Potential Sustainable Slow-Release Fertilizers Obtained by Mechanochemical Activation of MgAl and MgFe Layered Double Hydroxides and K₂HPO₄

Abstract

This study describes the behavior of potential slow-release fertilizers (SRF), prepared by the mechanochemical activation of calcined Mg₂Al-CO₃ or Mg₂Fe-CO₃ layered double hydroxides (LDH) mixed with dipotassium hydrogen phosphate (K₂HPO₄). The effects of LDH thermal treatment on P/K release behavior were investigated. Characterizations of the inorganic composites before and after release experiments combined X-Ray diffraction (XRD), Fourier-transform infra-red spectroscopy (FTIR), solid-state nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR), scanning electron microscopy (SEM) and energy-dispersive X-ray spectroscopy (EDX). The best release profile (<75% in 28 days and at least 75% release) was obtained for MgAl/K₂HPO₄ (9 h milling, 2:1 molar ratio, MR). Compared to readily used K₂HPO₄, milling orthophosphate into LDH matrices decreases its solubility and slows down its release, with 60% and 5.4% release after 168 h for MgAl/K₂HPO₄ and MgFe/K₂HPO₄ composites, respectively. Mechanochemical addition of carboxymethylcellulose to the LDH/K₂HPO₄ composites leads to a noticeable improvement of P release properties.

1. Introduction

Concerning plant nutrition, new products or methods to improve nutrient management have become more and more important for environmental resilience. Most inorganic fertilizers currently used in agriculture have high solubility or volatility and need to be spread over fields in excessive amounts to ensure optimal efficiency of food production. Consequently, nutrient accumulation can pollute water resources through the eutrophication of surface water reservoirs. In this scenario, economic losses are generated by these non-sustainable nutrient supplies.

Based on these issues and considering that food production is an essential activity for human life, the development of sustainable agricultural practices based on new agrochemicals is of great importance. Slow-release fertilizers (SRF) and controlled-released fertilizers (CRF) are promising chemicals formulated to deliver nutrients (e.g., N, P, K, oligoelements) under kinetically controlled conditions. They provide a nutrient supply during the desired periods of germination and plant growth, and limit losses. Such properties are of great interest from a societal and economic point of view [1]. Different strategies to produce sustainable NPK SRF are reported in the literature. Nutrients have been incorporated in various matrices either by coating [2,3], by encapsulation in polymeric matrices [4] or in emulsions [5,6], or by intercalation into layered structures [7,8]. Recently, the mechanochemical activation method [9] has been described as an efficient way to produce SRF. Clay minerals and soluble potassium phosphate salts were mixed using mechanochemical treatments and the resulting composites displayed interesting K/P release properties [10,11]. Clay minerals, natural soil components, possess a great variety of chemical compositions and layered structures reactive for the incorporation of nutrients, providing huge options for obtaining different SRF. Recent studies report on the mechanochemical treatment of kaolinite [9,10] talc, montmorillonite [12] or even chrysotile [13] conjointly with phosphate salts to produce crystalline and/or amorphous phases displaying slow release properties of interest. It is noteworthy that insoluble phosphate fractions can prevent a total P release.

In order to prepare SRF with release performances of interest, we extended this strategy to layered double hydroxides (LDH), another family of inorganic matrices. LDH are synthetic clay minerals with anion exchange properties. The LDH structure occurs naturally as hydrotalcite mineral, and the ideal generic formula, is described as [M²⁺_1−xM³⁺_x(OH)₂]^x+(Aⁿ⁻)_x/n.yH₂O, where M^II and M^III correspond to metal cations, and Aⁿ⁻ represents anions. [14,15] LDH is built of M(OH)₆ octahedra in a brucite-like structure, where the M^II to M^III isomorphic provides residual positive charge that is stabilized by anionic species, e.g., PO₄⁻³, CO₃⁻², NO₃⁻ located in the interlayer space. There are many methods for synthesizing LDH; e.g., coprecipitation, induced hydrolysis, sol-gel and mechanochemical activation of insoluble precursors [16,17].

On one hand, the use of LDH has been investigated for environmental remediation and phosphate adsorption [18,19]. For instance, Luengo et al. [20] studied LDH matrices synthesized by the coprecipitation method for phosphate adsorption and the results showed these to be promising environmentally friendly materials for use in aquatic systems. On the other hand, it was reported that it is possible to take advantage of the LDH anionic exchange properties to develop SRF [7,21,22,23,24]. For instance, Everaert et al. [23] reported that hydrogenophosphate intercalated MgAl was up to 4.5 times more efficient than a soluble phosphate-based fertilizer for use in acidic soils. Hatami et al. [24] also reported some important assays on adsorption and desorption of phosphate using ZnAl LDH matrix, in simulated soil solution. The results provided evidence of a partial reversible release of phosphate with a percentage of desorption lower than 35% in 0.03 mol L⁻¹ KNO₃ solution after 8 h.

