Transcutaneous flow related variables measured in vivo: the effects of gender

Abstract

Backgound

The identification of potential sources of error is a crucial step for any new assessment technique. This is the case for transcutaneous variables, such as flow and arterial gases, which have been applied as functional indicators of various aspects of human health. Regarding gender, a particular subject-related determinant, it is often claimed that women present higher transcutaneous oxygen pressure (tcpO₂) values than men. However, the statistical significance of this finding is still uncertain.

Methods

The haemodynamical-vascular response to a local reactive hyperaemia procedure (the tourniquet cuff manoeuvre) was studied in two previously selected group of volunteers (n = 16; 8 women and 8 men). The effect of gender was assessed under standardised experimental conditions, using the transcutaneous flow-related variables tcpO₂-tcpCO₂ and Laser-doppler Flowmetry (LDF).

Results

Regarding tcpO₂, statistically significant differences between genders were not found, although higher values were consistently found for the gases in the female group. Regarding LDF, high statistically significant differences (p < 0.005) were found, with the men's group presenting the highest values and variability. Other derived parameters used to characterise the vascular response following the cuff-deflation (t-peak) were similar in both groups.

Conclusions

The relative influence of gender was not clearly demonstrated using these experimental conditions. However the gender-related LDF differences suggest that further investigation should be done on this issue. Perhaps in the presence of certain pathological disparities involving peripheral vascular regulation, other relationships may be found between these variables.

Background

Transcutaneous measurement of flow related variables such as blood flow velocity obtained by Laser Doppler "flowmetry" (LDF) and arterial gases (tcPO₂ and tcPCO₂) obtained by transcutaneous "gasometry" have proven to be very useful from both clinical and basic science perspectives [1-4]. Relevant research produced over the last 15–20 years has demonstrated a wide interest involving these variables, far beyond the primary areas of interest such as dermatology and vascular medicine [4-7]. It also contributed to identify most of the determinants affecting this variables when obtained in the adult, therefore contributing to define its full applicability. And this seems to be particularly important to the tcPO₂ assessment, through which several inferences involving the local arterial blood flow and tissue oxygenation [7-9] and the skin metabolic activity [10,11] are drawn.

It is known that the LDF signal is particularly dependent upon tissue light scattering which is complex at the skin's surface due to local variations and the structural specificity of the skin's vascular architecture [4,12] Artefacts such as the pulsatile profile of the signal [4,13] and some degree of laser instability (probably as a consequence of the reduced spatial resolution of most unidimensional flowmeters [14,15]) are systematically present. However it can be extremely useful to assess local microvascular perfusion as long as its depence on the focal point evaluated is considered [4,12,14-16]. As far as the arterial gases (tcpO₂ is and tcpCO₂) are concerned, further considerations should be taken into account. The assessment is usually made using an electrochemical technique based on a modified clark electrode coupled to a heat-source [17,18]. Once applied on the skin's surface the gas diffusion is set and detected by the gas-sensitive electrode. However (a) gas diffusion through the skin is specially dependent from the cardio-respiratory function [1,3,19] (b) a previous pre-heating of the skin (43 to 45°C) is necessary since at 37°C recorded values are near zero; in turn, some thermal instability is evoked at the skin surface leading to additional oxygen consumption [3,20](c) epidermal (cellular) consumption should also be considered as a factor contributing to decrease oxygen partial pressure detected at skin surface [1,3,19,20]; (d) Stratum corneum thickness and cohesion also affect the tcpO₂ diffusion [1]. Regarding tcPCO₂ it is accepted that, compared with tcPO₂, (a) it is faster eliminated, (b) it presents higher solubility in water, (c) it is not consumed by the evaluation electrode and, (d) it is relatively constant due to the high buffering capacity of the extracellular fluids [2,3]. However, there are limitations to its utility; its dependence on respiratory control, and relative difficulty in correlation with tissue metabolic activity, are among these.

Other person linked limitations and therefore, main potential sources of error specially affecting all flow dependent variables includes:

- regular (or even occasional) consumption of vasoactive substances such as alcohol and/or nicotine (cigarette smoking), specially capable of affecting the cutaneous microcirculation [21,22];

- posture of the individuals, specially when evaluated near the extremities, due to the special characteristics of microcirculatory dynamics at this regions [23-25]

- anatomical variation of tcPO₂ measurements, almost negligible in healthy individuals for various anatomical regions with the exception of the face (probably related with the pilosebaceous units) and the palm and sole (as a result of the particular epidermal thickness at this points)[3,26,27]

- age – values obtained in young children greatly differ from adults not only in terms of the respective cardiorespiratory indicators which influence this variables. The oxygen consumption rate of the skin was also found to be age dependent[1,26,28];

- gender – regarding tcPO₂, sex related differences have been reported [26]; in particular, it was suggested that women have significantly higher values than men [3,26,29].

