Haptoglobin administration into the subarachnoid space prevents hemoglobin-induced cerebral vasospasm

Abstract

Delayed ischemic neurological deficit (DIND) is a major driver of adverse outcomes in patients with aneurysmal subarachnoid hemorrhage (aSAH), defining an unmet need for therapeutic development. Cell-free hemoglobin that is released from erythrocytes into the cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) is suggested to cause vasoconstriction and neuronal toxicity, and correlates with the occurrence of DIND. Cell-free hemoglobin in the CSF of patients with aSAH disrupted dilatory NO signaling ex vivo in cerebral arteries, which shifted vascular tone balance from dilation to constriction. We found that selective removal of hemoglobin from patient CSF with a haptoglobin-affinity column or its sequestration in a soluble hemoglobin-haptoglobin complex was sufficient to restore physiological vascular responses. In a sheep model, administration of haptoglobin into the CSF inhibited hemoglobin-induced cerebral vasospasm and preserved vascular NO signaling. We identified 2 pathways of hemoglobin delocalization from CSF into the brain parenchyma and into the NO-sensitive compartment of small cerebral arteries. Both pathways were critical for hemoglobin toxicity and were interrupted by the large hemoglobin-haptoglobin complex that inhibited spatial requirements for hemoglobin reactions with NO in tissues. Collectively, our data show that compartmentalization of hemoglobin by haptoglobin provides a novel framework for innovation aimed at reducing hemoglobin-driven neurological damage after subarachnoid bleeding.

Introduction

Aneurysmal subarachnoid hemorrhage (aSAH) represents 5%–10% of all strokes and has an estimated global incidence of 6.67 per 100,000 people (1, 2). The loss of productive life years due to aSAH is as great as that for cerebral infarction because it frequently affects patients younger than 65 years of age (3). Delayed ischemic neurological deficit (DIND) complicates aSAH in one-third of cases and is a strong risk factor for unfavorable neurological outcomes, defining an unmet need for therapeutic innovation (4, 5).

Within days after aSAH, red blood cells in the cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) are disintegrated by immunological and nonimmunological processes. This erythrolysis is a temporally variable process, which results in individual time profiles of cell-free hemoglobin (Hb) in the CSF (6). We previously reported that elevated concentrations of Hb in CSF correlate with the occurrence of DIND, which suggests that cell-free Hb accelerates pathological processes in patients with aSAH (6). Cell-free Hb has been discussed for many years as a driver of damage and as a cause of vasospasm after aSAH (7–9). However, the mechanisms of toxicity remain poorly defined, and no therapeutic strategy has been proposed to specifically neutralize the devastating effects of Hb on the brain.

General mechanisms of cell-free Hb toxicity have been defined in models of systemic hemolysis, such as sickle-cell disease or after blood transfusion (10–14). The initial step of Hb toxicity is the dissociation of Hb tetramers (64 kDa) into small dimers (32 kDa) and their delocalization into tissues (15). Once delocalized, cell-free Hb initiates tissue damage by free-radical reactions (16, 17) and by NO depletion, which can cause vasoconstriction, ischemia, and cardiac failure (10, 15, 18–20). NO-dependent signaling pathways are indispensable for functional and metabolic homeostasis of the brain (21–25). Due to the short half-life of NO in tissue, its signaling activity highly depends on the localization and compartmentalization of molecules that it can react with, such as cell-free oxyHb and deoxyHb (26–28). Disruption of endothelial NO signaling by cell-free Hb in cerebral arteries may cause vasospasms (29–33) and may facilitate microthrombosis by disinhibiting platelet adhesion and aggregation (34–36). Within the brain parenchyma, depletion of NO may lower the threshold for pathological electrical activity, which leads to cortical spreading depolarizations (37, 38) and potentially dysregulates neuroinflammation (39, 40), eventually resulting in DIND. Despite the advanced scientific knowledge about the multifaceted pathogenesis of DIND, detection and treatment of angiographic vasospasm remains a pivotal factor in prevention of secondary neurological damage in aSAH patients (4, 41).

Haptoglobin is the archetypical Hb scavenger protein in vertebrates. It irreversibly binds cell-free Hb in the plasma, forming a large protein complex of greater than 150 kDa (42). In systemic hemolysis, haptoglobin blocks cell-free Hb extravasation and attenuates oxidative tissue toxicity and cardiovascular dysregulation that is triggered by Hb exposure (12, 15, 43–46). After aSAH, plasma-derived haptoglobin enters the CSF along with other plasma proteins (47). However, physiological quantities of haptoglobin cannot match the amount of cell-free Hb that is released by the erythrolytic process into the subarachnoid space, which results in uncontrolled cell-free Hb toxicity (47).

In this study, we explored whether haptoglobin could neutralize the vasoconstrictive activity of cell-free Hb in CSF of patients with aSAH. Additionally, we developed a sheep model to provide proof-of-concept that haptoglobin administration into the CSF can prevent cell-free Hb–mediated toxicity in the subarachnoid space, providing a novel framework for therapeutic development.

Results

Cell-free Hb in the CSF of patients with aSAH is the major disruptor of arterial NO signaling.

In a clinical study, we found that patients with DIND had higher cumulative cell-free Hb concentrations in CSF over a time period of 14 days after aSAH than patients without DIND (6). Vasospasm remains an important feature of DIND. Therefore, we wanted to define the role of cell-free Hb as a disruptor of vasodilatory arterial NO signaling in aSAH patients, and explore whether this toxic effect could be prevented by the Hb-binding properties of haptoglobin.

We collected CSF samples between 1 and 14 days after subarachnoid hemorrhage from patients with aSAH and DIND. To define temporal changes in protein composition of CSF, we performed a quantitative liquid chromatography mass-spectrometry (LC-MS/MS) proteome analysis of sequential CSF samples from 3 cases. Proteins identified by at least 2 unique peptides were classified into 3 categories by a k-means clustering analysis of the log-transformed and mean-normalized ion intensity ratios (day x/day 1) (Figure 1A and Supplemental Data Set 1; supplemental material available online with this article; https://doi.org/10.1172/JCI130630DS1). Cluster 1 contained proteins whose log ratios remained unchanged over time, such as albumin. Cluster 2 represented proteins with log ratios that decreased. This group contained haptoglobin. Cluster 3 encompassed proteins with increasing log ratios. This group included many red blood cell components, namely Hb and erythrocyte enzymes. This finding illustrates the delayed erythrolytic process that occurs in the subarachnoid space after aSAH, coinciding with DIND. Within cluster 3, we have also detected high concentrations of ferritin light and heavy chains, which indicates a localized adaptive macrophage response resulting in heme metabolism and iron detoxification. Endogenous haptoglobin was abundant in the initial samples but it was depleted over time. These data suggest that a large fraction of unbound Hb accumulates over time in the CSF of patients with aSAH.

Figure 1. Haptoglobin restores Hb-disrupted nitric oxide signaling in cerebral arteries.

