The value of magnetic resonance imaging in evaluation of myocardial and liver iron overload in a thalassaemia endemic population: a report from Northeastern Thailand

Abstract

Purpose

Patients with chronic haemolytic anaemia, such as in thalassaemia, require repeated blood transfusions, which leads to iron overload and cellular damage, especially in the heart and liver. Classically, serum ferritin and liver biopsy have been used to monitor patient response to chelation therapy. Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) has proven to be effective in detecting and quantifying iron in the heart and liver. The aim of the paper is to evaluate the accuracy of the MRI T2* procedure in the assessment of liver iron concentration and myocardial iron overload.

Material and methods

In 210 cases of monthly transfused patients, hepatic and myocardial iron overload was measured by multi-breath-hold MRI T2* and compared to serum ferritin (a traditional marker of iron overload).

Results

No significant correlation was observed between serum ferritin level and cardiac T2* MRI (p = 0.68, r = 0.06). However, a significant correlation was observed between serum ferritin and liver iron concentration evaluated by MRI (p = 0.04, r = 0.68).

Conclusion

Routine evaluation of liver and heart iron content using MRI T2* is suggested to better evaluate the haemosiderosis status in thalassaemic patients.

Introduction

Iron is an essential element that forms a vital component of metabolic and biological processes, but when present in excess it can yield tissue damage due to oxidative stress. Patients with thalassaemia require regular blood transfusions to survive beyond the second decade of life [1-3]. Even though transfusions improve health and survival, the chronic administration of large amounts of blood, along with extra vascular haemolysis and an increase in the intestinal absorption of iron, inevitably leads, despite chelation therapy, to significant haemosiderosis of all organs [4]. Excess body iron may accumulate in the liver, spleen, heart, bone marrow, pituitary, pancreas, and the central nervous system, initiating damage to these organs [5]. Iron overload cardiomyopathy (IOC) results from the accumulation of iron in the myocardium, and it frequently ensues late and can be difficult to reverse once established, and it is a significant cause of death in patients in receipt of chronic blood transfusion therapy [6,7]. Inopportunely, significant cardiac iron burden can happen regardless of low liver iron concentration [8]. There is significant clinical importance to reliably risk stratify patients for the development of heart failure, so that chelation therapy can be increased and cardiac morbidity averted [9]. Indirect markers of current cardiac iron overloading, namely single measurements of serum ferritin and biopsy-determined liver iron concentration, are inadequate for identifying myocardial iron deposition in chronically transfused patients [1-3,10].

Ferritin is a metalloprotein that is found in cells. It stores and releases iron in a controlled manner. In normal individuals, a small amount appears in the circulation and in general reflects the total body iron. Normal values of serum ferritin for men and women are 12-300 ng/ml and 12-150 ng/ml, respectively [1-3]. It is an acute phase reactant, and the serum levels may be disproportionately greater than the degree of iron loading in infections, inflammatory states, liver dysfunction, and malignancies [1-3]. However, magnetic resonance can measure the paramagnetic properties of tissue iron to provide direct, non-invasive iron assessments, and clinically this has been achieved by assessing the T2 and T2* relaxation parameters [11]. Magnetic resonance does not image the iron directly but instead images water protons as they diffuse near iron deposits in the tissue of interest [8]. The iron acts as small magnets, extinguishing the homogeneity of the magnetic field in iron-laden tissues. The moving water protons experience significantly dissimilar magnetic profiles and become desynchronised from one another. This causes the image to darken at a level proportional to the iron concentration [12]. This technique is unassuming, allowing fast and reproducible quantification of myocardial and hepatic iron, consequently allowing pre-symptomatic detection of myocardial siderosis [13]. The T2* technique has the potential to become a noninvasive standard technique in evaluating tissue iron [10-12]. In the present study, we also compared the MRI T2* results with serum ferritin levels of patients on regular blood transfusion.

Material and methods

Cardiac T2* and liver iron concentration (LIC) measurements were performed on 210 thalassaemia major patients (110 males and 100 females, age 11.1 ± 9.8 years) who received regular transfusion and iron chelation therapy with serum ferritin levels > 1000 ng/ml. Patients with a contraindication to magnetic resonance imaging, including pacemakers, claustrophobia, and inability to comply with the instructions, were excluded from the study. Approval was obtained from the Ethics Committee of the Faculty of Medicine.

