A novel construct with biomechanical flexibility for articular cartilage regeneration

Abstract

Background

Although tissue-engineered cartilage has been broadly studied, complete integration of regenerated cartilage with residual cartilage is still difficult for the inferior mechanical and biochemical feature of neocartilage. Chondrogenesis of mesenchymal stem cells can be induced by biophysical and biochemical factors.

Methods

In this study, autologous platelet-rich fibrin (PRF) membrane was used as a growth factor-rich scaffold that may facilitate differentiation of the transplanted bone marrow mesenchymal stem cells (BMSCs). At the same time, hydrostatic pressure was adopted for pre-adjustment of the seed cells before transplantation that may promote the mechanical flexibility of neocartilage.

Results

An in vitro study showed that the feasible hydrostatic pressure stimulation substantially promoted the chondrogenic potential of in vitro-cultured BMSC/PRF construct. In vivo results revealed that at every time point, the newborn tissues were the most favorable in the pressure-pretreated BMSC/PRF transplant group. Besides, the transplantation of feasible hydrostatic pressure-pretreated construct by BMSC sheet fragments and PRF granules could obviously improve the integration between the regenerated cartilage and host cartilage milieu, and thereby achieve boundaryless repair between the neocartilage and residual host cartilage tissue in rabbit temporomandibular joints. It could be concluded that feasible hydrostatic pressure may effectively promote the proliferation and chondrogenic differentiation of BMSCs in a BMSC/PRF construct.

Conclusion

This newly formed construct with biomechanical flexibility showed a superior capacity for cartilage regeneration by promoting the mechanical properties and integration of neocartilage.

Electronic supplementary material

The online version of this article (10.1186/s13287-019-1399-2) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Background

Despite its seemingly simple structure of the articular cartilage, the avascular nature of cartilage compromises its endogeneous capacity for repair, leading to a high incidence of unsolved cartilage-related injuries. Once damaged, full recovery of its structure, function, and biomechanical properties is not expected in most cases, and the damaged articular cartilage can proceed toward degeneration [1]. Traditional techniques for cartilage repair include marrow stimulation, allografts, and autografts. Although successful in some aspects, each of these techniques has limitations, such as forming fibrocartilage of inferior quality that does not persist, lacks integration, or acquires additional defects, especially when the lesion is beyond a limited size and severity [2]. Next-generation cell-based therapy uses stem cells instead of chondrocytes [3, 4]. Bone marrow mesenchymal stem cells (BMSCs) are the most widely adopted seed cells for cartilage regeneration [5–7]. Preclinical and clinical trials using adult mesenchymal stem cells have demonstrated encouraging results, although there are many unsolved problems at this moment [1]. Regenerated cartilage often undergoes degeneration and reorganization into fibrocartilaginous tissue and may eventually disappear, leading to delamination and exposure of subchondral bone [8]. There is still a gap in the proteoglycan content and mechanical properties between the neocartilage and autologous articular cartilage [9, 10]. Till now, ideal physiological and functional cartilage regeneration has not been achieved [11, 12]. It was hypothesized that the lack of success was due to the lack of some critical factors and cues for chondrogenic cell differentiation and biomechanical adaption from the seed cells’ milieu.

For cartilage regeneration, the matrix milieu aims to provide the transplanted stem cells a stable chondrogenic differentiation environment, while the mechanical milieu is critical to the quality and quantity of neocartilage tissues [12, 13]. It was known that the biomechanical environment of the articular cartilage, consisting of forces over a large range of motion, can take a devastating toll on neocartilage that lacks adequate biomechanical properties [9]. Because stem cells have a greater mechanical sensitivity than adult cells [13], biomechanical signals play a key role in regulating the phenotypic differentiation of stem cells [14]. In fact, to repair articular cartilage defects, tissue-engineered cartilage transplant inevitably has to fulfill the function of a load-bearing structure. Therefore, the transplant must regenerate and then play its role in a particular mechanical milieu. Despite the critical role of mechanical cues in articular cartilage maintenance [15–17], higher repair efficiency, lateral integration, and further functional cartilage regeneration by biomechanical milieu regulation have not been implemented.

Here we set out to develop a novel scaffold-free tissue-engineered cartilage transplant with biomechanical flexibility that may show a superior capacity for cartilage regeneration. To achieve this, autologous platelet-rich fibrin (PRF) membrane was used as a growth factor-rich scaffold that may facilitate differentiation of the transplanted BMSCs. At the same time, hydrostatic pressure was adopted for pre-adjustment of the seed cells before transplantation that may promote the mechanical flexibility of neocartilage. Our results provide the first evidence that the transplantation of mechanically pretreated construct by BMSC sheets fragments and PRF granules could obviously improve the integration between the regenerated cartilage and host cartilage milieu, and thereby achieve boundaryless repair between the neocartilage and residual host cartilage tissue in the temporomandibular joint (TMJ). This work demonstrates that biomechanical pressure is an indispensable factor that promotes tissue-engineered regeneration and repair of TMJ articular cartilage and plays a crucial role in improving the mechanical properties and integration of neocartilage. It may provide valuable insights into the development of future treatment options for articular cartilage regenerative medicine.

