Novel and de novo mutations in pediatric refractory epilepsy

Abstract

Pediatric refractory epilepsy is a broad phenotypic spectrum with great genetic heterogeneity. Next-generation sequencing (NGS) combined with Sanger sequencing could help to understand the genetic diversity and underlying disease mechanisms in pediatric epilepsy. Here, we report sequencing results from a cohort of 172 refractory epilepsy patients aged 0–14 years. The pathogenicity of identified variants was evaluated in accordance with the American College of Medical Genetics and Genomics (ACMG) criteria. We identified 43 pathogenic or likely pathogenic variants in 40 patients (23.3%). Among these variants, 74.4% mutations (32/43) were de novo and 60.5% mutations (26/43) were novel. Patients with onset age of seizures ≤12 months had higher yields of deleterious variants compared to those with onset age of seizures > 12 months (P = 0.006). Variants in ion channel genes accounted for the greatest functional gene category (55.8%), with SCN1A coming first (16/43). 81.25% (13/16) of SCN1A mutations were de novo and 68.8% (11/16) were novel in Dravet syndrome. Pathogenic or likely pathogenic variants were found in the KCNQ2, STXBP1, SCN2A genes in Ohtahara syndrome. Novel deleterious variants were also found in West syndrome, Doose syndrome and glucose transporter type 1 deficiency syndrome patients. One de novo MECP2 mutation were found in a Rett syndrome patient. TSC1/TSC2 variants were found in 60% patients with tuberous sclerosis complex patients. Other novel mutations detected in unclassified epilepsy patients involve the SCN8A, CACNA1A, GABRB3, GABRA1, IQSEC2, TSC1, VRK2, ATP1A2, PCDH19, SLC9A6 and CHD2 genes. Our study provides novel insights into the genetic origins of pediatric epilepsy and represents a starting-point for further investigations into the molecular pathophysiology of pediatric epilepsy that could eventually lead to better treatments.

Electronic supplementary material

The online version of this article (10.1186/s13041-018-0392-5) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Introduction

Epilepsy is a complex group of chronic brain disorders that are characterized by recurrent spontaneous seizures, and these can often begin in childhood. Repeated and refractory seizures can cause long-term cognitive impairment, decreased social participation and significantly lower quality of life [1, 2]. Epilepsy is one of the most common neurological disorders with 50 to 100 million affected worldwide, and 2 to 4 million new cases diagnosed each year [3].

Epilepsy is a heterogeneous disease with diverse clinical manifestations and causes, including altered ion channel expression, neurotransmitter signaling, synaptic structure, gliosis, and inflammation [1]. Estimates of heritability from twin studies range from 25% to 70% [4, 5]. Although the range of heritability estimates is quite large, disparate studies using varied methods and studying divergent populations are all consistent in concluding that there is a substantial inherited component to epilepsy [6]. Because of this, we sought to investigate the genome in a heterogeneous set of patients with epilepsy and their parents, with the hope that we would identify novel mutations and confirm existing reports of genetic associations with epilepsy. This type of genetic information can provide an entry point into the biology of epilepsy that could eventually lead to new molecular treatment targets.

With the rapid progress of next-generation sequencing (NGS) techniques, our knowledge of the genetic etiology in many brain disorders such as epilepsy, autism and intellectual disability has expanded greatly [7, 8]. NGS is now capable of efficient and accurate sequencing of entire genomes with small amounts of tissue at ever decreasing costs and has required new approaches to analysing the very large amount of data obtained. For this study, our priority was to separate common and benign genetic variants from those that are likely to be related to the cause of epilepsy, and we chose to apply the American College of Medical Genetics and Genomics (ACMG) guidelines [9–11]. The ACMG guidelines classify variants into pathogenic, likely pathogenic, uncertain significance, likely benign, and benign categories based on genetic information that includes population, functional, computational and segregation data. In this study, we investigated 153 epilepsy candidate genes in a cohort of 172 refractory epilepsy pediatric patients. We aimed to provide genetic diagnoses of this patient cohort and explore the genetic etiology of pediatric refractory epilepsy.

Method

Participants

We retrospectively collected and analyzed 172 cases of pediatric refractory epilepsy patients between the ages of 1 day to 14 years old in the Department of Pediatrics of Qilu Hospital, China. The program adhered to guidelines of patients’ consent for participation and research was supported by the Ethics Committee of Qilu hospital, Shandong University (No. 2016(027)).

All patients were examined and diagnosed at the Pediatric Department in Qilu Hospital using a combination of patients’ illness history, previous history, family history, physical examinations, developmental evaluation, hematological examination, ambulatory or video electroencephalography (AEEG/VEEG) monitoring, magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) or computed tomography (CT), and genetic sequencing. Developmental evaluation included gross motor, fine motor, language, and personal-social skills. The above information was reviewed by two qualified pediatric epileptologists. Seizure types and epilepsy syndromes were diagnosed and classified according to the guidelines of International League Against Epilepsy (2014, 2017) [12, 13].

Next-generation sequencing

Targeted gene capture and sequencing

Blood samples of the patients and their biological parents were collected to test if the mutations were de novo or inherited. Genomic DNA was extracted from peripheral blood using the QIAamp DNA Mini Kit (Qiagen, China).

One hundred fifty-three genes (Table 1) associated with epilepsy were selected by a gene capture strategy, using the GenCap custom enrichment kit (MyGenostics, China) following the manufacturer’s protocol. The biotinylated capture probes were designed to tile all of the exons without repeated regions. The captured DNAs were eluted, amplified and then their polymerase chain reaction (PCR) products were purified with SPRI beads (Beckman, USA). The enriched libraries were sequenced for paired-end reads of 150 bp by Illumina HiSeq X Ten.

Table 1.

One hundred fifty-three epilepsy genes tested in this study by NGS

ADSL	CHD2	DHFR	GLB1	MAGI2	PNPO	SLC9A6
ALDH7A1	CHRNA2	DIAPH3	GLRA1	MAPK10	POLG	SPTAN1
ALG13	CHRNA4	DNAJC6	GPR56	MBD5	PPT1	SRPX2
ARG1	CHRNA7	DNM1	GPR98	MDGA2	PROC	ST3GAL2
ARHGEF15	CHRNB2	DOCK7	GRIN1	ME2	PRRT2	ST3GAL5
ARHGEF9	CLCN2	EEF1A2	GRIN2A	MECP2	RBFOX1	STRADA
ARX	CLCN4	EFHC1	GRIN2B	MEF2C	RBFOX2	STXBP1
ASAH1	CLN3	ELP4	HAX1	MFSD8	RBFOX3	SYNGAP1
ATP13A4	CLN5	EPHB2	HDAC4	MTHFR	RELN	SYNJ1
ATP1A2	CLN6	ERBB4	HEXA	MTOR	RYR3	SZT2
ATP1A3	CLN8	FASN	HEXB	NDE1	SCN1A	TBC1D24
ATP6AP2	CNTN5	FLNA	HNRNPH1	NEDD4L	SCN1B	TCF4
ATP7A	CNTNAP2	FOLR1	HNRNPU	NID2	SCN2A	TNK2
BRAF	COX6B1	FOXG1	IQSEC2	NRXN1	SCN8A	TPP1
BSN	CSTB	FOXP2	KCNB1	PAFAH1B1	SHANK3	TSC1
CACNA1A	CTNNA3	GABBR2	KCNH5	PCDH19	SLC13A5	TSC2
CACNA1H	CTSD	GABRA1	KCNMA1	PDHA1	SLC19A3	TUBA1A
CACNB4	CYB5R3	GABRA6	KCNQ2	PIGA	SLC1A3	UBE3A
CASR	DBH	GABRB2	KCNQ3	PIGV	SLC25A22	VRK2
CDH13	DCX	GABRB3	KCNT1	PLCB1	SLC2A1	WDR45
CDH9	DEPDC5	GABRD	LGI1	PNKD	SLC35A2	ZEB2
CDKL5	DGKD	GABRG2	LIAS	PNKP	SLC46A1

