Skip to main content
Journal of Research of the National Bureau of Standards. Section A, Physics and Chemistry logoLink to Journal of Research of the National Bureau of Standards. Section A, Physics and Chemistry
. 1964 Nov-Dec;68A(6):703–707. doi: 10.6028/jres.068A.070

Intercomparison of High-Energy X-Ray Intensity Measurements

John S Pruitt, Steve R Domen
PMCID: PMC6478152  PMID: 31834732

Abstract

This paper describes experimental comparison of the sensitivity of the NBS P2–4 ionization chamber and a replica of Wilson’s Quantameter. The sensitivity ratios are used to compare calorimetric measurements of total x-ray beam energy made at the NBS and in the USSR between 20 and 90 MeV. The agreement is within the combined errors, but the source of an apparent 2 percent systematic difference has not been found.

1. Introduction

Several ionization chambers of various design have been calibrated in recent years to determine the total energy transported by a high-energy x-ray beam [1].1 In general, these calibrations depend on k0, the maximum photon energy, and although there have been some direct intercomparisons of different chambers when they have been calibrated in the same energy range, the task of intercomparisons of the measurements of different laboratories is by no means complete. The purpose of this paper is to report on comparison measurements made at the National Bureau of Standards between our standard chamber, P2–4 [2], and a Quantameter [3], a replica of the instrument which has been calorimetrically calibrated between 15 and 90 MeV by Komar, Kruglov, and Lopatin of the Academy of Sciences in the U.S.S.R. [4]. Despite the fact that the comparison was not direct, in the sense that a replica Quantameter was used, the profits have been severalfold. The agreement is a partial verification of the measurements of both laboratories, as well as of the energy dependence of these two chambers. Furthermore, the measurements of Komar, Kruglov, and Lopatin, when transferred to P2–4, have considerably reduced the uncertainty in its calibration.

2. The Ionization Chambers

Figure 1 is a schematic cross section of the Quantameter, an instrument which sums the ionization produced in twelve air cavities between 1-cm-thick copper plates. It is not large enough to absorb all of the secondary electrons, but compensates for the few percent leaking out the sides and back with peripheral air cavities and an oversize cavity at the rear. The internal cavities are alternately 2 mm and 1 mm thick, so that the measured ionization is proportional to a Simpson’s rule approximate integration of the total ionization produced in a semi-infinite copper medium. The advantage of this design is that the chamber calibration (joules incident per coulomb collected) should be almost independent of ko, since the ratio of cavity ionization to locally absorbed energy is known to vary very slowly with photon energy. This is apparently quite true for ko greater than about 100 MeV, but the data presented below indicates that the Simpson’s rule approximation breaks down at lower ko.

Figure 1.

Figure 1.

Ionization collection sector of a copper Quantameter.

Figure 2 is a schematic cross section of P2–4, a chamber which measures ionization produced at a depth of 27 g/cm2 in a medium of 2024 Dural (nominally 93.4% Al, 4.5% Cu, 1.5% Mg, and 0.6% Mn). Its design is based on the empirical fact that transition curves (cavity ionization as a function of depth) in water for ko between 10 and 40 MeV exhibit a common crossover point when normalized to include unit area [5], which implies that with proper selection of a front wall thickness it is possible to construct a chamber whose calibration is almost independent of ko over this energy range. Evidence presented below shows this to be true, although the calibration changes more rapidly with ko above about 100 MeV.

Figure 2.

Figure 2.

Ionization collection sector of a Dural P2 chamber.

3. Experimental Arrangement and Method

Figure 3 is a schematic diagram of the apparatus used in the comparison measurements. X rays from the NBS 180 MeV synchrotron successively passed through the donut wall (4.1 g/cm2 of Pyrex), a 0.3-in.-diam. beam forming aperture in a 12-in. lead block, a 4-in. lead baffle designed to stop stray secondary electrons and x rays without intercepting the main x-ray beam, an ionization chamber monitor (3.4 g/cm2 of Al), and a second nonintercepting 4-in. lead baffle, before bombarding either P2–4 or the Quantameter. These two chambers were alternately placed in the same position, and the ratio of their sensitivities per unit monitor response was determined at a variety of ko.

Figure 3.

Figure 3.

Experimental arrangement for chamber intercomparisons.

The quantameter was used both with the recommended filling of 760 mm of argon plus 40 mm of carbon dioxide [3], and filled with air at atmospheric pressure. P2–4 was always open to the atmosphere. The sensitivities of the air-filled chambers were corrected to 20 °C, 760 mm.

Ionization measurements were made for both the monitor and the comparison chamber with Townsend balance circuits, using polystyrene capacitors to collect the charge, potentiometers to supply and measure the bucking voltages, and vibrating reed electrometers as null detectors.