(A) K-means clustering of CSF proteins of 3 patients collected at days 1, 4, 7, 11, and 14 after aSAH. The right panel shows a principal component analysis of the identified proteins. Cluster 1: proteins remaining unchanged. Cluster 2: proteins decreasing over time. Cluster 3: proteins increasing over time. ALB, albumin; HP, haptoglobin; HPR, haptoglobin related protein; HBB, Hb-beta; HBA, Hb-alpha; FTH, ferritin heavy-chain; HBD, Hb-delta; CAT, catalase; CA1, carbonic anhydrase; FTL, ferritin light-chain. (B) Image and absorption spectrum of a (centrifuged) patient-derived CSF sample before (red) and after (green) selective removal of Hb. Erythrolysed CSF disrupts the dilatory NO response of porcine basilar arteries to MAHMA-NONOate. NO signaling is restored after removal of Hb from the CSF (n = 12, group mean ± SD). (C) Linear regression of CSF-protein ion intensities before and after passing through the haptoglobin-affinity column. (D) Tension traces of porcine basilar artery segments immersed in preerythrolysed (n = 1 patient; blue) and in erythrolysed (n = 2 patients; red/magenta) CSF from aSAH patients. Baseline and after sequential addition of MAHMA-NONOate, haptoglobin, MAHMA-NONOate, and L-NIO. Thick lines represent the mean recordings of replicate artery segments. (E) Relative changes of the steady-state tension of arteries immersed in patient-derived erythrolysed CSF after addition of haptoglobin (equimolar to cell-free Hb). The diamonds represent the mean and 95% CI (n = 8 patient samples). (F) NO-mediated dilation of arteries immersed in CSF from aSAH patients (n = 8) after administration of MAHMA-NONOate. Arteries were sequentially probed in preerythrolysed CSF (blue), erythrolysed CSF (red), and after the addition of haptoglobin to the erythrolysed CSF (green). (G) Size exclusion chromatography of CSF analyzed in E and F before (Hb) and after addition of haptoglobin (Hb-Hp).

An early clinical feature of DIND is the occurrence of vasospasms in cerebral arteries. Reactions of cell-free oxyHb (Fe²⁺O₂) and deoxyHb (Fe²⁺) with the vasodilator NO may shift the balance toward vasoconstriction. To investigate this mechanism of dysregulation, we quantified the NO-mediated vasodilatory responses ex vivo, using porcine basilar arteries immersed in human CSF samples. The expected dilatory response to administration of a short-lived NO donor (MAHMA-NONOate) was suppressed in arteries immersed in CSF that was collected from a patient during DIND at day 7 after aSAH, which contained a high concentration of cell-free Hb (Figure 1B). The physiological vasodilatory response to MAHMA-NONOate was restored when we selectively removed cell-free Hb from this CSF sample with a haptoglobin-affinity column (P < 0.001 for comparison of maximal dilatory responses between conditions, for each condition n = 12 dilation responses). Analyses of the CSF by LC-MS/MS before and after Hb removal demonstrated that the concentrations of other proteins in the CSF remained mostly unchanged by the haptoglobin column (Figure 1C). This result confirmed that cell-free Hb is the disruptor of arterial NO signaling in the CSF of patients with aSAH. Supplemental Figure 1 shows that suppression of dilatory NO-signaling is dependent on the Hb concentration with complete suppression at concentrations exceeding 10 μM oxyHb.

Addition of haptoglobin to patient-derived CSF restores the vascular dilatory response to intrinsic and extrinsic NO.

In the next experimental step, we evaluated whether haptoglobin in solution could also restore Hb-disrupted arterial NO signaling ex vivo (Figure 1D). In these experiments, we investigated the effect of aSAH patient-derived CSF on the intrinsic vasomotor balance of porcine basilar arteries, followed by the assessment of the dilatory response to exogenous NO, and the effect of haptoglobin addition.

We used a control CSF sample collected from a patient at day 0 after aSAH that contained no detectable cell-free Hb and CSF samples collected between days 4–10 from 2 patients with severe DIND, which contained cell-free Hb of 17.2 μM and 26.8 μM oxyHb, respectively. The vascular tension traces in Figure 1D show that the basilar artery segments that were immersed in the erythrolysed patient-derived CSF produced a higher steady-state tension than the segments that were immersed in the nonerythrolysed control CSF, indicating that the endogenous vascular NO pool was diminished when cell-free Hb was present. After the administration of a MAHMA-NONOate bolus, vessels that were immersed in erythrolysed CSF did not dilate, whereas vessels immersed in control CSF responded with a physiologic relaxation. Addition of haptoglobin (40 μM) to all samples did not have any effect on the tension of the artery segments that were immersed in control CSF, while the artery segments immersed in erythrolysed CSF slowly dilated until they reached the tension level of the controls. This slow dilation occurred in the absence of any exogenous NO donor, which suggests that haptoglobin restored an intrinsic vasodilatory pathway. At this point in the experiment, all arterial segments demonstrated an equal transient dilatory response to exogenous NO delivered by a bolus of MAHMA-NONOate. Haptoglobin restored the disrupted NO signaling effect of cell-free Hb. We then inhibited endogenous NO production with the NO-synthase inhibitor L-NIO (20 μM), which caused a slow contraction of all artery segments to the same steady-state level that was initially recorded with the basilar arteries exposed to erythrolysed patient-derived CSF. This contractile response reflected the loss of a similar endogenous NO pool in all artery segments.

To corroborate these observations, we further tested the ex vivo effect of haptoglobin using erythrolysed CSF collected from 8 patients between days 4–10 after aSAH containing cell-free oxyHb concentrations between 11.5 μM and 49 μM (mean 19 μM ± SD 12.5 μM). After the addition of haptoglobin, in a concentration that matched the cell-free Hb concentration in each sample, we observed a spontaneous dilation of the basilar artery segments in all patient-derived CSF samples until tensions reached approximately half of the initial values (Figure 1E). Haptoglobin also restored the vasodilatory response to exogenous NO to the level observed when using CSF that was sampled from the same 8 patients at day 0 or day 1 after aSAH, before erythrolysis occurred (Figure 1F). One-way ANOVA: P < 0.001; Tukey-Kramer post test corrected for multiple comparison: P < 0.001 for post-erythrolysed CSF versus the 2 other conditions and P = 0.94 between control CSF and post-haptoglobin CSF, for each group n = 8 dilation responses were performed. Size-exclusion chromatography (SEC) demonstrated that the addition of equimolar haptoglobin resulted in the binding of almost 100% of Hb in all patient samples as demonstrated by the shifted heme elution profile (Figure 1G).

Collectively, these data demonstrate that Hb is the main disruptor of arterial NO signaling in the CSF of patients with aSAH, and that it remains accessible to binding and neutralization by haptoglobin.

Haptoglobin halts Hb-induced cerebral vasospasms in sheep.

