Skip to main content
. 2019 Feb 26;7:e6522. doi: 10.7717/peerj.6522

Table 2. The stability of the expression of seven candidate reference genes in six groups as analysed by geNorm, NormFinder, BestKeeper.

Group Rank geNorm NormFinder BestKeeper
Gene Stability Gene Stability Gene SD CV
Abiotic Cotyledons 1 FtCACS 0.33 FtH3 0.058 FtSAND 0.33 1.32
2 FtH3 0.33 FtCACS 0.080 FtCACS 0.31 1.47
3 FtSAND 0.41 FtSAND 0.129 FtH3 0.33 1.64
4 FtExpressed1 0.54 FtExpressed1 0.280 FtExpressed1 0.59 2.48
5 FtEF-1α 0.73 FtEF-1α 0.683 FtEF-1α 1.04 5.70
6 FtGAPDH 0.84 FtGAPDH 0.751 FtGAPDH 1.07 6.26
7 FtActin 1.31 FtActin 1.678 FtActin 1.46 6.36
Abiotic Hypocotyls 1 FtH3 0.65 FtSAND 0.416 FtH3 0.51 2.47
2 FtSAND 0.65 FtCACS 0.437 FtSAND 0.69 2.68
3 FtCACS 0.72 FtH3 0.449 FtActin 0.79 3.38
4 FtExpressed1 0.84 FtEF-1α 0.469 FtExpressed1 0.81 3.34
5 FtEF-1α 0.91 FtExpressed1 0.475 FtCACS 0.86 3.75
6 FtGAPDH 1.05 FtGAPDH 0.811 FtEF-1α 0.92 5.32
7 FtActin 1.17 FtActin 0.895 FtGAPDH 1.35 7.59
Abiotic total 1 FtH3 0.55 FtCACS 0.304 FtH3 0.52 2.55
2 FtSAND 0.55 FtSAND 0.327 FtCACS 0.61 2.70
3 FtCACS 0.61 FtH3 0.349 FtSAND 0.63 2.46
4 FtExpressed1 0.72 FtExpressed1 0.380 FtExpressed1 0.73 3.02
5 FtEF-1α 0.89 FtEF-1α 0.694 FtEF-1α 1.02 5.71
6 FtGAPDH 1.01 FtGAPDH 0.782 FtActin 1.17 5.07
7 FtActin 1.30 FtActin 1.329 FtGAPDH 1.20 6.89
Al treatment 1 FtEF-1α 0.16 FtSAND 0.091 FtExpressed1 0.17 0.73
2 FtExpressed1 0.16 FtExpressed1 0.100 FtEF-1α 0.25 1.55
3 FtSAND 0.21 FtH3 0.105 FtH3 0.31 1.56
4 FtGAPDH 0.23 FtEF-1α 0.106 FtGAPDH 0.34 1.88
5 FtH3 0.27 FtGAPDH 0.156 FtCACS 0.35 1.57
6 FtCACS 0.30 FtCACS 0.282 FtSAND 0.37 1.43
7 FtActin 0.49 FtActin 0.652 FtActin 1.05 4.16
Immature seed stage 1 FtExpressed1 0.16 FtSAND 0.097 FtExpressed1 0.50 2.00
2 FtCACS 0.16 FtGAPDH 0.097 FtCACS 0.57 2.43
3 FtSAND 0.30 FtH3 0.167 FtSAND 0.82 3.03
4 FtGAPDH 0.36 FtCACS 0.292 FtEF-1α 0.83 4.32
5 FtH3 0.45 FtExpressed1 0.422 FtGAPDH 0.86 4.51
6 FtEF-1α 0.62 FtEF-1α 0.675 FtH3 1.11 5.29
7 FtActin 1.01 FtActin 1.354 FtActin 2.16 9.96
Total 1 FtH3 0.60 FtCACS 0.245 FtCACS 0.53 2.33
2 FtCACS 0.60 FtSAND 0.304 FtH3 0.54 2.69
3 FtSAND 0.66 FtH3 0.313 FtSAND 0.57 2.24
4 FtExpressed1 0.71 FtExpressed1 0.377 FtExpressed1 0.68 2.85
5 FtGAPDH 0.87 FtGAPDH 0.650 FtGAPDH 0.97 5.53
6 FtEF-1α 0.97 FtEF-1α 0.780 FtEF-1α 1.03 5.91
7 FtActin 1.33 FtActin 1.480 FtActin 1.36 5.70