An exploration of Prevotella-rich microbiomes in HIV and men who have sex with men

Abstract

Background

Gut microbiome characteristics associated with HIV infection are of intense research interest but a deep understanding has been challenged by confounding factors across studied populations. Notably, a Prevotella-rich microbiome described in HIV-infected populations is now understood to be common in men who have sex with men (MSM) regardless of HIV status, but driving factors and potential health implications are unknown.

Results

Here, we further define the MSM-associated gut microbiome and describe compositional differences between the fecal microbiomes of Prevotella-rich MSM and non-MSM that may underlie observed pro-inflammatory properties. Furthermore, we show relatively subtle gut microbiome changes in HIV infection in MSM and women that include an increase in potential pathogens that is ameliorated with antiretroviral therapy (ART). Lastly, using a longitudinal cohort, we describe microbiome changes that happen after ART initiation.

Conclusions

This study provides an in-depth characterization of microbiome differences that occur in a US population infected with HIV and demonstrates the degree to which these differences may be driven by lifestyle factors, ART, and HIV infection itself. Understanding microbiome compositions that occur with sexual behaviors that are high risk for acquiring HIV and untreated and ART-treated HIV infection will guide the investigation of immune and metabolic functional implications to ultimately target the microbiome therapeutically.

Electronic supplementary material

The online version of this article (10.1186/s40168-018-0580-7) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Background

One bodily fluid people rarely think of as related to human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) infection is feces. However, the gut microbiome may hold the key for preventing disease transmission and progression and for improving the quality of life for the 1.2 million Americans and 36.7 million individuals worldwide with chronic HIV infection for several reasons [1]. First, the gut microbiota can induce T cell activation [2] and since HIV preferentially infects activated T cells, microbiome composition at mucosal sites, specifically in the rectum/anus, may influence disease transmission in men who have sex with men (MSM) [3–5]. Second, increased peripheral immune activation driven by translocation of gut bacterial components has been linked to HIV disease progression in both untreated and treated infection [6], and the high peripheral immune activation may be influenced by gut microbiota with more pro-inflammatory components [2]. Finally, although life expectancy of individuals infected with HIV has been greatly increased by antiretroviral therapy (ART) [7], there has been a concurrent increase in non-infectious comorbidities including metabolic and cardiovascular diseases associated with chronic inflammation [7–9]. Outside the context of HIV infection, these diseases have been associated with microbiome dysbiosis [10–12].

Understanding compositional changes of the gut microbiome that occur with HIV infection is hindered by the complexity of the HIV-infected population and the myriad confounding factors [13]. Most notably, a prominent HIV-associated microbiome alteration observed by our group [14] and independently by several others [15–17] was an increase in the genus Prevotella and decrease in the genus Bacteroides. However, recent studies have shown that MSM have a Prevotella-rich fecal [2, 18] and rectal mucosal [9] microbiome regardless of HIV infection status. HIV-negative MSM are therefore necessary controls for distinguishing the effects of HIV infection itself on microbiome composition, especially in US populations where the majority of HIV-positive individuals are MSM [5].

Potential health implications of Prevotella-rich microbiomes have been a topic of much interest [19]. Human gut microbiomes across many studies show related clustering patterns based on their composition, leading to the suggestion that human microbiomes form distinct “enterotypes” characterized by particular community structures [20]. The Prevotella enterotype, which is characterized by a high relative abundance of the genus Prevotella, occurs in approximately 18% of healthy individuals in western populations [20]. It has been linked with diets low in animal products and high in carbohydrates/fiber [21] and with beneficial metabolic effects in the context of a high-fiber diet [22]. Prevotella-rich microbiomes are also typical of healthy individuals in agrarian cultures [23]. However, high Prevotella has also been described in inflammatory states such as rheumatoid arthritis [24] and has been linked with obesity [25, 26] and insulin resistance [27]. Furthermore, we have shown that in in vitro stimulations the Prevotella-rich fecal microbiome of MSM induces higher activation of human innate immune cells compared to non-MSM [2], supporting the idea that the MSM microbiome is potentially a contributing factor to increased inflammation observed in MSM both systemically [28, 29] and in rectal mucosa [9].

In this paper, we characterize the fecal microbiome of MSM and non-MSM to explore potential driving factors and health implications of Prevotella-rich microbiomes in MSM individuals. We also further characterize gut microbiome attributes that are associated with HIV infection and ART. Taken together, this study provides an in-depth characterization of microbiome differences that occur in a US population infected with HIV and demonstrates the degree to which these differences may be driven by lifestyle factors, ART, and HIV infection itself. This understanding will help to guide efforts to investigate the functional implications of these differences and ultimately target the microbiome therapeutically.

Results

Cohort description

This paper compares the fecal microbiome of 217 individuals as assessed by sequencing the V4 region of the 16S ribosomal RNA (rRNA) gene (Table 1; Additional file 1: Table S1). Sixty-eight percent of the cohort filled out a sexual preference/behavior questionnaire (Table 2; Additional file 2: Table S2). Taken together, our analysis includes HIV-positive individuals on ART; HIV-positive, ART-naïve individuals; and a seronegative cohort. The seronegative cohort includes 35 MSM of which the majority (n = 32) engaged in high-risk behaviors within the prior year; 29 men who identify as heterosexual and did not report engaging in any sexual risk factors (referred to here as MSW; men who have sex with women); and 41 women, 3 of whom reported in engaging in receptive anal intercourse within a year of sample collection (Tables 1 and 2).

