Somatic drivers of B-ALL in a model of ETV6-RUNX1; Pax5^+/− leukemia

Abstract

Background

B-cell precursor acute lymphoblastic leukemia (B-ALL) is amongst the leading causes of childhood cancer-related mortality. Its most common chromosomal aberration is the ETV6-RUNX1 fusion gene, with ~25 % of ETV6-RUNX1 patients also carrying PAX5 alterations.

Methods

We have recreated this mutation background by inter-crossing Etv6-RUNX1 (Etv6^RUNX1-SB) and Pax5^+/− mice and performed an in vivo analysis to find driver genes using Sleeping Beauty transposon-mediated mutagenesis and also exome sequencing.

Results

Combination of Etv6-RUNX1 and Pax5^+/− alleles generated a transplantable B220 + CD19+ B-ALL with a significant disease incidence. RNA-seq analysis showed a gene expression pattern consistent with arrest at the pre-B stage. Analysis of the transposon common insertion sites identified genes involved in B-cell development (Zfp423) and the JAK/STAT signaling pathway (Jak1, Stat5 and Il2rb), while exome sequencing revealed somatic hotspot mutations in Jak1 and Jak3 at residues analogous to those mutated in human leukemias, and also mutation of Trp53.

Conclusions

Powerful synergies exists in our model suggesting STAT pathway activation and mutation of Trp53 are potent drivers of B-ALL in the context of Etv6-RUNX1;Pax5^+/−.

Electronic supplementary material

The online version of this article (doi:10.1186/s12885-015-1586-1) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Background

B-cell precursor acute lymphoblastic leukemia (B-ALL) is the most common childhood tumor [1]. The most common chromosomal rearrangement in B-ALL is the t(12;21)(p13;q22) translocation generating the ETV6-RUNX1 fusion gene [2]. This fusion is necessary but insufficient for the development of B-ALL, as monozygotic twin studies, and the detection of the ETV6-RUNX1 fusion in fetal blood spots from patients who do not go on to develop B-ALL have shown [3, 4].

PAX5, a guardian of B-cell identity and function, is somatically mutated in ~40 % of cases of childhood B-ALL [5]. Moreover, the most common recurrent focal deletion region in ETV6-RUNX1+ tumors involves PAX5 (9p13.2; 25 %) and these deletions are thought to be early events in leukemogenesis [6]. Previously, we generated a knock-in mouse model of ETV6-RUNX1 ALL, in which expression of the fusion gene is driven from the endogenous Etv6 promoter, and is linked to expression of the Sleeping Beauty (SB) transposase allowing the identification of transposon gene mutations that co-operate with Etv6-RUNX1 in leukemia development [7]. Given that PAX5 heterozygosity is a frequent event in ETV6-RUNX1 patients [5], we bred these mice onto a background of Pax5 heterozygosity and performed a SB transposon-mediated mutagenesis screen to explore the profile of co-operating drivers. We coupled this approach with targeted exome sequencing of tumors to find additional mutations, and in particular hotspot mutation events.

Methods

Mouse strains

Generation and genotyping of Etv6-RUNX1, T2Onc [7] and Pax5 [8] mice has been described previously. For secondary bone marrow transplants of tumors, 6–12 week old SCID mice were inoculated with 3.5-5 × 10⁵ bone marrow or spleen cells by tail vein injection. Animal studies were approved by the Home Office UK. Flow cytometric analysis of CD antigen expression was performed on single-cell suspensions from spleen or bone marrow as described previously [7].

Identification and analysis of genes affected by SB mutagenesis

Isolation of the transposon insertion sites and Gaussian kernel convolution statistical methods to identify common insertion sites (CISs) have been described previously [7]. Whole transcriptome sequencing (RNA-seq) was performed on splenic RNA using the mRNA Seq Sample Prep Kit (Illumina, San Diego, CA) to create libraries that were sequenced on the Illumina platform. HTSeq-counts (HTSeq framework; v0.54p5) were used as input to edgeR (v3.4.2). Genes with significant differential expression were defined based on an FDR of 5 %. Pathway and gene set enrichment analysis (GSEA) was performed using Ingenuity Pathway Analysis and GSEA (v2.0.14), respectively.

