Low Carbon sink capacity of Red Sea mangroves

Abstract

Mangroves forests of Avicennia marina occupy about 135 km² in the Red Sea and represent one of the most important vegetated communities in this otherwise arid and oligotrophic region. We assessed the soil organic carbon (C_org) stocks, soil accretion rates (SAR; mm y⁻¹) and soil C_org sequestration rates (g C_org m⁻² yr⁻¹) in 10 mangrove sites within four locations along the Saudi coast of the Central Red Sea. Soil C_org density and stock in Red Sea mangroves were among the lowest reported globally, with an average of 4 ± 0.3 mg C_org cm⁻³ and 43 ± 5 Mg C_org ha⁻¹ (in 1 m-thick soils), respectively. Sequestration rates of C_org, estimated at 3 ± 1 and 15 ± 1 g C_org m⁻² yr⁻¹ for the long (millennia) and short (last century) temporal scales, respectively, were also relatively low compared to mangrove habitats from more humid bioregions. In contrast, the accretion rates of Central Red Sea mangroves soils were within the range reported for global mangrove forests. The relatively low C_org sink capacity of Red Sea mangroves could be due to the extreme environmental conditions such as low rainfall, nutrient limitation and high temperature, reducing the growth rates of the mangroves and increasing soil respiration rates.

Introduction

Mangrove forests supply important ecosystem services that support the livelihoods of coastal societies in the tropics and subtropics¹. However, these extend beyond the local communities to yield, through their role as a globally-relevant carbon sinks, climate change mitigation benefits to the global community^2–5. Although mangroves occupy only 0.5% of the area of the global coastal ocean⁶ and represent only 0.7% of the tropical forests of the world⁷, they account for about 1% and 14% of the carbon sequestered annually by the world’s forests and the global ocean, respectively⁸.

The intense organic carbon (C_org) sequestration by mangrove forests is mainly due to their high net ecosystem production⁹, resulting in high loads of leaf litter and biomass to the soil, combined with their high capacity to trap and retain soil resulting in vertical accretion¹⁰ compared to other forests and coastal areas devoid of vegetation¹¹. Further, high C_org preservation due to low oxygen availability^{12, 13} combined with lack of fires in the aquatic environment where mangroves thrive³, results in high carbon storage in mangroves^{14, 15}.

Unfortunately, mangrove ecosystems have declined globally, with one third of the global mangrove area lost since World War II¹⁶. Mangrove deforestation leads to losses of their carbon sink capacity as well as greenhouse gas emissions from remineralization of the large C_org stocks that mangroves accrete^{3, 14}. Annual CO₂ emissions associated with mangrove deforestation have been estimated at 0.02 to 0.12 Pg C¹⁴, contributing to CO₂ emissions through land-use change, the second largest anthropogenic source of CO₂ to the atmosphere after fossil fuel combustion¹⁷.

The Red Sea has recently been identified as possibly the only mangrove province where mangroves are not only stable, but have expanded by 12% over the last four decades¹⁸. Lack of freshwater and soil inputs lead to acute nutrient limitation of Red Sea mangroves¹⁹, resulting in mangrove forests being dominated by dwarf trees²⁰, similar to those in other arid areas (e.g. Gulf of California²¹ and areas lacking surface runoff such as the Indian River Lagoon in Florida²²). Hence, we would expect mangrove forests in the Red Sea to have a relatively modest carbon sink capacity so that, despite the stability of the forests, their contribution to carbon sequestration would still be marginal. Yet, most estimates of carbon sequestration and stocks in mangrove forests have been, hitherto, derived from mangrove forests in the wet tropics^{6, 8}, and whether those growing in the arid topics contribute significantly to carbon sequestration remains an open question. However, a recent assessment reports a C_org sequestration for dwarf mangrove forests in the arid shores of Baja California of, on average, 1000 Mg C_org ha⁻¹ in 1.5 m-thick soils (adapted from ref. 23), similar to that found under some of the tallest tropical mangroves in the Mexican Pacific coast²³, which has been linked to the stability of these forests. These observations question the assumption that dwarf mangroves in arid shores support low carbon sequestration rates and stocks.

Here we assess the C_org stock and sequestration rates and stocks supported by Avicennia marina mangrove forests in the Central Red Sea. We do so by combining measurements of soil C_org density down to 10 cm with soil chronologies derived from ²¹⁰Pb and soil C_org density down to 1 m depth with soil chronologies derived from ¹⁴C, to estimate (a) the stock of C_org contained within the top meter of the soil, and (b) the burial rate of C_org over short-term (last 100 years) and long-term (last millennia) periods. Further, we use stable carbon and nitrogen isotopes of the organic matter in the soil and putative sources (mangroves, halophytes, seaweed, seagrass and seston) to estimate the potential contribution of different sources of C_org to mangrove soil carbon stocks.

