Supplemental Digital Content is available in the text
Keywords: antiretroviral therapy, exhaustion, HIV, immune activation, immune reconstitution, recent thymic emigrants, senescence
Abstract
Objective:
Around 20–30% of HIV-infected individuals (HIV+) on successful antiretroviral therapy (ART) fail to normalize their CD4+ T-cell counts. Various factors could contribute to the lack of immune reconstitution, one of them being thymic insufficiency. We aimed to explore associations between recent thymic emigrants (RTEs) and CD4+ T-cell recovery.
Design:
ART-naive HIV+ individuals who started ART with advanced AIDS were selected. Good versus poor immune reconstitution was defined by CD4+ gains above or below 100 CD4+ T cells/μl. The follow-up period was 6 months.
Methods:
Peripheral blood mononuclear cells were isolated and flow cytometry was used to characterize RTEs as the fraction of naive CD4+ T cells expressing CD31+, the platelet endothelial cell adhesion molecule. Markers of cellular activation, senescence, exhaustion and cycling were also assessed.
Results:
After 6 months on ART, HIV+ individuals with good immune reconstitution had higher absolute numbers of RTEs, compared with those with poor immune reconstitution, and these strongly correlated with CD4+ gains in those individuals with good immune reconstitution but not with poor immune reconstitution. We also found that CD8+ T-cell immune activation decreased as early as 2 months post-ART initiation in individuals with good immune reconstitution, but only at month 6 post-ART in individuals with poor immune reconstitution. Levels of immune activation were inversely correlated with the absolute numbers of RTEs in both groups, but more strongly so in individuals with poor immune reconstitution.
Conclusion:
We show that RTEs are linked to CD4+ T-cell recovery and that the degree of immune reconstitution is not directly linked to persistent immune activation.
Introduction
A fair number of antiretroviral (ART)-experienced HIV-infected individuals (HIV+) do not recover their CD4+ T-cell counts despite complete suppression of HIV viremia [1,2]. Failure to normalize CD4+ T-cell counts to levels above 500 cells/μl is associated with poor clinical outcome [3–5] and has been attributed to impaired peripheral and lymphoid tissue homeostasis [6], accelerated T-cell death, chronic immune activation [7–9] and thymic insufficiency [10–12].
Recent thymic emigrants (RTEs) are thought to represent newly produced peripheral naive CD4+ T cells and have been extensively used as a surrogate marker to quantify thymic export [13,14]. RTEs can be measured by flow cytometry in peripheral blood, allowing for their phenotypic and functional characteristics to be examined [15–17]; and are defined as the fraction of naive CD4+ T cells that express CD31+, the platelet endothelial cell adhesion molecule (PECAM-1) [18]. Numerous studies have shown that RTEs contribute towards CD4+ T-cell recovery and their frequency and absolute numbers in peripheral blood predict immune restoration in ART-experienced individuals [12,19–28]. Indeed, HIV+ individuals who achieve good immune reconstitution (immunological responders, defined by absolute CD4+ T-cell counts above 350 cells/μl after 2 years of undetectable plasma viremia) have frequencies of RTEs matching to those of HIV seronegative individuals (HIV−), as opposed to those who do not achieve immune reconstitution (immunological nonresponders, CD4+ T cells below 350) [23,29,30].
Much work has been done in order to assess thymic reactivation and its association with immune reconstitution using markers of thymic output, such as RTEs and T-cell excision circles (TREC) [14]. However, and to our knowledge, detailed phenotypic characterization of RTEs has not been fully investigated in untreated and short-term-treated HIV infection [31].
Therefore, we thought to examine changes in the expression of markers of activation (HLADR, CD38), senescence (CD57), exhaustion (PD-1) and cycling (Ki67) on RTEs as HIV+ individuals transition from untreated to treated HIV infection. We also explored associations between the expression of these markers and CD4+ T-cell recovery. Our study included two longitudinal cohorts, an HIV+ cohort, primarily HIV+ individuals with advanced AIDS and an HIV− cohort, with three-time point measurements, and a follow-up of 6 months. Both cohorts included individuals who were naive to therapy (baseline) and started therapy, ART for HIV+ and preexposure prophylaxis (PrEP) for HIV−. Our aim was to understand associations between RTEs and early CD4+ T-cell recovery. We sought to identify if there were differences in frequencies, absolute numbers and/or phenotypic characteristics of RTEs from HIV+ individuals based on their degree of immune reconstitution, here assessed by CD4+ gains.