In this work, SRF were prepared by mechanochemical reaction of various mixtures of calcined LDH and K₂HPO₄. Mg₂Al(OH)₆(CO₃)_0.5.3H₂O and Mg₂Fe(OH)₆(CO₃)_0.5.2.5H₂O LDH and K₂HPO₄ were used as sources of Mg²⁺ and K⁺ and phosphate, respectively. Our goal was to react the LDH structure with K₂HPO₄ by ball milling in order to obtain K-Mg-Fe-PO₄ phases with a large panel of solubility allowing a controlled release over a long period of time. Such an approach could allow a large amount of P to be immobilized per amount of LDH. One can theoretically calculate that for a Mg₂Al LDH/ K₂HPO₄ molar ratio of 1:1, a milled material with 14.6% of P should typically be obtained, compared to 5.6% of P in the case of a hybrogenophosphate intercalated Mg₂Al matrix. The influence of MgAl and MgFe LDH thermal treatments on the release behavior of the different products was studied using kinetic and thermodynamic studies. The effect of the addition of a biopolymer, the carboxymethylcellulose (CMC), during the mechanochemical process on the release profile was also investigated.

2. Materials and Methods

2.1. Preparation of Slow-Release Fertilizers

Mg₂Al(OH)₆(CO₃)_0.5.3H₂O (MgAl) and Mg₂Fe(OH)₆(CO₃)_0.5.2.5H₂O (MgFe) LDH were synthesized by the coprecipitation method as reported in the literature [14]. Briefly, aqueous solutions of Mg²⁺ (0.66 mol L⁻¹) and M³⁺ (Al³⁺, Fe³⁺) (0.33 mol L⁻¹) nitrate salts, with a Mg²⁺:M³⁺ molar ratio equal to 2:1, and mixed Na₂CO₃ (0.50 mol L⁻¹)/NaOH (2.00 mol L⁻¹) solution were simultaneously added at a constant rate (5 mL/h) into an aqueous solution whose pH was automatically maintained at 10.5. After the addition was completed, the precipitates were collected after repeated cycles of centrifugation and washing. Samples were then dried at room temperature. The as-prepared LDH were calcined at different temperatures (200 °C, 300 °C, 400 °C and 500 °C) for 4 h in air.

2.2. Mechanochemical Treatment

A planetary ball mill, PM 200 model from Retsch equipped with a 50 mL agate jar and ten agate balls of 10 mm was used for this study (rate 450 rpm). The mechanochemical treatment was investigated in three steps. Firstly, the calcined LDH materials were milled with K₂HPO₄ with a LDH/ K₂HPO₄ molar ratio (MR) equal to 1:2 for 9 h to study the effect of the thermal treatment on the performances of SRF. Secondly, systematic mechanochemical treatments were performed on LDH and K₂HPO₄ mixtures with different molar ratios (MR) of LDH/ K₂HPO₄ (1:2, 1:1, 2:1) and different milling times (3, 6, and 9 h) according to the experimental plan (2²), with the central point in triplicate. The results showed that the MgAl₂₀₀/K₂HPO₄ system gave the best results for the 1:2 molar ratio, while for the MgFe₂₀₀/K₂HPO₄ system, the best release was obtained for a 2:1 molar ratio (results not shown).

From the sets of milling and K/P release experiments, LDH/K₂HPO₄ selected materials were submitted to subsequent ball milling incorporation of carboxymethylcellulose (CMC). The CMC was incorporated at a weight content of 20% of the total mass of the solid. The addition was performed following three different protocols (Table 1). The first involved the addition of CMC with a previously milled LDH/K₂HPO₄ composite, followed by a final grinding of 3 h. The second method involved the ball-milling of CMC and LDH/ K₂HPO₄ both previously ground for 3 h and 9 h, respectively. Finally, the latter method involved one-step milling of CMC/LDH/K₂HPO₄ mixtures for 9 h.

Table 1.

Description of the three methods used to incorporate carboxymethylcellulose (CMC) into the systems’ layered double hydroxides (LDH) matrices calcined at 200 °C.

System	Method	Time of Milling (h)	LDH/K2HPO4/CMC Weight Ratio
MgAl/K2HPO4/CMC	Method 1	3	1.00:1.65:0.53
	Method 2	3	1.00:1.65:0.53
	Method 3	9	1.00:1.65:0.53
MgFe/K2HPO4/CMC	Method 1	3	1.00:0.82:0.40
	Method 2	3	1.00:0.82:0.40
	Method 3	9	1.00:0.82:0.40

2.3. Release Experiments

The release experiments were performed under isothermal conditions at 10 °C, 25 °C and 50 °C by adding 25 mg of SRF into 10 mL of deionized water, simulating flooded crops, i.e., with a higher release rate than when applied to the soil. At different times, ranging from 1 h to 31 days, solids were separated and concentrations of released P and K in supernatants were analyzed by ICP-AES. Solids and solutions obtained after 1 h and 168 h were used for further detailed experimental investigations.

2.4. Characterization Techniques

Powder X-ray diffraction (PXRD) data were obtained using a Panalytical X’pert diffractometer with a CuKα radiation (λ = 1.54155 Å). Fourier-transform infrared spectroscopy (FTIR) measurements were carried out on solid products using a Thermo Nicolet 5700 spectrometer, employing KBr tablets at a mass ratio of 1:100 (sample:KBr) with a resolution of 4 cm⁻¹ and accumulation of 64 scans. The solid-state ²⁷Al, ³¹P and ²⁹Si NMR spectra were acquired using a Bruker AVANCE 300 spectrometer operating at 7.05 Tesla, equipped with a 4 mm zirconia multinuclear solids probe and magic angle spinning at 12 kHz. Thermagravimetric analysis (TGA) curves and differential thermal analysis (DTA), used to calculate the water content in the LDH precursors, were obtained with a TG-DTA SETSYS Evolution analyzer from SETARAM, using 150 μL alumina crucibles and a heating rate of 5 °C min⁻¹ under air flow of 50 mL min⁻¹.