Table 1.

Cohort description

			N	Age (year)	Race (C/AA/O)	Hispanic	IVDU	BMI (kg/m2)	CD4 (cells/μL)	Viral load (copies/mL)
HIV negative		MSM	35	34.5 ±  8.5	33/1/1	6 (17.1%)	0	26.1 ±  4.2	NA	0
		MSW	29	38.0 ±  14.3	25/1/3	3 (10.3%)	0	25.7 ±  3.1	NA	0
		Women	41	32.9 ±  9.8	37/0/4	5 (12.2%)	0	24.7 ±  3.4	NA	0
HIV positive	ART treated	MSM	50	50.0 ±  10.1	42/7/1	8 (16.0%)	1 (2.0%)	26.3 ±  4.0	699 ±  311	12 ±  14
		MSW	2	55.5 ±  1.5	1/0/0	0	0	27.1 ±  0.6	962 ±  344	10 ±  10
		Women	15	50.9 ±  9.4	11/3/1	3 (20.0%)	0	30.0 ±  6.5	816 ±  336	35 ±  80
	ART naïve	MSM	40	33.5 ±  9.1	28/10/2	7 (17.5%)	2 (5.0%)	24.4 ±  4.3	560 ±  206	126,714 ±  189,725
		MSW	1	51.0 ±  0.0	1/0/0	0	0	26.8	551	3880
		Women	4	30.0 ±  5.2	4/0/0	0	1 (25.0%)	27.5 ±  7.2	600 ±  357	33,250 ±  40,880

A statistical analysis of differences in parameters across groups that were compared is given in Additional file 1: Table S1

C Caucasian, AA African American, O Other

Table 2.

Behavioral data

			N	Orientation (H/B/G)	Frequency of RAI			IVDU	New STI	Sexual risk	Sample within survey range†
					Never	< 1 time per week	> 1 time per week
HIV negative		MSM	29	0/2/27	4 (13.8%)	18 (62.1%)	7 (24.1%)	0	2 (6.9%)	19 (65.5%)	18
		MSW	25	25/0/0	24 (96.0%)	0	1 (4.0%)	0	0	1 (4.0%)	22
		Women	35	29/2/4	32 (91.4%)	3 (8.6%)	0	0	0	0	33
HIV positive	ART treated	MSM	30	0/3/27	15 (50.0%)	11 (36.7%)	3 (10.0%)	1 (3.3%)	2 (6.7%)	14 (46.7%)	21
		MSW	2	2/0/0	2 (100.0%)	0	0	0	0	0	1
		Women	6	6/0/0	6(100.0%)	0	0	0	0	0	3
	ART naïve	MSM	18	0/1/17	4 (22.2%)	8 (44.4%)	6 (33.3%)	2 (11.1%)	5 (27.8%)	17 (94.4%)	8
		MSW	1	1/0/0	1 (100.0%)	0	0	0	0	0	1
		Women	2	1/1/0	0	0	2 (100.0%)	1 (50.0%)	0	2 (100.0%)	1

A statistical analysis of differences in parameters across groups that were compared is given in Additional file 2: Table S2

H heterosexual, B bisexual, G gay/lesbian

^†Sample collected < 12 months before survey date

Almost all of the HIV-positive men who responded to our behavior questionnaire (95%) were sexually active MSM, usually engaging in anal intercourse with other HIV-positive individuals (Table 2). Although 25 of the 93 HIV-positive men did not respond to our behavior questionnaire, we included these 25 individuals in our HIV-positive, MSM cohort. To confirm that potential false identification as MSM would not affect our results, we also performed analysis without the 25 HIV-positive men of unsure MSM status, and there was no significant change in results (Additional file 3: Table S3). One of the HIV-positive males in the ART group is a female to male (FTM) transgender who identifies as MSW and is categorized as such in our analyses.

The ART-treated cohort all had plasma HIV RNA at or below the limits of detection. There were significantly higher CD4+ T cell numbers (cells/μL) in HIV-positive MSM on ART compared to the ART-naïve cohorts, but no significant difference between ART-treated and ART-naïve HIV-positive women (p < 0.05 and p = 0.32; Kruskal-Wallis test; Additional file 1: Table S1). Of note, 12 HIV-positive individuals had a CD4+ T cell count below 300/μL, 6 in the ART cohort (1 female, 5 MSM) and 6 in the ART-naïve cohort (1 female, 5 MSM). These numbers—an estimate of HIV disease progression—suggest very few individuals in our cohort with immune deficiencies consistent with advanced HIV infection.

Sexual behavior is the strongest descriptor of compositional variation in the gut microbiome

We observed clear clustering by gender/sexual behavior but not HIV infection status when applying principal coordinates analysis (PCoA) to weighted (Fig. 1a, c, Additional file 4: Figure S1B) and unweighted (Fig. 1b, Additional file 4: Figure S1A) UniFrac distance matrices as well as abundance and binary Jaccard (Additional file 5: Figure S2A,B). Applying the Adonis test showed significant effects for MSM and HIV with weighted Unifrac, which explained 16.4% and 1.4% of the variation respectively, and for MSM, HIV, and ART with unweighted Unifrac, which explained 7.0%, 0.9%, and 0.7% respectively (Additional file 3: Table S3).

Fig. 1.

