Abstract Abstract
Phyllopsora is a crustose to squamulose lichen genus inhabiting the bark of trees in moist tropical forests and rainforests. Species identification is generally challenging and is mainly based on ascospore morphology, thallus morphology and anatomy, vegetative dispersal units, and on secondary chemistry. While regional treatments of the genus have been conducted for Africa, South America and Australia, there exists no study focusing on the Asian and Melanesian species. Previously, 24 species of Phyllopsora s. str. have been reported from major national studies and checklists representing 13 countries. We have studied herbarium material of 625 Phyllopsora specimens from 18 countries using morphology, anatomy, secondary chemistry, and molecular data to investigate the diversity of Phyllopsora species in Asia and Melanesia. We report the occurrence of 28 species of Phyllopsora including the following three species described as new to science: P.sabahana from Malaysia, P.siamensis from Thailand and P.pseudocorallina from Asia and Africa. Eight species are reported as new to Asia. A key to the Asian and Melanesian species of Phyllopsora is provided.
Keywords: Malaysia, Sri Lanka, Thailand, rainforest, TLC, phylogeny, identification key
Introduction
The genus Phyllopsora Müll. Arg. consists of 54 crustose or squamulose species (Kistenich et al. in press). They grow mostly on bark of trees in (sub-)tropical rainforests or moist woodlands. The genus was described in 1894 from New Zealand (Müller 1894), but the first modern revision of the pantropical genus was conducted 87 years later by Swinscow and Krog (1981) focusing on the East African species. Ten years later, Brako (1991) monographed the Neotropical species, while Elix (2009) summarized the Australian species and their occurrence. Additional reports and regional studies of the genus and its species, distribution can be found from Eastern Africa (Timdal and Krog 2001), Peru (Timdal 2008b) and the West Indies (Timdal 2011). From Asia, however, only a few reports exist for selected countries. Upreti et al. (2002) listed five Phyllopsora species from India. Later, Mishra et al. (2011) described two species and one variety from India as new to science. Recently, Kondratyuk et al. (2016) described a new species from South Korea. Phyllopsoroid specimens have been reported in additional checklists and geographical studies from, for example, Bangladesh (Aptroot and Iqbal 2011), Northeast India (Logesh et al. 2017), Sri Lanka (Weerakoon and Aptroot 2014), South Korea (Joshi et al. 2011) and Thailand (Aptroot et al. 2007). A general Asian, transnational study focusing on Phyllopsora has to date not been published. So far, 24 of the 54 accepted Phyllopsora species have been reported to occur in Asia and Melanesia (Table 1). An additional nine species reported from Asia represent either synonyms or have recently been excluded from the genus (Kistenich et al. in press; 2018b; Table 1).
Table 1.
Species of Phyllopsora reported from Asia and Melanesia.
Species | Authorship | Cambodia | China | Fiji | India | Indonesia | Japan | Malaysia | Nepal | New Caledonia | Papua New Guinea | Philippines | Solomon | South Korea | Sri Lanka | Taiwan | Thailand | Vanuatu | Vietnam |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Accepted species | |||||||||||||||||||
P. africana | Timdal & Krog | ** | ** | ** | * | ** | ** | ** | ** | * | |||||||||
P. breviuscula | (Nyl.) Müll. Arg. | * [10] | ** | ** | ** [17] | * | |||||||||||||
P. buettneri | (Müll. Arg.) Zahlbr. | * | [16] | ** | * [1, 5, 15] | [5] | * | [3] | ** [6] | [4] | |||||||||
P. castaneocincta | (Hue) Kistenich & Timdal | * | * [16] | * T | ** | ** | * | * | * T | * | ** [17] | * | ** | ||||||
P. chodatinica | Elix | ** | ** | * [5] | * | ||||||||||||||
P. cinchonarum | (Fée) Timdal | ** [12] | * T | ** [6] | |||||||||||||||
P. confusa | Swinscow & Krog | [10] | * | * | ** | ** [1, 15] | ** [17] | * | ** | ||||||||||
P. cuyabensis | (Malme) Zahlbr. | ** | |||||||||||||||||
P. dolichospora | Timdal & Krog | * | ** | ** [17] | |||||||||||||||
P. foliata | (Stirt.) Zahlbr. | ** | ** [17] | ||||||||||||||||
P. furfuracea | (Pers.) Zahlbr. | [10] | [5] | [8] | * [2, 7] | T | * [17] | [3] | ** [6, 19] | [4] | |||||||||
P. gossypina | (Sw.) Kistenich et al. | [12] | [13] | [8] | [14, 15] | ** [17] | [6] | [4] | |||||||||||
P. halei | (Tuck.) Zahlbr. | [1, 2] | ** | [3] | |||||||||||||||
P. himalayensis | G.K. Mishra et al. | T | |||||||||||||||||
P. isidiosa | Kistenich & Timdal | ** | ** | ** | ** | ** | |||||||||||||
P. kalbii | Brako | [10] | ** | ||||||||||||||||
P. loekoesii | S.Y. Kondr. et al. | ** | ** | * T | |||||||||||||||
P. longiuscula | (Nyl.) Zahlbr. | ** | ** | * | |||||||||||||||
P. mediocris | Swinscow & Krog | * | |||||||||||||||||
P. neofoliata | Elix | * | |||||||||||||||||
P. parvifolia | (Pers.) Müll. Arg. | [18] | [16] | [7, 8] | [14] | * | |||||||||||||
P. parvifoliella | (Nyl.) Müll. Arg. | ** | * | * | ** | ||||||||||||||
P. porphyromelaena | (Vain.) Zahlbr. | * | * [10] | * | ** | ** | * | * | * T | * | ** | * T | ** | ||||||
P. pseudocorallina | Kistenich & Timdal | ** | ** | ** | |||||||||||||||
P. sabahana | Kistenich & Timdal | ** | |||||||||||||||||
P. santensis | (Tuck.) Swinscow & Krog | [12] | [2] | [5] | * | ||||||||||||||
P. siamensis | Kistenich & Timdal | ** | |||||||||||||||||
P. subhispidula | (Nyl.) Kalb & Elix | ** | |||||||||||||||||
Reported, not confirmed species | |||||||||||||||||||
P. chlorophaea | (Müll. Arg.) Zahlbr. | [10] | [3] | ||||||||||||||||
P. corallina | (Eschw.) Müll. Arg. | [9, 16] | [11] | [17] | [3] | [4] | |||||||||||||
P. isidiotyla | (Vain.) Riddle | [10] | |||||||||||||||||
P. mauritiana | (Taylor) Swinscow & Krog | [10] | |||||||||||||||||
P. nemoralis | Timdal & Krog | [10] | |||||||||||||||||
P. pyxinoides | (Nyl.) Kistenich et al. | [6, 19] | |||||||||||||||||
P. swinscowii | Timdal & Krog | [10] | |||||||||||||||||
Excluded species | |||||||||||||||||||
P. catervisorediata | G.K. Mishra et al. | T | |||||||||||||||||
P. densiflorae | (Vain.) Gotth. Schneid. | T | |||||||||||||||||
P. griseocastanea | (Vain.) Gotth. Schneid. | T | |||||||||||||||||
P. manipurensis | (Müll. Arg.) Müll. Arg. | T | |||||||||||||||||
P. subcrustacea | (Malme) Brako | [10] | |||||||||||||||||
P. viridis | Paulson | T | |||||||||||||||||
P. borbonica | Timdal & Krog | [17] | |||||||||||||||||
P. sorediata | (Aptroot & Sparrius) Timdal | [6] | |||||||||||||||||
P. soralifera | Timdal | [9] |
T: Type material (of the accepted name or a synonym); *: Identified in this study, based on morphology/chemistry; **: Identified in this study, based on DNA; [1]: Aptroot 1997; [2]: Aptroot et al. 1997; [3]: Aptroot and Sparrius 2003; [4]: Aptroot and Sparrius 2006; [5]: Brako 1991; [6]: Buaruang et al. 2017; [7]: Elix 2009; [8]: Elix and McCarthy 1998; [9]: Logesh et al. 2017; [10]: Mishra et al. 2011; [11]: Moon 2013; [12]: Ohmura and Kasiwadani 2018; [13]: Sipman 1993; [14]: Streimann 1986; [15]: Streimann and Sipman 1994; [16]: Upreti et al. 2002; [17]: Weerakoon and Aptroot 2014; [18]: Wei 1991; [19]: Wolseley et al. 2002.
Species of Phyllopsora are generally challenging to identify by morphology only. In a molecular phylogeny of the lichen family Ramalinaceae C. Agardh, Kistenich et al. (2018b) showed the genus Phyllopsora to be polyphyletic. Consequently, they excluded ten species from the genus. Three of the excluded species most likely belong in the family Malmideaceae Kalb, Rivas Plata & Lumbsch. An additional three of the excluded species were transferred to the new genus Parallopsora Kistenich, Timdal & Bendiksby. The species of Parallopsora grouped together in a poorly resolved clade with a number of tropical genera, such as Eschatogonia Trevis., Krogia Timdal and Physcidia Tuck. (Kistenich et al. 2018b). Little is known about these genera in Asia, which are generally very similar to Phyllopsora in their macromorphology. They often differ, however, from Phyllopsora in ascospore size and arrangement, presence of prothallus, thallus construction and chemistry (Kalb and Elix 1995; Kistenich et al. 2018b; Timdal 2008a; 2009). Recently, Kistenich et al. (2018a) described three new species of Krogia from Asia and Oceania, which were all tentatively identified as Phyllopsora sp., indicating the morphological similarity between these two genera.
The scope of the present study is to revise Asian and Melanesian Phyllopsora specimens mainly collected between 1990 and 2017 by the authors. Herein, we provide an overview of the species of Phyllopsora occurring in the Asian countries with an updated taxonomy based on multiple sources of evidence, including DNA sequence data. We describe three new species and provide a key to the Asian and Melanesian species of Phyllopsora.
Materials and methods
The specimens
We investigated material from 18 different countries in Asia and Melanesia (Table 1) based on herbarium collections made mainly between 1990 and 2017. Older material of Phyllopsora is generally not suitable for DNA sequencing (Kistenich et al. in press). In addition to material from our own herbaria directly available to us (BM, BORH, O, PDA), we received loans from the institutional herbaria B, E, H, TNS, and UPS, as well as from the private herbarium of P. Diederich. In total, we investigated 908 specimens of Phyllopsora and related genera. Author names for the studied species are provided in Tables 1 and 2.
Table 2.
Specimens used in this study with voucher information and GenBank accession numbers. New sequences are indicated by accession numbers in bold. – indicates missing data.
Species | Extract # | mtSSU | ITS | Country | Year | Voucher | Herbarium |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Biatorabeckhausii (Körb.) Tuck. | – | MG925858 | AF282071 | Norway | 1995 | Holien, H. 6744 | TRH |
B.vacciniicola (Tønsberg) Printzen | – | MG925861 | MG925960 | Norway | 2013 | Klepsland, J. JK13-L330 | O |
Crocyniamolliuscula (Nyl.) Nyl. | 7359 | MK352275 | – | La Réunion | 1996 | Krog, H. & Timdal, E. RE18/03 | O |
7360 | MK352276 | – | Mauritius | 1991 | Krog, H. & Timdal, E. MAU58/02 | O | |
Phyllopsoraafricana Timdal & Krog ch1 | 470 | MK412413 | MK412480 | Thailand | 1993 | Aguirre, James & Wolseley 2475a | BM |
471 | MK412414 | MK412481 | Thailand | 1992 | Aguirre–Hudson, B. & Wolseley, P.A. 1327 | BM | |
509 | MK352138 | MK352317 | La Réunion | 1996 | Krog, H. & Timdal, E. RE08/13 | O | |
1436 | MK352175 | MK352348 | La Réunion | 1996 | Krog, H. & Timdal, E. RE22/09 | O | |
4037 | MK352199 | MK352370 | Thailand | 2012 | v.d. Boom, P. 46982 | hb. v.d. Boom | |
7224 | MK412469 | MK412512 | Sri Lanka | 2017 | Kistenich S. & Weerakoon, G. SK1-517 | PDA | |
P.africana ch1? | 1012 | MK412425 | – | Indonesia | 2000 | Wolseley, P. T15 | BM |
P.africana ch2 | 477 | MK352122 | MK352301 | Japan | 1995 | Thor, G. 13199 | UPS |
6770 | MK412461 | MK412504 | Sri Lanka | 2017 | Weerakoon, G. Ri056 | PDA | |
P.africana ch3 | 472 | MK412415 | – | Solomon Islands | 1965 | Hill, D.J. 9242 | BM |
1416 | MK412435 | – | Malaysia | 2012 | Wolseley, P., Thüs, H. & Vairappan, C. D.8.04.oQ | BORH | |
1427 | MK412443 | – | Indonesia | 2000 | Wolseley, P. T22 OQ | BM | |
6348 | MK352231 | MK352401 | Philippines | 1994 | Diederich, P. 13345 | hb. Diederich | |
6351 | MK412447 | – | Philippines | 1994 | Diederich, P. 13213 | hb. Diederich | |
6352 | MK412448 | – | Philippines | 1994 | Diederich, P. 13119 | hb. Diederich | |
6772 | MK412462 | MK412505 | Sri Lanka | 2017 | Weerakoon, G. Im015 | PDA | |
7205 | MK412463 | MK412506 | Sri Lanka | 2017 | Kistenich S. & Weerakoon, G. SK1-543 | PDA | |