Methods

Derivation of BMSC sheet and PRF membrane

Adult male New Zealand rabbits (approximately 4 months old) were obtained from the Animal Center, Fourth Military Medical University. BMSCs were cultured using the whole marrow-adherence method, and then were identified (see Additional file 1: Figure S1). The rabbit BMSCs (P3) obtained in the previous section were placed into six-well plates at a density of 3 × 10⁴ cells/well in complete medium until they reached subconfluence. Vitamin C was then added at a concentration of 48 μg/ml for a further incubation until the edge of the cell sheet became slightly rolled up, which is believed to be an indication of cell sheet maturation. For PRF preparation, 10-ml blood samples were extracted aseptically from the central auricular arteries of rabbits using a 10-ml disposable syringe and then immediately transferred into glass centrifuge tubes. PRF was obtained by immediate centrifugation of blood samples at 3000 r/min for 10 min. The PRF clot formed in the middle layer of the tube was taken using sterile tweezers and gently compressed with two pieces of sterile dry gauze for 10 s, to form the PRF membrane. The growth curve of BMSCs in the BMSC/PRF construct and continued growth factor release from PRF in the BMSC/PRF construct over 96 h were detected (see Additional file 2: Figure S2 and Additional file 3: Table S1).

Selection of favorable hydrostatic pressure conditions for BMSC proliferation and chondrogenic differentiation in co-cultured BMSC/PRF construct

The indirectly co-cultured BMSC cell sheet and PRF membrane were stimulated with hydrostatic pressure using a custom-designed multi-functional in vitro cell compression system (see Additional file 4: Figure S3). The specific characteristics of the compression device, its operation procedures, and the selection of favorable pressure conditions are described [18–20]. Our group has demonstrated that in an environment loaded with pressure using the compression device, 90 kPa for 1 h can result in extensive biological effects on BMSCs, including enhanced cell proliferation activity, elevated alkaline phosphatase activity, upregulation of estrogen receptor-α, and assembly of intracellular stress fibers [21]. In the present study, we compressed the BMSC/PRF construct rather than monolayer-cultured BMSCs to investigate the effects of biomechanical stimulation to the chondrogenic characteristics of the construct. Therefore, according to the optimal pressure condition for BMSCs selected in the previous experiments, we increased the force value and prolonged the time to determine the most suitable conditions of pressure stimulation for chondrogenic differentiation of BMSCs in the construct. During the experiment, six-well plates containing the construct were placed in the cell compression device and stimulated with pressure under fixed conditions for either 1 or 6 h every day for 2, 4, or 6 days. Thus, the 2-day, 4-day, and 6-day treatment groups were each subdivided into 0 kPa/1 h, 0 kPa/6 h, 90 kPa/1 h, 90 kPa/6 h, 120 kPa/1 h, 120 kPa/6 h, 150 kPa/1 h, and 150 kPa/6 h subgroups.

For real-time PCR (polymerase chain reaction) analysis, the total cellular RNA was isolated from the maintenance cell cultures with Trizol (Invitrogen, Carlsbad, CA, USA) to evaluate the expression of cell proliferation markers, including Pcna (proliferating cell nuclear antigen), and chondrogenesis-related genes, including Sox9 (SRY-related HMG box-9), Col II (collagen II), and Acan (Aggrecan) by real-time PCR (TaKaRa Bio, Tokyo, Japan). The reaction product was quantified using a relative quantification tool (CFX Manager, Bio-Rad) with Gadph as a reference gene. The primer sequences for Pcna, Acan, Sox9, and Col II (Sango Biotech, Shanghai, China) are listed in Additional file 5: Table S2. Afterwards, the effects of the hydrostatic stimulation of the BMSC/PRF construct on cartilage regeneration were evaluated both in vitro and in vivo.

Electron microscopic observation of the pressure effects on the ultrastructure of BMSCs co-cultured with PRF

The BMSC sheet and indirectly co-cultured BMSC sheet and PRF treated with and without the abovementioned optimal mechanical stimulation were prepared to observe the ultrastructural changes of BMSCs. After treatment, the cell sheet was immediately fixed in 3% glutaraldehyde–1.5% paraformaldehyde followed by 1% osmic acid–1.5% potassium ferrocyanide and then observed using transmission electron microscopy (TEM). Additionally, the culture solution for each culture specimen was removed. The specimens were immersed in 2.5% glutaraldehyde and fixed at 4 °C for 2 h. After CO₂ critical-point drying and gold-ion sputtering, the specimens were observed, and images were acquired by scanning electron microscopy (SEM).

Construction of the BMSC/PRF tissue-engineering transplant

The rabbit BMSC sheet and PRF were prepared as previously described in “Derivation of BMSC sheet and PRF membrane”. Then, the PRFs were cut into small pieces (0.5 × 0.5 × 0.5 mm) in a sterile dish. The cell sheet was stripped with forceps from the dish and chopped into cell sheet fragments (0.5 × 0.5 mm). The transplanted BMSC/PRF construct for subsequent ectopic or orthotopic cartilage tissue regeneration was obtained by combining cell sheet fragments of BMSCs with PRF granules at the ratio that we selected prior to this work (see Additional file 6: Figure S4 and Additional file 7: Figure S5) [22].

Ectopic transplantation of the biomechanical pressure-pretreated BMSC/PRF construct in nude mice

Forty-five nude mice (6-week-old males; Fourth Military Medical University Animal Center, Xi’an, China) were used. Mice were equally and randomly assigned to three groups for transplantation of BMSC sheet, BMSC/PRF construct, and pressure-pretreated BMSC/PRF construct, respectively. Anesthesia was achieved by intramuscular injection of 1% sodium pentobarbital (30 mg/kg). An approximately 1-cm skin incision was made aseptically above the posterior superior iliac spine along both sides of the back of each mouse. Blunt dissection of the subcutaneous tissue formed two subcutaneous pockets. Each group of animals was transplanted with a pure BMSC sheet, a statically cultured BMSC/PRF construct, or a pressure-pretreated BMSC/PRF construct. The material wrapping a 0.028-g fragment of auricular cartilage was transplanted into the subcutis of nude mice to imitate the cartilage milieu. Thereafter, the incision was closely sutured. Specimens were taken at 2, 4, and 8 weeks after surgery, five mice at each time point. The specimens were fixed in 4% paraformaldehyde for 48 h and then dehydrated, cleared, and embedded in paraffin following conventional procedures. Subsequently, the specimens were sliced longitudinally from the central area, and the sections were subjected to hematoxylin and eosin (HE) and toluidine blue (TB) staining before light microscopy observation.

