A combined chloroplast atpB–rbcL and trnL-F phylogeny unveils the ancestry of balsams (Impatiens spp.) in the Western Ghats of India

Abstract

Only a few Impatiens spp. from South India (one of the five centers of diversity for Impatiens species) were included in the published datum of molecular phylogeny of the family Balsaminaceae. The present investigation is a novel attempt to reveal the phylogenetic association of Impatiens species of South India, by placing them in the global phylogeny of Impatiens based on a combined analysis of two chloroplast genes. Thirty species of genus Impatiens were collected from different locations of South India. Total genomic DNA was extracted from fresh plant leaf, and polymerase chain reaction was carried out using atpB–rbcL and trnL-F intergenic spacer-specific forward and reverse primers. Thirteen sequences of Impatiens species from three centers of diversity were obtained from GenBank for reconstructing the evolutionary relationships within the genus Impatiens. Bayesian inference analysis was carried out in MrBayes v.3.2.2. This analysis supported Southeast Asia as the ancestral place of origin of extant Impatiens species. Molecular phylogeny of South Indian Impatiens spp. based on combined chloroplast sequences showed the same association as that of morphological taxonomy. Sections Scapigerae, Tomentosae, Sub-Umbellatae, and Racemosae showed Southeast Asian relationship, while sections Annuae and Microsepalae showed African affinity.

Electronic supplementary material

The online version of this article (doi:10.1007/s13205-016-0574-8) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Introduction

Two genera, namely, Impatiens and Hydrocera, are the sole members of the family Balsaminaceae. The genus Hydrocera is monotypic. Impatiens is a large genus containing more than 1000 species with a distribution pattern in the mountain areas of old world tropics and subtropics (Janssens et al. 2006). The five biodiversity hotspots for this highly endemic genus have been identified as Southeast Asia, Southern India and Sri Lanka, tropical Africa, Madagascar, and the Eastern Himalayas (Yuan et al. 2004; Janssens et al. 2006). Several novel species, belonging to this explosively speciating plant, are recognized in these regions every year (Kuang et al. 2014; Gogoi and Borah 2014; Luo et al. 2015). The genus Impatiens contains more than 210 species in India with amazing localization in two biodiversity hotspots, namely, Himalayas in the north of India and the Western Ghats in the south of India. Over half of these occur in the Western Ghats of India and at least 103 species of Impatiens are endemic to the Western Ghats alone (Bhaskar 2012).

Molecular phylogeny of balsams based on ITS sequences (Yuan et al. 2004) proposed that extant Impatiens species are of Southeast Asian origin, from where it dispersed to other parts of the globe in several dispersal events. Contrarily, atpB–rbcL intergenic spacer sequences based on phylogenetics of Janssens et al. (2006) suggested that Impatiens originated in South China from which it colonized the nearby regions and afterwards dispersed to north America, India, Africa, the Southeast Asian peninsula, and the Himalayan area. All these published data of molecular phylogeny and biogeography of Balsaminaceae inferred from ITS sequences (Yuan et al. 2004) and chloroplast atpB–rbcL spacer sequences (Janssens et al. 2006) contained only a few samples of Impatiens species from South India, creating a gap in the existing phylogeny of balsams. Hence, this work is a novel attempt on the molecular phylogeny of Impatiens species with representatives from six sections of balsams from South India.

Materials and methods

Representative samples from the different sections of Impatiens species were collected from Southern Western Ghats of India. The plants were authenticated, and voucher specimens were deposited in the Herbarium of St. Thomas College (Palai, Kerala, India). The details of the sample collection were summarized in Table 1.

Table 1.

Species used in this study with location, voucher no., and GenBank accession no. of atpB–rbcL and trnL-F sequences

