Skip to main content
. 2019 Jan 3;8:11. [Version 1] doi: 10.12688/f1000research.15869.1

Table 4. Risk of bias.

Question Responses
Sequence Generation Low risk = Randomization was mentioned and good method used
High risk = Randomized but poor method used
High risk = Non-randomized
Unclear risk = Randomized but no method described
Unclear risk = No mention of randomized or non-randomized
Allocation Concealment Low risk = Method used to conceal the allocation sequence is described in sufficient detail
Unclear risk = Insufficient information to determine if the allocation sequence was concealed
High risk = The allocation sequence was not concealed or was concealed in a poor manner
Blinding of Personnel Low risk = All personnel involved in giving intervention were blinded to the study groups
Unclear = Insufficient information to determine if any personnel giving intervention were blinded to
the study groups
High risk = All personnel giving intervention were described to be unblinded to the study groups
Blinding of Outcome Assessment Low risk (all) = Outcome assessors were blinded to the study groups for each outcome assessed
Low risk (some) = Outcome assessors were blinded to the study groups for at least one outcome
assessed. Select the outcomes that were blinded
Unclear = Insufficient information to determine if outcome assessors were blinded during assessment
High risk = Outcome assessors not blinded to the study groups
Incomplete Outcome Data Low risk = N values were consistent between methods and results for all outcomes, or inconsistent
N values were explained (e.g. only N=3 animals were selected for histological analysis)
Unclear = The N value was either not presented in the methods or in the results, and therefore there
is insufficient information to permit judgment
High risk = N values were not consistent between methods and results for the final outcomes without
explanation of attrition or were inconsistent between outcomes
Potential Bias due to the Source
of Funding
Low risk = Non-industry source of funding (or no funding)
High risk = Any industry source of funding
Unclear = Funding source not reported
Potential Bias due to the Sample
Size Calculation
Low risk = Sample size calculations were correctly performed and followed
High risk = Sample size calculations were incorrectly performed or followed
Unclear = Sample size calculations were not reported
Potential Bias due to Reported
Conflict of Interest
Low risk = Authors reported no conflict of interest
High risk = Authors reported potential conflict of interest
Unclear = Potential conflicts of interest not reported