Durability-enhanced two-dimensional hole gas of C-H diamond surface for complementary power inverter applications

Abstract

Complementary power field effect transistors (FETs) based on wide bandgap materials not only provide high-voltage switching capability with the reduction of on-resistance and switching losses, but also enable a smart inverter system by the dramatic simplification of external circuits. However, p-channel power FETs with equivalent performance to those of n-channel FETs are not obtained in any wide bandgap material other than diamond. Here we show that a breakdown voltage of more than 1600 V has been obtained in a diamond metal-oxide-semiconductor (MOS) FET with a p-channel based on a two-dimensional hole gas (2DHG). Atomic layer deposited (ALD) Al₂O₃ induces the 2DHG ubiquitously on a hydrogen-terminated (C-H) diamond surface and also acts as both gate insulator and passivation layer. The high voltage performance is equivalent to that of state-of-the-art SiC planar n-channel FETs and AlGaN/GaN FETs. The drain current density in the on-state is also comparable to that of these two FETs with similar device size and V_B.

In an ideal inverter system (Fig. 1) for next-generation power conversion systems, a combination of n-channel and p-channel power field-effect transistors (FETs) with equivalent power switching performance is required to achieve complementary operation for power compact systems such as simple gate drive circuits. Diamond, in addition to having the highest reported breakdown field and thermal conductivity, also has the highest hole mobility¹, the highest p-type conductivity²,³ and a two-dimensional hole gas (2DHG)⁴ that makes it a unique and fascinating p-channel material for complementary inverter applications (Fig. 1). In wide bandgap semiconductors, such as III-nitrides, p-type conductivity is much less prevalent than n-type conductivity. The superior p-type nature of diamond enables its use in p-channel FETs; the highest drain current density was reported in wide bandgap p-channel FETs at more than 1 A/mm⁵ and an on-resistance of 4 Ωmm at a submicron gate length that is comparable to that of n-channel AlGaN/GaN FETs⁶, because the surface density of the 2DHG is as high as 10¹²,¹³ cm^−2  7,⁸. The 2DHG appears where there is a hydrogen-terminated (C-H) diamond surface that has appropriate adsorbates⁹,¹⁰ or film coatings⁹ to induce holes (Supplementary Fig. S1).

Figure 1. System of complementary wide bandgap semiconductor devices such as that used for power inverters, where the source potentials of the n-channel FETs in the lower arm and the p-channel FETs in the upper arm are fixed at ground level and at a high level, respectively.

This is an almost ideal circuit and is much simpler than that used in current inverter circuits, in which n-channel FETs are used in both the upper and lower arms, and the source potential in the upper arm is not fixed and thus must be changed by on-off switching. An extra gate drive circuit is needed in the current inverter circuit to apply the appropriate gate-source voltage, but is not required in the complementary system shown.

The reliability of C-H diamond FETs has been improved by the passivation¹¹,¹² of the adsorbates on C-H diamond by Al₂O₃ atomic layer deposition (ALD). Recently, the high-temperature stability of a 2DHG¹³ was reported after ALD of Al₂O₃ at 450 °C on a cleaned C-H diamond surface by in situ removal of the adsorbates immediately before the ALD process. The 2DHG is generated by the ALD Al₂O₃ itself, and not necessarily by the adsorbates. The ALD Al₂O₃ film induces hole accumulation on the n-type Si (n-Si) surface, i.e., a p-type inversion layer¹⁴ is produced by the negative charging (electron occupation) of Al₂O₃ near its interface with n-Si. At the C-H diamond surface, hole accumulation is caused by the negative charging of unoccupied levels such as the interstitial oxygen point defects O_i¹⁵,¹⁶ or the aluminium vacancies V_AL¹⁵. These levels are located below the C-H diamond valence band edge, as shown in Fig. 2a. The Oi level (unoccupied states) is located 1.0 eV¹⁶ above the valence band edge and the valence band offsets between C-H diamond and Al₂O₃ are 2.9 eV¹⁷ and 3.9 eV¹⁸, respectively. When the Oi states near the interface are occupied by electrons with a density of more than 10¹² cm⁻², 2DHG formation with an equivalent hole density near the interface in C-H diamond satisfies the charge neutrality condition.

Figure 2.