Results

The distribution of soil grain size differed among mangrove forests, with soils sampled at Thuwal Island, Economic City and Khor Alkharar having a sandy texture, (∼85% of sand fraction >0.063 mm) compared to loamy sand in Petro Rabigh (32% of mud <0.063 mm) (Table 1), where the clay and silt contents in the soils was 2 to 3-fold higher (P < 0.001), (Tukey HSD multiple comparison post-hoc test, P < 0.05). Mangrove forests at Thuwal Island grow in the coarsest soil (80% particles between 0.125 and 1 mm) compared to the other study sites (47 to 65% particles between 0.125 mm and 1 mm, Table 1).

Table 1.

Mean (±SE) grain size fractions (%) and texture in mangrove soils from the four study sites in the Central Red Sea.

Location	n	% of Soil classification <1 mm					Texture
		Clay and Silt particles (<0.063 mm)	Very fine sand (<0.125 and >0.063 mm)	Fine sand (<0.25 and >0.125 mm)	Medium sand (<0.5 and >0.25 mm)	Coarse sand (<1 and >0.5 mm)
Thuwal Island	65	10.2 ± 0.7b	11 ± 0.5a	25.5 ± 0.7a	29.8 ± 0.6a	23.5 ± 1a	Sand
Economic City	104	17.9 ± 0.7b	18.1 ± 0.6a	21.9 ± 0.4a	21.8 ± 0.5a	20.2 ± 0.7a	Sand
Petro Rabigh	78	31.6 ± 1.8a	21.1 ± 1.3a	23.1 ± 1.3a	13.7 ± 1b	10.5 ± 1.2b	Loamy sand
Khor Alkharar	65	16.2 ± 0.8b	19 ± 0.5a	25.6 ± 0.4a	21.9 ± 0.5ab	17.2 ± 0.8ab	Sand
Averages	312	19.4 ± 0.7	17.6 ± 0.5	23.7 ± 0.4	21.5 ± 0.5	17.8 ± 0.5	Sand
R 2		0.7	0.8	0.6	0.9	0.9
F ratio (location)		11**	2.8 ns	1.1 ns	6.3**	3.9*
F ratio (depths nested-within-cores)		3.9**	5.6**	2.9**	6.4**	3.4**

R ² and F ratio correspond to the square-root results of the GLMMs testing the effect of independence of samples. Study site and soil depth (nested within cores) as fixed factors, whereas replicate cores within sites was treated as random factor. *P value between 0.01 and 0.05, **P value < 0.01 for significant differences whereas (^ns) means not significant. Columns linked with the same letter did not differ significantly among themselves (Tukey HSD multiple comparison post-hoc test, P > 0.05).

The C_org density and % C_org were generally low, ranging from 3 to 9 mg C_org cm⁻³ and 0.2% to 1.5% C_org (Table 2). The C_org density and % C_org significantly decreased with soil depth, while δ¹⁵N and δ¹³C significantly increased with depth, except for δ¹⁵N signatures at Thuwal Island which remained constant (Tukey HSD post hoc test, P < 0.05, Fig. 1 and Table 2). Mangrove soils in Khor Alkharar were characterized by relatively high soil C_org density (1 to 39 mg C_org cm⁻³ along the 170 cm soil profile), and high % C_org (0.2 to 17% C_org in the upper 25 cm), compared to the other locations (<14 mg C_org cm⁻³ and <1% C_org, Tukey HSD post hoc test, P < 0.05, Fig. 1). δ¹³C values did not differ among locations, whereas soil at Petro Rabigh mangroves had higher δ¹⁵N values (0.6 to 7.8‰ along the 170 cm soil profile) compared with those in other locations (<3.2‰ along the 170 cm soil profile) (Tukey HSD post hoc test, P < 0.05; Fig. 1 and Table 2).

Table 2.

Mean (±SE) C_org density, % organic carbon (C_org) and C and N stable isotope ratios of mangrove soil from four different locations in the Central Red Sea.

