Skip to main content
Chest logoLink to Chest
. 2019 Mar 4;155(3):646. doi: 10.1016/j.chest.2018.08.1065

HIPPOCRATES IS TURNING IN HIS GRAVE

Yvette A Schnoeker-Shorb 1
PMCID: PMC6435896

The first time I went to a specialist,

he had me—naked from the top up,

sheeted from the breasts down—

lie on the examining table,

where he felt hand to skin

every organ in my body. He was

from the “old school” of medicine,

more efficient than robotic,

less impressed with technology

than he was with patient cases,

but the hospital replaced him

after he turned eighty.

So when you tell me how

your new, young gastroenterologist

didn’t even have you undress

but simply discussed your condition,

chronic stomach ailments, I wonder

if she failed you, all those possible

parts of you crying out for attention,

to be felt, to be understood

by someone whose tactile sense

was trained by tradition, not by

a current practice in medicine

that eliminates touch.

Footnotes

Editor’s Note:The author writes, “Many years ago, I was being treated by a Mayo Clinic cardiologist from the “old school” who literally took the time to feel every organ in my body when considering a diagnosis. As he proceeded, he would explain to me how each organ might be related to the particular ailment. Recently, more and more friends and relatives report that their doctors, particularly specialists, simply talk to them about their respective symptoms—without ever feeling the troubled areas of their bodies.” Yvette A. Schnoeker-Shorb has been an educator, a researcher, and an editor, and is co-founder of a 501(c)(3) nonprofit natural history press.


Articles from Chest are provided here courtesy of American College of Chest Physicians

RESOURCES