Current applications and future prospects of nanomaterials in tumor therapy

Abstract

Tumors are one of the most serious human diseases and cause numerous global deaths per year. In spite of many strategies applied in tumor therapy, such as radiation therapy, chemotherapy, surgery, and a combination of these treatments, tumors are still the foremost killer worldwide among human diseases, due to their specific limitations, such as multidrug resistance and side effects. Therefore, it is urgent and necessary to develop new strategies for tumor therapy. Recently, the fast development of nanoscience has paved the way for designing new strategies to treat tumors. Nanomaterials have shown great potential in tumor therapy, due to their unique properties, including passive targeting, hyperthermia effects, and tumor-specific inhibition. This review summarizes the recent progress using the innate antitumor properties of metallic and nonmetallic nanomaterials to treat tumors, and related challenges and prospects are discussed.

Introduction

The development of tumors occurs at the molecular level¹ when multiple subgroups of genes undergo genetic alterations. Either tumor-suppressor genes are inactivated or oncogenes are activated, which leads to malignant proliferation of tumor cells, tissue infiltration, and organ dysfunction.² Many methods have been developed for tumor therapy, such as immunotherapy,^3,4 gene therapy,^5,6 and radiofrequency ablation (RFA).^7–9 Nevertheless, traditional radiotherapy,^10,11 surgery,^12–14 and especially chemotherapy^15,16 are still the major strategies utilized in clinical tumor treatments. However, chemotherapy has a number of problems, including nonspecific distribution of the drug and the lack of tumor-specific treatments.¹⁷ In the continuous fight against tumors, patients have to be administered drugs that increase in dose over time, which is associated with considerable adverse effects, such as multidrug resistance and accumulative systemic toxicity. Chemotherapy also causes side effects in healthy tissues, which have negative impacts on the quality of life of the patients.^18,19 In addition, chemotherapy may concomitantly damage adjacent organs or tissues, and these adverse effects are difficult to avoid.^20,21

In recent decades, the development of nanotechnology has provided an opportunity to overcome the aforementioned side effects. The integration of various nanomaterials (NMs) with spectroscopic, biochemical, and optical methods has allowed the development of advanced methods for tumor therapy, which may revolutionize the treatment of tumors. An emerging approach is to utilize nanotechnology and NMs to minimize toxicity to healthy tissues. Various NMs have performed attractively in various aspects of antitumor treatment and garnered intense research interest, and they have presented great potential for antitumor treatment by enhancing the effectiveness of treatments and reducing systemic side effects.

The term “nano-” is derived from the Greek noun nanos,²² and a nanometer (nm) is equivalent to 10⁻⁹ m.²³ The specific physical and/or chemical properties of NMs make them very attractive in biomedical applications.^24,25 Over the past few decades, the explosion of studies involving NMs can be ascribed to their special optical, thermodynamic, magnetic, and mechanical properties.^26–28 Potential medical applications of NMs have been recognized to have good biocompatibility.²⁹ Nanoparticles (NPs) with suitable diameter range have been reported to be able to enter blood circulation and undergo endocytosis into cells.³⁰ Furthermore, scientific research shows that NM-based therapeutics have great potential in the treatment of tumors, diabetes, infection, neurodegenerative disease, and inflammation.^31–33 The integration of tumor therapy with NMs is expected to bring about new breakthroughs for nanotechnology in the field of medicine.

The physical and chemical properties of NMs impact on biodistribution, cellular processes, and cytotoxic effects.^27,34,35 For example, the size of the NM affects cellular tropism by facilitating or inhibiting actin polymerization.³⁶ In addition to size, the shape of NMs influences organ and cellular tropism.³⁷ Spherical NMs promote phagocytosis of macrophages, but disk-shaped structures do not. By tailoring these aspects, specific properties of NMs can be used to design new biomedical applications, which include various clinical and research activities and modulation of processes in target cells.³⁸ With the development of nanotechnology, the integration of NMs into tumor therapeutics is one of the rapidly advancing fields, and more new NMs will be increasingly used in the field of tumor treatment.

