Exposure to inorganic arsenic can lead to gut microbe perturbations and hepatocellular carcinoma

Abstract

Arsenic is a carcinogenic environmental factor found in food and drinking water around the world. The mechanisms in which arsenic alters homeostasis are not fully understood. Over the past few decades, light has been shed on varying mechanisms in which arsenic induces cancer. Such mechanisms include gut microbe perturbations, genotoxic effects, and epigenetic modification. Gut microbe perturbations have been shown to increase the level of pathogen-associated molecular patterns such as lipopolysaccharide (LPS) leading to uncontained inflammation. Increase in inflammation is the major factor in cirrhosis leading to hepatocellular carcinoma. Alterations in gut permeability and metabolites have also been observed as a fallout of arsenic induced gut microbe modification. The guts proximity and interaction through portal flow make the liver susceptible to gut perturbations and ensuing inflammatory responses. Genotoxic and epigenetic dysregulation induced by arsenic and its toxic metabolites present a more direct mechanism that works synergistically with gut microbe perturbations to induce the incidence of cancers. These pathways combined could be some of the main causes of arsenic-induced carcinogenesis.

Graphical abstract

Arsenic is an environmental factor with known carcinogenic effects that make it a global health concern. Arsenic has shown the ability to perturb the gut microbe population leading to negative effects in mice and human. The ability of arsenic to increase pathogen-associated molecular patterns (PAMPs) in the perturbed gut can increase inflammatory response leading to adverse effects. The genotoxic and epigenetic effects of arsenic also pose a direct toxicity to tissues and organs, revealing multiple pathways in which it can induce cancer within skin, lung, kidney, urinary bladder, prostate, and liver.

1. Introduction

Arsenic is the 20th most common element in the earth׳s crust and is considered a group 1 carcinogen¹. Arsenics abundance and known cariogenic properties make it a global health concern. Arsenic is an environmental factor that is known to contaminate drinking water and food supply if not adequately regulated. Over 100 million people worldwide rely on arsenic-contaminated drinking water on 5 of the earth׳s continents². There are multiple forms of arsenic, but naturally occurring trivalent inorganic arsenic possess the highest toxicity. Trivalent arsenic can be directly methylated leading to volatile products while pentavalent arsenic is not readily taken up by cells and is often reduced to trivalent arsenic³. Once ingested arsenic is metabolized in the liver where hepatocytes uptake trivalent arsenic, within the hepatocytes, subsequent conjugations and methylations occur leading to volatile products⁴.

Arsenic has been found to increase the incidence of cancers including skin, lung, kidney, urinary bladder, prostate, and liver¹. Hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) is the leading form of liver cancer and will serve as the focus for this review. The mechanisms in which arsenic induces such cancers are continually investigated.

The carcinogenic effects of arsenic cannot be pinpointed to one simple mechanism, since arsenic perturbs physiological functions through multiple interworking pathways. Such proposed mechanisms leading to cancers include shifts in gut microbiota, genotoxic effects, and epigenetic dysregulation5, 6, 7. These mechanisms work synergistically to induce cancers, such as HCC.

The human body is host to many trillions of gut microbes and this microbial community works in symbiosis to aid in normal physiological functions, such as digestion and metabolism⁸. Perturbations in the gut microbiota have been associated with many diseases from obesity to various forms of cancer⁹. It has been shown that arsenic can alter the microbiome and metabolic profile in mice. It is proposed that alterations in the gut microbiota by arsenic can lead to many physiological imbalances aiding in HCC development.

As mentioned previously, arsenic has the potential to induce genotoxic fallout and abnormal epigenetic modifications⁵. Arsenic is considered a genotoxic metalloid with the ability to cause DNA strand breaks, sister chromatid exchanges, and micronuclei¹⁰. Aberrant epigenetic modifications have also been related to arsenic exposure¹¹. Arsenic has the potential to induce HCC through multiple mechanisms, therefore proving an elusive environmental carcinogen (Fig. 1).

Figure 1.