MSM is more strongly associated with Prevotella richness than HIV infection. a Weighted UniFrac PCoA and b unweighted UniFrac with points colored by orientation and shaped by HIV status. c Genus-level taxonomic summary plot. (Bottom) Genera with mean relative less than 2% abundance are binned together into the category “Other”. Each column represents one individual. (Top) Samples are marked with HIV status and orientation. Each column corresponds to the genus plot below. Samples are ordered by the coordinate on the weighted UniFrac principle coordinate 1

In order to empirically determine any clustering within the data, we performed the standard “enterotyping” methods as previously described [21]. In short, clusters are defined on a Jensen-Shannon divergence matrix by partition around medoids clustering (Additional file 6: Figure S3B). Calculating the Silhouette index on our data revealed optimum clustering into two clusters (Additional file 6: Figure S3A). These clusters are primarily defined by a dominance of the genus Bacteroides or Prevotella (Additional file 6: Figure S3C). We subsequently refer to individuals in the Prevotella-dominant enterotype as individuals with Prevotella-rich microbiomes. MSM were more likely to be Prevotella-rich than females and MSW (p < 0.001; Fisher’s exact test).

HIV-negative and HIV-positive MSM had significantly greater phylogenetic diversity (PD; [30]) and observed operational taxonomic units (OTUs, defined at a 99% identity threshold) compared to non-MSM (p < 0.05; Kruskal-Wallis test; Fig. 2a) and many significantly different OTUs (Additional file 7: Table S4). The most striking difference in MSM compared to non-MSM is the increase in relative abundance of the Prevotella genus. On average HIV-negative MSM had 3.9 times higher relative abundance of Prevotella compared to HIV-negative non-MSM.

Fig. 2.

HIV-negative MSM have significantly different microbiome composition compared to HIV-negative MSW. a MSM have significantly higher alpha diversity than MSW with and without controlling for HIV status (Kruskal-Wallis test; *p< 0.05, **p< 0.01, ***p< 0.001, NS not significant). b Several OTUs are significantly different between HIV-negative Prevotella-rich MSM and HIV-negative Prevotella-rich non-MSM. The significant (Kruskal-Wallis; FDR-corrected p < 0.1) OTUs are displayed as the log2 abundance fold change in MSM compared to non-MSM. More detailed information on the significant OTUs is given in Additional file 9: Table S6

Prevotella-rich microbiomes differ in MSM compared to non-MSM

Prevotella-rich non-MSM clustered together with Prevotella-rich MSM in weighted but not unweighted UniFrac (Fig. 1c; Additional file 4: Figure S1A), indicating compositional differences in rare taxa. To understand these enteroyptes in the context of other studies, our samples were classified using enterotypes.org [31], which uses large-scale microbiome studies including the Human Microbiome Project [32] and MetaHIT [33] to form an enterotype reference space to which other data can be compared. We found that the proportion of Prevotella-rich individuals as defined by “enterotyping” in our study who did not fit within the general Prevotella-rich reference space defined in enterotypes.org was significantly higher for MSM (81.4% of individuals) than non-MSM (46.7%) (Additional file 8: Table S5; Fisher’s test; p < 0.05). Prevotella-rich, HIV-negative MSM (n = 25) and non-MSM (n = 9) had significantly different relative abundances of 39 OTUs in 21 different genera (Kruskal-Wallis test; FDR p < 0.1; Fig. 2b. Additional file 9: Table S6). Interestingly, the OTUs with the largest increase and decrease in MSM were both identified as Prevotella copri, suggesting strain-level differences in Prevotella (Additional file 9: Table S6).

To understand the highly interactive set of co-occurring microbes within these Prevotella-rich microbiomes, we used SparCC correlations to build a co-occurrence network of OTU-OTU correlations in Prevotella-rich, HIV-negative MSM (Additional file 10: Figure S4; Additional file 11: Table S7) and separately in Prevotella-rich, HIV-negative non-MSM (Additional file 12: Table S8). We had a deep sampling of the Prevotella-rich, HIV-negative MSM (n = 25) compared to the non-MSM (n = 9) and thus designed our analysis to determine the degree to which OTU-OTU relationships that were reliably observed in the MSM group at a sample depth of 9 were observed in the non-MSM at the same depth. Specifically, we performed jackknifing at an n of 9 on the MSM samples 100 times and weighted the edges in the resulting network by the fraction of times the edge was observed. We then evaluated whether high-confidence edges (correlations) in the MSM network (weight of 75% or greater) were found in the non-MSM network. Only 18.6% of high-confidence edges (n = 18) in the MSM network were shared with the non-MSM network. Of note, 8.2% (n = 8) of the high-confidence edges in the MSM network have one or both of the nodes within the Prevotella genus; however, none of these are shared with the non-MSM network.

Potential drivers of Prevotella richness in MSM

We collected behavioral data including frequency of receptive anal intercourse (RAI) (Table 2) on a total of 77 MSM individuals. As some subjects received the questionnaire retrospectively, our analysis included only the 47 MSM individuals who answered within the 1-year timeframe of sample collection that the behavior questions referred to (Table 2). However, we did not find any significant association with microbiome taxonomy or alpha or beta diversity between MSM who engaged in RAI (n = 31) and those who did not (n = 15) when controlling for sexual orientation and HIV status (Additional file 13: Figure S5; taxonomy and alpha diversity—Kruskal-Wallis test; beta diversity—Adonis test; p > 0.05). We also did not find a significant association with RAI frequency (< 1 time per week compared to > 1 time per week). The 5 women (3 HIV negative and 2 HIV positive) who reported engaging in RAI—2 at relatively high frequency (> 1 time per week)—were all Bacteroides rich and clustered with non-RAI-engaging women and MSW in Unifrac PCoA (Additional file 13: Figure S5).