SI. no.	Species name with section	Locationa	Voucher no. of sample deposited	GenBank accession number
				atpB–rbcL	trnL-F
Section: Scapigerae
1	I. levingei	Eravikulam National Park	S.P.P.4854	KU316381	KU341090
2	I. modesta	Eravikulam National Park	S.P.P.4857	KU530217	KU341091
3	I. pandata	Eravikulam National Park	S.P.P.4856	KU316383	KU513967
4	I. scapiflora	Vagamon	S.P.P.4502	KF447374	KJ746922
Section: Annuae
5	I. aadishankarii	Wayanad	S.P.P. 4546	KU316371	KU341086
6	I. chinensis	Munnar	S.P.P.4545	KU316374	KU341088
7	I. dalzellii	Eravikulam National Park	S.P.P.4852	KU316375	KU341089
8	I. gardneriana	Wayanad	S.P.P.4520	KF562062	KJ746912
9	I. herbicola	Neryamangalam	S.P.P.4505	KF562065	KJ746914
10	I. ligulata	Wayanad	S.P.P.4530	KF562063	KJ746916
11	I. minor	Neryamangalam	S.P.P.4504	KF447375	KJ703108
12	I. oppositifolia	Eravikulam National Park	S.P.P.4855	KU316382	KU341092
13	I. raziana	Eravikulam National Park	S.P.P.4851	KU316379	KU341093
14	I. tomentosa	Agasthyamala Biosphere Reserve	S.P.P.4861	KU316386	KU341094
Section: Microcepalae
15	I. bababudenensis	Anamudi Hills	S.P.P.4548	KU316373	KU341087
16	I. balsamina	Munnar	S.P.P.4517	KF582043	KJ746906
17	I. dasysperma	Neryamangalam	S.P.P.4506	KM360163	KJ746909
18	I. latifolia	Eravikulam National Park	S.P.P.4549	KU316378	KU508414
19	I. mysorensis	Wayanad	S.P.P.4534	KF582048	KU508416
20	I. pulcherrima	Eravikulam National Park	S.P.P.4853	KU316384	KU508417
21	I. scabriuscula	Wayanad	S.P.P.4531	KF562058	KJ746921
22	I. walleriana	Munnar	S.P.P.4518	KF58205	0KJ746925
Section: Tomentosae
23	I. johnii	Wayanad	S.P.P.4543	KU316377	KJ746915
24	I. munronii	Wayanad	S.P.P.4532	KF582047	KU508415
25	I. neo-munronii	Wayanad	S.P.P.4523	KF562061	KJ746919
Section: Sub-Umbellatae
26	I. cordata	Munnar	S.P.P.4515	KF582044	KU508411
27	I. disotis	Wayanad	S.P.P.4528	KF582042	KU508412
28	I. uncinata	Wayanad	S.P.P.4529	KF562057	KJ746923
Section: Racemosae
29	I. maculata	Devikulam	S.P.P.4507	KF562056	KJ746918
30	I. wightiana	Wayanad	S.P.P.4522	KF582052	KJ746926

^aAll locations in Kerala, India

Total genomic DNA was extracted using Gen Elute Plant Genomic DNA Miniprep Kit (Sigma Aldrich, St. Louis, USA). For PCR amplification, OrionX h-Taq PCR Smart Mix (Origin, India) was used. The primers used for the amplification of the chloroplast atpB–rbcL intergenic spacer gene were IMP-atpB—5′-ACATCTAGTACCGGACCAATGA-3′ and IMP-rbcL—5′-AACACCAGCTTTGAATCCAA-3′ (10 pM each) (Janssens et al. 2006), and trnL-F region were trnL-F—c:5′-CGAAATCGGTAGACGCTACG-3′ and trnL-F—f:5′-ATTTGAACTGGTGACACGAG-3′ (10 pM each) (Taberlet et al. 1991).

The temperature profile of amplification of atpB–rbcL intergenic spacer region was as per Janssens et al. (2006), and that of trnL-F region was as per Taberlet et al. (1991). Amplification reactions were carried out in an Agilent Sure Cycler 8800 (Agilent Technologies, USA) (ESM Figs. 1S, 2S). Amplicons (atpB–rbcL amplicon of size 900 bp and trnL-F amplicon of size 600–650 bp) were sequenced in AB1 cycle sequencer (Scigenome Labs Pvt. Ltd., Cochin, Kerala, India).

All sequences generated in this study were subjected to a BLAST search (NCBI) against the GenBank nucleotide database and submitted to GenBank (Table 1). I. omeiana was selected as outgroup for phylogenetic analyses of Impatiens (Janssens et al. 2009). Sequences of Impatiens species from three diversity hotspots were collected from GenBank accessions (Table 2). The sequences were multiple aligned and edited using the CLUSTALW (Thomson et al. 1994) program incorporated in BioEdit 7.0.5.2 (Hall 1999).

Table 2.

Details of sequences of atpB–rbcL and trnL-F of Impatiens spp. obtained from GenBank

SI. no.	Place of origin and species name	Genbank accession number
		atpB–rbcL	trnL-F
East and Southeast Asia
1	I. aquatilis	DQ147811	KP776115
2	I. davidi	DQ147835	KP776129
3	I. faberi	DQ147841	KP776132
4	I. gongshanensis	KP776024	KP776135
5	I. napoensis	DQ147861	KP776146
6	I. omeiana	KC905619	KP776152
7	I. platychlaena	DQ147867	KP776154
8	I. soulieana	DQ147880	KP776164
9	I. uliginosa	DQ147887	KP776173
Africa
10	I. hians	DQ147849	EF649977
11	I. keilii	FJ826654	KP776138
12	I. mannii	FJ826660	EF649980
Himalaya
13	I. scabrida	DQ147877	KP776162

The Akaike information criterion (AIC) implemented in the program jModelTest version 2.1.5 (Darriba et al. 2012) was used to choose substitution models that best fit the data set. Bayesian inference analysis was carried out in MrBayes v.3.2.2 (Ronquist et al. 2012) in two independent runs, each with one heated chain and one cold chain and for one lakh generations. Convergence occurred when standard deviation (SD) of split frequencies fell below 0.05; the first 25% of MCMC generations were discarded as burn-in and a consensus phylogram was created. Posterior probability values were used to estimate branch support. Trees were visualized by Fig Tree, Tree Figure drawing tool version 1.4.2 (Rambaut 2014).

