Para-duodenal hernia: a report of five cases and review of literature

Abstract

Background

Para-duodenal hernia (PDH) represents rare clinical entities based on few literatures.

Case presentation

We report five cases of Para-duodenal hernia, all occurring in male patients ranging from 34 to 75 years of age. The patients had varied manifestations presenting with abdominal pain with or without vomiting and nausea and with or without signs of intestinal obstruction. CT images showed cluster of dilated bowel segments with displaced mesenteric vessels at hernial orifice. Laparoscopic surgical approach was adopted, and the patients were discharged about a week later without further complications.

Conclusion

We hope to raise awareness about the management of this rare clinical entity and the benefits of CT imaging and laparoscopic surgery as standard approaches.

Background

Para-duodenal hernias (PDH) have traditionally been considered the most frequent type of congenital internal hernia [1]. Left para-duodenal hernia (hernia of Lanzert) is about three times more common than the right counterpart (Waldayer’s hernia) [2]. Left para-duodenal hernia (LPDH) is a congenital defect with an occurrence of approximately 2% of the population. It is posterior to the inferior mesenteric vein and left branches of middle colic artery and is situated to the left of the fourth part of the duodenum. It arises from the fossa of Landzert [3–5]. The fossa to the left of the fourth part of the duodenum is the area where the small bowel loops (usually jejunum) prolapse through and into the left portion of the transverse mesocolon. The herniated small bowel loops may therefore become trapped within the mesenteric sac [5, 6]. The initial rotation of the midgut behind and then left to the superior mesenteric artery and comes to lie in the left side of the abdomen behind the mesentery of the descending colon leads to development of LPDH [7]. The right para-duodenal hernia (RPDH) occurs when the small bowel herniates through a defect in the first part of the jejunal mesentery in the so called Waldeyer’s fossa. At autopsy, the Waldeyer’s fossa was found in about 1% of the population [8]. The malrotation of the midgut and failure of fusion of mesentery to parietal peritoneum create a hernial defect called RPDH. PDH can lead to bowel obstruction, ischemia, and perforation with a high mortality [6]. Clinical diagnosis of PDH is a challenge as symptoms are entirely non-specific. They usually affect males more than females (3:1) [9, 10]. Most patients are diagnosed between the 4th and 6th decades of life and the mean age of diagnosis is 38.5 years [2]; for our case series all were males. 75% of mesocolic hernias occur on the left side and 25% on the right side with middle mesocolic hernia being very rare [11]. In medical literature, para-duodenal hernias causing intestinal obstruction are few and report no evidence of long lasting postoperative ileus after surgery. We report herein five cases of PDH and their management based on a review of literatures.

Case presentation

Case 1

A 68-year-old man complained left middle abdominal pain for 10 days. The pain was paroxysmal without nausea and vomiting. It got worse after meals. He has a past medical history of chronic gastritis treated with regular proton pump inhibitor. He had laparoscopic cholecystectomy 2 years ago. The results of complete blood count, serum and urine amylase were within normal limit. Endoscopy showed chronic gastritis with bile reflux. His abdominal CT scan showed that a part of small intestine and its mesentery were folded together on the left side of the abdomen (Fig. 1). The patient was diagnosed with abdominal internal hernia and laparoscopic surgery was done. During the surgery, a soft mass of 5 cm in diameter was found within the transverse mesocolon. It was later found to be that 60 cm of the small intestine, which was trapped through a defect in the transverse mesocolon. The defect was 2 cm in diameter on the left side of the ascending part of duodenum (Fig. 2) within the mesocolon. The entrapped intestinal loop was reduced, and the defect was repaired. He was diagnosed with left paraduodenal hernia and was discharged on 7th post-operative day. No abnormal presentation was found during follow-up. (Table 1).

Fig. 1.

Transverse view of CT image showing the cluster of small intestine and its mesentery. The entrapped intestinal loop was behind the infernal mesenteric vein (white arrow)

Fig. 2.

The defect in the transverse mesocolon. M: transverse mesocolon, D: the ascending part of duodenum, HO: hernia orifice

Table 1.