Samples for glycosaminoglycan (GAG) content determination were taken at predetermined time points and lyophilized, and digested with 1 ml of 0.1% papain solution. Hoechst 33258 was added for DNA dye, and the absorbance was measured by a fluorescence spectrophotometer at 460 nm to detect the total DNA content in the sample. Dimethyl methylene blue was added, and the absorbance of each sample was detected at 525 nm to determine the content of GAG in the sample. The ratio of GAG content to DNA content (GAG/DNA) was characterized as GAG secreting ability of each sample. Six parallel samples were set up in the experiment.

Animal surgery and groups

A total of 180 skeletally mature, male, 6-month-old New Zealand White rabbits, obtained from the Animal Center (Fourth Military Medical University), were used to create a full-thickness, bilateral chondral defect model based on previous studies [23, 24]. Animals were randomly assigned to five groups: blank control (natural recovery, Group A), PRF alone (Group B), BMSC sheet alone (Group C), BMSC/PRF construct (Group D), and pressure-pretreated BMSC/PRF construct (Group E). First, we established a rabbit model of articular cartilage defect in unilateral TMJ (3 mm in diameter and 3 mm in depth) (see Additional file 8: Figure S6). Then, animals of the control group were used to simply establish a condylar cartilage defect model, without any repair treatment. Animals of the PRF alone group were transplanted with the PRF membrane. The PRF was trimmed into small pieces slightly larger than the condylar cartilage defect area and carefully filled into the defect. The PRF membrane was kept in close contact with the hole wall, and its surface was level with the surface of the surrounding normal articular cartilage. The same procedure was followed to transplant the BMSC sheet, the BMSC/PRF construct, and the pressure-pretreated BMSC/PRF construct into the corresponding groups. Then, the articular disc was repositioned, and the skin and joint capsule were closed. To ensure normal eating after surgery, for all the experimental animals, only right TMJ received defect and repair operation, with the other side of TMJ receiving just open-and-close operation as a sham. Total repetition for each experimental group was 12 (n = 12). To minimize discomfort, carprofen (4 mg/kg) was administered for 3 days postoperatively. All animals were returned to their cages where they were allowed unrestricted weight-bearing activity and were observed for signs of pain, infection, and proper activity.

Histomorphometric evaluation of explants

Animals were sacrificed 2, 4, or 8 weeks after surgery to collect specimens. For histological staining, after gross observation of the repaired tissue, the specimens were immediately fixed in 4% paraformaldehyde for 48 h and then dehydrated, cleared, and embedded in paraffin following conventional procedures. Sections were sliced along the sagittal plane of condyle, perpendicular to the defect repair area. The section specimens were stained with HE staining and 1% TB staining before light microscopy observation. For each sample, five slides were randomly selected and five high power fields (× 200) on each slice were randomly selected for chondrocyte-like cells counting, which appeared as round or oval cells by HE staining. Histological sections from each location of each joint were scored blindly and independently using a well-established scoring algorithm for osteochondral tissue repair. Seven total parameters were used to analyze tissue repair for the cartilage defect according to the modified histomorphometric evaluation of explants as the individual chondral and subchondral regions [25] (see Additional file 9: Table S3). The overall defect repair was evaluated for the percent filled with newly formed tissue and percent degradation of the implant. The chondral defect region was evaluated for tissue morphology, thickness, regularity, chondrocyte clustering, and cell/GAG content. The subchondral defect region was examined for quality of new tissue filling, integration, and cartilage morphology.

Chondrogenetic gene detection in repaired cartilage

For genetic detection, specimens were collected and immediately placed into microcentrifuge tubes containing 1 ml of PCR preservative solution. The tubes were placed on ice, and cartilage was resected from the defect site in the condyle and fully ground in liquid nitrogen. For real-time PCR analysis, total cellular RNA was isolated from the samples with Trizol (Invitrogen, Carlsbad, CA, USA) to evaluate the expression of chondrogenesis-related genes, including Sox9, Col II, and Acan, by real-time PCR (TaKaRa Bio, Tokyo, Japan). The reaction products were quantified using a relative quantification tool (CFX Manager, Bio-Rad) with Gadph as a reference gene. The primer sequences for Acan, Sox9, and Col II (Sango Biotech, Shanghai, China) are listed in Additional file 5: Table S2.

Biomechanical assay for the elastic modulus of the regenerated articular cartilage

For the biomechanical assay of the elastic modulus of the tissue-engineered cartilage, we prepared condyles of each group into a cubic shape, being centered at the condylar cartilage defect and having smooth, parallel upper and lower surfaces. We measured and calculated the cross-sectional area and height of the sample before determining the longitudinal elastic modulus. The line of force of the loading device was set perpendicular to the sample surface before measurement. The ElectroForce® 3200 Series III test instrument (Bose Corporation Endura TEC Systems Group, Minnetonka, MN, USA) was applied for low-force testing of the engineered cartilage. The relative displacement and load were measured at a compression rate of 1 mm/min. The load–displacement curve was drawn with displacement as the abscissa axis and load as the vertical axis. In the initial stage of the load–displacement curve, we chose to analyze the relatively smooth, linear portion and calculated the elastic modulus (E) of the tissue-engineered cartilage: E = stress/strain, where stress = load/sectional area of the structure, and strain = relative displacement/height of the sample (see Additional file 10: Figure S8). Specimens of each group had three replicates at each time (2, 4, and 8 weeks).