To validate our approach of using haptoglobin to reverse Hb-mediated cerebral artery vasospasms in vivo, we established a sheep ventricular infusion model. In this model, the distribution of Hb and Hb-haptoglobin complexes could be visualized by T1-weighted MRI and vasospasms could be monitored by selective cerebral digital subtraction angiography (DSA). We slowly infused artificial CSF, or solutions containing Hb, haptoglobin, or Hb-haptoglobin complexes into the frontal horn of the left lateral ventricle (Figure 2C). The intracranial pressure was continuously monitored to avoid its uncontrolled change during the experiment (Supplemental Figure 2). Minutes after infusion, the hemoproteins appeared in the CSF, which drained from a suboccipital spinal cannula, indicating a rapid distribution from the lateral ventricle into the external CSF compartment (i.e., the subarachnoid space). The distribution of cell-free Hb and Hb-haptoglobin complexes was visualized by MRI after replacing iron protoporphyrin (FePP) in the hemoproteins with manganese protoporphyrin (MnPP) (Figure 2A). The T1-weighted MRI images confirmed that the Hb(MnPP) and Hb(MnPP) haptoglobin complexes were distributed equally throughout the ventricular system, the cisterna magna, and the basal subarachnoid space (Figure 2B and Supplemental Videos 1–3). Twenty minutes after infusion, a robust MnPP signal at the base of the brain visualized the arterial circle of Willis immersed in CSF containing a high concentration of hemoproteins (Figure 2, D and E). These results confirmed that our ventricular infusion model effectively distributed Hb and haptoglobin into the subarachnoid space.

Figure 2. Distribution of hemoproteins after intraventricular infusion in sheep.

(A) Sagittal reconstruction of T1-weighted MR images from a sheep before and 20 minutes after infusion of MnHb. Subtraction of the baseline image from the image after infusion reveals the specific signal of MnHb. Binary image of the intracranial MnHb signal. (B) Overlay of the signals from MnHb (left) and MnHb-haptoglobin (right) 20 minutes after infusion on the corresponding T2-weighted anatomical MR images. (C) Schematic diagram indicating the positions of the external ventricular drain (orange) and the suboccipital subarachnoid drainage catheter (yellow). (D) Three-dimensional reconstruction of the MnHb signal 20 minutes after infusion. (E) Visualization of the circle of Willis on digital subtraction angiography (DSA), on a photograph of an anatomical specimen and on a curved multiplanar reconstruction (MPR) of a T1-weighted MR image. The bright (white) signal in the curved MPR represents the infused hemoprotein (MnHb-haptoglobin complex in this example), surrounding the posterior communicating artery (PCOM) and the basilar artery (BA), as indicated in the coronal view images. The dashed lines (labeled 1–3) in the curved MPR indicate the location of the coronal sections shown on the right. DSA images were obtained with a ×1.5 magnification.

We then used the sheep ventricular infusion model to assess the effect of cell-free Hb on vascular tone in vivo (Figure 3A). Selective cerebral angiography performed after the infusion of a 5-mL bolus of cell-free oxyHb (HbFe²⁺O₂, 5 mM) into the ventricular CSF demonstrated segmental vasospasms in different arteries in angiographies recorded after 45 minutes and 60 minutes (Figure 3B and Figure 4A), which coincided with drainage of cell-free Hb from the subarachnoid space as recorded by SEC (Figure 3A). To test whether cell-free Hb in the subarachnoid space was accessible for binding and neutralization by haptoglobin, we administered a concentrated haptoglobin solution (5 mL, 4 mM) into the lateral ventricle of a sheep previously infused with Hb. Within minutes, 100% of cell-free Hb was bound to haptoglobin, forming Hb-haptoglobin complexes (as indicated by SEC); subsequently, Hb-induced vasospasms soon resolved.

Figure 3. Hb-induced vasospasm of cerebral arteries and protection by haptoglobin.

(A) SEC elution profiles of CSF collected from the subarachnoid space at baseline (blue), after intraventricular infusion of Hb at t = 0 minutes (red), and after infusion of haptoglobin at t = 90 minutes (green). Standard elution profiles are shown on the top. (B) Angiograms of the middle cerebral artery (MCA) at baseline, 45 minutes after Hb infusion (t = 45 minutes) and 45 minutes after haptoglobin infusion (t = 135 minutes). The square in the far-right image indicates the position of the zoom-images. DSA images were obtained with a ×1.5 magnification. (C) Relative change in diameter of cerebral arteries 60 minutes after infusion of Hb or Hb-haptoglobin. ACA, anterior cerebral artery; BA, basilar artery; ICA, internal carotid artery. Diamonds represent the mean and the 95% confidence interval (n = 4 sheep per group). (D) Cumulative analysis of the relative diameter changes of analyzed arterial segments 60 minutes after infusion of aCSF (n = 32), Hb (n = 16), or Hb-haptoglobin (n = 16). Colors represent vascular areas defined in C. Group means were compared by 1-way ANOVA, P < 0.001. The scheme depicts the experimental protocol. (E) NO-mediated relaxation profiles (n = 8 per condition) of porcine basilar arteries immersed in sheep CSF collected after the 60-minute posttreatment angiograms. Blue line: CSF samples after infusion of artificial CSF (CSF-heme 0 μM). Red line: CSF samples after infusion of Hb (CSF-heme 200–240 μM). Green line: CSF samples after infusion of Hb-haptoglobin (CSF-heme 200–240 μM). Thick lines represent the treatment group means. Dilatory responses were induced with a single bolus of MAHMA-NONOate. (F) Addition of equimolar haptoglobin to the Hb-containing sheep CSF restored the dilatative response to MAHMA-NONOate. Red line: before haptoglobin addition, same CSF as in E. Black line: after haptoglobin addition. Thick lines represent treatment group means of relaxation profiles (n = 8).

Figure 4. Hb-induced vasospasm after ventricular infusion in sheep.

(A) Angiograms illustrating segmental vasospasms in major vascular territories, including the middle cerebral artery in the lateral projection (arrowheads, upper panel), the anterior cerebral artery (arrow, lower panel), and the middle cerebral artery (asterisk, lower panel) in the dorsoventral projection, 60 minutes after Hb infusion. The demonstrated angiograms are from the same experiment shown in Figure 3B. (Identical images are shown in Figure 3B and Figure 4A for the dorso-posterior projections at baseline). (B) Comparison of illustrative digital subtraction angiography in lateral projection of 2 sheep 60 minutes after infusion of Hb (left) or Hb-haptoglobin complexes (right). Segmental vasospasms of the basilar artery (arrow) were apparent 60 minutes after infusion of Hb, whereas no segmental vasospasms could be detected in animals infused with Hb-haptoglobin complexes. DSA images were obtained with a ×1.5 magnification.

