Comparative genomics of multidrug-resistant Enterococcus spp. isolated from wastewater treatment plants

Haley Sanderson; Rodrigo Ortega-Polo; Rahat Zaheer; Noriko Goji; Kingsley K Amoako; R Stephen Brown; Anna Majury; Steven N Liss; Tim A McAllister

doi:10.1186/s12866-019-1683-4

. 2020 Jan 24;20:20. doi: 10.1186/s12866-019-1683-4

Comparative genomics of multidrug-resistant Enterococcus spp. isolated from wastewater treatment plants

Haley Sanderson ^1,², Rodrigo Ortega-Polo ¹, Rahat Zaheer ¹, Noriko Goji ³, Kingsley K Amoako ³, R Stephen Brown ^2,⁴, Anna Majury ^2,⁵, Steven N Liss ^2,^6,^✉, Tim A McAllister ^1,^✉

PMCID: PMC6982392 PMID: 31980014

Abstract

Background

Wastewater treatment plants (WWTPs) are considered hotspots for the environmental dissemination of antimicrobial resistance (AMR) determinants. Vancomycin-Resistant Enterococcus (VRE) are candidates for gauging the degree of AMR bacteria in wastewater. Enterococcus faecalis and Enterococcus faecium are recognized indicators of fecal contamination in water. Comparative genomics of enterococci isolated from conventional activated sludge (CAS) and biological aerated filter (BAF) WWTPs was conducted.

Results

VRE isolates, including E. faecalis (n = 24), E. faecium (n = 11), E. casseliflavus (n = 2) and E. gallinarum (n = 2) were selected for sequencing based on WWTP source, species and AMR phenotype. The pangenomes of E. faecium and E. faecalis were both open. The genomic fraction related to the mobilome was positively correlated with genome size in E. faecium (p < 0.001) and E. faecalis (p < 0.001) and with the number of AMR genes in E. faecium (p = 0.005). Genes conferring vancomycin resistance, including vanA and vanM (E. faecium), vanG (E. faecalis), and vanC (E. casseliflavus/E. gallinarum), were detected in 20 genomes. The most prominent functional AMR genes were efflux pumps and transporters. A minimum of 16, 6, 5 and 3 virulence genes were detected in E. faecium, E. faecalis, E. casseliflavus and E. gallinarum, respectively. Virulence genes were more common in E. faecalis and E. faecium, than E. casseliflavus and E. gallinarum. A number of mobile genetic elements were shared among species. Functional CRISPR/Cas arrays were detected in 13 E. faecalis genomes, with all but one also containing a prophage. The lack of a functional CRISPR/Cas arrays was associated with multi-drug resistance in E. faecium. Phylogenetic analysis demonstrated differential clustering of isolates based on original source but not WWTP. Genes related to phage and CRISPR/Cas arrays could potentially serve as environmental biomarkers.

Conclusions

There was no discernible difference between enterococcal genomes from the CAS and BAF WWTPs. E. faecalis and E. faecium have smaller genomes and harbor more virulence, AMR, and mobile genetic elements than other Enterococcus spp.

Keywords: Vancomycin resistant Enterococcus (VRE), Enterococci, Genomics, Antimicrobial resistance, Mobilome, Genome size, Wastewater, Pangenome, Biomarker

Background

Enterococci are ubiquitous in nature and can be found in a variety of environments, including soil, plants, surface water, wastewater, food, and the gastrointestinal tract of animals and humans [43, 60]. Enterococcus faecalis and Enterococcus faecium, are associated with a variety of clinical infections of the urinary tract, heart, surgical wounds, bloodstream and neonates [67] as well as indicators of fecal contamination [10]. The ability to treat infections caused by Enterococcus spp. is hindered by the development and spread of antimicrobial resistance (AMR) [1]. Resistance to antimicrobials of last resort, such as vancomycin, impairs the control of enterococcal infections and is usually accompanied by resistance to other antimicrobials [24, 32].