(a) Energy band diagram of interface between Al₂O₃ and H-terminated (C-H) diamond. The band offset at the valence band edge is 3.0–4.0 eV¹⁷,¹⁸. Oi is the unoccupied energy level of the interstitial oxygen located at 1.0 eV from the valence band edge of Al₂O₃. Oi is negatively charged and holes thus accumulate at the C-H diamond surface. (b) Cross-sectional and (c) 3D structure representations of C-H diamond FET with 200-nm-thick Al₂O₃ gate insulator and drift passivation layer with an asymmetric source and drain structure, where the gate-drain distance L_GD was varied from 1 μm up to 25 μm. Electric field distribution along the Al₂O₃/C-H diamond interface is schematically shown in (b), where a cross symbol indicates the point of the highest electric field on the diamond side.

Using the high temperature (450 °C) ALD Al₂O₃ as gate oxide and passivation of gate-drain region (drift region), a C-H diamond metal oxide semiconductor (MOS) FET was uniquely designed for high-voltage and high-temperature operation. It is shown schematically as a cross-sectional structure in Fig. 2b and as a 3D image in Fig. 2c. The MOSFET shows clear pinch-off and saturation characteristics with a high on-off ratio in the temperature range from −263 °C (10 K) to 400 °C (673 K) (Supplementary Figs S2 and S3).

We consider two typical MOSFETs, which both have Al₂O₃ gates; the first has a passivation oxide thickness of 200 nm, a gate length (L_G) of 2 μm, a source-gate distance (L_SG) of 2 μm and a gate-drain distance (L_GD) of 17 μm, while the second has an oxide thickness of 400 nm, an L_G of 9 μm, an L_SG of 3 μm and an L_GD of 16 μm, and their maximum drain current densities (I_DS) were 116 mA/mm and 110 mA/mm, according to their I_DS-V_DS characteristics (Fig. 3a and c), respectively. The two MOSFETs exhibited breakdown voltages (V_B) of 1538 V and 1662 V (Fig. 4a, Fig. 5), respectively. Using a device simulation based on the two-dimensional negatively charged sheet model (Fig. 2a, Fig. 6a, Supplementary Fig. S4), the I_DS-V_DS characteristics shown in Fig. 3a were reproduced almost exactly in terms of their V_GS dependence in Fig. 3b using a negative charge areal density (N_S) of 5 × 10¹² e cm⁻² with a hole channel mobility of 80 cm²V⁻¹ s⁻¹ at the Al₂O₃/C-H diamond interface. In general, the charge sheet model is successful in reproducing the characteristics of an AlGaN/GaN FET, where the interface polarization produces the positive charge sheet that is responsible for the two-dimensional electron gas. At the Al₂O₃/C-H diamond interface, a 2DHG might be formed by the negatively charged sites near the interface as shown in Fig. 2a.

Figure 3. I_DS-V_DS characteristics at low drain bias and various gate voltages for a diamond FET with breakdown voltages of 1538 V and 1662 V.

Saturation behaviour is observed at V_GS > 0 V and pinch-off is obtained at V_GS = 30 V. (a) L_G = 2 μm, L_GD = 17 μm, and oxide thickness of 200 nm, (b) Simulation of (a); (c) L_G = 9 μm, L_GD = 16 μm, and oxide thickness of 400 nm.

Figure 4. Logarithmic I_D-V_DS characteristics showing the blocking behaviour of C-H diamond MOSFETs with a common gate width (25 μm) in the off-state for various L_GD values of 9, 16, 17, 20 and 22 μm.

Solid lines represent the source-drain current (I_DS) and dotted lines represent the source-gate-drain current (I_DGS).(a) For L_GD values of 9, 16, and 22 μm, the breakdown voltages are V_B = 996, 1662, and 1646 V at room temperature, respectively. (b) For L_GD of 17 μm, the breakdown voltages are V_B = 1516 and 1270 V at 200 °C and 300 °C, respectively.

Figure 5. Maximum breakdown voltage (V_B) as a function of gate-drain length (L_GD).

The MOSFETs are composed of a 200-nm-thick Al₂O₃ layer as the gate insulator and 200- or 400-nm-thick Al₂O₃ layers acting as a passivation layer between the gate metal and drain metal. V_GS for the off-states are +20- + 60 V.

