The stats are in: an update on statin use in COPD

Abstract

COPD is a chronic inflammatory disease of the lungs associated with an abnormal inflammatory response to noxious particles, the most prevalent of which is cigarette smoke. Studies have demonstrated that cigarette smoking is associated with activation of the bone marrow, and chronic smoking can lead to the inflammatory changes seen in COPD. Due to the inflammatory nature of the disease, medications affecting the inflammatory pathway may have clinical benefit and are being evaluated. One such class of medications, HMG-CoA reductase inhibitors, have been evaluated in the COPD population. Early studies have suggested that HMG-CoA reductase inhibitors have a variety of benefits in COPD including improvements in inflammatory markers, exacerbation rates, and mortality rates. However, the majority of this data comes from retrospective cohort studies, suggesting the need for randomized controlled trials. Recently, two randomized controlled trials, STATCOPE and RODEO, evaluated the benefit of HMG-CoA reductase inhibitors in the COPD population and found no benefit in exacerbation rates and vascular or pulmonary function, respectively. These results are reflected in practice guidelines, which do not support the use of HMG-CoA reductase inhibitors for the purpose of reducing COPD exacerbations.

Introduction

COPD is a chronic respiratory condition associated with enhanced inflammatory response of the airways to noxious particles,¹ the most prominent of which is cigarette smoke. Cigarette smoking has been associated with contribution to the inflammatory response in the lungs and resultant stimulation of the bone marrow. A study by van Eeden and Hogg² sought to assess the effects of smoking on the bone marrow amongst 38 adult smokers and 15 matched controls. Compared to the control group, the smoking group had a higher mean total leukocyte (P=0.001), polymorphonuclear leukocyte (P=0.003), and band (P=0.01) count. This increase in polymorphonuclear leukocytes and bands, along with elevated levels of l-selectin, an adhesion molecule, and MPO, an enzyme found in the circulating polymorphonuclear cells in the smoking population compared to the control population (P<0.05 for both), demonstrates bone marrow stimulation in response to chronic smoking.² Similar results demonstrating inflammation have been reported elsewhere.³ Persistent use of cigarettes over time can lead to a chronic inflammatory response in COPD.⁴ This inflammatory response leads to the long-term physiologic changes seen in COPD.^1,5–11 By measuring CRP and IL-6 values of 983 subjects in Iceland, Thorleifsson et al found both values to be independently related to lower forced vital capacity and forced expiratory volume in 1 second values. Both inflammatory markers were also found to be associated with smoking pack-years, further supporting that chronic smoking and COPD result from inflammatory processes.¹² This association of elevated inflammatory mediators in COPD has been found in a number of other studies.^13–16 Systemic inflammation becomes important as elevated plasma CRP has been associated with increased cardiovascular risk¹⁷ thereby supporting systemic inflammation as a potential focus of treatment.

Anti-inflammatory effects of HMG-CoA reductase inhibitors

Due to the inflammatory nature of COPD, medications targeting the inflammatory process should have a theoretical benefit. One such class of medication, the HMG-CoA reductase inhibitors, or statins, are primarily utilized for the management of lipid and cardiovascular disorders. Statins have also been shown to have pleiotropic and anti-inflammatory properties which have demonstrated benefits in a number of disease states including but not limited to those of infectious,¹⁸ cardiovascular,^17,19–23 and pulmonary origin.²⁴ Some proposed mechanisms behind this effect include interference with cellular adhesion²⁵ and proliferation,²⁴ increased apoptosis,²⁶ and alteration of cytokine release.²⁷ Multiple studies in cardiovascular patients have demonstrated the ability of statins in reducing inflammatory mediators like CRP, independent of the lipid lowering potential further supporting their potential use in inflammatory based diseases.^17,19–23 Similar to cardiovascular trials, in a randomized, double-blind, parallel group study in patients with COPD, Lee et al noted a reduction in CRP and IL-6 in patients treated with pravastatin compared to placebo, indicating the possibility for a role in modulating the inflammatory process of COPD.²⁸ Initial trials of statins in COPD patients suggest potential benefit; however, many of the trials were retrospective in nature and did not address major outcome measures, such as hospitalization rates or mortality, indicating the need for further evaluation.²⁴ The potential role of HMG-CoA reductase inhibitors in COPD is reviewed in this article.

Data selection

A search of MEDLINE was performed using the search terms chronic obstructive pulmonary disease [drug therapy] and HMG-CoA reductase inhibitor [therapeutic use], from the time period January 2009 through May 2015, and limited to the English language and humans, to identify relevant literature. References from each identified article were also reviewed for applicable articles. Studies selected for inclusion in this review were randomized controlled, observational cohort, case-controlled, and population-based analyses that included major outcome measures. Laboratory based studies were excluded.