Exome sequencing and bait design

Spleen (‘tumor’) and tail (‘normal’) genomic DNA were extracted using the Gentra Puregene Cell Kit (Qiagen). Exon-coding sequences of genes previously found to be involved in cancer were captured using custom-designed baits (Additional file 1) and sequenced on an Illumina platform. For each tumor-normal pair, MuTect (v1.14) was used to identify somatic SNVs, which were annotated using the Variant Effect Predictor tool (Ensembl v74). The Jak1, Jak3 and Trp53 mutations were validated by capillary sequencing.

Results and discussion

To perform the SB transposon-mediated mutagenesis screen we intercrossed Pax5 (Pax5^+/−) mice with transposon-carrying T2Onc mice and the resulting offspring were intercrossed with transposase-carrying Etv6-RUNX1 (Etv6^+/RUNX1-SB) mice (Methods). The resulting genotypes in which transposition would occur were Etv6^+/RUNX1-SB, T2Onc^+/Tg, Pax5^+/− (hereafter referred to as ER, Onc, Pax) and Etv6^+/RUNX1-SB, T2Onc^+/Tg mice (hereafter referred to as ER, Onc). Importantly we found that ER, Onc, Pax mice showed a significant increase in the proportion of B-cell precursor (BCP)-ALL cases when compared to ER, Onc mice wildtype for Pax5 (41/159 (26 %) versus 1/37 (3 %); p < 0.005 using a 2-tailed Fisher’s exact test), with 27/41 (66 %) of these cases being B220+ CD19+ (Fig. 1). Additional immunophenotyping of these B220+ CD19+ cells from ER, Onc, Pax mice confirmed their ontogenic arrest at the pre-B stage (consistent with Hardy fraction C’/D and ETV6-RUNX1+ patient leukemic cells; Fig. 1d). Importantly, the leukemias with an almost pure population of B220 + CD19+ cells were also transplantable in SCID mice (with recipients developing B-ALL within 11–55 days; Fig. 1e). RNA-seq analysis performed on 20 B-ALL cases and 6 age-matched control cases (ER, Onc, Pax mice that never developed disease) revealed that 14/34 (41 %) differentially expressed genes were components of canonical B cell development pathways (p = 1.26 × 10⁻⁶; Ingenuity Pathway Analysis), while GSEA revealed a significant enrichment for genes up-regulated in early B-cell development, specifically the pre-B stage (Additional file 2: Figure S1). Perturbation of B-cell homeostasis, in particular a maturation arrest at the pro-/pre-B stage, is a hallmark of human B-ALL [9]. Thus, our mouse model and the human disease show significant similarities, both in terms of differentially expressed genes and the stage of B-cell arrest. Interestingly we did not find that Pax5 heterozygosity accelerated leukemia development (Fig. 1a), suggesting its sole contribution to B-ALL development in our model is at the level of the induction of maturation arrest. This is in contrast to an additional cross we performed in which Etv6^+/RUNX1-SB mice were bred to an Ink4a-deficient background resulting in a significantly decreased latency to leukemogenesis (p = 0.0012 using a Log-rank test; Additional file 3: Figure S2), which is in agreement with reports that INK4A inactivation is associated with an aggressive clinical course in ETV6-RUNX1+ B-ALL [10].

Fig. 1.