Data analysis and pathogenicity of candidate variants

After sequencing, raw data were saved in FASTQ format. Illumina sequencing adapters and low quality reads (< 80 bp) were filtered by Cutadapt [14]. Clean reads were aligned to UCSC hg19 human reference genome using the Burrows-Wheeler Alignment [15] tool. Duplicated reads were removed using Picard (http://broadinstitute.github.io/picard). Insertions, deletions and SNP variants were detected and filtered using the Genome Analysis Toolkit [16]. Then the identified variants were annotated using ANNOVAR [17] and associated with the following databases: 1000 genomes, Exome Aggregation Consortium, The Human Gene Mutation Database, and predicted by Mutation Taster (MT) [18], Sorting Intolerant From Tolerant (SIFT) [19], PolyPhen-2 (PP2) [20] and Genomic Evolutionary Rate Profiling (GERP++) [21, 22]. Splice-site were predicted by Human Splicing Finder [23]. All variants identified by the Illumina HiSeq X Ten sequencer were confirmed by Sanger sequencing. The pathogenicity of mutations was assessed in accordance with American College of Medical Genetics and Genomics guideline (ACMG) [9–11].

Statistical analysis

Statistical analysis was performed using SPSS19. The yields of deleterious variants in patients with different onset age or family history were compared using the chi-squared test.

Results

In the current study, we recruited 172 epilepsy pediatric patients, including 23 with Dravet syndrome, ten with Ohtahara syndrome, two with Ohtahara syndrome evolving to West syndrome, ten with West syndrome, two with West syndrome evolving to Lennox-Gastaut syndrome, five with Lennox-Gastaut syndrome, four with Doose syndrome, two with epilepsy of infancy with migrating focal seizures, two with epileptic encephalopathy with continuous spike and wave during sleep, and one each with temporal lobe epilepsy, early myoclonic encephalopathy, Landau-Kleffner syndrome, and glucose transporter type 1 deficiency syndrome. Three patients had Rett syndrome, five had tuberous sclerosis complex, and one had Sturge-Weber syndrome. Forty-two patients were diagnosed as unclassified epileptic encephalopathy and 57 patients were diagnosed as unclassified refractory epilepsy due to nonspecific manifestations (Table 2).

Table 2.

Clinical diagnosis in 172 refractory epilepsy and their pathogenic or likely pathogenic mutations

Clinical diagnosis	Cases	P/LP mutations	P/LP gene(recurrent no.)
DS	23	16	SCN1A (16)
OS	10	2	KCNQ2 (1), SCN2A (1)
OS-WS	2	1	STXBP1 (1)
WS	10	4	STXBP1 (1), KCNT1 (1), CDKL5 (1), ADSL (1)
WS-LGS	2	–	–
LGS	5	–	–
EIMFS	2	–	–
ECSWS	2	–	–
EME	1	–	–
LKS	1	–	–
UEE	42	8	CACNA1A (1), GABRA1 (1), GABRB3 (1), SCN8A (2), IQSEC2 (1), PCDH19 (1), CHD2 (1)
Doose	4	1	SYNGAP1 (1)
TLE	1	–	–
GLUT1-DS	1	1	SLC2A1 (1)
Rett	3	1	MECP2 (1)
TSC	5	5	TSC2 (5)
SWS	1	–	–
UE	57	4	VRK2 (1), ATP1A2 (1), TSC (1), SLC9A6 (1)
Total	172	43	–

P pathogenic, LP likely pathogenic, DS Dravet syndrome, OS Ohtahara syndrome, OS-WS Ohtahara syndrome evolves to West syndrome, WS West syndrome, WS-LGS West syndrome evolves to Lennox-Gastaut syndrome, LGS Lennox-Gastaut syndrome, Doose Doose syndrome, ECSWS epileptic encephalopathy with continuous spike and wave during sleep, EIMFS epilepsy of infancy with migrating focal seizures, TLE temporal lobe epilepsy, EME early myoclonic encephalopathy, LKS Landau-Kleffner syndromes, UEE unclassified epileptic encephalopathy, GLUT1-DS glucose transporter type 1 deficiency syndrome. Rett Rett syndrome, TSC tuberous sclerosis complex, SWS Sturge-Weber syndrome, UE unclassified refractory epilepsy

One hundred fifty-three epilepsy-related genes were selected for sequencing in all patients. The expression pattern of the targeted 153 genes across tissues were analyzed and classified according to the National Center for Biotechnology Information (NCBI, https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov) and The Human Protein Atlas (https://www.proteinatlas.org) database (Additional file 1: Table S1). In our 153-gene panel, 51 genes show elevated expression, 14 genes have low expression, and 88 of them exhibit medium levels of expression in brain. The 14 low-expression genes have been associated with epilepsy, including: ARG1 [24–27], ARHGEF15 [28], CASR [29, 30], CHRNA2 [31], DBH [32–34], DIAPH3 [35], FOLR1 [36, 37], GABRA6 [38, 39], GLRA1 [40, 41], NID2 [42, 43], PROC [44], SLC13A5 [45, 46], SLC19A3 [47], SRPX2 [48]. Specifically, among 51 elevated genes in brain, 4 genes (GABRG2, GABBR2, GABRA1, GRIN1) show restricted brain expression.

The DNA samples of patients were analyzed by using NGS and the variants were validated by Sanger Sequencing. For the samples subjected to targeted sequencing, the quality assurance (QA) /quality control (QC) file are provided in Additional file 1: Table S2.

After sequencing the 153 epilepsy genes, we identified 43 deleterious variants in 23.3% patients (40 of 172), with three children harbouring more than one deleterious variant. Our results were similar to previous reports, with diagnostic yields ranging between 10% and 48.5% [49–56]. There were 60.5% (26/43) novel deleterious variants found in our study. A total of 43 variants in 22 genes were scored as pathogenic or likely pathogenic, including SCN1A (16), TSC2 (5), STXBP1 (2), SCN8A (2), TSC1(1), MECP2 (1), CHD2 (1), PCDH19 (1), GABRA1 (1), GABRB3 (1), SLC2A1 (1), SLC9A6 (1), IQSEC2 (1), KCNQ2 (1), SCN2A (1), CACNA1A (1), KCNT1 (1), SYNGAP1 (1), ATP1A2 (1), CDKL5 (1), ADSL (1), VRK2 (1) (Fig. 1a). Among these 43 pathogenic or likely pathogenic variants, there were 18 (41.9%) missense mutations, 3 (7%) splice site mutations, 11 (25.6%) nonsense mutations, 10 (23.3%) frame-shifts, and 1 (2.3%) deletion mutations (Fig. 1a, Table 3).

Fig. 1.

Mutated pathogenic or likely pathogenic genes in 172 refractory epilepsy children. a The frequency of mutated genes scored as pathogenic or likely pathogenic adhered to ACMG; b Functional classification of the mutated pathogenic or likely pathogenic genes; c The yield of pathogenic and likely pathogenic variants according to the electroclinical phenotype. Abbreviations: DS, Dravet syndrome; OS, Ohtahara syndrome; OS-WS, Ohtahara syndrome evolves to West syndrome; WS, West syndrome; WS-LGS, West syndrome evolves to Lennox-Gastaut syndrome; LGS, Lennox-Gastaut syndrome; Doose, Doose syndrome; ECSWS, epileptic encephalopathy with continuous spike and wave during sleep; EIMFS, epilepsy of infancy with migrating focal seizures; TLE, temporal lobe epilepsy; EME, early myoclonic encephalopathy; LKS, Landau-Kleffner syndromes; UEE, unclassified epileptic encephalopathy; GLUT1-DS, glucose transporter type 1 deficiency syndrome; Rett, Rett syndrome; TSC, tuberous sclerosis complex; SWS, Sturge-Weber syndrome; UE, unclassified refractory epilepsy

Table 3.

