Abstract
Elementary schools can be effective sites for universal preventive interventions. Less is known about how long effects of intervention in elementary grades last. Can they improve outcomes in adulthood? To test effects of a social developmental intervention in the elementary grades on adult life through the 30s, the Seattle Social Development Project, a nonrandomized controlled trial, followed all consenting 5th-grade students (N = 808) from 18 Seattle public elementary schools from age 10 (in 1985) to age 39 (in 2014), with 88% retention. The sample was gender balanced and ethnically and economically diverse. The full intervention, called Raising Healthy Children, continued from Grades 1 through 6 and consisted of teacher in-service training in classroom management and instructional methods; cognitive, social, and refusal skills training for children; and parent workshops in child behavior monitoring and management, academic support, and anticipatory guidance. Using structural equation modeling, we examined intervention effects from age 30 to age 39 across 9 constructs indicating 3 domains of adult life: health behavior, positive functioning, and adult health and success. An omnibus test across all 9 constructs indicated a significant positive overall intervention-control difference. Examined individually, significant intervention effects included better health maintenance behavior, mental health, and overall adult health and success. Significant effects were not found on substance use disorder symptoms, sex-risk behaviors, or healthy close relationships in the 30s. Results indicate that sustained, theory-based, multicomponent intervention in the elementary grades can produce lasting changes in health maintenance, mental health, and adult functioning through the 30s.
Keywords: childhood intervention, elementary school, social development, adult health, adult functioning, mental health, Raising Healthy Children
Almost all children attend elementary school in the United States and most other parts of the world (European Commission/EACEA/Eurydice, 2016; National Center for Education Statistics, 2009; Nationmaster, n.d.). Given this broad reach, the elementary school setting holds great promise for universal preventive intervention to promote positive youth development (Cruden, Kelleher, Kellam, & Brown, 2016; Langford et al., 2014). The proximal goals of such interventions often include reducing problem behavior and promoting school success, but a larger aspiration is to change developmental trajectories, leading to improved wellbeing and more positive outcomes that persist beyond childhood (Hawkins, Guo, Hill, Battin-Pearson, & Abbott, 2001; Heckman, Pinto, & Savelyev, 2013; Lewin-Bizan, Bowers, & Lerner, 2010; Vergunst et al., 2019). Though preventive, primary school interventions show short-term success, less is known about how long effects last. If developmental trajectories are changed by preventive intervention during the elementary grades, is it possible that youth who experience these interventions have measurably better lives well into adulthood?
A handful of studies of preventive interventions provided early in life have reported long-term effects into the 20s (Dodge et al., 2015; Kellam et al., 2014; Olds et al., 2014; Reynolds, Ou, Mondi, & Hayakawa, 2017), but only a few have followed participants further into adulthood (Campbell et al., 2014; Schweinhart, 2013). We are aware of only one other follow-up of a universal intervention in public elementary schools that followed participants to age 30. Newcomer et al. (2016) reported that the Good Behavior Game, implemented with Baltimore public school children in Grades 1 and 2, was associated with reduced risk for suicide attempt to age 30 (mediated by effects on positive childhood peer relations). The present study examines the potential of universal preventive intervention during the elementary grades to improve outcomes further into the 30s when many behavior patterns have stabilized, and family formation, career development, and serious physical health problems are more prevalent (Arnett, 2016; Arnett, Žukauskienė, & Sugimura, 2014; Capaldi, Feingold, Kim, Yoerger, & Washburn, 2013; Capaldi, Tiberio, Washburn, Yoerger, & Feingold, 2015; Roberson, Norona, Zorotovich, & Dirnberger, 2017). Specifically, we test effects of a social developmental intervention implemented in Grades 1 through 6, the “full intervention” condition, on multiple domains of adult life from age 30 through age 39.
Raising Healthy Children
The Seattle Social Development Project (SSDP) is a longitudinal study of health behavior and health outcomes within which a multicomponent preventive intervention called Raising Healthy Children (RHC) is nested. The RHC intervention was guided theoretically by the social development model (SDM; Catalano & Hawkins, 1996; Hawkins & Weis, 1985) and sought to improve social developmental processes in schools and families (Hawkins et al., 2003). Based on the SDM, we hypothesized that providing children with greater opportunities, skills, and recognition for involvement in their classrooms and families would build stronger prosocial bonds of commitment and attachment to school, family, and prosocial peers that would, in turn, promote healthy norms and behaviors and protect against unhealthy behaviors. We further posited that, to the extent that changes in developmental experiences during elementary grades were successful, long-term developmental trajectories of children could be altered, leading to healthier adult lives.
Published analyses have found positive effects of the RHC intervention in Grades 1 through 6 across development up to age 30. In comparison with controls, girls assigned to intervention classrooms at the start of Grade 1 evidenced less self-destructive behavior and boys engaged in less aggressive behavior by the end of Grade 2 (Hawkins, Von Cleve, & Catalano, 1991). By the beginning of Grade 5, fewer in intervention classrooms had initiated alcohol use and/or delinquency and they reported better family communication and perceived rewards from teachers and school, as well as higher bonding to family and school than controls (Hawkins et al., 1992). By Grade 6, at the end of the intervention period, intervention students had higher achievement test scores compared with controls (Abbott et al., 1998). By age 18, youth from intervention classrooms reported less heavy alcohol use, lifetime violence, and sex-risk behaviors, and higher bonding to school and self-reported school achievement (Hawkins, Catalano, Kosterman, Abbott, & Hill, 1999). At age 21, fewer from intervention classrooms had criminal records and symptoms of mental health disorders, they were functioning better in school (more graduated from high school) or work and, among females, they were less likely to report ever having been pregnant or having a baby than controls (Hawkins, Kosterman, Catalano, Hill, & Abbott, 2005; Lonczak, Abbott, Hawkins, Kosterman, & Catalano, 2002). Significant effects on better mental health continued at age 27 among those from intervention classrooms, in addition to more educational and economic attainment than controls (Hawkins, Kosterman, Catalano, Hill, & Abbott, 2008). By age 30, fewer from the full intervention classrooms had experienced a sexually transmitted infection (Hill et al., 2014). This current report asks: To what extent do the effects of the RHC intervention persist through the 30s?