Statistical analysis

The results are expressed as the mean ± standard deviation and were compared by one-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) in combination with the Newman-Keuls post hoc test. The detection results were statistically analyzed using SPSS 17.0 (SPSS, USA). P < 0.05 was accepted as statistically significant.

Results

Microstructure and ultrastructure of the PRF, BMSC cell sheet, and BMSC/PRF construct

Rabbit BMSCs were isolated and identified (see Additional file 1: Figure S1 and Additional file 2: Figure S2) and then were seeded in six-well plates in α-MEM containing 100 μg/ml vitamin C and 10% fetal bovine serum for 10–14 days. A milky sheet-like structure was formed at the bottom of all culture plates. The edge of the sheet was curled, and white granular nodules were found on the surface of the sheet. After being gently stripped off the plate, the sheet was slightly retracted with certain elasticity (Fig. 1a). Microscopic observation showed good growth of cells, which overlapped and appeared fusiform, in an intertwined arrangement (Fig. 1b). A 10-μl blood sample was rapidly extracted from the central auricular arteries of rabbits and centrifuged in glass tubes at 3000 r/min for 10 min (Fig. 1c). After centrifugation, a PRF clot was visible between the top layer of serum and bottom layer of red corpuscles (Fig. 1d). The glass tubes were allowed to stand for 10–15 min before the PRF clot was completely removed using tweezers (Fig. 1e). When the P3 generation of BMSCs formed the sheet, they were placed in sterile Petri dishes together with the prepared PRF granules. The two components were manually and thoroughly mixed at a particular ratio to obtain the rabbit BMSC/PRF construct (Fig. 1f). The ultra-structural features of the construct were examined from different angles using SEM after 4 days of mixed culture. In the cross section, we found many long, fusiform BMSCs adhering to the porous, reticular structure of PRF (Fig. 1g). In the longitudinal section, cells were embedded into the mesh-like structure of PRF by extending pseudopodia, which closely bound the two components (Fig. 1h, i). Owing to this mechanism, the BMSC/PRF construct formed a coherent whole, rather than two membranes stacked together.

Fig. 1.

Structure of the platelet-rich fibrin (PRF). a A cell sheet that could be fully stripped was formed after 14 days of induction with cell sheet induction medium. b Inverted microscope observation showed the intertwined arrangement and stable growth morphology of the cell sheet (× 40, bar = 200 μm). c Blood samples (10 ml) were extracted from the central auricular arteries of rabbits and immediately centrifuged at 3000 r/min for 10 min. d PRF clot between the top layer of serum containing a few cells and the bottom layer of red corpuscles. e Complete removal of the PRF clot. f Preparation of the BMSC/PRF construct. g–i Cross-sectional observation by SEM. g Horizontal view at low magnification (× 1000). h Longitudinal view at low magnification (× 2000). i Longitudinal view at high magnification (× 20,000) (red arrow: BMSCs; yellow arrow: PRF)

Determination of favorable hydrostatic pressure conditions for BMSC proliferation and chondrogenic differentiation in BMSC/PRF co-culture system

Real-time quantitative PCR analysis showed an overall trend of proliferation and chondrogenic gene expression in the BMSC sheets co-cultured with PRF and stimulated under different pressure conditions. The mRNA expression levels of cell proliferation-related Pcna (Fig. 2a) and chondrogenesis-related Acan (Fig. 2b), Sox9 (Fig. 2c), and Col II (Fig. 2d) peaked in the cells at 4 days and began to decline at 6 days. Further analysis revealed that BMSCs of the construct showed higher Pcan and Acan mRNAs than the non-pressure group at 2 days (P < 0.001, P < 0.05), while no significant difference was found in Sox9 and Col II between the pressure and non-pressure groups at the same time point (P > 0.05). BMSCs in the construct showed significantly higher Pcna, Acan, Sox9, and Col II levels than those in the control group at 4 days (P < 0.05). Under different pressure conditions, all four genes were expressed at the highest levels in the 120 kPa/1 h group, which showed significant differences compared with the other pressure groups at the same time points (P < 0.05). There was no significant difference between the pressure groups stimulated for 1 h and 6 h per day (P > 0.05). After 6 days of repeated pressure loading, only 90 and 120 kPa for 1 h per day exhibited a promoting effect on Col II mRNA. In contrast, a downward trend was found in the expression of proliferation-related genes and most chondrogenic differentiation-related genes in BMSCs under the pressure conditions with the three force values lasting for 6 h per day; however, the decreases were not statistically significant (P > 0.05). According to the quantitative PCR results in the different pressure conditions, we determined that 120 kPa, 1 h per day, for 4 days, was optimal for BMSC proliferation and chondrogenic differentiation.

Fig. 2.