The experimental approach with sequential injection of Hb and haptoglobin into sheep CSF has several limitations, such as different time points in the experiment at which we evaluated vasospasms before and after haptoglobin infusion, as well as possibly heterogeneous dilution effects (i.e., the haptoglobin solution dilutes the Hb in CSF). To overcome these limitations, we repeated the experiments with injection of a 2.5-mL bolus of either Hb or Hb-haptoglobin complexes at equal concentrations (3 mM heme) and visualized the cerebral vascular morphology by DSA 60 minutes after injection for quantitative analysis of vasospasms. Segmental vasospasms occurred in 4 of 4 sheep injected with Hb, whereas no vasospasms were detected in 4 sheep injected with Hb-haptoglobin complexes (Figure 4B). We performed a blinded and semiautomatic quantitative analysis of arterial diameters in the DSA images of 4 ex ante defined cerebral artery regions to objectify the visual impression of vasospasms (Supplemental Figure 3). We found a significant narrowing of the basilar artery and anterior and middle cerebral arteries, as well as of the cisternal internal carotid artery in Hb-infused animals compared with those in Hb-haptoglobin–infused animals (Figure 3C). Hb-induced vascular contractions became even more apparent in a pooled analysis of all arterial segments (Figure 3D). The Hb-induced reduction in cerebral artery diameters appeared to be moderate (15%). However, considering that the resistance (R) of a vessel is inversely proportional to the fourth power of its radius (R ~ 1/r⁴), a 15% reduction in arterial diameter doubles the vascular resistance in these segments. We found no significant change in arterial diameters after Hb-haptoglobin infusion or after infusion of an equal volume of artificial CSF, which was performed as a general control procedure during the initial phase of each experiment (Figure 3D). These results showed that cell-free Hb causes vasospasms accompanied by a reduction in arterial diameters and that this was reversed by binding of Hb to haptoglobin.

To assess whether the recovery of Hb-induced vasospasms by haptoglobin was related to effects on vascular NO signaling, we quantified NO-mediated arterial dilation ex vivo using porcine basilar artery segments immersed in sheep CSF sampled from the subarachnoid space of the sheep used in the previous experiments, immediately after angiography (Figure 3E). We found that CSF from Hb-infused sheep (200–240 μM Hb) completely suppressed the dilatory response to MAHMA-NONOate. In contrast, the dilatory response in CSF from Hb-haptoglobin–infused animals (200–240 μM Hb-haptoglobin) was intact and not different from the physiological response recorded in CSF samples collected after the injection of artificial CSF. Finally, we explored whether haptoglobin could restore physiological responses in arteries rendered unresponsive to NO by previous immersion in CSF from Hb-infused animals. When adding haptoglobin to such an equilibrated system at quantities that matched the concentration of cell-free Hb, physiological responses of the cerebral arteries to NO were reestablished within minutes (Figure 3F). Comparison of the maximal vasodilatory responses revealed a significant difference between the Hb CSF and all other groups (P < 0.0001, n = 4 per group). These results are in concordance with the outcome of our initial in vivo experiment in which delayed administration of haptoglobin into the ventricular CSF reverted cell-free Hb-induced vasospasms.

Collectively, the functional data obtained in our sheep model demonstrate that haptoglobin administration into the CSF could bind cell-free Hb in a Hb-haptoglobin complex restoring vascular NO signaling and cerebral artery dilation.

Hb and the Hb-haptoglobin complex have identical NO reaction kinetics in the subarachnoid space.

The reaction of oxyHb with NO is the fundamental mechanism that causes Hb-induced vasospasms in our model. NO reacts with oxyHb in a 3-step reaction (Figure 5A and ref. 27). We have previously reported estimates for the NO reaction kinetics of oxyHb bound to haptoglobin (15). However, these experiments were performed under conditions of Hb excess over NO, and therefore captured only the first step of the reaction, which oxidizes oxyHb(Fe²⁺) to metHb(Fe³⁺), consuming 1 NO molecule. In the current study, we compared NO reaction kinetics of cell-free Hb and Hb-haptoglobin complex using an excess concentration of NO, which allows us to follow the sequence of reactions. Figure 5B shows absorbance changes at 405 nm of Hb and the Hb-haptoglobin complex after rapid mixing with NO in a stop-flow instrument. We used a glutaraldehyde polymerized Hb as a control compound that mimics the large size of the Hb-haptoglobin complex lacking the additional protein component of haptoglobin. The absorbance data could be best approximated by a function expressed as a sum of 3 exponentials, which mathematically supports the 3-step reaction mechanism (Supplemental Figure 4, A and B). The calculated rate constants for k1 and k2 confirm that the NO reaction is very similar for all 3 hemoproteins. In another stop-flow experiment, we compared the reaction of NO with CSF that was recovered from the subarachnoid space of sheep after intraventricular infusion of Hb or Hb-haptoglobin complex. This experiment demonstrates that haptoglobin does not change the biochemical reaction of Hb with NO in the subarachnoid space, as long as the hemoprotein remains accessible for NO (Supplemental Figure 4, C and D).

Figure 5. The protective function of Hb-haptoglobin in the brain is determined by its molecular size.

(A) Reaction sequence of oxyHb with NO under conditions of excess NO. In a 3-step reaction, oxyHb can scavenge up to 3 molecules of NO. (B) NO-reaction kinetics of Hb (left), Hb-haptoglobin (middle), or polymerized Hb (right). Shown are absorbance changes at 405 nm after rapid mixing of NO and oxyHb in a stopped-flow spectrophotometer. Estimates of the reaction rates (k1 and k2) were calculated by approximating the data with an equation defined by the sum of 3 exponential functions. (C) Tension traces (mean ± SD) of porcine basilar arteries immersed in buffer containing 10 μM Hb (left; red, n = 16), Hb-haptoglobin (middle; green, n = 16), or polymerized Hb (right, brown, n = 8). A bolus of MAHMA-NONOate was added (arrowhead) to induce NO-mediated dilation. (D) Coronal vibratome sections (2 mm anterior to the bregma) of mouse brains 2 hours after subarachnoid injection of TCO-labeled Hb (left), Hb-haptoglobin (middle) and polymerized Hb (right). The false-colored images represent the signal intensity of the injected compound after postmortem coupling to a fluorophore (tetrazine-5-TAMRA). Intraparenchymal delocalization is only observed in the mouse injected with Hb and not after injection of Hb-haptoglobin and polymerized Hb (images are representative for n = 3 per group). The signal in the area of the puncture channel (dashed boxes) serves as a positive control for the injection and labeling procedure. (E) SEC elution profiles of pure Hb (left; red), Hb-haptoglobin (middle; green), and polymerized Hb (right; brown) measured at 414 nm illustrate the different molecular size of the injected compounds.

Large molecular size of the Hb-haptoglobin complex preserves dilatory NO signaling in porcine basilar arteries and prevents translocation of the NO-reactive complexes into the brain.