Summary of five cases of paraduodenal hernia

Cases	1	2	3	4	5
Features
Age (years old)	68	34	68	75	40
Gender	Male	Male	Male	Male	Male
Imaging modality	CT	CT	CT	CT	X-ray, CT
Radiological signs	CT scan showed a part of small intestine and its mesentery folded together at the left abdomen.	CT scan showed a fold at the left upper abdomen, consisting of small intestine coiled with mesentery.	CT scan showed part of small intestine was folded.	CT scan showed jejunum was folded at the left abdomen.	X-ray showed a mass at right upper abdominal quadrant. CT scan showed a part of small intestine and its mesentery were folded together at the right abdomen.
Location of hernia	Left	Left	Left	Left	Right
Presenting symptoms	Left middle abdominal paroxysmal pain for 10 days without nausea and vomiting.	Left upper abdominal paroxysmal pain for 24 h with vomiting.	Upper abdominal paroxysmal pain for 2 days with vomiting.	Paraumbilical pain and abdominal distention with nausea and vomiting for 13 h.	Right abdominal pain for 11 h with sudden onset.
Type of surgery	Laparoscopy	Laparoscopy	Laparoscopy	Laparoscopy turned into open	Laparoscopy
Discharge (nth POD)	7	7	7	14	9
Complications during follow-up	None	None	None	None	None

Case 2

A 34-year-old man complained about left upper abdominal pain for 24 h. The pain was paroxysmal accompanied with vomiting. His abdominal CT scan showed a fold, at the left upper abdomen, consisting of small intestine coiled with mesentery (Fig. 3). Subsequent laparoscopy found a loop of jejunum was entrapped in the left side of mesocolon through a defect on the left side of the ascending part of duodenum. After the reduction of the small intestine, the hernia orifice was opened large enough to prevent further herniation (Fig. 4). Post-operative recovery was uneventful, and the patient was discharged on 7th post-operative day. No abnormalities were found during follow-up so far. (Table 1).

Fig. 3.

Transverse view of CT image showing the cluster of small intestine and its mesentery

Fig. 4.

The defect in the transverse mesocolon was opened. M: mesocolon, IMV: inferior mesenteric vein, D: the ascending part of duodenum, HS: hernia sac

Case 3

A 68-year-old man complained about upper abdominal pain for 2 days. The pain was paroxysmal accompanied with vomiting. He was diagnosed with chronic gastritis 2 months ago and was treated with medications without any relief. His abdominal CT imaging showed part of the small intestine was folded (Figs. 5, 6). He underwent paraduodenal hernioplasty via laparoscopy. Surgery consisted of reduction of intestinal loops in the hernial sac and subsequent repair of the defect (Fig. 7). The length of the folded intestine was found to be 100 cm and the hernia was on the left side of mesocolon. He was discharged on 7th post-operative day and had no complications during follow-up so far. (Table 1).

Fig. 5.

Transverse view of CT image showing the cluster of small intestine and its mesentery entrapped in the left side of abdomen, beneath the left branch of middle mesenteric artery. The attenuated enhancement of the entrapped intestinal loop suggested intestinal ischemia

Fig. 6.

Coronary view of CT scan image showing the cluster of the small intestine

Fig. 7.

The defect in the transverse mesocolon. TC: transverse colon, D: the ascending part of duodenum, HO: hernia orifice

Case 4

A 75-year-old man complained about abdominal distention and pain for 13 h. The pain was paraumbilical accompanied with nausea and vomiting. His abdominal CT imaging showed that the jejunum was folded at the left abdomen (Figs. 8, 9). He was diagnosed with left paraduodenal hernia and laparoscopy was carried out. During the surgery, reduction of the entrapped jejunal loops from the hernial sac was attempted but failed due to severe adhesion with surrounding organs. It was then converted to open enterolysis. The defect of the mesocolon was found on the right side of the ascending duodenum and was repaired eventually with interrupted sutures (Fig. 10). After the surgery, the patient still felt occasional distension after meals, but no acute episode of obstruction has ever occurred. He was discharged two weeks later, and he had no complications during follow-up so far. (Table 1).

Fig. 8.

Transverse section of CT scan image showing the cluster of jejunum

Fig. 9.

Coronary view of CT scan image showing the cluster of the small intestine

Fig. 10.