Location	n cores	Soil Corg Density (mg Corg cm−3)	% Corg	Isotopes
				δ13C	δ15N
Thuwal Island	65	3 ± 0.3b	0.3 ± 0.03b	−19 ± 0.3a	2 ± 0.1b
Economic City	104	4 ± 0.2b	0.4 ± 0.02b	−20 ± 0.2a	2 ± 0.1b
Petro Rabigh	78	3 ± 0.2b	0.2 ± 0.03b	−21 ± 0.3a	4 ± 0.2a
Khor Alkharar	65	9 ± 1a	1.5 ± 0.38a	−21 ± 0.4a	2 ± 0.1b
R 2		0.8	0.8	0.8	0.8
F ratio (location)		7.3**	5.8**	1.8 ns	12.6**
F ratio (depths nested-within-cores)		14**	15.7**	17.8**	5 **
All	312	4 ± 0.3	0.6 ± 0.1	−21 ± 0.2	3 ± 0.1

R ² and F ratio correspond to the square-root results of the GLMMs testing the effect of independence of samples. Study site and soil depth (nested within cores) as fixed factors, whereas replicate cores within sites was treated as random factor. *P value between 0.01 and 0.05, **P value < 0.01 for significant differences whereas (^ns) means not significant. Columns linked with the same letter did not differ significantly among themselves (Tukey HSD multiple comparison post-hoc test, P > 0.05).

Figure 1.

Vertical profiles of (A) % organic carbon (C_org), (B) C_org density (g C_org cm⁻³), and (C,D) δ¹³C and δ¹⁵N (‰) in mangrove soils in central Red Sea. It was not possible to plot average values for the replicate cores against decompressed depths because replicate cores experienced different degrees of compaction during coring.

The seaweed species analyzed (i.e. Padina, Colpomenia, Turbinaria and Sargassum species, Table 3) were unusually enriched in δ¹³C and, therefore, quite similar in carbon isotopic values to seagrass. This was the case also for seston, suggesting that it is mostly comprised of seagrass and macroalgal detritus in the mangrove waters sampled. Hence, the discrimination between these three sources (seaweed, seston and seagrass) was poor and involved considerable uncertainty (Table 3). Likewise, halophytes and mangroves had comparable δ¹³C signatures, but much lighter than those derived from plants performing aquatic photosynthesis (Table 3). The analysis of δ¹⁵N and δ¹³C values of marine plants and soil indicated that the source of the C_org in mangroves soil from the Red Sea was composed, on average, of 2/3 of C_org derived from atmospheric photosynthesis (e.g. mangrove and halophytes) and 1/3 of C_org derived from aquatic photosynthesis (e.g. seaweed, seston and seagrass, Tables 2 and 3, Fig. 2).

Table 3.

Mean (±SE) of isotopic carbon and nitrogen values of marine plants (‰) collected at the four study sites. N indicated the number of samples analyzed.

Sources	Site	n	δ13C	δ15N
Mangrove and halophytes	Thuwal Island	39	−26 ± 0.2	2 ± 0.2
	Economic City	39	−27 ± 0.2	1 ± 0.3
	Petro Rabigh	24	−24 ± 0.9	5 ± 0.3
	Khor Alkharar	42	−25 ± 0.6	2 ± 0.4
Seagrass	Thuwal Island	6	−8 ± 0.4	−1 ± 0.3
	Economic City	39	−7 ± 0.2	−1 ± 0.2
	Petro Rabigh	27	−10 ± 0.3	2 ± 0.4
	Khor Alkharar	36	−9 ± 0.3	1 ± 0.2
Seaweed	Thuwal Island	27	−14 ± 0.7	2 ± 0.1
	Economic City	3	−8 ± 0.6	2 ± 0.2
	Petro Rabigh	—	—	—
	Khor Alkharar	18	−12 ± 0.8	2 ± 0.1
Seston	Thuwal Island	3	−14 ± 1.3	3 ± 0.1
	Economic City	3	−4 ± 2.1	2 ± 0.2
	Petro Rabigh	3	−17 ± 0.9	3 ± 0.1
	Khor Alkharar	3	−11 ± 2.5	2 ± 0.6

Figure 2.

The sources of soil organic carbon (C_org) in mangrove forests obtained using IsoSource from potential organic matter sources and soil δ¹⁵N and δ¹³C values.