P.amazonica Kistenich & Timdal | 3619 | MK352194 | MK352365 | Brazil | 2014 | Barbosa, R.S., Haugan, R. & Timdal, E. 90 | O |
4155 | MK352208 | MK352379 | Brazil | 2015 | Kistenich, S. & Timdal, E. SK1-85 | MPEG | |
P.breviuscula (Nyl.) Müll. Arg. | 528 | MG925892 | MG925990 | La Réunion | 1996 | Krog, H. & Timdal, E. RE36/18 | O |
1305 | MG925893 | MG925991 | Brazil | 1980 | Kalb, K. & Marcelli, M. in: Kalb, Lich. Neotropici 515 | GZU | |
1432 | MK412445 | – | Sri Lanka | 2007 | Jayalal, U. A4-5-8-5 | PDA | |
2100 | – | MK352355 | Philippines | 1992 | Tan, B.C. 92-187 | B | |
6752 | MK352245 | MK352412 | New Caledonia | 2016 | Rikkinen, J. 35509 | H | |
6754 | MK412456 | MK412499 | New Caledonia | 2016 | Rikkinen, J. 35503 | H | |
6760 | MK412457 | MK412500 | Sri Lanka | 2017 | Weerakoon, G. Im042 | PDA | |
P. breviuscula | 6764 | MK412458 | MK412501 | Sri Lanka | 2017 | Weerakoon, G. Mn093 | PDA |
6765 | MK412459 | MK412502 | Sri Lanka | 2017 | Weerakoon, G. Mo81 | PDA | |
7212 | MK352256 | MK352422 | Sri Lanka | 2017 | Kistenich, S. & Weerakoon, G. SK1-642 | PDA | |
7213 | MK412465 | MK412508 | Sri Lanka | 2017 | Kistenich S. & Weerakoon, G. SK1-601 | PDA | |
7217 | MK412466 | MK412509 | Sri Lanka | 2017 | Weerakoon, G. 982 | PDA | |
7218 | MK412467 | MK412510 | Sri Lanka | 2017 | Weerakoon, G. 1013 | PDA | |
7229 | MK412470 | MK412513 | Sri Lanka | 2017 | Kistenich S. & Weerakoon, G. SK1-649 | PDA | |
7234 | – | MK412516 | Sri Lanka | 2017 | Kistenich S. & Weerakoon, G. SK1-648 | PDA | |
7235 | MK412472 | MK412517 | Sri Lanka | 2017 | Kistenich S. & Weerakoon, G. SK1-640 | PDA | |
P.buettneri (Müll. Arg.) Zahlbr. ch1 | 428 | MK352103 | MK352283 | Thailand | 1994 | Wolseley, P. & Kanajriavanit, S. s.n. | BM:734816 |
995 | MK352146 | MK352322 | Thailand | 1993 | James, P.W. & Wolseley, P.A. 2466a | BM | |
1041 | MK352160 | MK352335 | Kenya | 2007 | Divakar, Lumbsch & Mangold 19553D | hb. Pérez-Ortega | |
P.buettneri ch2 | 6464 | MK352239 | MK352406 | Brazil | 2015 | Dahl, M.S., Kistenich, S., Timdal, E. & Toreskaas, A.K. AM-37 | O |
7177 | MK352252 | – | Venezuela | 1984 | Brako, L. 8110 | GZU | |
P.buettneri ch3 | 429 | MK352104 | MK352284 | Thailand | 1993 | Aguirre, B., James, P.W. & Wolseley, P. 2736 | BM |
493 | MK352131 | MK352311 | Thailand | 1994 | Wolseley, P. & Kanajriavanit, S. s.n. | BM:1104011 | |
6462 | MK352238 | – | Japan | 1995 | Thor, G. 13183 | UPS | |
P.byssiseda (Nyl.) Zahlbr. | 4737 | MK352211 | MK352382 | Venezuela | 2015 | Dahl, M.S., Kistenich, S., Timdal, E. & Toreskaas, A.K. SK1-220 | VEN |
4739 | MK352212 | MK352383 | Venezuela | 2015 | Dahl, M.S., Kistenich, S., Timdal, E. & Toreskaas, A.K. SK1-229 | VEN | |
P.canoumbrina (Vain.) Brako | 3627 | MK352195 | MK352366 | Brazil | 2014 | Barbosa, R.S., Haugan, R. & Timdal, E. 166 | O |
P.castaneocincta (Hue) Kistenich & Timdal | 460 | MK352116 | MK352295 | Tanzania | 2008 | Timdal, E. 10912 | O |
461 | MK412412 | MK412479 | Thailand | 1993 | Aguirre, James & Wolseley 2482B | BM | |
998 | MK412420 | – | Thailand | 1991 | Wolseley, P.A. & Aguirre–Hudson, B. 5564 | BM | |
999 | MK412421 | MK412486 | Thailand | 1993 | Wolseley, P.A. & David, F. 3314 | BM | |
1022 | MK412427 | MK412490 | Thailand | 1992 | Wolseley, P.A. & Aguirre–Hudson, B. 5583 | BM | |
P. castaneocincta | 1032 | MK412429 | – | Nepal | 2007 | Sharma, L.R., Olley, L., Cross L7.1 | E |
1045 | MK412431 | – | Thailand | 1993 | James, P.W. & Wolseley, P.A. 2466b | BM | |
1264 | MK412433 | MK412492 | Malaysia | 2012 | Wolseley, P., Thüs, H. & Vairappan, C. M.3.10.1 | BORH | |
1420 | MK412439 | – | Malaysia | 2012 | Wolseley, P., Thüs, H. & Vairappan, C. M.3.10.2a | BORH | |
1421 | MK412440 | MK412493 | Malaysia | 2012 | Thüs, H., Wolseley, P. & Vairappan, C. M110 | BORH | |
3560 | MK352186 | MK352358 | South Africa | 2014 | Burrows, J. & Timdal, E. 14280 | O | |
4032 | MK352196 | MK352367 | Thailand | 2012 | v.d. Boom, P. 47239 | hb. v.d. Boom | |
6743 | MK352243 | MK352410 | Kenya | 2013 | Kirika, P., Mugambi, G. & Lumbsch, H.T. 3011 | O | |
7232 | – | MK412515 | Sri Lanka | 2017 | Kistenich S. & Weerakoon, G. SK1-594 | PDA | |
7255 | MK352270 | MK352434 | Australia | 1992 | Elix, J.A. 32834 | CANB | |
P.chlorophaea (Müll. Arg.) Zahlbr. | 529 | MK352145 | MK352321 | La Réunion | 1996 | Krog, H. & Timdal, E. RE36/17 | O |
1051 | MK352165 | MK352340 | Kenya | 2002 | Killmann, D. & Fischer, E. s.n. | hb. Killmann | |
1309 | MK352172 | – | Venezuela | 1986 | Brako, L. & Berry, P.E. 8685 | GZU | |
SE382 | MG925894 | MG925992 | La Réunion | 1996 | Krog, H. & Timdal, E. RE08/10 | O | |
P.chodatinica Elix | 513 | MK352139 | – | Australia | 1986 | Elix, J.A. & Streimann, H. 21023 | O |
1539 | MK352177 | MK352350 | New Caledonia | 2005 | Elvebakk, A. 05:691 | O | |
6456 | MK352237 | MK352405 | Malaysia | 2014 | Paukov, A. 2232 | B | |
P.cinchonarum (Fée) Timdal | 439 | MK352105 | – | Thailand | 2002 | Sipman, H. 48664 | B |
440 | MK352106 | MK352285 | Japan | 2006 | Thor, G. 21521 | UPS | |
4168 | MK352210 | MK352381 | Venezuela | 2015 | Dahl, M.S., Kistenich, S., Timdal, E. & Toreskaas, A.K. SK1-201 | VEN | |
6063 | MK352227 | – | Guatemala | 2004 | v.d. Boom, P. 33395 | hb. v.d. Boom | |
P.concinna Kistenich & Timdal | 4041 | MK352202 | MK352373 | Panama | 2010 | v.d. Boom, P. 43947 | hb. v.d. Boom |
4776 | MK352224 | MK352395 | Brazil | 2015 | Dahl, M.S., Kistenich, S., Timdal, E. & Toreskaas, A.K. SK1-445 | O | |
6455 | MK352236 | MK352404 | Venezuela | 2015 | M.S. Dahl, J.E. Hernández M., S. Kistenich, E. Timdal & A.K. Toreskaas SK1-225 | O | |
7176 | MK352251 | MK352418 | Guatemala | 2002 | Andersohn, C. s.n. | B | |
P.confusa Swinscow & Krog | 514 | MK352140 | MK352318 | Kenya | 1972 | Krog, H. & Swinscow, T.D.V. K48/177 | O |
1018 | MK412426 | MK412489 | Thailand | 1991 | Wolseley, P.A. 1049 | BM | |
P. confusa | 1024 | MK352150 | MK352325 | Cuba | 2007 | Tønsberg, T. 37813 | BG |
1300 | MK352169 | MK352343 | Venezuela | 1969 | Oberwinkler, B., Oberwinkler, F. & Poelt, J. s.n. | GZU | |
1417 | MK412436 | – | Malaysia | 2012 | Wolseley, P., Thüs, H. & Vairappan, C. M.3.10.6 | BORH | |
3571 | MK352190 | MK352362 | Ecuador | 2014 | Prieto, M. s.n. | HUTPL | |
4741 | MK352214 | MK352385 | Venezuela | 2015 | Dahl, M.S., Kistenich, S., Timdal, E. & Toreskaas, A.K. SK1-237 | VEN | |
6360 | MK412451 | – | Papua New Guinea | 1992 | Diederich, P. 11056 | hb. Diederich | |
6361 | MK412452 | – | Papua New Guinea | 1992 | Diederich, P. 10319 | hb. Diederich | |
6766 | MK412460 | MK412503 | Sri Lanka | 2017 | Weerakoon, G. Ri030 | PDA | |
7185 | MK352253 | MK352419 | Cameroon | 1999 | Frisch, A. & Tamnjong Idi 99/Ka1213 | hb. Frisch | |
7220 | MK412468 | MK412511 | Sri Lanka | 2017 | Weerakoon, G. 176 | PDA | |
7236 | MK352260 | MK352426 | Sri Lanka | 2017 | Kistenich, S. & Weerakoon, G. SK1-609 | PDA | |
7239 | MK412473 | MK412518 | Sri Lanka | 2017 | Kistenich S. & Weerakoon, G. SK1-567 | PDA | |
7240 | MK412474 | – | Sri Lanka | 2017 | Kistenich S. & Weerakoon, G. SK1-532 | PDA | |
P.corallina (Eschw.) Müll. Arg. | 1316 | MK352173 | MK352346 | Venezuela | 1986 | Brako, L. & Berry, P.E. 8659 | GZU |
4164 | MK352209 | MK352380 | Venezuela | 2015 | Dahl, M.S., Kistenich, S., Timdal, E. & Toreskaas, A.K. SK1-185 | VEN | |
4762 | MK352220 | MK352391 | Brazil | 2015 | Dahl, M.S., Kistenich, S., Timdal, E. & Toreskaas, A.K. SK1-377 | O | |
4775 | MK352223 | MK352394 | Brazil | 2015 | Dahl, M.S., Kistenich, S., Timdal, E. & Toreskaas, A.K. SK1-430 | O | |
P.cuyabensis (Malme) Zahlbr. | 449 | MK352107 | MK352286 | Peru | 2006 | Timdal, E. 10258 | O |
450 | MK352108 | MK352287 | Thailand | 1993 | Aguirre, B., James, P.W. & Wolseley, P. 2467a | BM | |
1290 | MK352166 | MK352341 | Venezuela | 1996 | Hafellner, J. 53910 | GZU | |
1291 | MK352167 | MK352342 | Guatemala | 1979 | Kalb, K. & Plöbst, G. s.n. | GZU | |
2048 | MK352180 | MK352352 | Bolivia | 2008 | Flakus, A. & Rodriguez, P. 12792 | O | |
P.dolichospora Timdal & Krog | 515 | MK352141 | MK352319 | Mauritius | 1991 | Krog, H. & Timdal, E. MAU65/22 | O |
6357 | MK352233 | – | Papua New Guinea | 1992 | Diederich, P. 10847 | hb. Diederich | |
P. dolichospora | 6359 | MK412450 | – | Papua New Guinea | 1992 | Diederich, P. 10846 | hb. Diederich |
6763 | MK352247 | MK352414 | Sri Lanka | 2017 | Weerakoon, G. Hg40 | PDA | |
6767 | MK352248 | MK352415 | Sri Lanka | 2017 | Weerakoon, G. Si113B | PDA | |
7258 | MK352271 | MK352435 | Sri Lanka | 2017 | Kistenich, S. & Weerakoon, G. SK1-643 | PDA | |
P.fendleri (Tuck. & Mont.) Müll. Arg. | 2098 | MK352183 | MK352354 | Costa Rica | 1985 | H. Sipman & A. Chaverri 20806 | B |
7473 | MK352277 | MK352437 | Venezuela | 1979 | Sipman, H. 10688 | B | |
P.foliata (Stirt.) Zahlbr. | 1035 | MK352157 | MK352332 | Japan | 2004 | Kashawadani, H. 46389 | TNS |
7238 | MK352261 | MK352427 | Sri Lanka | 2017 | Kistenich, S. & Weerakoon, G. SK1-627 | PDA | |
7247 | MK352265 | MK352431 | Australia | 2006 | Elix, J.A. 38235 | CANB | |
P.foliatella Elix | 7243 | MK352262 | MK352428 | Australia | 1986 | Elix, J.A. & Streimann, H. 20241 | CANB |
7246 | MK352264 | MK352430 | Australia | 1986 | Elix, J.A. & Streimann, H. 20203 | CANB | |
7253 | MK352268 | – | Australia | 2005 | Elix, J.A. 37286 | CANB | |
7254 | MK352269 | – | Australia | 1998 | Streimann, H. 61609 | CANB | |
P.furfuracea (Pers.) Zahlbr. | 451 | MK412411 | MK412478 | Thailand | 1993 | Aguirre, James & Wolseley 2918 | BM |
452 | MK352109 | MK352288 | La Réunion | 1996 | Krog, H. & Timdal, E. RE36/22 | O | |
453 | MK352110 | MK352289 | Trinidad And Tobago | 2008 | Rui, S. & Timdal, E. 10799 | O | |
455 | MK352111 | MK352290 | Peru | 2006 | Timdal, E. 10183 | O | |
P.furfurella Kistenich & Timdal | 3570 | MK352189 | MK352361 | Ecuador | 2014 | Prieto, M. s.n. | HUTPL |
4036 | MK352198 | MK352369 | Dominican Republic | 2008 | v.d. Boom, P. 39069 | hb. v.d. Boom | |
P.glaucella (Vain.) Timdal | 1000 | MK352147 | MK352323 | Dominican Republic | 1987 | Harris, R.C. 20779 | BM |
2125 | MK352184 | MK352356 | Argentina | 2013 | Ferraro, L.I., Aptroot, A. & Cáceres, M.E.S. 10761 | O | |
4766 | MK352221 | MK352392 | Brazil | 2015 | Dahl, M.S., Kistenich, S., Timdal, E. & Toreskaas, A.K. SK1-393 | O | |
4780 | MK352225 | MK352396 | Brazil | 2015 | Dahl, M.S., Kistenich, S., Timdal, E. & Toreskaas, A.K. AM-44 | O | |
P.gossypina (Sw.) Kistenich et al. | – | AY584615 | – | Costa Rica | 2002 | Lücking, R. 16052 | DUKE |
P.gossypina ch1 | 3575 | MK352192 | MK352363 | Brazil | 2014 | Barbosa, R.S., Haugan, R. & Timdal, E. 141 | O |
3576 | MK352193 | MK352364 | Brazil | 2014 | Barbosa, R.S., Haugan, R. & Timdal, E. 34 | O | |
4160 | MG925867 | MG925967 | Brazil | 2015 | Kistenich, S. & Timdal, E. SK1-108 | O | |
P.gossypina ch1 | 4746 | MG925868 | MG925968 | Brazil | 2015 | Dahl, M.S., Kistenich, S., Timdal, E. & Toreskaas, A.K. SK1-287 | O |
7201 | MK352254 | MK352420 | Sri Lanka | 2017 | Kistenich, S. & Weerakoon, G. SK1-584 | PDA | |
P.gossypina ch2 | 4750 | MK352219 | MK352390 | Brazil | 2015 | Dahl, M.S., Kistenich, S., Timdal, E. & Toreskaas, A.K. SK1-297 | O |
P.halei (Tuck.) Zahlbr. ch2 | 457 | MK352113 | MK352292 | Tanzania | 2008 | Timdal, E. 10931 | O |
1044 | MK352161 | MK352336 | Kenya | 2007 | Divakar, Lumbsch & Mangold 19574K | hb. Pérez–Ortega | |
P.halei ch3 | 7221 | MK352257 | MK352423 | Sri Lanka | 2017 | Weerakoon, G. 1008 | PDA |
P.hispaniolae Timdal | 1545 | MK352178 | – | Ecuador | 1999 | Palice, Z. 3875 | hb. Palice |
3569 | MK352188 | MK352360 | Ecuador | 2014 | Prieto, M. s.n. | HUTPL | |
4039 | MK352201 | MK352372 | Panama | 2010 | v.d. Boom, P. 44158 | hb. v.d. Boom | |
P.imshaugii Timdal | 3558 | MK352185 | MK352357 | Ecuador | 2014 | Prieto, M. s.n. | HUTPL |