Based on nanotechnology, various NMs have been developed, such as iron oxide NPs, gold NPs (AuNPs), cerium oxide NPs, carbon-based materials, polymeric NPs, and quantum dots (QDs).^39–44 NMs have shown great potential in tumor prevention, detection, diagnosis, imaging, and treatment. Due to their specific physical, chemical, and biological properties and unique structure, NMs are able to work at the molecular level. Therefore, NMs themselves are antigenic or medicinally active, and can stimulate a strong immune response in the body.⁴⁵ Some NMs can kill or inhibit pathogenic cell types by exploiting their autoimmunity or cellular toxicity (selective block by toxicity).^46–48 Various NMs themselves are used as potential antitumor drugs, and are being developed as photothermal therapy (PTT) agents.^49,50 Therefore, this review discusses some specific metallic NMs (MNMs) and nonmetallic NMs that act as a medicine or drug additive in tumor therapy (Figure 1).

Figure 1.

Metallic and nonmetallic nanomaterials that act as active medicine or drug additive in tumor therapy through their innate antitumor properties.

Abbreviations: NMs, nanomaterials; NPs, nanoparticles.

Metallic NMs

MNMs are metal or metal oxide nanocrystals. MNMs are readily prepared, have surfaces relatively easy to modify, and in general have low toxicity.^51,52 Because of their unique properties, the advantage of using MNMs lies primarily in their ability to interact directly with cell membranes and intracellular structures.^41,42 As discussed earlier, these special properties make MNMs useful for numerous diagnostic and therapeutic applications.⁵³ Most MNMs for tumor therapy consist of iron oxide, gold NPs, and cerium oxide NPs (Figure 2).^54–57

Figure 2.

Transmission electron microscope images of (A) iron oxide nanoparticles; (B) gold nanoparticles; (C) gold nanocages; (D) cerium oxide nanoparticles.

Notes: Figure A adapted with permission from Bronstein LM, Huang XL, Retrum J, et al. Influence of iron oleate complex structure on iron oxide nanoparticle formation. Chem Mater. 2007;19(15):3624–3632. Copyright © 2007, American Chemical Society.⁵⁴ Figure B adapted with permission from Schulz-Dobrick M, Sarathy KV, Jansen M. Surfactant-free synthesis and functionalization of gold nanoparticles. J Am Chem Soc. 2005;127(37):12816–12817. Copyright © 2007, American Chemical Society.⁵⁵ Figure C adapted with permission from Chen JY, Wang DL, Xi JF, et al. Immuno gold nanocages with tailored optical properties for targeted photothermal destruction of cancer cells. Nano Lett. 2007;7(5):1318–1322. Copyright © 2007, American Chemical Society.⁵⁶ The method reported in Lee et al⁵⁷ was used when creating the nanoparticles shown in Figure D.

Iron oxide

Iron oxide is a type of magnetic material that is used in tumor PTT and targeted therapy. PTT is based on using optical heating to facilitate direct and specific destruction of tumor cells.⁵⁸ PTT is a highly promising approach to tumor therapy. Phototherapy employs near-infrared light (NIR)-absorbing agents with high absorption in the NIR region, which then release vibrational energy (heat) to kill the targeted tumor cells.

Fe₃O₄-based magnetic NPs are recognized as promising hyperthermia-specific agents. To treat metastatic bone tumors, Matsumine et al⁵⁹ used novel Fe₃O₄ powder for hyperthermia-induced apoptosis in several patients. One week later, after incorporating Fe₃O₄ in the adhesive that repaired the bone, patients were subjected to a localized electromagnetic field at a temperature estimated to be 40°C–45°C, in order to improve the lesion. This treatment stopped further metastatic progression, and demonstrated the benefit of using iron oxide in bone-tumor treatments.

In addition to PTT, potential medical applications of magnetic NPs have also been approved, due to their good biocompatibility.²⁶ According to a recent report, magnetic NPs with diameters ranging between several (~9 nm) and hundreds (~200 nm) of nanometers can circulate in blood vessels and undergo endocytosis into cells.⁶⁰ The authors also found that dimercaptosuccinic acid-coated iron oxide NPs have excellent potential for applications that target breast-tumor cells.