Because diet composition has been associated with enterotypes [21], we also collected diet information on a subset of the subjects (n = 98). Comparison of diets between HIV-negative MSM (n = 24) and non-MSM (n = 45) revealed several significant differences in diet composition in both data normalized to 1000 kcal (Additional file 14: Table S9) and non-normalized data (Additional file 15: Table S10) (Mann-Whitney U; FDR p < 0.1). Most notably, MSM reported eating more ounces of lean meat from beef, pork, veal, lamb, and game and fewer servings of fruit and grams of dietary fiber (Fig. 3). However, these diet changes do not appear to be driving our reported differences between MSM and MSW/females as linear models that included diet did not change the significance of the top ten most significantly different OTUs with MSM status (Additional file 16: Table S11). Lastly, though previous studies have suggested an effect of IV drug usage on microbiome composition in HIV [34], our cohort did not include a sufficient number of IV drug users (n = 4) to infer any statistically significant influence.

Fig. 3.

FFQ diet analysis of MSM compared to non-MSM shows MSM eat significantly few servings of red meat and fruits and less fiber. Reported values are normalized per 1000 kcals. More detail on significant diet components is given in Additional files 14 and 15: Tables S9 and S10 (Kruskal-Wallis test; *p< 0.05)

Identifying HIV-associated microbiome differences while controlling for sexual behavior and gender

We stratified our cohort into analyses containing MSM only and women only to investigate changes in the microbiome that may occur with HIV infection and ART (Fig. 4a). We observed no significant difference in alpha diversity with HIV infection status in MSM (Fig. 2). In MSM, six OTUs were significantly different between HIV-negative, HIV-positive, untreated, and HIV-positive on ART based on Kruskal-Wallis with Dunn’s post hoc test and FDR correction (Table 3; Additional file 17: Table S12). The relative abundances of these OTUs followed one of two trends: First, no significant difference in untreated HIV infection compared to HIV-negative controls and significant decrease in treated HIV infection compared to untreated. This trend suggests microbes not altered due to HIV infection but depleted with ART and includes an OTU identified as Fenollaria massiliensis and an OTU within the Peptoniphilus genus. Second, a significant increase in abundance in untreated HIV infection compared to HIV-negative controls and a significant decrease in treated compared to untreated HIV infection. This trend suggests microbes that may respond to viral load and immune depletion in untreated infection that is corrected by ART and includes OTUs identified as Fusobacterium equinum, Turicibacter sanguinis, Finegoldia magna, and Streptococcus sp. (S. mitis group).

Fig. 4.

HIV-specific changes in women in MSM. Weighted UniFrac PCoA of a MSM only and b women only shows that only half of HIV-positive women cluster apart from HIV-negative women whereas there is no distinctive clustering of HIV in MSM. c Alpha diversity differences in women only (Kruskal-Wallis test; *p< 0.05, NS not significant)

Table 3.

Significantly altered OTUs in HIV

Taxonomy	Mean relative abundance			p value	FDR p value
	HIV negative	Treated	Untreated
MSM
No difference in HIV and significant reduction in ART treatment (—\)
Fenollaria massiliensis	1.76E−03	2.00E−03	3.01E−04	< 0.001	< 0.05
Peptoniphilus sp.	1.44E−03	2.41E−03	5.28E−04	< 0.001	< 0.05
Significant increase in HIV and significant reduction in ART treatment (/\)
Streptococcus mitis group	5.09E−05	1.84E−03	2.32E−05	< 0.001	< 0.01
Fusobacterium equinum	1.17E−03	7.77E−03	1.84E−04	< 0.001	< 0.05
Turicibacter sanguinis	5.55E−04	6.02E−04	3.17E−04	< 0.01	< 0.1
Finegoldia magna	5.60E−03	8.26E−03	5.23E−03	< 0.01	< 0.1
Women
No difference in HIV and significant reduction in ART treatment (—\)
Blautia luti	7.71E−03	5.48E−03	1.93E−03	< 0.001	< 0.1
Significant decrease in HIV and no change in ART treatment (\_)
Fusicatenibacter Saccharivorans	1.18E−02	4.46E−03	1.87E−03	< 0.001	< 0.1

Detailed p values are in Additional file 17: Table S12

PCoA analysis of women alone revealed that half of the HIV-positive women, both ART-treated and untreated, clustered with the HIV-negative women, with the other half clustering separately in the PCoA space using the “enterotyping” procedure (Fig. 4b) [21]. This clustering pattern was not significantly associated with CD4+ T cell count, viral load, CD4 nadir, CD4+CD38+HLA-DR+, and CD8+CD38+HLA-DR+ cells, antibiotic use in past 6 months, and engagement in RAI as assessed with either Kruskal-Wallis comparison of these factors between clusters or correlation with position of PC1 (primary axis of cluster division). Interestingly, these HIV-positive women who were compositionally divergent from HIV-negative women were characterized by microbiomes relatively high in Prevotella and low in Bacteroides (Additional file 18: Table S13), raising the intriguing possibility that this difference is driven by an unknown risk behavior-related factor, as the HIV-negative control women were not exhibiting any measured high-risk behaviors.

