Abstract Abstract
Background
A revised checklist of the British and Irish Heloridae and Proctotrupidae (Proctotrupoidea) substantially updates the previous comprehensive checklist, dating from 1978. Country level data (i.e. occurrence in England, Scotland, Wales, Ireland and the Isle of Man) is reported where known.
New information
A total of three Heloridae and 39 Proctotrupidae (including only certainly recorded species) represents a 27% increase in the British list since 1978. Most species are still poorly known and there has been a dearth of taxonomic and faunistic work on the British and Irish fauna.
Keywords: Heloridae , Proctotrupidae , fauna, Ireland, Britain
Introduction
This paper is part of a series of new checklists to the British and Irish Hymenoptera fauna, that started with Broad and Livermore (2014b), Broad and Livermore (2014a) and Liston et al. (2014)and is the first update to the Hymenoptera checklist since 1978 (Fitton et al. 1978). Proctotrupoids are koinobiont endoparasitoids of holometabolous insect larvae. Although Proctrotrupidae can be common and readily collected by sweep netting or Malaise traps, the superfamily is poorly known biologically. Proctotrupidae are parasitoids of Coleoptera and, to a lesser extent, Diptera larvae, with one extraordinary host record from a centipede, whereas Heloridae have been reared from Neuroptera larvae (biology summarised in Gauld and Bolton 1988). Extralimital families attack Coleoptera and Neuroptera, or (Austroniidae, Peradeniidae, Proctorenyxidae) are completely unknown biologically.
The superfamily 'Proctotrupoidea' has generally been a welcoming home to a variety of parasitoid groups and recognised as not being monophyletic (Rasnitsyn 1988, Ronquist et al. 1999, Dowton and Austin 2001); in the 1978 checklist (Fitton et al. 1978) the Platygastroidea and Diaprioidea were included in the Proctotrupoidea. The removal of the Diapriidae, Maamingidae and Monomachidae to their own superfamily (Diaprioidea) has recently gained acceptance (e.g. Klopfstein et al. 2013). The Proctotrupoidea as presently defined (e.g. Sharkey 2007) now comprises the Heloridae and Proctotrupidae in Britain and the extralimital families Austroniidae, Pelecinidae, Peradeniidae, Proctorenyxidae, Roproniidae and Vanhorniidae.
There has been very little work on the British proctotrupoid fauna and most of what we know about the British and Irish Proctotrupidae derives from the global monograph of Townes and Townes (1981). Both families can be recognised instantly by their distinctive wing venation and they each have a characteristic habitus (Figs 1, 2, 3). A revision of the British fauna would undoubtedly reveal more species.
Figure 1.
Representative British Heloridae. Helorus ruficornis Förster, female, England, Herts., Aldbury, 2013, coll. G.R. Broad.
Figure 2.
Representative British Proctotrupidae. Disogmus basalis (Thomson), male, England, Herefordshire, Mary Knoll Valley, 21-24.5.2007, coll. D.G. Notton, NHMUK010209578.
Figure 3.
Representative British Proctotrupidae. Proctotrupes brachypterus (Schrank), female, England, Rothamsted, 26.9.1973, NHMUK010209579.
Materials and methods
Much of the distribution data are taken from Townes and Townes (1981). Distribution data pertaining to Ireland are mostly from O'Connor et al. (2004). Other sources are referred to. There is an excellent online resource, The Proctotrupidae of the World. The taxonomy follows Townes and Townes (1981) and Townes (1977) with subsequent changes referenced. We have tried to account for every name on the 1978 checklist Fitton et al. (1978) and all additions to the fauna since then have been referenced. A more complete methodology and rationale behind the checklist can be found in Broad (2014). The following conventions and abbreviations are used here:
[species] taxon deleted from the British and Irish list
NHM Natural History Museum, London
# known or suspected introductions with at least temporarily self-sustaining populations
? status (including uncertain synonymy) or identification in the British Isles uncertain
misident. has been misidentified as this name
nom. dub. nomen dubium, a name of unknown or doubtful application
nom. ob. nomen oblitum, ‘forgotten name’, does not have priority over a younger name
nom. nov. nomen novum, a replacement name
nom. nud. nomen nudum, an unavailable name, with no type specimen
preocc. name preoccupied (junior homonym)
stat. rev. status revocatus, revived status (e.g., raised from synonymy)
unavailable not meeting the requirements of the International Code of Zoological Nomenclature
var. variety, only available as a valid name under the provisions of article 45.6 of the ICZN
Alternative versions of the checklist, as a formatted Word document and Excel spreadsheet, are provided here in the supplementary materials: Suppl. materials 1, 2.