Adult Development in the 30s
In the 30s, the importance of health behavior and functioning may become more evident than in previous life stages. A sedentary lifestyle is associated with a number of poor health outcomes in adulthood and, for some, weight gain accelerates in the 30s (de Rezende, Rodrigues Lopes, Rey-Lopez, Matsudo, & Luiz Odo, 2014; Ostbye, Malhotra, & Landerman, 2011; Wang et al., 2017). Although heavy substance use typically decreases in the 30s, continued heavy use increases risk for health problems with age (Karlamangla, Zhou, Reuben, Greendale, & Moore, 2006; Schulte & Hser, 2013). The importance of positive adult functioning with respect to work and finances, relationships, and community also becomes more prominent in the 30s as many seek to stabilize career paths and establish an independent home and family life (Settersten, 2003; Settersten & Ray, 2010). The present study examines multiple assessments of health behavior and positive functioning through the 30s, as well as mental health, physical health, and socioeconomic status indicators. We test effects on each of these outcomes of the RHC intervention that ended more than 18 years earlier.
Methods
Sample and Design
The first phase of the SSDP longitudinal study began in 1981 with an experimental intervention initiated with all first-grade students in eight Seattle public schools serving high-crime neighborhoods. This early intervention was randomized at both the school and classroom level, as shown in Figure 1. In 1985, due to a change in funding, the study was expanded to a total of 18 matched Seattle public schools, adding new study conditions and additional control participants (Hawkins & Catalano, 2005). The longitudinal sample was established in 1985 from the population of 1,053 students entering Grade 5 in these 18 schools, 808 (77%) of whom assented, with their parents’ consent, to participate in the longitudinal study. Thereafter, all fifth-grade students in each school received either the intervention or no intervention according to their school’s intervention assignment. This resulted in a nonrandomized controlled trial with four conditions, two of which—the “full intervention” and control conditions—are the focus of this report. The full intervention group consisted of those who received at least two semesters of intervention—one in Grades 1 through 4 and one in Grades 5 and 6—with an average dose of 4.13 years of intervention exposure. The control group received no intervention from the project throughout. Other conditions did not meet these criteria and are not discussed in this report (a “late intervention” group and a “parent workshops only” group received intervention components during Grades 5 and 6 only, and 24 students could not be classified because they left participating schools before spending at least one semester). A study flowchart and group sample sizes are shown in Figure 1.
Figure 1.
Study flowchart. The quasi-experimental study (shaded above) tested in the present study was established in Grade 5 and included participants recruited from an earlier trial of 8 schools in addition to new participants from 13 added schools (3 early schools closed and their students were merged into new schools, for a total of 18 schools at the Grade 5 baseline).
Of the 808 study participants, 49% are female; 47% are European American, 26% African American, 22% Asian American, and 5% Native American. Of these, 5% are Hispanic. Over 52% of the sample experienced childhood poverty as evidenced by participation in the National School Lunch/Breakfast Program between the ages of 10 and 12. Participants have been interviewed 15 times starting at age 10, with the most recent survey waves at ages 30, 33, 35, and 39 (the interview at age 35 used an abbreviated survey focusing on substance use and physical health). Retention of still-living participants averaged 88% from age 30 to 39 (37 participants were deceased by age 39).
Attrition and Internal Validity
The overall distribution of participants in the full intervention and control conditions by age 39 did not significantly differ for those lost to attrition (37% of whom were in the full intervention condition) versus the analysis sample (42% of whom were in the full intervention condition; X2 = .59, p = .444); nor, among those retained in the analysis sample, did the distribution of participants in the full intervention and control conditions differ with respect to gender (male is 47% v. 51%, respectively; X2 = .32, p = .574), ethnicity (European American is 48% v. 46%; X2 = .20, p = .652), foreign birth (15% v. 12%; X2 = .54, p = .464), childhood poverty (56% v. 53%; X2 = .26, p = .611), mother not a high school graduate (21% v. 20%; X2 = .13, p = .720), or single-parent home at age 11 (40% v. 39%; X2 = .06, p = .809). Given the requirement that full intervention students attended project schools at least one semester in Grades 1 through 4 and in Grades 5 and 6, whereas some control students were added to the study at Grade 5 (and may have been in non-project schools previously), it is important to rule out differences in residential stability, a potential threat to internal validity. Analyses comparing the full intervention and control groups found no significant differences in number of years living in Seattle by age 12 (10.43 v. 10.09, respectively; F = .64, p = .425), number of residences lived in from age 5 to 14 (2.98 v. 3.37; F = 1.05 , p = .306), or in perceived safety of residential neighborhood from age 10 to 12 (M = 2.05 v. 2.31 on 4-point scale; F = .13, p = .720). Differential school or teacher receptivity to intervention is also an unlikely threat to internal validity. Teachers in six of eight participating schools during Grades 1 through 4 were randomly assigned to either intervention or control classrooms. At Grade 5, newly eligible schools were matched demographically to early experimental schools, and each agreed to serve as a control or late intervention school prior to assignment. During the course of the intervention in the 1980s, the Seattle school district used mandatory busing to achieve comparable racial makeup of schools, which substantially reduced the risk that outcomes observed reflected contextual or neighborhood differences, school demographic differences, or parent school-selection effects.