Enterococci and antimicrobials are excreted in urine and feces, and in urbanized developed nations, most of this waste is transported to and treated in wastewater treatment plants (WWTPs) prior to discharge into surface waters. WWTPs could be considered points of control for the environmental dissemination of AMR and ideal environments to investigate the epidemiology of AMR from a “One Health” perspective [2, 44, 57]. Within this environment, enterococci can not only exchange genes coding for AMR, but also for heavy metal resistance as well as other genes that increase persistence and survival in other environments [3]. This outcome can facilitate the broader dissemination of AMR genes [2]. Comparative genomics has been applied to identify genes responsible for virulence, AMR, metabolism, secondary metabolite production and gene mobility. Comparative genomics can also be used to compare genes from other functional categories, to predict the ecological fitness of strains, and to discern evolutionary relationships among species.

We previously isolated a number of species of enterococci from two WWTPs with different treatment processes, a conventional activated sludge (CAS) and a biological aerated filter (BAF) system, with E. faecalis being the dominant species identified [61]. This work demonstrated changes in AMR phenotypes between wastewater enterococci before and after treatment and between WWTPs. In the current study, we selected 39 wastewater enterococci for sequencing out of 1111 enterococci isolated, including 308 that exhibited vancomycin resistance in broth culture. Isolates were selected so as to be representative of before and after treatment in both WWTPs [61]. We hypothesized that the genomes would not cluster by treatment process but genomes from the BAF system may contain more biofilm-related genes than those from the CAS system. We also proposed that there would be more virulence, AMR, and genetic mobility genes in E. faecalis and E. faecium than other Enterococcus spp. and that the larger genomes in these clinically relevant species would correlate with the number of mobile genetic elements and genes conferring fitness for survival in a broader range of environments.

Results

Sequence statistics and Pan-genomic analysis

A summary of sequencing statistics for the 39 Enterococcus spp. genomes can be found in Table 1. The genomes ranged from 2.48–3.54 Mbp. The genomes of E. casseliflavus and E. gallinarum (3.37–3.54 Mbp, 3161–3344 genes) were larger than those of E. faecalis (2.69–3.09 Mbp, 2528–3051 genes) and E. faecium (2.48–3.02 Mbp, 2374–2992 genes). The GC content of the genomes ranged from 37.3–37.7%, 37.5–38.1%, and 40.4–42.9% for E. faecalis, E. faecium, and E. casseliflavus/E. gallinarum, respectively.

Table 1.

Genome Characteristics of Enterococcus spp. Isolated from Municipal Wastewater Treatment Plants