4. Results and Corrections

The measured ratios of P2–4 sensitivity to Quantameter sensitivity are listed as a function of ko in table 1. The replica Quantameter had been constructed according to Wilson’s original design, but when it was assembled, the air-cavity thicknesses were found to differ from the design dimensions by 0.03 to 0.08 mm with an average of 0.055 mm. If all of the cavities had been too thick (or too thin) by 0.055 mm, the measured sensitivity would have been in error by about 3.5 percent, but the Quantameter design is such that dimensional errors tend to cancel, and cavities which are too thick alternate with cavities which are too thin.

Table 1.

Ratio of P2–4 sensitivity (20 °C, 760 mm) to Quantameter sensitivity with A + CO2 filling (20 °C, 800 mm) and with air filling (20 °C, 760 mm)

ko Filling
A+CO2 Air



MeV
15 3.120
20 1.951 3.106
25 1.949 3.093
30 1.940 3.079
35 1.934 3.081
40 1.936 3.082
45 1.940 3.092
50 1.937 3.098
55 3.110
60 1.951 3.114
70 1.957 3.130
90 1.970 3.150
110 1.971 3.150
130 1.955 3.128
150 1.936 3.101
170 1.908 3.063

A correction for these deviations was calculated with the help of transition curves for copper obtained from Marshall, Rosenfeld, and Wright [6] at ko= 46 MeV, and from Kruglov [7] at ko=85 MeV. These were used to determine the relative contribution of each cavity to the total ionization, and it was found that the replica Quantameter sensitivity was higher than the design value, but only by 0.1 percent at each energy. Transition curves for lead [8] and for 2024 Dural [9], which cover a wider energy range, were used to show that the sensitivity correction caused by errors in the air-cavity thicknesses would have varied from 0.06 percent at 25 MeV to 0.17 percent at 170 MeV if the plates had been lead (of the same g/cm2 thickness), and from 0.03 percent at 25 MeV to 0.05 percent at 170 MeV if they had been Dural. The correction for copper should be between these extremes, and was finally taken as 0 for ko<45 MeV and 0.1 percent for larger ko.

During the comparison measurements it was found that the ends of the bolts holding together the quantameter (not shown in fig. 1) collected enough charge from ionized air behind the chamber to raise the measured sensitivity by as much as 0.67 percent. This correction is included in the A + CO2 ratios of table 1, which were obtained before this was discovered, and it was avoided in the measurements with air filling by covering these studs with rubber caps.

5. Quantameter Calibrations

Table 2 is a list of the Quantameter calibrations obtained by multiplying the corrected ratios of table 1 by the calorimetric calibrations of P2–4 measured earlier in this laboratory [2, 8], with uncertainties equal to those of the P2–4 calibrations plus 0.3 percent for these ratios and corrections. The calibrations are plotted as a function of k0 in figure 4, which shows that in general, they agree with those of Komar et al. to within the stated errors. There is also agreement that the calibration increases with decreasing k0 at these energies. The calibrations obtained at higher energies by comparing the A+CO2 filled Quantameter with a thick-walled Cornell ionization chamber [1] indicate that the energy dependence does indeed disappear with increasing k0.

Table 2.

Quantameter calibration (joules/coulomb) with A+ CO2 filling (20 °C, 800 mm) and with air filling (20 °C, 760 mm).

ko Filling
Uncertainty
A+CO2 Air




(MeV)
20 8.12×10 5 12.92×10 5 ±2.4%
26 8.00 12.70 2.7
31 7.99 12.69 1.8
36 7.95 12.66 1.5
41 7.92 12.61 2.1
45 7.80 12.43 1.8
50 7.74 12.36 1.8
60 7.69 12.27 1.8
70 7.56 12.08 2.7
90 7.49 11.97 2.7
110 7.58 12.10 2.7
130 7.46 11.92 1.5
150 7.40 11.85 1.8
170 7.39 11.85 1.8

Figure 4.

Figure 4.

Quantameter calibration in joules/coulomb.

6. P2–4 Calibrations

Table 3 is a listing of the P2–4 calibrations obtained by dividing the corrected ratios of table 1 into the Quantameter calibrations of Komar, et al [4]. They are plotted in figure 5 along with all other known P2–4 calibrations [1]. There are enough of these to warrant some statistical manipulation, and they have consequently been fitted to a curve of the type:

P2−4calibration=∑i=04aiχi,joules/coulomb

where χ=9.80 log10 (k0 (MeV)/43.2) with uncertainties expressed as:

Δ(%)=∑i=04δiχi.

Table 3.

P2–4 calibration (joules/coulomb) at 20 °C. 760 mm

ko joules/coulomb Uncertainty



(MeV)
15 4.17×10 5 ±1.5%
20 4.18 1.3
25 4.22 1.2
30 4.24 1.3
35 4.21 1.2
40 4.16 1.1
53 3.93 2.1
55 4.05 1.0
70 3.95 1.2
72 3.90 1.9
85 3.88 1.3
90 3.89 1.1

Figure 5.