Photographs were taken using a Canon EOS 450D digital camera attached to a Leica MZ12 stereomicroscope and partially focused images were combined using Helicon Focus v.4.80 software.
Checklists
Proctotrupoidea
PROCTOTRUPOIDEA
Heloridae
Förster, 1856
Notes
Distribution data from Townes (1977), Fergusson and Smith (1974), Cooter and Fergusson (1993) and O'Connor et al. (2004).
Helorus
Latreille, 1802
COPELUS Provancher, 1881
Helorus anomalipes
(Panzer, 1798)
Sphex anomalipes Panzer, 1798
ater Latreille, 1802
paradoxus (Provancher, 1881, Copelus)
Helorus anomalipes ?bifoveolata Gregor, 1938
Helorus anomalipes ?nigrotibia Hellén, 1941
Distribution
England, Ireland
Helorus nigripes
Förster, 1856
rugosus Thomson, 1858
Distribution
England
Helorus ruficornis
Förster, 1856
coruscus Haliday, 1857
corruscus misspelling
flavipes Kieffer, 1907
Distribution
England, Ireland
Proctotrupidae
Latreille, 1802
Notes
Distribution data from Townes and Townes (1981) and O'Connor et al. (2004).
Brachyserphus
Hellén, 1941
Brachyserphus parvulus
(Nees, 1834)
Codrus parvulus Nees, 1834
Distribution
England, Ireland
Codrus
Panzer, 1801
Codrus niger
Panzer, 1805
Distribution
England, Ireland
Codrus picicornis
(Förster, 1856)
Disogmus picicornis Förster, 1856
subcompressus (Hedicke, 1927, Phaenoserphus)
vexator (Nixon, 1938, Phaenoserphus)
subclavatus (Hellén, 1941, Phaenoserphus)
Distribution
England, Ireland
Notes
Listed as Phaenoserphus subcompressus in Fergusson (1978).
Cryptoserphus
Kieffer, 1907
Cryptoserphus aculeator
(Haliday, 1839)
Proctotrupes aculeator Haliday, 1839
ater (Nees, 1834, Codrus) preocc.
perrisi (Kieffer, 1908, Seprhus)
deshii Drake, 1970, Cryptoserphus
Distribution
England, Scotland, Ireland
Cryptoserphus dilatus
Townes, 1981
Distribution
Ireland
Notes
added by Townes and Townes (1981)
Cryptoserphus flavipes
(Provancher, 1881)
Proctotrupes flavipes Provancher, 1881
brevimanus (Kieffer, 1908, Serphus)
longicalcar (Kieffer, 1908, Serphus)
cumaeus Nixon, 1938
fungorum Szelényi, 1940
Distribution
Ireland
Cryptoserphus longitarsis
(Thomson, 1858)
Proctotrupes longitarsis Thomson, 1858
Distribution
Ireland
Disogmus
Förster, 1856
Disogmus areolator
(Haliday, 1839)
Proctotrupes areolator Haliday, 1839
aequator Förster, 1856
discrepator Förster, 1856
elegans (Thomson, 1858, Proctotrupes)
nigripennis (Thomson, 1858, Proctotrupes)
canadensis Harrington, 1900
diversicornis Kieffer, 1906
glabratus Kieffer, 1906
carinatus Kieffer, 1907
torvus Whittaker, 1930
Distribution
England, Scotland, Ireland
Disogmus basalis
(Thomson, 1858)
Proctotrupes basalis Thomson, 1858
fuscitarsis Kieffer, 1907
Distribution
England, Scotland, Ireland
Exallonyx
Kieffer, 1904
Notes
unplaced species of Exallonyx:
[Exallonyx leviventris Kieffer, 1908 nom. dub., from England]
Exallonyx
Kieffer, 1904
Exallonyx (Exallonyx) ater
(Gravenhorst, 1807)
Codrus ater Gravenhorst, 1807
aterrimus (Dalla Torre, 1898, Proctotrypes)
xanthocerus Kieffer, 1908
filicornis Kieffer, 1908
syriacus Kieffer, 1908
gracilis Nixon, 1938
Distribution
England, Ireland
Exallonyx (Exallonyx) brevimala
Townes, 1981
Distribution
England, Ireland
Notes
added by Townes and Townes (1981)
Exallonyx (Exallonyx) confusus
Nixon, 1938
Distribution
England, Ireland
Exallonyx (Exallonyx) crenicornis
(Nees, 1834)
Codrus crenicornis Nees, 1834
clavipes (Thomson, 1858, Proctotrupes)
donisthorpei Kieffer, 1908
fumipennis Kieffer, 1908
Distribution
England, Scotland
Notes
Listed, as Codrus fumipennis (Kieffer), as doubtfully British by Fergusson (1978); status as a British species confirmed by Townes and Townes (1981).