Figure 6.

(a) Simulation model for a MOSFET displaying the I_DS-V_DS characteristics shown in Fig. 3a. A MOS structure is composed of metal, Al₂O₃ and undoped diamond. Source and drain metals contact with the undoped diamond at both edges with 0 eV Schottky barrier height. Negative and positive charge sheets are spaced at the Al₂O₃/diamond interface and at the bottom of undoped diamond, respectively. (b) Electric field distributions along the Al₂O₃/C-H diamond interface that were calculated using the model shown in (a), where the Al₂O₃ thickness is 200 nm. (c) The same electric field distributions, calculated when the Al₂O₃ thickness is 400 nm.

The off-state characteristics before breakdown of the diamond MOSFETs of Al₂O₃ (mostly 200 nm in thickness) with a common gate width (25 μm) and different gate-drain length (L_GD) values of 9, 16, 17, and 22 μm were investigated at room temperature (RT) and at higher temperatures until breakdown started to occur, and the results are shown in Fig. 4. V_GS for the off-states are +20- + 60 V. The maximum V_B at each L_GD are 996 V (L_GD = 9 μm), 1270 V (20 μm, 300 °C), 1512 V (17 μm, 200 °C), 1646 V (22 μm), and 1662 V (16 μm, with a thicker oxide layer of 400 nm). The source-drain current (drain leakage current) I_DS gradually increases at higher temperatures. At 800 V, the leakage currents at room temperature range from 2 × 10⁻⁷ to 5 × 10⁻⁶ A/mm (Fig. 4a) and the corresponding values at 200 and 300 °C are 8 × 10⁻⁶ A/mm and 10⁻³ A/mm (Fig. 4b), respectively. In general, the drain leakage current increases gradually at a high voltage (high electric field) and breakdown starts to occur. These values are acceptable for power device applications. In contrast, the source-gate-drain current (or gate leakage current) I_DGS is one to two orders of magnitude less than I_DS, as shown in Fig. 4. At the start of the breakdown process, when I_DGS reaches I_DS, gate-drain breakdown through the gate oxide may be a main cause. One such example is a FET with L_GD = 9 μm and V_B = 996 V (see Fig. 4a). In other cases, however, I_DGS is less than I_DS by more than an order of magnitude at breakdown. Most breakdown processes are initiated at the drift region near the gate.

The maximum breakdown voltage V_B at each L_GD is shown in Fig. 5 with two different passivation thicknesses (200 nm and 400 nm). When L_GD is 1 μm, V_B = 365 V is obtained (Supplementary Fig. S5). For a short L_GD of 1 μm, the punch-through condition (under which the difference between the electric fields along the Al₂O₃ /C-H diamond interface on the gate and drain sides is small) has been applied based on the electric field distribution that can be calculated via device simulations, as discussed later in this work. The averaged electric field is simply calculated to be V_B/L_GD = 3.6 MV/cm. This value is equivalent to that of the breakdown fields of SiC and GaN. As L_GD increases to 9 μm, V_B also increases and reaches 996 V at L_GD = 9μm. As L_GD increases further, V_B also increases correspondingly until L_GD = 22 μm. V_B values of 1600 V and 1646 V are obtained at L_GD = 20 and 22 μm (Fig. 5), respectively. With a thicker (400 nm) Al₂O₃ passivation layer between the gate and the drain, V_B values from 1097 to 1708 V are obtained from L_GD = 11 to 16 μm (Fig. 5). When a thicker oxide layer is used, V_B increases above 1000 V up to 1700 V with increasing L_GD. The peak electric field at diamond side with thicker passivation layer (400 nm) is decreased by 25–30% compared with that of 200 nm thickness (discussed later). The V_B of 1708 V (Supplementary Fig. S6) is the highest value ever reported for a diamond FET with on-state I_DS~100 mA/mm, and is comparable to that of SiC¹⁹ or AlGaN/GaN²⁰,²¹ FETs with similar L_GD (Table 1).

Table 1. Comparison of maximum breakdown voltages V_{B Max} and maximum drain current density I_{D Max} at a particular L_GD less than 20 μm in planar FETs of SiC, AlGaN/GaN, AlGaN/AlGaN, and diamond.

