Broadband on-chip single-photon spectrometer

Abstract

Single-photon counters are single-pixel binary devices that click upon the absorption of a photon but obscure its spectral information, whereas resolving the color of detected photons has been in critical demand for frontier astronomical observation, spectroscopic imaging and wavelength division multiplexed quantum communications. Current implementations of single-photon spectrometers either consist of bulky wavelength-scanning components or have limited detection channels, preventing parallel detection of broadband single photons with high spectral resolutions. Here, we present the first broadband chip-scale single-photon spectrometer covering both visible and infrared wavebands spanning from 600 nm to 2000 nm. The spectrometer integrates an on-chip dispersive echelle grating with a single-element propagating superconducting nanowire detector of ultraslow-velocity for mapping the dispersed photons with high spatial resolutions. The demonstrated on-chip single-photon spectrometer features small device footprint, high robustness with no moving parts and meanwhile offers more than 200 equivalent wavelength detection channels with further scalability.

Single photon devices are needed for many future technologies, but resolving the color of single photons in a compact architecture is still a challenge. The authors present a broadband, chip-scale spectrometer for measuring single photon wavelengths from 600 to 2000 nm with no moving parts.

Introduction

High-performance single-photon spectrometers are among the most sought-after instruments in cutting-edge research fields especially for applications in photon-scarce environments. For example, in the applications such as astronomical spectroscopy¹, fluorescence imaging^2,3, and remote sensing, the signal light is extremely faint, and thus single-photon sensitive spectrometers with low-dark count noise are crucial. In wavelength division multiplexed quantum communications^4–7, advanced single-photon detectors with spectral resolvability combining low-dark counts, fast speed, and high timing resolution are ideal devices as the quantum receivers. However, current implementations of single-photon spectrometers consist of bulky wavelength-scanning components and photomultiplier tubes or semiconductor-based single-photon counters of finite channels^8–10, hindering parallel detection of broadband photon input with high spectral resolutions. Moreover, the semiconductor detectors, such as InGaAs single-photon avalanche diodes used in telecom-band photon counting, also suffer from huge dark counts, limited efficiency, slow speed and after-pulsing¹¹.

On the other hand, superconducting nanowire single-photon detectors (SNSPDs)^12,13 have recently emerged as one of the best alternatives, outperforming the semiconductor counterparts in all aspects with near-unity efficiency, high speed, low jitter, low dark counts^14–18, and the capability of on-chip integration with integrated nanophotonic circuits^19–28. However, these detectors operate in a strong non-linear mode—only informing the presence or absence of photons—and thus cannot discriminate the energy or provide the spectral information of the detected photons. Waveguide-based structure is proposed to circumvent this problem²⁹, where up to eight parallel SNSPDs are co-integrated with an arrayed waveguide grating, and used for the fluorescence imaging of color centers in diamond. Yet, individual readout scheme is employed here for the discrete detector array, which ultimately limits the scalability of the detection channels as well as further improvement of the spectral resolution and operation bandwidth. In another research on fiber-assisted spectrometers^30,31, SNSPDs are employed in conjunction with very long fibers to convert the arrival time of detected photons to the wavelength information based on the large dispersion introduced by the fibers. However, this scheme only works with pulsed photon sources, and the complete set-up comprises discrete components that remain to be integrated.

Here, we propose and experimentally implement a broadband on-chip single-photon spectrometer that overcomes all the above-mentioned challenges. By interfacing a millimeter-size nanophotonic echelle grating with a single-element meandered SNSPD, we realize continuous mapping of the spectral information of dispersed input photons (Fig. 1a). The meandered SNSPD is capped with a high-k (high-dielectric constant) layer to form a microstrip transmission line with a group velocity as low as 0.0073c (c: the speed of light in vacuum) for precision time-tagging, which has been recently employed to realize a single-photon imager³². With a continuous NbN nanowire of a total length of 7 mm, we demonstrate more than 200 effective single-photon detection channels over a broad wavelength range between 600 and 2000 nm. This on-chip spectrometer uniquely combines the benefits of planar nanophotonic and superconducting nanowire circuits and therefore is inherently scalable. Future scale-up fabrication of our design at wafer dimensions could further enhance the spectral resolution and the number of detection channels while maintaining the same integration and readout architecture.

Fig. 1.

