Absorption spectra of early stool from preterm infants need to be considered in abdominal NIRS oximetry

Abstract

Necrotizing enterocolitis (NEC) is the most common gastrointestinal emergency of the preterm infant. Low abdominal tissue oxygen saturation (StO₂) measured by near-infrared spectroscopy (NIRS) oximetry may be an early sign of NEC relevant for treating or even preventing NEC. However, current commercial NIRS oximeters provide inaccurate StO₂ readings because they neglect stool as an abdominal absorber. To tackle this problem, we determined the optical properties of faeces of preterm infants to enable a correct abdominal StO₂ measurement. In 25 preterm born infants (median age 31 0/7 ± 2 1/7 weeks, weight 1478 ± 511 g), we measured their first five stool probes with a VIS/NIR spectrometer and calculated the optical properties using the Inverse Adding Doubling (IAD) method. We obtained two absorption spectra representing meconium and transitional stool. Probabilistic cluster analysis correctly classified 96 out of 107 stool probes. The faeces spectra need to be considered to enable correct abdominal StO₂ measurements with NIRS oximetry.

1. Introduction

Near-infrared spectroscopy (NIRS) is able to measure regional tissue haemoglobin oxygen saturation (StO₂) non-invasively. Light in the near infrared (NIR) diagnostic window penetrates a few centimeters into tissue. In this range (probing volume), there is reportedly ~25% arterial and ~75% venous blood present [1], even though the arterial to venous ratio may be different than anticipated by most commercial oximeters [2,3]. Consequently, regional StO₂ represents a local oxygen balance (ratio between delivered and consumed oxygen). NIRS has been successfully applied for monitoring cerebral StO₂ in preterm infants (e.g [4,5]). Additionally, there is an increasing interest to monitor abdominal StO₂ to detect splanchnic ischemia, in particular in preterm infants who are at risk of developing necrotizing enterocolitis (NEC) [6–15]. However, abdominal NIRS readings have a clinically unacceptable low precision and a too high variability to reliably detect and monitor NEC [16,17].

Recent studies have applied commercially available NIRS oximeters (INVOS [8–10,15,18], InSpectra [14]) to the abdomen, although neither these sensors nor the algorithms were designed for abdominal measurements. Abdominal StO₂ shows much higher variability than cerebral and renal StO₂, and this variability decreases during the first weeks of life [18]. One probable reason for this high variability is that conventional NIRS oximetry does not account for the absorption of stool, which is present in the abdomen. For example, meconium staining reduces the measured intensity in red light, thus alters an optical signal [19]. Additionally, lavaging the lumen to perform reflectance spectrophotometry in the gastrointestinal tract was advised as stool presents interference [20]. Consequently, meconium and early stool show an interference not to be neglected and are likely to cause the high variability in abdominal StO₂ readings [20–23].

The aim of this study is to determine the optical properties of stool and their change during the first days of life of preterm infants in order to incorporate them into future abdominal StO₂ measurements.

2. Methods

2.1 Study design

Twenty-five preterm infants were enrolled, excluding children with congenital malformations. With approval from the ethical committee (KEK-ZH-Nr. 2013-0558) and the written consent from the parents, the first five stool probes excreted by a preterm infant (gestational age < 35 weeks) were collected. Clinical information such as weight and gestational age were recorded together with an assessment of stool color, consistency and texture. Every stool probe was measured using a spectrophotometer within 24 hours whenever possible. Due to fast accumulation of diaper fillings, measurements were in some cases delayed with the latest measurement starting 42 hours after excretion.

2.2 Measurement procedure

Each stool probe was removed from the diaper with a spatula and placed into four demountable, cylindrical quartz glass cuvettes (Hellma Analytics, Müllheim, Germany) with different thicknesses (0.1, 0.2, 0.5 and 1.0 mm). If not enough stool was available, the medium thicknesses 0.2 mm and/or 0.5 mm were filled first. Stool characteristics such as texture, color and homogeneity were recorded. Homogeneous green stool probes with no or very few curd beads were classified as meconium, whereas stool probes with numerous curd beads and colors in the range from green to brown and yellow were classified as transitional stool. The number of curd beads was registered as mottle level in the categories no beads, few beads, many beads and no more beads.