Wide Bandgap Planar FETs	VB MAXBreakdow Voltage	LGD Gate Drain Distance	VB/LGDBreakdown Field	ID MAXDrain Current Density
SiC n-FET19	1600 V	20 μm	0.8 MV/cm	90 mA/mm
AlGaN/GaN20,21 n-FET	1500 V	15 μm	1.0 MV/cm	300-600 mA/mm
AlGaN/AlGaN22 n-FET	1700 V	10 μm	1.7 MV/cm	200 mA/mm
C-H Diamond p-FET	1700 V	16 μm	1.0 MV/cm	110 mA/mm

In the off-state of the MOSFET with the two-dimensional negative charge sheet (Fig. 2a, Fig. 6a), the electric field along the Al₂O₃/C-H diamond interface in the lateral direction contains a peak that occurs near the gate edge, as indicated by the cross shown in Fig. 2b, with a maximum value denoted by E_M. The electric field along the Al₂O₃/diamond interface decreases with increasing distance from the gate edge, and almost reaches zero at a distance L₀ from the gate edge. The electric field distribution along the Al₂O₃/diamond interface is evaluated using MOSFET device simulations with various densities (N_S) of the 2D negative charges (1 × 10¹¹ × 10¹³ cm⁻²) that were distributed homogeneously at the Al₂O₃/C-H diamond interface (Fig. 6a). In Fig. 6b and c, along the Al₂O₃/diamond interface, several of the electric field distributions that are responsible for V_DS = 1600 V are shown for various N_S. The reason why V_DS = 1600 V was selected as an example here is that it is approximately equal to the frequently observed value of the highest operating voltage that is available in FETs at present. The V_GS for the off-state is maintained at 30 V, so the gate-drain voltage drop is higher than the source-drain voltage drop. However, the gate potential does not have a major effect on the electric field or the potential distribution between the source and the drain. E_M is effectively reduced by the thicker Al₂O₃ (400-nm-thick) layer at each N_S. At N_S = 5 × 10¹² cm⁻², which reproduces an experimental I_DS-V_DS characteristic in the on-state (Fig. 3a and b), the E_M and L₀ values with the 200-nm-thick Al₂O₃ layer are calculated to be 8.1 MV/cm and 3.5 μm at V_DS = 1600 V (Fig. 6b), respectively. The corresponding values when using a 400-nm-thick Al₂O₃ layer are calculated to be 5.9 MV/cm and 4.5 μm at 1600 V, respectively (Fig. 6c). Because the voltage drop of 1600 V occurs within the calculated L₀ (<5 μm), MOSFETs with V_B ~1600 V are expected to be realized at an L_GD of just over 5 μm, but are actually obtained experimentally at L_GD > 16 μm (Fig. 5). This inconsistent result indicates that that the real value of L₀ is greater and the real E_M is smaller than the values calculated based on N_S = 5 × 10¹² cm⁻². It is reasonable that the effective value of N_S is much lower than 5 × 10¹² cm⁻². At N_S = 3 × 10¹¹ cm⁻², L₀ reaches 16 μm, as shown in Fig. 6b and c. The fact that V_B ~1600 V is obtained at an L_GD of more than 16 μm indicates that N_S < 3 × 10¹¹ cm⁻². As shown in Fig. 5, the maximum value of V_B is roughly proportional to L_GD. This behaviour may also be caused by a lower effective charge density, such as N_S < 3 × 10¹¹ cm⁻².