The scanning electron microscopic (SEM) images were obtained using a Cambridge Scan 360 SEM operating at 1 kV and a Zeiss supra 55 FEG-VP operating at 3 keV. The samples were mounted on conductive carbon adhesive tabs for imaging.

3. Results

3.1. Influence of LDH Thermal Treatment on Milled Compounds and Their Release Properties

Powder X-ray diffraction (PXRD) patterns of pristine MgAl and MgFe LDH materials (Figure 1) confirmed the preparation of pure carbonate LDH phases crystallizing with the expected hexagonal structure (R-3m symmetry) and typical interlayer distances of 0.76 nm and 0.78 nm for MgAl-CO₃ and MgFe-CO_3, respectively, consistent with the literature [25]. The presence of carbonate anions was further confirmed on the FTIR spectra by the presence of the intense band (ν₃) at 1354 cm⁻¹ (Figure S1). The first attempts to prepare SRF by ball milling K₂HPO₄ with as-prepared LDH were unsuccessful. The high hydration states of MgAl and MgFe LDH prevents any incorporation or reaction between LDH and phosphate salts and limits the efficiency of the milling process for SRF preparation. Consequently, LDH were dehydrated before the milling step. Thermal treatments were performed in the temperature range of LDH dehydration and dehydroxylation (200 °C–500 °C). As already reported in the literature [15], MgAl-CO₃ LDH can undergo reversible calcination/rehydration processes when the conditions of calcination do not exceed MgO and MgAl₂O₄ crystallization (T < 500 °C). Interestingly, when rehydration of the amorphous phases is conducted with solutions containing anions, the LDH structure intercalated by these specific anions is then reconstructed [26]. The PXRD of calcined LDH are displayed in Figure 1A,B. MgAl and MgFe LDH structures were partially maintained after calcination at 200 °C despite a net decrease in the diffraction line intensity. At 300 °C, the diffraction lines characteristic of the LDH disappeared due to total structure collapse. For both MgAl and MgFe matrices, calcinations over 300 °C led to the formation of amorphous mixed oxides that retained a layered structuration, the so-called layered double oxides (LDO). Diffraction lines pointed at 35.4°, 43.4° and 63.0° (2θ) correspond to amorphous MgO. These structural changes were further confirmed by FTIR analysis (Figure S1). The progressive loss of the CO₃²⁻ stretching bands (ν₃ cm⁻¹; ν₁ cm⁻¹) and of the MO-H (ν cm⁻¹) and M-(OH)₆/OMO (ν cm⁻¹) lattice vibrations of the LDH structures, and the occurrence of MO₆ lattice bands at low energy, account for dehydroxylation/decarbonatation processes and these thermally-induced structural transformations.

Figure 1.

PXRD data of (A): MgAl (a), MgAl calcined at: 200 °C (b), at 300 °C (c), at 400 °C (d) and at 500 °C (e); and (B): MgFe (a), MgFe calcined at: 200 °C (b), at 300 °C (c), at 400 °C (d), and at 500 °C (e).

Then the various calcined LDH were tested for their reactivity with K₂HPO₄ and the effect of milling treatment was evaluated using PXRD analysis in order to relate structural changes to release behaviors (Figure 2). When pure K₂HPO₄ was submitted to a similar grinding treatment, no structural transformation was observed. After milling LDH/K₂HPO₄ mixtures, X-ray patterns of pristine solids disappeared, and all residual solid composites resulted in an amorphous phase. The diffraction feature of K₂HPO₄ was no longer visible; the grinding made it totally react with calcined LDH, leading to unidentified structures. For composites ground using MgAl and MgFe LDH calcined at low temperatures (200 °C, 300 °C), a new phase emerged associated with diffraction lines of low intensity corresponding to the struvite-K phase (KMgPO₄.6H₂O) (ICDD 75-1076) [27] (Table S1). Additive structural information was obtained from FTIR analysis of MgAl-based compounds (Figure S2) whose spectra displayed features of well-identified vibrations. In the intermediate energy region (1000 cm⁻¹–1600 cm⁻¹), ν₃ (antisymmetric stretch. of HPO₄²⁻ and PO₄³⁻), ν₁ (antisymmetric stretch. HPO₄²⁻ and PO) and ν₄ (OPO bending) stretching bands of phosphate anions were clearly observed at 1045–1064, 980−983, and 532–540 cm⁻¹ respectively, with values depending on the calcined LDH precursors. The vibration bands progressively shifted to those of pure K₂HPO₄. The higher the calcination temperature, the closer the bands were to K₂HPO₄, indicating greater reactivity of the MgAl LDH calcined at lower temperature (200 °C).

Figure 2.

PXRD data of milled samples (9 h, 450 rpm) (A): MgAl₂₀₀/K₂HPO₄ (a), MgAl₃₀₀/K₂HPO₄ (b), MgAl₄₀₀/K₂HPO₄ (c), MgAl₅₀₀/K₂HPO₄ (d), K₂HPO₄ (e); and (B): MgFe₂₀₀/K₂HPO₄ (a), MgFe₃₀₀/K₂HPO₄ (b), MgFe₄₀₀/K₂HPO₄ (c), MgFe₅₀₀/K₂HPO₄ (d), K₂HPO₄ (e) with LDH/K₂HPO₄ MR 1:2.