The stool probes were analyzed with a spectrophotometer (UV 1601, Shimadzu Corporation, Kyoto, Japan). Three different measurement series were conducted: unscattered transmittance (U) with the standard sample holder and total transmittance (T) as well as total reflectance (R) with an integrating sphere. The probed wavelength range was 600 nm to 1000nm. Every measurement was repeated three times per sample (delivering _{$M_{\text{U},j},M_{\text{T},j},M_{\text{R},j}$} with _$j=1,2,3$). For further analysis, the median data set _{$M_{X,j},X\in \left\{U,R,T\right\},j\in \left\{1,2,3\right\}$} with the largest number of measurement points in between the two other curves was employed, greatly reducing computation time [24].

2.3 Data analysis

Established methods to assess optical properties from spectrometric measurements are the Kubelka Munk theory and Monte Carlo simulations as well as the (inverse) adding doubling method [25,26]. Kubelka Munk assumes isotropic scattering and perfectly diffuse illumination as well as matched boundary conditions, whereas Monte Carlo methods are computationally expensive. Inverse adding doubling (IAD) was the method (version 3-9-11, https://omlc.org/software/iad/) of our choice to analyze the stool spectra since this method is valid for all ratios of µ_s’ to µ_a coefficients, accommodates to arbitrary scattering phase functions, and accounts for internal reflections at the samples boundaries [27]. IAD iteratively estimates a set of optical properties and runs a Monte Carlo employing the adding doubling method [28,29] until the calculated total reflectance (R), total and unscattered transmittance (T, U) match the measured values [30,31]. These Monte Carlo simulations solve the radiative transfer equation and hold true for homogeneous, smooth samples with an infinite plane-parallel slab tissue geometry, assuming time independent light distribution and ignoring polarization effects. With a fixed refractive index n, IAD extracts from the measurements _{$M_{X.j}$} the absorption µ_a, reduced scattering µ_s’ and anisotropy g spectra. To correct abdominal NIRS readings for stool interference, only the µ_a spectra are of interest. However, as the full data set, including µ_s’ and g spectra, may be of interest to other fields, the complete data set is represented in this work. We assume a refractive index of _$n=1.33$ as the main constituents of meconium, water [32,33] and intestinal mucosa [34], exhibit this value. If the stool was optically very dense without light transmittance _{$\left(M_{\text{T}}\left({\lambda }_k\right)=0,{\lambda }_k\in \left\{600\text{nm,1000nm}\right\}\right)$}, the respective sample was rejected. Furthermore, the noisiest 5% of all complete spectra were excluded from further analysis. If multiple stool probes per diaper were available, the spectra from the thickest sample was analyzed further, because it has the highest signal to noise ratio.

2.3.1 Water content correction

When chyme passes the large intestine, water is being withdrawn and reabsorbed. The longer chyme stays within the large intestine before excretion, the more compacted it becomes. This delivers a broad range of stool densities, resulting in µ_a and µ_s’ spectra with a large intermeasurement variability. In this work, we are not interested in the water content of the stool probe, but the µ_a spectra of stool from preterm infants. We minimized the influence of varying water content by applying the multiplicative signal correction (MSC) [35–37]. All absorption spectra were modelled as _{${\mu }_{\text{a},m,k}=a_m+b_m\times {\overline{\mu }}_{\text{a},k}+e_{m,k}$} with m being the sample and k being the wavelength number. The average µ_a at the _{$k^{\text{th}}$} wavelength is _{${\overline{\mu }}_{\text{a},k}=N^{-1}{\displaystyle {\sum }_{j=1}^N{\mu }_{\text{a},j,k}}$}. The _{$a_m,b_m$} coefficients were estimated individually for each sample, whereas the variable _{$e_{m,k}$} describes the model error. MSC transforms _{${\mu }_{\text{a},m,k}$} to _{${{\mu }^{*}}_{\text{a},m,k}=\left({\mu }_{\text{a},m,k}-a_m\right)/b_m$}.

2.3.2 Principal component analysis and probabilistic clustering

To identify structures within the µ_a spectra of the stool probes, a principal component analysis (PCA) was performed on the MSC µ_a curves. The scores and loadings from the mean centered µ_a matrix _$M$were computed by applying the singular value decomposition _{$M=\left(UD\right)V^T$} in the R statistics software (R version 3.5.1 [38]). The new set of base vectors is equal to _$V$, they are called loadings and are referred to as principal components (PC) in this work. The new coordinates are called scores and given by _$UD$. To investigate the µ_a spectra in the PC space on structures, a probabilistic clustering method was employed. The Bayesian Information Criterion [39] (BIC) was applied to estimate the optimal number of clusters describing the data structure assuming Gaussian mixture models. Subsequently, the probabilistic clustering method from the mclust package [40,41] identified the number of clusters proposed by BIC.