The defect of transverse mesocolon was identified and closed with interrupted sutures. TC: transverse colon, D: the ascending part of duodenum, HO: hernia orifice

Case 5

A 40-year-old man complained about right abdominal pain for 11 h. The pain occurred suddenly without triggering factors. It was mild and intermittent. He has a history of laparoscopic cholecystectomy for one year. His abdominal X-ray showed a mass in the right upper quadrant of abdomen (Fig. 11). CT scan showed that a part of small intestine and its mesentery were folded together at the right abdomen (Figs. 12, 13). A diagnosis of right paraduodenal hernia was made. The patient underwent laparoscopic surgery during which the entrapped intestinal loop was reduced from a defect in the first part of the jejunal mesentery. He was discharged on 9th post-operative day. No other abnormal presentation was found during follow-up so far. (Table 1).

Fig. 11.

Abdominal X-ray showed a mass in the right upper quadrant of abdomen

Fig. 12.

Transverse view of CT image showing the cluster of small intestine and its mesentery on the right upper quadrant of abdomen before the descending part of duodenum

Fig. 13.

Coronary view of CT image showing the cluster of small intestine and its mesentery trapped within the right side of mesocolon

Discussion & conclusion

PDH also known as mesocolic hernias are congenital and derive from embryonary peritoneal anomalies and associated abnormal intestinal rotation [12]. These patients usually present with chronic abdominal pain and vomiting with or without signs of intestinal obstruction [9]. There is an associated risk of strangulation and intestinal infarction for more than 50% over the course of a lifetime, making it necessary to investigate radiological signs of hypoperfusion and intestinal ischemia [13]. The high rate of mortality associated with these complications make early identification indispensable and justifies the role of abdominal CT in the early pre-operative diagnosis of paraduodenal hernia. Multislice computer tomography (CT) offers high resolution and multiplanar images which may be very demonstrative and characteristic providing a precise and early diagnosis, useful for surgical treatment planning [6, 12]. In typical CT images, PDH shows a cluster of dilated bowel segments with engorged and displaced mesenteric vessels at the hernial orifice [14]. Early surgical intervention is essential to avoid future complications because patients with PDH have a 20–50% mortality for acute presentations [15, 16]. A literature search was performed to identify the rare cases of paraduodenal hernia treated with laparoscopic approach. Only 28 case reports were published between January 1998, in which Uernatsu et al. [17]. first described the minimally invasive treatment of this surgical emergency, and November 2015. The several advantages of laparoscopic approach, deduced after analysing data in previous cases, were: decrease in post-operative pain, reduced morbidity, early food resumption (1.33 average, 1–3), shorter hospital stay (3.60 average, range 1–10). These benefits occurred regardless of type of intervention (elective or emergency), type of repair (closure of hernial defect with continuous or interrupted suture, enlargement of defect or resection of the sac) and type of material used (adsorbable or not adsorbable, monofilament or poly-filament) [9, 10, 17–35]. We opted for laparoscopic approach for all our five patients who shared same benefits as described by other authors.

Therefore, based on our experience and current literatures, we believe that laparoscopic approach is the optimum treatment strategy for patients with paraduodenal hernia, especially in health centres with strong experience of advanced laparoscopic surgery. Patients with or without small bowel obstruction and hemodynamically stable are suitable to enjoy the benefits of laparoscopic approach. Computed tomography remains the gold standard of imaging modality for early diagnosis of this clinical entity. However, the limitation of our report is that the number of cases is small and hence, a concrete conclusion can only be drawn based on our experience so far.

Abbreviations

CT

Computed Tomography

LPDH

Left paraduodenal hernia

PDH

Paraduodenal hernia

POD

Post-operative Day

RPDH

Right paraduodenal hernia

Authors’ contributions

KS, DR and XP all have made substantial contributions to conception, acquisition of data, analysis, and interpretation of data. All of them have been involved in drafting the manuscript and revising it critically for important intellectual content. All authors read and approved the final manuscript and take public responsibility for appropriate portions of the content and agreed to be accountable for all aspects of work.

Ethics approval and consent to participate

Not applicable.

Consent for publication

Written informed consent was obtained from the participants for publication of this article and any accompanying tables/images. A copy of the written consent is available for review by the Editor of this journal.

Competing interests

The authors declare that they have no competing interests.

Publisher’s Note

Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.