A preliminary study of phosphate release was performed for two release times, 1 h and 168 h (Figure 3). It is important to bear in mind that LDH have low solubility (K_SO (Mg₂Al(OH)₆(CO₃).3H₂O) = 25.43 [28] while K₂HPO₄ is totally soluble for the concentrations used in this study. First of all, it must be noted that phosphate was never fully released at the end of the experiments. Release after 1 h increased linearly with calcination temperature. Indeed, from 200 °C to 500 °C, release was improved by 39.01% and 36.80% for MgAl and MgFe, respectively. The amount of P recovery was about 8% (mean value) higher for MgAl/K₂HPO₄ than for MgFe/K₂HPO₄. After 168 h (7 days) of contact time, release did not increase compared to the earlier stage except for MgAl₂₀₀/K₂HPO₄ and MgAl₃₀₀/K₂HPO₄ (+19.0% and +11.74%, respectively). Unexpectedly, we even observed a decrease of phosphate leaching for MgAl₅₀₀/K₂HPO₄ (−6.2%) and MgFe/K₂HPO₄ (−1.2%, −6.3%, −8.2%, and −11.8% for T: 200 °C, 300 °C, 400 °C, and 500 °C, respectively). A dissolution/precipitation process probably explains such results. In conclusion, most of the release was obtained in 1 h, similar to other potential CRF such as MgAl-PO₄ LDH [7], or milled hydroxyapatite/ammonium sulfate [29]. However, the rate of P release should slow down in soils were water concentration and water diffusion, and PO₄ mobility are reduced. Interestingly, a reserve of less soluble PO₄ was formed either during milling or in solution, during the release experiment, allowing a longer PO₄ release under acidic soil conditions. The remaining insoluble phosphate phases were formed either during milling or in solution, during the release experiment. According to this 2-data point kinetic study, MgAl₂₀₀/K₂HPO₄ provides the best release profile, with the highest release content after 168 h and the highest release gradient from 1 h to 168 h (+19.1%). Therefore, in the following sections we focus on MgAl₂₀₀/K₂HPO₄ (9 h, MR 1:2) and MgFe₂₀₀/K₂HPO₄ (9 h, MR 2:1) for further investigation of SRF behavior.

Figure 3.

Phosphate release essays at 1 hour and 168 hours for MgAl/K₂HPO₄ (A); and MgFe/K₂HPO₄ (B) systems, with LDH calcined at: 200 °C (a), 300 °C (b), 400 °C (c) and 500 °C (d).

SEM (Figure 4) and solid-state NMR (Figure 5) analyses of both MgAl₂₀₀/K₂HPO₄ and MgFe₂₀₀/K₂HPO₄ amorphous solids were realized in order to better understand the structural and textural changes over grinding preparation and release conditions.

Figure 4.

SEM images of MgAl LDH (A); MgFe LDH (B); K₂HPO₄ (C); MgAl₂₀₀ (D); MgFe₂₀₀ (E); MgAl₂₀₀/K₂HPO₄ (F); and MgFe₂₀₀/K₂HPO₄ (G).

Figure 5.

²⁷Al NMR spectra of MgAl (a); and MgAl₂₀₀/K₂HPO₄ (b); and ³¹P NMR spectra of K₂HPO₄ (c); and MgAl₂₀₀/K₂HPO₄ (d).

In analyzing the SEM images, after calcination at 200 °C (Figure 4D,E) the LDH precursor particles appeared to be more aggregated, but the characteristic layered morphology was still evident. Pure K₂HPO₄ (Figure 4C) presented huge molten crystals. After mechanochemical activation, there were considerable changes in the morphologies. The image of MgAl₂₀₀/K₂HPO₄ compound (Figure 4F) presents welded crystals. For the MgFe₂₀₀/K₂HPO₄ image (Figure 4G), the milling step induced a reduction of the particle size while the characteristic feature of the K₂HPO₄ was no longer observed. It is noteworthy that both LDH based systems presented different morphologies after milling compared to the characteristic morphologies of the precursors.

The main ²⁷Al NMR signals (74.4%) of MgAl (Figure 5a) pointed at 8.6 ppm is characteristic of Al^III cations in the octahedral environment, as expected for aluminum-containing hydrotalcite structures [30,31]. The broad but low intense peak (25.6%) centered at −0.4 ppm may be assigned to amorphous aluminum hydroxide Al(OH)₃ as discussed by Gro Nielsen and colleagues [32]. After the milling step between MgAl-calcined and K₂HPO₄, the octahedral ²⁷Al signal (Figure 5b) remained present [33]; however, two additional peaks appeared at δ = 52.3 ppm and δ = 63.5 ppm, typical of tetrahedral Al³⁺ sites (δ = −0.7 ppm). Tetrahedral sites arise from partial migration of Oh Al³⁺ out of the MgAl LDH layers during calcination. This evidence suggests that the mechanical activation of the MgAl₂₀₀/K₂HPO₄ mixture strongly affected these two structures, leading to a diffusion of the Al³⁺ cation from Oh to Td sites. Moreover, the proportion of the amorphous Al phase increases under milling, from 25% to 87%.