The original negative charge density can be either reduced or cancelled in one of two main ways. The first involves hole injection into the Al₂O₃ layer on an undoped diamond layer. Energetic (hot) holes that are accelerated by a high electric field can enter the Al₂O₃ layer beyond the large band offset between the Al₂O₃ layer and C-H diamond (2.9–3.9 eV) (Fig. 2a)¹⁷,¹⁸. This effect on the electric field distribution can also be simulated using smaller N_S values such as N_S = 1 × 10¹² and 3 × 10¹¹ cm⁻², as shown in Fig. 6b and c. The other way involves use of positively ionized nitrogen donors in a nitrogen-doped diamond substrate (nitrogen concentration of 10¹⁹ cm⁻³) under the undoped diamond layer (Fig. 2b). Substitutional nitrogen atoms that act as deep donors can be positively ionized via hole recombination with an electron from a neutral nitrogen donor. The deep donor level (1.7 eV) means that this positive charge can be maintained for a long time because of the very low density of the conduction electrons. The ionized donors are randomly distributed in a nitrogen-doped substrate beneath the undoped layer. For simplicity, we assume here that the donors are distributed as a positive charge sheet with a charge areal density of N_B. In the device simulations, it is varied from 1–6 × 10¹² cm⁻² at the bottom of the undoped diamond (Fig. 6a) and N_S is fixed at 5 × 10¹² cm⁻² (N_S0), then N_B compensates N_S0 to produce N_S0 − N_B. When N_S0 − N_B produces values of 1 × 10¹² and 3 × 10¹¹ cm⁻², the corresponding electric field distributions (which are not shown here) are calculated to be almost the same as those shown at N_S = 1 × 10¹² and 3 × 10¹¹ cm⁻² in Fig. 6b and c. When N_S0 − N_B = 0, perfect charge compensation occurs and the electric field distribution becomes flat, as shown in Fig. 5b and c (indicated by the green lines). This is an ideal situation for high-voltage device structures such as super-junctions. When 1 × 10¹² cm⁻² > N_S0 − N_B > −1 × 10¹² cm⁻². the maximum I_DS is preserved at 60–90% of the value obtained by the N_S0 (Fig. 3b), indicating that the positively charged embedded layer does not reduce the channel and drift hole conduction so greatly near the surface.

The drain current density (I_DS) of the diamond FET with the breakdown voltage of 1538 V and 1662 V exceeds 100 mA/mm, according to the I_DS-V_DS characteristics at low drain bias shown in Fig. 3. Saturation behaviour is observed at V_GS > 0 V and pinch-off is obtained at V_GS = 50 V. At V_GS < 0 V, the drain current increases and becomes linear. Finally, the drain current does not increase further upon application of a more negative gate bias. The saturated slope of the I_DS-V_DS characteristic is mainly due to the gate-drain resistance, because it is the main resistive part of the high voltage device. However, the total drain on-current for a source-to-drain distance of 25–30 μm is more than 100 mA/mm, which is comparable to the corresponding currents of SiC lateral MOSFETs (90 mA/mm)¹⁹, AlGaN/GaN HFETs (300–600 mA/mm)²⁰,²¹ and AlGaN/AlGaN HFETs (200 mA/mm)²² with an equivalent device size and V_B (Table 1). A higher on-current can be achieved at a lower V_DS by increasing either the hole areal density or the sub-surface mobility.

The maximum I_DS was investigated as a function of temperature for diamond FETs with the C-H channel (2DHG) and with a boron-doped channel (Fig. 7). The I_DS of the C-H channel only changes by approximately 40% from −263 °C to 300 °C. In the C-H channel MOSFETs, which show V_B of more than 1000 V, I_DS is approximately 20 mA/mm at V_DS = 10 V and approximately 100 mA/mm at V_DS = 50 V at room temperature. At higher temperatures, I_DS decreases slightly because of the reduction in hole mobility caused by phonon scattering. In contrast, the boron-doped channel FETs with a high V_B of more than 600 V show a rapid increase in I_DS by more than one order of magnitude over the range from room temperature to 200–300 °C. This is caused by the activation of boron as a relatively deep acceptor (0.37 eV), with doping levels of 5 × 10¹⁵ and 1 × 10¹⁷ cm⁻³ in the metal-semiconductor field-effect transistor (MESFET)²³ and the junction FET (JFET)²⁴,²⁵, respectively. The drain current densities of the 2DHG channel are more than two orders and one order of magnitude higher than those of the boron-doped channel at room temperature and in 200–300 °C range, respectively.

Figure 7. Temperature dependence of maximum drain current density (I_DS) of diamond FETs.

The current density is normalized with respect to the gate width. The temperature dependence of a MOSFET under drain source bias of 10 V and 50 V and that of a junction FET²⁵ and a MESFET²³ with a boron-doped channel at V_DS = 10 V are also shown.