Results and discussion

Phylogenetic analysis of this study included two chloroplast regions (atpB–rbcL, trnL-F) from 30 sequences of South Indian Impatiens species. In addition, 13 sequences of each of these regions were obtained from NCBI database. To assess the level of congruence between these data sets, each data set was analyzed independently to see if they produced a similar topology. The separate analyses produced topologies similar to each other. In comparison with separate analyses, the combined phylogeny had a well-resolved topology.

The combined atpB–rbcL and trnL-F data matrix contained 1664 characters. A general time reversible model of evolution with invariant sites and a gamma distribution (GTR + I + G) was selected using jModelTest version 2.1.5. This model was used for the Bayesian inference (BI) analysis. The resulted tree by BI analysis had a well-resolved topology (Fig. 1). The resolved lineages of Impatiens species were grouped into four clades with strong Bayesian posterior probability (BPP) values. Two Southeast Asian species and the Himalayan species formed clade 1. Clade 2 included four Southeast Asian species. Two Southeast Asian species formed clade 3. Clade 4 was divided into two subclades, i.e., A and B (BPP of 1.00). Subclade A contained species of sections Racemosae, Sub-Umbellatae, Tomentosae, and Scapigerae (BPP of 1.00). Subclade B is divided into three subclades, i.e., B1, B2, and B3. African species (I. hians) formed Subclade B1. Subclade B2 included African species (I. keilii and I. mannii) and South Indian species of section Microsepalae with BPP of 0.89. Species of section Annuae produced Subclade B3 with BPP of 0.94.

Fig. 1.

Bayesian consensus cladogram based on combined sequences of chloroplast atpB–rbcL intergenic spacer and trnL-F genes. The numbers by the nodes indicate Bayesian posterior probabilities greater than 0.5

Implications on infrageneric classification and biogeography of Impatiens species of Western Ghats

Impatiens is considered taxonomically as one of the most difficult genera of angiosperms, mainly due to hypervariable structure and fragile nature of its flowers making examinations of dried specimen extremely difficult (Grey-Wilson 1980). The important revision of the African taxa by Grey-Wilson (1980) distinguished six informal infrageneric groups for the African species for practical diagnosis. Based on morphological and molecular data sets, Yu et al. (2015) presented a new classification of Impatiens, with the genus being divided into two subgenera, subgenus Clavicarpa and subgenus Impatiens. The subgenus Impatiens was further subdivided into seven sections.

In the taxonomic treatments of South Indian Impatiens by Bhaskar (2012), balsams of South India were classified under seven sections, i.e., Scapigerae, Epiphyticae, Annuae, Microsepalae, Tomentosae, Sub-Umbellatae, and Racemosae. Based on the present molecular phylogenetic study, species of each section formed monophyletic association with strong BPP support. This study authenticates the morphological classifications of Bhaskar (2012).

Based on several morphological similarities among species endemic to Africa and South India, close affinity between African and South Indian taxa and a possible migration route connecting these two areas were suggested (Grey-Wilson 1980). In this study, species of sections Microsepalae and Annuae showed African affinities with sister–clade relationships. This confirms Grey-Wilson’s (1980) suggestions of affinity between African and South Indian species. Sections Scapigerae, Sub-Umbellatae, Tomentosae, and Racemosae formed a separate clade (Subclade A) with sister–clade relationships with the extant Southeast Asian species.

There are several hypotheses related to the origin of Impatiens (Jones and Smith 1966; Grey-Wilson 1980). Bhaskar (1981) proposed that Western Ghats is the place of origin of the genus Impatiens. His hypothesis was based on the observation that Western Ghats of India contains the phylogenetically old species with primitive radial pollen grains, diploid chromosome number, and shrubby habit.

ITS phylogeny of Yuan et al. (2004) and atpB–rbcL phylogeny of Janssens et al. (2006) revealed that Impatiens spp. colonized African continent from Southwest China in three independent dispersal events. Madagascan species was derived from a single colonization event (Janssens et al. 2009). The present combined chloroplast gene analysis contained only three African and no Madagascan species. In this African species, I. keilii and I. mannii were placed with species of section Microsepalae. Section Annuae formed a sister–clade with this section. Himalayan species (I. scabrida) showed affinity to Southeast Asian species (I. aquatilis and I. uliginosa).

The biogeographical elucidation based on the present study is mainly in accordance with the conclusion of Yuan et al. (2004). The present analysis postulated that South India was colonized by two independent dispersal events, i.e., once by Southeast Asian ancestor as shown by the sister–clade relationships of extant Southeast Asian species and the sections Scapigerae, Tomentosae, Sub-Umbellatae, and Racemosae and a more recent colonization by an ancestor with African affinities (sections Microsepalae and Annuae).

Electronic supplementary material

Below is the link to the electronic supplementary material.

Compliance with ethical standards

Conflict of interest

The authors declare that they have no conflict of interest.