ART-naïve, HIV-positive women had significantly reduced alpha diversity compared to the seronegative controls (Kruskal-Wallis; p < 0.05; Fig. 4c). Two OTUs were altered when comparing HIV-negative women; HIV-positive, ART-naïve women; and HIV-positive women on ART: Fusicatenibacter saccharivorans and Blautia luti (Table 3; Additional file 17: Table S12). B. luti had no significant difference in untreated HIV infection compared to HIV-negative controls and a significant decrease in treated HIV infection compared to untreated infection. This suggests B. luti may be responding to ART and not HIV infection as a driver; however, a failure to detect significant differences between HIV negative and ART naïve may have been a function of a low sample size in the ART-naïve cohort. F. saccharivorans had a significant decrease in relative abundance in untreated HIV infection compared to HIV-negative individuals and no significant difference between untreated and treated HIV-positive individuals, suggesting an HIV-driven change that was not fully corrected by ART.

Immune-microbiome correlations

To determine relationships between gut microbiome composition and markers of HIV disease progression/severity, we correlated the relative abundance of microbes in our HIV-positive, ART-naïve, and ART-treated MSM with blood CD4 count, plasma HIV RNA (viral load), and percent of HLA-DR+CD38+ chronically activated CD4+ and CD8+ T cells (Fig. 5). All of the significant correlations in the untreated population are negative, suggesting a loss of beneficial microbes with regard to inflammation especially when looking at the correlations with plasma viral load and CD8+HLA-DR+CD38+ percent. The CD4+HLA-DR+CD38+ correlations are more difficult to interpret: because activated CD4+ T cells are preferentially targeted in HIV infection, negative correlations may be due to a significant loss of these cells and not necessarily a reduction in activation.

Fig. 5.

Microbiome immune correlations. Correlations in HIV-positive, ART-treated (top), and ART-naive (bottom) MSM between OTUs and serum measures of CD4+ T cell count, CD4+/CD8+ CD38+ HLA-DR+ cell percent, and viral load (All OTUs with one or more correlation r > |0.4| are displayed) (Spearman rank test; FDR p value: ^{^}p < 0.2, ⁺p < 0.1, *p < 0.05)

In the ART-treated group, an OTU within the Prevotella genus was positively correlated with CD8+HLA-DR+CD38+ percent. When compared against the NCBI 16S rRNA gene database using BLAST, the OTU matched with 100% identity over 100% of the sequence to Massiliprevotella massiliensis strain Marseille-P2439 which is closely related to Prevotella stercorea [35]. Additionally, an OTU identified as Eubacterium dolichum was significantly negatively correlated with CD8+HLA-DR+CD38+ percent with a trending positive correlation with CD4+ T cell count, suggesting a potentially beneficial role.

Longitudinal analysis of HIV-positive individuals before and after ART initiation

In addition to the cross-sectional cohort, we also studied 40 individuals longitudinally.

HIV-negative (n = 16) and HIV-positive (n = 24) subjects were sampled 6–14 months apart. Individuals in the HIV-positive cohort were ART naïve at the first time point and then immediately initiated ART. The HIV-positive cohort had a significant increase in CD4+ T cell count (Wilcoxon signed-rank test; p < 0.05; Additional file 19: Figure S6) and decrease in viral load post-treatment with plasma HIV RNA counts between 0 and 40 (Wilcoxon signed-rank test; p < 0.001; Additional file 19: Figure S6).

HIV-positive individuals had significantly higher weighted but not unweighted beta diversity across time points compared to the seronegative controls, suggesting ART initiation results in significant alteration of the community proportions (UniFrac, Kruskal-Wallis test, p < 0.05 (weighted), p = 0.11 (unweighted); Fig. 6a). This result is also mirrored in abundance and binary Jaccard (Additional file 4: Figure S1D). There was no significant difference in the change in alpha diversity between the two time points when comparing HIV-positive individuals and HIV-negative controls (Fig. 6b). However, two subjects had a significant reduction in observed OTUs and one subject had significant reduction in Shannon diversity as defined by being significant outliers from the rest of the data (Tietjen-Moore test, p < 0.05). While there was a 3-month antibiotic exclusion criteria for initial enrollment, subjects may have taken antibiotics between the two collected time points. However, there was no significant association between beta diversity or change in alpha diversity and antibiotic usage in the 6 months prior to the second sample collection (p > 0.05; Kruskal-Wallis test; Fig. 6a, b). We also specifically tested whether the OTUs that had a significant reduction in relative abundance in ART-treated compared to untreated HIV infection in the cross-sectional analysis of MSM (Table 3) also were significantly reduced longitudinally after ART initiation. We found a significant reduction in the OTUs identified as Turicibacter sanguinis and Streptococcus sp. (S. mitis group) (Wilcoxon signed-rank test, p < 0.05; Fig. 6c).

Fig. 6.

