Asymmetry in CT Scan Measures of Thigh Muscle 2 Months After Hip Fracture: The Baltimore Hip Studies

Abstract

Background.

Hip fracture is an important problem for older adults with significant functional consequences. After hip fracture, reduced muscle loading can result in muscle atrophy.

Methods.

We compared thigh muscle characteristics in the fractured leg to those in the nonfractured leg in participants from the Baltimore Hip Studies 7th cohort using computed tomography scan imaging.

Results.

At 2 months postfracture, a single 10mm axial computed tomography scan was obtained at the midthigh level in 43 participants (23 men, 20 women) with a mean age of 79.9 years (range: 65–96 years), and thigh muscle cross-sectional area, cross-sectional area of intermuscular adipose tissue, and mean radiologic attenuation were measured. Total thigh muscle cross-sectional area was less on the side of the fracture by 9.46cm² (95% CI: 5.97cm², 12.95cm²) while the cross-sectional area of intermuscular adipose tissue was greater by 2.97cm² (95% CI: 1.94cm², 4.01cm²) on the fractured side. Mean muscle attenuation was lower on the side of the fracture by 3.66 Hounsfield Units (95% CI: 2.98 Hounsfield Units, 4.34 Hounsfield Units).

Conclusions.

The observed asymmetry is consistent with the effect of disuse and inflammation in the affected limb along with training effects in the unaffected limb due to the favoring of this leg with ambulation during the postfracture period.

Hip fracture is a major public health problem that results in significant burden to the health care system. More than 340,000 persons older than 65 years of age fracture a hip in the United States annually (1), and this number is expected to double by 2040 (2). Therefore, hip fracture is and will continue to be a significant burden on the health care system (3). A hip fracture event also has significant consequences for older patients and their families and often heralds a period of increased functional decline and disability (4,5).

Following a hip fracture, there is a sudden loss of physical function (as measured by ability to walk independently and walking speed) followed by a period of recovery that can continue for a year or more depending on the area of function examined (4). Half of those individuals who previously had been able to walk independently before their fracture are still not able to to do so 1 year after fracture (4,6). The duration of disability extends beyond that required for fracture healing, implying that the hip fracture event may trigger other adverse consequences that result in disability.

After hip fracture, reduced muscle loading secondary to pain and functional loss can result in muscle atrophy. Additionally, the increased energy demand due to the stress of surgery and healing, coupled with catabolism caused by the postinjury proinflammatory state, further increases the risk of muscle protein loss (7–9). Loss of muscle mass and declines in muscle quality may be important mechanisms that impede functional recovery after hip fracture and negatively affect function long after the fracture event. One study found that total body lean mass decreased by 6% in the first 2 months after a hip fracture while fat mass increased by 3.6% in the year following fracture (10). However, little research has examined how specific muscles are affected. Recent work has suggested that loss of muscle mass does not fully explain the decreased muscle strength seen with advanced age (11), with disproportionally larger declines seen in muscle strength than in loss of muscle mass (12). Measures of lower-extremity muscle composition may provide greater insights into the pathways through which hip fracture results in functional decline.

Computed tomography (CT) has been used extensively to characterize both the size and composition of skeletal muscle. The extent of radiological attenuation or “radio-density” is generally considered to result from lipid accumulation and has been extensively used as a radiologic proxy for muscle composition characteristics, including intramuscular fat infiltration (13,14). Indeed, higher muscle attenuation on CT scan imaging correlates with lower intramuscular fat content and greater muscle strength, independent of muscle mass (13).

We compared thigh muscle characteristics in the fractured leg to those in the nonfractured leg in older men and women, 2 months following hip fracture, in a cohort from the Baltimore Hip Studies. We hypothesized that compared to the nonfractured leg, there would be lower muscle cross-sectional area (CSA) and greater fat infiltration in the thigh musculature on the side of the fracture.

Methods

Parent Study

Study data were obtained from the Baltimore Hip Studies 7th cohort (BHS-7), a prospective cohort study that is being carried out in eight hospitals that participate in the BHS hospital network. Details of this study can be found elsewhere (15). Briefly, the goal of the parent BHS-7 study is to examine the metabolic, physiologic, neuromuscular, functional, and clinical consequences of hip fracture in both men and women.

Patients were eligible if they were aged 65 years or older and admitted to one of the study hospitals during the study period with a diagnosis of hip fracture (ICD-9 codes 820.00–820.9). Patients were excluded if they had a pathologic fracture, were not community dwelling at the time of the fracture, were non–English-speaking, were bedbound during the 6 months prior to the fracture, required human assistance with ambulation prior to the fracture, resided more than 70 miles from the hospital, weighed more than 300 pounds, did not undergo surgical repair, or had any hardware in the contralateral hip (either due to hip fracture or hip replacement) thereby leaving no unaffected hip for bone density scanning purposes. Participants were assessed at baseline (within 22 days of hospital admission) and 2 months postadmission.

Protocols for the two studies were reviewed and approved by the University of Maryland institutional review board and the review boards of participating hospitals.