Methods
Ethics statement
Our study was approved by the ethics committee of the National Institute of Respiratory Diseases, Mexico City, Mexico, and was conducted according to the principles expressed in the Declaration of Helsinki. All individuals were adults (over 18 years old). All participants provided written consent.
Study cohorts
Our study design is summarized in Supplementary Figure 1. A total of 55 individuals were included in this study.
The first cohort was composed of 41 HIV+ individuals with advanced AIDS who were selected based on five criteria: being ART-naive at study entry, starting their first ART regimen, having a good virological response to ART at month 6 defined by plasma HIV-1 RNA less than 400 copies/ml, having CD4+ T-cell count and plasma viral load (pVL) measurements available at all three time points of interest: pre-ART (T0, Baseline), 2-months (T2) and 6-months (T6) after ART initiation, and having stored peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMCs) available at all three time points (T0, T2 and T6).
The second cohort, our control cohort, was composed of HIV-uninfected individuals, who were eligible to start oral preexposure prophylaxis (PrEP, tenofovir disoproxil fumarate/emtricitabine, 300/200 mg) because they were at high-risk of HIV infection. To evaluate the risk of HIV acquisition, a risk behavior assessment questionnaire based on sexual practices was administered [32]. HIV testing was performed at study entry and at month 3 (T3) and month 6 (T6) after PrEP initiation. For this study, HIV-1-uninfected individuals were selected based on three criteria: having CD4+ T-cell count measurements available at baseline (pre-PrEP, T0), having an HIV negative test at month 3 (T3) and month 6 (T6) after PrEP initiation, having stored PBMCs available at all three time points (T0, T3 and T6). A total of 14 individuals were included. Note that for this cohort, CD4+ T-cell counts were not available at T3 and T6.
HIV-1 RNA plasma viral load and lymphocyte populations
HIV-1 RNA plasma viral load was determined by automated real-time PCR using m2000 system (Abbot, Abbott Park, Illinois, USA). Lymphocyte populations were obtained by flow cytometry using Trucount in a FACSCanto II (BD Biosciences, San Jose, California, USA).
Peripheral blood mononuclear cell isolation
Ethylene diamine tetraacetic acid (EDTA)-blood was quantified by venipuncture at all three visits for HIV+ and HIV-uninfected individuals. PBMCs were isolated as previously described [33].
Flow cytometry
PBMC from the same individual (T0, T2/3, T6) were thawed, stained and analyzed in the same experiment. Briefly, PBMC were thawed and washed in PBS, and then stained with a single cocktail of antibodies, which are listed in Supplementary Table 1, for 15 min at room temperature (RT). PBMC were then washed twice with PBS and permeabilized with the eBiosciences FOXP3/fixation permeabilization kit (Thermo Fisher Scientific, Waltham, Massachusetts, USA) following manufacturer‘s instructions. Next, PBMC were stained intracellularly for Ki-67 for 60 mins at RT, washed twice, fixed in 300 μl of 1% paraformaldehyde (Sigma-Aldrich, St. Louis, Missouri, USA), stored at 4 °C and acquired within 24 h of fixing. Live/Dead Aqua dye was used to exclude dead cells. A dump gate was used to exclude unwanted populations (see Supplementary Table 1). A minimum of 1.5 million events were acquired on a BD LSRFortessa (BD Biosciences, San Jose, California, USA) and analyzed using FlowJo V10 software (Tree Star, Ashland, Oregon, USA). FMO (fluorescence minus one) was used as gating control. Quality control was performed for each experiment using BD cytometer Setup & Tracking Beads (BD biosciences, San Jose, California, USA). A compensation matrix was calculated and applied individually to each experiment using BD Comp Beads (BD Biosciences). The gating strategy is shown in Supplementary Figure 2. Research staff performing the flow cytometry experiments were blinded to all information pertaining to group allocation and clinical data.