Exallonyx (Exallonyx) formicarius
Kieffer, 1904
Distribution
England, Scotland, Ireland
Exallonyx (Exallonyx) ligatus
(Nees, 1834)
Codrus ligatus Nees, 1834
Distribution
England, Ireland
Exallonyx (Exallonyx) longicornis
(Nees, 1834)
Codrus longicornis Nees, 1834
micrurus (Keiffer, 1908, Serphus)
Distribution
Scotland, Ireland
Exallonyx (Exallonyx) microcerus
Kieffer, 1908
hyalinipennis Kieffer, 1908
Distribution
England, Ireland
Notes
Listed as a synonym of Exallonyx formicarius in Fergusson (1978).
Exallonyx (Exallonyx) minor
Townes, 1981
Distribution
England, Scotland, Ireland
Exallonyx (Exallonyx) nixoni
Townes, 1981
Distribution
England
Exallonyx (Exallonyx) pallidistigma
Morley, 1922
niger misident.
milleri (Tomšík, 1942, Phaenoserphus)
Distribution
England, Ireland
Exallonyx (Exallonyx) quadriceps
(Ashmead, 1893)
Proctotrypes quadriceps Ashmead, 1893
crassicornis Kieffer, 1908
hyalinipennis (Morley, 1922, Proctotrypes)
Distribution
England, Scotland, Ireland
Notes
Recorded by Townes and Townes (1981).
Exallonyx (Exallonyx) subserratus
Kieffer, 1908
curtigena Nixon, 1938
Distribution
England, Ireland
Exallonyx (Exallonyx) trichomus
Townes, 1981
Distribution
England, Ireland
Notes
added by Townes and Townes (1981)
Exallonyx (Exallonyx) trifoveatus
Kieffer, 1908
talpae Kieffer, 1908
borneanus (Cameron, 1912, Proctotrypes)
reicherti (Enderlein, 1916, Proctotrupes)
parvulus Brues, 1919
philonthiphagus Williams, 1932
Distribution
England, Ireland
Notes
added by Townes and Townes (1981)
Exallonyx (Exallonyx) wasmanni
Kieffer, 1904
myrmecophilus Kieffer, 1904
socialis Kieffer, 1908
Distribution
England, Ireland
Notes
Although excluded from the Irish list by O'Connor et al. (2004), the locality ‘Tanrego’ quoted by Townes and Townes (1981) refers to an estate in Sligo.
Eocodrus
Pschorn-Walcher, 1958
Exallonyx (Eocodrus) brevicornis
(Haliday, 1839)
Proctotrupes brevicornis Haliday, 1839
lineata Kieffer, 1908
Distribution
England, Scotland, Ireland
Mischoserphus
Townes, 1981
Mischoserphus arcuator
(Stelfox, 1950)
Cryptoserphus arcuator Stelfox, 1950
ione (Kozlov, 1971, Cryptoserphus)
Distribution
Ireland
Paracodrus
Kieffer, 1907
Paracodrus apterogynus
(Haliday, 1839)
Proctotrupes apterogynus Haliday, 1839
albipennis (Thomson, 1858, Codrus)
bethyliformis Kieffer, 1907
Distribution
Ireland
Parthenocodrus
Pschorn-Walcher, 1958
CRYPTOCODRUS Pschorn-Walcher, 1958
Parthenocodrus elongatus
(Haliday, 1839)
Proctotrupes elongatus Haliday, 1839
buccatus (Thomson, 1858, Proctotrupes)
Distribution
England, Ireland
Phaenoserphus
Kieffer, 1908
CARABIPHAGUS Morley, 1931
Phaenoserphus chittii
(Morley, 1922)
Proctotrypes chittii Morley, 1922
dubiosus Nixon, 1938
Distribution
England, Ireland
Phaenoserphus fuscipes
(Haliday, 1839)
Proctotrupes fuscipes Haliday, 1839
Distribution
Scotland, Ireland
Phaenoserphus gregori
Tomšík, 1942
Distribution
Ireland
Phaenoserphus pallipes
(Jurine, 1807)
Codrus pallipes Jurine, 1807
rufipes (Brullé, 1846, Proctotrupes)
testaceicornis (Kieffer, 1908, Serphus)
Distribution
England, Ireland
Phaenoserphus viator
(Haliday, 1839)
Proctotrupes viator Haliday, 1839
curtipennis (Haliday, 1839, Proctotrupes)
laevifrons (Förster, 1861, Proctotrupes)
sixianus (Vollenhoven, 1879, Proctotrypes)
Distribution
England, Ireland
Phaneroserphus
Pschorn-Walcher, 1958
Notes
species of Phaneroserphus removed from the British and Irish list:
[cristatus Townes, 1981] Fauna Europaea lists Phaneroserphus cristatus as occurring in Britain and France but Townes and Townes (1981) state that this species is only found in Japan, and no literature citations for its European occurrence can be traced.