Strain	Location	Species	# of Contigs	Size (bp)	%GC	Genes	CDSs	ST*
B72	BAF FE	E. casseliflavus	32	3,538,396	42.8	3344	3283	NA
B79	BAF FE	E. casseliflavus	49	3,527,325	42.9	3327	3268	NA
W41	CAS PE	E. faecalis	21	2,693,209	37.7	2528	2471	116
B139	BAF FE	E. faecalis	30	2,720,730	37.7	2553	2496	138/501
W314	CAS PE	E. faecalis	11	2,721,427	37.6	2583	2524	277
C34	CAS PE	E. faecalis	13	2,731,087	37.6	2615	2556	715
R95	BAF PE	E. faecalis	38	2,761,310	37.6	2596	2538	674
W350	CAS FE	E. faecalis	28	2,789,796	37.6	2731	2673	84
R76	BAF FE	E. faecalis	51	2,800,339	37.6	2690	2627	16
C106	CAS PE	E. faecalis	24	2,817,683	37.4	2670	2610	16
B48	BAF PE	E. faecalis	29	2,822,491	37.5	2701	2641	16
B168	BAF PE	E. faecalis	39	2,834,215	37.5	2725	2667	21
W191	CAS FE	E. faecalis	22	2,839,739	37.6	2745	2684	207
W460	CAS FE	E. faecalis	27	2,848,194	37.4	2733	2674	672
H120S2	BAF PE	E. faecalis	21	2,853,021	37.4	2731	2670	16
C33	CAS PE	E. faecalis	19	2,860,595	37.3	2722	2662	16
R378	BAF FE	E. faecalis	50	2,892,126	37.5	2858	2796	326
W75	CAS FE	E. faecalis	59	2,901,424	37.5	2838	2776	209
B6	BAF FE	E. faecalis	48	2,906,126	37.5	2796	2738	26
R395	BAF PE	E. faecalis	35	2,951,239	37.5	2844	2785	40
W195	CAS FE	E. faecalis	30	2,970,793	37.5	2865	2806	40
H114S2	BAF PE	E. faecalis	35	2,979,979	37.4	2881	2822	40
C379	CAS FE	E. faecalis	42	2,988,783	37.5	2902	2844	40
R61	BAF FE	E. faecalis	37	3,004,659	37.3	2969	2907	16
B150	BAF FE	E. faecalis	41	3,012,117	37.3	2955	2893	16
W37	CAS PE	E. faecalis	68	3,088,982	37.3	3051	2990	768
C329	CAS FE	E. faecium	63	2,480,628	38.1	2374	2305	40
B466	BAF FE	E. faecium	71	2,553,406	38.1	2512	2443	672
C567	CAS FE	E. faecium	21	2,778,016	37.9	2714	2644	1216
C12d	CAS PE	E. faecium	169	2,879,332	37.7	2823	2755	18
H101S2	BAF PE	E. faecium	177	2,884,826	37.8	2836	2770	18
H123S2	BAF PE	E. faecium	170	2,912,775	37.7	2871	2803	18
H53S1	CAS PE	E. faecium	165	2,959,005	37.6	2915	2847	18
F11j	CAS PE	E. faecium	181	2,964,368	37.6	2916	2848	18
R407	BAF PE	E. faecium	176	3,005,175	37.5	2955	2887	18
B492	BAF FE	E. faecium	189	3,008,305	37.5	2961	2893	18
R337	BAF PE	E. faecium	195	3,023,784	37.5	2992	2924	18
W17	CAS FE	E. gallinarum	14	3,367,806	40.5	3161	3102	NA
G12 s	CAS PE	E. gallinarum	30	3,442,529	40.4	3303	3244	NA

Open in a new tab

BAF: biological aerated filter, CAS: conventional activated sludge, PE: primary effluent, FE: final effluent, % GC: guanine-cytosine content, CDS: protein coding sequence, ST: sequence type, NA: not available

The range in contigs generated during sequencing was greater in E. faecium (21–195 contigs) than in other species (11–68 contigs), likely due to the presence of repetitive and insertion genetic elements complicating assembly [54]. Genome sizes were greater for vancomycin and multi-drug resistant strains of E. faecium (3.04 Mbp) than for susceptible strains (2.60 Mbp). The genome size of vancomycin-resistant and multi-drug resistant E. faecalis was similar to their susceptible counterparts.

The E. faecalis pangenome consisted of 5708 genes with a core of 2054 genes (36%), a soft-core of 91 genes (1.6%), a shell genome of 1193 (20.9%) and a cloud genome of 2370 genes (41.5%; Fig. 1 a). The E. faecium pangenome consisted of 3950 genes with a core of 1959 genes (49.6%), a shell of 1186 genes (30%) and a cloud genome of 805 genes (20.4%; Fig. 1 b).

Fig. 1 — *Enterococcus faecalis (*a) and Enterococcus faecium (b) pan-genome illustrated as a matrix with the core SNP tree of the strains on the left and a presence (blue) and absence (white) matrix of core and accessory genes

Multi-locus sequence typing

In the current study, 4 sequence types (STs) for E. faecium and 15 STs for E. faecalis were identified (Table 1). Eight E. faecium genomes belonged to ST18, part of the clonal complex 17 (CC-17). Out of the E. faecalis STs identified in this study, ST16 (n = 7) and ST40 (n = 4) were the most common.

Phenotypic antimicrobial resistance profiles

Sequenced enterococci exhibited a number of phenotypic antimicrobial resistant profiles, with some isolates being resistant to as many as seven antimicrobials (Table 2). VAN^R, TEC^R, AMP^R, ERY^R were among the most common resistant phenotypes found in enterococci.