Longitudinal analysis of ART. a Beta diversity and b change in alpha diversity of HIV-negative individuals compared to HIV-positive pre- and post-ART initiation. c Two taxa observed in the cross-sectional cohort as significantly reduced with HIV and ART have significantly reduced relative abundance longitudinally (Wilcoxon signed-rank test; *p value < 0.05, NS not significant)

Discussion

This study describes microbiome differences that occur in a US population infected with HIV and establishes the degree to which these differences may be driven by sexual practices, diet, ART, and HIV infection itself. Our data supports that Prevotella-rich microbiomes are associated with MSM and not independently with HIV infection status as has been previously reported [18]. Surprisingly, given that Prevotella enterotypes have been associated with diets rich in carbohydrates and poor in animal products [21], we found MSM in our cohort to be consuming significantly less fiber and more red meat than non-MSM. This supports the conclusion of Noguera-Jullian et al. that dietary differences were not a likely driving factor of the Prevotella-rich MSM microbiome, especially given that both that study and ours found similar MSM-associated microbiome changes but different diet changes [18]. Furthermore, when analyzing a subset of our cohort for which we had diet data with linear models that included kilocalorie normalized amount of fiber or servings of red meat, we did not see a loss of significance of OTUs that differed between MSM and MSW/women. There were no microbiome associations with RAI engagement or frequency in MSM or women. Another potential driving factor of an altered microbiome in MSM could be a higher incidence of STDs; however, we did not have enough data on STDs within our study population to examine this. Additionally, Noguera-Julian et al. did not find associations between Prevotella richness and various STDs including human papillomavirus, hepatitis B, or hepatitis C infection [18]. Taken together, we unfortunately still do not understand what drives Prevotella-rich microbiomes in MSM.

Prevotella-rich microbiomes in MSM also display marked differences with Prevotella-rich microbiomes of non-MSM, suggesting potential differences in functional attributes. Compositional differences between Prevotella-rich microbiomes in different contexts may underlie contradictory reports in the literature regarding potential health implications. Some studies have suggested a health benefit with Prevotella enrichment such as improved glucose metabolism in the context of a high-fiber diet [22]. Other studies suggest a detrimental effect indicated by associations with rheumatoid arthritis [24] and with insulin resistance [27]. Experiments to test for causality have used the one commercially available strain of P. copri (DSM-18205/JCM 13464) and have shown this strain to have a wide range of effects: with detrimental effects such as greater insulin resistance and glucose intolerance [27] as well as aggravated DSS-induced colitis [24]. The exclusive use of a single strain in these experiments is not optimal. Consistent with strain-level differences in P. copri detected in rheumatoid arthritis versus controls using shotgun metagenomic sequencing [24], we saw evidence of strain-level variation in Prevotella-rich MSM compared to non-MSM, with one OTU identified as P. copri (4475169) significantly more abundant in MSM and another OTU also identified as P. copri (4482723) significantly less abundant (Fig. 2b; Additional file 9: Table S6). Performing experiments with P. copri strains cultured directly from fecal samples of interest will be needed to understand a possible effect of strains on differing health phenotypes.

However, strong co-occurrence associations between P. copri—as well as Prevotella species in general—and other taxa suggests that such a strong emphasis on P. copri may not be warranted when trying to understand potential health implications of Prevotella-rich microbiomes. We observed many differences in composition and co-occurrence relationships in Prevotella-rich microbiomes of MSM compared to non-MSM, suggesting that there may be different sub-types of Prevotella-rich microbiomes. In a separate study, we have used in vitro stimulations with collections of whole intact bacterial cells isolated from feces and found that MSM microbiomes induced more pro-inflammatory innate immune activation compared to non-MSM controls [2]. Several OTUs more abundant in Prevotella-rich MSM compared to Prevotella-rich non-MSM, but not any OTUs in the Prevotella genus, correlated strongly with high CD4+ and CD8+ T cell activation in these in vitro stimulations [2]. We have also previously used in vitro stimulation assays to show that one of these MSM and immune activation-correlated bacteria, Holdamenella biformis ATCC 27806 (formally Eubacterium biforme) but not P. copri DSM-18205, is far more pro-inflammatory than other gut commensals tested, inducing high TNF-α to IL-10 ratio in peripheral blood mononuclear cell (PBMC) stimulations [14]. Further work will be needed to understand potential health implications of the MSM-associated gut microbiome and whether Prevotella itself or other co-occurring microbes are important drivers of functional phenotypes.

Since most microbiome studies aimed at understanding gut microbiome differences with HIV have not controlled for MSM behavior [14–16, 36–38], we still have an incomplete understanding of HIV-associated microbiome characteristics. Many of the species and genera that we have found to be increased in MSM compared to non-MSM have been previously reported to differ with HIV in studies not controlled for MSM risk behavior including H. biformis [14], Prevotella [14–17], Catenibacterium [14, 15], and Desulfovibrio [38]. Additionally, we confirm a prior report of an increase in alpha diversity in MSM [18]. The high number of MSM in our previous HIV-positive cohorts is likely to be the driver of our previously reported result of an increase in alpha diversity with HIV [38]. This significant increase in alpha diversity in MSM challenges popular opinion that higher alpha diversity always equates to a healthier gut microbiome, especially with preliminary results suggesting the MSM microbiome may be more inflammatory [2]. Unlike Noguera-Julian et al., we did not find a significant decrease in alpha diversity with HIV infection status in MSM [18]. However, the cohort with the lowest alpha diversity in that study were immunologic non-responders to ART (i.e., individuals with poor CD4+ T cell recovery after ART) and our current cohort had few individuals who would fit this definition.

