respiratory function in the effort to identify cases of airway hyperreactivity or subclinical asthma. Specifically designed studies are needed to address the influence of metabolic syndrome on asthma occurrence and severity, and to unveil the potential underlying common mechanisms. Future studies will hopefully provide convincing evidence on useful therapeutic schemes that today are still unrevealed.