Device architecture and operation principle. a–d Three-dimensional sketch of the device. The on-chip focusing echelle grating operates as wavelength-discriminating microphotonic component while the superconducting nanowire functions simultaneously as a single-photon detector and a slow microwave delay line to continuously map the dispersed photons. The nanowire is capped with AlO_x as high-k dielectric material and Al as top metal ground to form a slow microwave transmission line. e Schematic illustration of the Rowland mounting. The input waveguide and the superconducting nanowire are mounted on the Rowland circle, which internally tangents with the focusing grating line. The focusing grating is projected from a flat grating with the radius of the curvature equal to the diameter of the Rowland circle. f Schematic representation of the signal transduction pathway and the device operation principle

Results

Principle and device design

The dispersive component of our device is based on the echelle grating, which is known in astronomical and precision spectroscopy for its high dispersive power. With the advent of integrated photonics, it becomes feasible to lithographically define millimeter-diameter echelle gratings on a chip and effectively disperse the incoming photons from an input waveguide, as recently demonstrated in silicon photonic structures³³. Here, we implement the echelle spectrometer in stoichiometric silicon nitride (Si₃N₄) to allow for broadband optical waveguiding from visible to mid-infrared. In Fig. 1e, we present the schematic of the standard Rowland mounting³⁴ to illustrate the operation principle. The facets of a flat grating are projected onto a circular section to form a focusing grating with the radius equal to the diameter of the Rowland circle, upon which the input waveguide and the superconducting nanowire are lithographically mounted. The focusing grating and the Rowland circle are internally tangent at the center of the grating. Photons are first edge-coupled from the lensed fiber into the tapered Si₃N₄ waveguide (Fig. 1c) and then diverge in the free propagation region of the dielectric slab within the Rowland circle (Fig. 1d). Afterwards, the photons are reflected, diffracted, and refocused by the concave grating to the focusing point P on the superconducting nanowire (Fig. 1e), the position of which varies with the wavelength of the input photons. The diffraction angle is determined by the equation

$$d\left(\sin \left({\theta }_{\mathrm{in}}\right)+\sin \left({\theta }_m\right)\right)=\frac{m\lambda }{n_{\mathrm{eff}}},$$ 1

where d is the period of the grating, θ_in the angle of incidence, θ_m the angle of the mth order diffraction, λ the wavelength of the incident photons in free space, and n_eff the effective refractive index of the mode in the slab waveguide. The blaze angle of the grating facets can be tuned to guide the diffracted light into the desired order.

While inheriting all conventional merits of SNSPDs, our nanowire detector features an ultralow-velocity microwave delay line formed by capping the NbN superconducting nanowire with high-k dielectric material (alumina or AlO_x) and top metal ground (aluminum or Al) as shown in Fig. 1b. Due to the very large kinetic inductance of the nanowire and the slow microstrip line design, the pair of photon-excited microwave pulses of opposite polarities propagate slowly at a group velocity as low as 0.73% of the vacuum speed along the circumference of the Rowland circle. It is worth noting that this is the slowest result reported among the superconducting nanowire delay lines and twice slower than oxide-cladded delay lines achieved previously²⁸ (see Supplementary Note 3). As a result, the times of arrival to the amplifiers attached at the both ends of the nanowire transmission line could be registered with high temporal resolution. This time-tagged single-photon signal or the arrival time difference Δt = t₁ − t₂ can be used to trace out the spatial distribution of incident photons. In our nanophotonic devices, this spatial distribution in turn arises from dispersed photons of different colors by the echelle grating with high spatial resolution (Fig. 1f). Therefore, our design permits a single-element nanowire to function as a multi-channel spectral-resolving single-photon detector.

To demonstrate the proof of principle and modes of operation, multiple devices of varying size and design parameters are fabricated on the same chip and cooled down to 1.5 K temperature in a dilution refrigerator for characterizations. The edge-coupling scheme between the fiber and the device chip based on our cryogenic active alignment set-up could guarantee broad spectrum input coupling from visible to infrared waveband. We categorize the devices into two main designs: (i) broadband design based on a 400 µm-radius Rowland circle and targeting 600–2000 nm waveband and (ii) telecom-band devices using a larger 1.6 mm-radius Rowland circle and dedicatedly designed for telecommunication waveband between 1420 and 1640 nm. More details on the design parameters, device fabrication and characterization can be found in the Methods section and Supplementary Notes 1 and 2. The optical micrograph and scanning electron micrograph (SEM) images for one of the broadband devices are shown in Fig. 2a–d. The detector part consists of a long 60 nm-wide meandering NbN wire, both ends of which are gradually tapered to microns width to form Klopfenstein-type impedance tapers that help preserve the fast-rising edges of photon-excited microwave pulses.

Fig. 2.