Figure 5.

P2–4 calibration in joules/coulomb.

The ai and δi are listed in table 4. The ai were obtained by least squares, with each calibration weighted with a factor equal to the inverse square of its uncertainty. The δi were calculated using Gauss’ law for combining errors. The two curves of figure 5 represent the extreme predictions of this formula. There is no guarantee that the true P2–4 calibration lies between these curves, since they were obtained statistically, using weights which include both statistical and systematic uncertainties, but the good agreement between the calibrations obtained in several laboratories by several means supports this view.

Table 4.

Coefficients in “P2–4 joules/coulomb = ∑i=04aiχi,” and in “Δ(%) = ∑i=04δiχi,” where χ = 9.80 log10 (k0(MeV)/43.2)

i ai δj



0- 4.077×105 0.39
1- −.0650 −.017
2- −.00971 .0001
3- .001187 −.00009
4- .0001809 .000243

7. Comments

The NBS Quantameter calibrations of figure 4 agree with those of Komar et al. to within the combined uncertainties, but there is indication of a systematic discrepancy of about 2 percent between the measurements of these two laboratories. In each case, the original calibrations were made with calorimeters of about the same design, and an obvious place to look for systematic differences is in the corrections made to the calorimeter data for leakage of secondary photons and electrons. In the NBS case, this correction was based on scintillation measurements of backscattering plus photographic determinations of energy leaking from the other surfaces [8]. The Soviet correction is presumably based on ionization chamber measurements described earlier by Kruglov and Lopatin [10], which are presented in a form well suited for comparison. Their measurements indicate that for a 9-cm-diam 7.5 cm lead cylinder, such as we used, they would expect a leakage flux of 5.3 percent of the incident energy at k0=50 MeV, and 5.1 percent at 85 MeV, while our own measurements indicate 5.4 percent at each of these energies. This difference is both too small and in the wrong direction to explain the 2 percent discrepancy.

The only other plausible source of a 2 percent systematic difference is the Quantameter dimensions, which should be controlled very carefully because of the thin air-cavity dimensions. A direct comparison of the two Quantameters would certainly help to clear up the reasons for this difference.

After these intercomparisons had been completed, it was found that Komar et al., have calibrated a replica P2 chamber [11] and have also found a difference of about 2 percent between the NBS and Soviet calibrations.

Acknowledgments

The authors thank the operators of the NBS synchrotron for their help with these intercomparisons.

Footnotes

1

Figure in brackets indicate the literature references at the end of this paper.

8. References

  • [1].Methods of Experimental Physics, Vol. V, Pt. B, Sec. 2.8.2.4., ed. Marton L. (Academic Press, New York, N.Y., 1963). [Google Scholar]
  • [2].Pruitt John S. and Domen Steve R., NBS Mono. 48 (1962). [Google Scholar]
  • [3].Wilson R. R., Nuclear Instr. 1, 101 (1957). [Google Scholar]
  • [4].Komar A. P., Kruglov S. P., and Lopatin I. V., Dok. Akad. Nauk SSSR 145, 309 (1962) [Google Scholar]; [Sovict Phys.-Dok. 7,653 (1963)]; [Google Scholar]; Komar A. P. and Kruglov S. P., Zh. Tekh. Fiz. 30, 1369 (1960) [Google Scholar]; [Soviet Phys.-Tech. Phys. 5, 1299 (1961)]. [Google Scholar]
  • [5].Zendle Bernard, private communication.
  • [6].Marshall L., Rosenfeld A. H., and Wright S. C., Phys. Rev. 83, 305 (1951). [Google Scholar]
  • [7].Kruglov S. P., Zh. Tekh. Fiz. 31, 1451 (1961) [Google Scholar]; [Soviet Phys.-Tech.Phys. 6, 1060 (1962)]. [Google Scholar]
  • [8].Pruitt J. S. and Domen S. R., J. Res. NBS 66A (Phys. and Chem.), 371 (1962). [Google Scholar]
  • [9].The data from which figure 16 in reference [2] was taken.
  • [10].Kruglov S. P. and Lopatin I. Y., Zh. Tekh. Fiz. 32, 1399 (1962) [Google Scholar]; [Sovict Phys.-Technical Phys. 7, 1031 (1963)]. [Google Scholar]
  • [11].Komar A. P., Kruglov S. P., and Lopatin I. V., Zh. Eksper. i Teoret. Fiz. 45, 825 (1963). [Google Scholar]

Articles from Journal of Research of the National Bureau of Standards. Section A, Physics and Chemistry are provided here courtesy of National Institute of Standards and Technology

RESOURCES