Real-time PCR assay of proliferation- and chondrogenesis-related gene expression in BMSCs of the BMSC/PRF construct under different conditions of mechanical stimulation. a Pcna. b Acan. c Sox9. d Col II. ^*P < 0.05, vs. control group; ^#P < 0.05, vs. indicated group

Effects of favorable hydrostatic pressure to the ultrastructure of the BMSCs

TEM images showed a relatively closed state of endoplasmic reticulum in cells of the BMSC sheet (Fig. 3A_{1, 2}) and that co-cultured with PRF (Fig. 3B_{1, 2}). Partially dilated endoplasmic reticulum was found in BMSC sheets pre-pretreated with the abovementioned optimal mechanical stimulation (Fig. 3C_{1, 2}), while the greatly dilated endoplasmic reticulum was observed in cells of the pressure-pretreated BMSC/PRF construct group (Fig. 3D_{1, 2}). These results indicated that pressure stimulation at 120 kPa/1 h for 4 days enhanced the secretory function of BMSCs in the BMSC/PRF construct. SEM images revealed the presence of a large number of cell populations arranged densely on the surface of the cell sheet and wrapped by extracellular matrix (ECM) in the BMSC group (Fig. 3E_1,2) and the BMSC/PRF group (Fig. 3F_1,2). There was a small number of reticular collagen fibers and particulate proteoglycan-like secretions on the surface of the cell sheet in the pressure-pretreated BMSC sheet group, (Fig. 3G_{1, 2}). In contrast, a large amount of reticular collagen fibers and particulate proteoglycan-like secretions was distributed on the surface of cell sheet in the pressure-pretreated BMSC/PRF construct group (Fig. 3H_{1, 2}). These results indicated that optimal pressure stimulation promotes the secretion of cartilage matrix by BMSCs with PRF in existence.

Fig. 3.

TEM and SEM images of the BMSC/PRF construct. A₁–D₁ TEM images at low magnification (× 5000, bar = 2 μm). A₂–D₂ TEM images at high magnification (× 10,000, bar = 1 μm,); yellow arrow points to the endoplasmic reticulum structure. E₁–H₁ SEM images at low magnification (× 1000, bar = 50 μm). E₂–H₂ SEM images at high magnification (× 3000, bar = 10 μm); white arrow points to granular secretions and red arrow points to reticular collagen fibers

Cartilage regeneration after ectopic transplantation

Forty-five nude mice had normal activities and eating after surgery. The wound healed well, and no swelling or oozing was observed. The transplant showed no significant absorption over time, and the surrounding tissue had no signs of necrosis or infection. Specimens were taken for staining and observation after 2, 4, or 8 weeks of in vivo culture in nude mice. HE staining showed that only a few cartilage-like cells were formed in the BMSC transplantation group at 8 weeks after transplantation. However, in the BMSC/PRF and pressure-pretreated BMSC/PRF transplantation groups, cartilage-like cells were distributed in the cell lacunae after 2, 4, and 8 weeks of culture in the subcutis of nude mice. The cartilage-like cells were surrounded by uniform ECM, and the number of cartilage-like cells formed gradually increased over time. However, the pressure-pretreated BMSC/PRF transplantation group formed a greater number of cartilage-like cells than the other groups at a given time point (Fig. 4A).

Fig. 4.

Histological and biomechanical examination of cartilage tissue regenerated in the subcutis of nude mice using the BMSC/PRF construct. a HE staining of specimens from nude mice. a–c BMSC sheet group at 2, 4, and 8 weeks, respectively; d–f BMSC/PRF construct group at 2, 4, and 8 weeks, respectively; and g–i pressure-pretreated BMSC/PRF construct group at 2, 4, and 8 weeks, respectively (red arrow indicates the implanted cartilage fragment; × 100, bar = 100 μm). b Toluidine blue staining of specimens from nude mice. a–c BMSC sheet group at 2, 4, and 8 weeks, respectively; d–f BMSC/PRF construct group at 2, 4, and 8 weeks, respectively; and g–i pressure-pretreated BMSC/PRF construct group at 2, 4, and 8 weeks, respectively (red arrow indicates the implanted cartilage fragment; × 100, bar = 100 μm). c Image analysis of toluidine blue staining intensity of specimens from nude mice. ^aP < 0.05, vs. BMSC sheet transplantation group; ^bP < 0.05, vs. no-pressure BMSC/PRF transplantation group

After TB staining, the neocartilage-like ECM was stained blue, similar to normal cartilage tissue (Fig. 4B). GAG/DNA ratio analysis revealed that the GAG content gradually increased over time in the BMSC/PRF and pressure-pretreated BMSC/PRF transplantation groups at 2, 4, and 8 weeks, with the GAG/DNA ratios significantly higher than that in the BMSC transplantation group at each given time point (P < 0.05). In particular, the pressure-pretreated BMSC/PRF transplantation group showed significantly higher GAG/DNA ratios than those of the no-pressure BMSC/PRF group at 4 and 8 weeks (P < 0.05) (Fig. 4C).

General observation

Altogether, 176 New Zealand rabbits survived the surgery. The animals had normal activities and eating. No infection of the incision was observed. The growth condition of the animals was good (see Additional file 11: Movie S1 and Additional file 12: Movie S2). At 2, 4, and 8 weeks after surgery, the condylar articular surface of each group kept pyriform, greater in the front and smaller in the back. No periostosis or adhesion between condyle and articular disc was observed. Only in the blank control group, the tissue surrounding the defect site gradually absorbed over time, which made the cartilage defect clearly visible. In the other experimental groups, the defect was gradually filled with the repair tissue. Better results were always achieved in the pressure-pretreated BMSC/PRF transplantation group compared with other groups at the same time point. In the pressure-pretreated BMSC/PRF group, the repair tissue completely filled the defect at 12 weeks; there was no clear boundary from the surrounding cartilage, and the color and texture were generally consistent with those of normal cartilage (Fig. 5A).