Pathogenic and likely pathogenic mutations adhered to ACMG guidelines in 172 refractory epilepsy children

Case code	Gene	Gene location	Transcript	cDNA change	Protein change	SIFT	PP2	MT	HSF	GERP++	MAF-ExAC	MAF-KG	Parental Origin	ACMG scoring	ACMG pathogenicity	Diagosis
13	SCN1A	chr2–166,901,702	NM_006920	c.1513A > T	p.K505X	–	–	A	–	6.17 (C)	–	–	De novo	PVS1 + PS2 + PM2	LP	DS
23	SCN1A	chr2–166,854,657 166,854,660 a [101]	NM_006920	c.4331_4334del	p.E1444fs	–	–	–	–	–	–	–	De novo	PVS1 + PS1 + PS2 + PM2	P	DS
26	SCN1A	chr2–166,870,270	NM_001165963	c.3689T>C	p.L1230P	D	D	D	–	5.28 (C)	–	–	De novo	PS2 + PM1 + PM2 + PP3	LP	DS
35	SCN1A	chr2–166,900,287 166,900,288	NM_001165963	c.1934_1935del	p.V645fs	–	–	–	–	–	–	–	De novo	PVS1 + PS2 + PM2	P	DS
38	SCN1A	chr2–166,859,121	NM_006920	c.G4112T	p.G1371V	D	P	D	–	5.54 (C)	–	–	De novo	PS2 + PM2	LP	DS
53	SCN1A	chr2–166,894,306 166,894,337	NM_001165963	c.2895_2926del	p.Q965fs	–	–	–	–	–	–	–	Unknown	PVS1 + PM2	LP	DS
56	SCN1A	chr2–166,908,355 a [102]	NM_006920	c.838T > C	p.W280R	D	D	D	–	5.41 (C)	–	–	De novo	PS1 + PS2 + PM2 + PP3	P	DS
65	SCN1A	chr2–166,850,927	NM_006920	c.4549-1G > C	splicing	–	–	D	+	5.76 (C)	–	–	De novo	PVS1 + PS2 + PM2	P	DS
115	SCN1A	chr2–166,848,614	NM_006920	c.5138C > A	p.A1713D	D	D	D	–	5.8 (C)	–	–	De novo	PS2 + PM2 + PP3	LP	DS
124	SCN1A	chr2–166,848,438 a [103]	NM_006920	c.5314G > A	p.A1772T	D	D	D	–	5.69 (C)	–	–	De novo	PS1 + PS2 + PM2 + PP3	P	DS
130	SCN1A	chr2–166,854,634 166,854,639 a [101]	NM_006920	c.4352_4356del	p.Y1451Cfs*22	–	–	–	–	–	–	–	De novo	PVS1 + PS1 + PS2 + PM2	P	DS
140	SCN1A	chr2–166,911,210 166,911,211	NM_006920	c.539delT	p.L180X	–	–	–	–	–	–	–	De novo	PVS1 + PS2 + PM2	P	DS
148	SCN1A	chr2–166,901,579	NM_001165963	c.1636G > T	p.E546X	–	–	A	–	6.17 (C)	–	–	Unknown	PVS1 + PM2	LP	DS
149	SCN1A	chr2–166,894,430 a [104]	NM_006920	c.2769G > A	p.M923I	D	D	D	–	5.18 (C)	–	–	Paternal	PS1 + PM2 + PP3	LP	DS
162	SCN1A	chr2–166,848,043 166,848,045	NM_001165963	c.5740_5742del	p.1914_1914del	–	–	–	–	–	–	–	De novo	PS2 + PM2 + PM4	LP	DS
172	SCN1A	chr2–166,903,330	NM_006920	c.1327G > T	p.E443X	–	–	A	–	5.31 (C)	–	–	De novo	PVS1 + PS2 + PM2	P	DS
93	SCN2A	chr2–166,243,416	NM_001040142	c.4712T > C	p.I1571T	D	D	D	–	5.17 (C)	–	–	De novo	PS2 + PM1 + PM2 + PP3	LP	OS
55	KCNQ2	chr20–62,073,781 a [105]	NM_172107	c.794C > T	p.A265V	D	P	D	–	3.38 (C)	–	–	De novo	PS1 + PS2 + PM2	P	OS
90	STXBP1	chr9–130,423,419 a [53]	NM_003165	c.364C > T	p.R122X	–	–	A	–	4.92 (C)	–	–	Unknown	PVS1 + PS1 + PM2	P	OS-WS
52	ADSL	chr22–40,745,935	NM_000026	c.253C > T	p.R85X	–	–	A	–	5.59 (C)	–	–	Maternal	PVS1 + PM2	LP	WS
		chr22–40,742,633 [58]	NM_000026	c.71C > T	p.P24L	T	B	D	–	0.153 (N)	–	–	Paternal	PM2	UC
89	KCNT1	chr9–138,651,532 a [106]	NM_020822	c.862G > A	p.G288S	T	D	D	–	5.05 (C)	–	–	De novo	PS1 + PS2 + PM1 + PM2	P	WS
104	CDKL5	chrX-18,593,592 18,593,593	NM_003159	c.265delT	p.F89Lfs*24	–	–	–	–	–	–	–	De novo	PVS1 + PS2 + PM2	P	WS
151	STXBP1	chr9–130,428,529	NM_003165	c.748C > T	p.Q250X	–	–	A	–	5.72 (C)	–	–	De novo	PVS1 + PS2 + PM2	P	WS
29	SYNGAP1	chr6–33,393,659 33,393,662	NM_006772	c.274_277del	p.G92fs	–	–	–	–	–	–	–	De novo	PVS1 + PS2 + PM2	P	Doose
164	SLC2A1	chr1–43,396,517	NM_006516	c.296T > G	p.M99R	D	B	D	–	5.51 (C)	–	–	De novo	PS2 + PM2	LP	GLUT1-DS
30	MECP2	chrX-153,296,516 a [63]	NM_001110792	c.799C > T	p.R267X	–	–	A	–	3.55 (C)	–	–	De novo	PVS1 + PS1 + PS2 + PM2	P	Rett
32	TSC2	chr16–2,126,095 a [91]	NM_000548	c.2666C > T	p.A889V	D	D	D	–	5.09 (C)	–	–	Paternal	PS1 + PM2 + PP3	LP	TSC
94	TSC2	chr16–2,130,180 a [107]	NM_000548	c.3412C > T	p.R1138X	–	–	A	–	4.74 (C)	–	–	De novo	PVS1 + PS1 + PS2 + PM2	P	TSC
	TSC2	chr16–2,130,366 a [66]	NM_000548	c.3598C > T	p.R1200W	D	D	D	–	4.74 (C)	–	–	De novo	PS1 + PS2 + PM2 + PP3	P
98	TSC2	chr16–2,138,467	NM_001077183	c.5079C > G	p.Y1693X	–	–	D	–	0.137 (N)	–	–	Paternal	PVS1 + PM2	LP	TSC
	TSC2	chr16–2,138,465 2,138,466	NM_001077183	c.5077delT	p.Y1693fs	–	–	–	–	–	–	–	Paternal	PVS1 + PM2	LP
7	SCN8A	chr12–52,184,209 a [108]	NM_001177984	c.4324G > A	p.E1442K	D	D	D	–	4.68 (C)	–	–	Paternal	PS1 + PM2 + PP3	LP	UEE
	IQSEC2	chrX-53,263,621 53,263,622	NM_001111125	c.4246_4247insG	p.S1416fs	–	–	–	–	–	–	–	De novo	PVS1 + PS2 + PM2	P
63	CACNA1A	chr19–13,566,019 a [109]	NM_001127221	c.301G > C	p.E101Q	D	D	D	–	5.01 (C)	–	–	De novo	PS1 + PS2 + PM1 + PM2 + PP3	P	UEE
66	SCN8A	chr12–52,200,885 a [110]	NM_001177984	c.5492G > A	p.R1831Q	D	D	D	–	4.91 (C)	–	–	De novo	PS1 + PS2 + PM2 + PP3	P	UEE
69	PCDH19	chrX-99,551,873 99,551,874	NM_001184880	c.2849-1G > −	splicing	–	–	–	+	–	–	–	Unknown	PVS1 + PM2	LP	UEE
157	GABRB3	chr15–26,812,802 a [111]	NM_021912	c.761C > T	p.S254F	D	D	D	–	6.06 (C)	–	–	De novo	PS1 + PS2 + PM1 + PM2 + PP3	P	UEE
160	GABRA1	chr5–161,309,645 a [112]	NM_001127648	c.641G > A	p.R214H	D	D	D	–	5.34 (C)	–	–	De novo	PS1 + PS2 + PM1 + PM2 + PP3	P	UEE
54	CHD2	chr15–93,540,231	NM_001271	c.3640G > T	p.G1214X	–	–	A	–	5.64 (C)	–	–	De novo	PVS1 + PS2 + PM2	P	UEE
40	VRK2	chr2–58,312,086	NM_001130483	c.C256 + 1G > A	splicing	–	–	D	+	5.86 (C)	–	–	Unknown	PVS1 + PM2	LP	UE
44	ATP1A2	chr1–160,098,521	NM_000702	c.1097G > T	p.G366V	D	D	D	–	4.77 (C)	–	–	De novo	PS2 + PM1 + PM2 + PP3	LP	UE
68	TSC1	chr9–135,772,854	NM_000368	c.2768_2769insC	p.L924Ffs*26	–	–	–	–	–	–	–	De novo	PVS1 + PS2 + PM2	P	UE
79	SLC9A6	chrX-135,080,322 135,080,336	NM_001042537	c.582_595del	p.Y194fs	–	–	–	–	–	–	–	De novo	PVS1 + PS2 + PM2	P	UE