Schematic summary of arsenic-induced disease progression demonstrating synergistic mechanisms leading to liver cirrhosis and hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC). Arsenic consumption leads to both genotoxic/epigenetic dysregulation and gut perturbations. Gut perturbation increases the incidence of inflammation leading to cirrhosis and potentially HCC. Genotoxic and epigenetic dysregulation disrupts intracellular mechanisms, increasing the potential for HCC development.

2. Arsenic perturbs gut microbiota

When inorganic arsenic is ingested into the body through contaminated food and water, it is metabolized by the liver, where hepatocytes uptake trivalent arsenic via aquaglyceroporins and hexose permeases. Within the hepatocyte, arsenic is conjugated with glutathione, generating arsenic triglutathione. Methylation may also take place leading to dimethylarsenic glutathione which has been found to be excreted in bile and into the blood stream. Dimethylarsenic glutathione is unstable and has the potential to form volatile compounds, such as dimethylarsine. Red blood cells are also able to efficiently take up arsenic and store the arsenic as protein-bound trivalent dimethylarsenicals throughout the body⁴.

Whether arsenic is stored in the cells of the human body or within the gut microbe population, negative effects ensue. A metagenomics and metabolomics analysis conducted by Lu et al.⁷, in which mice were treated with arsenic through drinking water at a concentration of 10 ppm for four weeks, revealed that the control and treated animals were well separated with 19.95% and 10.66% variation explained by principal component analysis. In a second study, mice were treated with arsenic for 2, 5, and 10 weeks at low to moderate levels of arsenic (10–250 ppb) and microbial biofilms that lined the intestine of control mice were degraded in the treatment mice indicating that moderate levels of arsenic exposure (250 ppb) can alter the gut microbiota¹². Degradation of symbiotic microbial biofilms in the intestine may alter normal physiological function and have the potential to open a niche for pathogenic infection. The destruction of microbial biofilms may also alter the permeability of the gut leading to abnormal absorption. Dheer and colleagues¹² observed a significant increase in the number of bacteroidetes when mice were treated with 250 ppb arsenic in water for 2, 4, and 10 weeks. An increase in bacteroidetes is significant because bacteroidetes are Gram-negative bacteria with lipopolysaccharide (LPS) on their outer membrane. LPS is an important virulence factor which causes widespread inflammation disrupting normal biological functions¹³. An increase in pathogenic arginine metabolites in the mouse circulation was also observed¹². Arginine is maintained in host cells and upon infection of intracellular pathogens, such as Salmonella typhimurium or Mycobacterium tuberculosis, and it has the ability to utilize the host arginine pool releasing increased levels of pathogenic arginine metabolites. The increase in arginine metabolites acts as an indicator of microbial perturbations and infection¹⁴. The combination of altered gut permeability and the increase in pathogen-associated molecular patterns (PAMPs), such as LPS, are both possible factors in the induction or progression of liver cirrhosis and HCC.

3. Perturbed gut microbiota has potential to induce HCC

Altering the gut microbe population has shown to stimulate inflammatory pathways that in turn interrupts liver function leading to cirrhosis and HCC. A recent study by Seki and colleagues¹⁵ reported that inflammation triggered through toll like receptor 4 (TLR4) activation induced hepatic fibrogenesis. TLR4 is a receptor responsible for recognizing certain PAMPs. TLR4 specifically recognizes the LPS layer found on gram negative bacteria. Seki et al.¹⁶ challenged mice with LPS and observed TLR4 activation in quiescent hepatic stellate cells (HSCs) which resulted in chemokine secretion and an increase in chemotaxis of Kupffer cells. The over active inflammatory response in the liver due to LPS leads to damaged hepatic tissue and function. Seki and colleagues¹⁶ also showed that gut sterilization and bile duct ligation in mice lead to a decrease in hepatic fibrosis. Isolating the liver from the gut microbe population decreases the livers exposure to PAMPs, which in turn decreases the inflammatory response and hepatic damage.

Increased levels of PAMPs and inflammation have been associated with viral hepatitis in clinical study. Viral hepatitis is a leading cause of liver cirrhosis. Sandler and colleagues¹⁷ reported through clinical studies that compared with uninfected individuals, HCV- and HBV-infected individuals had higher plasma levels of LPS, I-FABP (indicating enterocyte death), sCD14 (produced upon LPS activation of monocytes), and IL-6. Levels of CD14 correlated with markers of hepatic inflammation and fibrosis. CD14 is a co-receptor with TLR4 that detects LPS and other PAMPs, such as lipoteichoic acid.