Broadband device images. a Overview optical micrograph image of the device. The input waveguide is first split into two waveguides, one to feed photons to the spectrometer, the other used for power calibration and monitoring the return power during the fiber-to-chip alignment. At the ends of the impedance tapers, the microstrip lines are converted to coplanar waveguides (CPWs) to match the modes of ground-signal-ground (GSG) RF probes. The yellow color represents Al and AlO_x beneath, while the signal pads in orange color are made of gold (Au). Scale bar, 250 µm. b Close-up SEM image of the impedance taper. Both ends of the nanowire detector are tapered from 60 nm to microns width to preserve the fast-rising edges of photon-excited microwave pulses. Scale bar, 10 µm. c Close-up SEM image of the meander nanowire detector. The nanowire is patterned from 8 nm-thick NbN film. The width, pitch and depth of the nanowire is 60 nm, 700 nm and 3 µm, respectively. Scale bar, 1. d Angular SEM view of a section of the echelle grating. The pitch of the grating teeth is 0.8 µm and the blaze angle is 20 degree. Scale bar, 1 µm. e Expanded SEM view of the waveguide splitter. Scale bar, 10 µm. The SEM images are taken prior to the deposition of AlO_x and Al for Device B (see Supplementary Note 1)

Broadband device

Figure 3a presents 2.5-dimensional finite-difference time-domain (FDTD) simulation results of the broadband device. As expected, the diffracted light could be well refocused on the Rowland circle where the superconducting nanowire is placed. For shorter wavelengths, higher-order diffraction modes (m > 1) exist, but they are effectively suppressed at least one order of magnitude lower than fundamental modes by tuning the blaze angle of the grating. The 0th order mode (m = 0) represents the direct reflection of the input beam by the grating without diffraction, which do not have wavelength-discriminating effect and are not desired. The nanowire detector therefore is not mounted in this diffraction region. In Fig. 3b, we plot the normalized histogram of photon counts versus Δt measured for different wavelength input photons (see Supplementary Note 7 for the raw data). All the major peaks are from TE modes, while the minor peaks marked by dashed circles are due to the TM modes, n_eff of which are always smaller than that of TE modes. The TM modes are excited at shorter wavelengths due to the multimode operation of the input waveguide, while they are suppressed for longer wavelengths where the waveguide only supports single TE modes. Note that such imperfection could be resolved in future optimizations of the device by introducing an on-chip TE-pass polarizer to the input waveguide. The full width at half maximum (FWHM) of the major peaks are 13–19 ps, which corresponds to a better than 7 nm spectral resolution and suggests more than 200 wavelength detection channels between 600–2000 nm. In Fig. 3c, Δt corresponding to the major peaks are extracted and plotted versus the wavelength, which agrees well with the diffraction angles obtained from the FDTD simulation results (see Fig. 1e for the angle definition). Figure 3d shows the normalized photon counting rates measured as a function of the relative bias current to the switching current (I_bias/I_SW) at wavelengths from 750 to 1970 nm. Apparent saturation behavior is observed for all the curves, suggesting a near-unity internal quantum efficiency of the nanowire detector over the whole spectrum^14–16. To the best of our knowledge, it is the first time to realize such a compact on-chip single-photon spectrometer simultaneously covering visible and infrared wavebands.

Fig. 3.

Broadband device results. a Electric field distribution of the device from 2.5-dimensional FDTD simulation results at different wavelengths. Scale bar, 100 µm. b Normalized histogram of photon counts versus time difference Δt measured for different wavelength photons from 600 nm to 1970 nm. The main peaks are from the TE modes while the minor peaks marked by the dashed circles are from TM modes. The histogram is recorded with the nanowire detector biased at 80% of its switching current I_SW. c Comparison between experimentally measured Δt and the diffraction angle extracted from the simulation results. d Normalized photon counting rates (PCR) measured as a function of the bias current relative to the switching current of the device I_bias/I_SW at wavelengths from 750 to 1970 nm. The complete saturation trend of the curves indicates a near-unity internal quantum efficiency of the nanowire detector over the whole spectrum. The histogram results are taken from Device C with double-nanowire detector, while the efficiency curves are measured from Device B with single-nanowire structure for better comparison between different wavelengths (see Supplementary Note 1)

