Suspended consultant surgeon challenges official inquiry: In the second paragraph of this story (10 October, p 970) it was incorrectly stated that the clinical panel that reported on Christopher Ingoldby was headed by Professor Liam Donaldson. As the then director of the NHS Executive Northern and Yorkshire Regional Office, Professor Donaldson set up the panel; it was headed by Bill Darling, chairman of Gateshead and Greater Tyneside Health Authority.