Retrospective studies and epidemiologic surveys

Since 2009, several observational and epidemiological studies evaluating statin use in patients with COPD have been published and are summarized in Table 1. Bando et al conducted an epidemiological cross-sectional study in Japan between 2007 and 2008 which included 853 patients. Patients greater than 40 years of age who regularly visited one of the 16 participating primary health care facilities were included in this investigation. Participants were defined as either statin users or statin non-users. The outcome of interest in each cohort was airflow limitation defined as forced expiratory volume in 1 second/forced vital capacity <70%. Prevalence of airflow limitation was 2.25% in the statin use cohort compared to 10.5% in the statin non-use cohort (P=0.01). Upon multivariate analysis to address potential confounding variables, the odds ratio for statin use as factor of airflow limitation was 0.28 (0.06–1.28). Ultimately the authors concluded that although airflow limitation was five times lower in the statin use cohort, the decrease in airflow limitation was not directly attributable to the potential disease modifying effects of statins.²⁹

Table 1.

Summary of statins in COPD retrospective trials and epidemiologic surveys

Trial	Study design	Patient characteristics	Outcomes
Bando et al29	Cross-sectional study	All Japanese outpatients >40 years old who regularly visited a participating primary health care facility n=853	Airflow limitation prevalence 2.25% in statin users vs 10.5% in non-users (P=0.01) Adjusted OR 0.28 (95% CI 0.06–1.28; P=0.101)
Lawes et al30	Population-based cohort	Patients 50–80 years old with hospitalization for COPD in New Zealand n=1,687 patients; 596 in statin group and 1,091 in non-statin group	242 deaths (40.6%) in statin users vs 429 (39.3%) in non-users Adjusted HR 0.69, (95% CI 0.58–0.84)
Sheng et al31	Population-based cohort	Patients with a diagnosis of COPD in Scotland Primary cardiovascular prevention cohort =1,274 patients; 617 in statin group and 657 in statin-unexposed group. Secondary cardiovascular prevention cohort =443 patients; 292 in the statin group and 151 in the statin-unexposed group	39% reduction in all-cause mortality in primary prevention statin users HR 0.61 (95% CI 0.43–0.85) 42% reduction in all-cause mortality in secondary prevention statin users HR 0.58 (95% CI 0.43–0.85)
Wang et al32	Retrospective nested case-control	All patients aged >45 years with two or more COPD-related outpatient visits that involved at least two COPD medications 14,316 patients resulting in 1,584 cases of hospitalization for ECOPD and 5,950 matched controls	Any use of statins is associated with a 30% reduction in exacerbations OR 0.70 (95% CI 0.56–0.88; P<0.05)
Ho et al33	Retrospective, population-based cohort	All patients who had been hospitalized for COPD exacerbations based on ICD-9 codes for COPD or pneumonia with secondary diagnosis of COPD n=4,204; 288 taking statins at enrollment	1 year mortality with statin use HR 0.33 (95% CI 0.47–0.91; P=0.013)
Ingebrigtsen et al34	Nested case-control	5,794 patients >40 years old diagnosed with COPD per GOLD criteria and a CRP measurement 530 cases with exacerbations matched to 1,016 controls	Statin use associated with reduced OR of exacerbation on univariate screen OR 0.68 (95% CI 0.51–0.91; P=0.01); multivariate logistic regression demonstrated OR 0.67 (95% CI 0.48–0.92; P=0.01); in the subgroup with the most severe COPD and no cardiovascular comorbidity, there was no difference; statin use also was associated with decreased CRP OR 0.69 (95% CI 0.56–0.85; P<0.001) and CRP was associated with increased risk of ECOPD HR 1.62 (95% CI 1.35–1.94; P<0.001)

Abbreviations: ECOPD, exacerbations of COPD; GOLD, Global Initiative for Chronic Obstructive Lung Disease; OR, odds ratio; HR, hazard ratio; CI, confidence interval; ICD-9, International Classification of Diseases, Ninth Revision; CRP, C-reactive protein.

