Table 4. Risk of bias.
Question | Responses |
---|---|
Sequence Generation | Low risk = Randomization was mentioned and good method used
High risk = Randomized but poor method used High risk = Non-randomized Unclear risk = Randomized but no method described Unclear risk = No mention of randomized or non-randomized |
Allocation Concealment | Low risk = Method used to conceal the allocation sequence is described in sufficient detail
Unclear risk = Insufficient information to determine if the allocation sequence was concealed High risk = The allocation sequence was not concealed or was concealed in a poor manner |
Blinding of Personnel | Low risk = All personnel involved in giving intervention were blinded to the study groups
Unclear = Insufficient information to determine if any personnel giving intervention were blinded to the study groups High risk = All personnel giving intervention were described to be unblinded to the study groups |
Blinding of Outcome Assessment | Low risk (all) = Outcome assessors were blinded to the study groups for each outcome assessed
Low risk (some) = Outcome assessors were blinded to the study groups for at least one outcome assessed. Select the outcomes that were blinded Unclear = Insufficient information to determine if outcome assessors were blinded during assessment High risk = Outcome assessors not blinded to the study groups |
Incomplete Outcome Data | Low risk = N values were consistent between methods and results for all outcomes, or inconsistent
N values were explained (e.g. only N=3 animals were selected for histological analysis) Unclear = The N value was either not presented in the methods or in the results, and therefore there is insufficient information to permit judgment High risk = N values were not consistent between methods and results for the final outcomes without explanation of attrition or were inconsistent between outcomes |
Potential Bias due to the Source
of Funding |
Low risk = Non-industry source of funding (or no funding)
High risk = Any industry source of funding Unclear = Funding source not reported |
Potential Bias due to the Sample
Size Calculation |
Low risk = Sample size calculations were correctly performed and followed
High risk = Sample size calculations were incorrectly performed or followed Unclear = Sample size calculations were not reported |
Potential Bias due to Reported
Conflict of Interest |
Low risk = Authors reported no conflict of interest
High risk = Authors reported potential conflict of interest Unclear = Potential conflicts of interest not reported |