Furthermore, Fe₃O₄ NPs can be functionalized using antibodies and achieve active targeted tumor therapy. There is a report of using anti-HER2-conjugated polypyrrole-Fe₃O₄ NPs to target and damage SK-BR-3 breast tumor cells in vitro.⁶¹ In fact, superparamagnetic iron oxide NPs (SPIONs; Fe₃O₄ or Fe₂O₃)⁶² have been recognized for clinical use in the form of ferucarbotran (carboxydextran SPIONs), ferumoxides (dextran SPIONs), and ferumoxtran 10 (dextran SPIONs).⁶³ These SPIONs are highly biodegradable and biocompatible; the iron core is recycled into soluble ferritin iron or hemosiderin.⁶⁴ Iron oxide NPs are also intensively used in imaging system as contrast agents in pathophysiological studies.⁶⁵

Gold NMs

In recent years, AuNMs have shown important potential in various biomedical and research applications, such as catalysis, bioanalysis, and imaging.^66,67 The preparation technology is simple, and it is easy to control the size and shape of AuNMs.^68,69 It has been reported that AuNMs can selectively and specifically recognize tumor cells.^70,71 Studies reported in the literature have shown that AuNMs are easily functionalized, increase the time of circulation, and are stable in systemic circulation. In addition, AuNMs have low toxicity and protect drugs from potential transformation in tissues and organs. Perhaps the most important property of AuNMs is their ability to destroy tumor cells.⁷² Thus, such AuNMs as AuNPs^73,74 and gold nanocages⁵⁶ are a promising tool for selectively killing tumor cells through photothermal (PT) damage.

AuNPs can enhance the apoptotic effect of tumors,⁷ which makes it possible to decrease radiation doses, thereby reducing side effects on surrounding normal tissues. AuNPs can also enhance the effect of radiotherapy, which has been verified in vivo and in vitro in animal models of tumors.⁷² AuNPs are commonly used as nanobioconjugates.^69,70,73 The functionalization of NPs (eg, with polyethylene glycol [PEG] or antibodies) allows the nanobioconjugates to remain in the bloodstream and preferentially accumulate in tumor tissue. These nanobioconjugates have the ability to penetrate the cell nucleus, increasing the likelihood that the active cytostatic substance acts directly on DNA.⁷⁴ Studies reported in the literature have shown that multifunctional AuNPs can be used both to image and treat tumors.⁷⁰

RFA is a novel therapeutic method for the treatment of tumors. This method uses imaging guidance to place a needle electrode either through the skin or directly (during surgery) into the pathological tissue. High-frequency electrical currents pass through the electrode and create heat that destroys tumor cells. AuNPs have been used in this field, making it possible to destroy tumor cells noninvasively by RFA.^12–14 The optical properties of nanoshells can be utilized in tumor-ablation techniques with NIR light or RFA. Laroui et al developed nanoshells coated with gold, absorbing specific wavelengths of light.⁷⁵ Fortina et al synthesized nanoshells linked to a ligand.⁷⁶ Citrate-coated gold has been shown to have antitumor properties.^77,78

Xia et al⁵⁶ synthesized novel gold nanocages ~45 nm in edge length. These gold nanocages have shown potential for targeted PT inhibition of tumor cells. The nanocages were designed to convert 810 nm NIR light to heat via a large absorptive cross section of 3.48×10⁻¹⁴ cm², and strongly absorbed light in the NIR region. PT studies of the nanocages showed that the PT cell-damage power-density threshold was 1.5 W/cm², which is lower than that of gold nanoshells (35 W/cm²) and gold nanorods (10 W/cm²). By conjugating the nanocages with monoclonal antibodies (anti-HER2), the nanocages can target epidermal growth factor receptors (EGFRs) that are overexpressed on the surface of breast-tumor cells. These results indicated that shape- and size-modulated AuNMs could be potential tumor PTT reagents.

Cerium oxide nanoparticles

Cerium oxide NPs include a cerium core surrounded by an oxygen lattice.⁷⁹ In normal cells, these NPs have an antioxidant and cytoprotective role under neutral pH. In an acid medium, which is one of the characteristics of tumor cells, these NPs show prooxidant and cytotoxic effects. Pei et al studied the antitumor effects of cerium oxide NPs in in vitro models, and the results showed that cerium oxide NPs inhibited the growth of tumor cells.⁸⁰ There has been another report indicating that a high concentration (10 μg/mL) of cerium oxide NPs can suppress tumor-cell migration and inhibit tumor-cell proliferation.⁸¹