Lawes et al performed a population-based cohort study utilizing national data in New Zealand. A total of 1,687 patients aged 50–80 years admitted to a hospital with a COPD event were included. Groups were based on statin use prior to hospitalization and included 596 statin users and 1,091 non-statin users. The majority of statin users (91%) were prescribed simvastatin, with atorvastatin prescribed in the remaining 9%. As with other observational studies, accurate data on statin dose and duration of treatment were not available. Time to death from any cause over a 4-year follow-up from hospital discharge was the outcome of interest. Proportion of deaths was similar with 242 deaths (40.6%) in the statin group and 429 (39.3%) in the non-statin group. After adjusting for confounders using Cox’s proportional hazards model, the hazard ratio (HR) of 0.69 (95% confidence interval [CI] 0.58–0.84) favored statin use.³⁰

Another observational study was conducted in Scotland by Sheng et al who used several linked databases to identify patients with a diagnosis of COPD and at least two total cholesterol measurements. Patients were classified into two cohorts, primary and secondary prevention of cardiovascular events. The primary prevention cohort included 1,274 patients, 617 in the statin group and 657 in the non-statin group. The secondary prevention cohort included 443 patients of which 292 were statin-treated and 151 were not. In the primary prevention cohort, association between statin use and cardiovascular events was not statistically significant. Statin use was associated with a 39% reduction in all-cause mortality (HR 0.61, 95% CI 0.43–0.85). In the secondary prevention cohort, statin use was associated with a 65% reduction in cardiovascular events (HR 0.35, 95% CI 0.15–0.87). Statin use also reduced risk for all-cause mortality by 42% (HR 0.58, 95% CI 0.35–0.97). The authors concluded that statins improve all-cause mortality, but are not protective for primary prevention of cardiovascular events and death.³¹

A retrospective nested case-control study, using data from a Taiwan health insurance database, was conducted by Wang et al. Of 14,316 patients greater than 45 years old with COPD and two or more COPD-related outpatient visits and two or more COPD-related medications within 1 year, 1,584 cases with hospitalization for COPD exacerbation were matched to 5,950 controls. Statins, including atorvastatin, simvastatin, lovastatin, and fluvastatin, were prescribed in 9% of cases and 12.3% of controls. After multivariate logistic regression analysis, risk of COPD exacerbation requiring hospitalization was reduced 30% in patients with any use of statins (odds ratio [OR] 0.70, 95% CI 0.56–0.88, P<0.05). When stratified by statin dose and duration, the risk was not decreased with increasing duration of statin use, but risk decreased in a dose-dependent manner. Smoking status was not measured, however sensitivity analyses suggest it was unlikely to confound the results.³²

In one of the most recent investigations, published in 2014, Ho et al using a retrospective, population-based cohort, sought to determine if statin use was associated with decreased mortality during hospitalization for COPD exacerbation and at 1 year after hospitalization. Patients were selected from the Longitudinal Health Insurance Database of Taiwan from 2005 to 2007 and followed until the end of 2008. All patients hospitalized for COPD exacerbations based on International Classification of Diseases, Ninth Revision (ICD-9) codes for COPD, or ICD-9 codes for pneumonia with a secondary diagnosis of COPD, were included. Of the 4,204 patients studied, 288 patients were taking statin medications at the time of hospitalization. Statin use was not a predictor of decreased in-hospital mortality based on multivariate analysis; however, 322 patients were receiving statins by hospital discharge and statin use was associated with increased survival at 1 year (HR 0.33 [0.47–0.91]). Based on the results of this investigation, the authors concluded that statins may have a dual cardiopulmonary protective effect and likely improve outcomes for patients with severe COPD exacerbations.³³

In the most recent investigation assessing statin use in COPD, Ingebrigtsen et al in a nested case control consisting of 5,794 individuals, matched 530 patients with COPD exacerbation to 1,016 controls. The outcome of interest, exacerbation of COPD, after multivariate logistic regression analysis, occurred less frequently in patients taking statins OR 0.67 (0.48–0.92). However, there was no benefit to statin use in the subgroup with the most severe COPD and no cardiovascular co-morbidity. Additionally, statin use was associated with a reduction in CRP, OR 0.69 (0.56–0.85) and CRP was associated with an increased risk of COPD exacerbation, HR 1.62 (1.35–1.94). Based on this data, the authors concluded that statin use was in fact associated with a reduced risk of COPD exacerbation; however, based on the subgroup analysis, this benefit is likely to be seen only in patients with COPD in the setting of co-morbid cardiovascular disease.³⁴

Prospective and randomized clinical trials

One of the few prospective studies examining the role of statins in COPD was conducted by Bartziokas et al and published in 2011. All consecutive patients admitted to either of two tertiary hospitals with a diagnosis of COPD exacerbation, as defined by the Global Initiative for Chronic Obstructive Lung Disease (GOLD) guidelines, were eligible for inclusion. Patients were stratified based on statin use vs statin non-use and followed for 1 year. During this period, 30-day and 1-year mortality did not differ between groups. However, exacerbations of COPD (ECOPD) were less frequent in patients taking statins compared to those not taking statins (2.1±2.7 vs 2.8±3.2 ECOPD/patient respectively; P=0.037). Additionally, the use of statins prolonged the time to next ECOPD (HR 0.656 [0.454–0.946]) and next severe ECOPD (HR 0.608 [0.381–0.972]), even after proper adjustments for significant confounders. Finally, the use of statins was related to a more profound improvement in health related quality of life at 2, 6, and 12 months after discharge (P<0.001).³⁵