Abbreviations: M male, F female, m month, y year, SIFT Sorts intolerant from tolerant (D, damaging; T, tolerant), PP2, polymorphism phenotyping v2 (D, damaging; P, possible damaging; B, benign), MT mutation taster (D, disease causing; A, disease causing automatic), HSF human splicing finder (+, altering splicing), GERP++ genomic evolutionary rate profiling (C, conserved; N, nonconserved), KG 1000 Genomes project, LP likely pathogenic, P pathogenic, DS Dravet syndrome, OS Ohtahara syndrome, OS-WS OS syndrome evolves to West syndrome, WS West syndrome, Doose Doose syndrome, GLUT1-DS glucose transporter type 1 deficiency syndrome, Rett Rett syndrome, TSC tuberous sclerosis complex, UEE unclassified epileptic encephalopathy, UE unclassified refractory epilepsy

^a Mutations have been reported in HGMD database

More recent studies suggest that many severe epilepsy types begin in infancy or childhood, especially those with psychomotor retardation and epileptic encephalopathies are often due to de novo mutations [30, 31]. In our study, 32/43 (74.4%) pathogenic or likely pathogenic variants were de novo, five (11.6%) were paternal, one (2.3%) was maternal, and five (11.6%) were unknown due to blood samples from parents were unavailable (Table 3).

To further explore the genetic pathogenesis of epilepsy, we subdivided the mutated genes into nine groups according to the molecular and biological function of the gene produce. These functional groups included voltage-gated ion channels, enzyme/enzyme modulators, membrane trafficking, ligand-gated ion channels, DNA/RNA binding, cell-adhesion proteins, glucose transporter, proton antiporter, and GTP/GDP exchanges. Variants in ion channel genes (SCN1A, SCN2A, SCN8A, CACNA1A, KCNT1, KCNQ2) accounted for 51.2% (22/43) of the pathogenic or likely pathogenic variants. Variants in enzyme/enzyme modulator genes (TSC1, TSC2, SYNGAP1, ATP1A2, CDKL5, ADSL, VRK2) accounted for 25.6% (11/43) of pathogenic or likely pathogenic variants. Variants in genes encoded membrane trafficking (STXBP1), ligand-gated ion channels (GABRA1, GABRB3), DNA/RNA binding proteins (MECP2, CHD2) each accounted for 4.7% (2/43) (Fig. 1b). Ion channels (voltage-gated and ligand-gated) accounted for 55.8% in total, suggesting that dysfunction of ion channels plays critical roles in the pathogenesis of epilepsy.

We then analyzed the yield of the epilepsy gene panel testing based on electroclinical syndrome (Fig. 1c). The yield of deleterious variants in Dravet syndrome (69.6%, 16/23) and glucose transporter type 1 deficiency syndrome (100%, 1/1) patients was higher than that in others. Patients with onset age of seizures ≤12 months had higher yields of deleterious variants compared to those with onset age of seizures > 12 months (31/101 vs 9/71; χ2 = 7.583, df = 1, P = 0.006). The family history did not affect whether or not a deleterious genetic variant was identified (7/27 vs 33/145; χ2 = 0.128, df = 1, P = 0.804).

There were 16 mutations in SCN1A gene, of which six (37.5%) were missense mutations, one (6.25%) was a splice site mutation, four (25%) were nonsense mutations, four (25%) were frame-shifts, and one (6.25%) was deletion mutation. Thirteen of the 16 (81.3%) SCN1A mutations were de novo and 11 (68.8%) were novel. We further analysed the positions of the mutations in the affected proteins corresponding to gene mutations and found that 43.8% (7/16) of protein changes are in the intracellular loop of sodium channel protein type 1 subunit alpha, 31.3% (5/16) are in the extracellular loop, 18.8% (3/16) are in the transmembrane region, and 6.25% (1/16) are in the pore forming area (Fig. 2).

Fig. 2.

Schematic representation of the mutations in subunit alpha of sodium channel type 1 (SCN1A) in our study. SCN1A alpha unit has four domains (I–IV), each domain includes 6 transmembrane segments (S1–S6). Purple circle = mutation; AEDs, anti-epileptic drugs. The position of mutations in SCN1A is approximate and is according to reference transcript NM_001165963.

There has been a marked increase in genetic diagnoses of a number of key childhood-onset epilepsy syndromes, such as Dravet syndrome, which has been mainly linked to SCN1A [17]. In our 16 patients diagnosed as Dravet syndrome with pathogenic or likely pathogenic variants, all identified mutations were in the SCN1A gene. These 16 Dravet syndrome patients had typical manifestations: onset between 3 to 8 months of age, fever-sensitive, multiple seizure types, and developmental delay after seizure onset. 81.25% (13/16) SCN1A mutations were de novo in Dravet syndrome patients and one was inherited from the father who had a history of febrile seizures (FS). 12.5% (2/16) SCN1A mutations were unknown. Pathogenic and likely pathogenic mutations each accounted for 50% (Table 4). 50% (8/16) of the Dravet syndrome variants cause nonsense or frameshift mutations that result in truncated proteins, which was consistent with a previous study [57]. We evaluated whether different seizure types, family history, abnormal brain MRI, or developmental delay were associated with specific SCN1A mutation types or locations within the gene. We did not detect any bias towards particular regions of the gene or in the type of mutation, although our small sample size did not provide substantial power (Additional file 1: Tables S3 and S4).