3. Results

The first 5 stool probes from 25 infants were aimed for. Thirteen stool probes showed incomplete spectra and were excluded. Five diapers were accidentally discarded. Two diapers contained more slime than stool and were excluded as well. Lastly, for two children there were 6 diapers analyzed as the final two diapers were filled within the short time frame of 30 minutes. Finally, from a total of 125 diapers, 107 diapers were analyzed and are presented in this paper.

The MSC scaled the stool µ_a and µ_s’ spectra towards the mean stool µ_a and µ_s’ spectra but preserved the shape. The result can be seen in Fig. 1. To test whether the MSC removes meaningful information from the data, principal component analysis (PCA) was performed on the µ_a and µ_s’ spectra with and without MSC. The resulting scores for both PCAs are shown with respect to sample thickness and mottle level (Fig. 2). MSC removes the influence of sample thickness on the scores distribution and uncovers the influence of mottle level (i.e. stool development) for the µ_a and µ_s’ spectra.

Fig. 1.

The optical spectra estimated by IAD are shown in blue for all 107 complete stool spectra through their mean and standard error of the mean (SEM). As the stool probes differed in water content, which masked the µ_a and µ_s’ features we are interested in, a multiplicative signal correction (MSC) was applied.

Fig. 2.

PCA of all 107 stool spectra, with and without MSC. The scores are shown for the first two PCs for µ_a, µ_s’ and g. (a) The sample thickness and (b) mottle level of the stool are presented with colors. (a) The color coding varies from red to blue with increasing thickness. Humid stool probes were more transparent and hence data from thicker cuvettes more likely to be included. MSC removes the influence on sample thickness in PCA as shown in the lower subplots, effectively removing the influence of varying water content. (b) Meconium entails the probes with zero up to few beads, colored in dark and light red. Transitional stool probes contain many beads or have no more beads left, they are shown in light and dark blue. MSC uncovers the influence of the mottle level on PCA in µ_a as seen in the bottom left subplot.

Continuing further analysis with MSC spectra only, PC1 and PC2 describe 92% of all variance in the µ_a data. Accordingly, the first two PCs are most likely to contain clustering information. The BIC proposes a model with two clusters on PC1 and PC2 scores. These clusters were identified with the mclust [40,41] package and shown in Fig. 3. The two clusters coincide for 96 from a total of 107 stool probes with the eye-sight classification into meconium and transitional stool. Table 1 shows the classification and probabilistic cluster analysis along with the gestational age and the preterm infants’ weight. This demonstrates that the differences in stool color and texture as seen in the visible wavelength range are apparent in the near-infrared spectrum as well. The median µ_a, µ_s’ and g spectra of both stool types, meconium and transitional stool, are plotted with their standard error in Fig. 4. The µ_a curves of haemoglobin are added for comparison [42]. Probabilistic clustering on PC1 and PC2 of the uncorrected µ_a spectra showed no agreement with neither sample humidity, the child’s age, GA nor with the stool’s age at time of measurement. Clustering information on PC1 and PC2 of the uncorrected data coincides with the stool types (meconium, transitional stool) for 53% of all samples in contrast to 90% for MSC corrected data.

Fig. 3.

PCA of all 107 MSC stool µ_a, µ_s’ and g spectra (a,b and c). A probabilistic cluster analysis was carried out on the scores of the first two principal components (PC), delivering two clusters for each property. In case of the µ_a spectra, these clusters coincide for 90% of all stool probes with the classification of stool into meconium (blue) and transitional stool (red). Following the development of µ_a from meconium to transitional stool, the clustering predicts a correct course for 17 out of 25 children (d).