Quantum dots

Another popular type of NM are QDs.⁴⁰ QDs are very small nanocrystals that emit fluorescence when stimulated by a specific wavelength of light, and their diameter is approximately 2–10 nm.^44,82,83 Their structure consists of an inorganic core and shell, which can be modified with biological molecules, such as PEG.⁸⁴ Their emission and absorption properties can be controlled precisely by modulating their size and shape.⁸⁵ The benefit of QDs for tumor therapy is attributed to their mechanisms of photosensitization and radiosensitization. With electronic energy levels in the 1–5 keV range, QDs can be used as photosensitizers for photodynamic treatments, which have become an approved therapy modality for some types of tumors. Because of their high electron and atom density, QDs act as radiosensitizers that absorb high-energy photons and cause localized or targeted damage to tumor cells.⁸⁶

Nonmetallic NMs

There are several different types of nonmetal NMs (Figure 3), and carbon compounds are some of the most extensively studied. Several different “pure” carbon-based constructs have been studied, such as fullerenes and their derivatives, which are composed of carbon atoms arranged in a spherical shape called a truncated icosahedron, and carbon nanotubes (CNTs), which are most frequently studied in biological systems.^3,87 Fullerenes and their derivatives are readily accessible to cells, and are conjugated with various therapeutic molecules because they have a unique nanostructure. In addition, the pure carbon composition of fullerenes gives them good biocompatibility. Moreover, carbon NMs have been linked with biological molecules and polymers, and so can be effectively used for antitumor applications in vivo.⁴⁰ Therefore, functional fullerenes and their derivatives can be linked to a wide variety of active molecules to target tumor cells.^87,88 Based on these experiments, fullerenes and their derivatives have become a new class of promising candidates for tumor treatments. This portion of the review attempts to provide insight into the progress of the use of fullerenes and their derivatives as tumor-therapy drugs.

Figure 3.

Structures of nonmetallic nanomaterials for tumor therapy.

Notes: (A) C₆₀; (B) carbon nanotubes; (C) graphene; (D) chitosan-structure units β-(1,4)-2-amino-d-glucose and β-(1,4)-2-acetamido-d-glucose.

C₆₀

C₆₀ (or “bucky-ball” C₆₀) is a hollow sphere with a diameter of 1 nm, and is made up of 60 carbon atoms. C₆₀ is effective in terms of interactions with the immune system, and has dramatic potential as an antitumor drug. Compared with conventional antitumor chemicals, fullerenes and their derivatives are more efficient at inhibiting the growth of tumors. The result is not due to toxic effects on tumor cells, but the fullerenes, which have almost no toxicity in vivo or in vitro, have a strong ability to enhance immunity and protect normal tissues from tumor invasion.^89,90

Endohedral metallofullerenes (fullerenes encapsulating a metal atom) have shown dramatic potential for biomedical applications. For example, Hirahara et al⁹¹ synthesized a multihydroxylated fullerene – Gd@C₈₂(OH)₂₂. Compared with some other clinical antitumor drugs, C₆₀(OH)₂₀ and Gd@C₈₂(OH)₂₂ NPs are highly effective at suppressing tumor growth in mice with negligible side effects. The high antitumor activity may be because the water-soluble NMs can effectively trigger the host immune system to eliminate tumor cells and regulate the angiogenesis and oxidative defense system in vivo.⁹²

Carbon nanotubes

CNTs are coaxial graphite layers with cylinders.⁹³ CNTs are formed by polymerization of single carbon atoms under specific conditions.⁹⁴ According to their structure, CNTs can be divided into two categories: single-walled CNTs (SWCNTs) and multiwalled CNTs (MWCNTs). The former is a single cylindrical carbon wall, and the latter is an MW cylinder nested in other cylinders.⁹⁵ With the development of nanotechnology, integration of CNTs into tumor therapeutics is a rapidly advancing field.^96,97 There are reports that CNTs promote the phagocytosis of dendritic cells at tumor sites, which produce more antigens to dendritic cells, significantly increasing the immunogenicity of proteins in the tumor.⁹⁸ Similarly, inhaled CNTs can inhibit lung-resident dendritic cells and promote lung immune suppression.⁴⁷ Regarding the direct therapeutic effect, CNTs can induce tumor-tissue destruction by PTT, based on strong optical absorbance under NIR-light excitation.^99,100 Therefore, CNTs have attracted interest as efficient PTT agents for tumor treatments.^101–103 Hyperthermia therapy is another type of optional solution for tumor treatment, especially for some solid malignant tumors, such as breast and liver tumors. CNTs are also used as PT tumor-ablation mediators.¹⁰⁰ Due to the thermal conductivity and optical properties of CNTs, they have become mediators to optically stimulate NTs that are placed inside living cells and that kill tumor cells via local hyperthermia.