The ²¹⁰Pb concentration profiles of 6 out of 10 cores showed intense mixing of the upper layers or did not contain excess ²¹⁰Pb, i.e. ²¹⁰Pb concentrations were not significantly different than supported ²¹⁰Pb and, thereby, it was not possible to apply a suitable ²¹⁰Pb model to determine soil accretion rates (SAR). The ²¹⁰Pb concentration profiles of 3 mangrove soil cores (KMC, KME and RMF) showed evidence of mixing in the upper 2 to 7 cm (Fig. 3a), and no apparent mixing in the top layers was observed for core TMF. Excess ²¹⁰Pb concentrations at the surface were low, averaging 9 ± 2 Bq kg⁻¹ in all cores, except for KME, which reached 90 Bq kg⁻¹. Excess ²¹⁰Pb concentrations decreased steadily below the surface mixed layer (when present) and down to 22, 12, 15 and 11 cm, in cores KMC, KME, RMF and TMF respectively. Supported ²²⁶Ra concentrations were similar among the 10 analyzed cores, averaging 10 ± 3 Bq kg⁻¹, with KMC concentrations being significantly lower at 5.6 ± 0.6 Bq kg⁻¹ (Fig. 3b, Table S5). The CF:CS model (Constant Flux: Constant Sedimentation rate^{24, 25}) was applied to these cores (below the mixed layer when present), obtaining SAR ranging from 0.7 ± 0.1 to 3.7 ± 0.7 mm yr⁻¹ over the last 100 years. Due to the presence of mixing, these rates must be considered as upper limits, especially for KMC and RMF. The resulting SAR averaged 2.2 ± 0.6 mm yr⁻¹ over the past 100 years (Table 4). The range of estimates of SAR over longer time-scales derived from ¹⁴C age estimates were comparable (0.4 to 1.8 mm yr⁻¹, Table 5) to those derived for the past century, while the average was 2.6 times lower. Long-term SAR did not differ among locations (Table 5, Tukey HSD post hoc test, P > 0.05).

Figure 3.

(A) Total and (B) excess concentration profiles of ²¹⁰Pb in dated mangrove soil cores of Central Red Sea. It was not possible to plot average values for the replicate cores against decompressed depths because replicate cores experienced different degrees of compaction during coring.

Table 4.

Mean (±SE) organic carbon (C_org) stocks in 10 cm-thick soils, and short-term (since 1900) soil accretion rates and soil C_org sequestration rates based on ²¹⁰Pb from four different locations in the Central Red Sea.

Location	n cores	Corg Stock-in 10 cm thick soil	210Pb soil accretion rate	Carbon sequestration using 210Pb (normalized to 1900)
		g Corg m−2	mm yr−1	g Corg m−2 yr−1
Thuwal Island	8	530 ± 146b	2.1 ± 0.7	10 ± 3c
Economic City	8	531 ± 58b	2.2 ± 0.7*	16 ± 6b
Petro Rabigh	6	382 ± 153b	2.4 ± 1.0	9 ± 4d
Khor Alkharar	7	1541 ± 430a	0.7 ± 0.1 to 3.7 ± 0.7	23 ± 1a
R 2		0.4	0.1	0.9
F ratio		5**	0.8 ns	10030**
All	29	744 ± 140	2.2 ± 0.7	15 ± 1

R ² and F ratio correspond to an ANOVA testing for significant differences between locations. *P value between 0.01 and 0.05, **P value < 0.01 for significant differences between depths, whereas (^ns) means not significant. Columns linked with the same letter did not differ significantly among themselves (Tukey HSD multiple comparison post-hoc test, P > 0.05).

*Here refers to the mean sediment accretion rate of the locations where ²¹⁰Pb could be used to establish a geochronology.

Table 5.

Mean (±SE) organic carbon (C_org) stocks in 1 m-thick soils, and long-term (millennia) soil accretion rates and soil C_org sequestration rates based on ¹⁴C from four different locations in the Central Red Sea.

Location	n cores	Corg Stock-in 1 m thick soil	14C soil accretion rate	Carbon Sequestration using 14C
		g Corg m-2	mm yr-1	g Corg m-2 yr-1
Thuwal Island	8	3034 ± 416b	1.8 ± 1a	5.5 ± 3.4a
Economic City	8	3838 ± 291b	0.4 ± 0.1a	1.6 ± 0.2a
Petro Rabigh	6	2471 ± 470b	0.6 ± 0.1a	1.5 ± 0.4a
Khor Alkharar	7	7618 ± 1530a	0.6 ± 0.2a	5 ± 2.8a
R 2		0.5	0.1	0.1
F ratio		7.8**	1.2 ns	0.8 ns
All	29	4246 ± 533	0.9 ± 0.3	3.5 ± 1.1

R ² and F ratio correspond to an ANOVA testing for significant differences between locations. *P value between 0.01 and 0.05, **P value < 0.01 for significant differences between depths, whereas (^ns) means not significant. Columns linked with the same letter did not differ significantly among themselves (Tukey HSD multiple comparison post-hoc test, P > 0.05).