Table 1. Data of all study subjects concerning gestational age, weight and stool probes measured. The number of stool probes measured in each category and their identification (ID) by the probabilistic clustering method is given in comparison to classification (class) by eye-sight.

child	GA	weight	meconium	transitional stool
	[weeks]	[g]	[ID / class samples]	[ID / class samples]
1	32 1/7	1960	3/3	0/0
2	33 1/7	1450	4/4	0/1
3	33 0/7	1680	2/2	1/1
4	33 0/7	2000	2/2	1/1
5	28 4/7	1200	2/2	3/3
6	30 6/7	1370	4/4	2/2
7	32 5/7	1710	2/2	3/3
8	32 5/7	1480	2/2	3/3
9	34 3/7	2760	4/4	1/1
10	32 5/7	1750	4/4	0/1
11	32 5/7	1340	2/2	3/3
12	29 6/7	1300	0/1	3/3
13	29 6/7	1200	0/1	3/3
14	31 1/7	1560	1/1	0/0
15	29 5/7	1165	3/3	1/2
16	26 3/7	580	1/1	1/1
17	29 6/7	1280	1/2	2/2
18	34 4/7	2280	3/3	0/2
19	26 6/7	1000	2/2	1/2
20	26 6/7	840	3/3	2/2
21	32 4/7	2310	1/1	2/2
22	29 6/7	1350	3/3	2/2
23	29 6/7	1390	4/4	1/1
24	30 1/7	600	5/5	0/0
25	30 1/7	1400	3/3	0/2
Mean ± Std	31 0/7 ± 2 1/7	1478 ± 511	61/64	35/43

Fig. 4.

The median µ_a, µ_s’ and g spectra for 107 meconium and transitional stool probes are shown with their standard error. The absorption µ_a, reduced scattering µ_s’ and anisotropy g coefficients are shown without (a, c, e) and with (b, d) multiplicative signal correction (MSC). Extinction coefficients of oxy- and deoxy-haemoglobin are shown in (f) for comparison.

4. Discussion

We determined the µ_a spectra of early stool probes from preterm infants in the NIR light. We discovered two different spectra coinciding with the stool types meconium and transitional stool. IAD was the method of our choice due to its broad applicability. Nevertheless, IAD poses certain requests on the spectroscopic measurements regarding sample size, homogeneity, thickness, sample holders and beam profile of the spectroscopic device. Most requirements were met, but our beam profile differed from the requested one and sample homogeneity was partly not fulfilled. Early meconium and late transitional stool probes are homogeneous, but the intermediate stool probes contain inhomogeneities in the form of curd beads. We obtained inhomogeneities in 57 samples (i.e. 53% of our samples). However, according to our assessment we are of the opinion that the inhomogeneities average out considering the rectangular beam profile (1 × 9 mm²) and sample size (thickness of 0.1, 0.2, 0.5 and 1.0 mm, diameter of 15 mm) being larger than the average inhomogeneity as well as the large number of stool probes being analyzed. Samples with inhomogeneities deliver properties with a higher variation but still blend into the development from early meconium to late transitional stool. In addition, IAD assumes a circular beam profile hitting the stool probe, whereas our beam profile has a rectangular cross section. Although IAD was informed with the correct sample area covered by light, the altered shape places some portions of light closer to the sample edge and the integrating sphere opening than anticipated by IAD. This results in a larger loss of light at the sphere opening and sample border than IAD will predict, which in turn will be interpreted as a higher sample extinction coefficient. However, stool µ_a in general showed high values, leaving only little room for signal loss at the border and its misinterpretation. Finally, IAD bases its Monte Carlo routine on a refractive index given by the user. The index of refraction was chosen to be n = 1.33 as water [32,33] and intestinal mucosa [34] show the same value and depict the main constituents of meconium. Nevertheless, the true refractive index of stool is to the best of our knowledge not known and can be larger than assumed due to other compounds such as biliverdin and bilirubin [43]. To investigate the possible influence of different refractive index values, we reran the complete analysis also on n = 1.43. We obtained the same stool µ_a features as for n = 1.33. The mean µ_a curves for meconium as well as transitional stool from the analysis with the smaller refractive index can be scaled and translated into the analysis with the larger refractive index.

The stool probes were classified by eye into either meconium or transitional stool. There is an uncertainty regarding the crossing from meconium to transitional stool as it is not clear where exactly meconium stops, and transitional stool starts. Consequently, probabilistic clustering is not expected to fully overlap with the eye-classification into the two stool types.