Table 2.

Phenotypic Antimicrobial Resistance Profiles of sequenced Enterococcus spp isolates

Isolate	AMR Phenotype*
E. casseliflavus B72	ERY^I, Q-D^R
E. casseliflavus B79	VAN^I, ERY^I, Q-D^I
E. faecalis W460	ERY^I, Q-D^R
E. faecalis W350	DOX^R, ERY^I, LZD^I
E. faecalis W191	DOX^R, Q-D^R
E. faecalis H120S2	ERY^R, STR^I
E. faecalis H114S2	VAN^R, TEC^R, AMP^R, LVX^R
E. faecalis C34	VAN^R, TEC^R, ERY^I, LZD^I, Q-D^R
E. faecalis C33	TEC^R, DOX^R, ERY^R, LZD^I,LVX^R, Q-D^R
E. faecalis B168	DOX^I, ERY^I, LZD^I, Q-D^R
E. faecalis B150	TEC^R, DOX^I, ERY^R, LZD^R, Q-D^R
E. faecalis B6	DOX^R, ERY^I, Q-D^R
E. faecalis B48	DOX^R, ERY^R, LZD^R, Q-D^R
E. faecalis B139	VAN^I, LZD^I, Q-D^R
E. faecalis C106	TEC^R, DOX^R, ERY^R, GEN^R, Q-D^R
E. faecalis C379	DOX^R, ERY^I, Q-D^R
E. faecalis R61	VAN^I, TEC^R, DOX^R, ERY^R, GEN^I, LZD^I, Q-D^R
E. faecalis R76	DOX^R, ERY^R, GEN^R, Q-D^R, STR^R
E. faecalis R95	DOX^I, ERY^R, GEN^I, LZD^I, Q-D^R, STR^R
E. faecalis R378	ERY^I, Q-D^I
E. faecalis R395	VAN^I, TEC^R, DOX^R, ERY^I, Q-D^R
E. faecalis W37	DOX^I, ERY^R, LVX^R, Q-D^I, STR^R
E. faecalis W41	VAN^I, TEC^R, DOX^R, ERY^I, Q-D^R
E. faecalis W75	VAN^I, Q-D^I
E. faecalis W195	DOX^I, ERY^I, Q-D^R
E. faecalis W314	TEC^R, ERY^I, LZD^R, Q-D^R
E. faecium R407	VAN^R, TEC^R, AMP^R, ERY^R, GEN^R, LVX^R, STR^R
E. faecium R337	VAN^R, TEC^R, AMP^R, ERY^R, NIT^I, LVX^R, STR^R
E. faecium H53S1	VAN^R, TEC^R, AMP^R, ERY^R, LVX^R, STR^I
E. faecium F11 J	VAN^R, TEC^R, AMP^R, ERY^R, LVX^R, STR^R
E. faecium C329	TEC^R, ERY^I, NIT^R, LZD^I, LVX^R
E. faecium B492	VAN^R, TEC^R, AMP^R, ERY^R, LVX^R, STR^R
E. faecium B466	AMP^R, DOX^R, ERY^R, NIT^I, LVX^I
E. faecium C12D	VAN^R, TEC^R, AMP^R, ERY^I, LVX^R
E. faecium C567	ERY^R, NIT^I, LZD^I
E. faecium H101S2	VAN^R, TEC^R, AMP^R, ERY^R, LVX^R, STR^I
E. faecium H123S2	VAN^R, TEC^R, AMP^R, ERY^R, LVX^R, STR^I
E. gallinarum W17	VAN^I
E. gallinarum G12S	VAN^I

Open in a new tab

a AMR phenotypic profiles using R for resistant to the antimicrobial and I for intermediately resistant to the antimicrobial. Antimicrobials used for disc susceptibility testing were vancomycin (VAN), teicoplanin (TEC), amipicillin (AMP), doxycycline (DOX), erythromycin (ERY), levofloxacin (LVX), linezolid (LZD), nitrofurantoin (NIT), gentamicin (GEN), streptomycin (STR), quinupristin/dalfopristin (Q-D), and tigecycline (TGC)