Statistical analysis of flow data
Mann--Whitney, Kruskal--Wallis and Friedman nonparametric tests were used as appropriate. All P values were corrected for multiple comparisons using Dunn's multiple comparisons test. Corrected P values below 0.05 were considered significant. Correlations were performed using a nonparametric Spearman test. Graphs and statistics were performed in GraphPad Prism version 7 (San Diego, California, USA) and STATA/SE 14 (STATA Corp. LP, College Station, Texas, USA).
Results
Study cohort
Table 1 shows the clinical and demographic characteristics of all individuals included in this study. This cohort is characterized by HIV+ individuals with advanced AIDS and very low pre-ART CD4+ T-cell counts. During the first 6 months on ART, HIV+ individuals gained a median of 172 [77–260] CD4+ cells/μl (T6-T0, ΔCD4). For this study, we defined a good versus poor immune reconstitution (GIR vs. PIR) based on a ΔCD4+ value of 100 CD4+ T cells/μl and this arbitrary value was chosen according to our cohort characteristics and after reviewing the literature. Accordingly, we divided our HIV+ cohort into individuals with GIR (n = 28, ΔCD4 ≥100 cells/μl) and PIR (n = 13, ΔCD4 <100 cells/μl). As expected, their median absolute CD4+ T-cell count at T6 was different (P = 0.0042) but not their baseline median absolute CD4+ T-cell count (GIR: 57.50 [26.25–263.5] vs. PIR: 143 [55–252.5] cells/μl, P ≥ 0.05). There were no differences between GIR and PIR with regards to age, BMI, nadir CD4+, duration on ART, ART regimen and co-infections (Table 1 and Supplementary Table 2).
Table 1.
Demographic and clinical characteristics of our cohort at baseline and at follow-up (6 months postantiretroviral therapy).
Baseline | Follow-up | |||||
GIR | PIR | P value | GIR | PIR | P value | |
Number | 28 | 13 | 28 | 13 | ||
Age (years)a | 34.5 (20–64) | 37 (26–55) | NS | |||
BMI (kg/m2) | 21.65 [19.88–23.78] | 22.50 [20.05–25.20] | NS | |||
Sexual preferenceb | ||||||
MSM | 23 (82) | 11 (85) | NS | |||
MSWM | 5 (18) | 2 (15) | ||||
CD4+ T (cells/μl) | 57.50 [26.25–263.5] | 143 [55–252.5] | NS | 336 [232.5–627] | 154 [96–310] | 0.0042 |
CD4+ (%) | 9 [5–16] | 10 [4–16] | NS | 18.50 [10–27.75] | 10 [5.5–21] | NS |
CD8+ T (cells/μl) | 499 [315–1076] | 878 [611.5–1715] | 0.055 | 1070 [619.3–1577] | 928 [546.5–1429] | NS |
CD8+ (%) | 58 [45–67] | 68 [57–75] | 0.028 | 53 [39.50–62] | 59 [52–74.50] | 0.038 |
CD4+/CD8+ ratio | 0.17 [0.09–0.27] | 0.13 [0.065–0.24] | NS | 0.325 [0.18–0.602] | 0.18 [0.08–0.385] | 0.06 |
Nadir CD4+ (cells/μl) | 57.50 [26.25–263.5] | 143 [55–252.5] | NS | |||
Log pVL (copies/ml) | 5.29 [4.78–5.68] | 4.68 [4.26–5.50] | NS | 1.5 (1.5–2.4) | 1.5 (1.5–2.0) | NS |
CD4 gains (cells/μl) | 213.5 [162.3–365.3] | 50 [11.50–77] | <0.0001 | |||
Time on ART (days) | 184 [180.5–194.8] | 178 [171–187] | NS |
Values are given as median [interquartile range, IQR] unless stated otherwise. ART, antiretroviral therapy; CD, cluster of differentiation; GIR, good immune reconstitution; HIV+, HIV-infected; log, logarithmic scale; MSWM, men who have sex with women or men; PIR, poor immune reconstitution; pVL, plasma viral load; NS, not significant (P ≥ 0.05).
aMedian (minimum--maximum).
bNumber (percentage).