Baseline Measures

Information regarding prefracture medical comorbidities, fracture type, and surgical repair was obtained by review of medical charts. Prefracture comorbid disease information was used to calculate the Charlson comorbidity index (16).

At the baseline visit, weight was measured using the same standard scale in all participants. Knee height was measured to the nearest 0.1cm in the left leg using a sliding caliper, and stature was estimated from the knee height measurement using the method of Chumlea and coworkers (17). Information on participant demographics was obtained at the baseline evaluation by patient self-report or proxy interviews.

CT Scan Measures

As part of an ancillary study to BHS-7, CT scans of the midthigh are being obtained at 2 months postfracture. All participants who were enrolled in the parent study and who had not died, dropped out, or been lost to follow-up by the 2-month follow-up visit were eligible for enrollment in the ancillary study. Participants were excluded if they were unable to lie supine for the CT scan or had cognitive impairment preventing them from being left alone during the CT scan. One hundred thirty-five participants in the BHS-7 study were screened for participation in the ancillary study; of these, 67 (49.6%) were determined to be eligible 50 of whom (74.6% of eligible participants) agreed to participate in the ancillary study.

Two participants failed to provide data at the baseline measurement (2 month postadmission). An additional five participants were subsequently withdrawn from this ancillary study due to an institutional review board–requested postprocedure audit of the parent study (three participants were found to be ineligible and two due to issues related to the informed consent process). The 43 remaining participants who provided CT scan data are included in these analyses.

A single 10-mm axial CT scan (Philips Brilliance 64 CT scanner; Phillips Electronics N.V. Eindhoven, The Netherlands) was obtained at the midthigh level on each participant at the time of the 2-month evaluation (18). All images were analyzed by one person. Thigh muscle CSA was quantified using SliceOmatic software version 3 (Tomovision, Montréal, Canada). Intermuscular adipose tissue was distinguished from the subcutaneous adipose tissue by manually drawing a line along the deep fascial plane surrounding the thigh muscles. Once the adipose tissue was segmented from the images, individual muscles were identified. Skeletal muscle attenuation was measured for each muscle as the mean attenuation value between 0 and 100 Hounsfield Units as a marker of skeletal muscle lipid content (13,18). Muscle CSA and muscle attenuation were quantified for all the muscles of the thigh, a majority of which are the quadriceps and hamstring muscles.

Analyses

Study participant data are presented as the mean and range. Paired sample t tests were performed to compare the fractured to the nonfractured legs. All analyses were performed using the statistical package SAS (SAS institute, Cary, NC).

Results

Data on 43 participants (23 men, 20 women) at 2 months after hip fracture are presented. Participant characteristics are presented in Table 1. Mean age was 79.9 years (range: 65–96 years). The majority of participants (n = 34) were either married or widowed. Fifteen participants (34.9%) had a high school diploma, while 19 (44.2%) had more than 12 years of formal education, and 9 individuals (20.9%) had less. Mean prefracture Charlson comorbidity index score was 2.53 (range: 0.0 to 8.0) suggesting a moderate comorbid disease burden.

Table 1.

Baseline Characteristics of Hip-Fracture Study Participants Who Received CT Scans of the Midthigh at 2 Mo After Fracture (N = 43)*

	Mean (range) or N (%)
Age, mean (range)	79.9 (65–96)
Male, N (%)	23 (53.5)
BMI (kg/m2), mean (range)	26.3 (20.4–38.2)
Charlson comorbidity index mean (range)	2.5 (0.0–8.0)
Marital status
Never married	5 (11.6)
Married	20 (46.5)
Widowed	14(32.6)
Divorced	4 (9.3)
Ethnicity†
White	38 (86.4)
African American	4 (9.1)
Other	2 (4.5)
Education (y)
≤12	9 (20.9)
12	15 (34.9)
>12	19 (44.2)
Fracture type
Subcapital	13 (30.2)
Trochanteric	24 (55.8)
Other	6 (14.0)
Surgical repair
Hemi-arthroplasty/arthroplasty	17 (39.5)
Internal fixation	25 (58.1)

Notes: CT = computed tomography; BMI = body mass index.

*Totals may be less than 43 due to the missing data.

^†Study participants may have identified with more than one ethnic group.

At 2 months postfracture (Table 2), on the side of the fracture, the thigh CSA was smaller by 9.46cm² (95% CI: 5.97, 12.95cm²), the CSA of intermuscular adipose tissue was greater by 2.97cm² (95% CI: 1.94, 4.01cm²), and the overall muscle attenuation was lower by 3.66 Hounsfield Units (95% CI: 2.98 Hounsfield Units, 4.34 Hounsfield Units).

Table 2.

CT-Scan Measurements of Thigh Muscle at 2 Mo Post–Hip Fracture (N = 43)*

	Fractured Leg	Nonfractured Leg	Difference†
Total thigh cross-sectional area (cm2)	74.80 (69.31, 80.29)	84.26 (77.43, 91.10)	−9.46 (−12.95, −5.97)
Cross-sectional area of intermuscular adipose tissue (cm2)	14.78 (13.09, 16.47)	11.95 (10.66, 13.24)	2.97 (1.94, 4.01)
Attenuation (Hu)	35. 87 (34.53, 37.21)	39.53 (38.14, 40.92)	−3.66 (−4.34, −2.98)

Notes: CT = computed tomography.

