Accelerated hepatocellular carcinoma recurrence rate after postoperative direct-acting antivirals treatment – preliminary report

Abstract

Aim of the study

New interferon-free direct-acting antiviral (DAA) therapy has led to major progress in hepatitis C virus (HCV) treatment. Current outcomes are promising, especially in compensated cirrhosis. However, there are reports of accelerated hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) recurrence after surgery in patients treated with DAAs. The influence of DAA therapy on the timing and frequency of recurrence after surgical treatment needs further observation.

Material and methods

Fifty-one HCV infected patients with advanced liver cirrhosis and history of surgical treatment for HCC in 2012-2016 were analyzed in a case-control study. Nineteen patients received DAA therapy (DAA group) after tumor remission achieved by surgery and 32 patients were not treated with DAA (NDAA group). Follow-up included multiphase computed tomography scan or magnetic resonance imaging of the liver and alpha-fetoprotein level in 3-6-month intervals.

Results

An sustained virological response was achieved in 18 (95%) DAA treated patients. Hepatocellular carcinoma recurrence was observed in 8 (42.1%) patients from the DAA group and in 21 (65.6%) from the NDAA group (p = 0.058). Relapse occurred within 265 days after surgery in the DAA group vs. 532 days in the NDAA group (p = 0.033). The one-year recurrence-free survival (RFS) rate was 47.3% vs. 75% in the DAA and NDAA group respectively (p = 0.45).

Conclusions

Use of DAA therapy in patients with a history of HCC may result in significantly accelerated relapse of the disease. The number of analyzed patients in this study is too small to state unquestionable conclusions. Further observation with a longer follow-up and larger patient group is needed. The study confirms that contemporary HCV treatment is highly effective.

Introduction

Hepatitis C virus (HCV) infection leads to chronic liver inflammation that results in cirrhosis in 20-30% of patients [1, 2]. Cirrhosis is the main risk factor for hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC), which occurs in 3.5% of these patients per year [3, 4]. Nearly 44% of HCC cases in Poland are caused by HCV cirrhosis [5].

Over the last few decades, HCV treatment has consisted of pegylated interferon (PegIFN) combined with ribavirin. The outcomes were evaluated as sustained virological response (SVR) – no viral RNA detected in blood in 12 weeks after completed therapy, which was observed in only 50% of patient [6, 7]. A positive response was correlated with significantly reduced risk of HCC occurrence [8-10].

The recent introduction of the new, interferon-free direct-acting antiviral agents (DAAs) led to major progress in HCV treatment. According to the latest reports, an SVR is achieved in more than 90% of cases including both groups of patients, with compensated and decompensated cirrhosis (95-97% vs. 85-90% respectively) [11-13]. Moreover, fewer contraindications and side effects compared to former therapy are noted [14]. Therefore, it is hoped that DAAs will provide better outcomes in prevention and treatment for both hepatic and extrahepatic HCV complications including HCC. However, there are reports of accelerated HCC recurrence after surgery in patients treated with DAA [15, 16]. The influence of DAA therapy on timing and frequency of the recurrence after surgery needs further observation.

Material and methods

Fifty-one HCV infected patients with advanced liver cirrhosis and history of surgical treatment for HCC in the Department of General and Transplantation Surgery of Medical University of Warsaw in the years 2012-2016 were analyzed in a case-control study.

The group consists of 33 male and 18 female patients at the mean age of 58.5 (36-67), body mass index (BMI) of 26.1 (22.5-28.4) and tumor diameter of 27.5 mm (12-50 mm). Diabetes was observed in 44.4% of patients.

Nineteen patients received DAA therapy (DAA group) after tumor remission achieved by surgery and 32 patients were not treated with DAA (NDAA group). Both groups were comparable in terms of age, sex, BMI, progress of liver cirrhosis (Child-Pugh A or B), diameter and number of tumor foci and class (0 or A) in the BCLC criteria. Initial alpha-fetoprotein (AFP) serum level was used only in the post-operative follow-up and it was not considered in the analysis due to weak predictive value. Surgical procedures included percutaneous radiofrequency ablation (RFA), RFA at open laparotomy or non-anatomic liver resection. All these methods for HCC treatment were considered as equivalent, referring to the meta-analysis by Yi et al. [17] (Table 1).

Table 1.

Patient groups characterization for tumor risk factors and time to direct-acting antiviral agents treatment introduction

Factors	Direct-acting antiviral agents		Not treated with direct-acting antiviral agents
Number of patients	19 (37%)		32 (63%)
Number of SVR	18 (94.7%)		–
Diameter of the tumor [mm]	25.9 (12-46)		29.6 (16-50)
AFP before treatment [mg/dl]	139.2 (2-880)		32.4 (1.7-198)
AFP after treatment [mg/dl]	19.2 (0-122)		11.6 (0-28)
Time from surgery to DAA [days]	326.7 (20-1513)		–
	HCC recurrence (8 cases) 259.6 (20-762)	No HCC recurrence (11 cases) 375.5 (31-1531)

SVR – sustained virological response, AFP – alpha-fetoprotein, HCC – hepatocellular carcinoma, DAA – direct-acting antiviral agent

Follow-up included multiphase computed tomography scan or magnetic resonance imaging of the liver and AFP serum level in 3-6-month intervals. The observation of any lesion with a characteristic HCC-like washout image in radiological examination was the basis to recognize the tumor relapse. Mean time from surgery to relapse was calculated for both groups to assess whether the tumor had recurred earlier in the DAA group. Moreover, one-year recurrence-free survival (RFS) rate, defined as the time from remission to any recurrence or any death according to the STEEP System proposed by American Society of Clinical Oncology (ASCO) [18], was estimated to unify the prognosis evaluation.