4043 | MK352204 | MK352375 | Guatemala | 2004 | v.d. Boom, P. 33433 | hb. v.d. Boom | |
4744 | MK352217 | MK352388 | Venezuela | 2015 | Dahl, M.S., Kistenich, S., Timdal, E. & Toreskaas, A.K. SK1-253 | VEN | |
P.isidiosa Kistenich & Timdal | 430 | MK412409 | MK412476 | Thailand | 1991 | Wolseley, P.A. & Aguirre–Hudson, B. 5552 | BM |
1027 | MK352153 | MK352328 | USA | 2006 | Lendemer, J.C. 7765 dupl. | BG | |
1030 | MK352155 | MK352330 | Nepal | 2007 | Sharma, L.R., Olley, L., Cross, A., Joshi, M. & Regmi, B. M16 | E | |
1031 | MK412428 | – | Nepal | 2007 | Sharma, L.R., Olley, L., Cross L25-2 | E | |
1259 | MK412432 | – | Malaysia | 2012 | Wolseley, P., Thüs, H. & Vairappan, C. S.P.5 | BORH | |
2099 | MK412446 | MK412494 | Indonesia | 2003 | L. Sudirman & H. Sipman 51474 | B | |
4035 | MK352197 | MK352368 | Dominican Republic | 2008 | v.d. Boom, P. 39012 | hb. v.d. Boom | |
4781 | MG925907 | MG926004 | Brazil | 2007 | Lücking, R & Rivas Plata, E. 23302 | SP | |
6349 | MK352232 | – | Philippines | 1994 | Diederich, P. 13210 | hb. Diederich | |
7251 | MK352267 | MK352433 | Australia | 2006 | Elix, J.A. 38478 | CANB | |
P.isidiotyla (Vain.) Riddle | 1315 | MG925906 | MG926003 | Brazil | 1979 | Kalb, K. & Plöbst, G. in: Kalb, Lich. Neotrop. 343 | GZU |
P.kalbii Brako | 456 | MK352112 | MK352291 | Thailand | 1993 | Aguirre, B., James, P.W. & Wolseley, P. 2695 | BM |
458 | MK352114 | MK352293 | Tanzania | 2008 | Timdal, E. 10913 | O | |
459 | MK352115 | MK352294 | Venezuela | 1989 | Kalb, K. & A. s.n. | O | |
1028 | MK352154 | MK352329 | USA | 2010 | Lendemer, J.C. 25770 | BG | |
2052 | MK352182 | – | Bolivia | 2010 | Flakus, A. & Quisbert, J. 19221 | O | |
P.loekoesii S.Y. Kondr. et al. | 1033 | MK352156 | MK352331 | Nepal | 2007 | Sharma, L.R., Olley, L., Cross A. C5 | E |
7478 | MK352279 | MK352439 | Japan | 1994 | Thor, G. 12574 | TNS | |
P.longiuscula (Nyl.) Zahlbr. | 454 | MG925899 | MG925996 | Peru | 2006 | Timdal, E. 10433 | O |
467 | MK352117 | MK352296 | Trinidad And Tobago | 2008 | Rui, S. & Timdal, E. 10730 | O | |
1011 | MK412424 | MK412488 | Thailand | 1992 | Wolseley, P.A. & Aguirre–Hudson, B. 5580 p.p. | BM | |
1039 | MK352159 | MK352334 | Cuba | 2006 | Pérez–Ortega, S. s.n. | hb. Pérez–Ortega | |
6761 | MK352159 | MK352413 | Sri Lanka | 2017 | Weerakoon, G. Kn136 | PDA | |
P.malcolmii Vezda & Kalb | 1303 | MK352170 | MK352344 | New Zealand | 1994 | Malcolm, W. in: Vezda, Lich. Rar. Exs. 200 | GZU |
P.martinii Swinscow & Krog | 489 | MK352129 | MK352309 | Tanzania | 1989 | Krog, H. 3T13/007 | O |
6740 | MK352242 | MK352409 | Kenya | 2014 | Kirika, P. & Lumbsch, H.T. 4087 | O | |
P.mauritiana (Taylor) Swinscow & Krog | 487 | MK352128 | MK352307 | Tanzania | 1988 | Krog, H. 2T12/037 | O |
488 | – | MK352308 | Mauritius | 1991 | Krog, H. & Timdal, E. MAU09/43 | O | |
SE386 | MG925900 | MG925997 | Mauritius | 1991 | Krog, H. & Timdal, E. MAU09/44 | O | |
P.mediocris Swinscow & Krog | 527 | MK352144 | MK352320 | Tanzania | 1988 | Krog, H. 2T06/023 | O |
6346 | MK352229 | MK352399 | Mauritius | 2016 | Diederich, P. 18571 | hb. Diederich | |
6347 | MK352230 | MK352400 | Mauritius | 2016 | Diederich, P. 18573 | hb. Diederich | |
P.melanoglauca Zahlbr. | 1038 | MK352158 | MK352333 | Cuba | 2006 | Pérez–Ortega, S. s.n. | hb. Pérez–Ortega |
4042 | MK352203 | MK352374 | Guatemala | 2004 | v.d. Boom, P. 33408 | hb. v.d. Boom | |
4740 | MK352213 | MK352384 | Venezuela | 2015 | Dahl, M.S., Kistenich, S., Timdal, E. & Toreskaas, A.K. SK1-232 | VEN | |
4743 | MK352216 | MK352387 | Venezuela | 2015 | Dahl, M.S., Kistenich, S., Timdal, E. & Toreskaas, A.K. SK1-247 | VEN | |
6450 | MK352235 | MK352403 | Brazil | 2015 | Dahl, M.S., Kistenich, S., Timdal, E. & Toreskaas, A.K. SK1-408 | O | |
P.nemoralis Timdal & Krog | 522 | MK352142 | – | La Réunion | 1996 | Krog, H. & Timdal, E. RE25/32 | O |
1434 | MK352174 | MK352347 | South Africa | 1996 | Nordin, A. 4622 | UPS:L:92604 | |
P.neofoliata Elix | 6745 | MK352244 | MK352411 | Kenya | 2015 | Kirika, P. & Lumbsch, H.T. 4728 | O |
7245 | MK352263 | MK352429 | Australia | 1992 | Elix, J.A. 32714 | O | |
7249 | MK352266 | MK352432 | Australia | 1989 | Elix, J.A. | CANB | |
P.neotinica Kistenich & Timdal | 505 | MK352137 | MK352316 | Trinidad And Tobago | 2008 | Rui, S. & Timdal, E. 10774 | O |
1023 | MK352149 | MK352324 | Cuba | 2007 | Tønsberg, T. 37923 | BG | |
1438 | MK352176 | MK352349 | Trinidad And Tobago | 2008 | Rui, S. & Timdal, E. 10763 | O | |
P. neotinica | 4742 | MK352215 | MK352386 | Venezuela | 2015 | M.S. Dahl, J.E. Hernández M., S. Kistenich, E. Timdal & A.K. Toreskaas SK1-246 | O |
4769 | MK352222 | MK352393 | Brazil | 2015 | Dahl, M.S., Kistenich, S., Timdal, E. & Toreskaas, A.K. SK1-402 | O | |
P.ochroxantha (Nyl.) Zahlbr. | 473 | MK352118 | MK352297 | Peru | 2006 | Timdal, E. 10338 | O |
474 | MK352119 | MK352298 | Peru | 2006 | Timdal, E. 10389 | O | |
475 | MK352120 | MK352299 | Trinidad And Tobago | 2008 | Rui, S. & Timdal, E. 10849 | O | |
4049 | MK352206 | MK352377 | Brazil | 2015 | Kistenich, S. & Timdal, E. SK1-47 | O | |
4747 | MK352218 | MK352389 | Brazil | 2015 | Dahl, M.S., Kistenich, S., Timdal, E. & Toreskaas, A.K. SK1-289 | O | |
P.parvifolia (Pers.) Müll. Arg. | 479 | MK352124 | MK352303 | Tanzania | 2008 | Timdal, E. 10935 | O |
480 | MK352125 | MK352304 | Trinidad And Tobago | 2008 | Rui, S. & Timdal, E. 10867 | O | |
2049 | MK352181 | MK352353 | Bolivia | 2010 | Flakus, A. & Quisbert, J. 20016 | O | |
3561 | MK352187 | MK352359 | South Africa | 2014 | Burrows, J. & Timdal, E. 14244 | O | |
6365 | MK352234 | MK352402 | Portugal | 2015 | v.d. Boom, P. 53877 | hb. v.d. Boom | |
P.parvifoliella (Nyl.) Müll. Arg. | 481 | MK352126 | MK352305 | Peru | 2006 | Timdal, E. 10302 | O |
482 | MG925902 | MG925999 | Indonesia | 2000 | Wolseley, P.A. s.n. | BM:1104069 | |
483 | MK352127 | MK352306 | Thailand | 1993 | James, P.W. & Wolseley, P.A. 2491 | BM | |
1004 | MK412422 | – | Thailand | 1993 | James, P.W. & Wolseley, P.A. 1847 | BM | |
P.phaeobyssina (Vain.) Timdal | 478 | MK352123 | MK352302 | Trinidad And Tobago | 2008 | Rui, S. & Timdal, E. 10872 | O |
P.porphyromelaena (Vain.) Zahlbr. ch1 | 490 | MK412416 | MK412482 | Thailand | 1994 | Wolseley, P. & Kanajriavanit, S. s.n. | BM:1104012 |
498 | MG925904 | MG926001 | La Réunion | 1996 | Krog, H. & Timdal, E. RE07/17 | O | |
502 | MK352135 | MK352314 | Japan | 1995 | Thor, G. 12941 | UPS | |
1050 | MK352164 | MK352339 | Kenya | 2002 | Killmann, D. & Fischer, E. s.n. | hb. Killmann | |
1429 | MK412444 | – | Sri Lanka | 2007 | Jayalal, U. B9-4-3-3 | PDA | |
7207 | MK412464 | MK412507 | Sri Lanka | 2017 | Kistenich S. & Weerakoon, G. SK1-634 | PDA | |
P.porphyromelaena ch2 | 491 | MK412417 | MK412483 | Thailand | 1993 | Aguirre–Hudson, B. & Wolseley, P.A. 1663 | BM |
496 | MK352133 | – | Tanzania | 1989 | Krog, H. 4T16/019 | O | |
503 | MK352136 | MK352315 | Japan | 2006 | Thor, G. 21238 | UPS | |
6436 | MK412454 | MK412497 | Malaysia | 2014 | Paukov, A. 2233 | B | |
7208 | MK352255 | MK352421 | Sri Lanka | 2017 | Kistenich, S. & Weerakoon, G. SK1-631 | PDA | |
P.porphyromelaena ch2 | 7479 | MK412475 | MK412519 | Japan | 2017 | Haugan, R. & Timdal, E. 16753 | O:L:209897 |
P.porphyromelaena ch3 | 492 | MK352130 | MK352310 | Thailand | 1993 | Aguirre, B., James, P.W. & Wolseley, P. 2857 | BM |
494 | MK352132 | MK352312 | Thailand | 1993 | Aguirre, B., James, P.W. & Wolseley, P. 2481 | BM | |
P.pseudocorallina Kistenich & Timdal | 1034 | MK412430 | MK412491 | Cambodia | 2005 | Kashiwadani, H. 47806 | TNS |
1418 | MK412437 | – | Malaysia | 2012 | Thüs, H., Wolseley, P. & Vairappan, C. M001a | BORH | |
1419 | MK412438 | – | Malaysia | 2012 | Thüs, H., Wolseley, P. & Vairappan, C. M005 | BORH | |
6356 | MK412449 | MK412495 | Papua New Guinea | 1992 | Diederich, P. 11386 | hb. Diederich | |
P.pyxinoides (Nyl.) Kistenich et al. | 3574 | MK352191 | – | Brazil | 2014 | Cáceres, M., Haugan, R. & Timdal, E. 21024 | O |
7358 | MK352274 | – | USA | 1991 | Ryan, B. 27530 | O | |
P.rappiana (Brako) Elix | 6737 | MK352240 | MK352407 | Australia | 2005 | Elix, J. 36867 | O |
7175 | MK352250 | MK352417 | Panama | 2010 | v.d. Boom, P. 43820 | hb. v.d. Boom | |
P.rosei Coppins & P. James | 1299 | MK352168 | – | UK | 1992 | Coppins, B., James, P.W. & Poelt, J. Sc92/446 | GZU |
6339 | MK352228 | MK352398 | France | 2000 | Diederich, P. 14602 | hb. Diederich | |
7356 | MK352272 | MK352436 | France | 1990 | Diederich, P. 9247 | hb. Diederich | |
7357 | MK352273 | – | UK | 1992 | Coppins, B., James, P.W. & Poelt, J. Sc92/193 | GZU | |
P.sabahana Kistenich & Timdal | 1265 | MK412434 | – | Malaysia | 2012 | Wolseley, P., Thüs, H. & Vairappan, C. S.B.oQ.3 | BORH |
1423 | MK412441 | – | Malaysia | 2012 | Thüs, H., Wolseley, P. & Vairappan, C. M089 | BORH | |
1425 | MK412442 | – | Malaysia | 2012 | Wolseley, P., Thüs, H. & Vairappan, C. D.8.02.4 | BORH | |
6435 | MK412453 | MK412496 | Malaysia | 2014 | Paukov, A. 2230 | B | |
6457 | MK412455 | MK412498 | Malaysia | 2014 | Paukov, A. 2229 | B | |
P.santensis (Tuck.) Swinscow & Krog | 2043 | MK352179 | MK352351 | Bolivia | 2009 | Flakus, A. & Rodriguez, P. 15581 | O |
4038 | MK352200 | MK352371 | Panama | 2010 | v.d. Boom, P. 44704 | hb. v.d. Boom | |
4051 | MK352207 | MK352378 | Brazil | 2015 | Kistenich, S. & Timdal, E. SK1-79 | O | |
P.siamensis Kistenich & Timdal | 448 | MK412410 | MK412477 | Thailand | 1993 | Wolseley, P.A. & Boonpragob, K. 3245 | BM |
996 | MK412418 | MK412484 | Thailand | 1992 | Wolseley, P.A. & Onsar 5590 | BM | |
997 | MK412419 | MK412485 | Thailand | 1993 | Aguirre–Hudson, B. & Wolseley, P.A. 1643 | BM | |
1010 | MK412423 | MK412487 | Thailand | 1992 | Wolseley, P.A. & Aguirre–Hudson, B. 5580 | BM | |
P. sp. 1 | 7230 | MK352259 | MK352425 | Sri Lanka | 2017 | Kistenich, S. & Weerakoon, G. SK1-545 | PDA |
P. sp. 2 | 1017 | MK352148 | – | Malaysia | 1997 | Wolseley, P. s.n. | BM:1104019 |
P. sp. 3 | 7227 | MK352258 | MK352424 | Sri Lanka | 2017 | Kistenich, S. & Weerakoon, G. SK1-555 | PDA |
P. sp. 4 | 7231 | MK412471 | MK412514 | Sri Lanka | 2017 | Kistenich S. & Weerakoon, G. SK1-570 | PDA |
P.subhispidula (Nyl.) Kalb & Elix | 501 | MK352134 | MK352313 | Tanzania | 1989 | Krog, H. 4T15/007 | O |
6738 | MK352241 | MK352408 | La Réunion | 1996 | Krog, H. & Timdal, E. RE36/15 | O | |
6771 | MK352249 | MK352416 | Sri Lanka | 2017 | Weerakoon, G. Hg29A | PDA | |
P.swinscowii Timdal & Krog | 476 | MK352121 | MK352300 | Peru | 2006 | Timdal, E. 10190 | O |
525 | MK352143 | – | Mauritius | 1991 | Krog, H. & Timdal, E. MAU09/50 | O | |
1025 | MK352151 | MK352326 | Cuba | 2007 | Tønsberg, T. 37817 | BG | |
1049 | MK352163 | MK352338 | Kenya | 2002 | Killmann, D. & Fischer, E. s.n. | hb. Killmann | |
4048 | MK352205 | MK352376 | Brazil | 2015 | Kistenich, S. & Timdal, E. SK1-115 | O | |
P.teretiuscula Timdal | 1026 | MK352152 | MK352327 | Cuba | 2007 | Tønsberg, T. 37814 | BG |
1306 | MK352171 | MK352345 | Costa Rica | 2003 | Hafellner & Emmerer 1490 | GZU | |
7474 | MK352278 | MK352438 | Puerto Rico | 1992 | Harris, R.C. 27320 | O | |
P.thaleriza (Stirt.) Brako | 1048 | MK352162 | MK352337 | Kenya | 2003 | Killmann, D. & Fischer, E. s.n. | hb. Killmann |
5465 | MG925880 | MG925982 | South Africa | 2014 | Burrows, J. & Timdal, E. 14191 | O | |
5466 | MG925881 | MG925983 | South Africa | 2015 | Rui, S. & Timdal, E. 13877 | O | |
5467 | MK352226 | MK352397 | South Africa | 2015 | Rui, S. & Timdal, E. 13873 | O |
The definition of Melanesia follows the United Nations geoscheme for Oceania as devised by the United Nations Statistics Division based on the M49 coding classification (https://unstats.un.org/unsd/methodology/m49/). Accordingly, it includes the five countries Fiji, New Caledonia, Papua New Guinea, Solomon Islands, and Vanuatu.