We confirm previous reports that there are relatively subtle differences in fecal microbiome composition with HIV infection in the absence of CD4+ T cell counts indicative of AIDS [18], or when analyzing populations dominated by heterosexual transmission [39]. However, our analyses in MSM individuals and women did reveal some OTUs that associated with HIV and ART. Perhaps the most interesting pattern observed is taxa that increase compared to MSM controls with untreated HIV infection and decrease to levels indistinguishable from the controls with effective ART, as these may be microbes whose populations are particularly sensitive to CD4+ T cell control. All four OTUs that showed this trend were highly related to potential pathogens including Turicibacter sanguinis [40], Fusobacterium equinum [41], Finegoldia magna [42], and Streptococcus sp. (S. mitis group) [43]. Interestingly, F. magna, Streptococcus, and Fusobacterium have been found to co-occur in clinical samples [44]. A recent study from our lab showed that, in vitro, microbiomes containing higher levels of T. sanguinis induced more elevated frequencies of HLA-DR+CD38+CD4+ T cells, a marker of chronic activation, when whole microbiome bacterial isolates were cultured with PBMCs [2], suggesting a potential mechanistic relationship between T. sanguinis and T cell activation in the gut with untreated HIV infection. For the Streptococcus mitis group related OTU, the 16S rRNA gene sequence was 100% identical in the sequenced V4 region to 7 different type species with high variation in genome content [45]. This highlights the need for isolation of bacteria directly from the study population and/or metagenomic sequencing to elucidate strain-specific changes in the microbiome and for follow-up experiments to establish functional implications.

Although our analysis of women showed stronger microbiome differences with HIV infection, with a proportion of HIV-positive women clustering apart from HIV negative at the community level, these results should be interpreted with caution since our control cohort was not recruited as women with high-risk behaviors. Notably, the enrichment of Prevotella and depletion of Bacteroides characterizing the HIV-positive women that diverged from HIV-negative women at the community level suggests the same unknown risk behavior may be a driving factor. Despite the variation in microbiome compositions of HIV-positive women, we observed significant differences in an OTU identified in the Blautia genus with HIV infection. This is consistent with a previously reported increase of Blautia in HIV-positive, ART-naïve individuals compared to HIV-negative controls in a heterosexual transmission dominated cohort recruited in Sweden [46].

In our longitudinal cohort, we observed more change in the microbiomes of HIV-positive individuals pre- and post-ART initiation compared to the HIV-negative controls over similar time intervals, suggesting that microbiome compositional changes after ART initiation are greater than the baseline stochasticity of the healthy human microbiome. Microbiome changes observed in our cross-sectional cohort were validated in our longitudinal cohort; specifically, Turicibacter sanguinis and Streptococcus sp. (S. mitis group) are significantly decreased with ART in both analyses, adding to our confidence in these results. ART-associated changes are likely driven by a combination of beneficial changes caused by restoration of immune function and viral suppression and potentially detrimental changes driven by the ART drugs themselves. The changes driven by the ART drugs themselves likely vary based on drug regimen. For instance in a study conducted in Mexico City, Mexico, unique microbiome changes were observed in individuals on non-nucleoside reverse transcriptase inhibitors compared to ritonavir-boosted protease inhibitors with the same backbone of nucleoside reverse transcriptase inhibitors [26]. However, the individuals in our cohort are on a wide variety of different ART drug combinations and we did not have enough power to determine ART-class-associated changes in the microbiome.

Conclusions

The gut microbiome in HIV is a potential contributor to infection, disease progression, and development of non-infectious HIV-associated diseases. However, developing an understanding of changes occurring with HIV infection has been complicated by large differences in the gut microbiomes of MSM, a population disproportionately affected by HIV in the USA. We observed significant microbiome changes in HIV-negative MSM populations both in the prevalence of Prevotella-rich microbiomes as well as a different microbiome composition compared to Prevotella-rich non-MSM. Potential health implications and driving factors of Prevotella-rich microbiomes have been discussed in other health contexts including metabolic and autoimmune diseases, and understanding context-specific differences in Prevotella-rich microbiomes may help deconvolute contradicting results.

When controlling for MSM, we observed HIV- and ART-associated changes in the microbiome in both MSM and in women, some of which were confirmed in a longitudinal cohort of HIV-positive individuals initiating ART, showing an increase in potential pathogens in untreated infection that have the potential to contribute to inflammatory phenotypes. Lastly, both our correlational analysis as well as the greater body of literature suggest a potential influence of the microbiome composition in HIV on the inflammatory state of the HIV-infected gut. This understanding will help to guide efforts to investigate the functional implications of these differences to ultimately target the microbiome to improve the health of this population.

Methods

Subject recruitment

Subjects were residents of the Denver, Colorado metropolitan area, and were recruited and studied at the Clinical Translational Research Center of the University of Colorado Hospital. Three cohorts were prospectively recruited based on HIV status: (1) HIV-1 infection untreated: Individuals with a positive antibody or PCR test at least 6 months prior to enrollment and either ART drug-naïve (defined as < 10 days of ART treatment at any time prior to entry), or previously on ART but off treatment for the previous 6 months prior to screening; (2) chronic HIV-1 infection on long-term ART: ART for ≥ 12 months with a minimum of three ART drugs prior to study entry and < 50 copies HIV RNA/mL within 30 days prior to study entry and no plasma HIV-1 RNA ≥ 50 copies/mL in the past 6 months; and (3) healthy controls: HIV-negative individuals both high and low risk for contracting HIV. High risk for HIV infection was defined as in a prior study of a candidate HIV vaccine: (1) a history of unprotected anal intercourse with one or more male or male-to-female transgender partners, (2) anal intercourse with two or more male or male-to-female transgender partners, or (3) being in a sexual relationship with a person who has been diagnosed with HIV [47]. Individuals who reported taking antibiotics within 3 months of sample collection were excluded from the study. The fecal microbiome data from 50 of the 217 subjects were described in our previous publications [14, 38].

