Skip to main content
Journal of the Medical Library Association : JMLA logoLink to Journal of the Medical Library Association : JMLA
. 2005 Jan;93(1):5–6.

More research needed on the Academy of Health Information Professionals, the profession, and the Medical Library Association

Lynda M Baker 1, Marge Kars 2, Janet Petty 3
PMCID: PMC545113  PMID: 15685267

We are writing to respond to the comments about our study on librarians' attitudes toward the Academy of Health Information Professionals [1]. Qualitative researchers are often confronted by statements, such as the one made by Flemming, Dorsch, and Funk, that we “selectively” chose comments of the respondents to include in our paper. The reason for this misconception stems from the subjectivity of qualitative research, an issue that many authors have addressed over the years. An article on the validity of qualitative research by Johnson [2] clearly explains this whole issue and provides several measures qualitative researchers can use to increase the validity of their research. Validity refers to results that are credible, trustworthy, defensible, and plausible.

One method to increase the validity of research is the use of investigator triangulation, which means that more than one person interprets the data. Another measure is inter-rater reliability, that is, the consistency of agreement when two people (raters) judge the same variables independently of each other. To address the issue of validity, both Kars and Baker independently coded and categorized the responses to the open-ended questions and, as explained in the paper, came together to discuss and categorize the ones we did not place in the same categories. Another method we used is what Johnson calls “low inference descriptors,” that is, the use of direct quotes of the respondents. Together, Kars and Baker chose quotes that they agreed were the most representative of each category.

Flemming, Dorsch, and Funk question the usefulness of our study, pointing out that the “right questions” need to be asked and the “right methods” used “to get useful answers about the value of membership in the academy.” It is easy to criticize other people's research and to state what should have been done. To contribute to a body of knowledge about a topic, researchers scan the literature to identify some aspect that has received little attention by other researchers. Finding little research on librarians' attitudes toward the academy, we decided to focus on this issue, thereby contributing new information to the literature about the academy. In response to this comment, we suggest that the Medical Library Association (MLA) support researchers in academia who are interested in health sciences issues by providing grants to conduct larger studies. More research needs to be done not only on the academy, but also on the profession and MLA, as Flemming, Dorsch, and Funk suggest.

Contributor Information

Lynda M. Baker, Email: aa0838@wayne.edu.

Marge Kars, Email: KARSM@bronsonhg.org.

Janet Petty, Email: JLPetty@mvh.org.

References

  1. Flemming T, Dorsch J, and Funk CJ. The Academy of Health Information Professionals: ripe for research [comment and opinion]. J Med Libr Assoc. 2004 Jul; 92(3):297–8. [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  2. Johnson RB. Examining the validity structure of qualitative research. In: Patten ML, ed. Understanding research methods. 2nd ed. Los Angeles, CA: Pyrczak Publishing, 2000. [Google Scholar]

Articles from Journal of the Medical Library Association are provided here courtesy of Medical Library Association

RESOURCES