There has been much research to show the feasibility of CNTs in the treatment of malignant tumors. SWCNTs are promising candidates as a PTT agent, because they also have high absorption in the NIR spectrum, which is ideal for inducing PT damage to tumor cells or tissues. Continuous NIR radiation can lead to cell death, because of excessive local heating of SWCNTs. Kam et al¹⁰⁴ showed that this approach is effective. In a similar work,¹⁰⁵ the authors showed that HER2-IGFR-SWCNTs were able to destroy all targeted tumor cells. MWCNTs also efficiently absorb NIR light and efficiently convert the absorbed energy into thermal energy. MWCNTs can be stimulated with NIR irradiation to damage cervical tumor HeLa cells¹⁰⁶ and EAC cells.¹⁰⁷ CNTs make it possible to damage tumor cells noninvasively, and the potential applications for CNTs in tumor therapy have attracted much clinical interest. Therefore, CNTs can be considered another class of tumor PTT system, and are highly promising for clinical trials.

Graphene

Graphene is an emerging NM with single-layered carbon atoms in a two-dimensional honeycomb structure. Graphene has attracted great interest since its tremendous groundbreaking discovery in 2004.^108–110 Graphene and its different subtypes, such as graphene oxide (GO) and reduced graphene oxide (RGO), have been extensively studied in the realm of nanomedicine, due to their exceptional physical, chemical, and mechanical properties.¹¹¹ Graphene-based NMs have a well-described role in tumor management.¹¹² Graphene-based NMs are used mainly for PTT.

Yang et al¹¹³ reported that PEGylated GO (GO-PEG) showed highly efficient tumor ablation under NIR-light irradiation, and GO-PEG was used for in vivo PTT. These authors noticed that GO-PEG had no obvious side effects, and was safe during the treatment. In a follow-up study, Yang et al¹¹⁴ verified that PEGylated nano-RGO (nRGO-PEG) with an ultrasmall average diameter of ~27 nm was a better NM than GO for PTT with low-power laser irradiation. The in vivo PTT study demonstrated that nRGO-PEG was more efficient in tumor ablation and that NIR laser-power density was greatly reduced. These results indicated that nRGO-PEG strongly absorbs light in the NIR region (808 nm), with an intensity threshold of 0.15 W/cm², to induce thermal destruction of tumor cells. There have been some studies that reported that nanoparticles such as AuNPs,^115,116 AgNPs,¹¹⁷ copper monosulfide NPs,¹¹⁸ and copper(I) oxide NPs¹¹⁹ attached to the surface of GO synergistically enhanced PTT. These results highlight that both the size and surface chemistry of GO are critical to the effectiveness of in vivo PTT, which indicates that optimized nanographene could be a PTT reagent for treating tumors.

Chitosan nanoparticles

Chitosan is a type of cationic oligosaccharide that is the major component of the exoskeleton of crustaceans and insects.¹²⁰ Chitosan is a biopolymer containing β-(1,4)-2-amino-d-glucose and β-(1,4)-2-acetamido-d-glucose units.⁷³ Chitosan NPs (ChNPs) are obtained by deacetylation, which removes an acetate moiety from chitin. ChNPs are primarily degraded in the colon by the action of lysozyme and bacterial enzymes, and are finally eliminated in the feces. Chitosan is a natural polysaccharide that has excellent biocompatibility, biosecurity, biodegradability, and nontoxic characteristics.^121,122 ChNPs are commonly modified with epichlorohydrin and PEG dicarboxylic acid.^123,124 ChNPs also have dramatic potential for tumor therapy.