Phylogeny

Genomes did not cluster based on WWTP, but all species formed separate monophylogenetic groups (Fig. 2). The majority of wastewater E. faecalis isolates were more closely related to livestock and food-derived E. faecalis genomes, while seven wastewater strains (B139, B168, C34, W37, W75, W191, and W314) clustered with strains isolated from human infections (Fig. 3). None of the E. faecalis wastewater, human, and agriculture (and food-derived) isolates clustered together by source, suggesting that agricultural and human clinical strains are phylogenetically distinct. Vancomycin-resistant E. faecalis isolates also did not cluster as they belonged to different STs, unlike vancomycin-resistant E. faecium, which did cluster as all isolates belonged to CC-17 (Fig. 4). For E. faecium, wastewater strains clustered separately from most clinical strains (Fig. 4). The bovine strain E. faecium F1129F clustered with human clinical strains, whereas the other bovine strain, E. faecium F1213D did not. Three wastewater isolates (E. faecium C567, E. faecium B466, and E. faecium C329) were more closely related to E. faecium F1213D (bovine) and E. faecium NRRL B-2354 (food) than to clinical isolates.

Fig. 3 — Phylogenetic tree of *Entercoccus faecalis* genome sequences from the present study and complete genome sequences from the NCBI GenBank database based on analysis of single-nucleotide variants (SNVs) of the core genes. *Enterococcus faecalis* ATCC29212 was used as the reference genome. Origin of Isolates are as indicated in the figures and are grouped by colour into clinical (red), agricultural/food (green) and wastewater/water (blue) groups

Fig. 4 — Phylogenetic tree of *Entercoccus faecium* genome sequences from the present study and genome sequences from the NCBI GenBank database based on analysis of single-nucleotide variants (SNVs) of the core genes. *Entercoccus faecium* DO served as the reference genome. Origin of isolates are as indicated in the figures and are grouped by colour into clinical (red), agricultural/food (green) and wastewater/water (blue) groups

Clusters of orthologous groups (COGs): functional categories and genome size

Clusters of Orthologous Groups (COGs) are broad functional categories used to assign proteins to their specific function [69]. Functional categorization of proteins into different COGs revealed variation profiles among Enterococcus spp., but little difference among strains within species, with the exception of the mobilome and genes associated with energy production and conversion (Additional file 1, sheet 6). We assessed which functional categories of genes were disproportionately represented in the isolates collected from the WWTPs with expanded genomes.

Given the variation in genome size between and within species, the relationships between genome size and the number of genes associated with specific functional categories was determined (Fig. 5; Additional file 1, Sheet 6). There were more COGs assigned to carbohydrate transport and metabolism, transcription, cell motility, secondary metabolite biosynthesis, transport, catabolism and signal transduction mechanisms in E. casseliflavus and E. gallinarum compared to enterococci more frequently associated with clinical infections.

Fig. 5 — Correlation plots showing the correlations between different COG categories, genome size and number of genes in all of the pooled *Enterococcus* species (a), *E. faecalis,* (b) and *E. faecium* (c)

When all of the wastewater Enterococcus genomes were pooled, there was a strong negative correlation (p < 0.001) between genome size and nucleotide transport and metabolism, lipid metabolism and translation, ribosomal structure and biogenesis and a strong positive correlation (p < 0.001) between genome size and cell motility (Fig. 5 a; Additional file 1, sheet 6). The total number of genes related to cell motility, signal transduction, and carbohydrate transport and metabolism were positively correlated (p < 0.001) with genome size. This is reflective of the greater genome size of environmental species compared to E. faecium and E. faecalis. The total number of genes related to cell division and chromosome partitioning, cell envelope biogenesis, outer membrane and post translational modification, protein turnover, and transcription were negatively correlated (p < 0.001) with genome size.