Although most of this "person-linked" sources of error may be avoided by adequate experimental design, some aspects such as the gender may be critical when defining a control group. Only a few papers approached this particular variable and, in some cases, results have been contradictory [26,29,30]. Thus, recognising the relative importance of gender as an eventual determinant of these flow related variables, we tested hemodinamical response in volunteers from both sexes following a tourniquet cuff occlusion manoeuvre. This methodology allows us to test the local vascular adaptation to controlled stress conditions by the transcutaneous indicators tcPO₂ and LDF.

Methods

Data was obtained from healthy volunteers selected after informed written consent, according to previously defined inclusion criteria. Volunteers (n = 16) were equally distributed in two groups according to the gender (females n = 8; and males n = 8). All volunteers were under the age of 25 years (21.9 ± 22.2 years) and presented a normal (non-pathological) profile as defined in the referred inclusion criteria. These included the total absence of (a) any history of skin or cardiovascular diseases; (b) systemic diseases; (c) regular medication 60 days (minimum) prior to selection, or occasional if vasoactive; (d) smoking and/or drinking (alcohol) addiction. An absolute restriction of alcohol and coffee was imposed to all volunteers 6 H before testing.

All measurements occurred in laboratory environment, involving the permanent control of room temperature and humidity, according to the usual recommendations regarding the application of this type of technologies[3,32,35]. Prior to all measurements volunteers were left in the room for at least 20 minutes in order to allow full skin's adaptation to room's (temperature and humidity) condition.

The experimental methodology involved the generation of a loal reactive hyperaemia as a consequence of a localised occlusion manoeuvre at the upper limb extremity following which the different transcutaneous indicators were registered and compared with basal reference values. The sequential steps for this methodology were adapted from previously published protocols [3,19,31] and taken as follows:

1. the cuff application took place, being applied immediately before the flexion surface of the left arm over the forearm ; the anatomical areas selected were the mid portion of the left ventral forearm (along the midline) and hand (3rd finger)

2. all volunteers adopted the seated position in order to avoid any hemodinamical changes influencing measurements [1,24,25]

3. supra-systolic pressure (180–240 mmHg) was insuflated into the pressure cuff in order to ensure full occlusion of the brachial artery and maintained for at least 3 minutes after confirmed stabilisation ;

4. after this period the cuff was deflated determining a local reactive hyperaemia; all variables were recorded for at least 15 minutes after occlusion, until full stabilisation.

Transcutaneous indicators considered adequate for the present study purposes were :

- transcutaneous (tc) pO₂ and tcpCO₂ (in mmHg) assessed through the TINA TCM3 system (Radiometer, Denmark); the probe consists in a sole combined electrode [3,17,18] which allows simultaneous recordings of tcpO₂ and tcpCO₂;

- local microcirculation assessed through laser doppler flowmetry (LDF, expressed in arbitrary blood perfusion units or BPU's) with the Oxford Array (Oxford Optronics, UK) system [4].

These variables permitted us to establish the dynamical dependencies between them, expressed in terms of the analysis of tcpO₂ and peripheral LDF dynamics modification during the hyperaemic period. Time to reach peak values of tcpO₂ and LDF ("t-peak tcpO₂" and "t-peak LDF" respectively) were calculated considering the 1st time value (immediately before cuff deflation) as zero until the first LDF curve peak obtained after cuff deflation. Respective slopes were further analysed and correlated (Spearman) to check for additional (functional) parameters and reciprocal relationships between this variables. Slopes obtained during the linear portion of the tcpO₂ falling curves during occlusion were used to estimate skin's oxygen consumption rate through the application of the following expression :

VO₂ = αΔPO₂

where α is the O₂ solubility in ml. g^-1. atm^-1 assumed to be that of water at the same temperature (0.02226 at 43°C) and ΔPO₂ the rate of fall of tcpO₂ in atm.min^-1[10,11]. The oxygen coefficient was fixed at 0.02226 ml O₂ (ml water)^-1. atm^-1 at 43°C.