Table 4.

Clinical features in DS patients

Case code	Gender/age	Diagosis	Age of onset	Seizure types	EEG	Brain MRI/CT	Developmental delay	Gene	cDNA change	Protein change	Parental Origin	ACMG pathogenicity
13	F/2y6m	DS	3m	FS, FoS, Myo	FSW	Normal	Yes	SCN1A	c.1513A > T	p.K505X	De novo	LP
23	F/3y	DS	7m	FS, FoS (A), Myo, FBTC	Multi. FD	Underdeveloped myelin	Yes	SCN1A	c.4331_4334del	p.E1444fs	De novo	P
26	F/5y11m	DS	5m	FS, SE, FoS (A), Myo, FBTC	FSW	Normal	Yes	SCN1A	c.3689T>C	p.L1230P	De novo	LP
35	M/4y	DS	3m	FS, SE, GTCS, aAb	Multi. FD	Normal	Yes	SCN1A	c.1934_1935del	p.V645fs	De novo	P
38	F/1y6m	DS	4m	FS, SE, Myo	FSW	Nonspecific	Yes	SCN1A	c.G4112T	p.G1371V	De novo	LP
53	M/5y	DS	7m	FS, aAb, Myo, Fos (I)	Multi. FD	Normal	Yes	SCN1A	c.2895_2926del	p.Q965fs	Unknown	LP
56	F/3y6m	DS	5m	FS, Myo, GTCS, SE, FoS (A), aAb	Multi. FD	Nonspecific	Yes	SCN1A	c.838T > C	p.W280R	De novo	P
65	M/2y4m	DS	5m	FS, SE, FoS (A)	FSW	Normal	Yes	SCN1A	c.4549-1G > C	splicing	De novo	P
115	M/2y1m	DS	8m	FS, FoS (I), FoS (hemi clonic), GTCS	FSW	Enlargement of the subarachnoid space in front of left temporal lobe	Yes	SCN1A	c.5138C > A	p.A1713D	De novo	LP
124	M/3y	DS	5m	FS, FoS (A), FBTC	FSW	Nonspecific	Yes	SCN1A	c.5314G > A	p.A1772T	De novo	P
130	F/11y	DS	6m	FS, FoS (A), aAb, Myo, GTCS	Multi. FD	Normal	Yes	SCN1A	c.4352_4356del	p.Y1451Cfs*22	De novo	P
140	F/1y9m	DS	3m	FS, GTCS, C, FoS (I)	FSW	Normal	Yes	SCN1A	c.539delT	p.L180X	De novo	P
148	F/6y8m	DS	4m	FS, GTCS, FoS, aAb	Multi. FD	Normal	Yes	SCN1A	c.1636G > T	p.E546X	Unknown	LP
149	M/3y6m	DS	4m	FS, FoS (A), Myo, GTCS	Multi. FD, GSW	Normal	Yes	SCN1A	c.2769G > A	p.M923I	Paternal (FS)	LP
162	M/4y	DS	5m	FS, FoS (A), Myo, FBTC	Multi. FD	Normal	Yes	SCN1A	c.5740_5742del	p.1914_1914del	De novo	LP
172	F/8y	DS	5m	FS, aAb, Myo, FBTC	Multi. FD, GSW, GPSW	Normal	Yes	SCN1A	c.1327G > T	p.E443X	De novo	P

Abbreviations: M male, F female, m month, y year, P pathogenic, LP likely pathogenic, UC uncertain, DS Dravet syndrome, FS febrile seizures, SE status epilepticus, FoS focal seizures, FoS (I) focal seizures (impaired awareness), FoS (A) focal seizures (aware), FBTC focal to bilateral tonic-clonic, Myo myoclonic, aAb atypical absence, GTCS generalized tonic-clonic seizures, FSW focal spike wave, Multi. FD multifocal discharges, GSW generalized spike-wave, GPSW generalized polyspike-wave

Twelve patients presented typical manifestation of Ohtahara syndrome: onset age within postnatal 30 days, tonic spasms, burst suppression EEG and developmental delay. Pathogenic or likely pathogenic variants in Ohtahara syndrome were in the KCNQ2 (1), STXBP1 (1), SCN2A (1) genes. The nonsense mutation in STXBP1 (c.364C > T, p.R122X) was detected in one Ohtahara syndrome patients that evolved to West syndrome. This patient had an onset age of postnatal 17 day, spasms, and burst-suppression EEG at postnatal 22 day and hypsarrhythmia EEG at 4 months (Table 5).

Table 5.

Clinical features in OS, WS, LGS, Doose, GLUT1-DS, Rett, TSC, UEE and UE patients

Case code	Gender/age	Diagosis	Age of onset	Seizure types	EEG	Brain MRI/CT	Developmental delay	Gene	cDNA change	Protein change	Parental Origin	ACMG pathogenicity
55	M/54d	OS	1d	FoS, Tonic spasms	BS, FSW	Normal	Yes	KCNQ2	c.794C > T	p.A265V	De novo	P
93	M/40d	OS	3d	Tonic spasms	BS	Normal	Yes	SCN2A	c.4712T > C	p.I1571T	De novo	LP
90	M/2y11m	OS-WS	17d	Tonic spasms, Spa.	BS, Hypsarrhy.	Normal	Yes	STXBP1	c.364C > T	p.R122X	Unknown	P
52	F/1y8m	WS	2m	Spa.	Multi. FD, Hypsarrhy.	Cerebral dysplasia	Yes	ADSL	c.253C > T	p.R85X	Maternal	LP
								ADSL	c.71C > T	p.P24L	Paternal	UC
89	F/1y11m	WS	19d	FoS, Spa.	Multi. FD, Hypsarrhy.	Subdural hemorrhage	Yes	KCNT1	c.862G > A	p.G288S	De novo	P
104	F/2y10m	WS	3m7d	Spa.	Hypsarrhy., Multi.FD	Normal	Yes	CDKL5	c.265delT	p.F89Lfs*24	De novo	P
151	F/9m	WS	3m	Spa.	Hypsarrhy., Multi. FD	Enlargement of the subarachnoid space	Yes	STXBP1	c.748C > T	p.Q250X	De novo	P
29	M/5y6m	Doose	1y3m	Myo-At., Myo, aAb	Abnormal background theta, GSW, GPSW	Normal	No	SYNGAP1	c.274_277del	p.G92fs	De novo	P
164	F/6y	GLUT1-DS	2y4m	GTCS	FSW, Multi. FD	Nonspecific (Hair loss leads to bald)	No	SLC2A1	c.296T > G	p.M99R	De novo	LP
30	F/4y4m	Rett	3y2m	Fos (I), FBTC	Multi. FD	Normal	Yes	MECP2	c.799C > T	p.R267X	De novo	P
32	M/8y	TSC	1y6m	FoS (I), FBTC	Multi. FD	Multi nodules	No	TSC2	c.2666C > T	p.A889V	Paternal	LP
94	F/9m	TSC (WS)	3m	Spa.	Multi. FD, Hypsarrhy.	Multi nodules	Yes	TSC2	c.3412C > T	p.R1138X	De novo	P
								TSC2	c.3598C > T	p.R1200W	De novo	P
98	M/3y	TSC (WS)	4m	Spa., aAb	Multi. FD, Hypsarrhy.	Nonspecific	Yes	TSC2	c.5079C > G	p.Y1693X	Paternal	LP
								TSC2	c.5077delT	p.Y1693fs	Paternal	LP
7	M/2y	UEE (EIEE13)	6m	FoS (I), FBTC	Multi. FD	Enlargement of the subarachnoid space	Yes	SCN8A	c.4324G > A	p.E1442K	Paternal	LP
								IQSEC2	c.4246_4247insG	p.S1416fs	De novo	P
63	M/4y	UEE (EIEE42)	5m	FoS, GTCS	Multi. FD	Normal	Yes	CACNA1A	c.301G > C	p.E101Q	De novo	P
66	M/1y9m	UEE (EIEE13)	4m	FBTC, FoS	Multi. FD	Enlargement of the subarachnoid space	Yes	SCN8A	c.5492G > A	p.R1831Q	De novo	P
69	F/2y1m	UEE (EIEE9)	1y3m	FBTC, C, T	Multi. FD	Normal	Yes	PCDH19	c.2849-1G > −	splicing	Unknown	LP
157	F/2y	UEE (EIEE43)	2m	C, FoS (I)	FSW	Normal	Yes	GABRB3	c.761C > T	p.S254F	De novo	P
160	M/6y	UEE (EIEE19)	6m	FoS (I), GTCS	FSW	Normal	Yes	GABRA1	c.641G > A	p.R214H	De novo	P
54	F/7y	UEE (EEOC)	4y2m	SE, GTCS, FoS (I)	Mult. FD	Normal	Yes	CHD2	c.3640G > T	p.G1214X	De novo	P
40	F/2y11m	UE	4m	FoS	FSW	Normal	No	VRK2	c.C256 + 1G > A	splicing	Unknown	LP
44	F/5y6m	UE	4y	FoS (automatisms, emotional)	Multi. FD	Nodules in internal side of left anterior limb of internal capsule; caput of caudate nucleus or heterotopic gray matter	Yes	ATP1A2	c.1097G > T	p.G366V	De novo	LP
68	M/6y	UE	4y	FoS (A)	FSW	Normal	No	TSC1	c.2768_2769insC	p.L924Ffs*26	De novo	P
79	M/3y	UE	1y2m	FoS (I), FBTC	Multi. FD	Normal	Yes	SLC9A6	c.582_595del	p.Y194fs	De novo	P