The ³¹P NMR spectra of anhydrous K₂HPO₄ (Figure 5c) was characterized by four sharp signals located at δ = 6.0; 2.6; −0.7 and −5.2 ppm [34]. After the mechanochemical reaction between calcined MgAl and K₂HPO₄, the ³¹P NMR signals (Figure 5d) broadened over a large spectral width (δ = −10 to +15 ppm) due to both strong amorphization and a change in the P environment. The main signal of the free orthophosphate (δ = 6.0 ppm) decreased in favor of the high field signal characteristic of bound phosphate (δ = 3.2 ppm and δ = −3.8 ppm). We note the presence of a sharp peak at 6.3 ppm that is clearly assigned, in agreement with PXRD data, to struvite-K [35].

3.2. Detailed Kinetic Study

The complete kinetic release study was performed by monitoring the K and P concentrations released in solution versus time. The experiments were duplicated at three different temperatures (10 °C, 25 °C and 50 °C). Figure 6 displays the P and K released concentrations for the different systems. From these data, the plots were fitted with different kinetic models (the pseudo-first order or Lagergren model, the pseudo-second order, and the intraparticular diffusion models [36,37,38,39] that may account for the diffusion pathways of phosphate and potassium ions from the bulk and the surface of the different inorganic phases. The kinetic constants (k) were calculated from the best reliable models. Comparison of the R-squared (R²) regression fit factors, calculated from the fit of the linearized forms of the kinetic models and agreements between the experimental and calculated concentration values of the desorbed element at the equilibrium time (Table 2 and Table 3) allowed us to assign the best kinetic models. The best fits were obtained for a pseudo-second order kinetic diffusion process ($dq/dt=k\_2 (q_e-q_t)$, where k₂ (g·mg⁻¹·min⁻¹) is the constant rate, q_e (mg/g) is the total amount of molecules desorbed at equilibrium, q (mg/g) is the amount of molecules desorbed at t that accounts for a rate process limited by the rate of diffusion of the ions in the pores of the matrices [12] due to chemical interactions with the host structure. Kinetic values for P and K release of MgAl₂₀₀/K₂HPO₄ experiments set at the three different temperatures are given in Table 2. Both MgAl₂₀₀/K₂HPO₄ and MgFe₂₀₀/K₂HPO₄ systems present results which account for a characteristic slow-release fertilizer, according to other studies in the literature; i.e., a fast release regime at the initial stage that occurs over a period of about 24 h, followed by a slow release that may continue until 744 h (the last experiment data point) and probably beyond.

Figure 6.

P (A,C) and K (B,D) release assays for MgAl₂₀₀/K₂HPO₄ (A,B) and MgFe₂₀₀/K₂HPO₄ (C,D). The symbols correspond to experimental data and the curves show the corresponding fit.

Table 2.

Kinetic data for MgAl₂₀₀/K₂HPO₄ material.

Nutrient	Temperature (°C)	Kinetic Parameters
K		Pseudo-second order
		kII (min−1)	qe (mg g−1)	R 2	Exp. qe (mg g−1)
	10	0.070	1.32	0.997	1.31
	25	0.134	1.46	0.999	1.44
	50	0.519	1.43	0.999	1.44
P	10	0.085	0.722	0.995	0.717
	25	0.342	0.462	0.999	0.453
	50	0.481	0.738	0.999	0.733

Note: q_e = desorbed ion at equilibrium time, k_II and k_d = kinetic constant.

Table 3.

Kinetic data for MgFe₂₀₀/K₂HPO₄ material Table 3.

Nutrient	Temperature (°C)	Kinetic Parameters
K		Pseudo-second order
		kII (min−1)	qe (mg g−1)			R 2	Exp. qe (mg g−1)
	10	0.31	0.447			0.998	0.443
	25	1.06	0.594			0.999	0.592
	50	0.631	0.542			0.999	0.541
P		Intraparticular diffusion
		Kd (mg g−1 min−0.5)		Intercept				R 2
	10	0.001		0.002				0.993
	25	0.003		0.001				0.995
		Pseudo-second order
		kII (min−1)	qe (mg g−1)		R 2		Exp. qe (mg g−1)
	50	1.79	0.0826		0.997		0.0807

Note: q_e = desorbed ion at equilibrium time, k_II and k_d = kinetic constant.

Constant rate values of K and P releases were in the same range of values between 0.0702 min⁻¹ and 0.519 min⁻¹ even though they were not correlated with each other. Obviously, in the MgAl₂₀₀/K₂HPO₄ composite, K⁺ and HPO₄²⁻ are no longer linked in a single phase. Milling forced both ions to react separately with the LDO structure and consequently undergo release with different mechanisms, comprising dissolution and ion exchange reactions. The kinetics are strongly dependent on the temperature of the release medium. Indeed, kinetic constant (k) increased in the 10 °C–50 °C temperature domain from 0.070 min⁻¹ to 0.519 min⁻¹ (7.4×) and from 0.085 min⁻¹ to 0.481 min⁻¹ (×5.7) for K and P, respectively. As expected, dissolution and ion diffusion processes involved in the mechanisms of K and P releases were activated by thermal energy.

For the MgFe₂₀₀/K₂HPO₄ system (Table 4), K release behavior was similar to MgAl₂₀₀/K₂HPO_4. In either case, at temperatures of 50 °C and 25 °C (also at 10 °C for MgAl₂₀₀/K₂HPO₄) 90%–100% of K was released after 744 h; but it can be observed that at 10 °C for MgFe₂₀₀/K₂HPO₄, 75% of K was released after 744 h, indicating that LDO structure from the MgFe LDH structure presented more interaction with K ions. The K release process was faster than for P, probably because each one presented a different chemical interaction with LDO structure, well-fitted by a pseudo-second order model, and controlled by thermal activation. The same mechanism was reported by Borges et al. [12] for SRF prepared by ball milling K₂HPO₄ with montmorillonite and talc. The maximum kinetic rate was obtained at the intermediate temperature of 25 °C (1.06 min⁻¹) suggesting competition between opposite mechanisms.