The non parametric Wilcoxon paired-test and Mann-Withney (for independent variables comparison) were chosen according with a normal or asymmetric data distribution. Spearman non parametric test was also used to study correlation between variables. A significance level of p < 0.05 was adopted.

A "Power Calculation" was also performed to assess the relative power of the analysis.

Results

Typical curves obtained under the present experimental conditions are shown in Figure 1 as an illustrative example of the methodology chosen. Recordings of transcutaneous gases and LDF served also to inform about the efficacy of the occlusion process (Table 1 and Table 3) although, for well known reasons a true zero value cannot be obtained for none of this variables [4,12,13].

Figure 1.

Example of transcutaneous recordings during a 300 second tourniquet cuff occlusion (initiated at 300 s and finished at 600 s) obtained in the upper extremity at arm level illustrating the sequential events detected in the variables tcpO₂, tcpCO₂ and LDF. Gender related differences, as reported in the literature for the transcutaneous gases are apparent. However, striking differences are consistently found for the LDF measurements obtained under the present experimental conditions (see text)

Table 1.

Descriptive statistics for the transcutaneously assessed gases

Female
tcO2 (mmHg)	Basal	Occlusion	Post occlusive	t-peak
	(T0)	(T1)	(T2)	(s)
Mean	73,9	3,6	76,9	346,9
St. deviation	14,6	2,1	10,8	147,1
	NS	NS	NS
p
	*	*
toCO2 (mmHg)	Basal	Occlusion	Post occlusive
	(T0)	(T1)	(T2)
Mean	40,5	52,6	39,2
St. deviation	9,8	13,1	10,2
	*	*	*
p
	*	*
Male
tcO2 (mmHg)	Basal	Occlusion	Post occlusive	t-peak
	(T0)	(T1)	(T2)	(s)
Mean	65,7	2,8	64,1	343,1
St. deviation	11,9	2,4	14,1	160,4
	NS	NS	NS
p
	*	*
toCO2 (mmHg)	Basal	Occlusion	Post occlusive
	(T0)	(T1)	(T2)
Mean	36,0	44,9	34,5
St. deviation	7,4	11,5	8,4
	NS	NS	NS
p
	*	*

NS non significant differences found ^* p < 0.05

Table 3.

Descriptive statistics for the LDF values obtained under the present experimental conditions

Female	Basal	Occlusion	Post exclusive	t-peak
LDF (BPU's)	(T0)	(T1)	(T2)	(s)
Mean	165,4	43,0	143,6	78,75
St. deviation	126,8	18,2	108,3	57,1
	NS	NS	NS
p
	*	*
Male	Basal	Occlusion	Post occlusive	t-peak
LDF (BPU's)	(T0)	(T1)	(T2)	(s)
Mean	547,8	51,1	536,2	131,3
St. deviation	211,5	11,1	215,4	178,7
	NS	NS	NS
p
	*	*

NS non significant differences found ^* p < 0.05

The female group have consistently higher mean values of tcpO₂ for each period of time considered. For this group tcpO₂ varied from 73.9 ± 14.6 mmHg in basal condition, to 3.6 ± 2.1 mmHg during stabilised occlusion, to 76.9 ± 10.8 mmHg in the post-occlusive (stabilised) period. For the male group tcpO₂ varied from 65.7 ± 11.9 mmHg in basal condition, to 2.8 ± 2.4 mmHg during stabilised occlusion, to 64.1 ± 14.1 mmHg in the post-occlusive (stabilised) period. Statistically significant differences between reference mean (basal) tcpO₂ and those obtained during the post-occlusive period could not be found (p > 0.05) in any of the groups, demonstrating full recovery to reference conditions during the experimental time considered.

The parameter "t-peak tcpO₂" values were very similar in both groups, suggesting a similar functional behaviour. In fact, no matter the differences detected between groups during the experiments, statistically significant differences (Mann-Whithey) could not be demonstrated between genders (power 0,8) for any of the considered periods nor for the "t-peak tcpO₂" parameter.

Regarding tcpCO₂ the same gender-related aspects were found. For the female group, values varied from 40.5 ± 9.8 mmHg in basal conditions, reaching a peak during occlusion at 52.6 ± 13.1 mmHg, to 39.2 ± 10.2 mmHg in the post-occlusive (stabilised) period. For the male group mean values were 36.0 ± 7.4 mmHg in basal conditions, 44.9 ± 11.5 mmHg, during occlusion and 34.5 ± 8.4 mmHg in the post-occlusive (stabilised) period. In both groups post-occlusive values significantly differed from basal values unlike the oxygen changes recorded (power ~1). Statistically significant differences (Mann-Whithney) could not be demonstrated between genders for any of the considered periods.