Morphology and secondary chemistry
All specimens were studied morphologically and when necessary, also anatomically. Microscope sections were prepared using a freezing microtome and mounted in water, 10% KOH (K), lactophenol cotton blue, and a modified Lugol’s solution in which water was replaced by 50% lactic acid. The types of upper cortex referred to in this paper (types 1 and 2) are those described by Swinscow and Krog (1981). Amyloid reactions in the apothecium were observed in the modified Lugol’s solution after pretreatment in K, and crystals of lichen substances were observed using polarized light. Ascospore measurements are given as X ± 1.5 × SD rounded to 0.5 µm, where X is the arithmetic mean and SD the standard deviation.
We performed thin-layer chromatography (TLC) as routine investigation for identification of lichen substances in accordance with the methods of Culberson (1972), modified by Menlove (1974) and Culberson and Johnson (1982). Generally, we examined the acetone-extracts in solvent system B’; fatty acids were not examined. In difficult cases, we additionally used solvent systems A and C for lichen substance identification.
Molecular methods and phylogenetic analysis
For DNA extraction, PCR amplification and DNA sequencing of the mitochondrial ribosomal small subunit (mtSSU) and the nuclear ribosomal internal transcribed spacer region (ITS: ITS1, 5.8S, ITS2), we followed the protocols outlined in Kistenich et al. (2018a). For sequence assembly and preliminary alignment, we used Geneious R9 (Kearse et al. 2012).
As many of the specimens, from which we generated sequences, had not been previously identified, we needed to find out, which specimens belonged in Phyllopsora s. str. and consequently, which sequences to use in the final phylogenetic analyses. Hence, we phylogenetically analysed a combined alignment of our Ramalinaceae dataset (Kistenich et al. 2018b) and the newly generated sequences using standard RAxML (i.e., applying the GTR substitution model for each pre-defined partition [mtSSU, ITS1, 5.8S and ITS2] with 100 rapid bootstrap inferences and the GAMMA model for evaluating and optimizing the likelihood of the final tree; Stamatakis 2014). Based on these RAxML trees, we selected those specimens falling into Phyllopsora s. str. and incorporated them into our Phyllopsora dataset (Kistenich et al. in press). This dataset was analysed phylogenetically in more detail (see below) to provide evidence for undescribed species.
Each marker was aligned separately using MAFFT v.7.408 (Katoh and Standley 2013) with the E-INS-i algorithm and the nucleotide scoring matrix set to 1PAM / κ=2. We trimmed the ends of the ITS alignment to comprise only the ITS-region and deleted the residual 18S and 28S sequence information. Each dataset was initially analysed by IQ-TREE v.1.6.7 (Nguyen et al. 2015) to infer a maximum likelihood tree using 1000 ultrafast bootstrap repetitions (Hoang et al. 2018). We checked for gene-tree incongruence using compat.py (Kauff and Lutzoni 2002) with a cut-off of 90. As we did not find any strongly supported incongruences, which would affect the circumscription of the new species, we concatenated the mtSSU and ITS alignments. We ran a detailed IQ-TREE analysis to find the best-fitting nucleotide substitution models and partitioning schemes (Chernomor et al. 2016; Kalyaanamoorthy et al. 2017) among models implemented in MrBayes (i.e., 1-, 2-, and 6-rate models) and to infer a maximum likelihood tree using 1000 standard non-parametric bootstrap repetitions (BS). We defined four subsets, one for mtSSU and three for ITS corresponding to the ITS1, 5.8S and ITS2 regions, and analysed those with the TESTMERGE function resembling PartitionFinder2. In addition, we analysed the dataset with MrBayes v.3.2.6 (Altekar et al. 2004; Ronquist and Huelsenbeck 2003) as described in Kistenich et al. (2018b). The temperature increment parameter was set to 0.05. We projected the BS values from the IQ-TREE analysis onto the MrBayes consensus tree with posterior probabilities (PP) and collapsed branches with BS < 50 and PP < 0.7. The resulting trees were edited in TreeGraph2 (Stöver and Müller 2010) and FigTree v.1.4.4 (http://tree.bio.ed.ac.uk/software/figtree).
Results
Morphology and secondary chemistry
Morphological identification of many specimens was challenging, but with data obtained by TLC, many specimens could be identified to species level. Of the 908 studied specimens, we found 625 specimens to belong in Phyllopsora, while 283 specimens were found to belong in other genera of the Malmideaceae and Ramalinaceae (not treated in this study). Of the 625 Phyllopsora specimens, 480 were identified to species level in Phyllopsora (Table 2, Suppl. material 2: Table S1), while 141 specimens (23%) were left unidentified (not included in Suppl. material 2: Table S1), most of which were not sequenced and did not contain lichen substances. The morphology and anatomy of the Phyllopsora species have been described in detail by Swinscow and Krog (1981) and Brako (1991), and are not repeated here. We often found the distinction between cortex type 1 and type 2 useful for species identification; however, in many species the cortex type is intermediate (type 1–2). The chemistry of the 54 accepted Phyllopsora species is summarized in Kistenich et al. (in press).
Information about all Phyllopsora species may also be found on our Phyllopsora website: http://nhm2.uio.no/lichens/Phyllopsora.
Molecular data and phylogenetic analysis
We obtained sequences for 140 phyllopsoroid specimens with 132 mtSSU and 106 ITS sequences (Tables 2, 3). Based on the initial RAxML analyses (not shown), 93 specimens were found to belong in Phyllopsora s. str. (Table 2) and were used in the subsequent analyses. The remaining 47 specimens did not belong in Phyllopsora s. str. (Table 3) and are referred to at the family level only due to many problems of generic affiliation.
Table 3.
Newly generated sequences for specimens not belonging to Phyllopsora with voucher information and GenBank accession numbers. – indicates missing data.
Family | Extract # | mtSSU | ITS | Country | Year | Voucher | Herb. |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Malmideaceae | 1268 | MK400188 | MK400239 | Malaysia | 2012 | Wolseley, P., Thüs, H. & Vairappan, C. D.1.10.3 | BORH |
Ramalinaceae | 417 | MK400189 | MK400240 | Thailand | 1993 | Wolseley, P.A. & David, F. 3347 | BM:749829 |
423 | MK400190 | MK400241 | Indonesia | 2000 | Wolseley, P. T9 LQ | BM:1104053 | |
427 | MK400191 | MK400242 | Indonesia | 2000 | Wolseley, P. T13 LQ | BM:1104062 | |
432 | MK400192 | MK400243 | Malaysia | 1997 | Wolseley, P. pkt. 8 | BM:1104016 | |
433 | MK400193 | MK400244 | Thailand | 1991 | Wolseley, P.A. & Aguirre–Hudson, B. 5548 | BM:749824 | |
435 | MK400194 | MK400245 | Indonesia | 2000 | Wolseley, P. T20 LMQ | BM:1104013 | |
1008 | MK400195 | – | Thailand | 1993 | Aguirre, James & Wolseley 2854 | BM | |
1013 | MK400196 | – | Thailand | 1993 | James, P.W. & Wolseley, P.A. 1700b | BM | |
1014 | MK400197 | MK400246 | Thailand | 1993 | Aguirre, James & Wolseley 2478a | BM:749861 | |
1015 | MK400198 | MK400247 | Thailand | 1993 | Aguirre, James & Wolseley 2715 | BM:749853 | |
1020 | MK400199 | – | Indonesia | 2000 | Wolseley, P. T6 LQ | BM:1104066 | |
1021 | MK400200 | – | Indonesia | 2000 | Wolseley, P. T1 | BM:1104063 | |
1266 | – | MK400248 | Malaysia | 2012 | Wolseley, P., Thüs, H. & Vairappan, C. D.4.04.2 | BORH | |
1270 | MK400201 | MK400249 | Malaysia | 2012 | Wolseley, P., Thüs, H. & Vairappan, C. M.1.12.oQ | BORH | |
1275 | MK400202 | MK400250 | Malaysia | 2012 | Wolseley, P., Thüs, H. & Vairappan, C. D+40 | BORH | |
1282 | MK400203 | MK400251 | Malaysia | 2012 | Wolseley, P., Thüs, H. & Vairappan, C. S.B.10.2 | BORH | |
1284 | MK400204 | MK400252 | Malaysia | 2012 | Wolseley, P., Thüs, H. & Vairappan, C. D.7.09.1 | BORH | |
1285 | MK400205 | MK400253 | Malaysia | 2012 | Wolseley, P., Thüs, H. & Vairappan, C. M.3.08.oQ.2 | BORH | |
1287 | MK400206 | MK400254 | Malaysia | 2012 | Wolseley, P., Thüs, H. & Vairappan, C. M.3.03.1 | BORH | |
1426 | – | MK400255 | Malaysia | 2013 | Vairappan, C. L261 | BM | |
1428 | MK400207 | MK400256 | Thailand | 1993 | Aguirre, James & Wolseley 2477e | BM:1031544 | |
6056 | MK400208 | – | Malaysia | 2014 | Paukov, A. 2236 | B | |
6057 | MK400209 | – | Malaysia | 2014 | Paukov, A. 2235 | B | |
6762 | MK400210 | MK400257 | Sri Lanka | 2017 | Weerakoon, G. Ne141 | PDA | |
6768 | MK400211 | MK400258 | Sri Lanka | 2017 | Weerakoon, G. WL60 | PDA | |
6769 | MK400212 | MK400259 | Sri Lanka | 2017 | Weerakoon, G. WL15/2 | PDA | |
7186 | MK400213 | MK400260 | Sri Lanka | 2017 | Kistenich, S. & Weerakoon, G. SK1-651 | PDA | |
7187 | MK400214 | MK400261 | Sri Lanka | 2017 | Kistenich, S. & Weerakoon, G. SK1-650 | PDA | |
7188 | MK400215 | MK400262 | Sri Lanka | 2017 | Kistenich, S. & Weerakoon, G. SK1-564 | PDA | |
7189 | MK400216 | – | Sri Lanka | 2017 | Kistenich, S. & Weerakoon, G. SK1-566 | PDA | |
7190 | MK400217 | MK400263 | Sri Lanka | 2017 | Kistenich, S. & Weerakoon, G. SK1-604 | PDA | |
7191 | MK400218 | MK400264 | Sri Lanka | 2017 | Kistenich, S. & Weerakoon, G. SK1-602 | PDA | |
7192 | MK400219 | MK400265 | Sri Lanka | 2017 | Kistenich, S. & Weerakoon, G. SK1-611 | PDA | |
7193 | MK400220 | MK400266 | Sri Lanka | 2017 | Kistenich, S. & Weerakoon, G. SK1-558 | PDA | |
7195 | MK400221 | MK400267 | Sri Lanka | 2017 | Kistenich, S. & Weerakoon, G. SK1-560 | PDA | |
7196 | MK400222 | MK400268 | Sri Lanka | 2017 | Kistenich, S. & Weerakoon, G. SK1-673 | PDA | |
Ramalinaceae | 7198 | MK400223 | MK400269 | Sri Lanka | 2017 | Kistenich, S. & Weerakoon, G. SK1-659 | PDA |
7199 | MK400224 | MK400270 | Sri Lanka | 2017 | Kistenich, S. & Weerakoon, G. SK1-587 | PDA | |
7202 | – | MK400271 | Sri Lanka | 2017 | Kistenich, S. & Weerakoon, G. SK1-573 | PDA | |
7204 | – | MK400272 | Sri Lanka | 2017 | Kistenich, S. & Weerakoon, G. SK1-524 | PDA | |
7206 | MK400225 | MK400273 | Sri Lanka | 2017 | Kistenich, S. & Weerakoon, G. SK1-666 | PDA | |
7211 | MK400226 | MK400274 | Sri Lanka | 2017 | Kistenich, S. & Weerakoon, G. SK1-561 | PDA | |
7215 | – | MK400275 | Sri Lanka | 2017 | Kistenich, S. & Weerakoon, G. SK1-592 | PDA | |
7222 | MK400227 | MK400276 | Sri Lanka | 2017 | Weerakoon, G. 641 loc.31 | PDA | |
7226 | – | MK400277 | Sri Lanka | 2017 | Kistenich, S. & Weerakoon, G. SK1-628 | PDA | |
7228 | MK400228 | – | Sri Lanka | 2017 | Kistenich, S. & Weerakoon, G. SK1-667 | PDA |
The concatenated alignment had a length of 1,825 bp with 264 accessions including one specimen of Biatorabeckhausii (Körb.) Tuck. and one of B.vacciniicola (Tønsberg) Printzen for rooting of the phylogenetic trees. The alignment contained ca. 20% missing data and is available from TreeBase (study no. 23881).
The software IQ-TREE suggested the following substitution models for four subsets: GTR+I+Γ for mtSSU and SYM+I+Γ for ITS1, 5.8S and ITS2. Bayesian phylogenetic analysis halted automatically after 40×106 generations, when the ASDSF in the last 50% of each run had fallen below 0.01. Following a burnin of 50%, we used 80,004 trees for the final Bayesian majority-rule consensus tree. The phylogenetic results generated by IQ-TREE vs. MrBayes showed no incongruences. The extended majority-rule consensus tree (Fig. 1; see Suppl. material 1: Fig. S1 for the uncollapsed version of the tree), based on the Bayesian topology with all compatible groups (BS ≥ 50 and/or PP ≥ 0.7), shows an overall good resolution of Phyllopsora species. Seventeen unidentified specimens did not associate with any known species in the phylogenetic tree (Fig. 1). Four unidentified specimens (1017, 7227, 7230, and 7231) were resolved on long branches, while the remaining 13 specimens grouped into three distinct, strongly supported clades (Fig. 1A–C). Clade A is resolved as sister to a clade consisting of P.cinchonarum and P.concinna, clade B is found in a clade with P.castaneocincta, P.foliata and P.neofoliata among others, and clade C is resolved as sister to P.neotinica.
Figure 1.
Extended majority-rule consensus tree resulting from the MrBayes analysis of the mtSSU and ITS alignment with Bayesian PP ≥ 0.7 and/or IQ-TREE maximum likelihood BS ≥ 50 and branch lengths. Strongly supported branches (PP ≥ 0.95 and BS ≥ 75) are marked in bold; branches only supported with PP ≥ 0.7 or BS ≥ 50 are marked with a dot above the branch. Two species of Biatora were used for rooting. Accessions belonging to the same species are collapsed for convenience. Three clades are distinguished to facilitate the discussion of new species (A, B, C). ch = chemotype.