The high C_org content at Khor Alkharar resulted in the highest C_org stock at this site, which was significantly higher compared to all other locations (Tables 4 and 5). Likewise, recent C_org sequestration rates averaged 15 ± 1 g C_org m⁻² yr⁻¹ (i.e. based on ²¹⁰Pb dating) and varied three-fold, from the lowest rates at Petro Rabigh (9 ± 4 g C_org m⁻² yr⁻¹) to the highest rates at Khor Alkarar (23 ± 1 g C_org m⁻² yr⁻¹; Table 4, Tukey HSD post hoc test, P < 0.05). These differences were driven mostly by the differences in C_org density, as soil accretion rates were rather uniform and did not differ significantly among locations. The long-term C_org sequestration rates did not differ among locations, averaging 3.5 ± 1.1 g C_org m⁻² yr⁻¹ (Table 5, Tukey HSD post hoc test, P > 0.05).

Discussion

The sediment grain size we found was consistent with the findings of Gheith & Abou-ouf²⁶ who reported sandy sediments in Khor Alkharar Sea becoming coarser, with a higher gravel component, towards the beach, and sediment at Rabigh to be mainly composed of medium grain size sand. Although, the clay and silt content of mangrove soils at Khor Alkharar were relatively low compared to the other locations, site KME had considerably high content of mud 24% (average top 20 cm; soil thickness where excess ²¹⁰Pb is found), hence the high content of fine sediments at surface layers together with high concentrations of C_org can explain the higher inventory of excess ²¹⁰Pb found at this site compared to other locations.

The average (±SE) C_org density in Central Red Sea mangrove soils (0.0044 ± 0.00028 g C_org cm⁻³) is remarkably low compared to values reported from a global compilation (e.g. average 0.055 g C_org cm⁻³ and minimum 0.023 g cm⁻³ in Kosrae Island ²⁷, or 0.038 g C_org cm⁻³ and 0.061 g C_org cm⁻³ characteristic of estuarine and oceanic mangrove soils, respectively¹⁴). The C_org density in the mangrove soils of the Central Red Sea is 100 to 300-fold lower than in mangrove soils in wet temperate to subtropical climate at Rookery Bay, Florida (0.51 g cm⁻³; ref. 28) and dry tropical climate at Abu Dhabi, UAE (1.2 g cm⁻³; ref. 29). Soil C_org stocks are highly variable across hemispheres, latitudes, countries and plant community compositions³⁰, thereby the relatively lower C_org density values found at Central Red Sea could be explained by particular habitat characteristics and geomorphological settings not favorable for C_org sequestration.

In contrast, the recent soil accretion rates of Central Red Sea mangroves soil (mean 2 mm yr⁻¹) are close to the median global value of 2.8 mm yr^{−1  29} and half of the median value of 4.5 mm yr⁻¹ reported for mangroves globally³, and within the range previously reported (0.1 to 21 mm yr^{−1  3, 8}). Moreover, the values obtained for the Red Sea mangroves using ²¹⁰Pb chronologies are higher than those recently reported using comparable methods for mangroves in Moreton Bay and southeastern Australia (1.2 and 1.7 mm yr⁻¹, respectively³¹), and lower than the average rate reported in Florida (2.7 mm y⁻¹)³².

The SAR obtained using the ²¹⁰Pb method (for short-term periods, last 100 years) is up to 4-fold higher than those based on ¹⁴C (1 mm yr⁻¹), which encompass long-term (millennia) accretion, in areas such as Economic City, Petro Rabigh and Khor Alkharar. These results suggest an increase in SAR during the last decades, which is consistent with coastal development in the Saudi coast of the Central Red Sea, that experienced industrial and urban developments over the past decades. This is supported by the high value of ¹⁵N, that suggests an increase of nutrients from land runoff and coastal development as sewage and fertilizers are released to the sea. Moreover, decreasing δ¹³C values and increasing mud content (silt and clay) towards recent periods also support this hypothesis. However, the presence of mixing in top layers, decomposition of organic matter with ageing, compaction of soils during diagenesis, and intrinsic differences in ²¹⁰Pb and ¹⁴C methodologies could also explain the higher SAR found in recent times^33–35.