Phenotype of Etv6-RUNX1, T2Onc, Pax5 leukemias. a Kaplan-Meier curves showing the tumor latency of ‘jumping’ Etv6^+/RUNX1, T2Onc^+/Tg, Pax5^+/− (ER, Onc, Pax) and Etv6^+/RUNX1, T2Onc^+/Tg (ER, Onc) mice, and ‘non-jumping’ control mice (Onc, Pax and Onc). b The presence of lymphoblasts in the peripheral blood (PB), spleen, bone marrow and liver from a representative mouse with leukemia. Magnification: peripheral blood smear (×400), upper row organs (×400) and lower row organs (×1,000). c Classification of the leukemias developed by mice shown in the Kaplan-Meier curve according to the Bethesda criteria for lymphoid and non-lymphoid murine malignancies. d Upper row: FACS plots from the bone marrow of a representative mouse demonstrate only background Gr-1/Mac-1 myeloid cells, with the majority of cells having a B220+/CD19+/surface Ig-. Middle and lower row: FACS plots from the bone marrow of a representative mouse demonstrate the B220+ cells to have a CD43+, CD127+, AA4.1+, CD24+, BP-1- phenotype. e Survival curves for SCID mice transplanted with 3.5-5 × 10⁵ B220+, CD19+ leukemia cells from ER, Onc, Pax mice and TAPJ23.1a which was an ER, Pax5 mouse. Each color represents a different ‘primary’ leukemia, as indicated by the “TAPJ” name of the mouse (n = 7)

To define common transposon insertion sites (CISs), loci in the genome that have increased clustering of transposon insertion events and hence may contain candidate driver genes, tumor DNAs from the 20 mice that developed B220+ CD19+ B-ALL with a tumour cell fraction >60 % were analysed using 454-based ligand-mediated PCR sequencing [7]. Six statistically significant CISs were identified: Jak1, Stat5b, Zfp423, Il2rb, Cblb and Foxp1 (Fig. 2a). Four of these 6 genes (Zfp423, Cblb, Stat5b and Foxp1) have well-characterised roles in regulating B-cell maturation. Analysis of the RNA-seq data generated from the tumor collection confirmed that insertions in Zfp423, Jak1 and Stat5b resulted in significantly increased expression of these genes (Fig. 2a). Increased ZNF423 expression has been reported in BCP-ALL (revealing a strong association with ETV6-RUNX1+ cases) and elevated expression of this gene has been linked to a B-cell differentiation block [11]. Activation of the JAK/STAT signaling pathway is a frequent theme in hematological malignancies. In fact, increased expression of activated STAT5 is correlated with poor prognosis in ALL patients, and haploinsufficiency of Pax5 or Ebf1 synergize with constitutively expressed STAT5 to induce B-ALL [12]. Somatic mutations of CBL/CBLB in B-ALL typically involve small deletions affecting the intron/exon boundaries of exon 8, leading to skipping of this exon and the abolition of E3 ligase function; the transposon insertions in Cblb were in intron 8 and thus are likely to function via a similar mechanism [13]. Mutation of CBL is an alternative route to activate the RAS pathway [13], and mutations in RAS have been reported in hyperdiploidy BCP-ALL and ETV6-RUNX1+ cases [14]. Thus, our Etv6-RUNX1; Pax5^+/− mouse model has several cardinal genetic features associated with B-ALL.

Fig. 2.