Magnetic resonance imaging interpretation

The images were acquired on a 1.5-T Avanto system (Siemens Medical Solutions, Erlangen, Germany) following a standard protocol system using a cardiac phased-array coil. Each patient was scanned using both the optimised bright-blood [14,15] and the original black-blood sequences [16]. In summary, each technique is a cardiac-gated, multi-echo, fast gradient sequence acquired within a single breath-hold. The black-blood technique employs an additional double inversion recovery pre-pulse to null the blood signal in the heart chamber. A single midventricular short-axis slice was acquired with a slice thickness of 6 and 10 mm for the black blood techniques. Imaging parameters were a TR of 19 ms, eight echo times (2.616.74 ms with 2.02-ms steps), a matrix of 128 x 256, and a FOV of 40 cm, which yielded a voxel size of 3.1 x 1.6 x 10 mm³, while the inversion time (TI) was set to suppress the blood signal. The acquired images were analysed locally and also transferred in DICOM format to be processed at the reference site. All T2* analyses were performed independently at the site using individual, custom software developed in MATLAB (The MathWork, Natick, MA) [14,15]. All image data were fit to the offset model at the reference site (REF-offset) and fit to the offset (LOC-offset) and mono-exponential (LOC-typical) models at the local site. ROIs had been defined, manually, from the whole interventricular septum (WS) at the reference site, as in the conventional method, and from the partial interventricular septum (PS) region using prior knowledge of a T2* map to avoid susceptibility artefacts and partial volume effect at the edge of the septum, as suggested in previous studies [14-16]. A radiologist with more than 10 years’ experience in cardiac MR analysis independently performed the analyses. The T2* results of all models in this study were reported by using both their mean and median values. The result from a typical LOC method reported by its median is, therefore, equivalent to the MPS-PW method. For the measurement of liver T2*, a single trans-axial slice through the centre of the liver was imaged at eight echo times (2.3-16 ms). The TR was set to 200 ms without cardiac gating. Signal intensity analysis was performed in the periphery of the liver away from the large central vessels.

The cut-off points in this MRI instrument were as follows for liver iron concentrations (LIC): normal ≤ 3 mg Fe/g dw, mild 3-7 mg Fe/g dw, moderate 7-15 mg Fe/g dw, and severe ≥ 15 mg Fe/g dw (Figure 1).

Figure 1.

Example of liver iron concentration evaluated by MRI from mild (A), moderate (B), and severe (C) liver iron overload thalassaemia patients

Cardiac T2*: normal > 25 msec, marginal 20-25 msec, mild to moderate 10-20 msec, and severe ≤ 10 msec (Figure 2).

Figure 2.

Example of cardiac MRI and T2* colour map from normal (A), mild to moderate (B), and severe (C) iron overload thalassaemia patients

Serum ferritin levels

Measurements were carried out using a microparticle enzyme immunoassay (MEIA; Abbot Diagnostics, IMX System, Ferritin, IL, USA).

Statistical analysis

Statistical analysis was performed with commercially available software (SPSS Inc., version 18.0, Chicago, IL, USA). A paired Student’s t-test was selected to evaluate the difference between the two data. A p value less than 0.05 was considered to be significant.

Results

Patients

Cardiac T2* and liver iron concentration measurements were performed on 210 thalassemia major patients (110 males and 100 females, age 11.1 ± 9.8 years). Splenectomy had been performed in 12 of the patients. All patients had received iron chelation therapy from early childhood for a median duration of 18 months.

Serum ferritin levels versus myocardial T2* and liver iron concentration values

Serum ferritin ranged between 298 and 14,827. About 17% of the patients showed mildly elevated ferritin level, while equal percentages (41%) had moderate and severe high ferritin levels. Myocardial T2* ranged from 48.1 to 7.1 and was at normal level among the majority of the patients (81.4%), 7.1% presented with marginal and mild to moderate each, and 4.3% had severe myocardial iron overload (Table 1). The liver iron concentration ranged from 0.7 to 27.9, about third of the patients showed mild and severe levels (30.0% and 35.7%, respectively), moderate liver iron concentration was seen in 21.4%, while only 12.9% showed normal hepatic iron load (Table 2). Serum ferritin levels showed a significant negative correlation with the liver T2* values (p = 0.01, r = 0.318). No significant correlation was observed between serum ferritin level and cardiac T2* MRI (p = 0.68, r = 0.06). Nevertheless, a significant correlation was observed between serum ferritin and liver iron concentration evaluated by MRI (p = 0.04, r = 0.68).

Table 1.

Relationship between serum ferritin levels and myocardial T2*

Myocardial T2*	Number of patients	Serum ferritin levels
Normal	171	1911 ± 351
Marginal	15	2084 ± 443
Mild to moderate	15	731 ± 342
Severe	9	4572 ± 908

Table 2.