The initial portion of the tcpO₂ occlusion curve was also used to assess the local metabolic oxygen consumption. This parameter was calculated from the linear portion of the decremental rate period of tcpO₂ curve during occlusion. As shown in Table 2 similar VO₂ values (female:0.008 ± 0.004 ml O₂. g^-1. min^-1 and male: 0.007 ± 0.004 ml O₂. g^-1. min^-1) were obtained in both sexes which reflects the non-significant (p > 0.05) differences detected for the tcpO₂ slopes calculated during this period.

Table 2.

Skin metabolic O₂ consumption estimation with subjects breathing in atmospheric air

Female	ΔPO2	VO2
	atm.min-1	ml O2/g/min
Mean	-0,3500
St. deviation	-0,1977
Male	ΔPO2	VO2
	atm.min-1	ml O2/g/min
Mean	-0,1780
St. deviation	0,1204

Evaluation of the peripheral LDF in both groups showed highly significant perfusion differences (power~ 1) between female and male volunteers. Similar profiles but presenting very different magnitudes were obtained in each of the considred periods. For females, LDF varied from 165.4 ± 126.8 BPU's in basal condition, to 43.0 ± 18.2 BPUs during stabilised occlusion, to 143.6 ± 108.3 BPU's in the post-occlusive (stabilised) period (Table 3); statistically significant differences between reference mean (basal) LDF and those obtained during the post-occlusive period could not be found (p > 0.05). For the male group mean LDF values were 547.8 ± 211.5 BPU's in basal condition, 51.1 ± 11.1 mmHg during stabilised occlusion, and 536.2 ± 215.4 BPU's in the post-occlusive (stabilised) period; again, statistically significant differences between basal and post-occlusive values were not found. Regarding the "t-peak LDF", no matter the different signal magnitudes recorded, statistically significant differences could not be found (p = 0.779) comparing "t-peak LDF" parameters in both groups, involving 78.8 ± 57.1 s for the female group and 131.3 ± 178.7 s for the male group, respectively (Table 3).

Discussion

The possibility to quantitatively describe transcutaneous variables such as tcPO₂, tcPCO₂, and LDF offered the opportunity to non-invasively assess several potential indicators of vascular physiology and pathophysiology from the microcirculatory perspective [5,7,32]. LDF and tcPO₂ measurements were advantageous in many different areas of applicability to classical methods such as peripheral pulses and peripheral blood pressure measurements assessed by plethysmography or by doppler segmental pressure analysis [7,11,32,33].

Among the several methodologies proposed, special attention was given to "tourniquet cuff occlusion", a dynamical manoeuvre often used in vascular physiology and pathophysiology to test the regulatory response of the vascular territory to a sudden change of perfusion conditions [3,11,19,34]. This manoeuvre is frequently used to describe dynamical phenomena determining the local oxygen supply and consumption, obtaining parameters such as the Oxygen Reappearance Time (ORT) following occlusion, and the Oxygen Recovery Index (ORI), which is also used to assess the time for O₂ molecules to diffuse from capillaries to the tcpO₂ sensor[34] or to obtain, from the tcPO₂ signal, other hemodinamical representative parameters [20,32,34]. This procedure was also recently suggested to validate the cutaneous blood flow assessment techniques [35].

Therefore, this approach seemed to be particularly suitable to test, under controlled conditions, the influence of several determinants over this variables, including gender. The occlusion methodology, a critical aspect of this procedure, was consistently reproducible as shown from the T1 (stabilised occlusion) values both for tcpO₂ and LDF (Table 1 and Table 3) although an absolute "zero" value could not be achieved. It was impossible to obtain a true zero value for the LDF signal. This results from the residual movement capacity of red blood cells still arrested in the occluded vessels, thus producing minor doppler components which are detected by the system [4,12-15]. The same impossibility detected for the tcpO₂ seems to result from the slow release of the gas from the blood arrested in the territory under occlusion which cannot be accomplished during the time duration of the experiment.

Even though it is reported as one factor influencing tcPO₂ measurements [26], only a few papers refer to the influence of gender on transcutaneous measurements. The most recently published study involving tcpO₂ mapping in several anatomical sites could only detect statistically significant differences in the leg [29].