An exception to the pattern of initial condition equivalence was a higher proportion of participants in the control condition who reported that their mothers were 19 years of age or less when they were born. Eleven percent of the full intervention condition, compared to 20% of the control condition reported that their mothers were teens when they were born (X2 = 4.22, p = .040). Therefore, having a teen mother was included as a covariate in all outcome analyses.
Intervention Components
The full intervention consisted of three core components (more fully described in prior reports (Hawkins, Catalano, Jones, & Fine, 1987; Hawkins et al., 1999; 2005; Lonczak et al., 2002). Teacher staff development: Each year during Grades 1 through 6, teachers received 5 days of in-service training in classroom management and instructional methods, including proactive classroom management, interactive teaching, and structured cooperative learning (Abbott et al., 1998; Cummings, 1983; Cummings, Barber, & Cuervo, 1982; Hawkins, Arthur, & Catalano, 1997; Hawkins, Doueck, & Lishner, 1988; Slavin, 1991). Child competencies: Additionally, first-grade teachers received instruction in the use of a cognitive and social skills training curriculum (Shure & Spivack, 1980, 1982) and, during Grade 6, a study consultant provided students with training in refusal skills (Comprehensive Health Educational Foundation, 1999). All teachers in the full intervention condition participated in the child competencies and/or staff development trainings. Parent workshops: When children were in Grades 1 through 3, parents were offered a seven-session curriculum in child behavior management skills (Hawkins et al., 1987) and a four-session curriculum in skills for supporting their children’s academic development (Hawkins & Catalano, 2003b). During Grades 5 and 6, parents were offered a five-session curriculum designed to strengthen skills to reduce their children’s risks for problem behaviors (Hawkins & Catalano, 2003a). Forty-three percent of intervention parents attended at least one parenting class during Grades 1 through 3 (Hawkins et al., 1987), and 29% attended at least one class during Grades 5 or 6, indicating that the parent workshop component had less reach than the teacher and child components.
Measures
Guided by prior research on adult development and functioning, we sought to identify a broad but limited set of primary outcome indices that reflected the most meaningful, major domains of adult life (Kosterman et al., 2005; 2014; 2011; Scales et al., 2016). For each of three life domains, we then identified three key constructs that were assessed from age 30 to age 39 in SSDP. Finally, for each construct, three manifest indicators were computed, resulting in 27 distinct measures of adult health or functioning. The measurement framework is shown in Table 1. All measures were labeled and coded such that higher scores indicated better health or functioning. Unless noted below, measures were based on self-reports at ages 30, 33, and 39; multimodal survey administration included in-person, phone, and self-administered web-based confidential interviews. Survey instruments have been developed and updated over the course of the longitudinal study and are pilot-tested prior to each wave. Note that most measures are formula-based (e.g., obesity, which is derived from body mass index), summative indices (e.g., symptom counts), or derived from a single item at each age for which internal consistency estimates are not appropriate; for scales that averaged multiple items at each age, overall reliability (Cronbach’s alpha) is reported.
Table 1.
Measurement Framework Used to Examine Intervention Outcomes in the 30s
Life domains | Constructs | Measured indicators |
---|---|---|
Adult health behavior | ||
Health maintenance | Exercise Adequate sleep Stress management |
|
Low substance use disorder | Few nicotine symptoms Few alcohol symptoms Few other drug symptoms |
|
Low sex-risk behavior | Familiarity with partner(s) Consistent condom use No new STI diagnosis |
|
Positive adult functioning | ||
Responsible and constructive | Financial responsibility Constructive engagement Work attendance |
|
Healthy close relationships | Prosocial partner/spouse Prosocial peers Low household conflict |
|
Civic engagement | Volunteer activities Local problem solving Political activities |
|
Adult health and success | ||
Mental health | Emotion regulation Few depressive symptoms Few anxiety symptoms |
|
Physical health | General health Not obese Not high blood pressure |
|
Socioeconomic success | Exceeds U.S. median SES Owns home or condo Low public assistance |
Note. STI = sexually transmitted infection; SES = socioeconomic status.
Adult health behavior.
Scales assessing health maintenance included exercise (minutes of moderate and vigorous exercise per week), adequate sleep (frequency of “adequate” and at least 7 to 8 hours of sleep; α = .87), and stress management (frequency of controlling daily and life stress; α = .78). Low substance use disorder was assessed by the Diagnostic Interview Schedule (DIS; Robins et al., 1999) to obtain DSM-IV (American Psychiatric Association, 1994) criterion counts for nicotine dependence, alcohol abuse and dependence, and other drug abuse and dependence (all reverse coded); these measures included assessments at age 35 in addition to ages 30, 33, and 39. Indicators of low sexual risk behavior were familiarity with sex partner(s) (e.g., spouse, steady relationship, casual partner), consistency of condom use (if not married or cohabitating), and no new diagnoses of sexually transmitted infection.
Positive adult functioning.
Scales assessing responsible and constructive behavior included financial responsibility (reverse frequency of squandering needed money), constructive engagement (cumulative time engaged in work, school, and/or homemaking), and work attendance (reverse frequency of missing work not due to illness). Healthy close relationships was indicated by prosocial partner or spouse (degree to which partner is physically active; volunteers; and avoids smoking, drinking heavily, using other drugs, and arrest; α = .75), prosocial peers (degree to which close friends are physically active; volunteer; and avoid smoking, drinking heavily, and using other drugs; α = .87), and low household conflict (reverse frequency of insulting, swearing, pushing, threatening, etc.; α = .72). Civic engagement was indicated by frequency of volunteer activities and involvement in local problem solving with others in the community, and by political activities (e.g., voting, contributing money, joining a march; α = .82).