*Mean (95% CI).

^†Values in the fractured leg minus those in the non-fractured leg.

Discussion

Atrophy and replacement of muscle with adipose tissue is a well-described phenomenon of aging, and CT scan–based measures of thigh muscle composition has previously been examined in nondisabled older men and women (19,20). Compared to the data from these studies in nondisabled elderly, hip fracture patients appear to have lower mean thigh muscle CSA, in either leg, than nondisabled elderly, with similar muscle attenuation (19,20). Although muscle atrophy and replacement of muscle by adipose tissue may occur with aging, such changes may be accelerated by the decreased loading of thigh muscles resulting from pain and disability that occurs early on in hip fracture recovery. Results of the current analysis demonstrate lower muscle area, lower mean muscle attenuation, and greater intermuscular fat in the fractured compared to the nonfractured legs. To our knowledge, this is the first study to examine thigh muscle composition in hip fracture patients using CT scanning and the first study to demonstrate asymmetry in measures of thigh muscle between the fractured and nonfractured leg.

In addition to decline in the lean mass that has been seen following hip fracture (10), changes in muscle composition may also have important functional consequences in this frail population of older adults and may help to further explain the profound functional declines seen following hip fracture (5). Greater muscle attenuation on CT scan imaging reflects lower intramuscular fat content and is positively associated with muscle strength, independent of muscle mass (13). It is muscle strength rather than muscle mass that is believed to be important for function in older adults, including those recovering from hip fracture (20–22). Thus, the changes in muscle composition observed here of decreased lean muscle mass and increased fat in and around the muscle in the fractured leg may explain some of these adverse functional consequences in this population.

The differences in the fractured and nonfractured legs may be explained by the physiologic response to the initial injury of hip fracture and surgical repair, as well as postfracture disuse of the affected leg due to functional loss and pain (23,24). Following trauma such as hip fracture and hip fracture surgery, there is an inflammatory response in order to initiate healing through the recruitment of immune and inflammatory cells to the site of injury (25). These cells are instrumental in the orchestration of cell movement necessary for wound repair. Tumor necrosis factor alpha, a key cytokine in this process (26), also induces muscle catabolism and cachexia (8). The inflammatory response following injury may therefore contribute to the observed asymmetry between the affected and unaffected limbs (27). Inflammation following surgical trauma and hip fracture has been observed to be associated with an adverse effect on recovery (7,28). Pain, which is also mediated by inflammatory cytokines, is an important aspect of postinjury recovery (29).

The decreased weight bearing resulting from favoring the unaffected leg in ambulation during the post hip-fracture period may also explain the differences between the affected and unaffected leg that we observed at 2 months post hip-fracture repair, since muscle disuse resulting from the removal of weight bearing can lead to decreased protein synthesis and increased protein degradation (30). In contrast, the favoring of the unaffected leg in ambulation could lead to an increase in muscle volume and a decrease in adipose tissue content, due to a training effect, further increasing the asymmetry between the two limbs (31). Asymmetrical lower limb loading may persist beyond the 2-month time-point examined here. In one cross-sectional study, distal leg loading, knee extension strength, and calf muscle CSA were found to be lower on the fractured leg in older adults who were on average 3.5 years post hip fracture in one cross-sectional study (32). If measures of lower extremity muscle composition are associated with function in older adults, then this persistent asymmetry in lower limb musculature may help to explain the functional declines seen in hip fracture patients (5). A longitudinal analysis of thigh musculature using the CT scan data from the BHS-7 cohort may help identify factors associated with a persistence of thigh muscle asymmetry in hip fracture patients and the importance of this asymmetry to postfracture recovery.

Although these results are interesting, they should be viewed with the following limitations in mind. The analyses presented here are cross-sectional, and, therefore, we are unable to determine the direction of the association. Although we have speculated that disuse of the affected limb following hip fracture may explain the observed association, due to the cross-sectional nature of the analyses, we are unable to exclude that the observed asymmetry did not exist prior to the fracture, perhaps resulting from gait asymmetry that may have contributed to a fall and hip fracture.

In conclusion, at 2 months post hip-fracture repair, older men and women demonstrated lower muscle attenuation and greater intermuscular fat in the fractured compared to the nonfractured legs, on CT scan imaging. These changes are consistent with atrophy and replacement of muscle with fatty tissue and may be a result of decreased muscle use, inflammation, or both in the year postfracture. Future studies will better evaluate the processes that explain these changes and their influence on recovery of lower extremity function in the year following hip fracture. A better understanding of these processes may have implications not only for the care of hip fracture patients but may also aid in the understanding of the processes that underlie functional decline in frail and sarcopenic older adults in general.

Funding

This research was supported by grants from the National Institute on Aging (K23AG027746, R37 AG09901, R01 AG029315, and P30 AG028747).