The whole group is under constant observation in our clinic. Patients not treated throughout one year are still without DAA therapy, although the majority of them are being qualified for the treatment program. The further results will be updated.

The quantitative variables are expressed as mean with the range in parentheses, and qualitative variables are expressed as absolute numbers with the percentages in parentheses. The χ² test was used to determine whether there was a significant association between the study and control group. Kaplan-Meier estimates of the recurrence-free survival rates were calculated and compared using the Wilcoxon test. A p-value < 0.05 was considered as statistically significant.

Results

An SVR was achieved in 18 (95%) DAA treated patients. Hepatocellular carcinoma recurrence was observed in 8 (42.1%) patients from the DAA group and in 21 (65.6%) from the NDAA group (p = 0.058). There is no statistical evidence that the use of DAAs is associated with an increased rate of HCC recurrence. Relapse occurred within 265 (94-698) days after surgery in the DAA group vs. 532 (118-1360) days in the NDAA group, which was statistically significant (p = 0.033). The one-year recurrence-free survival (RFS) rate was 47.3% (9 patients) vs. 75% (24 patients) in the DAA and NDAA groups, respectively (p = 0.45) (Fig. 1).

Fig. 1.

Kaplan-Meier plot to compare hepatocellular carcinoma recurrence-free survival in both groups

Discussion

The new DAA therapy is certainly a breakthrough in HCV treatment. Effectiveness defined as an SVR is achieved in more than 90% of cases [11-13] in comparison to 50% in traditional PegIFN and ribavirin treatment [6, 7]. Direct-acting antiviral agents also improve the function of the cirrhotic liver with a decrease of aminotransferase level in serum and reduction of fibrosis stage in FibroScan imaging. Moreover, many authors have stated that the use of contemporary treatment in patients with HCV reduces the risk of HCC incidence [8-11, 13] as well as IFN therapy [8-10].

However, some disturbing reports of an increased HCC recurrence rate after the previous surgery have emerged. An unexpected increase of the tumor relapse was noted by Conti et al. [16]. Another trial did not confirm a similar dependency [15], although there is a lack of convincing evidence to certainly prove it. Our study reveals a relevant difference in the HCC recurrence rate in DAA and NDAA groups (42.1% vs. 65.6% respectively) although statistical significance was not achieved (p > 0.05). Meanwhile, some reports suggest possible acceleration of tumor relapse in the group of DAA-treated patients. Although the final recurrence rate is close to the result in the control group, it seems that the neoplasm may recur earlier in the postoperative period and spread more aggressively than the primal lesion [15, 16, 19, 20]. In our trial recurrence was observed significantly earlier in the DAA than in the NDAA group (256 vs. 532 days after surgery, p < 0.05).

Early recurrence may be correlated with numerous factors, such as diameter and volume of the tumor, cancer malignancy, number of lesions, invasion of the vessels, elevated level of AFP and progress of liver cirrhosis. In the material, the mean diameter of the tumor in the NDAA group was larger than in the DAA group (25.9 mm vs. 29.6 mm), which could be the reason for the higher recurrence rate in the NDAA group. Meanwhile, the 4-times higher level of AFP observed in the DAA group compared to NDAA may be related to the more aggressive form of HCC and can explain faster relapse.

The use of DAA treatment is a new factor with an unknown impact on the tumor. One of the current hypotheses of Tatsumi et al. indicates involvement of immunological mechanisms. Dysregulation of the NK cell population in the liver caused by C virus was revealed. The immediate elimination of the virus and pathogenic antigens caused by DAAs is suspected to inflict the conversion of NK cells. That could lead to the loss of immunological surveillance and accelerate the neoplasm relapse [21].

Due to the need for understandable international communication especially in oncology we also decided to present the outcome of the trial as the one-year RFS rate using criteria proposed by ASCO – the STEEP System. STEEP defines RFS as the time from remission to any recurrence or any death [18]. One-year lasting RFS achieved by less than half of DAA patients (47.3%) vs. 75% of the NDAA group (p < 0.05).

It is important to perform further observations of DAAs’ effects on the group of patients with history of HCC surgical treatment.

Conclusions

Contemporary HCV treatment is highly effective especially in compensated cirrhosis. The trial shows that use of DAA therapy in patients with a history of HCC may result in significantly accelerated relapse of the disease and a lower one-year RFS rate, which leads to worse prognosis for this group of patients. However, the numbers in the study are too small to generalize the conclusions. Further observation with a longer follow-up and larger patient group is needed.

Considering these facts, we suggest carefully deliberating indications to introduce the DAAs and increase the intensity of long-term post-operative care (examination with CT-scan/MRI, Duplex-Doppler USG and AFP included) in the group of patients with HCC.

Disclosure

Authors report no conflict of interest.