Adult health and success.
Mental health measures included emotion regulation (reverse frequency of feeling distressed, frustrated, upset, quick-tempered, and annoyed; α = .89) and DIS assessments of DSM-IV depressive symptoms and generalized anxiety symptoms (reverse coded). Physical health was indicated by self-reported general health (excellent, good, fair, or poor), and objective measures of body mass index (not obese) and blood pressure (not high) collected in person, including assessments of these at age 35. Indicators of socioeconomic success were attainment of above-median education or household income (relative to U.S. Census measures for corresponding year), owning a home or condominium, and low reliance on public assistance (reverse percent of income from TANF, food stamps, WIC vouchers, child care subsidy, etc.).
Analysis
A Global Test Statistic (Feng & Thompson, 2002) was used to test for an overall intervention effect across the nine different constructs in Table 1. Next, using a structural equation modeling approach with Mplus 7.4 (Muthèn & Muthèn, 1998-2015), we examined intervention effects on each construct separately modeled as a latent variable indicated by three manifest measures as outlined above (see Figure 2). We then examined intervention effects on each of the three life domains modeled as a second-order latent variable indicated by three latent constructs. To include all available data, the intervention variable was dummy coded to compare the full intervention group to controls, coded as the reference category. Other conditions in which participants received partial intervention are also compared to controls in the models, although this was not a focus of the present study. (We found in prior reports that participants in these other conditions were rarely significantly different from controls; Hawkins et al., 1999; 2005; 2008. This led to the approach taken in the current analyses that focused on the full intervention and control conditions.) A dichotomous measure of having been born to a teen mother was included in all models as an exogenous covariate to control for the preexisting group differences on this factor. Full information maximum likelihood methods were used for missing data; two-tailed tests were used throughout.
Figure 2.
Illustration of structural models used to test intervention effects. Panel A illustrates the model used to test intervention effects on the 9 constructs shown in Table 1. Panel B illustrates the second-order factor model used to test intervention effects on the 3 life domains in Table. 1.
Given the study’s design, the unit of intervention assignment consisted of the series of classrooms to which some individuals were assigned in Grades 1 through 4 and the condition assignments of schools attended by all participants in Grades 5 and 6. Of the 376 participants assigned to the control and full intervention conditions, over 124 different classroom/school sequences were identified, consistent with the unit of intervention assignment. On average, only 3.03 participants experienced the same units of intervention within conditions. For this reason, and to be consistent with prior reports, analyses were conducted at the individual level (Hawkins et al., 1999; 2005, 2008; Lonczak et al., 2002).
Results
Given the multiple health and functioning constructs of interest and the relatively large number of possible comparisons, the Global Test Statistic (Feng & Thompson, 2002) was used to examine the average t-value from analyses of the nine constructs in Table 1, taking into account their intercorrelation (Feng & Thompson, 2002). This omnibus test indicated a significant overall positive effect of the RHC intervention on health and functioning through age 39 among those in the full intervention group compared to controls (T = 2.91, p = .004). Given this overall effect on health and functioning, we examined intervention effects on each individual construct and on each life domain to understand what specific constructs and domains were most affected by the intervention and contributing to the overall positive effect of RHC.
Effects on Health and Functioning Constructs in the 30s
A series of structural equation models corresponding to Panel A in Figure 2 was examined to test possible long-term effects of the full intervention on each adult health and functioning construct assessed in the 30s. As shown in Table 2, after controlling for having been born to a teen mother, the full intervention had significant effects on better health maintenance and better mental health, as well as marginally significant effects on responsible and constructive behavior and socioeconomic success. Differences in substance use disorder symptoms, sex-risk behavior, healthy close relationships, civic engagement, and physical health were not significant. (In order to provide results for all the structural pathways corresponding to the models shown in Figure 2, the combined “other conditions versus control” results are also included in Table 2, though not a focus of the current investigation.)
Table 2.
Effects of Full Intervention and Covariates on Intervention Outcomes in the 30s
Predictor pathways |
|||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Full intervention v. control |
Other conditions v. control |
Born to teen mother |
|||||||
Intervention outcomes | β | (SE) | p | β | (SE) | p | β | (SE) | p |
Health/functioning constructs | |||||||||
Health maintenance | .44** | (.13) | .001 | .22* | (.10) | .035 | −.08 | (.13) | .513 |
Low substance use disorder | .12 | (.14) | .391 | .07 | (.11) | .505 | −.14 | (.12) | .255 |
Low sex-risk behavior | .03 | (.11) | .769 | .04 | (.09) | .678 | −.41 ** | (.10) | <.001 |
Responsible and constructive | .30+ | (.17) | .073 | .34* | (.14) | .014 | −.31* | (.15) | .047 |
Healthy close relationships | .08 | (.12) | .482 | −.12 | (.10) | .228 | −.28** | (.11) | .008 |
Civic engagement | .12 | (.11) | .304 | −.05 | (.09) | .577 | −.10 | (.10) | .303 |
Mental health | .26* | (.12) | .038 | .13 | (.10) | .180 | −.39** | (11) | <.001 |
Physical health | .19 | (.13) | .154 | .15 | (.10) | .154 | −.52** | (.11) | <.001 |
Socioeconomic success | .23+ | (.13) | .072 | .19+ | (.10) | .064 | −.59** | (.11) | <.001 |
Life domains | |||||||||
Adult health behavior | .16 | (.15) | .267 | .09 | (.11) | .412 | −.24 | (.16) | .140 |
Positive adult functioning | .18 | (.13) | .175 | .00 | (.10) | .993 | −.32** | (.12) | .005 |
Adult health and success | .35* | (.14) | .012 | .22* | (.11) | .047 | −.74** | (.12) | <.001 |
Note. Path coefficients are standardized betas (standard errors in parentheses). Intervention outcomes were labeled and coded such that higher scores indicated better health or functioning. Intervention condition was dummy coded to compare the full intervention group to controls; all other conditions were combined in this coding, including “could not be classified,” and effects were not hypothesized.
p < .10
p < .05
p < .01.