Discussion
In this study, we present the first revision of the genus Phyllopsora for Asia and Melanesia based on the integrative study of morphology, chemistry and DNA sequence data. We investigated 625 specimens of Phyllopsora collected from 18 countries and found the material to comprise at least 28 species of Phyllopsora s. str. (Figs 2–10) including three supported clades that we describe as species new to science. With this study, the genus Phyllopsora comprises 57 species.
Figure 2.
Species of Phyllopsora occurring in Asia and Melanesia. APhyllopsoraafricana (Kistenich & Weerakoon SK1-517) BP.breviuscula (Kistenich & Weerakoon SK1-601) CP.buettneri (Thor 13183). Scale bars: 2 mm.
Figure 10.
Species of Phyllopsora occurring in Asia and Melanesia. APhyllopsorasantensis (Aguirre, James & Wolseley 2485) BP.siamenses sp. nov. (holotype, Wolseley & Boonpragob 3245) CP.subhispidula (Weerakoon 1248). Scale bars: 2 mm.
Several species seem to be rather widespread throughout Asia and Melanesia, for instance, P.castaneocincta, P.confusa, P.isidiosa, and P.porphyromelaena (Table 1, Suppl. material 2: Table S1). In contrast, specimens of, for example, P.cuyabensis, P.mediocris and P.neofoliata, are rarely collected and reported from few countries (Table 1, Suppl. material 2: Table S1). Thus, their distribution range requires further studies.
Among the 28 species of Phyllopsora, eight are reported as new for Asia and Melanesia (Table 1). One of these new species is P.africana (Fig. 2A). This species has recently been found to be morphologically and chemically heterogeneous, comprising three chemotypes (Kistenich et al. in press). In addition to the known isidiate morph, a lacinulate morph was detected among P.africana material by Kistenich et al. (in press). Moreover, they described two new chemotypes. The lacinulate morph occurred in specimens of chemotype 1 and 3, but has so far never been found in those of chemotype 2. Specimens of chemotype 2, however, were shown to be morphologically cryptic to the sister species P.swinscowii (Kistenich et al. in press). In this study, we added twelve specimens of P.africana to our phylogeny (mainly lacinulate specimens of chemotype 3), but are not able to disentangle the difficult nature of this species complex. While we found most specimens of P.africana to roughly group according to chemotype in the phylogenetic tree (Suppl. material 1: Fig. S1), one specimen of P.africana chemotype 1 (7224) was more closely related to P.swinscowii (Suppl. material 1: Fig. S1). This raises the question of whether the two species should be synonymized based on their morphological and chemical similarity in combination with the short branches in the phylogenetic tree (Suppl. material 1: Fig. S1). We refrain from synonymizing them here, awaiting more data.
The two species P.cuyabensis (Fig. 4B) and P.longiuscula (Fig. 7B) are reported as new for the Asian continent. Specimens of both species are morphologically congruent with their Neotropical representatives. In the phylogenetic tree (Suppl. material 1: Fig. S1), however, the respective Asian accessions sit on rather long branches, clearly distinct from the Neotropical specimens. In these cases, there seem to exist genetically different populations for Neotropical and Asian specimens and more specimens should be collected to investigate the extent of genetic variation.
Figure 4.
Species of Phyllopsora occurring in Asia and Melanesia. APhyllopsoraconfusa (Kistenich & Weerakoon SK1-532) BP.cuyabensis (Aguirre, James & Wolseley 2467a) CP.dolichospora (Weerakoon Si113B). Scale bars: 2 mm.
Figure 7.
Species of Phyllopsora occurring in Asia and Melanesia. APhyllopsoraloekoesii (Sharma, Olley & Cross AC5) BP.longiuscula (Weerakoon Kn136) CP.mediocris (holotype, Moberg 1481a-1, Tanzania). Scale bars: 2 mm.
The genus Phyllopsora was recently shown to be polyphyletic by Kistenich et al. (2018b). The typical growth form, which characterizes this genus, has evolved multiple times independently in the family Ramalinaceae. These findings corroborate the morphological co-evolution in tropical lichens already indicated by Lakatos et al. (2006). Hence, molecular methods are often the only means of reliably assigning specimens to Phyllopsora or rather to its morphologically similar relatives (e.g., Bacidia De Not., Bacidina Vězda, Eschatogonia, Parallopsora). It is thus not surprising that several of our sequenced specimens (Table 3) were extraneous to Phyllopsora s. str. We did not assign those specimens to genus level, but all but one belong in the Ramalinaceae. The non-Ramalinaceae specimen appears to belong in the Malmideaceae. This indicates that correct taxonomic assignment even at family level using morphology may prove challenging in certain cases. Furthermore, about a quarter of the total material investigated could not be identified, partly because many of those unidentified specimens were sterile and deficient in lichen substances. Unfortunately, we were not able to generate sequences of all unidentified specimens in the course of this study.
New species
The three new species, P.pseudocorallina, P.sabahana and P.siamensis, fall into distinct and well-supported clades in the phylogeny (Fig. 1A–C). They were originally assumed to comprise Asian populations of the species P.porphyromelaena, P.corallina and P.imshaugii, respectively, based on morphology and/or chemistry. Their sequence data, however, revealed them as separate species clearly distinct from their look-alikes (Fig. 1). Phyllopsorapseudocorallina (Fig. 9B) is distinguished from its namesake, i.e. P.corallina, by forming a partly more rosulate thallus. Poorly developed specimens, however, might be difficult to assign to the correct species. Specimens of P.sabahana (Fig. 9C) are challenging to identify based on morphology only. The species is morphologically and chemically almost identical to P.porphyromelaena chemotype 1. It differs only in forming slightly smaller ascospores. Thus, sterile specimens cannot be identified without DNA sequence data. Phyllopsorasiamensis (Fig. 10B) is described from material collected in Thailand and we have not been able to detect this species in collections from other countries. The specimens resemble P.imshaugii in morphology and chemistry, but may be readily distinguished by forming larger ascospores. See also the remarks in the Taxonomy section.
Figure 9.
Species of Phyllopsora occurring in Asia and Melanesia. APhyllopsoraporphyromelaena (Kistenich & Weerakoon SK1-572) BP.pseudocorallina sp. nov. (holotype, Kashiwadani 47806) CP.sabahana sp. nov. (holotype, Wolseley, Thüs & Vairappan S.B.oQ.3). Scale bars: 2 mm.
In addition, we found sequences of the four unidentified specimens with extraction numbers 1017, 7227, 7230, and 7231 to be resolved on rather long branches (Fig. 1, Suppl. material 1: Fig. S1). Hence, we could not assign them to any other Phyllopsora species, for which DNA sequences of the mtSSU or ITS region were available, based on molecular data, either. It is possible that these specimens represent several new species. In this study, however, we refrain from describing them as new species pending the collection of more material. Even though specimens 1017 and 7230 are clustered together in a clade with short branches (Suppl. material 1: Fig. S1), they are morphologically quite distinct and more specimens are needed to support the hypothesis that they belong to the same species.
Unconfirmed species records
Despite investigating about 600 phyllopsoroid specimens, we were not able to find in our material any specimens belonging to seven species (i.e., P.chlorophaea, P.corallina, P.isidiotyla, P.mauritiana, P.nemoralis, P.pyxinoides, and P.swinscowii) previously reported from India, South Korea, Sri Lanka, Taiwan, Thailand, and Vietnam (Table 1), respectively. We have only investigated a few collections from especially India, South Korea, Taiwan, and Vietnam (Suppl. material 2: Table S1), though. Also for the other countries, collections are limited to certain areas and we cannot exclude the species’ occurrence in other parts of the respective countries. About 23% of the investigated material could not be identified to species level and it is possible that some of these unidentified specimens represent a poorly developed individual of any of these seven species. Regarding P.corallina, for instance, we found two candidate specimens from Papua New Guinea, but DNA sequence data is necessary to resolve their species status unambiguously. Alternatively, some of these species records might be based on misidentifications. In the case of P.swinscowii, we have shown the species to be morphologically identical to the isidiate morph of P.africana, a very widespread species. It is therefore possible that the records of P.swinscowii indeed represent P.africana. In general, we have repeatedly experienced difficulties in correctly identifying species of Phyllopsora based on morphology only. For many of the species records, it remains unclear whether anatomical studies and/or chemical investigations were performed as part of the identification process or not. Especially P.chlorophaea, P.corallina and P.isidiotyla may be difficult to identify without TLC or even sequence data.
Taxonomy
This taxonomy section is a result of the integrative species delimitation process primarily based on the conclusions from the statistically inferred species delimitation analyses combined with morphological and chemical evaluations as performed in the global Phyllopsora study by Kistenich et al. (in press). The additional material of the present study complements the global dataset for the phylogenetic analysis (Fig. 1, Suppl. material 1: Fig. S1) and revealed three new species, which were mainly delimited by forming separate clades on long branches compared to their neighboring clades.
Distribution references for Asia and Melanesia are cited in Table 1; for all other distributions, references are cited below.
Phyllopsora africana
Timdal & Krog
Description.
Distribution.
Africa (Timdal and Krog 2001), Asia, Australia (Elix 2009).
Remarks.
See discussion above and Kistenich et al. (in press) for taxonomic discussion. The species (Fig. 2A) is one of the most common in our material, represented by 59 collections (Suppl. material 2: Table S1). We found both isidate and lacinulate morphs as well as representatives of all three chemotypes (i.e., chemotype 1 contains chlorophyllopsorin and argopsin; chemotype 2 contains methyl 2,7-dichloropsoromate and methyl 2,7-dichloronorpsoromate; chemotype 3 contains chlorophyllopsorin, methyl 2,7-dichloropsoromate, methyl 2,7-dichloronorpsoromate, and argopsin) among the material. It is the phylogenetic sister to P.swinscowii (Fig. 1). The species is new to Asia and Melanesia, i.e. to Indonesia, Japan, Malaysia, Papua New Guinea, The Philippines, The Solomon Islands, Sri Lanka, Thailand, and Vanuatu.
Phyllopsora breviuscula
(Nyl.) Müll. Arg.
Description.
Distribution.
Pantropical (Brako 1991, as P.parvifoliavar.breviuscula; Timdal and Krog 2001; Elix 2009).
Remarks.
Paleotropical material of this species (Fig. 2B) tends to be more narrow-lobed and ascending than Neotropical material. Species delimitation analyses by Kistenich et al. (in press) show that the taxon could be split into three or four entities, but as all sequenced specimens fell into one well-supported clade, and morphologically intermediate specimens exist, we still treat the taxon as one variable species. It is the phylogenetic sister to P.mauritiana (Fig. 1). The species is new to New Caledonia, The Philippines, and Vietnam.
Phyllopsora buettneri
(Müll. Arg.) Zahlbr.
Description.
Swinscow and Krog (1981), Timdal and Krog (2001), Timdal (2008b, as P.buettneri chemotypes 1 and 2), Elix (2009).
Distribution.
Pantropical (Brako 1991, as P.buettnerivar.buettneri; Timdal and Krog 2001; Elix 2009).
Remarks.
We recognize five chemotypes of this species, three occurring in Asia and Melanesia (Fig. 2C). Chemotype 1 (pannarin and zeorin) was found in material from Japan, Sri Lanka, and Thailand; chemotype 3 (dechloropannarin, zeorin) in material from China, Japan, Sri Lanka, and Thailand; and chemotype 5 (pannarin and an unknown compound, no zeorin) in material from Papua New Guinea and Sri Lanka (Suppl. material 2: Table S1). The specimen of chemotype 1 from Japan, and one of the two from Sri Lanka, differed from typical specimens of the chemotype in lacking zeorin. Chemotype 5 is described here for the first time, and contains an unknown compound with Rf values similar to argopsin in solvent system B’ but with a distinct blue UV366 fluorescence (not quenching) on the chromatograms after development. Chemotype 2 (pannarin, phyllopsorin, zeorin) is Neotropical and chemotype 4 (argopsin, norargopsin, zeorin) is known from the Norfolk Islands. We were unable to sequence specimens of chemotype 4 and 5, but specimens of chemotype 1–3 are resolved in a clade with chemotype 1 and 2 of P.porphyromelaena (Fig. 1, Suppl. material 1: Fig. S1). The species is new to China, Japan, and Sri Lanka.
Phyllopsora castaneocincta
(Hue) Kistenich & Timdal
Description.
Timdal and Krog (2001), Elix (2009), both as P.kiiensis.
Distribution.
Africa (Timdal and Krog 2001), Asia, Australia (Elix 2009).
Remarks.
This is one of the most common species in our material (Suppl. material 2: Table S1). It is usually easily recognized by the well-developed squamulose thallus on a reddish brown prothallus and by containing furfuraceic acid (Fig. 3A), but care is needed as about 10% of the examined specimens were actually deficient in lichen substances. It is new to Cambodia, Malaysia, Nepal, New Caledonia, Papua New Guinea, The Solomon Islands, Taiwan, and Thailand.
Figure 3.
Species of Phyllopsora occurring in Asia and Melanesia. A Phyllopsoracastaneocincta (Kirika, Mugambi, & Lumbsch 3011) B P.chodatinica (Paukov 2232) C P.cinchonarum (Thor 21521). Scale bars: 2 mm.
Phyllopsora chodatinica
Elix
Description.
Elix (2006, 2009).
Distribution.
Australasia (Elix 2009) and Oceania.
Remarks.
This species resembles P.porphyromelaena and P.sabahana, to which it is closely related in the phylogenetic tree (Fig. 1), but differs in the presence of xanthones and the absence of argopsin and norargopsin. Kistenich et al. (in press) showed that probably all Neotropical records of this species (e.g., by Timdal 2008b, 2011) belong in another species, P.neotinica. Phyllopsorachodatinica (Fig. 3B) is new to Malaysia, New Caledonia, and Vanuatu.
Phyllopsora cinchonarum
(Fée) Timdal
Description.
Brako (1989, as Squamacidiajaneirensis), Timdal (2008b), Elix (2009, as Triclinumcinchonarum).
Distribution.
Central and South America (Brako 1989; Timdal 2008b), Asia, Australia (Elix 2009).
Remarks.
The species is recognized by the squamulose thallus on a white prothallus, long isidia, and the presence of lobaric acid (Fig. 3C). Several additional compounds are reported, for example atranorin, fumarprotocetraric acid, and a scarlet pigment. In our Asian material, we have encountered only lobaric acid (always major), atranorin (minor to absent), and some unknown compounds (minor to absent). It is the phylogenetic sister to the Neotropical P.concinna (Fig. 1).
Phyllopsora confusa
Swinscow & Krog
Description.
Swinscow and Krog (1981), Timdal and Krog (2001), Elix (2009).
Distribution.
Pantropical (Brako 1991; Timdal and Krog 2001; Elix 2009).
Remarks.
This species is characterized by the small, lacinulate squamules lacking lichen substances (Fig. 4A), but may be difficult to separate from, for example, P.foliata and P.mediocris. It is also possible that some of the specimens we have left undetermined belong in this species. We have sequenced nine specimens from Asia and Melanesia (Table 2), in addition to the holotype from Kenya, and those specimens make up the core in our concept of this species. The accessions of P.confusa form a strongly supported clade with P.loekoesii in the phylogenetic tree (Fig. 1). The two specimens from Papua New Guinea (6360 and 6361) fall in between the P.confusa and P.loekoesii clade (Suppl. material 1: Fig. S1) and show an intermediate morphology. Further specimens are needed to investigate the possible synonymy of these two species. Phyllopsoraconfusa is new to Indonesia, Japan, Malaysia, Taiwan, and Thailand.