Common insertion site and somatic mutation analysis of BCP-ALL cases in Etv6-RUNX1, T2Onc, Pax5 mice. a Transposon common insertion sites (CIS) in B-ALL cases. All CIS shown have a genome-wide p value of <0.025. Alterations in expression levels were determined using RNA-seq data (from 20 ER, Onc, Pax mice that developed B220+, CD19+ BCP-ALL and 8 age-matched ‘control’ ER, Onc, Pax mice that never developed disease), whereby the expression level of a gene in BCP-ALL cases containing insertions in a particular CIS was compared to the expression level of that gene in ‘control’ cases. FC, log fold change; FDR, false discovery rate (significance was assessed at an FDR of 5 %). b Acquired somatic events in B-ALL cases in ER, Onc, Pax mice. Each column represents a sample (individual mouse). Red indicates a stop mutation, brown indicates a splice acceptor variant, yellow indicates a splice region variant (intron) and blue indicates a missense variant. c The fraction of reads (expressed as a percentage) reporting the somatic variant alleles shown in b (in the same order as shown in b). d Schematic diagram of the protein structure of Jak1 and Jak3, showing the locations of the mutations identified in this study. FERM, band 4.1 ezrin; SH2, src-homology domain. e Somatically acquired mutations in Jak1/3 found in ER, Onc, Pax B-ALL tumors in which the corresponding JAK1/3 mutations have been found in human cancers. AA, amino acid. ^*These mutations have been shown to have gain-of-function and/or transforming activity. ^**These cases were pediatric high-risk B-cell progenitor ALL excluding BCR-ABL1+ ALL and hypodiploid ALL. ^***Acute megakaryoblastic leukemia of Down syndrome. ^****An AML with t(15;17)(q22;q12)

Interestingly an Etv6+/RUNX1-SB, T2Onc^+/+, Pax5^+/− mouse (TAPJ23.1a), in which transposition was not occuring, developed transplantable B-ALL (Fig. 1e), suggesting a contribution of background somatic mutations to tumor development leading us to investigate the somatic mutation landscape by targeted exome sequencing of 404 established cancer genes and candidate B-ALL drivers in 17 B220 + CD19+ B-ALL cases (Fig. 2b; Additional file 1). Strikingly the most commonly mutated genes were Jak3 (6/17 mice, 35 %), Trp53 (4/17 mice, 23 %) and Jak1 (2/17 mice, 11 %) with the missense mutations in Jak1/3 predominantly located in the pseudokinase domain (Fig. 2d). This domain has been demonstrated to exert an important negative regulatory function on the kinase domain [15] with many of the amino acid changes we identified falling into positions of JAK1/3 reported as being mutated in human leukemias, and shown to confer gain-of-function or transforming activity (Fig. 2e) [16–18]. Somatic mutations in JAK1 and JAK3 and have been reported in adult B-ALL [19] and high-risk/poor prognosis pediatric B-ALL [20], respectively. The variant allele frequency of Jak1/3 mutations was around 25 % suggesting that cells with these mutations represent a major clonal fraction (Fig. 2c). Recurrent somatic mutations in Jak1/3 have recently been reported in B-ALL tumors from Pax5^+/- mice [PMID: 25855603], suggesting that the synergy with Jak mutations in our model is a result of the knockout allele for Pax5 rather than the presence of the Etv6-RUNX1 allele. We also observed somatic Trp53 mutations in our mouse tumors with copy number and/or sequence alterations of p53 being an independent risk predictor of inferior outcome/high risk of treatment failure in B-ALL patients [21, 22].

Conclusions

Collectively, our findings support a model in which multiple small defects in a network of factors that regulate B-cell maturation (such as Pax5, Cblb, Zfp423, Foxp1, and Stat5b) together with activation/inactivation of oncogenes/tumor suppressor genes (such as the JAK/STAT signaling pathway and p53) cooperate with Etv6-RUNX1; Pax5^+/− to result in the development B-ALL. Our transplantable B-ALL tumors represent a novel tool for assessing potential therapeutic intervention strategies in cases of high risk/poor outcome B-ALL.

Additional files

Additional file 1: ^{(53.3KB, xlsx)}

List of targeted exome baits. The file contains a list of genes that were captured as part of the targeted exome sequencing performed as part of this study. (XLSX 53 kb)

Additional file 2: Figure S1. ^{(166KB, ppt)}

Pathway analysis showing enrichment for genes involved in early B-cell function in our model. (PPT 166 kb)

Additional file 3: Figure S2. ^{(162.5KB, ppt)}

Accelerated tumor development in Ink4a^−/−; Etv6^+/RUNX1-SB mice. (PPT 162 kb)