Effects on Life Domains in the 30s
To examine intervention effects on overall life domains, we created three second-order latent factors, each indicated by three corresponding constructs, as illustrated in Panel B of Figure 2. The full intervention was associated with significantly better overall adult health and success, as shown in Table 2. Significant effects were not found for overall adult health behavior or positive adult functioning.
Effects of Being Born to a Teen Mother
It is worth noting the strong association of being born to a teen mother with most of the outcomes examined. Those born to a mother under age 20 had consistently worse health and functioning, and the disparities were often highly significant. Intervention effects reported are after controlling for these strong effects of being born to a teen mother.
Differential Effects by Gender, Childhood Poverty, and Ethnicity
Multiple-group models were examined to identify possible differential effects of the full intervention by gender, childhood poverty, or ethnicity. One gender difference was found: The intervention was associated with reports of significantly more responsible and constructive behavior for males (β (SE) = .68 (.26), p = .008), but not for females (β (SE) = −.07 (.24), p = .758) (ΔX2 = 5.37, p = .021). Two differential effects were found for those experiencing childhood poverty (who participated in the National School Lunch/Breakfast Program): Intervention group members who experienced childhood poverty reported significantly more responsible and constructive behavior than control counterparts (β (SE) = .57 (.23), p = .012), but there was no effect for those from middle- and working-class childhoods (β (SE) = −.49 (.57), p = .392) (ΔX2 = 6.28, p = .012). Conversely, intervention group members from middle- and working-class childhoods reported better physical health than control counterparts (β (SE) = .57 (.18), p = .001), but no effect was found for those experiencing childhood poverty (β (SE) = −.11 (.18), p = .541) (ΔX2 = 6.82, p = .009). No interactions with ethnicity were found. It should be noted that, consistent with prior reports (Hawkins et al., 2008; Hill et al., 2014), there continued to be a large and significant difference in lifetime prevalence of STI among African Americans (but not for new STI diagnoses in the 30s examined in this report): 35% of African Americans in the intervention group reported a lifetime STI, compared with 69% of African Americans in the control group (β (SE) = −.82 (.31), p = .008).
Discussion
More than 18 years after the RHC intervention ended, all intervention-control differences were in the expected direction and, overall, showed significant improvement of the full intervention group compared with controls as indicated by a significant omnibus test of these differences. Modeling nine key health and functioning constructs across three major life domains in the 30s, significant intervention effects were found for health maintenance behavior, mental health, and overall adult health and success. Further, tests of interactions found that the intervention was associated with more responsible and constructive behavior among males and those who experienced childhood poverty, and better physical health among those from working- and middle-class childhoods. We found no evidence of significant effects through the 30s for substance use disorder symptoms, sex-risk behavior, or close relationships. These findings extend and are consistent with prior reports showing RHC intervention effects on mental health and SES attainment outcomes at age 27 (Hawkins et al., 2008), but effects on current sexual risk behaviors were not found in the 30s (Hawkins et al., 2008; Hill et al., 2014), when sex-risk behaviors typically decline (Chandra, Billioux, Copen, & Catlainn, 2012).
The Raising Healthy Children intervention targeted children’s opportunities, skills, and recognition to increase prosocial bonds to school and family through specific instructional and behavior management interventions during the elementary school years. It is noteworthy that effects not only persisted into the 30s, but that they encompassed diverse health and wellbeing outcomes, consistent with the contention that targeting common risk and protective factors can have broad “crossover” effects across a range of outcomes (Bailey, 2009; Hawkins et al., 1999; 2005; Hill et al., 2014). Results are also consistent with the premise that developmental trajectories can be changed by early intervention, leading to healthier adult lives in general. Although modeling of longitudinal trajectories and mechanisms is beyond the scope of this report, other SSDP studies bolster the hypothesized pathways of improved opportunities and bonding (Hawkins et al., 2001; Hill et al., 2014). Significant intervention effects on the life domain of adult health and success are particularly notable given the associations of mental health, physical health, and socioeconomic status with healthy aging (Depp & Jeste, 2006; Peel, McClure, & Bartlett, 2005; White, St John, Cheverie, Iraniparast, & Tyas, 2015).
Not all beneficial effects of the RHC intervention were maintained through the 30s. It is important to note the absence of significant effects on substance use disorder symptoms and sexual risk behaviors in the 30s in this study.
Study limitations include the quasi-experimental design, and the geographic and demographic limitations of study participants, all of whom originated from urban Seattle schools. About half of the participants were ethnic minorities and/or from low SES families. While these populations are often underrepresented in other studies, SSDP findings may not be generalizable to more homogeneous populations. With important exceptions (obesity, blood pressure), the study relied on self-report measures; however, SSDP’s long history of confidential interviews with the sample bolsters confidence in honest reporting.