Whereas SAR are not particularly low for Central Red Sea mangrove forests, their remarkably low soil C_org density resulted in low carbon sequestration rates. The average soil C_org sequestration rates of 15 g C_org m⁻² yr⁻¹ for Central Red Sea mangroves soils is 10-fold lower than the average value of 163 g C_org m⁻² yr⁻¹ reported for mangroves globally²⁹, and are in the low range of values previously reported (10 to 920 g C m⁻² yr⁻¹)⁸. The long-term (millenary time scale) soil C_org sequestration rates in Central Red Sea mangroves (3.5 g C_org m⁻² yr⁻¹) was also well below the soil C_org sequestration rates derived from ¹⁴C chronologies reported for dwarf A. germinans forests in arid Baja California (256 g C_org m⁻² yr⁻¹)²³ and Pohnpei Island, Micronesia dominated by Rhizophora apiculata, (93 g C_org m⁻² yr⁻¹)²⁹, despite SARs at the Micronesia sites being comparable to those reported here for Red Sea mangroves, of 2 mm yr^{−1  36}. Despite of the low long-term sequestration of carbon in Central Red Sea mangroves compared to other mangrove habitats, their capacity to sequester C_org is similar to that observed in tropical forest soils (2.3 to 2.5 g C_org m⁻² yr⁻¹)³⁷.

The relatively low C_org stocks and C_org sequestration rates in Red Sea mangroves are most likely due to the oligotrophic nature and low allochthonous inputs to the Red Sea. The lack of rivers and the extremely arid conditions result in nutrient-limited mangrove growth¹⁹, reflected in low-biomass dwarfed trees, particularly within the study region in the Central Red Sea²⁰. Moreover, the soils of Red Sea mangroves are mainly composed of biogenic coarse carbonates, which could also explain the relatively low C_org sequestration capacity of mangroves growing in unfavorable conditions for biomass production, soil accretion and preservation compared to mangrove habitats from temperate and sub-tropical habitats. The isotopic results showed that two-thirds of the soil C_org stocks originated from mangrove or tidal-marsh biomass, while one-third was derived from marine photosynthetic organisms. Previous studies demonstrated that terrigenous C_org inputs can contribute up to 30% of C_org stocks in mangrove soil associated with riverine ecosystems³⁸, but the lack of rivers implies that there is no influx of riverine soil and organic matter in coastal areas and, therefore, C_org sequestration in Red Sea mangroves is limited to autochthonous production and fluxes from the ocean.

The lack of terrigenous inputs is also reflected in the heavy carbon isotopic signatures of suspended particulate matter (−11.3 ±1.6‰), indicative of sestonic organic matter of marine origin, as seston from river sources is characterized by lighter values ranging from −18.5 to −26.4‰³⁹. Moreover, the seston carbon seems to be dominated by carbon derived from macrophytes as plankton-derived C_org is also relatively depleted in ¹³C (−24.7 to −26.0‰ in the open ocean, and −19.8 to −22.3‰ in semi-tropical regions)⁴⁰.

We hypothesized that in contrast with other mangrove forests, CO₂ capture by mangroves in the Red Sea would be extremely low due to the arid conditions of this region. Indeed, poor C_org preservation under coarse grained-soils, high hydraulic conductivity, and low moisture-holding capacity, could also result in low C_org storage, as previously demonstrated for mangroves from United Arab Emirates⁴¹. Considering the total mangrove area in the Red Sea (135 km²)¹⁸, the rates reported for Red Sea mangroves here represent about 2100 tons of carbon sequestered per year, which is a relatively low contribution. Whereas Red Sea mangroves remains a healthy and stable ecosystem in the Red Sea¹⁸, they offer a limited potential to support blue carbon strategies to mitigate CO₂ emissions.

Methods

Study location, sampling and laboratory procedures

Sampling was conducted in mangrove forests of Avicennia marina at Thuwal Island, Economic City, Petro Rabigh and Khor Alkharar (Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, Fig. 4). The area encompassed by this study extends along 80 km of coastline, from Thuwal Island where mangroves grow on a shallow soil of weathered coral⁴², to Khor Alkharar, a coastal lagoon permanently connected to the Red Sea⁴³. Petro Rabigh is a major industrial and petrochemical complex, whereas Economic City, about 40 km south of Petro Rabigh, is a newly developed city and harbor complex^{26, 44}. Thuwal Island and Khor Alkharar lagoon are relatively away from direct sources of human disturbance whereas mangrove forests near Petro Rabigh and the Economic City are subjected to disturbances caused by industrial and coastal development, respectively.

Figure 4.

Location of the Central Red Sea mangrove forests sampled. The map was produced with ArcMap Version 10.2. Background map credits: the World Administrative Divisions layer provided by Esri Data and Maps, and DeLorme Publishing Company. Redistribution rights are granted http://www.esri.com/~/media/Files/Pdfs/legal/pdfs/redist_rights_103.pdf?la=en.