Table 4.

Percentage release of the elements for CMC/MgAl₂₀₀/K₂HPO₄ and CMC/MgFe₂₀₀/K₂HPO₄ composites.

Release time	CMC/ MgAl200/K2HPO4			CMC/MgFe200/K2HPO4
		P (%)	K (%)	P (%)	K (%)
1 h	Method 1	6.6	16.3	2.4	12.9
	Method 2	8.0	23.0	6.2	25.4
	Method 3	11.1	21.7	5.9	17.1
168 h	Method 1	73.3	100.0	33.4	82.7
	Method 2	62.3	92.6	28.2	80.6
	Method 3	69.5	92.4	32.0	76.4

The release of P by the MgFe₂₀₀/K₂HPO₄ solid was very different from the other kinetic behaviors. First of all, only a small fraction of loaded P was released over the duration of the experiment, with only 10.8%, 25.1% and 32.5% at 10 °C, 25 °C and 50 °C, respectively. At 50 °C, the equilibrium of release was nearly reached, while for lower thermal activations the process was far from completed. Modeling these kinetic plots gave the best results with an intra-particular diffusion mechanism at 10 °C and 25 °C. In such cases, the overall release process is controlled by one or more diffusion steps (surface, pore, grain boundary, external diffusions) and the release constant rate is limited by the overall diffusion rate given by the fit (Table 4). Clearly, phosphate diffusion through MgFe₂₀₀/K₂HPO₄ particles was very slow (k_II < 0.003 min⁻¹ at 25 °C). This slow-down effect arises from the substitution of Al³⁺ by Fe³⁺ in the LDH. The strong reactivity between Fe³⁺ and phosphate leads to the formation of insoluble Fe/ phosphate phases and decreases the mobility of the free phosphate anions inside the fertilizer bulk.

Nearly 100% of K⁺ was released by both materials, MgAl₂₀₀/K₂HPO₄ and MgFe₂₀₀/K₂HPO₄, at T greater than 25 °C, while for a similar study reported for milled Montmorillonite/K₂HPO₄ and talc/K₂HPO₄ [12] K⁺ release did not exceed 70% of the loaded amounts. Indeed, clay structures are known to irreversibly fix K⁺ cations in the hexagonal holes of the structures, while no such sites exist in the LDO structure where K⁺ cations were loosely confined in mesopores.

3.3. Structural and Textural Characterizations of Residues upon Release

To get more insight into the process involved during the release, the solid residues isolated at 1 h and 168 h (7 days) were characterized. The PXRD data of MgAl₂₀₀/K₂HPO₄ and MgFe₂₀₀/K₂HPO₄ residues (Figure 7) showed major changes between 1 h and 168 h. In the early stage of release (<1 h), K-struvite was formed concomitantly with the LDH structure reconstruction. This rapid phase transformation promotes the fast K and P release rates. K-struvite (KMgPO₄·6H₂O) is the structural analogue of the NH₄-struvite which is used as a bioavailable source of Mg, K and P nutrients for plant growth. The solubility of NH₄-struvite has been the subject of many studies [40]. Data from the literature report pKs values from 9.41 to 13.15. Kinetic behaviors may be quite fast depending on the crystal morphology [41]. We observed that after 168 h of release there was no more crystallized K-struvite in the solid residue, and then LDH-rebuild remained as the insoluble residue. Consequently, LDH layer composition might undergo noticeable modifications, as part of Mg²⁺ must be transferred from the initial calcined LDH to the struvite phase.

Figure 7.

PXRD data for MgAl₂₀₀/K₂HPO₄ after release time of 1 h (a) and 168 h (b), and MgFe₂₀₀/K₂HPO₄ after release time of 1 h (c) and 168 h (d). * K-struvite.

Comparisons of SEM images (Figure 8) of precursors and solid residues for both MgAl₂₀₀/K₂HPO₄ and MgFe₂₀₀/K₂HPO₄ systems, showed strong morphological changes, in good agreement with PXRD data. K-struvite presented as large rod-like crystals beside nanoparticles probably composed of amorphous mixed oxides from LDH. As discussed for PXRD results, SEM images for the residues after 168 h of release (Figure 8B,D) no longer presented K-struvite crystals. For the Mg/Al system there were huge compact crystals, probably composed of the aggregation of small LDH particles. In the case of the Mg/Fe system, some aggregated particles with ill-defined morphology were apparent.

Figure 8.

SEM images of MgAl₂₀₀/K₂HPO₄ residues after 1 h (A) and 168 h (B); and of MgFe₂₀₀/K₂HPO₄ residues after 1 h (C) and 168 h (D).

Energy-dispersive X-ray spectroscopy (EDX) mapping was recorded for the two residues after 1 h of release assay (Figure 9). Analyses were focused on the large crystal that appeared under release. Struvite-K was clearly identified by the concomitant presence of Mg, P and K, homogeneously distributed over the crystals. No Al or Fe were detected in this region.

Figure 9.

EDX images of MgAl₂₀₀/K₂HPO₄ (A–D) and MgFe₂₀₀/K₂HPO₄ (E–H) residues after 1 h.