Relationship between serum ferritin levels and liver iron concentration

Liver iron concentration	Number of patients	Serum ferritin levels
Normal	27	1230 ± 355
Mild	63	1766 ± 390
Moderate	45	2489 ± 479
Severe	75	4999 ± 2033

Discussion

The assessment of tissue iron is vital for the determination of clinical outcomes, determining when to start chelation, and for selection of the regime that should be prescribed. The quantitative determination of the deposition of iron in various organs in multi-transfused patients with thalassaemia is of extreme importance for the effective monitoring of iron chelation therapy [17]. Until recently, liver iron concentration was quantitated by biopsy, and measurement of ferritin levels patients in steady state has been the only method available to this effect. Nevertheless, ferritin levels alone are not completely acceptable because they may demonstrate considerable variations due to inflammation, infection, or other chronic disorders. Furthermore, there have been instances of heavy iron deposition in which the serum ferritin levels were disproportionately low [8,9]. Tissue biopsy is the traditional gold standard for making the diagnosis of myocardial iron overload [18], but iron deposition has a tendency to be patchy [8,9]. Endomyocardial biopsies may therefore miss the areas of deposition and provide a false negative result; also, it is an invasive and hazardous procedure [18]. The discomfort and risk that a liver biopsy causes to the patients together with the weak correlation between liver fibrosis and iron concentration reduces the value of this examination, especially when this has to be repeated regularly [8,11]. Hence, it is not surprising that alternative, noninvasive, but accurate methods for the assessment of iron deposition have been sought in recent years. Serial assessment of liver and cardiac iron determines that cardiac iron changes lag behind changes in liver iron concentration. The liver is the foremost storage organ for excess iron and willingly acquires excess transferrin- and non-transferrin-bound iron; it also mobilises iron rapidly and proficiently in times of mandate or in response to iron chelation. Conversely, the heart has vigorous mechanisms to prevent excess transfer-mediated uptake [19]. Pathologic myocardial iron overload occurs when the iron binding capacity is saturated and labile free iron species begin to circulate. Even then, cardiac iron uptake is delayed compared to many other extrahepatic organs, including the pancreas. Therefore, many young patients can display severe hepatic iron overloading with no evidence of cardiac iron overloading [20]. T2* is an essential MRI relaxation time that shortens in the presence of iron. It is non-invasive, cost-effective, with no radiation exposure, and has widespread accessibility [21]. Anderson et al. were the first to use the T2* technique for myocardial iron assessment in subjects with thalassaemia major [2]. It was seen that there was a progressive decline in the ejection fraction of the heart as the myocardial iron deposition increased, and all patients with ventricular dysfunction had a myocardial T2* of less than 20 ms [18]. The purpose of the present study was to reassess the effectiveness of MRI in measuring the amount of iron deposited in the heart and liver of regularly transfused patients with thalassaemia in an endemic area. We included 210 patients with thalassemia major, and all patients were on a regular transfusion program and had been on iron chelation therapy for at least 18 months. The present study also revealed a correlation between liver iron concentration and serum ferritin levels in all patients, which is consistent with the results of Kaltwasser et al. and Fischer [8,22]. No significant correlation was found between serum ferritin levels and myocardial T2*, and there was a moderate negative correlation between serum ferritin and liver iron concentration evaluated by MRI in our study. Several other studies have found dissimilar correlation strengths, ranging from no correlation to low correlation, between serum ferritin and heart iron content; all have found that serum ferritin cannot satisfactorily evaluate cardiac haemosiderosis [23,24]. Such results therefore underscore the importance of MRI T2* as a more accurate method for estimating liver and heart iron overload. Five cases showed severe cardiac overload with mild liver iron overload and no corresponding high serum ferritin levels. There have been reports of heavy cardiac iron deposition in spite of the presence of low serum ferritin levels [2,25]. Noetzli et al. disclosed that low values of liver iron or serum ferritin do not certainly signify low-risk of iron-induced cardiomyopathy. This may arise because iron chelation therapy can eliminate iron more rapidly from the liver than from the heart, which may normalise liver iron while myocardial iron remains high [7]. T2* has been associated with myocardial and hepatic iron concentration in previous studies, including direct biopsies. Recently, cardiac and liver iron evaluations by MRI have become the primary outcome measures for clinical studies of iron chelation therapy [21,26]. Ha et al. [27] stated that liver biopsies are now outdated in thalassaemia cases, except for histological assessment of viral hepatitis. Our study has limitations due to the relatively small number of patients and lack of consideration of prevailing factors that may affect the serum ferritin levels, such as C-reactive protein, white blood cell count, and liver function tests.

Conclusions

MRI T2* provides a precise, reproducible, and non-invasive technique for measuring tissue iron concentration, sparing the patients from invasive biopsy. Through the widespread application of this technique it should be possible to improve the management of tissue iron overload, and in particular aid the presymptomatic recognition of myocardial siderosis, allowing earlier chelation intensification with its potential for reduced cardiac events.

Conflict of interest

The authors report no conflict of interest