Phyllopsora cuyabensis
(Malme) Zahlbr.
Description.
Distribution.
Central and South America (Brako 1991; Timdal 2008b), Asia.
Remarks.
The species is represented by a single specimen from Thailand in our material (Fig. 4B). The Asian accession (450) falls into a strongly supported clade with sequences from four Neotropical specimens, although resolved on a long branch as sister to all Neotropical accessions (Suppl. material 1: Fig. S1). Being morphologically identical to the Neotropical specimens, it is unclear whether this specimen (450) represents a new species or merely genetic variation within P.cuyabensis. Additional sequences of Asian specimens are necessary to evaluate this possibility further. The species is sister to a clade comprising P.byssiseda, P.fendleri and P.kalbii (Fig. 1). The species is new to Asia.
Phyllopsora dolichospora
Timdal & Krog
Description.
Distribution.
Africa (Timdal and Krog 2001), Asia.
Remarks.
This species (Fig. 4C) is morphologically and chemically (furfuraceic acid) similar to P.furfuracea, to which it is closely related (Fig. 1), but differs in forming longer ascospores and in containing additional substances (methyl furfuraceiate and methyl homofurfuraceiate). Judging from the number of examined specimens (Suppl. material 2: Table S1), P.dolichospora seems to be more common than P.furfuracea in Asia, although the number of reports (Table 1) suggests the opposite. This, however, might be a result of morphological misidentifications when TLC has not been run. The species is new to Japan and Papua New Guinea.
Phyllopsora foliata
(Stirt.) Zahlbr.
Description.
Distribution.
Asia, Australia (Elix 2009).
Remarks.
This rarely reported Australian species (Fig. 5A) is here confirmed from Japan and Sri Lanka mainly based on our DNA sequences (both mtSSU and ITS), which were compared with sequences obtained from Australian material (Table 2). It is new to Japan.
Figure 5.
Species of Phyllopsora occurring in Asia and Melanesia. APhyllopsorafoliata (Kistenich & Weerakoon SK1-627) BP.furfuracea (Wolseley & Aguirre-Hudson 4025) CP.gossypina (Kistenich & Weerakoon SK1-524). Scale bars: 2 mm.
Phyllopsora furfuracea
(Pers.) Zahlbr.
Description.
Distribution.
Pantropical (Brako 1991; Timdal and Krog 2001; Elix 2009).
Remarks.
Despite widespread reports in the literature, we were able to confirm the presence of this species (Fig. 5B) in Papua New Guinea, Sri Lanka, and Thailand, only. In the phylogenetic tree, P.furfuracea forms a clade with P.dolichospora and P.foliatella (Fig. 1).
Phyllopsora gossypina
(Sw.) Kistenich, Timdal, Bendiksby & S. Ekman
Description.
Distribution.
Apparently pantropical.
Remarks.
The species (Fig. 5C) was included in the genus Crocynia until recently (Kistenich et al. 2018b), and not originally a part of our taxon sampling; hence the few specimens examined. The accession from Sri Lanka (7201) clusters together with specimens of C.molliuscula (Suppl. material 1: Fig. S1), from which it is morphologically and chemically different. Further specimens need to be investigated to inform about its relationship to C.molliuscula. The species is the phylogenetic sister to P.imshaugii (Fig. 1).
Phyllopsora halei
(Tuck.) Zahlbr.
Description.
Swinscow and Krog (1981, as P.pannosa), Timdal and Krog (2001).
Distribution.
North America (Brako 1991), Africa (Timdal and Krog 2001), Asia.
Remarks.
This species (Fig. 6A) was previously known from the type collection from North America (Louisiana), East Africa (Ethiopia, Kenya, Tanzania), and a few reports from Asia (Table 1). We here confirm its presence in Asia, based on DNA sequences from material from Sri Lanka compared with sequences from Kenya and Tanzania (Suppl. material 1: Fig. S1). Three chemotypes of this species are known (Timdal and Krog 2001), differing in terpenoid patterns and presence of an unknown compound. Our two specimens from Sri Lanka belong in chemotype 3 of Timdal and Krog (2001). The species is the phylogenetic sister to P.amazonica (Fig. 1). It is new to Sri Lanka.
Figure 6.
Species of Phyllopsora occurring in Asia and Melanesia. APhyllopsorahalei (Weerakoon 1008) BP.isidiosa (Diederich 13210) CP.kalbii (Aguirre, James & Wolseley 2695). Scale bars: 2 mm.
Phyllopsora himalayensis
G.K. Mishra, Upreti & Nayaka
Description.
Distribution.
India (Mishra et al. 2011).
Remarks.
The species was not studied by us due to lack of response from LWG to our repeated loan requests.
Phyllopsora isidiosa
Kistenich & Timdal
Description.
Distribution.
Pantropical, also occurring in temperate Asia and North America (Kistenich et al. in press).
Remarks.
The species (Fig. 6B) is treated in detail by Kistenich et al. (in press). It is closely related to, for instance, P.dolichospora, P.foliatella, and P.furfuracea (Fig. 1).
Phyllopsora kalbii
Brako
Description.
Distribution.
North, Central, and South America (Brako 1991), Africa (Timdal and Krog 2001), Asia.
Remarks.
The species (Fig. 6C) was reported from India by Mishra et al (2011), and we confirm its presence in Asia by DNA sequences (mtSSU and ITS; 456) from material from Thailand. The species is sister to a clade comprising P.byssiseda and P.fendleri (Fig. 1). It is new to Thailand.
Phyllopsora loekoesii
S.Y. Kondr., E. Farkas, S.–O. Oh & Hur
Description.
Distribution.
Asia.
Remarks.
The species (Fig. 7A) was recently described from South Korea by Kondratyuk et al. (2016), and we report it as new to Japan and Nepal. Our sequences were compared to unpublished sequences of the holo- and isotype kindly provided to us by Sergey Kondratyuk. Our accessions form a strongly supported clade together with accessions of P.confusa (Fig. 1), from which it is difficult to distinguish. See also remarks for P.confusa.
Phyllopsora longiuscula
(Nyl.) Zahlbr.
Description.
Distribution.
Central and South America (Brako 1991), Asia, Australia (Kistenich et al. in press).
Remarks.
In the concept of Brako (1991) and Timdal (2011), this species is lacinulate. Kistenich et al. (in press), however, extend the concept to include the isidiate species P.intermediella, which they synonymize. The Asian material we have examined is lacinulate. The species (Fig. 7B) is the phylogenetic sister to P.thaleriza (Fig. 1). It is new to Asia (Sri Lanka, Thailand, and Vietnam).
Phyllopsora mediocris
Swinscow & Krog
Description.
Distribution.
Africa (Timdal and Krog 2001), Asia.
Remarks.
The species (Fig. 7C) was previously known from East Africa and the Mascarenes (Timdal and Krog 2001). Although not sequenced, we here report it as new to Asia based on a specimen (Moberg 2750, UPS) from Sri Lanka (Suppl. material 2: Table S1). The species is the phylogenetic sister to P.parvifolia (Fig. 1).
Phyllopsora neofoliata
Elix
Description.
Elix (2006, 2009).
Distribution.
Africa (Kistenich et al. in press), Asia, Australia (Elix 2009).
Remarks.
This originally Australian species is reported as new to Africa (Kenya) by Kistenich et al. (in press) and here as new to Asia (Sri Lanka; Fig. 8A). Both the African and Sri Lankan specimens were sequenced (mtSSU and ITS) and found to conform with sequences of an isotype (O L-1319). The species is generally identified by the squamulose, lacinulate thallus containing furfuraceic acid.
Figure 8.
Species of Phyllopsora occurring in Asia and Melanesia. APhyllopsoraneofoliata (Weerakoon WL21) BP.parvifolia (Kistenich & Weerakoon SK1-661) CP.parvifoliella (James & Wolseley 2491). Scale bars: 2 mm.
Phyllopsora parvifolia
(Pers.) Müll. Arg.
Description.
Distribution.
Pantropical, but mainly Neotropical, extending into the temperate zones in North and South America and in Europe (Brako 1991, as P.parvifoliavar.parvifolia; Kistenich et al. in press).
Remarks.
Despite several reports from Asia and Melanesia (Table 1), we have seen only a single specimen of this species (Sri Lanka, Kistenich & Weerakoon SK1-661, PDA, not sequenced; Fig. 8B) from the area. The species is the phylogenetic sister to P.mediocris (Fig. 1). It is new to Sri Lanka.
Phyllopsora parvifoliella
(Nyl.) Müll. Arg.
Description.
Distribution.
Central and South America (Brako 1991; Timdal 2008b), Asia.
Remarks.
This squamulose, isidiate species contains atranorin and parvifoliellin (Fig. 8C); characters it shares with P.concinna and P.rappiana. The molecular phylogeny (Fig. 1) shows that the three species are not closely related, though; rather P.parvifoliella belongs in a clade together with P.africana, P.ochroxantha, and P.swinscowii. We have sequenced material from Indonesia and Thailand, and here report the species as new to Asia and Melanesia, i.e. from Indonesia, Papua New Guinea, The Philippines, and Thailand.
Phyllopsora porphyromelaena
(Vain.) Zahlbr.
Description.
Timdal and Krog (2001), Elix (2009), both as P.albicans.
Distribution.
Pantropical (Brako 1991, as P.buettnerivar.glauca chemical stains I and III; Timdal and Krog 2001; Elix 2009).
Remarks.
This is the most common species in our material from Asia and Melanesia (Fig. 9A), despite previous records only from India, The Philippines, and Taiwan (mostly as P.albicans). Two chemotypes are previously recognized, and a third is recognized here. Chemotype 1 (argopsin and norargopsin) and chemotype 2 (argopsin and pannarin) are both widely distributed in Asia and Melanesia, but chemotype 3 (zeorin and three unknown compounds) is restricted to Thailand (Suppl. material 2: Table S1). The unknown compounds move in Rf-classes A:3–4, B’:4–5, C:5 (major compound); A:6, B’:6, C:5–6 (minor compound); and A:3, B’:3, C:5 (minor compound).
In the phylogenetic tree (Fig. 1, Suppl. material 1: Fig. S1), accessions of chemotypes 1 and 2 group into a weakly supported clade with P.buettneri, while accessions of chemotype 3 form a clade with P.chodatinica and the P.buettneri/P.porphyromelaena clade. Additional specimens of chemotype 3 should be sequenced to find out whether it indeed represents a chemical strain of P.porphyromelaena or rather a distinct species.
The species is morphologically very similar to P.sabahana; see that species for discussion. It is possible that some specimens listed as P.porphyromelaena chemotype 1 in Suppl. material 2: Table S1, especially those from Malaysia, represent P.sabahana. It is new to Fiji, Indonesia, Japan, Malaysia, New Caledonia, Papua New Guinea, South Korea, Sri Lanka, and Thailand.
Phyllopsora pseudocorallina
Kistenich & Timdal sp. nov
829572
Diagnosis.
Differs from P.corallina in having a more rosulate thallus and in substitutions in the mtSSU and ITS sequences.
Type.
CAMBODIA, Siem Reap: around Ta Nei temple, Angkor Wats complex, 13°27'N, 103°53'E, ca. 30 m alt., on rock (sand stone), 2005-12-20, H. Kashiwadani 47806 (TNS!—holotype) [TLC: no lichen substances; DNA: MK412430 (mtSSU), MK412491 (ITS)].
Description.
Thallus effuse or forming irregular rosettes up to 1 cm diam., squamulose; squamules medium sized, up to 1 mm wide, adnate to ascending, elongate, contiguous or partly imbricate, crenulate to incised, plane to weakly convex, medium green, glabrous on the upper side, faintly pubescent along the margin; isidia common, attached marginally to the squamules, cylindrical, simple or slightly branched, up to 0.1 mm wide and 0.6 mm long; upper cortex formed by thick-walled hyphae with rounded lumina (type 2), 20–30 µm thick; cortex and medulla not containing crystals (PD–, K–); prothallus indistinct to partly well developed, white.
Apothecia common, up to 1.5 mm diam., rounded when young, later often becoming irregular, simple or sometimes somewhat conglomerate, plane to moderately convex, yellowish to medium brown, with an indistinct, usually slightly paler, glabrous to finely pubescent margin; excipulum pale brown to colourless, K–; hypothecium pale brown to colourless, K–; epithecium colourless; no crystals in apothecium; ascospores narrowly ellipsoid to shortly bacilliform, simple, 6–10 × 2.5–3 µm (n=30). Conidiomata not seen.
Chemistry.
No lichen substances.
Distribution.
Cambodia, Malaysia, Papua New Guinea, The Seychelles.
Etymology.
The specific epithet refers to its morphological and chemical similarity to P.corallina.
Remarks.
The species is morphologically, anatomically, and chemically very similar to P.corallina. There is, however, a tendency of P.pseudocorallina being more rosulate, i.e., composed of more radiating and elongated marginal lobes. The phylogenetic tree (Fig. 1), however, shows the two species not to be closely related: P.corallina is resolved in a clade with P.glaucella and P.rappiana as sister to P.martinii, while P.pseudocorallina appears in a clade with P.castaneocincta and P.neofoliata among others (Fig. 1). The new species is widely distributed in Asia and also found on The Seychelles. It is unclear whether P.corallina occurs in Asia at all or if previously reported specimens of P.corallina rather represent specimens of P.pseudocorallina.
Additional specimens examined.
MALAYSIA, Sabah: Malaysian Borneo, Maliau, “Knowledge Trail”, pristine lowland dipterocarp forest; on stem (ca. 20 m high) of fallen tree on crushed bridge, 2012, H. Thüs, P. Wolseley & C. Vairappan M001a (BORH) [DNA: MK412437 (mtSSU)]; same locality data, H. Thüs, P. Wolseley & C. Vairappan M001b (BORH); same locality data, H. Thüs, P. Wolseley & C. Vairappan M005 (BORH) [DNA: MK412438 (mtSSU)]. PAPUA NEW GUINEA, Madang: Manam island, near Bogia, in gardens near Budua, 4°07'S, 145°00'E, 50 m alt., epiphytic, 1992-07-22, P. Diederich 11386 (hb. Diederich) [DNA: MK412449 (mtSSU), MK412495 (ITS)]. THE SEYCHELLES, Mahé: W of Anse Royale, Le Jardin du Roi, 4.74642S, 55.50297E, 150–200 m alt., parkland and neighbouring forest, on rock, 2015-07-26, P. Diederich 17809 (hb. Diederich); Port Glaud, near Sauzier Waterfall, 4.65847S, 55.41403E, 20–70 m alt., on tree, 2015-07-28, P. Diederich 17897 (hb. Diederich).
Phyllopsora sabahana
Kistenich & Timdal sp. nov.
829571
Diagnosis.
Differs from P.porphyromelaena in having smaller ascospores and in substitutions in the mtSSU and ITS sequences.
Type.
MALAYSIA, Sabah: Malaysian Borneo, SAFE-project Area, mostly Macaranga dominated secondary forest, 2012, P. Wolseley, H. Thüs & C. Vairappan S.B.oQ.3 (BORH!—holotype) [TLC: argopsin (major), norargopsin (minor); DNA: MK412434 (mtSSU)].
Description.
Thallus effuse, squamulose; squamules medium sized, up to 0.8 mm wide, ascending, elongated, often imbricate, incised to deeply divided, plane to weakly convex; upper side pale green to medium green, glabrous, epruinose; margin concolorous with upper side, often finely pubescent; lacinules common, developing from lobe-tips; upper cortex formed by thick-walled hyphae with cylindrical lumina (type 1), 30–40 µm thick, containing crystals dissolving in K (PD+ orange, K–); medulla containing crystals partly dissolving in K (PD+ orange, K–); prothallus well developed, reddish brown.
