The adiposity rebound in the 21st century children: meaning for what?

Abstract

With the increase in the prevalence of overweight and obesity worldwide, early adiposity rebound, which is known to have a strong association with obesity, has recently been a focus of research. Early adiposity rebound is conventionally known to have a close relationship with non-communicable diseases. However, novel insights into early adiposity rebound have implied an acceleration of growth and puberty, which is directly reflected in the trends in the timing of adiposity rebound, in the 21st century compared with in the past. Furthermore, the observation that lean mass changes rather than fat mass changes show a more similar pattern to body mass index trajectories is interesting. In this article, the later outcomes and risk factors of early adiposity rebound are briefly summarized, and the current trends in the timing of adiposity rebound and novel insights into its relationship with body composition are reviewed.

Introduction

During the developmental period, body mass index (BMI), which is used as an index of obesity, shows an interesting growth trajectory. In general, BMI rapidly increases during the first year of life, then subsequently decreases and reaches a nadir at around 6 years of age. Thereafter, BMI increases again throughout childhood, and this second rise is referred to as the adiposity rebound. Adiposity rebound was first reported in 1984 by Rolland-Cachera et al. [1] They found a relationship between the age at adiposity rebound and final adiposity (at age 16 years), and showed that an early rebound (before age 5.5 years) is followed by a higher adiposity level than a later rebound (after age 7 years) [1]. Since then, numerous studies have suggested early adiposity rebound as a predictive marker of obesity in later childhood, adolescence, and adulthood [2-9].

In 2010, approximately 6.7% of preschool-aged children worldwide were overweight or obese, and this prevalence is predicted to increase to 9.1% by 2020 [10]. According to the Korean National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey VII performed in 2016, 8.6% and 9.6% of children and adolescents aged 2-18 years were overweight and obese, respectively [11]. In line with these findings, the timing of adiposity rebound is expected to be different in the 21st century compared with that in the past. In this article, the trends and novel insights in the timing of adiposity rebound with conventional concepts are reviewed.

Determination of adiposity rebound

The exact timing of adiposity rebound is difficult to judge. The most traditional and best method is to trace an individual’s adiposity plot through visual inspection [1,12]. However, most previous studies were population studies or cross-sectional surveys, and only a few of them measured data with sufficient frequency to allow identifying the age of adiposity rebound. Moreover, owing to the small body size of children, even minimal errors in weight or height measurement may considerably influence the determination of BMI. To compensate for these practical weaknesses, various statistical approaches have been proposed [5,6,8,12,13].

In addition, depending on the characteristics of subjects, follow-up durations, and measurement intervals, some studies defined the timing of adiposity rebound as the age at which the lowest BMI occurred before the second BMI rise [5] or at which a specific BMI increase occurred during the period of adiposity rebound [14,15]. Apart from BMI, another study considered the timing of adiposity rebound based on weight and height separately, which implies the velocity rather than the nadir of BMI [16].

Later outcomes in children with early adiposity rebound

1. Childhood and adult obesity

Although there are many confounding factors, the close relationship between the timing of adiposity rebound and later obesity is well known [16]. The critical and sensitive periods in childhood for the development of obesity were reported to be gestation and early infancy, the period of adiposity rebound, and adolescence [17]. During the period of adiposity rebound, high BMI (overweight and obesity) at age 5 years [7,16,18-20] or 7 years of age [9] has been proposed to have a significant relationship with adult obesity. Some studies concluded that the timing of adiposity rebound could account for about 30% of adult obesity that begins in childhood [8,12,21].

2. Non-communicable diseases

There have been studies on the relationships between early adiposity rebound and non-communicable diseases such as insulin resistance/type 2 diabetes mellitus [22-24] and cardiovascular disease [5,24], not only in adulthood but also in adolescence or even earlier. Mo-Suwan et al. [23] showed a significant correlation between early adiposity rebound at 3–6 years of age and homeostasis model assessment of insulin resistance values at 8.5 years of age. Koyama et al. [5] found that early adiposity rebound is associated with higher triglyceride levels, atherogenic index, apolipoprotein B, and blood pressure, and lower high-density lipoprotein cholesterol levels at 12 years of age.

Risk factors for adiposity rebound

Many risk factors related to early adiposity rebound have been studied; however, for some of them, the evidence is not yet conclusive.