Preterm infants at our neonatal ward are initially fed with formula, which is gradually replaced with human milk. During the first days of life, the gastrointestinal tract evolves to stomach nutrition, which changes the stool pattern, texture and color. The changes in the near infrared spectrum for the first five stool probes were observed as they evolve from meconium to transitional stool. We have investigated the first steps in stool development and found that preterm infants’ stool evolves in varying speed. Furthermore, we observed no clustering information on neither child gestational age nor child weight at time of birth. We found no change in spectral µ_a arising from the waiting time between stool excretion and spectral analysis.

Are there other absorbers that may interfere with a correct StO₂ measurement? One strong absorber is melanin. Since most NIRS devices are based on a multidistance approach, since the multidistance measurements were shown to cancel the influence of superficial tissue [44,45], and since melanin is located very superficially, we do not expect that melanin will lead to inaccurate StO₂ readings. At most melanin will lead to a decreased light intensity at the detectors and this may increase the noise level slightly. Another such molecule may be bilirubin. But the absorption of bilirubin is high in the blue region and negligible in the NIR region [46]. Therefore, we do not expect any interference of bilirubin. Indeed, hemoglobin is by far the strongest absorber in tissue in the NIR with the exception of the abdomen, where meconium/stool absorbs NIR light strongly.

Larger blood vessels are known to act similar to black holes: they absorb all the light entering the blood vessel. Thus, they do not contribute to changes in the NIRS signal [47]. We expect that larger (>1mm) lumps of dense stool will be acting similarly. Such lumps will probably interfere little with a correct measurement of StO_2. However, we expect that there will also be unknown quantities of small meconium/stool particles or meconium/stool of low optical density, which will definitely interfere with a correct StO₂ measurement. Only an appropriate correction for stool may prevent such errors.

The spectra of meconium and transitional stool show a trend in µ_a opposite to oxy-haemoglobin. Consequently, if an oximeter measures on the abdomen and stool is present, this leads to erroneous readings of the oxy-haemoglobin concentration and a falsely low StO₂. This effect depends on the set of wavelengths of the light sources, but arguably will affect any NIRS device. If the µ_a spectra for meconium and transitional stool are considered, this will enable to correct NIRS oximeter readings.

In principle, it would be possible to reanalyze existing NIRS data, if the raw intensities were available and if the employed instrument provided raw intensities for at least three wavelengths. Three wavelengths are sufficient if they are placed at wavelengths, where meconium and transitional stool have similar absorption coefficients. Otherwise at least four appropriate wavelengths are necessary. Unfortunately, most commercial instruments do not provide raw intensities. Furthermore, it would be possible to determine the concentration of stool in the abdomen. However, no commercially available clinical NIRS instrument is able to quantify µ_a so far and in addition, the absorption spectrum of meconium/stool varies tremendously depending on the water concentration. But it should be possible to estimate the presence of stool in categories such as low, medium or high.

5. Conclusion and outlook

We have determined the µ_a spectra of meconium and transitional stool and found a strong absorption in the NIR light. This is very likely to disturb traditional oximeter readings and explain the observed high variability of such readings [14]. Probabilistic cluster analysis discovered differences between the two stool types. These µ_a spectra will be employed to correct abdominal oximeter readings for the interference of stool Abdominal NIRS measurements on at least three appropriate wavelengths are required to consider meconium and/or transitional stool spectra. Not taking the absorption spectral information of preterm stool into account when determining StO₂ with NIRS oximetry on the preterm abdomen will lead to false StO₂ values. Studies that missed this critical aspect in the abdominal NIRS measurements need to be reevaluated and reinterpreted.

Furthermore, expanding existing NIRS oximeter models to recognize the presence of meconium and transitional stool not only allows for stool-corrected abdominal StO₂, but also for the detection of stool. Similarly to classifying the interference of stool on abdominal NIRS measurements [22], the presence of stool can be estimated to be high, medium or low. Combining this rating with variations in time may enable conclusions on gut motility and constipation. This will promote NIRS oximetry as a non-invasive and cost-efficient tool to monitor the abdomen of critically ill preterm infants.

Funding

InnoSuisse (CTI number 14786.1 PFLS-LS), Swiss Cancer Research (KFS-3732-08-2015); the SwissTrans-Med project ONIRIUS, the Clinical Research Priority Programs (CRPP) Tumor Oxygenation TO2; Molecular Imaging Network Zürich MINZ of University of Zürich and the Swiss National Science Foundation (project 159490).

Disclosures

MW, SK, DO: OXYPREM AG (I,S), JB, DS: CARAG AG (F,E,P,S)