Fig. 5.

Histological and biomechanical examination of in situ regeneration and repair of condylar cartilage defects in rabbit using the BMSC/PRF construct. a Gross morphology of rabbit condyle (scale bar = 5 mm). b HE staining of rabbit condyle (× 40, bar = 250 μm). c Toluidine blue staining of rabbit condyle; a, g, and m control group at 2, 4, and 8 weeks, respectively; b, h, and n PRF group at 2, 4, and 8 weeks, respectively; c, i, and o BMSC group at 2, 4, and 8 weeks, respectively; d, j, and p BMSC/PRF group at 2, 4, and 8 weeks, respectively; e, k, and q pressure-pretreated BMSC/PRF construct group at 2, 4, and 8 weeks, respectively (× 40, bar = 250 μm). d Statistical analysis of GAG/DNA ratio of each specimen. e Morphological scores of repair tissue in rabbit condylar cartilage defects. ^aP < 0.05, vs. control group; ^bP < 0.05, vs. PRF transplantation group; ^cP < 0.05, vs. BMSC sheet transplantation group; ^dP < 0.05, vs. no-pressure BMSC/PRF transplantation group

Histological staining observation

Hematoxylin and eosin (HE) staining showed that from 2 to 8 weeks after surgery, the defect site was depressed and only partially filled with fibrous tissue in the control group; cartilage cell differentiation was not observed in the repair tissue during the observation period, while absorption was obvious in the adjacent articular cartilage. In the individual PRF and BMSC groups, a cartilage-like substance was gradually formed in the defect over time; however, the arrangement of layers was disordered, and the proliferative, hypertrophic layers of adjacent cartilage showed significant thickening. In the BMSC/PRF group, the repair tissue in the defect site kept up with the general level to the adjacent normal tissue at 8 weeks. However, the repaired cartilage was relatively thin compared to the adjacent normal cartilage and there was a clear dividing line between them. In the pressure-pretreated BMSC/PRF group, better repair of the condylar defect was achieved compared with other groups at any given time point. The cartilage defect site was generally repaired at 8 weeks after surgery, with the cartilage surface being covered with dense fibrous tissue, which was thicker than the normal fibrous layer. The neo cartilage layers were clear and in good continuity with the layers of adjacent normal cartilage (Fig. 5B).

Toluidine blue staining observation and GAG content evaluation

The neocartilage-like substance in the defects of each group was positive for TB staining, similar to normal cartilage tissue; however, the staining intensity varied between groups (Fig. 5C). Further analysis of the GAG content showed that the GAG/DNA ratio gradually increased in the four experimental groups (except the control group) from 2 to 4 to 8 weeks after surgery; the values were significantly higher than those of the control group at any given time point (P < 0.05). No significant difference was observed in the GAG/DNA ratio between the individual PRF and BMSC groups at each time point. However, the pressure-pretreated BMSC/PRF group showed significantly higher GAG/DNA ratio than the no-pressure BMSC/PRF group at the same time point (P < 0.05, Fig. 5D).

Histomorphometric evaluation of regenerated cartilage

As we have defined before, animals were randomly assigned to five groups: blank control (natural recovery, group A), PRF alone (group B), BMSC sheet alone (group C), BMSC/PRF construct (group D), and pressure-pretreated BMSC/PRF construct (group E). Statistical analyses showed that groups B, C, D, and E had significantly higher scores than group A at any given time point (P < 0.05). In particular, group E had significantly higher scores than the other three groups at each time point (P < 0.05) (Fig. 5E).

Real-time PCR assay for chondrogenic genes in regenerated cartilage

The ACAN and Sox9 expression levels in each group were significantly higher than those in the control group at any given time point, and they increased in a time-dependent manner (P < 0.05). Among the samples, the gene expression in the pressure-pretreated BMSC/PRF construct group was highest at each time point (P < 0.05) (Fig. 6a).

Fig. 6.

Real-time PCR assay of chondrogenesis-related gene expression in the repaired articular cartilage and biomechanical testing on the regenerated cartilage of each group. a Real-time PCR assay of chondrogenesis-related gene Acan, Sox9, and Col II. b Elastic modulus test in the repair region of rabbit condylar defects in different groups. ^aP < 0.05, vs. control group; ^bP < 0.05, vs. PRF transplantation group; ^cP < 0.05, vs. BMSC sheet transplantation group; ^dP < 0.05, vs. no-pressure BMSC/PRF transplantation group

Biomechanical testing on the regenerated cartilage

Biomechanical testing of neocartilage in the defect site showed that the elastic modulus of cartilage in the condylar center did not change significantly over time in the sham group. The elastic modulus in the other groups showed an upward trend over time and remained higher than the control group (P < 0.05). Data comparison between groups at various time points revealed that the condylar cartilage that regenerated in the BMSC/PRF transplantation group had significantly better biomechanical properties than the individual BMSCs or PRF transplantation group (P < 0.05). Among different experimental groups, the pressure-pretreated BMSC/PRF transplantation group obtained the most desired restoration of elastic modulus of cartilage, which was significantly higher than the other experimental groups (P < 0.05). The elastic modulus of cartilage in the pressure-pretreated BMSC/PRF transplantation group generally reached 75% of that in the positive control group at 8 weeks (Fig. 6b).