1. Parental obesity

Maternal obesity and paternal obesity were both identified as factors that accelerate the BMI growth trajectory of a child [15,16]; however, maternal weight seems to be the strongest and most consistent factor related to early adiposity rebound in many previous studies [25-28]. According to data from the Generation 1 study in Australia, maternal obesity in early pregnancy showed an odds ratio of 3.7 for early adiposity rebound compared with average adiposity rebound [26]. Toschke et al. [27] found that maternal BMI was associated with both a positive shifting and skewing in the BMI distribution. Genetic predisposition and sharing environment and habits may influence the adiposity of the child.

2. Small for gestational age at birth

A small size at birth per se is well known to be associated with early adiposity rebound, obesity, and metabolic syndrome [29,30], especially in children with early catch-up growth [31]. Maeyama et al. [14] reported an early age for adiposity rebound often before age 3 years. However, catch-up growth depends not only on birth weight but also on gestational age. The rate of catch-up growth, timing of adiposity rebound, and BMI trajectory during the first 3 years were reported to be dependent on gestational age at birth, which occurred at a boundary of 37 weeks gestational age [14].

3. Breastfeeding

To date, breastfeeding is the only factor known to have a protective effect against childhood obesity and early adiposity rebound. The mechanism of this protective effect was assumed to involve reducing the plasma insulin level, thereby decreasing fat storage and preventing the development of excessive early adiposity [32]. In other words, breastfeeding protects children from insulin resistance [23,33,34]. A meta-analysis of studies on long-term health outcomes found that breastfeeding was associated with a lower risk of type 2 diabetes, with an odds ratio of 0.65 [35].

4. Other concerns

Maternal smoking during the pregnancy [15,16], socio-economic status of the family [16], screen time [36], and early protein intake [37,38] have been suggested to be related to the timing of adiposity rebound; however, there are discrepancies in findings. Higher protein intake may stimulate the secretion of insulin and insulin-like growth factor-1, both of which accelerate growth and increase the fat mass (FM) [39].

Adiposity rebound in 21st century children

1. Adiposity curve in Korean children based on the national reference

A BMI curve was plotted using data from the 2017 Korean National Growth Chart (Fig. 1) [40]. As the 2017 Korean Growth Standard adopted the World Health Organization Child Growth Standards for children aged 0–35 months, there is a transition point at 36 months of age. At 24 months of age, there is another transition point from length-based BMI to height-based BMI. The timing of adiposity rebound was determined when all consecutive BMI values (interval of 1 month) showed an increase after the nadir exceeding 0.1 kg/m² [41].

Fig. 1.

Body mass index trajectories from birth to 18 years in Korean boys (A) and girls (B). The 1st, 3rd, 5th, 15th, 25th, 50th, 75th, 85th, 95th, 97th, and 99th percentile curves are shown in consecutive order. P, percentile.

In boys, BMI showed an infantile peak around 6–7 months of age regardless of the BMI percentile. Then, BMI decreased to the nadir value. In the 5th percentile of the BMI curve, the minimum BMI was 13.9 kg/m² and adiposity rebound occurred at age 77 months (6.5 years). In the 50th percentile of the BMI curve, the minimum BMI was 15.9 kg/m² and adiposity rebound occurred at age 66 months (5.5 years). In the 95th percentile of the BMI curve, the minimum BMI was 17.6 kg/m² and adiposity rebound occurred at age of 38 months (3.2 years).

In girls, BMI showed an infantile peak around 6–7 months of age regardless of the BMI percentile. Then, BMI decreased to the nadir value. In the 5th percentile of the BMI curve, the minimum BMI was 13.7 kg/m² and adiposity rebound occurred at age 89 months (7.4 years). In the 50th percentile of the BMI curve, the minimum BMI was 15.7 kg/m² and adiposity rebound occurred at age 66 months (5.5 years). In the 95th percentile of the BMI curve, the minimum BMI was 17.4 kg/m² and adiposity rebound occurred at age 37 months (3.1 years). The subsequent increase in BMI was more pronounced in the higher percentiles in both sexes, which was in accordance with the German Health Interview and Examination Survey for Children and Adolescents data [42].

2. Trends of adiposity rebound in 21st century children

Globally, there has been a time shift in the BMI distribution and adiposity rebound timing. In Scotland, there has been a substantial shift of BMI distribution in the general population of a birth cohort born in 2004 compared with those born in 1990 [43]. A longitudinal study in Japan showed that the mean age of having minimal BMI was 4.8 years in boys and 4.7 years in girls born between 1995 and 1996 [5]. In the Czech Republic, compared with that in 1951, the time of adiposity rebound has gradually shifted to earlier ages in both boys and girls (Table 1) [44]. Additionally, it has been suggested that the BMI velocity after adiposity rebound also changed over time. In the most recent cohort, boys and girls had greater maximum BMI velocities and adolescent BMI values than their counterparts in previous cohorts, although the BMI values at the age of adiposity rebound did not significantly differ [45].