In light of the very divergent effect on vascular NO signaling, the identical NO-reaction kinetics of cell-free Hb and the Hb-haptoglobin complex appear to be contradictory. We have therefore used the above-described polymerized Hb, which differs from cell-free Hb only by its large size, to explore a molecular size–dependent protection of vascular NO signaling in cerebral arteries. NO-mediated relaxation of basilar artery segments was completely interrupted by Hb, but it remained intact in the presence of equal concentrations of the Hb-haptoglobin complex or polymerized Hb (Figure 5C). The differential effects of the 3 hemoproteins on vascular responses were mirrored by the divergent ability of the proteins to translocate from the subarachnoid CSF space into the brain parenchyma (Figure 5D). For these mechanistic studies we injected trans-cyclooctene–labeled (TCO-labeled) Hb, Hb-haptoglobin, or polymerized Hb into the subarachnoid space of mice. TCO is a small tag, which can be visualized with a high signal-to-noise ratio on vibratome sections after a click-chemistry reaction with Cy5-conjugated tetrazine. Figure 5D shows that the small cell-free Hb delocalizes within 2 hours from the subarachnoid space deep into the mouse brain. This is in contrast to the Hb-haptoglobin complex and the polymerized Hb, which remained completely excluded from the brain parenchyma. In the brains of the Hb-haptoglobin and polymerized Hb-injected animals positive fluorescence signals were only detected in the region of the injection trajectory. Figure 5E shows SEC-HPLC elution profiles of the 3 hemoproteins demonstrating the small size of Hb, and the large size of Hb-haptoglobin complexes and polymerized Hb, respectively. From these studies, we hypothesized that size-restricted barriers may limit translocation of the Hb-haptoglobin complex from the subarachnoid CSF space into NO-sensitive compartments of the cerebral vasculature and the brain.

Haptoglobin blocks translocation of cell-free Hb from CSF to brain parenchyma and blood vessels in sheep.

In a next experimental step, we infused TCO-tagged Hb or Hb-haptoglobin complexes into the CSF of sheep to further analyze distribution and translocation patterns of Hb in the brain and the cerebral vasculature. The fluorescence scans of 120-μm sheep brain sections at 2 different sites of the forebrain and midbrain demonstrated that within 2 hours after infusion, the cell-free Hb was delocalized from the internal and external CSF spaces into the brain parenchyma, appearing as a rim of fluorescence signal along the internal and external CSF-brain interfaces (Figure 6A, left). This pattern of delocalization was absent in sheep brain sections that were infused with TCO–Hb-haptoglobin complexes (Figure 6A, right). For the illustration of the Hb-haptoglobin complex distribution in Figure 6A, we chose a section of the forebrain where the tip of the ventricular catheter was placed slightly into the brain parenchyma. At this location, a small quantity of TCO–Hb-haptoglobin was directly injected into the brain tissue, serving as a positive control for the staining and imaging procedure. In addition, the only distinct Hb-haptoglobin signal could be recognized alongside small arteries penetrating from the pial surfaces into the brain. Before sacrificing the sheep, we collected CSF from the subarachnoid space for SEC and SDS-PAGE analysis. Despite the absence of an Hb-haptoglobin signal in brain sections, we identified the large Hb-haptoglobin complex by SEC and SDS-PAGE in the CSF, which was sampled at the end of the experiment before sacrificing the animal (Figure 6, B and C). Collectively, these data support that cell-free Hb translocates from the CSF to the brain parenchyma and that the Hb-haptoglobin complex remains compartmentalized in the CSF space.

Figure 6. Haptoglobin blocks translocalization of Hb from CSF into the brain parenchyma.

(A) Representative fluorescent images of sheep brain sections (120 μm) after injection of TCO-labeled Hb (left panels) and Hb-haptoglobin complexes (right panels), stained for nuclei (blue) and the labeled compound (tetrazine-Cy5, yellow). Hb translocates from the ventricular system through the ependymal barrier and from the subarachnoid space through the glia limitans into the brain interstitial space (images are representative for n = 4 animals). This delocalization cannot be observed when Hb is bound to haptoglobin (images are representative for n = 5 animals). Fluorescent Hb-haptoglobin complexes can be recognized only along penetrating cortical vessels. In Section A, a small amount of Hb-haptoglobin complexes was injected directly into the brain parenchyma at the tip of the external ventricular drain catheter, serving as a positive control for the staining and imaging procedure (arrow head). Whole-slide scans were produced by stitching single images obtained at ×10 magnification. Scale bars are indicated in the figure. (B) Before animals were sacrificed, CSF samples from Hb- and Hb-haptoglobin–treated sheep were collected from the subarachnoid space and analyzed by SEC-HPLC, indicating typical elution profiles of cell-free Hb and large Hb-haptoglobin complexes. CSF sample of a sheep before infusion (blue trace), CSF sample of a sheep infused with Hb (red trace), CSF sample of a sheep infused with Hb-haptoglobin complexes (green trace). (C) The same CSF samples were reacted ex vivo with Cy5 tetrazine and analyzed by SDS page. The bands represent a/b globin chains in cell-free Hb (Hb) and Hb-haptoglobin complex (Hb-Hp). Under nonreducing conditions, the specific ladder pattern of the different type 2-2 haptoglobin polymers is clearly visible when analyzed on a gel optimized for high resolution of large proteins (7.5%).

In a next series of imaging studies, we evaluated whether cell-free Hb could translocate from the CSF into the vascular smooth muscle cell layer of cerebral arteries, where NO mediates its vasodilatory signal. This translocation may be a key pathophysiological pathway for cell-free Hb acting as a cerebral artery vasoconstrictor, which could be blocked for the large Hb-haptoglobin complex. For examination of vascular structures by confocal microscopy, sheep brain sections from animals infused with TCO-Hb or TCO–Hb-haptoglobin were stained for vascular smooth muscle cells and for the aquaporin-4–positive astrocyte end-feet, and confocal micrographs of several small arteries of different calibers in the periventricular area of the midbrain were taken. Cell-free Hb delocalized across the astrocyte barrier into the brain tissue and additionally into the vascular smooth muscle layer, reaching the subendothelial space (Figure 7). By contrast, the Hb-haptoglobin complex remained compartmentalized at a high concentration within the CSF-filled perivascular space (Virchow-Robin space) of penetrating arteries. This space is delineated by the outermost layer of the arteries (i.e., the adventitia) on one side and by the astrocyte end-feet on the other side (i.e., the glia limitans). These observations likely explain why cell-free Hb but not the large Hb-haptoglobin complex interrupts vasodilatory NO signaling in cerebral arteries and thereby induces vasospasm.

Figure 7. Haptoglobin blocks translocation of Hb from CSF into the brain vasculature.

Representative confocal images of small arteries in the periventricular area of the midbrain from a sheep after infusion of TCO-labeled Hb (A–D) or Hb-haptoglobin complexes (E–H). The 120-μm vibratome sections were immunostained for vascular smooth muscle cells (αSMA, green), astrocyte end-feet (AQP4, blue), and TCO-labeled Hb (tetrazine-Cy5, red). False-colored images (Hb-signal) display only the signal of the labeled hemoprotein from the corresponding image. The delocalization of cell-free Hb from the CSF into arterial vessel walls (smooth muscle cell layer) and the brain parenchyma (astrocyte covered area) is blocked by haptoglobin (images are representative for n = 4 animals injected with TCO-Hb, and n = 5 animals injected with TCO–Hb-haptoglobin complex). Scale bars: 20 μm. Bottom images show a whole slide scan as an overview at ×10 magnification. Boxes indicate the position of the vessels (A–H) that are shown with higher magnification above.