Junction FETs, including MESFETs, regulate their depletion layer fronts far away from their p-n or MES junctions to control their bulk p-type channel thicknesses. Therefore, the drain current controllability in these FETs is low, but the current is stable because the channel carriers are not affected by the junction charge. Because a MOSFET can control surface band bending, the current response of its gate is efficient, but it is also sensitive to interface charge. The 2DHG that occurs at the Al₂O₃/C-H diamond interface may originate from the electric field (band bending) that is induced by the negative charges in Al₂O₃ near the interface and the applied gate voltage. The drain current can be increased or reduced effectively, because the C-H surface has a very low surface state density when compared with that of the C-O surface that is normally used in MESFETs.

High performance 2DHG diamond MOSFETs with submicron gate lengths have already obtained maximum current densities of 1.2–1.3 A/mm⁵,²⁶, on-resistances of 4–6 Ωmm⁵, and transconductances of 200–480 mS/mm⁵. These values are comparable to those of AlGaN/GaN devices of the same size. In the long L_GD diamond FETs that are used for high voltage applications, however, the drain current density and the transconductance become more than one order of magnitude lower because of the low mobility (70–100 cm²V⁻¹ s⁻¹) in the 2DHG drift layer. Mobility enhancement of the 2DHG layer by up to 500 cm² V⁻¹s⁻¹ or the discovery of a shallow acceptor with an acceptor level that is lower than 0.2 eV will dramatically improve the specific on-resistance for high voltage applications.

Conclusions

By creation of a 2DHG using a high-temperature ALD Al₂O₃ layer on a C-H bond diamond surface, the following p-channel MOSFET characteristics have been obtained.

1) Off-state. When L_GD increases from 1 μm to 22 μm, V_B increases up to roughly 1600 V in the off-state with the increasing L_GD. The maximum breakdown voltage is 1700 V at room temperature, 1500 V at 200 °C and 1200 V at 300 °C and 400 °C.

2) On-state. In the high voltage FET with V_B of 1600 V, the maximum current density in the on-state when normalized with respect to the channel width is 100 mA/mm and is nearly constant from −200 °C (73 K) to 400 °C (673 K).

These high-voltage breakdown characteristics in the off-state and the drain current density per unit gate width in the on-state are comparable to those characteristics of lateral SiC and III-nitride FETs. Because the 2DHG at the C-H diamond surface is ubiquitous and was stably covered with ALD Al₂O₃, the above FET performance can easily be transferred to vertical power devices such as trench gate MOSFETs. These results demonstrates the potential for application of a diamond p channel FET as a smart power inverter using complementary power FETs (Fig.1).

Method

The C-H diamond MOSFET for high voltage and high temperature operation is shown schematically as a cross-sectional structure in Fig. 2b and as a 3D image in Fig. 2c. The MOSFET fabrication process without deterioration of the C-H bonds is briefly described in the following. The starting substrate is synthetic diamond (001), which was formed under high-pressure and high-temperature (HPHT) conditions. In this HPHT synthetic diamond, nitrogen atoms are incorporated as deep donors at a concentration of 10¹⁹ cm⁻³. On this substrate, a nominally undoped diamond layer is homoepitaxially grown by microwave plasma-assisted chemical vapour deposition to a thickness of 0.5 μm (Supplementary Fig. S7a). Source and drain metal contacts are then formed by Au/Ti deposition (Supplementary Fig. S7b). Most of the surface area, except for the source and drain contacts, is then H-terminated by remote plasma treatment at 600 °C (Supplementary Fig. S7c). During that time, TiC is formed to erode the diamond layer to a depth of a few nm and subsequently form a stable contact to the diamond. The H-terminations are replaced with O-terminations through a local oxidation process to form an isolated region, and thus an H-terminated channel remains between the source and drain (Supplementary Fig.S7d). Al₂O₃ is then deposited at 450 °C by ALD to simultaneously form the gate insulator and the passivation layer (Supplementary Fig. S7e). During Al₂O₃ formation, the conditions required for the 2DHG are satisfied. Finally, the gate metal (Al) is deposited and the gate is patterned using a lift-off process (Fig. 2c, Supplementary Fig. S7f).

Additional Information

How to cite this article: Kawarada, H. et al. Durability-enhanced two-dimensional hole gas of C-H diamond surface for complementary power inverter applications. Sci. Rep. 7, 42368; doi: 10.1038/srep42368 (2017).

Publisher's note: Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.