Discussion

The temporomandibular joint (TMJ) is one of the most sophisticated and frequently used joints in humans. The mandibular condylar cartilage of the TMJ is a secondary and fibrous type of cartilage that is characterized by a different cell composition and hierarchical organization compared with the articular cartilage of the knee joint (hyaline cartilage) [26]. Biomechanical factors resulting from the functional activity of the mandibular joint are thought to influence the growth of the condyle, especially of the pressure-sensitive articular cartilage [27–30]. After articular cartilage injury in large joints, the mechanical stimulation during cartilage repair can be controlled through joint immobilization. However, in the case of TMJ, such loading control is impossible because eating is necessary for the animal, and mechanical stimulation therefore constantly exists during the articular cartilage repair process [31, 32]. For this reason, the mechanical adaptation of mandibular condylar cartilage may be more significant compared with the cartilage of larger joints (e.g., knee and hip joints) [33, 34]. From this perspective, the TMJ condylar cartilage can be regarded as an excellent model for studying the regeneration and repair of the mechanical adaptability and controllability of articular cartilage.

Many studies have tried to induce cartilage regeneration both in vitro and in vivo, but they are still far from obtaining regenerated cartilage that has properties similar to those of native cartilage, as well as integrating engineered and native tissue [35–37]. It was hypothesized that the lack of success was due to the lack of some critical factors and cues for chondrogenic cell differentiation and biomechanical adaption from the seed cells’ milieu [12, 38–40]. In the present study, we reveal, for what we believe is the first time, that feasible hydrostatic pressure effectively promotes the proliferation and chondrogenic differentiation of BMSCs in a BMSC/PRF construct, and the transplantation of a mechanically pretreated construct made from BMSC sheet fragments and PRF granules could obviously improve the regeneration and repair quality of articular cartilage defects, especially the integration between the regenerated cartilage and host cartilage milieu. Our findings provide us with a new tissue-engineering cartilage transplant with degradable grafts, good biocompatibility, sustained release of multiple growth factors and biomechanical regulation potential. The newly formed construct with biomechanical flexibility showed a superior capacity for cartilage regeneration by promoting the boundaryless repair of full-thickness defects of articular cartilage. It can not only provide new ideas for the treatment of condylar cartilage defects but can also provide valuable research experience for the microenvironmental optimization of tissue-engineering treatments for various articular cartilage defects in other general joints.

We noticed that both the proliferation and chondrogenic markers of the BMSC/PRF construct decreased upon treatment under 120 kPa/1 h for 6 days compared with that for 4 days. One possible reason might be that the relevant mechanotransduction signal molecules in the cells are fully activated under pressure stimulation for 4 days, thereby regulating the expression of the BMSC cell proliferation genes and cartilage-related genes to the greatest extent. However, under 120 kPa/1 h for 6 days, as the sensitivity of the cells to mechanical stimuli might possibly decrease and the concentration of sustained-release growth factors in the PRF also decreased, the vigorous growth and secretion state of the cells can no longer be maintained at the highest level. To test our speculation, ELISA was performed to detect the release of four important growth factors (TGF-β, IGF-1, VEGF, and EGF) by the PRF membrane in the BMSC/PRF construct for 4 days. Studies have found that TGF-β1 [41–46], PDGF [47–49], IGF-1 [44–46, 50–52], and EGF [53] all have the function of promoting the differentiation of stem cells into chondrocytes. The results showed that the release of TGF-β, VEGF, and EGF was highest at day 1 and then gradually decreased on days 2–4. The release of IGF-1 peaked at day 2 and then gradually decreased afterwards (Table S1). Therefore, we speculate that the decrease in both the proliferation and chondrogenic markers in the BMSC/PRF construct under 120 kPa/1 h for 6 days might be related to the decreased growth factor release from the PRF or even the decreased synergistic effects between the mechanical stimulation and growth factors, which still needs further study.

In both ectopic and in situ cartilage regeneration experiments in the present work, we found that a large number of neocartilage-like tissues formed even in the PRF-free BMSC transplantation group, but the quality and quantity of the neocartilage were inferior to those in the BMSC/PRF group. This showed from another point of view that BMSCs have limited chondrogenic differentiation potential without the support of PRF. Additionally, the use of local high concentrations of growth factors in a cartilage defect in situ can promote cartilage defect repair through cell homing [54]. In an in situ rabbit condylar cartilage regeneration experiment, we also found that a large number of cartilage-like tissues filled the defect at 8 weeks after the transplantation of PRF alone. These data suggest that, to a certain degree, PRF can activate the recruitment of intrinsic stem/progenitor cells to the damaged site and further support the lasting chondrogenesis of the PRF. According to the above analysis, we concluded that PRF can promote cartilage regeneration by simultaneously facilitating the homing and chondrogenic differentiation of exogenous seed cells in the repair of oversized defects in the mandibular condylar cartilage.