To link the observed perivascular Hb exposure of small parenchymal vessels (diameter range of 50–100 μm) to the functional readouts for large cerebral arteries, we performed a histomorphometric analysis. For this purpose, we stained 120-μm sheep brain sections through the fourth ventricle for smooth muscle cells (Supplemental Figure 5A). Confocal images of the small alpha smooth muscle actin–positive (αSMA-positive) vessels in the tela choroidea were acquired by a researcher blinded to the treatments (n = 3 sheep per group, a total of 25 images of Hb-treated sheep, 32 images for Hb-haptoglobin–treated sheep). We have chosen the periventricular area for this analysis because this tissue is very rapidly exposed to the intraventricularly instilled fixative, ensuring excellent structural preservation after euthanasia. For each vessel, the lumen and total cross-sectional areas were quantified based on the inner and outer circumference of the αSMA-positive structures, which were manually determined by 3 blinded researchers (Supplemental Figure 5B). While vessels with a contracted appearance were abundant in all Hb-infused animals, none could be found in Hb-haptoglobin–infused animals (Supplemental Figure 5C). Supplemental Figure 5, D and E, shows the quantitative analysis of the luminal fraction areas of all analyzed vessels, as well as the mean per sheep. In both ways of analysis, the differences were statistically significant with smaller fractional lumen areas of Hb compared with Hb-haptoglobin–treated animals.

Discussion

In patients with aSAH, erythrolysis in the subarachnoid space leads to an accumulation of cell-free Hb exceeding haptoglobin scavenger capacity in the CSF. We confirmed that this unbound Hb is the principal dysregulator of vascular NO signaling, and thus promotes spasms in cerebral arteries and smaller parenchymal arterioles. Our results show that delocalization of cell-free Hb from CSF into vascular structures is the primary cause of this pathophysiology, which can be prevented by size-dependent compartmentalization of Hb in the CSF by the formation of large Hb-haptoglobin complexes. We further identified delocalization of Hb into the brain parenchyma as another pathway of Hb-induced pathophysiology, which is also blocked by haptoglobin. These observations suggest that haptoglobin may control a spectrum of oxidative and NO-related toxicities that have been associated with cell-free Hb, heme, and iron exposures within the brain (Figure 8).

Figure 8. Mechanism of cell-free Hb toxicity and protection by complex formation of Hb with haptoglobin.

Cell-free Hb is released from lysing erythrocytes in the subarachnoid blood clot after aSAH and distributes within the CSF (red). Delocalization of small Hb dimers (32 kDa) into vessel walls of resistance arteries causes macro- and microvascular vasospasms through NO depletion in the vascular wall. Delocalization into the brain parenchyma may cause oxidative damage and alter the interstitial microenvironment. Therapeutic haptoglobin injected into the ventricular system binds Hb in the subarachnoid space and prevents delocalization of the large Hb-haptoglobin complex (>150 kDa), thereby attenuating toxicity (blue).

We found no NO-depleting or vasoconstrictive activity in human CSF samples collected from patients shortly (1 or 2 days) after the inciting bleeding event. In contrast, samples collected at later phases of the disease displayed an erythrolysed protein signature that disrupted NO signaling and shifted vascular tone balance toward vasoconstriction. Selective removal of Hb from patient-derived CSF by a haptoglobin column was sufficient to abate this activity. Furthermore, the collective experimental data presented here suggest that a therapeutic intervention targeting compartmentalization of Hb within the CSF might be sufficient to prevent cerebral vasospasm. The slow time course of Hb accumulation in CSF after the inciting bleeding event provides a window of opportunity to restore the Hb binding capacity of CSF by exogenous haptoglobin.

The protective physiological effect of haptoglobin during systemic hemolysis has been related to the large molecular size of the Hb-haptoglobin complex (15, 43). The complex is too large to be filtered by the kidney or to extravasate from blood into the wall structures of coronary arteries or the interstitial space of the myocardium (15, 48). These observations helped to resolve the enigma that the biochemical reactivity, which was recognized as the source of cell-free Hb toxicity, was not substantially different in the case of the Hb-haptoglobin complex compared with unbound Hb. According to the compartmentalization hypothesis, the potentially detrimental peroxidase and dioxygenase reactions of Hb remain uneventful as long as they occur within the circulatory plasma compartment. Here, we could extend and reinforce this hypothesis in experiments mimicking intracranial conditions, which are fundamentally different from the models of intravascular hemolysis that we have studied before.

In patient and sheep CSF, the reaction kinetics of cell-free Hb and the Hb-haptoglobin complexes with NO were similar, even though we adapted our experimental conditions to model the full 3-reaction kinetics of Hb with NO depicted in Figure 5B and Supplemental Figure 4. However, we discovered that haptoglobin was able to block 2 divergent pathways of cell-free Hb delocalization from CSF. First, haptoglobin prevented translocation of cell-free Hb from the CSF into the smooth muscle layer and subendothelial space of arterial vessels. We assume that the size-restricted interruption of this delocalization path by haptoglobin spatially separates the Hb-haptoglobin from functional NO and thus preserves vascular NO signaling, preventing vasospasms in small and large cerebral arteries. The finding that chemically crosslinked Hb-polymers — with a large molecular size but unaltered NO reactivity compared with Hb — not only mimicked the spatial compartmentalization effect of the Hb-haptoglobin complex, but also showed the same NO-sparing effect in ex vivo vascular function studies, supported this assumption. Second, haptoglobin prevented translocation of cell-free Hb through the inner and outer CSF-brain barrier into the brain interstitial space (i.e., through the ependymal layer and glia limitans) (49, 50). Again, we found no evidence that the Hb-haptoglobin complex could cross this anatomical barrier, which is permeable to proteins up to 70 kDa (49, 50). Prevention of Hb delocalization into the brain’s interstitial space may avert Hb-triggered oxidative stress to neural tissue (43, 51) and spare NO signaling within the neurovascular unit. Furthermore, prevention of this delocalization may reduce Hb-triggered microthrombosis (34–36), neuroinflammation (39, 40), and pathological electrical activity (i.e., cortical spreading depression; CSD) (37).

Vasodilatory NO signaling can be disrupted at several levels after aSAH (41, 52). Our studies focused on the sink theory, by which oxyHb reacts with NO and depletes the vasodilator within the vascular wall or in neuronal tissues. Several other mechanisms of NO dysfunction have also been demonstrated; however, the quantitative contribution toward pathophysiology continues to be defined. Perivascular nerve fibers expressing nitric oxide synthase (NOS) among other vasoactive substances are critical for the regulation of cerebral arterial vascular tone (53, 54). These NOS-expressing neurons disappear after aSAH, presumably as a result of Hb and heme toxicity (55, 56). It has also been observed that the endogenous NOS inhibitor asymmetric dimethyl arginine (ADMA) accumulates in CSF after aSAH (57).

Additionally, Hb, heme, and heme-degradation products can exert vascular effects via NO-independent mechanisms. Oxidation of bilirubin, the ultimate heme-metabolism product, results in the accumulation of bilirubin oxidation products (BOXes) and propentdyopents in patient CSF (58–60). Heme, BOXes, and propentdyopents can all promote vasoconstriction by acting on large conductance BK_Ca potassium channels in astrocytes and vascular smooth muscle cells (60–62). Finally, oxyHb can stimulate production of the potent vasoconstrictor, endothelin (63, 64), and alter expression of calcium and potassium channels in cerebral arteries (65–67). Cell-free Hb and heme may also accelerate acute and chronic inflammatory processes promoting more chronic disruption of vascular homeostasis, which occurs alongside the NO depletion–related vasoconstriction after aSAH (68).