The species-specific patterns in genomic proportions for each functional category differ from the pooled genomes for the genus. In both E. faecalis and E. faecium, a larger genome was strongly correlated with the mobilome (p < 0.001) (Fig. 5 b and c), a functional category not included in the analysis of Konstantinidis and Tiedje [34]. In contrast, the mobilome was not correlated with genome size in the pooled Enterococcus genomes. There was also a positive correlation (p = 0.005) between the number of unique AMR genes and genome size of E. faecium, suggesting the acquisition of AMR genes occurs through horizontal gene transfer. For example, E. faecium R337 had a genome of 3.02 kbp, 58 genes associated with the mobilome and 23 AMR genes; while E. faecium C329 had a genome of 2.48kbp and 15 genes associated with the mobilome and 3 AMR genes.

The total number of genes related to cell motility (p < 0.001), DNA replication, recombination, and repair (p < 0.001), extracellular structures (p < 0.001), and mobilome (p < 0.001) was positively correlated with genome size in E. faecium. The number of AMR genes also showed a positive correlation (p = 0.002) with the amount of genes related to the mobilome in this species (Fig. 5 c). The eight E. faecium genomes belonged to the same sequence type (CC-17), while E. faecalis genomes were more diverse.

Antimicrobial resistance genes

In this study, we screened 39 multi-antimicrobial resistant enterococci genomes against the CARD database for antimicrobial resistance genes (ARGs) (Additional file 1, Sheet 8) and ten genes (eatAv, emeA, lsaA, efrA, efrB, tetL, efmA, msrC, ermY, and lsaE) associated with multi-drug efflux pumps and other transporters were detected. These efflux proteins may confer intermediate resistance to a variety of antimicrobials.

Genes conferring glycopeptide (vancomycin and teicoplanin) resistance were detected in 20 of the genomes. In E. faecium and E. faecalis, resistance was conferred by vanA and vanM in E. faecium or vanG in E. faecalis. Vancomycin resistance was mediated by vanC, and this was the only ARG detected, in E. casseliflavus and E. gallinarum.

ErmB confers resistance to macrolide-lincosamide-streptogramin B (MLSB) antimicrobials and was found in E. faecium (n = 7) and E. faecalis (n = 4). Other erm genes (ermC, ermG, ermT, ermY) were detected in one E. faecium genome. msrC, which codes for a macrolide efflux pump, was only detected in E. faecium (n = 11). The most common macrolide resistance gene detected in enterococcal genomes was ermB (n = 15).

Thirteen of the enterococci isolates were resistant to high concentrations of gentamicin and streptomycin. In our study, cross-resistance to levofloxacin and the aminoglycosides (gentamicin and streptomycin) occurred in 5 isolates with 3 additional isolates exhibiting intermediate resistance to one or more of these antimicrobials. In our study, additional aminoglycoside genes (ant(9′)-Ia, aad(6′), aph(3′)-IIIa, SAT-4, ant(6′)-Ia, and aac(6′)-Ie-aph(2″)-Ia) were detected in the genomes of up to 5 E. faecalis and 7 E. faecium aminoglycoside resistant isolates. Gentamicin resistance arises as the result of the acquisition of aac(6′)-Ie-aph(2″)-Ia, which was detected in 7 genomes (2 E. faecalis and 5 E. faecium) and confers resistance to all aminoglycosides except streptomycin [42]. The prevalence of streptomycin resistance versus gentamicin resistance differed between species, with streptomycin resistance being more common in E. faecium and gentamicin resistance more common in E. faecalis.

Genes encoding tetracycline resistance were detected in 26 of the genomes, including E. faecium and E. faecalis. In this study, determinants for macrolide and tetracycline were detected together in 16 of the enterococcal genomes. Genes associated with resistance to antimicrobials not included in the disc susceptibility panel were also detected. A gene associated with chloramphenicol resistance, cat, was detected in two E. faecalis genomes. Genes associated with diaminopyrimidine resistance (dfrE, dfrF, and dfrG) were also detected in E. faecium and E. faecalis. Two E. faecalis genomes also had genes associated with lincosamide resistance (InuB and InuG).