Phaneroserphus calcar
(Haliday, 1839)
Proctotrupes calcar Haliday, 1839
calcaratus (Thomson, 1858, Proctotrupes)
seticornis (Thomson, 1858, Proctotrupes)
areolatus (Kieffer, 1908, Serphus)
castaneus (Kieffer, 1908, Serphus)
Distribution
England, Scotland, Ireland
Proctotrupes
Latreille, 1796
SERPHUS Schrank, 1780
ERODORUS Walckanaer, 1802
PROCTRUPES Rafinesque, 1815
PROCTOTRYPES Aggasiz, 1846
PROCTOTROPIS Gistel, 1848
Proctotrupes brachypterus
(Schrank, 1780)
Serphus brachypterus Schrank, 1780
divagator (Olivier, 1792, Ichneumon)
campanulator (Fabricius, 1798, Ichneumon)
emarciator (Fabricius, 1798, Ichneumon)
bimaculatus (Walckenaer, 1802, Erodorus)
brevipennis Latreille, 1802
bicolor Haliday, 1839
gladiator Haliday, 1839
sulcatus (Kieffer, 1908, Serphus)
hofferi (Tomšík, 1944, Serphus)
azarbajdzhanicus (Samedov, 1954, Serphus)
Distribution
England, Ireland
Proctotrupes gravidator
(Linnaeus, 1758)
Ichneumon gravidator Linnaeus, 1758
meridionalis Gribodo, 1880
rufigaster Provancher, 1881
collaris Szépligeti, 1901
suzukii Matsumura, 1912
zabriskiei (Brues, 1919, Serphus)
Distribution
England, Ireland
Notes
Proctotrupes indivisus (Kieffer, 1908, Serphus) removed from synonymy by Notton (2007).
Tretoserphus
Townes, 1981
Notes
species of Tretoserphus removed from the British and Irish list:
[foveolatus (Möller, 1882, Proctotrupes)] Listed as British by Fergusson (1978) as perkinsi was then considered to be a junior synonym of foveolatus.
Tretoserphus laricis
(Haliday, 1839)
Proctotrupes laricis Haliday, 1839
nigricauda (Kieffer, 1908, Serphus)
melanderi (Brues, 1919, Cryptoserphus)
Distribution
England, Ireland
Tretoserphus perkinsi
(Nixon, 1942)
Cryptoserphus perkinsi Nixon, 1942
Distribution
England, Ireland
Supplementary Material
Checklist of British and Irish Proctotrupoidea
Broad, G.R.
Data type: formatted text
Brief description: Word document version of the checklist
File: oo_74853.docx
Checklist of British and Irish Proctotrupoidea
Broad, G.R.