In relation to the NO-sink framework, the protective mechanism underlying our observations is related to the large molecular size of the Hb-haptoglobin complex restricting access of cell-free Hb to NO-sensitive structures in the vascular wall. Haptoglobin demonstrates additional protective functions, which are related to its structural stabilization of bound Hb molecule dimers. We have shown that free radicals are stabilized and less reactive in the Hb-haptoglobin complex compared with free Hb (69, 70), that the complex has an enhanced resistance against oxidative damage (71, 72), and that the oxidant heme cannot be released and transferred from Hb-haptoglobin to lipid compartments (73). In many experimental models, these functions of haptoglobin translate into antioxidant and cytoprotective effects (44, 74, 75). It remains to be investigated how these additional functions of haptoglobin may protect against a broader range of Hb- and heme-driven pathologies after aSAH.

We noted several limitations of our study that need to be addressed before an haptoglobin-based therapy can be further developed for a clinical trial in patients with aSAH. First, our studies were designed to dissect the toxicity of cell-free Hb in CSF as a distinct and targetable pathophysiological factor potentially accelerating the development of secondary neurological damage after aSAH. Our models do not account for mechanisms of early brain injury (EBI) caused by aneurysm rupture in aSAH patients (41, 76). Interspecies differences and mode of bleeding induction are known to limit translation of animal model data in SAH research to clinical practice (77). We have tried to compensate for this limitation by the use of different species and the use of CSF samples of aSAH patients in ex vivo vascular function experiments.

Various haptoglobin phenotypes occur in humans. Haptoglobin 1-1 is a homodimeric molecule with a molecular size of 84 kDa without bound Hb and 148 kDa with 2 Hb dimers bound at each pole of the protein (42). Haptoglobin 2-2 and haptoglobin 2-1 are heterogeneous mixtures of larger polymers. Earlier hypotheses that outcomes of aSAH depended on haptoglobin phenotypes have been refuted (78), and our own studies could not reveal significant biochemical or physiological differences between the binding and detoxifying effects of haptoglobin 1-1 and haptoglobin 2-2 in vitro or in the systemic circulation of guinea pigs (79). In this study, we used a plasma-derived haptoglobin product, which is almost exclusively composed of larger haptoglobin polymers (haptoglobin 2-2 and haptoglobin 2-1). Therefore, we cannot make predictions regarding the functionality of haptoglobin 1-1 to detoxify cell-free Hb in the CSF. A homodimeric product, plasma-derived or recombinant, may be advantageous as a therapeutic compound compared with the heterogenous mixture of Type 2-2 polymers because it could be better characterized and may be formulated at a higher concentration with less aggregation and viscosity. These features may prove to be a critical advantage for a tightly volume-restricted intrathecal administration. However, since compartmentalization due to large molecular size proved to be the definite mechanism of protection, a careful comparison of the protective effect of the smaller haptoglobin 1-1 versus the larger haptoglobin 2-2 needs to be carried out.

Another open question that needs to be addressed relates to the clearance of Hb-haptoglobin complex from the CSF. We assume that a large proportion of the Hb-haptoglobin complexes formed in vivo could be removed by CSF drainage. However, we still expect that some Hb-haptoglobin complexes would be retained in more secluded areas of the subarachnoid space, such as within the widely ramified Virchow-Robin spaces. Macrophages clear Hb-haptoglobin complexes by the CD163 scavenger receptor, and have a high capacity to metabolize heme by heme-oxygenase (80, 81). However, few studies have addressed this clearance pathway in the CSF compartment (47), and it will be critical to further elucidate its efficiency after therapeutic haptoglobin supplementation. Additionally, it will be essential to understand how Hb-haptoglobin clearance may modulate macrophage phenotypes and inflammatory functions.

The last question relates to the technical feasibility of our concept. The typical bleeding volume in aSAH is 35 mL (82), which contains 4–5 g of cell-free Hb. We expect that an optimized therapeutic formula should contain at least 100 mg/mL of active haptoglobin, and 40–50 mL of such a therapeutic formula should be administered into the CSF of a patient during a treatment course if all Hb in the clot should be captured. Although this volume seems large, the slow erythrolysis over several days provides a significant time window for a fractionated dosing schedule. Furthermore, the HPLC and wire-myography methods that we describe in this paper may support personalized dosing schemes based on functional target effects. Finally, we do not know how haptoglobin may be distributed within the subarachnoid space when a subarachnoid blood clot compromises physiologic flow and free diffusion in the CSF. Mechanical obstruction would likely reduce the accessibility of cell-free Hb within the clot and in the vicinity of the culprit blood vessel (83). However, as demonstrated in our patients and in the sheep model, cell-free Hb distributes in the CSF after erythrolysis, well beyond the site of the initial bleeding with potentially far-reaching toxic effects, and we consider this fraction of Hb as the accessible target of a haptoglobin-based therapeutic formula.

Future treatment strategies to improve neurological outcomes after aSAH will likely leverage the synergistic effects of multiple drugs. Currently, the calcium channel blocker nimodipine is the only drug approved for DIND prevention in the United States and Europe (84, 85). Despite ambiguous scientific evidence, intraarterial mechanical or chemical angioplasty is generally accepted as rescue therapy for selected patients with DIND and refractory cerebral vasospasms (84, 85). Endothelin receptor blockers reportedly reversed angiographic vasospasms in clinical trials but failed to improve neurological outcomes (86, 87), likely because of the significant systemic adverse effects. Additionally, therapeutic approaches limited to reversal of vasospasm in large arteries may not sufficiently address the cascading pathophysiology of DIND, which starts with the rupture of the aneurysm leading to early brain damage (41, 76, 88), and which is subsequently amplified by secondary hits such as accumulation of cell-free Hb in CSF.

Based on the recognized importance of dysfunctional NO signaling in the pathophysiology of vasospasm and DIND, there remains a keen interest in the use of NO donors as preventive or rescue therapies. NO can be delivered by systemic administration of NO-releasing molecules such as sodium nitroprusside, nitroglycerin, molsidomine, or NONOates, by inhalation of NO gas, or locally, either via an arterial catheter during angiography or into the CSF (89–91). In mice, inhalation of NO reduced microvascular vasospasm, attenuated brain damage, and improved neurological outcome in an experimental model of SAH (92). Nitrite is another NO donor, which liberates NO in a reaction with deoxygenated Hb (93). Intravenous nitrite was effective in preventing and reversing cerebral artery vasospasm in a primate model of SAH, and demonstrated an acceptable side effect profile in humans (33, 94, 95). Hypothetically, the local NO-sparing effect of haptoglobin may support the concomitant use of NO donors or other vasodilatory drugs, leveraging synergistic activities. Furthermore, the strong Hb-stabilizing and antioxidant functions of Hp may alleviate prooxidant adverse effects of metHb formation that are associated with the use of NO donors (73, 96).