In the present study, consistently higher tcpO₂ values were obtained in the female group; however (Table 1 and Figure 1) these values were not significantly different, in statistical terms, from the mean values obtained in the male group. These differences may result from different magnitudes of well known variables affecting measurements in both groups, namely (1) different epidermal thickness between male and female, thus determining different tcpO₂ diffusion capacities; (2) different epidermal consumption, apparently lower in the female group, determining lower oxygen consumption levels at skin surface; (3) minor thermal instability at skin's surface as a consequence of the previous factors, determining lower local electrode consumption in the female group. However, it is important to underline that, regarding the "t-peak" parameter which was used as an indicator of the autoregulatory reflex response induced by the occlusion manoeuvre, identical values were obtained in both sexes, suggesting that the vascular response is not affected by the gender in the present experimental conditions. Further analysis involving this property which provides information about local vascular status, may be done in other patient groups with vascular disease meaning that a possible influence of gender should be still investigated [8,31,32,36].

Regarding LDF signals, the influence of gender over the LDF data is not referred to in the literature, where posture [37,40] physical[38] and mental activities [39], anatomical region [40], and age and race [41,42] are claimed to be the main subject-related influencing factors. However, under the present experimental conditions, a clear difference was observed between genders with a clear predominance of the male group (Figure 1) for the absolute means obtained in T1 and T2 (p < 0.005). The "t-peak LDF" assessed in both groups to further characterise the vascular reactive response following occlusion, was not significantly different between groups (Table 3). The evaluation of the slopes obtained by the line defined between cuff deflation and the first 75 seconds following this period significantly differed in both groups (p < 0.005) as a consequence of the basal (T1) differences, thus involving different local blood masses and ejection velocities. Despite these results, conclusions on this matter should further consider (1) the relative unspecificity of this signal, (2) the pulsatile nature of the recordings, complicating the numerical analysis and (3) the reduced number of volunteers involved in the present analysis. Moreover, accepting that, from a physiological point of view LDF and tcpO₂ are typically defined by a flow – related character, relationships between the evolution of these variables were investigated using the non-parametric Spearman correlation test. Analysis focusing either the linear portion of the occlusion decremental phase and the hyperaemic response following cuff deflation as well, could not demonstrate any significant relationship regarding these variables evolution, which underlines the high variability of data distribution.

The tcO₂ decay curve was also used to estimate the local tissue metabolic activity (Table 2). In order to assess this information the amount of oxygen delivered by haemoglobine (Hb) must be determined by an O₂ – Hb binding curve at the evaluation temperature (43°C)[20]. In the present case O₂ consumption rate (VO₂) was estimated from the oxygen solubility coefficient chosen at 0.02226 ml O₂ (ml water)^-1. atm^-1 at 43°C [38] and no other corrections were made for the patients breathing atmospheric air. So, this information was only estimated to confirm the similar character of the VO₂ parameters obtained in both groups, resulting from similar tcO₂ curve profiles. Although slightly higher values were obtained for the female group, no statistically significant differences could be found.

Finally, it is accepted that tcpCO₂ is governed by different factors from those primarily affecting the tcPO₂ and LDF. tcpCO₂ values basically correspond to the arterial gas content added by the local blood flow CO₂, by the temperature effect and by the local tissue production, including the skin (estimated around 2–6 mmHg) [2,3,42]. Good correlation between arterial and transcutaneous pCO₂ are described [42,43] but tcpCO₂ values are slightly higher mainly due to the surface electrode heating and to the skin's metabolic contribution. As shown in Table 1, the female group presented higher tcpCO₂ values in every period but, not significantly different from the male group. It is interesting to note though, that the mean post-occlusion values (T2) were consistently lower than the basal values in both groups (Table 1). This reduction, although not significant from the statistical point of view, may also indicate about the local vascular status, suggesting that the evoked autoregulatory reactive response following occlusion (the respective maximum being reached at the end of the occlusion period) may determine a local "washout" removing the CO₂ excess [3,36].

Conclusion

The vascular dynamical changes induced by the present approach suggests, regarding transcutaneous variables, that gender may not represent a main source of error at least from a functional (physiological) point of view. However, considering the preliminary characteristic of the study and the relative importance of a well defined control group specially for clinical purposes, this aspect should be further investigated in order to fully explore the practical relevance of these variables in the transcutaneous assessment of flow related functional parameters.

Competing Interests

None declared

Pre-publication history

The pre-publication history for this paper can be accessed here:

http://www.biomedcentral.com/1471-5945/1/4/prepub