Virulence genes

The number of shared virulence genes among genomes of the same species were 16, 6, 5 and 3 for E. faecium, E. casseliflavus, E. faecalis, and E. gallinarum, respectively (Additional file 1, Sheet 9–11). All of the E. faecium isolates contained genes related to adhesion to surfaces (tuf, aga, efaA, and sgrA), cell wall biosynthesis (phosphatase cytidylyltransferase, uppS), cellular defense (lisR), biofilm formation and surface proteins (acm, esp, scm and type A and B pili). Other functions including bile salt degradation (bsh), proteases (tip/ropA), biofilm formation (bopD), enolase (eno), and antiphagocytosis and capsule formation (rfbA-1) were also identified. All of the E. faecalis genomes contained genes for cell adhesion (tuf), carbohydrate metabolism (hyl), endocarditic and biofilm association (ebp) pili (ebpA), Type III secretion proteins (bopD) and fibrinogen-binding proteins (fss1). All of the E. casseliflavus genomes contained the same five virulence genes with functions of: capsule biosynthesis (capE), enolase (eno), leucine aminopeptidase (lap), heat shock protein (hsp60), and protein modification (lplA1). All of the E. gallinarum genomes had an enolase (eno), a flagellar biosynthesis protein (flhA) and a bile salt hydrolase (bsh). One of the E. gallinarum genomes also contained genes related to capsule proteins and another isolated from effluent possessed 2 genes associated with metal transporter (ssaB and psaA) as well as those associated with the CAS system. Hyaluronidase (hyl) genes were detected in all the E. faecalis genomes.

Mobile gene elements

ICE and transposons present in the genomes were identified and described using the ICEberg database (Table 3; Additional file 1, sheet 17). The transposon, Tn917 was identified in 8 of the sequenced E. faecalis genomes. One transposon, Tn6098 was present in all genomes. A multidrug resistance transposon, Tn5385 was also found in all E. faecalis genomes. Other Tn5801 and Tn6013-like ICE elements of unknown function were also present in all E. faecium isolates, in addition to a cadmium and arsenic resistance ICE, ICESde3396. All of the E. gallinarum and E. casseliflavus isolates had Tn916-type transposons (Tn6079, Tn6087 and Tn6084, respectively). Seven out of the unique 27 ICE were present in genomes of more than one Enterococcus species.

Table 3.

Integrative conjugative elements (ICE) and transposons identified in the wastewater Enterococcus spp. genomes (n = 39)

Species	Common ICE	Function	Other Notable ICE	Function
E. casseliflavus	Tn6098 Tn6084 Tn6000(EfcTn1)	α-galactoside metabolism Tetracycline resistance Tetracycline resistance	No other ICE detected
E. faecalis	Tn6098 Tn5385	α-galactoside metabolism Erythromycin, gentamicin, streptomycin, tetracycline, penicillin/β-lactam, mercury resistance	Tn917 Tn2008 Tn1545 ICESp23FST81 Tn6009 ICESde3396 Tn5301 Tn5276 ICESt1	Tetracycline resistance Chloramphenicol, erythromycin, streptomycin, kanamycin resistance Sulfamethoxazole, trimethoprim, chloramphenicol, erythromycin, streptomycin resistance Tetracycline, chloramphenicol resistance, toxin-antitoxin system Mercury resistance Kanamycin, arsenic and cadmium resistance Nisin biosynthesis Nisin biosynthesis, sucrose fermentation Type II restriction modification system
E. faecium	Tn6098 Tn5801 Tn6084 Tn6000(EfcTn1) ICESauTW20–2 ICESauT0131–2 ICESauJKD6008–2 ICESpsED99–1 ICESauMu3–1	α-galactoside metabolism Tetracycline resistance Tetracycline resistance Tetracycline resistance Unknown Unknown Unknown Unknown Unknown	Tn2008 Tn1545 ICESde3396 ICESt1 ICEAusCo10a-1 10,750-RD.2	See above See above See above See above Toxin-antitoxin system Type II restriction modification, spectinomycin, erythromycin resistance
E. gallinarum	Tn6098 Tn6079 Tn6087 ICEsde3396	α-galactoside metabolism Tetracycline, erythromycin resistance Tetracycline, antiseptic and antimicrobial resistance (unspecified) Kanamycin, arsenic and cadmium resistance	Tn2008 Tn1545	See above See above