In the largest population-based cohort to date, statin use was associated with a lower risk of COPD-related hospitalization compared to statin non-use. Huang et al matched 6,252 newly diagnosed COPD patients receiving statins for hyperlipidemia to 12,469 newly diagnosed COPD patients not taking statin medications. Diagnosis and study inclusion were based on ICD-9 codes corresponding with COPD of any disease severity. The outcome of interest was hospitalization with a principle diagnosis of COPD exacerbation, based on ICD-9 code. During an average follow-up of 4.58 years, 508 (8.1%) statin-treated patients were hospitalized compared to 1,324 (10.6%) patients from the control group. After adjusting for differences in baseline characteristics, statin use was associated with a decreased risk of hospitalization for COPD-related complications (HR 0.66 [0.60–0.74]).³⁶

Lahousse et al performed a prospective nested case control analysis using data from the Rotterdam Study, a population-based cohort study conducted in the Netherlands. From a population of 7,983 individuals, 363 patients with COPD who died during follow-up were matched to 2,345 controls. Risk of all-cause mortality was stratified according to statin use and baseline serum level of CRP. After adjusting for confounders using conditional logistic regression, there was a 39% reduced risk of all-cause mortality when statins were used longer than 2 years (OR 0.61, 95% CI 0.38–0.99, P=0.045). Further reduction was seen in the long-term statin group when baseline CRP was greater than 3 mg/L (OR 0.22, 95% CI 0.06–0.74, P=0.015). This finding suggests that statin therapy may be most effective in those with evidence of increased systemic inflammation.³⁷

STATCOPE was the largest, prospective clinical trial designed to elucidate if statin therapy reduced exacerbations in patients with moderate to severe COPD as defined by the GOLD guidelines. Eight hundred and fifty-five patients not requiring statin therapy for other indications were enrolled, 433 of whom received simvastatin 40 mg daily and 452 of whom received matching placebo. The mean number of exacerbations per person-year was 1.36±1.61 in the simvastatin group compared to 1.39±1.73 in the placebo group (P=0.54). Similarly, time to first exacerbation showed no statistical difference between the simvastatin and placebo groups, 223 (95% CI, 195–275) days and 231 (95% CI, 193–303) days respectively. Due to futility in terms of minimal to no differences in number of exacerbations per person-year and time to first exacerbation, as well as severity of exacerbation, number of acute cardiovascular events, quality of life and changes in spirometric variables, STATCOPE was stopped early after 43 months of follow-up. Ultimately the authors concluded that simvastatin had little treatment effect in reducing COPD exacerbations. Notably, the dose of simvastatin used in this trial may have been insufficient to produce significant anti-inflammatory effects and may explain the differences in treatment effect observed in STATCOPE compared to multiple retrospective investigations.³⁸

Another randomized, controlled trial, RODEO, was conducted by Neukamm et al to determine whether treatment with rosuvastatin improved vascular function in patients with COPD in the absence of standard indications for statin therapy. Patients with diabetes, history of coronary artery disease, cerebrovascular and peripheral vascular disease were excluded. Ninety-nine patients were randomized, the majority of whom were considered low risk for cardiovascular disease; 49 received rosuvastatin 10 mg daily and 50 received daily matching placebo for 12 weeks. No significant changes from baseline in vascular function or pulmonary function were observed. Secondary outcomes were changes from baseline of inflammatory markers CRP and IL-6, of which significant improvement was seen in the rosuvastatin group. The authors concluded that short-term treatment with rosuvastatin in patients with stable COPD did not improve vascular function or pulmonary function, but did reduce CRP levels and attenuate the rise of IL-6. As with the STATCOPE study, the statin dose used may have been too low to produce significant anti-inflammatory effects and the length of treatment was likely too short to produce a demonstrable effect on clinical outcomes.³⁹ The summary of the prospective and randomized clinical trials^35–39 can found in Table 2.

Table 2.