ChNPs can directly affect the metabolism of tumor cells by inducing apoptosis and inhibiting cellular growth. Likewise, ChNPs play a role in increasing the immune function of the organism by facilitating the contact between the drug and the tumor-cell membrane.^125,126 Reports show that ChNPs have high stimulatory activity on B and T lymphocytes and the humoral immune system, which can be activated at the same time.¹²⁷ ChNPs also have a strong immunostimulating effect by increasing the activation and accumulation of polymorphonuclear and macrophage cells, and they induce cytokine production after intravenous injection.^128,129 There is another example that indicates that ChNPs have their own antitumor effects. ChNPs themselves have a positive charge; therefore, they can neutralize the negative charges on the surface of tumor cells, which has a tendency to contribute to their selective uptake. In this way, ChNPs can effectively inhibit proliferation of tumor cells by increasing the concentration of cytostatic agents at the tumor sites.¹³⁰ All these attributes and examples show that ChNPs have great potential in tumor therapy.

Challenges and future perspectives

Over the last 20 years, NMs have come to play a significant role in commercial development. Indeed, we might expect to produce many breakthroughs and new prospects for the world economy from advances in nanotechnology. With the potentially wide application of NMs in the future, NMs may be extensively used in various fields, especially tumor therapy. NMs can be used for clinical diagnosis and tumor therapy, based on their size, biocompatibility, surface chemistry, relatively good stability, and adjustable toxicity in biological systems. It is highly expected that the application of NMs in tumor therapy will greatly improve current methods of tumor-cell detection, tumor imaging, and tumor therapy, while reducing toxicity compared to traditional tumor treatments.

However, there are several challenges in the field, and there are still controversies about the potential risk of anti-tumor therapies. The most pressing problems are potential chronic and acute toxic effects; the potential toxicity of NMs cannot be ignored in antitumor therapy.¹³¹ There have been reports on the toxicity of NMs. NMs may be attached to the surface of biological membranes by adsorption or electrostatic interactions, and they can cause damage to cells by producing reactive oxygen species, leading to protein denaturation, lipid peroxidation, DNA damage, and ultimately cell death.^132–134 For instance, NPs and CNTs can damage the respiratory and cardiovascular systems,^135,136 and they can enter the centralnervous system through the blood–brain barrier, resulting in a variety of nervous system diseases.^137–139 In vitro studies have shown that CNTs can induce cell apoptosis, decrease cell viability, and disrupt the cell cycle and inflammatory responses.^140–142 It has been confirmed that CNTs can damage lung tissue¹⁴³ and that they are toxic to the immune system in mice.⁴⁶ Besides, the blood incompatibility of CNTs also limits their use in the clinic. Although many studies have shown that the functionalization of CNTs can improve their water-solubility, proof of their biocompatibility and safety is currently insufficient. For example, Li et al¹⁴⁴ reported that sugar-functionalized SWCNTs formed stable homogeneous aqueous solutions, Barzegar et al¹⁴⁵ reported that noncovalent functionalized SWCNTs could also improve the water solubility of SWCNTs, and Ali et al¹⁴⁶ functionalized SWCNTs with the TGAD enzyme to render SWCNTs soluble in a plethora of solvents. However, the biocompatibility of functionalized SWCNTs was not evaluated in these studies. When QDs are applied in the body, their toxicity cannot be ignored, because they may contain heavy metals. It is necessary to carry out a detailed toxicity study to ensure safety prior to further applications in humans. Further research will not be conducive to the clinical application of NMs and industrial production unless the toxicity problem is resolved. In addition, only a few types of materials have been approved by the US Food and Drug Administration, and very few NMs have been approved as antitumor agents to enter Phase III clinical trials or enter the market, which indicates that NMs need to be understood more deeply before their potential application in tumor therapy.

Therefore, the long-term toxicity of NMs to living systems needs to be intensively studied. There is an article that analyzes the possible toxicological implications of NMs in nanomedicine. The authors believed that it is necessary to research the mechanisms of injury in cells due to NMs extensively before NMs can be used in tumor treatments.¹⁴⁷ Development of tumor therapies is a multidisciplinary field, and with more in-depth research on tumor biology, tumor immunology, molecular biology, and NMs, an ideal therapy or NM will eventually be produced for the treatment of tumors. The conversion of nanotechnology to routine clinical practice will require a multidisciplinary approach guided by clinical, ethical, and social perceptions. In view of the significant research results being dedicated to the field, it may be expected that humans will greatly benefit from nanotechnology and NMs in the very near future, especially in tumor therapy.