Open in a new tab

CRISPR-Cas arrays and bacteriophage

Type II CRISPR-Cas systems were detected in 13 E. faecalis genomes (Fig. 6). Orphan CRISPR arrays (without Cas genes) were identified in 27 of the genomes (Fig. 6). Comparison of CRISPR arrays flanked by Cas genes revealed unique arrays among Enterococcus species, but some arrays were shared among strains of the same species. Arrays identified in the sequenced Enterococcus genomes contained 4 to 20 direct repeat sequences associated with functional CRISPR arrays. An additional 72 unique spacers associated with orphan CRISPR arrays were identified in this study. Eleven E. faecalis and 10 E. faecium genomes lacked CRISPR-Cas systems. Any genomes lacking functional arrays exhibited resistance to 4 or more antimicrobial agents.

Functional CRISPR arrays and intact prophage were identified in 10 E. faecalis genomes, but the combination was not seen in the other 29 genome sequenced in this study. Some of the spacer regions identified in CRISPR arrays were 100% identical to incomplete prophage sequences, but these genomes still contained at least one prophage.

Bacteriophage-mediated transduction of AMR has been demonstrated in enterococci and potential virulence determinants have been identified in phage associated with E. faecalis. Phages found in the genomes were members of the Siphoviridae and Myoviridae (Additional file 1, Sheet 12). Thirty-four of the 39 genomes contained at least one putative phage ranging in size from 19.2 kb to 70.6 kb. A total of 55 unique intact prophages were identified across 34 sequenced genomes. E. faecium and E. faecalis contained up to 3 intact prophages, whereas E. casseliflavus and E. gallinarum contained 1 or 2 intact prophages.

Secondary metabolites

Bacteriocins were identified in 8 E. faecalis and 9 E. faecium genomes in addition to 1 E. gallinarum genome (Additional file 1, Sheet 18). Enterocin A was identified in nine E. faecium genomes. Lantipeptides were identified in 3 E. faecalis genomes as cytolysins, which have both haemolytic and bacteriolytic activities [12]. Lassopeptides were identified in 6 E. faecalis genomes. Terpenes were detected in all E. casseliflavus and E. gallinarum, but not in E. faecalis or E. faecium genomes. Aryl polyene was detected in one E. faecalis (C34) genome.

Biomarker search

The small number of genomes limited the identification of biomarkers, particularly for searches within the same species isolated from different sources (Additional file 1, Sheet 19). These biomarkers are genes or gene fragments only present in one group of genomes and not others making them possible identifiers of the origin of collected isolates. The majority of searches have identified biomarkers with scores below a correlation cut-off of 0.95. However, in our study, E. faecalis from wastewater that clustered with agricultural and animal sources revealed a biomarker associated with CRISPR-associated genes that differentiated (score = 0.8043) these isolates from E. faecalis from wastewater that clustered with human sources. A comparison of E. faecium from clinical (inclusion) and wastewater (exclusion) sources yielded 7 biomarkers with scores greater than 0.80. These were associated with phage (n = 6) and hypothetical proteins (n = 1). A search for potential biomarkers that distinguished among species in this study resulted in 98 signatures for E. faecalis, 130 signatures for E. faecium, and 3 signatures E. casseliflavus and E. gallinarum. These signatures include genes related to various types of nucleotide and carbohydrate metabolism, as well as other functions.

Discussion

Sequence statistics and Pan-genomic analysis

There was considerable variation in the size of the genomes and the number of contigs generated by sequencing each genome. The variation in the size of the genomes within a species could be a result of differences in the size of the chromosome and the presence/absence of plasmids. The variation in the number of contigs is likely due to the presence of repetitive and insertion genetic elements complicating assembly [54]. While the number of genomes used to generate the pan-genome in our study was small, the pan-genome of Enterococcus spp. is considered open as it is continually expanding and acquiring new accessory genome elements from other enterococci and bacterial species [80].