In order to assess the C_org sink capacity of Red Sea mangroves, a total of 29 soil cores were sampled: 8 cores at Thuwal Island, 8 cores at Economic City, 6 cores at Petro Rabigh and 7 cores at Khor Alkharar (Fig. 4 and Table S1 in Supplementary materials). The soils were sampled using manual percussion and rotation of PVC pipes (170 cm long, high pressure class 12 with an inner diameter of 62.6 mm) that were gently hammered into the soil (<0.5 m water depth). The top core was sealed with PVC tape before retrieval to create vacuum and avoid losing the sample during recovery. The cores were sealed at both ends and transported vertically to the laboratory for further processing. Half of the cores collected at each location were kept intact and transported to the laboratory (hereafter referred to as ‘whole cores’). The other cores from each study location were sampled using a corer consisting of a PVC pipe with pre-drilled holes in the sidewall (3 cm wide and 3 cm apart; hereafter referred to as ‘port cores’), allowing sub-sampling of soil samples along the core in the field by inserting 60 ml syringes into the pre-drilled holes along the PVC pipes. The length of the core barrel inserted into the soil and the length of retrieved mangrove soil were recorded in order to correct the core lengths for compression effects and all variables studied here are referenced to the corrected, uncompressed depths. The volume of each subsample retrieved from the port cores was recorded in the field. The whole cores were sealed at both ends and transported vertically to the laboratory together with the subsamples obtained from the port cores.

PVC whole cores were cut lengthwise and cut into 1 cm-thick slices. Each slice from the whole cores and the subsamples from the port cores were weighed before and after oven drying at 60 °C until constant weight (dry weight; DW) to estimate dry bulk density (DBD in g DW cm⁻³). Then, every second slice of whole cores and all subsamples from port cores were divided into two subsamples by quartering. One subsample was ground and analyzed for organic carbon (C_org), and stable carbon and nitrogen isotopic composition (δ¹³C and δ¹⁵N), and the other subsamples were used for soil grain-size, ¹⁴C and ²¹⁰Pb analyses.

Samples were acid-rinsed to ensure complete removal of inorganic carbon (i.e., carbonates) before C_org analysis, despite the fact that this procedure may lead to an underestimation of soil C_org stocks^{45, 46}. For C_org, δ¹³C and δ¹⁵N analyses, 1 g of ground samples was acidified with 1 M HCl until bubbling stopped to remove inorganic carbon, centrifuged (3500 RPM; 5 min) and the supernatant with acid residues was removed using a pipette, then washed in deionized water once, the residues were centrifuged again and the supernatant removed. The residual samples were re-dried (70 °C) and encapsulated for analysis using a Thermo Delta V Conflo III coupled to a Costech 4010 at the UH Hilo Analytical Laboratory, USA (Table S2 in Supplementary materials). The content of C_org was calculated for the bulk (pre-acidified) samples. Organic carbon and Nitrogen isotope ratios are expressed as δ values in parts per thousand and relative to the Vienna Pee Dee Belemnite and atmospheric nitrogen using USGS 40 and USGS 41 standards, respectively. Analyses of replicates and reference materials were carried out to ensure reproducibility of the results.

The carbon and nitrogen elemental and isotopic composition was also analyzed in Avicennia marina macro-detritus (i.e. aerial roots, green and senescent leaves, stem, buds, flowers), halophytes (e.g. Salicornia spp. etc.), seaweeds (i.e. Padina, Colpomenia, Turbinaria and Sargassum spp.), seagrasses (i.e. rhizomes, roots and leaves from Halophila, Halodule, Thalassodendrum, Thalassia and Enhalus spp.) and seston particulate organic matter (fraction retained on a 0.7 μm pore diameter filter) collected at the four study locations. The samples from living materials were milled, and encapsulated for elemental and isotopic analyses as described above. Living material containing carbonates in their tissues were acidified with 1 M HCl before analyses (see Table S3 in Supplementary materials). The seston filters were pretreated with acid using the fumigation method⁴⁷. In total 312 samples for carbon and nitrogen isotopic composition of putative carbon sources were analyzed.

For soil grain-size analysis, a Mastersizer 2000-Malvern was used following sieving (1 mm) digestion of <1 mm samples with 30% hydrogen peroxide at the Centro de Estudios Avanzados de Blanes, Spain. Grain size classification and texture were categorized following the Wentworth scale⁴⁸.