Telecom-band device

The spectral-resolving power of our on-chip single-photon spectrometer can be further assessed with a telecom-band device design, which has four times larger Rowland circle radius and uses 6th order diffraction for enhanced dispersive effect. Figure 4a shows the normalized histogram of photon counts versus Δt. The FWHM of each peak is 25–30 ps, corresponding to a resolution of 2.5–3 nm in wavelength. In order to further evaluate the spectral resolution, we combine two continuous-wave (CW) laser beams with wavelengths separated by 2.5 nm through a fiber-splitter and send them to the device after an appropriate attenuation. As shown in Fig. 4b, there are two distinctly resolved peaks, consistent with the projected resolution for single photons. Due to the continuous and sub-wavelength structure of the nanowire detector, the measurement precision of Δt can be always boosted by repetitive measurement, which indicates that our spectrometer device can also work in wavelength-meter mode to provide a resolution well beyond the aforementioned value when measuring the wavelength of single-color input photons. The histogram curves shown in Fig. 4c displays the response from light inputs of 0.1 nm wavelength difference. We note that the resolution in this operation mode is not determined by the FWHM values of the histogram peaks but limited by the stability of laser source and the long integration time of the histogram measurement associated with the limited acquisition speed and refresh rate of the oscilloscope. By further scaling our device and utilizing application-specific high speed correlation electronics as oppose to an oscilloscope, we expect that the wavelength resolution could be improved to picometer level. We also characterize the timing performance of the spectrometer by recording the histogram of photon counts as a function of the arrival time difference between the detector signal and the synchronization signal of a 2.4 ps-pulsed laser. The results are shown in Fig. 4d with 40 ps jitter defined as the FWHM of the histogram profile, which is consistent with conventional SNSPDs. More details on the jitter characterization and the impact of noise-introduced timing jitter on spectral resolution are provided in Supplementary Notes 5 and 6.

Fig. 4.

Telecom-band device results. a Normalized histogram of photon counts versus time difference Δt measured for photons with different wavelength from 1480 to 1640 nm. b Normalized histogram measured for a mixture of two coherent light sources with their wavelengths separated by 2.5 nm. The red dashed line represents double-Gaussian fitting for the measured data, which is the sum of two Gaussian distribution displayed in blue dashed lines. c Normalized histogram measured for a single-color source with slightly varied wavelength step by 0.1 nm. d Normalized histogram measured for a 1560 nm pulsed source as a function of the arrival time difference between the averaged detector signal (t₁ + t₂)/2 and laser synchronization signal t₀. All the histogram results are measured with the nanowire detector biased at 80% of I_SW. All the results are taken from Device A (see Supplementary Note 1)

Discussion

The ultimate resolution of our single-photon spectrometer is set by the achievable size of the grating which is eventually limited by the wafer size and also the total length of the nanowire delay line to cover all the desired diffraction angles. As detailed in Supplementary Note 8, we estimate that 100 pm resolution with 200 nm bandwidth and thus 2000 wavelength channels is feasible with a telecom-band device design based on a 50 mm-radius Rowland circle and a 40 mm-long nanowire. In order to realize such a device, although we anticipate that the superconducting nanowire circuit could be fabricated without degradation as previously demonstrated in large-area SNSPDs³⁵, some technical challenges remain to be solved on the photonics side, such as pattern decoherence induced by thermal expansion and stitching error during the electron-beam lithography of large nanophotonic structure across distant writing fields. Future improvement also requires the optimization of the device design to improve the system detection efficiency (see Supplementary Notes 1 and 4) and remove the non-Gaussian tails in the histogram results to increase the dynamic range (see Supplementary Note 7). It is also notable that although this work focuses on the single-photon detection regime, our on-chip spectrometer can also be extended to study two-photon absorption events²⁸ and thus could be an important tool for characterizing spectrally entangled photon pairs. Moreover, our design can be easily extended to mid-infrared waveband, where lots of important and fast-emerging applications reside, such as remote sensing and single-photon lidar. We envision that our spectrometers will find important and immediate applications in quantum sensing, communication and frontier spectroscopic imaging technologies.

Methods

Device fabrication

The photonic circuit components are patterned from 330 nm-thick stoichiometric Si₃N₄ on Si wafers covered with 3.3 µm-thick thermally grown oxide. The superconducting detectors and microwave circuits are realized in a 8 nm-thick NbN thin film, which is deposited on the Si₃N₄ with alignment markers (10 nm Cr/100 nm Au) fabricated in advance. After the NbN film deposition, we define superconducting nanowires along with impedance tapers by the exposure of negative-tone 6% hydrogen silsesquioxane (HSQ) resist using high-resolution (100 kV) electron-beam lithography (EBL) and the subsequent development in tetramethylammonium hydroxide-based developer MF-312. In a second EBL step, electrode pads are defined using double-layer polymethyl methacrylate (PMMA) positive-tone resist. After the development in methyl isobutyl ketone and isopropyl alcohol, we liftoff electron-beam evapoarted 10 nm Cr adhesion layer and 100 nm Au in acetone to form the contact pads. Later, the HSQ nanowire pattern is transferred to the NbN layer in a timed reactive-ion etching (RIE) step employing tetrafluoromethane (CF4) chemistry. In a third EBL step, we expose the positive-tone ZEP520A polymer resist for the photonic microstructures, including echelle gratings and waveguides. The patterns are aligned to the same alignment marks used in the previous steps for defining the superconducting nanowires. Following development in xylenes, the grating and waveguide patterns are transferred to the Si₃N4 film via carefully timed RIE in fluoroform (CHF3). The remaining resist is removed by hot NMP and gentle oxygen plasma. Afterwards, the AlO_x spacing layer and Al top ground layer are fabricated by another double-layer PMMA exposure in a fourth and final EBL step and the following development, electron-beam evaporation and lift off. The resulting devices are shown in Fig. 2 and Supplementary Note 1.