Abbreviations: M male, F female, m month, y year, P pathogenic, LP likely pathogenic, UC uncertain, OS Ohtahara syndrome, OS-WS Ohtahara syndrome evolves to West syndrome, WS West syndrome, Doose Doose syndrome, GLUT1-DS glucose transporter type 1 deficiency syndrome, Rett Rett syndrome, TSC tuberous sclerosis complex, UEE unclassified epileptic encephalopathy, UE unclassified refractory epilepsy, EEIE early-infantile epileptic encephalopathies, EEOC childhood-onset epileptic encephalopathy, Spa. Spasms, FoS focal seizures, FoS (I) focal seizures (impaired awareness), FoS (A) focal seizures (aware), FBTC focal to bilateral tonic-clonic, T tonic, C clonic, Myo myoclonic, aAb atypical absence, At. atonic, GTCS generalized tonic-clonic seizures, SE status epilepticus, BS burst suppression, Hypsarrhy. hypsarrhythmia, Multi. FD multifocal discharges, FSW focal spike-wave, GSW generalized spike-wave, GPSW generalized polyspike-wave

West syndrome patients in our study had onset ages of seizures ranging from postnatal 19 days to 6 months. Typical clinical manifestations were all observed, including spasms, hypsarrhythmia EEG, and developmental delay. 16.7% (2/12) of the West syndrome children evolves to Lennox-Gastaut syndrome. After sequencing, we identified 4 pathogenic or likely pathogenic mutations in the following genes: STXBP1 (1), KCNT1 (1), CDKL5 (1), ADSL (1). 75% (3/4) of these variants were de novo.

One of the West syndrome patients were found to carry two mutations: a nonsense ADSL (c.253C > T, p.R85X) mutation was scored as likely pathogenic and was inherited from her unaffected mother. Another reported missense ADSL (c.71C > T, p.P24L) [58] mutation which was inherited from her unaffected father were scored as uncertain pathogenicity. ADSL has been reported to be related to adenylosuccinate lyase deficiency, which is an autosomal recessive defect of purine metabolism [59, 60]. The patient presented with spasms 2 months after birth. Brain MRI showed cerebral dysplasia and EEG showed hypsarrhythmia and multifocal discharges. The patient also had developmental delay and lack of eye contact. A definitive diagnosis can be made with high performance liquid chromatography examination of the urine to detect the ratio of succinyladenosine and succinyl-aminoimidazole carboximide riboside, but this was not available for the patient in question. Thus, this patient was diagnosed clinically as having West syndrome.

A novel frame-shift mutation in SYNGAP5 (c.274_277del, p.G92fs) was detected in a patient with Doose syndrome. This patient presented with myoclonic and myoclonic-astatic seizures, as well as having atypical absence seizures. SYNGAP5 had been reported to be associated with Doose syndrome and mental retardation, autosomal dominant 5 (MRD5) [51, 61, 62]. This mutation, which is very rare, was de novo, and caused frameshift changes in Ras/Rap GTPase-activating protein SynGAP, was therefore scored as pathogenic (Table 5).

One glucose transporter type 1 deficiency syndrome patient presented with seizures at age 28 months. The patient has alopecia and was almost bald at 4 years old. The child did not have other abnormalities in blood tests, brain MRI, or neurological exam. Her cerebrospinal fluid glucose value was 2.04 mmol/L (blood glucose value was 7.2 mmol/L before lumbar puncture; fasting blood glucose value was 5.2 mmol/L). NGS identified a missense mutation in SLC2A1 (c.296T > G, p.M99R). The mutation was de novo and novel. The patient’s parents and sister were normal, which is consistent with the sequencing results. Symptoms improved with a ketogenic diet, with seizures controlled for more than 6 months.

One MECP2 mutation (c.799C > T, p.R267X) was detected in a girl diagnosed as Rett syndrome. The girl developed normally for the first 18 months, gradually lost speech ability while developing repetitive hand-wringing. Seizures began at age 3 years. The MECP2 gene is located on the X-chromosome, and Rett syndrome is inherited through this gene in a dominant fashion [63]. This patient had a de novo MECP2 nonsense mutation, consistent with her parents being unaffected.

40% (2/5) of tuberous sclerosis complex patients were diagnosed with West syndrome associated with tuberous sclerosis complex in our study. Tuberous sclerosis complex is closely related to the TSC1/TSC2 genes [64–67].

In our study, all of the tuberous sclerosis complex patients’ initial presentations were seizures, of which 80% (4/5) presented in the first year of life. 60% (3/5) had hypomelanotic macules and 40% (2/5) had multi nodules. One patient’s only clinical manifestation was seizures and three (60%) patients with seizures had only one major feature of tuberous sclerosis complex. After sequencing, 60% (3/5) patients were found to have deleterious TSC1 or TSC2 mutations.

We identified more than one TSC1/2 mutations in 2 patients. One patient has two TSC2 mutations inherited from his affected father. Facial angiofibromas appeared by age 3–4 years in 60% (3/5) patients in the follow-up period. Gilboa et al. [68] reported four patients with the same TSC1 genomic deletion (9q34.13q34.2) in a family and none of them fulfilled the clinical criteria for tuberous sclerosis complex. In our study, one patient with pathogenic TSC1 (c.2768_2769insC, p.L924Ffs*26) mutation presented with focal seizures beginning at age four. There were two hypopigmented macules on the patient’s abdomen. The brain MRI results were normal and there are no other features of tuberous sclerosis complex. This de novo mutation causes a frame-shift in hamartin and has not been reported previously. Thus, this patient was considered to have unclassified refractory epilepsy.