Important strengths of the study include a theory-guided, universal intervention offered to all students and their parents in intervention classrooms; intent-to-treat analyses (with minimal enrollment requirements for the full intervention group); control of an important covariate (teen mother); little evidence of internal validity threats; a significant omnibus test; systematic tests of latent variable models for a broad set of important adult outcomes; and tests of moderation.
This study supports the proposition that sustained, theory-based, multicomponent intervention during the elementary school grades can produce lasting changes in important indicators of adult health and functioning through the 30s. Overall, results show the promise of universal preventive intervention during elementary school to improve meaningful life outcomes well into adulthood.
Supplementary Material
Acknowledgments
Compliance with Ethical Standards
This research was supported by National Institute on Drug Abuse (NIDA) grant numbers R01DA033956, 1R01DA024411, and 1R01DA09679. Content is solely the responsibility of the authors. NIDA played no role in the study design; in the collection, analysis and interpretation of data; in the writing of the report; nor in the decision to submit the article for publication. Dr. Catalano is a board member of Channing Bete Company, distributor of Guiding Good Choices®. This program was tested in the study that produced the dataset used in this paper. Other authors have no conflicts of interest to report. Informed consent was obtained from all individual participants included in the study. All procedures were in accordance with the ethical standards of the Human Subjects Review Committee at the University of Washington (STUDY00002228) and with the 1964 Helsinki declaration and its later amendments. We thank our funder, the study participants, and the staff of our research group. An earlier version of this paper was presented at the annual meeting of the Society for Prevention Research, in Washington, DC, May 2016.
Footnotes
Publisher's Disclaimer: This Author Accepted Manuscript is a PDF file of a an unedited peer-reviewed manuscript that has been accepted for publication but has not been copyedited or corrected. The official version of record that is published in the journal is kept up to date and so may therefore differ from this version.
Contributor Information
Rick Kosterman, Social Development Research Group, School of Social Work, University of Washington.
J. David Hawkins, Social Development Research Group, School of Social Work, University of Washington.
Karl G. Hill, Institute of Behavioral Science, Department of Psychology and Neuroscience, University of Colorado, Boulder
Jennifer A. Bailey, Social Development Research Group, School of Social Work, University of Washington
Richard F. Catalano, Social Development Research Group, School of Social Work, University of Washington
Robert D. Abbott, Social Development Research Group, School of Social Work, University of Washington
References
- Abbott RD, O’Donnell J, Hawkins JD, Hill KG, Kosterman R, & Catalano RF (1998). Changing teaching practices to promote achievement and bonding to school. American Journal of Orthopsychiatry, 68, 542–552. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- American Psychiatric Association. (1994). Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders (4th ed.). Washington, DC: American Psychiatric Association. [Google Scholar]
- Arnett JJ (2016). College students as emerging adults: The developmental implications of the college context. Emerging Adulthood, 4, 219–222. [Google Scholar]
- Arnett JJ, Žukauskienė R, & Sugimura K (2014). The new life stage of emerging adulthood at ages 18–29 years: Implications for mental health. The Lancet Psychiatry, 1, 569–576. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Bailey JA (2009). Editorial: Addressing common risk and protective factors can prevent a wide range of adolescent risk behaviors. Journal of Adolescent Health, 45, 107–108. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Campbell F, Conti G, Heckman JJ, Moon SH, Pinto R, Pungello E, & Pan Y (2014). Early childhood investments substantially boost adult health. Science, 343, 1478–1485. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Capaldi DM, Feingold A, Kim HK, Yoerger K, & Washburn IJ (2013). Heterogeneity in growth and desistance of alcohol use for men in their 20s: Prediction from early risk factors and association with treatment. Alcoholism: Clinical and Experimental Research, 37, E347–E355. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Capaldi DM, Tiberio SS, Washburn IJ, Yoerger K, & Feingold A (2015). Growth, persistence, and desistance of alcohol use for at-risk men in their 30s. Alcoholism: Clinical and Experimental Research, 39, 1203–1211. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Catalano RF, & Hawkins JD (1996). The social development model: A theory of antisocial behavior In Hawkins JD (Ed.), Delinquency and crime: Current theories (pp. 149–197). New York, NY: Cambridge University Press. [Google Scholar]
- Chandra A, Billioux VG, Copen CE, & Catlainn S,C (2012). HIV risk-related behaviors in the United States household population aged 15–44 Years: Data from the National Survey of Family Growth, 2002 and 2006–2010. National Health Statistics Reports, 46(January 19), 1–19. [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Comprehensive Health Educational Foundation. (1999). Here’s Looking at You 2000. Seattle, WA: Author. [Google Scholar]
- Cruden G, Kelleher K, Kellam S, & Brown CH (2016). Increasing the delivery of preventive health services in public education. American Journal of Preventive Medicine, 51, S158–S167. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Cummings C (1983). Managing to teach. Edmonds, WA: Teaching, Inc. [Google Scholar]
- Cummings C, Barber C, & Cuervo AG (1982). School Enhancement Research And Demonstration Project. Methods of instruction. Teacher’s manual (Secondary). Washington, DC: Prepared for Office of Juvenile Justice and Delinquency Prevention, U.S. Department of Justice. [Google Scholar]