Apothecia not common, up to 2 mm diam., rounded to irregular, simple or soon becoming conglomerate, weakly to moderately convex, yellowish brown, more or less immarginate even when young; excipulum pale brown to colourless, K–; hypothecium medium brown, K–; epithecium pale brown to colorless; no crystals in apothecia; ascospores narrowly ellipsoid, simple, 6–8 × 2–2.5 µm (n=20). Conidiomata not seen.
Chemistry.
Argopsin (major), norargopsin (minor). Medulla and upper cortex PD+ orange, K–, C–, KC–.
Distribution.
Malaysia (Borneo).
Etymology.
The specific epithet refers to its occurrence in Sabah, Malaysia.
Remarks.
The species is morphologically and chemically very similar to P.porphyromelaena chemotype 1, and is close to be regarded as a morphologically cryptic species. It may, however, be distinguished in forming smaller ascospores (6–8 × 2–2.5 vs. 8–13 × 2–4 µm). Apothecia are not common in neither species, however, and the measurements are based on only 20 spores from each species (the holotype of P.sabahana and two specimens of P.porphyromelaena from La Réunion). In the phylogenetic tree (Fig. 1), the five accessions of P.sabahana form a strongly supported clade as sister to the Neotropical species P.neotinica, from which it may readily be distinguished in its composition of lichen substances (P.neotinica contains xanthones). So far, P.sabahana is only known from Borneo.
Additional specimens examined.
MALAYSIA, Sabah: Malaysian Borneo: Maliau Basin, surroundings of Agathis Camp, pristine lowland Dipterocarp forest, 2012, P. Wolseley, H. Thüs & C. Vairappan, C. M089 (BORH) [DNA: MK412441 (mtSSU)]; Danum valley, pristine lowland Dipterocarp forest, 2012, P. Wolseley, H. Thüs & C Vairappan D.8.02.4 (BORH) [DNA: MK412442 (mtSSU)]; Ranau district, Kinabalu park, Tambuyukon trail, Kera camp (loc. T089), 6°12.742'N, 116°43.609'E, 728 m alt., epiphytic, 2014-12-08, A. Paukov 2229 (B) [DNA: MK412455 (mtSSU), MK412498 (ITS)] & 2230 (B) [DNA: MK412453 (mtSSU), MK412496 (ITS)].
Phyllopsora santensis
(Tuck.) Swinscow & Krog
Description.
Distribution.
North, Central, and South America (Brako 1991, as P.corallinavar.santensis; Timdal 2008b), Asia, Australia (Elix 2009).
Remarks.
The species was previously reported from Japan, Papua New Guinea, and The Philippines (Table 1), and is here reported from four localities in Thailand (Fig. 10A). We were unable to produce DNA sequences from our material, and the identification is based on typical morphology and presence of argopsin (major) and noragopsin (minor). New to Thailand.
Phyllopsora siamensis
Kistenich & Timdal sp. nov.
829573
Diagnosis.
Differs from P.imshaugii in having more well developed squamules, larger ascospores, and in substitutions in the mtSSU and ITS sequences.
Type.
THAILAND, Lampang: Doi Khun Tan National Park, loc. T118, 18°25'N, 99°14'E, 1000 m alt., hill evergreen forest, 1993-01-11, P.A. Wolseley & K. Boonpragob 3245 (BM 749856!—holotype) [TLC: norstictic acid; DNA MK412410 (mtSSU), MK412477 (ITS)].
Description.
Thallus effuse, crustose to squamulose; squamules small, up to 0.4 mm wide, adnate, isodiametrical, more or less scattered when young, later contiguous or fusing, more or less crenulate, plane to weakly convex; upper side medium green, somewhat shiny, epruinose, glabrous; margin concolorous with upper side, often pubescent; isidia common, attached marginally to the squamules, cylindrical, simple or slightly branched, up to 0.15 mm wide and 1.5 mm long; upper cortex formed by thick-walled hyphae with rounded lumina (type 2), 15–30 µm thick, containing a few scattered crystals dissolving in K; medulla containing crystals dissolving in K and recrystallizing by forming acicular, red crystals, PD+ yellow, K+ red; prothallus well developed, thick, white.
Apothecia seen in the holotype only, up to 1.5 mm diam., more or less plane when young, soon becoming weakly to moderately convex, medium brown, rounded to irregular, simple, when young with a rather thick, paler, weakly pubescent margin, later becoming more or less immarginate; excipulum pale brown in the rim, darker brown in inner part; hypothecium dark brown, K–; crystals present in inner part of exciple and in hypothecium, dissolving in K and recrystallizing by forming acicular, red crystals; epithecium pale brown to colourless, K–; ascospores narrowly ellipsoid or fusiform to bacilliform, simple, 15–22 × 3.5–4.5 µm (n=20). Conidiomata not seen.
Chemistry.
Norstictic acid (major), atranorin (minor to trace or absent). Medulla PD+ yellow, K+ red, C–, KC–.
Distribution.
Thailand.
Etymology.
The specific epithet refers to its occurrence in Thailand.
Remarks.
The species is morphologically and chemically very similar to P.imshaugii. Phyllopsorasiamensis, however, may be distinguished by forming slightly larger squamules and longer ascospores (15–22 × 3.5–4.5 vs 10.5–14.5 × 3–4 µm; the latter measurements are based on 40 spores in the type material from Jamaica) than P.imshaugii. So far, P.imshaugii is only known to occur in the Neotropics, while P.siamensis is solely known from Thailand. In the phylogenetic tree (Fig. 1), the four accessions of P.siamensis cluster in a strongly supported clade as sister to a clade comprising P.cinchonarum and P.concinna, from which the new species is readily distinguished by its chemistry. Phyllopsoraimshaugii and P.siamensis are the only Phyllopsora species known to contain norstictic acid; the major compound of the two other species are lobaric acid and parvifoliellin, respectively.
Additional specimens examined.
THAILAND, Chiang Mai: Doi Suthep National Park headquarters walk, loc. 62.4, 18°48'N, 98°54'E, 1050 m alt., tropical mixed deciduous forest, on Lauraceae, 1993-03-27, B. Aguirre–Hudson & P.A. Wolseley 1643 (BM 749866) [DNA: MK412419 (mtSSU), MK412485 (ITS)]; Uthai Thani: Khao Nang Rum, Cathouse site, 15°29'N, 99°18'E, 650 m alt., tropical mixed deciduous forest, 1992-01-07, P.A. Wolseley & B. Aguirre–Hudson 5580 p.p. (BM 1031552 p.p.) [DNA: MK412423 (mtSSU), MK412487 (ITS)]; Khao Nang Rum, Khao Kiew, 15°27'N, 99°20'E, 1250 m alt., oak/chestnut forest, 1992-01-23, P.A. Wolseley and Onsar 5590 (BM 749833) [DNA: MK412418 (mtSSU), MK412484 (ITS)].
Phyllopsora subhispidula
(Nyl.) Kalb & Elix
Description.
Distribution.
Africa (Timdal and Krog 2001), Asia.
Remarks.
This species resembles closely the more common P.buettneri, but differs in forming isidia, not lacinules (Fig. 10C). It contains argopsin (major), norargopsin (minor), zeorin (major), and sometimes atranorin (trace), similar to chemotype 4 of P.buettneri. Phylogenetically (Fig. 1), the two species are not closely related, though. Phyllopsorasubhispidula is sister to the clade comprising P.nemoralis and P.hispaniolae/P.rosei (Fig. 1). It is new to Asia (Sri Lanka).
Key to the phyllopsoroid genera in Asia and Melanesia
1 | Apothecia zeorine, surrounded by a thalline sheath | Physcidia p.p. |
– | Apothecia biatorin | 2 |
2(1) | Tholus non-amyloid or with an indistinct conical amyloid structure; ascospores filiform, spirally arranged in ascus; thallus and apothecia with red or purple patches caused by non-crystalline, acetone-insoluble pigment | Krogia |
– | Tholus with a distinct amyloid conical structure (Bacidia type); ascospores ellipsoid to filiform, not spirally arranged in ascus; thallus and apothecia without red patches | 3 |
3(2) | Upper and lower cortices formed by a single layer of isodiametric cells, continuous over the edge of the areolae/squamule | Eschatogonia |
– | Upper cortex multicellular or poorly differentiated; lower cortex absent | 4 |
4(2) | Ascospores ellipsoid to fusiform, simple or rarely pseudoseptate | 5 |
– | Ascospores bacilliform to filiform, septate or pseudoseptate | 6 |
5(4) | Apothecia and prothallus blackish brown to black; isidia lacking; thallus containing fumarprotocetraric acid | ‘Phyllopsora’ cfr. nigrocincta (Malmideaceae) |
– | Apothecia brown; prothallus white to dark reddish brown; isidia present or absent; if fumarprotocetraric acid present, then isidia present | Phyllopsora |
6(4) | Thallus sorediat | 7 |
– | Thallus not sorediate | 8 |
7(6) | Squamules mostly adnate, bursting into convex soralia, containing atranorin and divaricatic acid | ‘Phyllopsora’ sorediata |
– | Squamules ascending, with labriform soralia, containing methyl barbatate and often terpenoids | ‘Phyllopsora’ glaucescens |
8(6) | Thallus large, subfoliose, isidiate | ‘Physcidia’ cylindrophora |
– | Thallus crustose to squamulose, not isidiate | 9 |
9(8) | Thallus formed by ascending squamules, lacinulate, containing stictic acid | Parallopsora sp.* |
– | Thallus crustose or formed by adnate squamules, not lacinulate, not containing lichen substances | 10 |
10(9) | Thallus crustose | Sporacestra |
– | Thallus squamulose | Aciculopsora |
Key to the species of Phyllopsora in Asia and Melanesia
1 | Thallus pruinose, rosulate, broad-lobed | 2 |
– | Thallus not pruinose, effuse to rosulate, narrow to broad-lobed | 3 |
2(1) | Thallus lacinulate, containing pannarin, dechloropannarin or rarely argopsin | P. buettneri |
– | Thallus isidiate, containing argopsin | P. subhispidula |
3(1) | Upper cortex absent or poorly developed | 4 |
– | Upper cortex well developed | 5 |
4(3) | Species always apotheciate; isidia lacking; apothecia plain to concave, with a pale margin; lichen substances present | P. gossypina |
– | Species apotheciate or not; isidia often present; apothecia convex, more or less immarginate; lichen substances absent | P. cuyabensis |
5(3) | Medulla K+ red (norstictic acid) | P. siamensis |
– | Medulla K– | 6 |
6(5) | Medulla PD+ orange to red | 7 |
– | Medulla PD– | 10 |
7(6) | Prothallus white or absent; lacinules absent | P. santensis |
– | Prothallus brown; lacinules present or absent | 8 |
8(7) | Squamules isodiametrical or shortly elongate, more or less adnate, containing chlorophyllopsorin or methyl 2,7-dichloronorpsoromate; isidia or lacinules present | P. africana |
– | Squamules elongate, ascending, lacking chlorophyllopsorin and methyl 2,7-dichloronorpsoromate; lacinules present | 9 |
9(8) | Ascospores narrowly ellipsoid, 6–8 × 2–2.5 µm | P. sabahana |
– | Ascospores narrowly ellipsoid to fusiform or bacilliform, 8.0–12.5 × 2.5–3.5 µm | P. porphyromelaena |
10(6) | Thallus isidiate | 11 |
– | Thallus phyllidiate, lacinulate or apotheciate | 20 |
11(10) | Prothallus white or absent | 12 |
– | Prothallus brown | 15 |
12(11) | Isidia often more than 1 mm long, mainly simple; ascospores bacilliform to acicular, 26–41 × 2–3 µm; containing lobaric acid | P. cinchonarum |
– | Isidia shorter than 1 mm, globular to coralloid; ascospores ellipsoid to shortly bacilliform, less than 12 µm long; containing only atranorin or no lichen substance | 13 |
13(12) | Isidia globular; thallus containing atranorin; crystals present in medulla and hypothecium | P. himalayensis |
– | Isidia cylindrical to coralloid; thallus and apothecia lacking lichen substances and crystals | 14 |
14(13) | Isidia becoming coralloid; species crustose, effuse; areoles up to 0.1 mm diameter | P. isidiosa |
– | Isidia cylindrical or weakly branched; species squamulose, effuse or rosulate; squamules up to 1 mm diameter | P. pseudocorallina |
15(11) | Thallus crustose, consisting of more or less scattered areoles or sometimes isidia only | 16 |
– | Thallus squamulose | 17 |
16(15) | Ascospores narrowly ellipsoid, 7–13 × 2–3 µm; containing furfuraceic acid only | P. furfuracea |
– | Ascospores bacilliform, 16–25 × 2–3 µm; containing furfuraceic acid and 2–3 related compounds | P. dolichospora |
17(15) | Prothallus thick, forming a cushion with colonizing areoles along the periphery | 18 |
– | Prothallus thin, not forming a cushion | 19 |
18(17) | Thallus containing atranorin and terpenoids | P. halei |
– | Thallus containing furfuraceic acid or rarely no compounds | P. castaneocincta |
19(17) | Isidia globular or shortly cylindrical; thallus pale green, containing atranorin or no lichen substances | P. kalbii |
– | Isidia cylindrical; thallus dark green to brown, containing atranorin and parvifoliellin | P. parvifoliella |
20(10) | Thallus containing xanthones | P. chodatinica |
– | Thallus not containing xanthones | 21 |
21(20) | Thallus containing furfuraceic acid | P. neofoliata |
– | Thallus not containing lichen substances | 22 |
22(21) | Prothallus brown, well developed | 23 |
– | Prothallus white or absent | 27 |
23(22) | Thallus rosulate or composed of elongated squamules | 24 |
– | Thallus effuse, composed of more or less isodiametrical squamules | 26 |
24(23) | Thallus phyllidiate; phyllidia mainly occurring in central part of thallus | P. parvifolia |
– | Thallus lacinulate | 25 |
25(24) | Squamules long, linear, deeply incised to branched | P. breviuscula |
– | Squamules short, crenulate to narrowly incised | P. mediocris |
26(23) | Thallus crustose, consisting of closely adnate areoles and ascending lacinules | P. longiuscula |
– | Thallus squamulose, consisting of ascending squamules, breaking into lacinules | P. confusa |
27(22) | Thallus phyllidiate; phyllidia mainly occurring in central part of thallus | P. parvifolia |
– | Thallus lacinulate | 28 |
28(27) | Squamules closely adnate, elongated, linear, somewhat branched | P. loekoesii |
– | Squamules ascending, short, not branched | 29 |
29(28) | Ascospores narrowly ellipsoid to fusiform, 11–20 × 2–3 µm | P. foliata |
– | Ascospores narrowly ellipsoid to shortly bacilliform, 9–11 × 2–2.5 µm | P. confusa |
Supplementary Material
Acknowledgements
We are grateful to the following herbaria for providing loans of material for our study: B, E, H, TNS, and UPS, in addition to the private herbarium of P. Diederich. We would like to thank S. Kondratyuk for providing sequences of the type material of P.loekoesii. ET, MB and SK thank Siri Rui for curatorial assistance at the Natural History Museum, University of Oslo (Norway). Special thanks are due to everyone who accompanied the authors in the field in Indonesia, Malaysia, Sri Lanka and Thailand. We acknowledge the Sabah Biodiversity Council, the administration units at Danum Valley and Maliau Conservation Areas for granting permits to access and work in the studied sites in the framework of the NHM “Danum-Maliau Quantitative Inventory” (JKM/MBS.1000-2/2 (77), MBMC 2012/15) and for the provision of logistic support. GW is thankful for the Research funding received from National Geographic Society (USA) and Dilmah Conservation (Sri Lanka) to conduct fieldwork in Sri Lanka in 2017. SW and GW are grateful for the collecting and export permits from Forest and Wildlife departments of Sri Lanka. The Science library at the University of Oslo (Norway) is acknowledged for its financial support to SK for open access publishing.