In summary, we defined Hb delocalization from CSF into cerebral vasculature and brain parenchyma as the most upstream mechanism of Hb toxicity after aSAH. Therapeutic haptoglobin supplementation compartmentalizes Hb in CSF and restores the physiological NO signaling in cerebral vasculature, which shifts the balance toward vasodilation. We conclude that intraventricular haptoglobin administration may present a useful therapeutic approach to reduce the toxicity of cell-free Hb in patients with hemorrhages into CSF.

Methods

Hemoglobin, haptoglobin, Hb-haptoglobin complexes, and polymerized hemoglobin.

Hb was purified from sheep blood or expired human blood concentrates as previously described (97). Hb concentrations were determined by spectrophotometry as described and are given as molar concentrations of total heme (1M Hb tetramer is, therefore, equivalent to 4M heme) (73). For all Hb used in these studies, the fraction of ferrous oxyHb (HbFe²⁺O₂) was always greater than 98% as determined by spectrophotometry, unless stated otherwise. Haptoglobin from human plasma (phenotype 2-2 predominant) was obtained from CSL Behring. The identity, purity, and function of the protein were confirmed by liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry (LC-MS/MS), PAGE, and SPR as previously described (79, 98). Hb binding capacity of the haptoglobin was quantified with SEC chromatography. After complex formation, the purity of the complex and the absence of free Hb was verified using SEC chromatography.

Polymerized bovine Hb was prepared at a 40:1 molar ratio of glutaraldehyde to human Hb as described (99). The preparation of MnPP-Hb and MnPP–Hb-haptoglobin complexes is described in the supplement.

CSF samples from patients with aSAH.

Patients with radiological high-grade (Fisher grade 3 or 4) aSAH and external ventricular drain insertion who were admitted to our Neurocritical Care Unit, University Hospital of Zurich (an academic tertiary care center), between April 2017 and December 2018 were included in a consecutive study approved by the local ethical review board of the canton of Zurich. Written consent was obtained from all patients or their legal representatives before study inclusion.

HPLC measurements.

Samples containing Hb and/or Hb-haptoglobin were separated on an analytical BioSep-SEC-s3000 (600 × 7.8 mm) LC column coupled with a BioSep-SEC-s3000 (75 × 7.8 mm) Guard Column (Phenomenex). Details are provided in the supplement.

Proteomics of CSF samples.

The proteomics workflow including sample preparation and LC-MS/MS analysis is described in the Supplemental Methods.

Measurement of Hb-NO reaction by stopped-flow spectrophotometry.

The HbO₂ reaction with NO was measured with a SX18MV stopped-flow spectrophotometer (Applied Photophysics Ltd.) (100). Details of the measurement and data analysis are provided in the supplement.

Ex vivo vascular function experiments.

Vascular function experiments were performed in a Multi-Channel Myograph System 620 M (Danish Myo Technology) as described in the supplement. The NO-mediated vasodilatory responses were induced by the addition of MAHMA-NONOate (ENZO Life Sciences). If not otherwise stated, the recorded Hb-induced vascular function responses were normalized relative to maximum NO dilatation without Hb exposure (equal to 100%) and the level of tonic contraction before addition of MAHMA-NONOate (equal to 0%), respectively, during a single experiment.

Sheep model.

Animal studies were conducted according to the Swiss legal requirements for animal protection and welfare (TschG 455) and received ethical approval from the cantonal veterinary authorities “Kantonale Tierversuchskommission Zürich” (permission no. ZH234/17). Swiss alpine sheep, age 2–4 years, were obtained from the Staffelegghof.

Under general anesthesia, female ventilated sheep were instrumented with a left frontal external ventricular drain (DePuys Synthes) and a suboccipital spinal needle (Dalhausen) for CSF sampling from the subarachnoid space, and a right frontal multimodal neuromonitoring probe (Luciole Medicale AG). Illustration of the experimental setup is provided in Supplemental Figure 6. For controlled ventricular injections of aCSF, Hb, haptoglobin, or Hb-haptoglobin complexes, a PHD Ultra syringe pump (Harvard Apparatus) was connected to the external ventricular drain. Ventricular injections were performed with maximal flow rates of 30 mL/h, and intracranial pressure maintained constant. A detailed description of the model is provided in the Supplemental Methods.

Digital subtraction angiography (DSA).

Digital subtraction angiography was performed in an Allura Clarity angiography suite (Philips) with an angiographic 5F catheter (Cordis) placed into the largest anastomosis between the right maxillary artery and the extradural rete mirabile. Details of the procedure, image processing, and data analysis are provided in the Supplemental Methods and in Supplemental Figure 3.

Magnetic resonance imaging.

In vivo magnetic resonance imaging was performed in a clinical 3 Tesla MRI unit (Philips Ingenia). Details are provided in the supplement.

Mouse model.

Wild-type male C57BL/6J mice (10–12 weeks, total n = 9) were obtained from Charles River and maintained at the Laboratory Animal Services Center of the University of Zurich and treated in accordance with the guidelines of the Swiss Federal Veterinary Office. The studies were conducted according to the Swiss legal requirements for animal protection and welfare (TschG 455) and received ethical approval from the cantonal veterinary authorities “Kantonale Tierversuchskommission Zürich” (permission no. ZH073/17). Details of the stereotactic injection model and sample preparation are provided in the supplement.

Histology.

Details of sample preparation and staining procedures including identity of antibodies are provided in the supplement.

Statistics.

We used JMP software from SAS (versions 13 or 14) for all analyses. Data are presented with all data points plotted. Overlayed diamonds represent mean, 95% CI, and overlap marks (horizontal lines above and below the mean line), which define statistical significant difference between groups if not overlapping (P < 0.05). Groups were compared with 1-way ANOVA, applying a Tukey-Kramer post-test correcting for multiple comparisons. A P value of less than 0.05 was considered statistically significant.

Study approval.

All animal studies were approved by the cantonal veterinary authorities “Kantonale Tierversuchskommission Zürich.” The clinical study (CSF sampling) was approved by the local ethical review board of the Kanton of Zurich, and written consent was obtained from all patients or their legal representatives.

Author contributions

MH and RMB designed the study, performed experiments, analyzed data, and wrote the paper. CAS designed and performed experiments. HR and MD coordinated and performed animal studies. VA performed and analyzed angiography studies. KA performed animal studies, analyzed data, and wrote the paper. LM designed, performed, and analyzed stopped flow experiments. RV, JWD, PWK, and JHB performed experiments. FV wrote the paper. ZK performed and analyzed angiography studies. LR provided critical input and provided patient samples. AFP and ISP provided essential materials. RH analyzed data and generated illustrations. EK designed the clinical study and collected patient material. PWB provided essential material and wrote the paper. PRK coordinated large animal experiments. DJS conceptualized the project, designed the study, analyzed data, and wrote the paper. Authorship order for the 2 co-first authors was determined based on their time of entry into the project (MH entered the project before RMB).

Version 1. 08/27/2019

In-Press Preview

Version 2. 10/22/2019

Electronic publication

Version 3. 12/02/2019

Print issue publication