Inflammation and cirrhosis are major causative factors in the development of hepatocellular carcinoma. There are many mechanisms that lead to HCC, but all of them start with some form of cirrhosis of the liver¹⁸. Inflammation which was induced via the mechanisms mentioned above leads to cirrhosis and potentially HCC. Yu et al.¹⁹ reported in a laboratory study that depletion of Gram-negative bacteria reduces toxic models of HCC. Yu et al.¹⁹ treated rats with bactericidal drugs against enteric Gram-negative bacteria days prior to diethylnitrosamine (DEN) administration. DEN is a cancer inducing model commonly used in rodents. Twenty-one days after DEN injection, bactericidal treated rats showed a reduced number and size of HCC nodules. The ability to reduce the occurrence of HCC nodules by simply altering the gut microbiome shows the direct and significant impact the microbes of the body have on homeostasis. Since arsenic has been shown to alter the gut microbe population, it should be considered as a serious environmental factor with the potential to cause disease via multiple mechanisms.

4. Arsenic has genotoxic and epigenetic altering effects which can induce HCC

When arsenic enters the body through water consumption, it is metabolized in the liver. Arsenic has been shown to induce genotoxic effects and epigenetic dysregulation which has the potential to aid in HCC progression⁵. Some genotoxic mechanisms of arsenic include DNA repair inhibition and development of micronuclei. Sinha et al.²⁰ reported that oxidative damage induced by arsenic interferes with DNA repair mechanisms through downregulation of DNA repair enzymes like β-polymerase and inhibition of ligation. The exact mechanism in which arsenic deploys its genotoxic effect is elusive because there are more than 5 metabolites that are all known to have toxic properties²¹. The methylated arsenic metabolite methylarsonous acid (MMAIII) is known to have carcinogenic potential. Tokar et al.²² chronically exposed TRL1215 rat liver cells to MMAIII (0.25–1.0 μmol/L) and were tested for oxidative DNA damage and acquired malignant phenotype. The liver cells acquired a cancer phenotype with MMAIII exposure at about 20 weeks, based on increased matrix metalloproteinase secretion, colony formation and invasion. Kojima et al.²³ reported that arsenic biomethylation seems to be obligatory for arsenic-induced oxidative DNA damage and appears linked in TRL1215 rat liver cells with the accelerated transition to an in vitro cancer phenotype.

Arsenic has also been shown to induce abnormal epigenetic modifications, such as DNA hypermethylation of tumor suppressor genes. In the past few decades, epigenetic regulation has been identified as a major factor in post-transcriptional regulation. Many studies have indicated that arsenic exposure leads to globally altered DNA methylation24, 25, 26. Tsang et al.²⁷ showed that arsenic exposure in utero of mice in tandem with high folate administration caused a hugely significant change in CpG island methylations. CpG island methylation is known to modify chromatin structure and potentially inhibit transcription. Cui and colleagues²⁸ demonstrated that mice fed orally with arsenic water (100 ppm) showed an abnormal P16 and RASSF1A methylation pattern in lung tissues, and an increased incidence in tumor formation. A meta-analysis conducted by Wang et al.²⁹ indicated that long-term inorganic arsenic exposure through drinking water increases the risk of liver cancer mortality. Overall, arsenic has shown to alter the gut microbe population and also cause direct genotoxic and epigenetic effects leading to various diseased states, including cirrhosis and HCC.

5. Concluding remarks

Arsenic is an environmental factor with known carcinogenic effects that make it a global health concern. Arsenic has shown the ability to perturb the gut microbe population leading to negative effects in mice and human. The ability of arsenic to increase PAMPs in the perturbed gut can increase inflammatory response leading to adverse effects. The genotoxic and epigenetic effects of arsenic also pose a direct toxicity to tissues and organs, revealing multiple pathways in which it can induce cancer within above-mentioned organs.