Summary of statins in COPD prospective and randomized clinical trials

Trial	Study design	Patient characteristics	Comparison	Outcomes
Bartziokas et al35	Prospective observational	All consecutive patients admitted to either of two tertiary hospitals with diagnosis of COPD exacerbation according to GOLD definition. All current or former smokers with 20 pack year history and previous diagnosis of COPD	Statin use vs non-use	No difference in 30-day or 1-year mortality
Huang et al36	Prospective population-based cohort	6,252 newly diagnosed COPD patients receiving statins for HLD, matched to 12,469 newly diagnosed COPD patients not taking statins	Statin use vs non-use	508 (8.1%) statin users were hospitalized compared to 1,324 (10.6%) non-users HR 0.66 (95% CI 0.60–0.74, P<0.001)
Lahousse et al37	Prospective NCC	Patients >55 years, diagnosed with COPD, CRP at baseline, at least 3 months of medication history, at least 2 years of follow-up between incident COPD and death 7,983 patients resulting in 363 cases matched to 2,345 controls	Statin use vs non-use	Statin use >2 years was associated with a 39% reduced risk of all cause death (95% CI, 0.38–0.99, P=0.045). When stratified by CRP, risk reduction increased to 78% (95% CI, 0.06–0.74, P=0.015) in those with CRP >3 mg/L
Criner et al38 STATCOPE	R, PC, P	40–80 years old with moderate-severe COPD defined by GOLD guidelines; current or former smoker with 10 pack year history; one of the following within 1 year of enrollment: supplemental O2, systemic steroids, antibiotics, ED visit or hospitalization for exacerbation n=885 patients; 433 in simvastatin arm, 452 in placebo arm	Simvastatin 40 mg vs placebo	No difference in exacerbation rates or time to exacerbation; trial stopped early for futility
Neukamm et al39 (2014) RODEO	R, PC, DB, P	Patients with COPD without a clear indication for statin therapy referred to two pulmonary outpatient clinics in Norway N=99; 49 in rosuvastatin group and 50 in placebo group	Rosuvastatin 10 mg vs placebo	No significant difference in change in vascular function (RHI 2.54 vs 2.51, P=0.292) or change in pulmonary function (FEV1, 1.35 L vs 1.45 L, P=0.462; FEV1/FVC, 47.3% vs 47.9%, P=0.292); improvement in inflammatory markers was seen in rosuvastatin group (CRP −20% vs 11%, P=0.017; IL-6 8% vs 30%, P=0.028)

Abbreviations: DB, double blind; FEV₁, forced expiratory volume in 1 second; FVC, forced vital capacity; GOLD, Global Initiative for Chronic Obstructive Lung Disease; HLD, hyperlipidemia; NCC, nested case-control; P, parallel; PC, placebo controlled; R, randomized; RHI, reactive hyperemia index; ED, emergency department; HR, hazard ratio; CI, confidence interval; CRP, C-reactive protein.

Conclusion

Although there is a growing body of retrospective and prospective cohort evidence suggesting that statin use in COPD is associated with improvements in many aspects of the disease process, including reduction in mortality, hospitalizations for COPD, ECOPD, severity of exacerbations, inflammatory mediators, and improved health related quality of life, similar conclusions have yet to be borne out in prospective, randomized trials. The absence of confirmatory data from randomized, prospective clinical trials may stem from the use of statin doses insufficient to produce the pleiotropic effects necessary to modify the COPD disease process. Bonnet et al comparing atorvastatin 80 mg to atorvastatin 10 mg, demonstrated a dose-dependent effect of atorvastatin on lowering CRP.¹⁹ With this data in mind, future investigations exploring the role of statins in COPD should consider the use of high dose statins, namely atorvastatin 80 mg and rosuvastatin 40 mg.

Given the lack of confirmatory prospective data, the most recent iteration of the GOLD guidelines provide no guidance regarding the use of statins for COPD. Additionally, the 2015 joint guideline from American College of Chest Physicians and Canadian Thoracic Society for prevention of acute ECOPD recommends against the routine use of statins.⁴⁰ Authors of the guideline do remark however, that many patients with COPD will require statins based on cardiovascular comorbidities, and should be treated accordingly. Due to the highest level of evidence not supporting the use of statins in COPD, and prominent guidelines recommending against routine use, it is the opinion of this panel that statins not be routinely prescribed for management of COPD; however, in patients with multiple COPD exacerbations despite optimal medical management, especially for those with cardiovascular comorbidities, statin use may provide significant benefit. In order to optimize potential benefits of statin therapy in this patient population, high dose therapy with atorvastatin 80 mg or rosuvastatin 40 mg is warranted to take full advantage of the pleiotropic effects. Atorvastatin and rosuvastatin may be started at the respective doses without titration; however, caution is warranted when using high dose statins due to the potential increased risk for statin-related myalgias and myopathies.