Table 2.
Author | Year | Type of Study | Strength | Limitations |
---|---|---|---|---|
Cedermark et al.[28] | 1981 | Retrospective observational study | • Histology proven adrenal metastases • Use of ACTH stimulation test for diagnosis with clear documentation of values. • Representative of patients with bilateral metastases |
• Small sample size with 7 consecutive patients, 3 with bilateral adrenal metastases. |
Seidenwurm et al.[29] | 1984 | Retrospective observational study | • Moderate sample size • Clear documentation of bilateral disease via CT or autopsy • Representative of patients with bilateral metastases |
• Used symptoms, signs or biochemistry suggestive of AI, as well as response to glucocorticoids as part of diagnostic criteria rather than ACTH-stimulation testing (only 2 patients had documented inappropriate response to ACTH testing out of those included as AI) • May have included patients with nephrectomy/adrenalectomy |
Redman et al.[30] | 1987 | Prospective observational study with intervention arm | • Excluded treatment induced AI • Used ACTH stimulation test for diagnosis with clear documentation of values • Clear documentation of bilateral disease • Representative of patients with bilateral metastases |
• Small sample size |
Lutz et al.[31] | 2000 | Cross sectional observation study. | • Clear documentation of bilateral adrenal disease • Exclude patients with prior treatment that could affect adrenal function. • Used ACTH stimulation testing • Representative of patients with bilateral disease |
• Small sample size • Diagnostic criteria for subclinical AI not validated (use of ACTH:cortisol ratio) |
Lam et al.[32] | 2002 | Retrospective observational study | • Large sample size • Clear documentation of bilateral disease via autopsy, adrenalectomy or FNA • Population representative of patients with bilateral metastases |
• Inconsistent use of ACTH stimulation test for diagnosis • Authors did not disclose the values for diagnosis of AI • Diagnosed AI by using signs, symptoms and biochemical evidence with unclear documentation of what this entails. |
Delivanis et al.[13] | 2016 | Retrospective observational study | • Moderate sample size with bilateral disease • Confirmed radiological evidence of bilateral disease • Representative of population of interest |
• No ACTH stimulation testing, used low cortisol and high ACTH levels to diagnosis AI |
AI = adrenal insufficiency, ACTH = adrenocorticotropin hormone, CT = computer tomography, FNA = fine needle aspiration.