Longitudinal cohort

A subset of HIV-positive, untreated patients returned for a second visit and sample collection after 6–14 months of ART. A control cohort of HIV-negative participants also provided two samples 6–14 months apart. Analysis of microbiome change (beta diversity and delta alpha diversity) over time revealed no significant effect of variation in time between samples within a 6–14-month window (Spearman rank test; p > 0.05); therefore, we did not account for time between samples in our analysis.

DNA extraction and sequencing

Stool samples were collected on sterile swabs by the patient within 24 h prior to their clinic visit and stored at − 80 °C. DNA was extracted using the standard DNeasy PowerSoil Kit protocol (Qiagen). Extracted DNA was PCR amplified with barcoded primers targeting the V4 region of 16S rRNA gene according to the Earth Microbiome Project 16S Illumina Amplicon protocol with the 515F:806R primer constructs [48]. Control sterile swab samples that had undergone the same DNA extraction and PCR amplification procedures were also processed. Each PCR product was quantified using PicoGreen (Invitrogen), and equal amounts (ng) of DNA from each sample were pooled and cleaned using the UltraClean PCR Clean-Up Kit (MoBio). Sequences were generated on six runs on a MiSeq personal sequencer (Illumina, San Diego, CA) (Additional file 20).

Sequence data analysis

Raw sequences were demultiplexed using QIIME 1.9.1 [49]. DADA2 [50] was used for error correcting and unique sequence identification. During DADA2 processing, all sequences were truncated to 112 bp. Unique sequences were then binned into 99% OTUs using sortmeRNA (closed reference) [51] and UCLUST (open reference) [52] in QIIME 1.9.1 and taxonomy was assigned using the GreenGenes database 18_3 [53]. Samples were rarefied at 11,218 reads. Beta diversity metrics were calculated using weighted and unweighted UniFrac [54, 55] and binary and abundance Jaccard [56]. Alpha diversity metrics were calculated using phylogenetic diversity whole tree [30], observed OTUs, and Shannon using QIIME. Co-occurrence network modeling was performed using an in-house python script utilizing sparCC [57] implemented as fast sparCC (https://github.com/shafferm/fast_sparCC) in the programming language, Python. Markdown of analysis is provided in Additional file 20.

Diet information

Food frequency questionnaires were collected using Diet History Questionnaire II [58]. Diet composition was processed using the Diet*Calc software and the dhq2.database.092914 database [59]. All reported values are based on USDA nutrition guidelines. Reported dietary levels were both normalized per 1000 kcal and unnormalized.

Behavioral assessment

A behavioral questionnaire to assess sexual preference and risk behaviors within the past year was administered to study participants either at the time of fecal sample collection or retroactively. Data on sexual preference was used to assess MSM status in all individuals, but data on practices such as frequency of RAI were only used for individuals who filled out the questionnaire within a year of fecal sample collection.

Immunologic assays

Whole blood was collected in BD Vacutainer tubes containing EDTA. Fifty microliters of blood was surface stained for CD4 counts with anti-CD3, anti-CD4, anti-CD45 (BD Biosciences Tri-Test), and CD8 counts with anti-CD3, anti-CD8, and anti-CD45 (BD Biosciences Tritest). Red blood cells (RBCs) were lysed with FACS Lysis Solution (BD) and fixed with 1% formaldehyde. Fifty microliters of blood was surface stained for CD38 and HLA-DR counts on CD4 and CD8 cells using anti-CD4/CD8, anti-CD38, anti-CD3, and anti-HLA-DR (BD Biosciences Multitest). RBCs were lysed (BD) and fixed with 1% formaldehyde. Analysis was performed on a BD FACSCALIBUR using Multiset software.

Statistical analysis

Non-parametric statistical tests were performed in the R software package (v 3.3.2; http://www.r-project.org). All correlations were performed using Spearman correlation. Analysis of variance was calculated using Kruskal-Wallis test. Paired longitudinal analysis was calculated using Wilcoxon signed-rank test. p values less than 0.05 were considered significant. The Benjamini-Hochberg procedure was used to correct for multiple tests, when applicable, (FDR p): FDR p values less than 0.1 were considered significant. The R package, vegan, was used to perform the Adonis test at 10,000 permutations [60].

Abbreviations

ART

Antiretroviral therapy

FTM

Female to male

HIV

Human immunodeficiency virus

MSM

Men who have sex with men

MSW

Men who have sex with women

OTU

Operational taxonomic unit

PBMC

Peripheral blood mononuclear cell

PCoA

Principal coordinates analysis

PD

Phylogenetic diversity

RAI

Receptive anal intercourse

Authors’ contributions

AJSA analyzed and interpreted all data. AJSA and CAL wrote the manuscript. CG and SF recruited the subjects and collected the samples. NMN prepared and ran the sequencing. AJSA and MS wrote computational resources. CPN and JMS performed the immune assays. AF, TC, BEP, and CAL procured the funding. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.

Ethics approval and consent to participate

Informed consent was obtained from each subject, and the study protocol was approved by the Colorado Multiple Institution Review Board (CoMIRB 09-0898 13-2986 14-1595, 15-1692).

Consent for publication

Not applicable

Competing interests

The authors declare that they have no competing interests.

Publisher’s Note

Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.