One unclassified epileptic encephalopathy patient had two deleterious mutations: SCN8A inherited from his affected father (c.4324G > A, p.E1442K) and IQSEC2 (c.4246_4247insG, p.S1416fs). Early-infantile epileptic encephalopathies (EIEE) caused by SCN8A mutations are designated as EIEE13 (OMIM #614558) [69]. The missense mutation in SCN8A is very rare in the general population, and had been previously predicted to be damaging by SIFT, MT and PP2. IQSEC2 is an X-linked gene that has been reported to be related to intellectual disability and epilepsy, and it encodes the IQ motif and SEC7 domain-containing protein 2 [70]. The identified novel IQSEC2 mutation was de novo and was scored as being pathogenic.

Other pathogenic or likely pathogenic mutations found in patients with unclassified epileptic encephalopathy included CACNA1A, GABRA1, GABRB3, PCDH19, and CHD2. Epileptic encephalopathies with the above mutations had been designated as EIEE42, EIEE19, EIEE43, EIEE9 and EEOC (childhood-onset epileptic encephalopathy) according to Online Mendelian Inheritance in Man (OMIM). Other deleterious variants found in patients with unclassified refractory epilepsy were in VRK2, ATP1A2, and SLC9A6. Taking these unclassified epileptic encephalopathies and unclassified refractory epilepsy patients’ clinical manifestations into consideration, we found that all patients with deleterious mutations in genes encoding ion channels (SCN8A, CACNA1A, GABRB3, GABRA1) had similar clinical symptoms: onset age of seizures within the first year, epileptic encephalopathy and developmental delay. In contrast, patients with mutations in VRK2, ATP1A2, and SLC9A6, had relatively later onset age of seizures.

We then assessed the clinical benefit of genetic testing in those patients with identified deleterious variants. NGS helped with the diagnosis (n = 8), medication selection (n = 18), reproductive planning (n = 4), and treatment planning (n = 1). The finding of the SLC2A1 variant in Case 164 prompted other tests such as cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) glucose that were clinically useful. Identification of deleterious SCN1A mutations in five young infants with clinically suspected Dravet syndrome helped early diagnosis (Case 13, 38, 65, 115, 140) and led to the discontinuation of oxcarbazepine (Case 13) that exacerbated seizures. Identification of SCN1A mutations in other Dravet syndrome patients helped to avoid sodium channel blockers such as oxcarbazepine, carbamazepine and lamotrigine. Among the four Dravet syndrome patients who responded to anticonvulsants (Case 13, 26, 149, 172), 75% (3/4) of them were prescribed sodium valproate or clonazepam suggesting that these medications may be effective in Dravet syndrome. The finding of the TSC2 variants in Cases 94 and 98 helped early diagnosis and Case 32 experienced remission with administration of rapamune. Identification of TSC1 prompted clinical surveillance for tuberous sclerosis complex in Case 68. The findings of patients with deleterious variants in TSC2 (Case 32, 98), SCN8A (Case 7), SCN1A (Case 149), ADSL (Case 52) which were inherited, helped in prenatal counselling (Table 6).

Table 6.

Clinical benefits after molecular diagnosis

Clinical benefits		Effects (Case details)
Diagnosis	SLC2A1 (GLUT1-DS)	Definitive diagnosis (Case 164)
	SCN1A (DS)	Definitive diagnosis (Case 13, 38, 65, 115, 140)
	TSC2 (TSC)	Definitive diagnosis (Case 94, 98)
Management implications	SLC2A1, using KD	Controlled (Case 164, KD)
	SCN1A, stopping OXC	Remitted (Case 13, VPA, TPM,10–20 / month)
	SCN1A, avoiding OXC, CBZ, and LTG	Remitted (Case 23, VPA, TPM, seizure-free for 5 months; Case 26, LEV, TPM, CZP, seizure-free for 6 months; Case 149, VPA, TPM, LEV, CZP, seizure-free for 4 months; Case 172, VPA, TPM, CZP, seizure-free for 1 year)
		Uncontrolled (Case 35, 38, 53, 56, 65, 115, 124, 130, 140, 148, 162)
	TSC2, using rapamune	Remitted (Case 32, seizure-free for 7 months)
Long-term follow up	TSC1 (risk of TSC)	Case 68
Reproductive planning	Suggesting the family conduct genetic counseling	TSC2 (Case 32, 98), SCN8A (Case 7), SCN1A (Case 149), ADSL (Case 52)

Abbreviations: DS Dravet syndrome, GLUT1-DS glucose transporter type 1 deficiency syndrome, Rett Rett syndrome, TSC tuberous sclerosis complex, KD ketogenic diet, OXC oxcarbazepine, CBZ carbamazepine, LTG lamotrigine, VPA sodium valproate, TPM topiramate, LEV levetiracetam, CZP clonazepam

Discussion

Epilepsy is highly heterogeneous and can be primarily genetic in origin, or be secondary to structural or metabolic disorders of the central nervous system [71, 72]. To date, over 500 genes have been implicated in epilepsy [73–76]. However, the overlapping clinical features of different epilepsy syndromes and non-specific phenotypes can hamper clinical and genetic diagnosis [53]. The correct genetic diagnosis can help to guide treatment and prognosis. In addition to genetic origins, pediatric epilepsy may also arise from epigenetic mechanisms mediating gene-environment interactions during neurodevelopment. In this study, we used NGS to investigate 153 epilepsy related genes in a cohort of 172 refractory epilepsy children.

Approximately one quarter of genes identified in epilepsy encode ion channel proteins, including voltage-gated channels (Na⁺, K⁺, Ca2⁺ channels and hyperpolarization-activated cyclic nucleotide-gated channels) and ligand-gated ion channels (N-Methyl-D-Aspartate receptors, Gamma-aminobutyric acid receptors and Nicotinic Acetylcholine receptors) [77]. The genes that encode ion channels and are relevant to epilepsy include SCN1A, SCN1B, SCN2A, SCN8A, KCNA1, KCNA2, KCNB1, KCNC1, KCNMA1, KCNQ2, KCNQ3, KCNT1, KCTD7, HCN1, CACAN1A, CACNA1H, GRIN1, GRIN2A, GRIN2B, GRIN2D, GABRA1, GABRB3, GABRG2, CHRNA2, CHRNA4, CHRNB2. In our study, 51.2% pathogenic or likely pathogenic variants were found in voltage-gated ion channels and 4.7% were found in ligand-gated ion channels. Thus, we further confirmed that ion channels play an important role in the pathogenesis of epilepsy.

An SCN1A mutation was first discovered in epilepsy in 2000 [72], and now hundreds of new SCN1A mutations have been described in epilepsy patients, making it the most common epilepsy-related gene [78]. In our study, we found SCN1A mutations in 16/44 deleterious variants, making it the most common gene to show variation in our study. SCN1A encodes the Nav1.1 pore-forming α-subunit, expressed mainly in inhibitory GABAergic neurons. The α-subunit comprises four homologous domains (I–IV), forming a tetrameric structure. Each domain is composed of six transmembrane segments (S1–S6) [77]. The S4, voltage-sensing segment has multiple positively charged amino acids. The intracellular loop between III and IV domain functions as the inactivation gate. The α-subunit is usually associated with two β-subunits that influence α-subunit localization and function [77]. Among α-subunit of sodium channel genetic variants in our study, 43.8% (7/16) are within the intracellular loop, 31.3% (5/16) in the extracellular loop, 18.8% (3/16) in the transmembrane area, and 6.25% (1/16) in the pore forming area. All the extracellular mutations are between S5 and S6, which is very close to the pore forming area. These variants may influence the initiation and propagation of action potentials, making these inhibitory GABAergic neurons less excitable. Some antiepileptic drugs (AEDs) bind to the inner cavity of the pore of the sodium channel (IS6, IIIS6 and IVS6) [77, 79]. The pore forming area or internal/external loop could be promising targets for new seizure prophylaxis medications.

