First Author
|
Year
|
# of Patients
|
Study Design
|
Inclusion Criteria
|
Cut-off Time
|
Findings
|
Aebi M [32]
|
1986
|
100
|
Retrospective
|
Cervical spinal injuries treated operatively
|
N/A
|
Early surgery associated with shorter ICU stay, lower incidence of pulmonary complications, and lower cost of treatment.
|
Croce MA [8]
|
2001
|
291
|
Retrospective
|
Spine fractures due to blunt trauma admitted to an urban level 1 trauma center
|
3 days
|
Early surgery associated with shorter ICU stay, lower incidence of pulmonary complications, and lower cost of treatment.
|
Fehlings MG [12]
|
2012
|
313
|
Prospective
|
Adults (age 18-60) with cervical SCI
|
1 day
|
Early surgery associated with higher rate of ≥ 2 grade improvement in ASIA Impairment Scale grade at 6 months follow-up. No significant difference in complication rate between early and late treatment group.
|
Heiden, JS [5]
|
1975
|
356
|
Retrospective
|
Operated and nonoperated patients with complete and incomplete cervical myelopathies
|
7 days
|
Patients with complete lesions did not benefit from early treatment. Early anterior cervical fusion for patients with complete sensorimotor paralysis was associated with increased pulmonary morbidity.
|
Levi L [17]
|
1991
|
103
|
Retrospective
|
Cervical spine trauma treated with anterior decompression
|
1 day
|
Early surgery associated with shorter hospital stay and fewer respiratory procedures required.
|
Mac-Thiong [13]
|
2012
|
477
|
Retrospective
|
Acute traumatic spinal cord injury at any spinal cord level with evidence of cord compression
|
1 day
|
Early surgery associated with decreased costs and length of stay.
|
Marshall LF [6]
|
1987
|
283
|
Prospective
|
Spinal-cord injured patients
|
5 days
|
Neurological deterioration observed in cervical spine-injured patients undergoing early surgery, but not seen in the late surgery group.
|
Mirza SK [31]
|
1999
|
43
|
Retrospective
|
Acute cervical spinal injury neurologic deficit treated surgically
|
3 days
|
Early vs late surgery not associated with changes in complication rate. Early surgery may improve neurologic recovery.
|
Papadopoulous SM [34]
|
2002
|
91
|
Prospective
|
Acute traumatic spinal cord injury
|
“Immediate”
|
Immediate spinal column stabilization associated with improved neurologic outcome.
|
Pollard ME [18]
|
2003
|
412
|
Retrospective
|
Traumatic incomplete cervical spinal injuries
|
1 day
|
Neurologic recovery not associated with timing of surgery.
|
Sapkas GS [30]
|
2007
|
67
|
Retrospective
|
Fracture and fracture-dislocations at C3-7 treated surgically
|
3 days
|
No statistically significant difference in final neurological outcome between early and late treatment groups.
|
Wagner FC [33]
|
1982
|
44
|
Retrospective
|
Closed cervical spine and spinal cord injury at C3-7
|
2 days
|
Early surgery associated with shorter ICU stay, lower incidence of pulmonary complications, and lower cost of treatment.
|
Vaccaro AR [7]
|
1997
|
123
|
Randomized prospective
|
Traumatic spinal cord injuries at C3-T1
|
Early surgery: 72 hours, late surgery: >5 days
|
No significant difference in length of intensive care stay, improvement in American Spinal Injury Association grade, or motor score.
|