In traditional cartilage tissue engineering, seed cells cultured in vitro lack mechanical stimuli, resulting in cartilage tissues with the disadvantages of irregular cell arrangement and low cartilage matrix content [33]. The inevitable load-bearing property of tissue-engineered articular cartilage used for cartilage defect repair in vivo makes it easier to achieve the continuous mechanical stimulation of seed cells than by using sustained growth factor stimulation. To reveal the effect of the mechanical milieu on cells or tissues in vivo, many studies have performed in vitro cell mechanics experiments and designed particular loading methods (e.g., mechanical type, size, time, and frequency) to observe the effect of mechanical stimulation on cells [55]. Because stem cells have increased mechanical sensitivity compared to adult cells [13], biomechanical signals may play key roles in the regulation of the phenotypic differentiation of stem cells [14]. They can sense the mechanical properties and perceive mechanical information that directs broad aspects of cell functions, including lineage commitment. However, although mechanical stimulation may be able to enhance the regeneration process of articular cartilage [56], the underlying molecular regulation mechanism is far from clear. Several studies have pointed out that the Ihh/PTHrP signaling pathways in condylar cartilage are related to stress [50, 57]. In addition, it has been reported that TGF-β/Smad is involved in the mechanically stimulated development and repair of condylar artilage [58, 59]. We also carried out a series of studies on BMSCs’ mechanotransduction mechanism, which confirmed that P38MAPK/NF-κB signaling, Wnt signaling, and BMP/Smads signaling all participate in the mechanotransduction process of BMSCs. To better understand the mechanical and biological responses and the signal transduction mechanisms of BMSCs in response to stress, stable isotope labeling by amino acid (SILAC) detection in BMSCs was further used to screen differentially expressed signal molecules after mechanical stimulation. We found that a novel mechanosensor, anthrax toxin protein receptor 1 (ANTXR1), plays a crucial role in BMSC mechanotransduction (unpublished data, Additional files 1, 2, 3, 4, 5 and 6: Figures S1, S2, S3, S4; Tables S1, S2).

Previous studies have found that the proliferation and differentiation abilities of BMSCs changed under certain mechanical stimulations [60–67]. In the present study, we further found that, in the mechanically pretreated BMSC/PRF construct transplant group, the repaired tissue had no clear boundary with the surrounding normal cartilage after 8 weeks of repair. Such superior regeneration may be associated with our improvements of the tissue-engineered cartilage in the following three aspects. First, a particular hydrostatic pressure condition can significantly stimulate the gene expression of the proliferation-related Pcna and chondrogenesis-related Acan, Sox9, and Col-II in BMSCs. Moreover, we found through in situ regeneration and repair experiments of condylar cartilage defects that cartilage-like cells were poorly arranged in the generated neocartilage after the transplantation of BMSCs without mechanical stimulation; the hierarchical arrangement of the cells was far less ordered than those in the experimental group transplanted with BMSCs pretreated by mechanical stimulation. This suggests that the mechanical adjustment of the seed cells may also have a great impact on the polar arrangement and secretion direction of the cells. Second, PRF, as a new type of cartilage scaffold and multiple growth factor carrier, enables the tissue-engineered cartilage constructed from BMSC sheet fragments and PRF granules to directly bond to the adjacent cartilage. Third, the elastic modulus of the articular cartilage 8 weeks after repair using the pressure-pretreated BMSC/PRF construct exceeded 70% of that in normal cartilage. Thus, the differences in composition and biomechanics between the neocartilage and surrounding host cartilage could be effectively narrowed, and the cartilage-to-cartilage integration and overall biomechanical properties of the repaired cartilage could be improved. In another work, we will further explore the mechanical signal transduction mechanism of adult stem cells in response to mechanical stimuli and the synergistic effect of mechanical stimulation and growth factors, which will contribute to the ideal functional regeneration and repair of articular cartilage defects.

Conclusion

Many studies have tried to induce articular cartilage regeneration both in vitro and in vivo; however, we are still far from obtaining regenerated articular cartilage that has the properties similar to the native cartilage, as well as integrating engineered and native tissue. Our study provides a novel method of transplant construction with PRF as a source of multiple growth factors and an autologous scaffold for tissue-engineered articular cartilage repair. We obtained the first evidence that appropriate pressure pretreatment can maximize the chondrogenic differentiation potential of seed cells in the novel BMSC/PRF tissue-engineered cartilage transplant. We found that implanting the pressure-pretreated construct can effectively improve the regeneration and repair rate, matrix content, and mechanical parameters of neocartilage, thereby achieving boundaryless repair between the neocartilage and residual host cartilage and ultimately realizing integration with the host cartilage milieu and functional regeneration and repair. Our work demonstrates that pressure is an indispensable factor that promotes tissue-engineered regeneration and repair of TMJ articular cartilage and plays a crucial role in improving the mechanical properties and integration of neocartilage.

Abbreviations

α-MEM

Minimum Essential Medium-α

Acan

Aggrecan

ANOVA

Analysis of variance

BMSCs

Bone marrow mesenchymal stem cells

Col

Collagen

ECM

Extracellular matrix

GAG

Glycosaminoglycans

HE

Hematoxylin and eosin

Pcna

Proliferating cell nuclear antigen

PCR

Polymerase chain reaction

PRF

Platelet-rich fibrin

SEM

Scanning electron microscopy

Sox9

SRY-related HMG box-9

TB

Toluidine blue

TEM

Transmission electron microscopy

TMJ

Temporomandibular joint

Authors’ contributions

BXC, TT, XS, and YZL acquired the array data, designed the primers, and performed in cell culture, cell biomechanical assay, and immunostaining, Western blotting, and PCR assay. YZ developed the multi-functional pressure loading system for in vitro cultured cells. YHZ, YJL, and HC carried out animal experiments. MZ and YJC analyzed the data and wrote the paper. MZ conceived the project and coordinated and supervised the experiments. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.

Funding

This study was supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (NSFC 31570951).

Availability of data and materials

The datasets generated during and/or analyzed during the current study are available from the corresponding author on reasonable request.

Ethics approval and consent to participate

All animal procedures performed in this study were reviewed and approved by the Animal Experimental Ethical Inspection of Fourth Military Medical University (No. 12023) and were performed in accordance with the guidelines of the International Association for the Study of Pain.

Consent for publication

Not applicable.

Competing interests

The authors declare that they have no competing interests.