These structural changes were also confirmed by ²⁷Al NMR analysis of the various solid residues. From the ²⁷Al NMR spectra (Figure 10), the tetrahedral Al(IV) (52.3 and 63.5 ppm) disappeared after 1 h water contact, with the octahedral Al(VI) site remaining, in agreement with the reconstruction of the structure of Mg₂Al LDH phase (Figure 10a). At the same time, two broad signals appeared at δ = −3.3 ppm and −12.0 ppm after 1 h of release and then disappeared for a longer period of contact time (7 and 31 days). Such an upfield signal may be assigned to amorphous aluminum hydroxide (δ = −3.3 ppm) and Al(VI)-PO₄ (δ = −12.0 ppm) species that form due to Mg diffusion from LDH layer into struvite. For residues at 7 and 31 days, ²⁷Al NMR spectra are characteristic of mixture of MgAl LDH and amorphous Al(OH)₃ (Figure 10b,c). The ³¹P NMR spectra of residue at 1 h (Figure 10d) can be resolved into five components. Compared to the ³¹P NMR spectra of the MgAl₂₀₀/K₂HPO₄ precursor, three well-identified signals at 5.0, 0.7 and −2.9 ppm occurred concomitantly. These components, which disappeared after 7 and 31 days of release, must be related to struvite-K, according to XRD analysis, even though they appeared to have shifted slightly upfield compared to the chemical shift of struvite. Residue derived from the dissolution of struvite-K (7 and 31 days of release) contained phosphate groups with a wide variety of chemical environments, as shown by the broad ³¹P NMR signals observed (Figure 10e,f).

Figure 10.

²⁷Al SSNMR spectra of MgAl₂₀₀/K₂HPO₄ residues after 1 h (a); 7 days (b); 31 days (c); and ³¹P SSNMR spectra of MgAl₂₀₀/K₂HPO₄ residues after 1 h (d); 7 days (e); 31 days (f).

3.4. Characterization Results of Assays Involving the Incorporation of Carboxymethylcellulose (CMC)

Carboxymethylcellulose (CMC), an environmentally friendly polymer, has been used in CRF/SRF formulation, due to its biodegradable properties and water swelling capacity that allow control of NPK nutrient release by soil moisture conditions [42,43]. SRF based on inorganic compounds (silica, clay minerals) have been formulated with CMC in order to improve the swelling properties and mechanical strength of the SRF nanocomposites [44]. Using a similar strategy, in order to better tune the K and P release kinetics of MgAl₂₀₀/K₂HPO₄ and MgFe₂₀₀/K₂HPO₄ composites, and particularly to slow down the process at the earlier stage of release, CMC was used as a binder to densify the assemblies of LDH and K₂HPO₄ crystallites. Composites made of calcined LDH, K₂HPO₄ and CMC were prepared following three different methods as described in the Materials and Methods section.

PXRD data of CMC/LDH/K₂HPO₄ composites are shown in Figure S3. As reported by Biswal and Singh [44], milling of pure CMC does not affect its structure with a broad diffraction pattern in the region of 15° to 30° (2θ) characteristic of an amorphous biopolymer. When milled with MgAl₂₀₀ and K₂HPO₄, whatever the method, the characteristic CMC broad diffraction peak was no longer observed. This indicates that under mechanochemical treatment with LDH and K₂HPO₄, CMC has undergone a high level of dispersion into the mixed mineral composite. Inorganic LDH particles and CMC are closely associated thanks to the charge compatibility between positive LDH layer surface and anionic CMC carboxy groups. In contrast, incorporation of CMC into the MgFe₂₀₀/K₂HPO₄ mixture is less effective since the CMC wide peak is partially maintained. Again, when LDH and K₂HPO₄ were milled with CMC, both structures collapsed, leading to samples with a predominant amorphous state. ¹³C NMR analysis (Figure S4 and Table S2) of CMC milled alone, or with LDH₂₀₀/K₂HPO₄, revealed the structural stability of the biopolymer under the various treatments. The milling with CMC led to an increase of amorphization of the matrix as shown by ²⁷Al and ³¹P NMR spectra (Figure S5).

The SEM images (Figure S6) show evidence of drastic changes in CMC morphology; its long micrometric morphology was no longer observed for both ground samples [45]. These observations corroborate the XRD data, indicating that the polymer was modified by mechanochemical reaction with the LDH and K₂HPO₄ mixtures. When the MgAl₂₀₀ grinding was performed, the sample presented in the form of large aggregates with a molten appearance, as already observed for the sample of MgAl₂₀₀/K₂HPO₄ without CMC. For the sample involving grinding with MgFe₂₀₀, agglomerates of small particles without molten appearance were observed.

3.5. Kinetics of Nutrients Release for MgAl₂₀₀/K₂HPO₄ and MgFe₂₀₀/K₂HPO₄ Formulated with CMC

As a first step, the influence of the three different milling methods on the release properties was investigated. The release experiments (Table 4) highlight that the milling sequences used to prepare the compounds had very little effect on K/P release. Systematically, in the earlier release stage (1 h), all MgAl₂₀₀/K₂HPO₄ and MgFe₂₀₀/K₂HPO₄ samples formulated with CMC displayed significantly slower release behavior compared to the previously studied composites without CMC (Figure 3), for both P and K. It must be noted that no Mg²⁺ release was observed. Mg²⁺ released after struvite-K solubilization probably reacted with amorphous hydroxides to precipitate Mg based LDH.