Patients harboring SCN1A mutations can have with Dravet syndrome or generalized epilepsy with febrile seizures plus. One Dravet syndrome patient inherited the SCN1A mutations from his father only had febrile seizures. This could be due to somatic mosaicism [72, 80, 81]. A Dravet syndrome mouse model (Nav1.1 knockout-based) responded well to stiripentol and clobazam, which are commonly used to treat Dravet syndrome [82–85]. One of the patients in our study was treated with oxcarbazepine, which blocks sodium channels and worsened seizures, before the diagnosis of Dravet syndrome was made. This case illustrates the importance of correct molecular diagnosis in selecting the best anticonvulsant.

Approximately half of Ohtahara syndrome patients with STXBP1 mutations evolve to West syndrome [86]. In our study, there was one such patient with a nonsense mutation in STXBP1, suggesting that this gene could play a role in the etiology of West syndrome. Our findings also suggest that STXBP1 is related to both Ohtahara syndrome and West syndrome.

KCNT1 is associated with epilepsy of infancy with migrating focal seizures, autosomal dominant nocturnal frontal lobe epilepsy, and other types of early onset epileptic encephalopathies [87–89]. Ohba et al. [88] found 11 KCNT1 mutations in a total of 362 epilepsy patients: 9/18 epilepsy of infancy with migrating focal seizures cases (50%), 1/180 West syndrome cases (0.56%), and 1/66 unclassified early onset epileptic encephalopathy cases (1.52%), suggesting that KCNT1 may be a causal gene for West syndrome. In our study, one KCNT1 (c.862G > A, p.G288S) mutation was found in a patient diagnosed as West syndrome.

Genetic studies of neuropsychiatric disease have led to the discovery of molecular etiology and pathophysiology. For example, most cases of Rett syndrome are now known to arise from mutations in the MECP2 gene, which codes for a methyl-CpG-binding protein 2 [90]. Another example is glucose transporter type 1 deficiency syndrome, which has been attributed to variants in SLC2A1, SLC2A2, and GLUT1. In our study, the glucose transporter type 1 deficiency syndrome patient did not have cerebrospinal fluid analysis as part of their diagnostic work-up until the genetic data suggested the diagnosis. This example illustrates the utility of NGS in clinical scenarios, and in time this may become an important part of the evaluation of pediatric patients with epilepsy. In some epilepsy syndromes, crucial interventions such as diet modification can have dramatic beneficial effects, so early diagnosis is vital [91, 92].

In our study, SCN1A was the main deleterious variant in Dravet syndrome and KCNQ2, STXBP1, SCN2A were found in Ohtahara syndrome. Deleterious variants in STXBP1, KCNT1, CDKL5, ADSL genes were found in West syndrome. Novel mutations in SYNGAP1 were found in Doose syndrome, a SLC2A1 mutation was found in GLUT1-DS and a de novo MECP2 mutation were found in Rett syndrome. TSC1/TSC2 variants were found in 60% of patients with tuberous sclerosis complex. Mutations found in unclassified epileptic encephalopathy were mainly in ion-channel genes. Thus, our study reinforces previous observations that the clinical syndrome and genetic etiology do not always match.

We tested 153 epilepsy genes and found 43 pathogenic and likely pathogenic variants in this study. Considering that over 500 epilepsy genes have been reported [73–76], our work was not comprehensive, which is a limitation of this study. With the decreasing cost of whole genome sequencing, the interrogation of the entire genome is now feasible for larger samples of epilepsy patients, and this approach has already been fruitful in other neuropsychiatric disorders such as autism, Kabuki syndrome, Bohring-Opitz syndrome and others [93, 94].

For genetic testing, it is proposed to conduct the strong candidate gene sequencing first (SCN1A for Dravet syndrome, MECP2 for Rett syndrome and TSC1/2 for tuberous sclerosis complex) before a NGS multi-gene panel testing [95–97]. In our study, we conducted targeted panel sequencing on Dravet syndrome and Rett syndrome patients before screening the strongest candidate gene for the following reasons. First, the correct clinical diagnosis of these syndromes can be difficult, especially in some of the younger patients in our sample, and often requires longitudinal assessment, which delays the correct diagnosis. Thus, we elected to perform NGS on our subjects before knowing the clinical diagnosis in some cases, such as these syndromes. Since our NGS panel that contains 153 epilepsy genes, our approach could facilitate the correct diagnosis in some cases. Second, it is now apparent that while 70–80% Dravet syndrome patients have SCN1A mutations, mutations in other genes such as SCN1B, SCN2A, SCN8A, PCDH19, GABRA1, GABRG2, STXBP1, CHD2 genes can cause Dravet syndrome like phenotypes [98], which would be missed if only SCN1A was sequenced. Similarly, CDKL5 and FOXG1 have been associated with atypical Rett syndrome [99], in addition to MECP2.

In tuberous sclerosis complex patients, we have a similar clinical scenario in which most features of tuberous sclerosis complex become evident only after 3 years of age, limiting their usefulness for early diagnosis [100]. In our study, all of the tuberous sclerosis complex patients’ initial presentations were seizures, of which 80% presented in the first year of life. 60% had hypomelanotic macules and 40% had multi nodules. 20% patient’s only clinical manifestation was seizures and 60% patients with seizures had only one major feature of tuberous sclerosis complex. 60% patients were found to have deleterious TSC1 or TSC2 mutations by NGS sequencing. Facial angiofibromas appeared by age 3–4 years in 60% patients in the follow-up period.

In summary, we identified 43 pathogenic or likely pathogenic variants, of which 26 mutations were novel and 32 were de novo. Variants in ion channel genes accounted for the largest category of gene in children with refractory epilepsy. Dravet syndrome is closely related to the SCN1A gene, which was the most frequently-appearing gene showing variants in our study. Novel and de novo mutations were found in Ohtahara syndrome, West syndrome, Doose syndrome and tuberous sclerosis complex pediatric patients. We also found a novel mutation in glucose transporter type 1 deficiency. Our results reinforce the importance and feasibility of precise genetic diagnosis for epilepsy, with the hope that in future, this will both aid in understanding the molecular pathophysiology and lead to new treatment targets.

Abbreviations

ACMG

American College of Medical Genetics and Genomics

AEDs

antiepileptic drugs

EEOC

childhood-onset epileptic encephalopathy

EIEE

early-infantile epileptic encephalopathies

MT

Mutation Taster

NGS

next-generation sequencing

OMIM

Online Mendelian Inheritance in Man

PP2

PolyPhen-2

SCN1A

subunit alpha of sodium channel type 1

SIFT

Sorting Intolerant From Tolerant

Authors’ contributions

BML and JL were responsible for the original concept and the overall design of the research. JL, LLT, BML, RPS analyzed the EEG results and diagnosed patients. JL, SSS, YN, JL, XW, FL collected the clinical data and sample. JL, LLT, SSS, YN, XW, JL, JZ, FL, JW carried the experiments and analysed the sequencing data. JL, HYL performed structural and functional analysis experiments. JL, BML, CZ, AW, FL wrote and revised the manuscript. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.

Ethics approval and consent to participate

The program adhered to guidelines of patients’ consent for participation and research and was supported by the Ethics Committee of Qilu hospital, Shandong University (No. 2016(027)).

Consent for publication

All authors read and approved the final manuscript.

Competing interests

The authors declare that they have no competing interests.

Publisher’s Note

Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.