The concentrations of ²¹⁰Pb in the upper 20 to 30 cm of one to two cores per location were determined in the soil fraction <125 μm at the Universitat Autònoma de Barcelona (Spain) through the measurement of its granddaughter ²¹⁰Po assuming radioactive equilibrium between both radionuclides⁴⁹. Briefly, after addition of a known amount of ²⁰⁹Po as yield tracer, samples were acid digested in an analytical microwave, the polonium isotopes were auto-plated in silver discs and the concentration of ²¹⁰Po quantified by alpha spectrometry. The concentrations of excess ²¹⁰Pb used to obtain the age models were determined as the difference between total ²¹⁰Pb and ²²⁶Ra (supported ²¹⁰Pb). Concentrations of ²²⁶Ra were determined for selected samples along each core by low-background liquid scintillation counting method (Wallac 1220 Quantulus)⁵⁰. These concentrations were found to be in agreement with the concentrations of total ²¹⁰Pb at depth below the excess ²¹⁰Pb horizons. Analyses of reagent blanks, replicates and a reference material (IAEA - 315, marine sediment) were carried out for both ²¹⁰Pb and ²²⁶Ra to assess for any contamination and to ensure reproducibility of the results, (Table S4 in Supplementary materials).

A total of 94 radiocarbon analyses were conducted in 25 of the 29 cores sampled (2–5 cores per location) at two soil depths per core (cm 18–21 and the bottom cm towards the end for the ‘port core’, and cm 40 and the bottom cm towards the end for the ‘whole core’), at the AMS Direct Laboratory (USA). Samples consisted of pooled shells and bulk soil, (Table S5 in Supplementary materials).

The IsoSource software package⁵¹ was used, using δ¹³C and δ¹⁵N, to estimate the proportion of the C_org in the soil derived from different plants with atmospheric (e.g. A. marina and halophytes) and aquatic (e.g. seaweeds, seagrasses and suspended particulate organic matter ‘seston’) photosynthesis collected at the four study sites, using a 1% increment and 0.1 to 0.5‰ tolerance.

The soil C_org stocks per unit area (g C_org m⁻²) were estimated for 10 cm and 1 m soil thicknesses (i.e. cumulative mass). Where necessary (i.e. in 7 cores), we inferred C_org stocks below the limits of the reported data to 1 m, by extrapolating linearly the cumulative C_org stocks to 1 m.

Soil C_org sequestration rates (expressed in g DW m⁻² y⁻¹) for the last century and the last millennia were estimated using ²¹⁰Pb (CF:CS model)²⁴, and ¹⁴C age models, respectively. Mean soil accretion rates (SAR; mm y⁻¹) over the last 200 to 5000 years (i.e. based on ¹⁴C) were determined by calibrating the raw radiocarbon dates reported by the Laboratory using the R routine “Bacon” (Marine13 curve) for Bayesian chronology building⁵² and corrected for the marine reservoir effect (i.e. subtracting Delta R value of 110 ± 38 for the Red Sea)⁵³. From the Bacon routine output, the mean age was used to produce an age-depth weighted regression model forced through 0 (0 cm is cal. BP: 1950), using as weight the sum of the Euclidean distance of the minimum and maximum ages.

Sequestration rates of C_org were estimated by dividing the inventories in 100 cm-thick soil by the average soil accretion rate derived from ¹⁴C, whereas, the ²¹⁰Pb-derived sequestration rate was calculated for 10 cm-thick soils by multiplying the soil accretion rate by the fraction of C_org accreted since 1900. For the cores that were not possibly dated, we assumed they supported the same accretion rates as the dated cores at the same location. The cores from Economic city could not be successfully dated with ²¹⁰Pb (i. e. showed mixing) and we assumed that the soil accretion rate of that area is the average of the successfully dated cores in other locations.

Statistical analyses were carried out using JMP software, including descriptive statistics and ANOVA (for all 29 cores), and General Linear Mixed Models (GLMM) (for 25 cores, as cores less than 1 m long were excluded) to test for differences among forests, followed by Tukey HSD posthoc tests to assess pairwise differences among sites and soil depths.

Generalized Linear Mixed Models (GLMM) were used to take into account the potential non-independence of samples taken at different depths within the same core, since depth is a proxy for time in the cores. And given the spatial separation of cores within mangrove forests (hundreds of meters) we considered the cores themselves to be spatially independent. All response variables (bulk density, C_org, δ¹³C signatures and soil grain size fractions) were square-root transformed prior to analyses to homogenize their variances. Study sites (Thuwal Island, Economic City, Petro Rabigh and Khor Alkharar) and soil depth nested within cores were treated as fixed factors, whereas replicate cores within sites was treated as random factor.

Author Contributions

H.A., O.S., C.M.D. and X.I. designed the study. H.A. and O.S. carried out the field measurements. H.A., O.S., A.A.O. carried out the lab measurements. All authors contributed to the statistical analysis and writing of the manuscript.

Competing Interests

The authors declare that they have no competing interests.