Data type: spreadsheet
Brief description: Excel spreadsheet version of the checklist
File: oo_84638.xlsx
References
- Broad G. R. Checklist of British and Irish Hymenoptera - Introduction. http://biodiversitydatajournal.com/articles.php?id=1113. Biodiversity Data Journal. 2014;2:e1113. doi: 10.3897/BDJ.2.e1113. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Broad G. R., Livermore L. Checklist of British and Irish Hymenoptera - Evanioidea. http://biodiversitydatajournal.com/articles.php?id=1116. Biodiversity Data Journal. 2014;2:e1116. doi: 10.3897/BDJ.2.e1116. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Broad G. R., Livermore L. Checklist of British and Irish Hymenoptera - Ceraphronoidea. Biodiversity Data Journal. 2014;2:e1167. doi: 10.3897/BDJ.2.e1167. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Cooter J., Fergusson N. D.M. Helorus nigripes Förster (Hym., Heloridae), a fifth British record. Entomologist's Monthly Magazine. 1993;129:29. [Google Scholar]
- Dowton M., Austin A. D. Simultaneous analysis of 16S, 28S, COI and morphology in the Hymenoptera: Apocrita - evolutionary transitions among parasitic wasps. Biological Journal of the Linnean Society. 2001;74:87–111. [Google Scholar]
- Fergusson N. D.M. Proctotrupoida. In: Fitton M. G., Graham M. W.R. de V., Bouček Z. R.J., Fergusson N. D.M., Huddleston T., Quinlan J. undefined, Richards O. W., editors. Kloet and Hincks. A check list of British insects. Part 4: Hymenoptera. 11(4): ix + 159 pp. Handbooks for the Identification of British Insects; 1978. 13 [Google Scholar]
- Fergusson N. D.M., Smith K. G.V. Helorus rugosus Thomson (Hym., Heloridae) in Britain. Entomologist's Monthly Magazine. 1974;109[1973]:222. [Google Scholar]
- Fitton M. G., Graham M. W.R. de V., Boucek Z. R.J., Fergusson N. D.M., Huddleston T., Quinlan J., Richards O. W. Kloet and Hincks. A check list of British insects. Part 4: Hymenoptera. Handbooks for the Identification of British Insects. 1978;11:1–159+ix. [Google Scholar]
- Gauld I. D., Bolton B. The Hymenoptera. British Museum (Natural History) and Oxford University Press; Oxford: 1988. 332 [Google Scholar]
- Klopfstein S., Vilhelmsen L., Heraty J. M., Sharkey M., Ronquist F. The hymenopteran tree of life: evidence from protein-coding genes and objectively aligned ribosomal data. PLoS ONE. 2013;8(8):23pp.. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0069344. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Liston A. D., Knight G. T., Sheppard D. A., Broad G. R., Livermore L. Checklist of British and Irish Hymenoptera - Sawflies, ‘Symphyta’. Biodiversity Data Journal. 2014;2:e1168. doi: 10.3897/BDJ.2.e1168. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Notton D. G. A catalogue of types of the smaller taxa of Proctotrupoidea (Hymenoptera) in the Muséum national d’Histoire naturelle, Paris, with notes on the history of the insect collection of L. A. G. Bosc d’Antic. Zoosystema. 2007;29(3):457–470. [Google Scholar]
- O'Connor J. P., Nash R., Notton D. G., Fergusson N. D.M. A catalogue of the Irish Platygastroidea and Proctotrupoidea (Hymenoptera) Occasional Publication of the Irish Biogeographical Society. 2004;7:1–110. [Google Scholar]
- Rasnitsyn A. P. An outline of the evolution of the hymenopterous insects (order Vespida) Oriental Insects. 1988;22:115–145. [Google Scholar]
- Ronquist F., Rasnitsyn A. P., Roy A., Eriksson E., Lindgren M. Phylogeny of the Hymenoptera: A cladistic reanalysis of Rasnitsyn's (1988) data. Zoologica Scripta. 1999;28:13–50. doi: 10.1046/j.1463-6409.1999.00023.x. [DOI] [Google Scholar]
- Sharkey M. J. Phylogeny and classification of Hymenoptera. Zootaxa. 2007;1668:521–548. [Google Scholar]
- Townes H. A revision of the Heloridae (Hymenoptera) Contributions of the American Entomological Institute. 1977;15(2):1–12. [Google Scholar]
- Townes H. K., Townes M. A revision of the Serphidae (Hymenoptera) Memoirs of the American Entomological Institute. 1981;32:1–541. [Google Scholar]
Associated Data
This section collects any data citations, data availability statements, or supplementary materials included in this article.
Supplementary Materials
Checklist of British and Irish Proctotrupoidea
Broad, G.R.
Data type: formatted text
Brief description: Word document version of the checklist
File: oo_74853.docx
Checklist of British and Irish Proctotrupoidea
Broad, G.R.
Data type: spreadsheet
Brief description: Excel spreadsheet version of the checklist
File: oo_84638.xlsx