Table 1.

Trends in the timing of adiposity rebound in 21st century children

Country	BMI	Boys		Girls		Reference
Czech Republic	Year of the survey	2001	1995	2001	1951	[44]
	BMI 10P	5.3 yr	6.4 yr	5.6 yr	6.5 yr
	BMI 50P	4.9 yr	6.2 yr	5.2 yr	6.4 yr
	BMI 90P	4.2 yr	6.0 yr	4.1 yr	5.8 yr
Poland	Year of the survey	2010	1983	2010	1983	[57, 58]
	BMI 15P	6.4 yr	7.7 yr	5.3 yr	7.4 yr
	BMI 50P	5.2 yr	7.5 yr	3.0 yr	7.4 yr
	BMI 85P	<3.0 yr	6.6 yr	<3.0 yr	7.3 yr
Germany	Year of the survey	2003–2006		2003–2006		[42]
	BMI 10P	6.5 yr		6.5 yr
	BMI 50P	5.5 yr		5.5 yr
	BMI 90P	4.5 yr		4.5 yr
United States	Year of the survey	1999–2008		1999–2008		[59]
	BMI mean, White	5.5 yr		5.0 yr
	BMI mean, African American	4.8 yr		4.9 yr
	BMI mean, Hispanic	4.8 yr		5.1 yr
	BMI mean, Asian	5.1 yr		5.5 yr

BMI, body mass index; P, percentile.

The timing of adiposity rebound has shifted not only among overweight and obese children, but also among children at the 10th percentile of BMI for age. Therefore, beyond the predictive role of later obesity, the secular trend of increased height, accelerated growth, and earlier maturation compared with that in the past may imply the timing of adiposity rebound [44]. Moreover, environmental factors such as low levels of physical activity, frequent television watching, and inappropriate feeding practices have been reported to be responsible for early increase in BMI in some children [46].

Novel insights into adiposity rebound in relation to body composition

Because BMI reflects both FM and lean mass (LM), to confirm that the renewed increase of BMI is the true increase of adiposity, changes in body composition were studied. A small Dunedin study in girls that used dual-energy X-ray absorptiometry showed that early adiposity rebound was associated with increases in FM rather than LM, as expected [47]. However, several studies suggested that the direction of change in BMI and the LM index during the period of adiposity rebound was identical [48], whereas an increase in the FM index lagged behind 2-3 years, particularly for boys [48,49]. On the basis of the evidence on changes in body composition, adiposity rebound coincided with a cessation of FM decline and an increase in LM [48,50]. Therefore, the timing of adiposity rebound was the indicator of individual development rather than increased body fat [48], and a more accurate term for adiposity rebound would be “BMI rebound.” [28] In line with this, being tall at age 3 years, rather than having a high BMI at age 3 years, was shown to be associated with an earlier rebound [51].

Williams and Goulding [16] found different rates of physical development between the early, average, and late rebound groups, with the late-rebound group reaching maturity later. Several other studies have also noted that a more rapid linear growth in infancy or tallness in early childhood is associated with early pubertal maturation or later obesity [52-54]. German et al. [55] studied the onset and tempo of puberty in relation to adiposity rebound, and showed that the early AR group had earlier pubarche and menarche in girls and a more rapid progression of puberty in boys than the later adiposity rebound group. Therefore, early adiposity rebound indicates faster growth, more advanced development, and earlier puberty. In this context, the finding that the shifting trends in adiposity rebound reflect the acceleration of growth in the 21st century is not surprising.

Conclusions

Although the timing of adiposity rebound has complex meanings, an important point is that BMI rebound has a impact on adverse health outcomes. Therefore, targeting modifiable factors in very early life to delay the timing of adiposity rebound is important. Nowadays, 63.3% of 0- to 1-year-old children and 90.6% of 1- to 5-year-old children spend time in some form of childcare center based on a childcare survey in 2013 by the Korea Institute of Child Care and Education [56]. Therefore, childcare settings should be involved in intervention efforts to prevent obesity. Additionally, health check-up programs for infants and children should be emphasized to screen for those at a high risk for early adiposity rebound.