- de Rezende LF, Rodrigues Lopes M, Rey-Lopez JP, Matsudo VK, & Luiz Odo C (2014). Sedentary behavior and health outcomes: An overview of systematic reviews. PLoS One, 9, e105620. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Depp CA, & Jeste DV (2006). Definitions and predictors of successful aging: A comprehensive review of larger quantitative studies. The American Journal of Geriatric Psychiatry, 14, 6–20. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Dodge KA, Bierman KL, Coie JD, Greenberg MT, Lochman JE, McMahon RJ, & Pinderhughes EE (2015). Impact of early intervention on psychopathology, crime, and well-being at age 25. American Journal of Psychiatry, 172, 59–70. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- European Commission/EACEA/Eurydice. (2016). Compulsory education in Europe – 2016/17 Eurydice facts and figures. Luxembourg: Publications Office of the European Union; Retrieved from https://webgate.ec.europa.eu/fpfis/mwikis/eurvdice/images/2/24/Compulsory_Education_in_Europe_2016_2017.pdf. [Google Scholar]
- Feng Z, & Thompson B (2002). Some design issues in a community intervention trial. Controlled Clinical Trials, 23, 431–49. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Hawkins JD, Arthur MW, & Catalano RF (1997). Six State Consortium for Prevention Needs Assessment Studies: Final Report. Seattle, WA: Social Development Research Group, University of Washington. [Google Scholar]
- Hawkins JD, & Catalano RF (2003a). Guiding Good Choices. South Deerfield, MA: Channing Bete Company. [Google Scholar]
- Hawkins JD, & Catalano RF (2003b). Preparing for School Success. South Deerfield, MA: Channing Bete Company. [Google Scholar]
- Hawkins JD, & Catalano RF (2005). Doing prevention science: A response to Dennis M. Gorman and a brief history of the quasi-experimental study nested within the Seattle Social Development Project. Journal of Experimental Criminology, 1, 79–86. [Google Scholar]
- Hawkins JD, Catalano RF, Jones G, & Fine DN (1987). Delinquency prevention through parent training: Results and issues from work in progress In Wilson JQ, & Loury GC (Eds.), From children to citizens: Vol. III. Families, schools, and delinquency prevention (pp. 186–204). New York, NY: Springer-Verlag. [Google Scholar]
- Hawkins JD, Catalano RF, Kosterman R, Abbott R, & Hill KG (1999). Preventing adolescent health-risk behaviors by strengthening protection during childhood. Archives of Pediatrics and Adolescent Medicine, 153, 226–234. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Hawkins JD, Catalano RF, Morrison DM, O’Donnell J, Abbott RD, & Day LE (1992). The Seattle Social Development Project: Effects of the first four years on protective factors and problem behaviors In McCord J, & Tremblay RE (Eds.), Preventing antisocial behavior: Interventions from birth through adolescence (pp. 139–161). New York, NY: Guilford Press. [Google Scholar]
- Hawkins JD, Doueck HJ, & Lishner DM (1988). Changing teaching practices in mainstream classrooms to improve bonding and behavior of low achievers. American Educational Research Journal, 25, 31–50. [Google Scholar]
- Hawkins JD, Guo J, Hill KG, Battin-Pearson S, & Abbott RD (2001). Long-term effects of the Seattle Social Development intervention on school bonding trajectories. Applied Developmental Science, 5, 225–236. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Hawkins JD, Kosterman R, Catalano RF, Hill KG, & Abbott RD (2005). Promoting positive adult functioning through social development intervention in childhood: Long-term effects from the Seattle Social Development Project. Archives of Pediatrics and Adolescent Medicine, 159, 25–31. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Hawkins JD, Kosterman R, Catalano RF, Hill KG, & Abbott RD (2008). Effects of social development intervention in childhood 15 years later. Archives of Pediatrics and Adolescent Medicine, 162, 1133–1141. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Hawkins JD, Smith BH, Hill KG, Kosterman R, Catalano RF, & Abbott RD (2003). Understanding and preventing crime and violence: Findings from the Seattle Social Development Project In Thornberry TP, & Krohn MD (Eds.), Taking stock of delinquency: An overview of findings from contemporary longitudinal studies (pp. 255–312). New York, NY: Kluwer Academic/Plenum. [Google Scholar]
- Hawkins JD, Von Cleve E, & Catalano RF Jr. (1991). Reducing early childhood aggression: Results of a primary prevention program. Journal of the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry, 30, 208–217. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Hawkins JD, & Weis JG (1985). The social development model: An integrated approach to delinquency prevention. The Journal of Primary Prevention, 6, 73–97. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Heckman J, Pinto R, & Savelyev P (2013). Understanding the mechanisms through which an influential early childhood program boosted adult outcomes. American Economic Review, 103, 2052–2086. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Hill KG, Bailey JA, Hawkins JD, Catalano RF, Kosterman R, Oesterle S, & Abbott RD (2014). The onset of STI diagnosis through age 30: Results from the Seattle Social Development Project intervention. Prevention Science, 15(Suppl. 1), S19–S32. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Karlamangla A, Zhou K, Reuben D, Greendale G, & Moore A (2006). Longitudinal trajectories of heavy drinking in adults in the United States of America. Addiction, 101, 91–99. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Kellam SG, Wang W, Mackenzie ACL, Brown CH, Ompad DC, Or F, … Windham A (2014). The impact of the good behavior game, a universal classroom-based preventive intervention in first and second grades, on high-risk sexual behaviors and drug abuse and dependence disorders into young adulthood. Prevention Science, 15(Suppl 1), S6–S18. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Kosterman R, Hawkins JD, Abbott RD, Hill KG, Herrenkohl TI, & Catalano RF (2005). Measures of positive adult behavior and their relationship to crime and substance use. Prevention Science, 6, 21–33. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Kosterman R, Hill KG, Lee JO, Meacham MC, Abbott RD, Catalano RF, & Hawkins JD (2014). Young adult social development as a mediator of alcohol use disorder symptoms from age 21 to 30. Psychology of Addictive Behaviors, 28, 348–358. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Kosterman R, Mason WA, Haggerty KP, Hawkins JD, Spoth R, & Redmond C (2011). Positive childhood experiences and positive adult functioning: Prosocial continuity and the role of adolescent substance use. Journal of Adolescent Health, 49, 180–186. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Langford R, Bonell CP, Jones HE, Pouliou T, Murphy SM, Waters E, … Campbell R (2014). The WHO Health Promoting School framework for improving the health and well-being of students and their academic achievement. The Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, CD008958. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Lewin-Bizan S, Bowers EP, & Lerner RM (2010). One good thing leads to another: Cascades of positive youth development among American adolescents. Development and Psychopathology, 22, 759–770. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Lonczak HS, Abbott RD, Hawkins JD, Kosterman R, & Catalano RF (2002). Effects of the Seattle Social Development Project on sexual behavior, pregnancy, birth, and sexually transmitted disease outcomes by age 21 years. Archives of Pediatrics and Adolescent Medicine, 156, 438–447. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Muthén LK, & Muthén BO (1998-2015). Mplus user’s guide (3rd ed.). Los Angeles, CA: Muthén & Muthén. [Google Scholar]
- National Center for Education Statistics; (2009). Digest of Education Statistics: Table 165 Age range for compulsory school attendance and special education services, and policies on year-round schools and kindergarten programs, by state: Selected years, 1997 through 2008. Washington, DC: Institute of Education Sciences, U.S. Deptartment of Education; Retrieved from https://nces.ed.gov/programs/digest/d08/tables/dt08_165.asp. [Google Scholar]
- Nationmaster. (n.d.). Countries compared by education > Duration of compulsory education: Countries compared. International Statistics at NationMaster.com. Aggregates compiled by NationMaster. UNESCO Retrieved from http://www.nationmaster.com/country-info/stats/Education/Duration-of-compulsory-education.
- Newcomer AR, Roth KB, Kellam SG, Wang W, Ialongo NS, Hart SR, … Wilcox HC (2016). Higher childhood peer reports of social preference mediates the impact of the Good Behavior Game on suicide attempt. Prevention Science, 17, 145–156. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Olds DL, Kitzman H, Knudtson MD, Anson E, Smith JA, & Cole R (2014). Effect of home visiting by nurses on maternal and child mortality: Results of a 2-decade follow-up of a randomized clinical trial. JAMA Pediatrics, 168, 800–806. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Ostbye T, Malhotra R, & Landerman LR (2011). Body mass trajectories through adulthood: Results from the National Longitudinal Survey of Youth 1979 Cohort (1981–2006). International Journal of Epidemiology, 40, 240–250. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Peel NM, McClure RJ, & Bartlett HP (2005). Behavioral determinants of healthy aging. American Journal of Preventive Medicine, 28, 298–304. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Reynolds AJ, Ou SR, Mondi CF, & Hayakawa M (2017). Processes of early childhood interventions to adult well-being. Child Development, 88, 378–387. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Roberson PNE, Norona JC, Zorotovich J, & Dirnberger Z (2017). Developmental trajectories and health outcomes among emerging adult women and men. Emerging Adulthood, 5, 128–142. [Google Scholar]
- Robins LN, Cottler LB, Bucholz KK, Compton WM, North C, & Rourke K (1999). The Diagnostic Interview Schedule for DSM-IV (DIS-IV). St. Louis, MO: Washington University. [Google Scholar]
- Scales PC, Benson PL, Oesterle S, Hill KG, Hawkins JD, & Pashak TJ (2016). The dimensions of successful young adult development: A conceptual and measurement framework. Applied Developmental Science, 20, 150–174. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Schulte MT, & Hser Y-I (2013). Substance use and associated health conditions throughout the lifespan. Public Health Reviews, 35(2). [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Schweinhart L (2013). Long-term follow-up of a preschool experiment. Journal of Experimental Criminology, 9, 389–409. [Google Scholar]
- Settersten RA (2003). Age structuring and the rhythm of the life course In Mortimer JT, & Shanahan MJ (Eds.), Handbook of the life course (pp. 81–98). Boston, MA: Springer US. [Google Scholar]
- Settersten RA Jr., & Ray B (2010). What’s going on with young people today? The long and twisting path to adulthood. The Future of Children, 20, 19–41. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Shure MB, & Spivack G (1980). Interpersonal problem solving as a mediator of behavioral adjustment in preschool and kindergarten children. Journal of Applied Developmental Psychology, 1, 29–44. [Google Scholar]
- Shure MB, & Spivack G (1982). Interpersonal Problem Solving (ICPS): A training program for the intermediate elementary grades. Philadelphia, PA: Hahnemann University, Department of Mental Health Sciences. [Google Scholar]
- Slavin RE (1991). Synthesis of research of cooperative learning. Educational Leadership, 48, 71–82. [Google Scholar]
- Vergunst F, Tremblay RE, Nagin D, Algan Y, Beasley E, Park J, … Côté SM (2019). Association of behavior in boys from low socioeconomic neighborhoods with employment earnings in adulthood. JAMA Pediatrics, Advance online publication. doi: 10.1001/jamapediatrics.2018.5375. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Wang M, Yi Y, Roebothan B, Colbourne J, Maddalena V, Sun G, & Wang PP (2017). Trajectories of body mass index among Canadian seniors and associated mortality risk. BMC Public Health, 17, 929. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- White CM, St John PD, Cheverie MR, Iraniparast M, & Tyas SL (2015). The role of income and occupation in the association of education with healthy aging: Results from a population-based, prospective cohort study. BMC Public Health, 15, 1181. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
Associated Data
This section collects any data citations, data availability statements, or supplementary materials included in this article.