Citation
Kistenich S, Bendiksby M, Vairappan CS, Weerakoon G, Wijesundara S, Wolseley PA, Timdal E (2019) A regional study of the genus Phyllopsora (Ramalinaceae) in Asia and Melanesia. MycoKeys 53: 23–72. https://doi.org/10.3897/mycokeys.53.33425
Footnotes
unpublished data
Supplementary materials
This dataset is made available under the Open Database License (http://opendatacommons.org/licenses/odbl/1.0/). The Open Database License (ODbL) is a license agreement intended to allow users to freely share, modify, and use this Dataset while maintaining this same freedom for others, provided that the original source and author(s) are credited.
Sonja Kistenich, Mika Bendiksby, Charles S. Vairappan, Gothamie Weerakoon, Siril Wijesundara, Patricia A. Wolseley, Einar Timdal
Uncollapsed version of the tree presented in Fig. 1
Data type: phylogenetic data
Explanation note: Extended majority-rule consensus tree resulting from the MrBayes analysis of the mtSSU and ITS alignment with Bayesian PP ≥ 0.7 and/or IQ-TREE maximum likelihood BS ≥ 50 and branch lengths. Strongly supported branches (PP ≥ 0.95 and BS ≥ 75) are marked in bold; branches with PP ≥ 0.95 and BS < 75 or PP < 0.95 and BS ≥ 75 are marked in bold grey; branches only supported with PP ≥ 0.7 or BS ≥ 50 are marked with a dot above the branch. Two species of Biatora were used for rooting. Terminal names include DNA extraction number, species name and when relevant, chemotype (ch). Three clades are distinguished to facilitate the discussion of new species (A, B, C).
This dataset is made available under the Open Database License (http://opendatacommons.org/licenses/odbl/1.0/). The Open Database License (ODbL) is a license agreement intended to allow users to freely share, modify, and use this Dataset while maintaining this same freedom for others, provided that the original source and author(s) are credited.
Sonja Kistenich, Mika Bendiksby, Charles S. Vairappan, Gothamie Weerakoon, Siril Wijesundara, Patricia A. Wolseley, Einar Timdal
Specimens of Phyllopsora examined in this study
Data type: specimens data
References
- Altekar G, Dwarkadas S, Huelsenbeck JP, Ronquist F. (2004) Parallel metropolis coupled Markov chain Monte Carlo for Bayesian phylogenetic inference. Bioinformatics 20: 407–415. 10.1093/bioinformatics/btg427 [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Aptroot A. (1997) Lichen biodiversity in Papua New Guinea, with report of 173 species on one tree. Bibliotheca Lichenologica 68: 203–213. [Google Scholar]
- Aptroot A, Iqbal SH. (2011) Some lichens of Bangladesh. The Bryologist 114: 466–468. 10.1639/0007-2745-114.3.466 [DOI] [Google Scholar]
- Aptroot A, Diederich P, Sérusiaux E, Sipman HJM. (1997) Lichens and lichenicolous fungi from New Guinea. Bibliotheca Lichenologica 64: 1–220. [Google Scholar]
- Aptroot A, Saipunkaew W, Sipman H, Sparrius L, Wolseley P. (2007) New lichens from Thailand, mainly microlichens from Chiang Mai. Fungal diversity 24: 75–134. [Google Scholar]
- Aptroot A, Sparrius LB. (2003) New microlichens from Taiwan. Fungal diversity 14: 1–50. [Google Scholar]
- Aptroot A, Sparrius LB. (2006) Additions to the Lichen Flora of Vietnam, with an Annotated Checklist and Bibliography. The Bryologist 109: 358–371. 10.1639/0007-2745(2006)109[358:ATTLFO]2.0.CO;2 [DOI]
- Brako L. (1989) Reevaluation of the genus Phyllopsora with taxonomic notes and introduction of Squamacidia, gen. nov. Mycotaxon 35: 1–19. [Google Scholar]
- Brako L. (1991) Phyllopsora (Bacidiaceae). Flora Neotropica: 1–66.
- Buaruang K, Boonpragob K, Mongkolsuk P, Sangvichien E, Vongshewarat K, Polyiam W, Rangsiruji A, Saipunkaew W, Naksuwankul K, Kalb J. (2017) A new checklist of lichenized fungi occurring in Thailand. MycoKeys 23: 1–91. 10.3897/mycokeys.23.12666 [DOI] [Google Scholar]
- Chernomor O, von Haeseler A, Minh BQ. (2016) Terrace aware data structure for phylogenomic inference from supermatrices. Systematic Biology 65: 997–1008. 10.1093/sysbio/syw037 [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Culberson CF, Johnson A. (1982) Substitution of methyl tert.-butyl ether for diethyl ether in the standardized thin-layer chromatographic method for lichen products. Journal of Chromatography 238: 483–487. 10.1016/S0021-9673(00)81336-9 [DOI] [Google Scholar]
- Culberson CF. (1972) Improved conditions and new data for identification of lichen products by standardized thin-layer chromatographic method. Journal of Chromatography 72: 113–125. 10.1016/0021-9673(72)80013-X [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Elix JA. (2006) Additional lichen records from Australia 58. New records from Norfolk Island. Australasian Lichenology 59: 23–29. [Google Scholar]
- Elix JA. (2009) Phyllopsoraceae. In: McCarthy PM. (Ed.) Flora of Australia.ABRS and CSIRO Publishing, Canberra and Melbourne, 41–59.
- Elix JA, McCarthy PM. (1998) Catalogue of the lichens of the smaller Pacific Islands. Bibliotheca Lichenologica 70: 1–361. [Google Scholar]
- Hoang DT, Chernomor O, von Haeseler A, Minh BQ, Vinh LS. (2018) UFBoot2: Improving the Ultrafast Bootstrap Approximation. Molecular Biology and Evolution 35: 518–522. 10.1093/molbev/msx281 [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Hue A. (1909) Lichenum generis Crocyniae Mass. plerasque species juxta archetypa specimina morphologice et anatomice descripsit. Memoires de la Société Nationale des Sciences Naturelles et Mathématiques de Cherbourg 37: 223–254. [Google Scholar]
- Joshi Y, Nguyen TT, Wang XY, Lőkös L, Koh YJ, Hur J–S. (2011) Contribution to the lichen mycota of South Korea. Mycotaxon 116: 61–74. 10.5248/116.61 [DOI] [Google Scholar]
- Kalb K, Elix J. (1995) The lichen genus Physcidia. Bibliotheca Lichenologica 57: 265–296. [Google Scholar]
- Kalyaanamoorthy S, Minh BQ, Wong TKF, von Haeseler A, Jermiin LS. (2017) ModelFinder: fast model selection for accurate phylogenetic estimates. Nature Methods 14: 587. 10.1038/nmeth.4285 [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed]
- Katoh K, Standley DM. (2013) MAFFT Multiple Sequence Alignment Software Version 7: Improvements in Performance and Usability. Mol Biol Evol 30: 772–780. 10.1093/molbev/mst010 [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Kauff F, Lutzoni F. (2002) Phylogeny of the Gyalectales and Ostropales (Ascomycota, Fungi): among and within order relationships based on nuclear ribosomal RNA small and large subunits. Mol Phylogenet Evol 25: 138–156. 10.1016/S1055-7903(02)00214-2 [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Kearse M, Moir R, Wilson A, Stones–Havas S, Cheung M, Sturrock S, Buxton S, Cooper A, Markowitz S, Duran C. (2012) Geneious Basic: an integrated and extendable desktop software platform for the organization and analysis of sequence data. Bioinformatics 28: 1647–1649. 10.1093/bioinformatics/bts199 [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Kistenich S, Bendiksby M, Ekman S, Cáceres MES, Hernández JE, Timdal E. (in press) Towards an integrative taxonomy of Phyllopsora (Ramalinaceae). The Lichenologist.
- Kistenich S, Rikkinen J, Thüs H, Vairappan C, Wolseley PA, Timdal E. (2018a) Three new species of Krogia (Ramalinaceae, lichenized Ascomycota) from the Paleotropics. MycoKeys: 69–88. 10.3897/mycokeys.40.26025 [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed]
- Kistenich S, Timdal E, Bendiksby M, Ekman S. (2018b) Molecular systematics and character evolution in the lichen family Ramalinaceae (Ascomycota: Lecanorales). Taxon 67: 871–904. 10.12705/675.1 [DOI] [Google Scholar]
- Kondratyuk SY, Lőkös L, Halda JP, Upreti DK, Mishra GK, Haji Moniri M, Farkas E, Park JS, Lee BG, Liu D. (2016) New and noteworthy lichen-forming and lichenicolous fungi 5. Acta Botanica Hungarica 58: 319–396. 10.1556/ABot.58.2016.3-4.7 [DOI] [Google Scholar]
- Logesh AR, Chinlampianga M, Shukla AC, Upreti DK. (2017) Studies on Lichens of Mizoram, Northeast India. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, India Section B: Biological Sciences 87: 445–457. 10.1007/s40011-015-0592-z [DOI] [Google Scholar]
- Menlove JE. (1974) Thin-layer chromatography for the identification of lichen substances. British Lichen Society Bulletin 34: 3–5. [Google Scholar]
- Mishra GK, Upreti DK, Nayaka S, Haridas B. (2011) New taxa and new reports of Phyllopsora (lichenized Ascomycotina) from India. Mycotaxon 115: 29–44. 10.5248/115.29 [DOI] [Google Scholar]
- Moon KH. (2013) Lichen-forming and lichenicolous fungi of Korea. Korean Lichen Research Institute (KoLRI), 139 pp.
- Müller J. (1894) Conspectus systematicus specierum lichenum Novae Zelandiae. Bulletin de l‘Herbier Boissier 2 (Appendix 1): 1–114.
- Nguyen L–T, Schmidt HA, von Haeseler A, Minh BQ. (2015) IQ-TREE: A Fast and Effective Stochastic Algorithm for Estimating Maximum-Likelihood Phylogenies. Molecular Biology and Evolution 32: 268–274. 10.1093/molbev/msu300 [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Ohmura Y, Kashiwadani H. (2018) Checklist of lichens and allied fungi of Japan. National Museum of Nature and Science Monographs 49: 1–110. [Google Scholar]
- Ronquist F, Huelsenbeck JP. (2003) MrBayes 3: Bayesian phylogenetic inference under mixed models. Bioinform 19: 1572–1574. 10.1093/bioinformatics/btg180 [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Sipman HJ. (1993) Lichens from Mount Kinabalu. Tropical Bryology 8: 281–314. 10.11646/bde.8.1.29 [DOI] [Google Scholar]
- Stamatakis A. (2014) RAxML version 8: a tool for phylogenetic analysis and post-analysis of large phylogenies. Bioinformatics 30: 1312–1313. 10.1093/bioinformatics/btu033 [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Stöver BC, Müller KF. (2010) TreeGraph 2: Combining and visualizing evidence from different phylogenetic analyses. BMC bioinformatics 11: 7. 10.1186/1471-2105-11-7 [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed]
- Streimann H. (1986) Catalogue of the lichens of Papua New Guinea and Irian Jaya. Bibliotheca Lichenologica 22: 1–145. [Google Scholar]
- Streimann H, Sipman H. (1994) New lichen records from the island of New Britain in Papua New Guinea. Fragmenta Floristica et Geobotanica 39: 369–382. [Google Scholar]
- Swinscow TDV, Krog H. (1981) The genus Phyllopsora, with a report on East African species. The Lichenologist 13: 203–247. 10.1017/S0024282981000315 [DOI] [Google Scholar]
- Timdal E. (2008a) Studies on Eschatogonia (Ramalinaceae) in Peru. The Lichenologist 40: 31–38. 10.1017/S0024282908007457 [DOI] [Google Scholar]
- Timdal E. (2008b) Studies on Phyllopsora (Ramalinaceae) in Peru. The Lichenologist 40: 337–362. 10.1017/S0024282908007846 [DOI] [Google Scholar]
- Timdal E. (2009) Krogiaantillarum (Ramalinaceae), a new lichen species from the West Indies. The Bryologist 112: 387–389. 10.1639/0007-2745-112.2.387 [DOI] [Google Scholar]
- Timdal E. (2011) The lichen genus Phyllopsora (Ramalinaceae) in the West Indies. Bibliotheca Lichenologica 106: 319–351. [Google Scholar]
- Timdal E, Krog H. (2001) Further studies on African species of the lichen genus Phyllopsora (Lecanorales). Mycotaxon 77: 57–90. [Google Scholar]
- Upreti DK, Divakar PK, Nayaka S. (2002) Notes on species of the lichen genus Phyllopsora in India. Bibliotheca Lichenologica 86: 185–191. [Google Scholar]
- Weerakoon G, Aptroot A. (2014) Over 200 new lichen records from Sri Lanka, with three new species to science. Cryptogamie, Mycologie 35: 51–62. 10.7872/crym.v35.iss1.2014.51 [DOI] [Google Scholar]
- Wei JC. (1991) An Enumeration of Lichens in China. International Academic Publishers, Beijing, 278 pp. [Google Scholar]
- Wolseley PA, Aguirre–Hudson B, McCarthy PM. (2002) Catalogue of the lichens of Thailand. Bulletins of the Natural History Museum: Botany Series 32: 13–59. 10.1017/S0968044602000038 [DOI] [Google Scholar]
Associated Data
This section collects any data citations, data availability statements, or supplementary materials included in this article.
Supplementary Materials
This dataset is made available under the Open Database License (http://opendatacommons.org/licenses/odbl/1.0/). The Open Database License (ODbL) is a license agreement intended to allow users to freely share, modify, and use this Dataset while maintaining this same freedom for others, provided that the original source and author(s) are credited.
Sonja Kistenich, Mika Bendiksby, Charles S. Vairappan, Gothamie Weerakoon, Siril Wijesundara, Patricia A. Wolseley, Einar Timdal
Uncollapsed version of the tree presented in Fig. 1
Data type: phylogenetic data
Explanation note: Extended majority-rule consensus tree resulting from the MrBayes analysis of the mtSSU and ITS alignment with Bayesian PP ≥ 0.7 and/or IQ-TREE maximum likelihood BS ≥ 50 and branch lengths. Strongly supported branches (PP ≥ 0.95 and BS ≥ 75) are marked in bold; branches with PP ≥ 0.95 and BS < 75 or PP < 0.95 and BS ≥ 75 are marked in bold grey; branches only supported with PP ≥ 0.7 or BS ≥ 50 are marked with a dot above the branch. Two species of Biatora were used for rooting. Terminal names include DNA extraction number, species name and when relevant, chemotype (ch). Three clades are distinguished to facilitate the discussion of new species (A, B, C).
This dataset is made available under the Open Database License (http://opendatacommons.org/licenses/odbl/1.0/). The Open Database License (ODbL) is a license agreement intended to allow users to freely share, modify, and use this Dataset while maintaining this same freedom for others, provided that the original source and author(s) are credited.
Sonja Kistenich, Mika Bendiksby, Charles S. Vairappan, Gothamie Weerakoon, Siril Wijesundara, Patricia A. Wolseley, Einar Timdal
Specimens of Phyllopsora examined in this study
Data type: specimens data