Optical grating and waveguide design

To ensure high fabrication yield and verify the device principles, in this work we design relatively small gratings and short nanowires. The radius of Rowland circle for broadband device is 400 µm, while the telecom-band device is 1.6 mm. For the broadband design, we use small grating pitch (0.8 µm) and fundamental diffraction mode (m = 1) to minimize the order mixing. For the telecom-band design, we use a much larger grating pitch size (8 µm) and higher-order mode (m = 6) to enhance the resolution and directivity. The width of the optical waveguide is 1.2 µm to suppress TM modes and higher-order TE modes for telecom wavelength around 1550 nm. For efficient coupling with off-chip fibers, the input part of the waveguide is adiabatically tapered to 4 µm to match the mode size of the lensed fiber.

Detector and microwave circuit design

The NbN nanowires on the Rowland circle are 60 nm wide, which is narrow enough to provide saturated detection efficiency of single photons over the whole spectrum as shown in Fig. 3d. For some of the devices, two nanowires are connected in parallel to boost the signal-to-noise ratio^36–38 while still maintaining the saturated internal detection efficiency (see Supplementary Notes 1 and 5 for more details). The NbN nanowires are capped with 150 nm-thick AlO_x and 150 nm-thick Al to allow the nanowires to also function as microwave delay lines. As a result, a signal propagation velocity of as low as 0.73% c is experimentally obtained, where c denotes the speed of light in vacuum. To preserve the fast-rising edges of the photon-excited detector pulses in readout circuits, we use Klopfenstein tapers for matching the impedance of the RF probe and cables to the nanowires by transforming the nanowire impedance to 50 Ω. The total length of the tapers is 8.8 mm, corresponding to 2.5 times effective wavelength of 1 GHz signal in the transmission line.

Device characterization

The sample chip containing multiple spectrometer devices is cleaved after fabrication and then mounted on a 3-axis stack of stages (Attocube) inside a dilution refrigerator (BlueFors) and cooled down to 1.5 K temperature. We drive the stages to move the sample chip and make the electrode contact with a multi-channel RF probe. Another set of 3-axis stages (Attocube) are employed to align a single-mode tapered/lensed fiber (OZ Optics) to couple light into the devices from waveguide facet. This cryogenic active edge-coupling set-up guarantees efficient fiber-to-chip coupling over a broadband spectrum and also allows us to characterize multiple devices on one chip within a single cool-down experimental procedure. We use a broadband thermal light source (Thorlabs SLS201L) and a monochromator (Newport CS130) to generate 600–1400 nm wavelength lines and employ tunable CW laser sources to generate other lines including 1480–1640 nm (Santec TSL-710) and 1970 nm (Thorlabs TLK-L1900M). For timing jitter characterization, we use a 2.4 ps-pulsed 1560 nm laser (PolarOnyx). The arrival time difference (Δt) of forward and backward photon-excited detector pulses are recorded by a 4 GHz and 40 GSample/s oscilloscope (Lecroy HDO9404). In order to minimize the extra timing jitter induced by the electronic noises from the readout circuits and thus maximize the spectral resolution, we employ two SiGe cryogenic low-noise amplifiers (Cosmic Microwave Technology CITLF1) operating at 4 K temperature to read out the photon-excited detector pulses (see Supplementary Note 5).

Author contributions

R.C., C.-L.Z., X.G. and H.X.T. conceived the idea and experiment; R.C. designed the devices; R.C. and S.W. fabricated the device; R.C. and X.H. performed the measurements; R.C., C.-L.Z. and X.G. analyzed the data. R.C., C.-L.Z. and H.X.T. wrote the paper with input from all authors. H.X.T. supervised the project.

Data availability

The data that support the plots within this paper and other findings of this study are available from the corresponding author upon reasonable request.

Competing interests

The authors declare no competing interests.

Supplementary information

Supplementary Information accompanies this paper at 10.1038/s41467-019-12149-x.