After 168 h of contact with water solution (second release period), CMC/MgAl₂₀₀/K₂HPO₄ samples presented a release percentage of P comparable to that of CMC-free solid (68.2%, Figure 3). According to the release percentage, the best slow-release profiles over the studied period of time were observed for CMC/ MgAl₂₀₀/K₂HPO₄ obtained through Method 2.

Interestingly, for the CMC/MgFe₂₀₀/K₂HPO₄ composite, a noticeable improvement of P release behavior was obtained for CMC/MgFe₂₀₀/K₂HPO₄ prepared when CMC was milled with MgFe₂₀₀/K₂HPO₄ (Method 1) (Table 4). After 168 h of the experiment, P-release increased (9.9% to 33.4%) compared to MgFe₂₀₀/K₂HPO₄, while K-release slightly decreased (99.4 to 82.7%), leading to it being considered as the most promising MgFe-based SRF candidate.

Figure 11 displays the kinetics of K and P releases (25 °C) by CMC/ MgAl₂₀₀/K₂HPO₄ (Method 2) and CMC/ MgFe₂₀₀/K₂HPO₄ (Method 1) composites and related CMC-free compounds (MgAl₂₀₀/K₂HPO₄ and MgFe₂₀₀/K₂HPO₄, respectively). Note that for the MgAl based sample, following what has already been observed for the punctual data (1 h and 168 h), with the addition of CMC, the first step starts with smaller release percentages considering the standard deviation of the tests. It is observed that for the slower stage (at 744 h) there were higher release percentages for P without significant changes for K. These are strong indications that the polymer incorporated into the material potentially influences the nutrient release behavior.

Figure 11.

Comparison between release curves for the MgAl₂₀₀/K₂HPO₄ system (Method 2) (A,B) and the MgFe₂₀₀/K₂HPO₄ system (Method 1) (C,D) with CMC, and without CMC.

This is even more significant in relation to the release curves for the MgFe based sample. At initial release times the percentage of released P was slightly higher compared to the sample without CMC. Along the release curve, this effect becomes even more pronounced (at 744 h, without CMC 25.1%, and with CMC 40.4%), emphasizing that in this matrix the presence of CMC allowed P to be made more available, i.e., to increase the percentage of release over time. In the case of K which is highly available, the CMC led to a slight decrease in the percentage released over time for the initial release phase, and also for the intermediate release points (between 72 h and 240 h).

These results highlight that the addition of CMC in the milling process modifies the release behavior of the nutrients K and P, especially at short release time, making the products more controlled according to the demand.

Interestingly if we compare the results obtained from LDH matrices with SRF prepared by mechanochemical activation of cationic clays such as montmorillonite and talc [12], it appears clear that in LDH-based SRF, the potassium is much more available systematically leading to 100% release at the longer time (744 h), while the P release amount can be tuned in a larger range from 25.1% to 75.9% (at 744 h) according to the chemical composition of the LDH precursors, and the use or not of CMC. It is a good point for versatile production, since other LDH compositions or biopolymers in the form of powder or plasticizers may be tested, depending on the expected release properties.

4. Conclusions

In this study, using the mechanochemical reaction between calcined LDH and K₂HPO₄ to prepare SRF, promising results were obtained with respect to the slow release behavior of P and K. The studies scrutinized the effect of the temperature of LDH calcination, showing that a thermal treatment at 200 °C is suitable to produce materials for the grinding process which display satisfactory release results. Higher calcination temperatures promote phosphate precipitation for longer release times (168 h), making compounds unsuitable as SRF. The release behavior for both systems studied is strongly dependent on the LDH chemical composition and on the temperature of the medium. Interestingly, in the presence of LDH precursors, even if struvite-K crystallizes after milling, and at short release time, it subsequently dissolves and it is probable that this formed structure is strongly related to the slow-release character. Furthermore, the addition of carboxymethylcellulose allows tuning of the release properties enhancing the release percentage of phosphate. This study involving LDH matrices allows the development of the SRF production process. The nature of the starting synthetic LDH precursors applied in mechanochemical assays enables a distinct study compared to systems involving natural precursors, such as clay minerals and LDH, ion exchange studies. The efficiency of these LDH based SRF on plant growth are under investigation to confirm their relevance in real-world conditions.

Supplementary Materials

The following are available online at http://www.mdpi.com/2079-4991/9/2/183/s1, Figure S1: FTIR data of LDH precursors and calcined LDH; Figure S2: FTIR data of milled samples; Figure S3: PXRD of milled samples obtained with CMC; Figure S4: ¹³C NMR of milled samples obtained with CMC; Figure S5: ²⁷Al and ³¹P NMR of CMC/MgAl₂₀₀/K₂HPO₄; Figure S6: SEM images of milled samples obtained with CMC; Table S1: XRD data for struvite-K; Table S2: ¹³C NMR milled samples obtained with CMC.

Author Contributions

R.B. performed the measurements, analyzed the results with the assistance of V.P. and C.F., and participated in editing the manuscript; E.P. performed the solid-state NMR experiments; F.P. corrected the manuscript; V.P. and C.F. supervised the research and finalized the manuscript.

Funding

This work was supported by CNPq, CAPES, FINEP and University Clermont Auvergne. RB also thanks CAPES PDSE for the PhD grant.

Conflicts of Interest

The authors declare no conflicts of interest.