Individuals with poor immune reconstitution have fewer naive CD4+ T cells than individuals with good immune reconstitution pre-antiretroviral therapy but not after 6 months on antiretroviral therapy
First, we analyzed the distribution of CD4+ T-cell maturation subsets based on the expression of the canonical markers CCR7 and CD45RO (expressed as frequencies). We found that HIV+ individuals have a skewed phenotype with increased frequencies of effector memory and terminally differentiated (TEMRA) and decreased frequencies of naive and central memory CD4+ T cells (Supplementary Figure 3). We found that the percentage of central memory was equally depleted in GIR and PIR, conversely, the percentage of effector memory was equally increased in GIR and PIR compared with HIV− during the first 6 months on ART (Fig. 1a--c). However, the proportion of naive CD4+ T cells were significantly lower in PIR when comparing with GIR (P = 0.0026) and HIV− (P = 0.0029) at baseline (T0) (Fig. 1a). When looking at the distribution of CD4+ T-cell maturation subsets expressed as absolute counts at baseline, we found that all four CD4+ T-cell subsets were decreased in HIV+ compared to HIV− (Supplementary Figure 4A). This pattern remained similar when dichotomizing the HIV+ cohort in individuals with GIR and PIR (Supplementary Figure 4A). Interestingly, at T6 (6 months post-ART), both GIR and PIR had significantly lower frequencies of naive CD4+ T cells compared with HIV− (P = 0.0192 and P = 0.0028, respectively) but similar levels between them (Fig. 1c). However, we found that PIR had significantly lower absolute number of naive CD4+ T cells compared with GIR at T2 and T6 (P = 0.0116 and P = 0.0.026, respectively, Supplementary Figure 5). We were unable to compare absolute numbers between HIV− and HIV+ GIR and PIR after ART initiation as absolute CD4+ T-cell counts were not available for the HIV− cohort at follow-up. There were no changes in the frequency of CD4+ T-cell differentiation subsets (naïve, central memory, effector memory, TEMRA) across HIV− and HIV+ (GIR and PIR) individuals during the entire follow-up period (Supplementary Figure 6).
Fig. 1.
PIR have fewer naive CD4+ T cells than GIR pre-ART but not after 6 months on ART.
Frequencies (%) of peripheral blood naïve (CD45RO- CCR7+), central memory (CM, CD45RO+ CCR7+), effector memory (EM, CD45RO+ CCR7-) and effector memory RA+ (TEMRA, CD45RO- CCR7-) T cells were identified by flow cytometry in GIR (green squares, n = 28), PIR (red squares, n = 13) and HIV- (blue, rounds n = 14) individuals. Frequency (%) of the CD4+ T-cell subpopulations were measured (a) before ART/PrEP, (b) 2/3 months and (c) 6 months after ART/PrEP initiation. Scatter plots were used to represent the data. Horizontal lines indicate median values. Each symbol represents one individual. Groups were compared using Kruskal--Wallis test correcting for multiple comparisons using Dunn's multiple comparisons test. Only significant corrected P values are shown in the graphs. ART, antiretroviral therapy; GIR, good immune reconstitution; HIV+, HIV-infected; HIV−, HIV-uninfected; NS, not significant; PIR, poor immune reconstitution; PrEP, preexposure prophylaxis.
Individuals with poor immune reconstitution have lower absolute number of recent thymic emigrants pre-antiretroviral therapy and after 6 months on antiretroviral therapy
As the main focus of our work was to understand the contribution of the thymus to immune recovery following ART initiation, we measured the fraction of naive CD4+ T cells (CCR7+ CD45RO−) that expressed CD31+, defined here as RTEs in terms of frequencies and absolute numbers. We found no differences in the frequency of RTEs when comparing HIV− with HIV+ or when comparing GIR and PIR (Supplementary Figure 7). However, we found that at study entry, HIV+ individuals, irrespective of having a GIR or PIR, had significantly fewer absolute numbers of RTEs compared to HIV− (P < 0.0001, Fig. 2a). After ART initiation, individuals with GIR had significantly more RTEs than PIR at T2 and T6 (P = 0.026 and P = 0.033, respectively, Fig. 2b). When we looked at changes in RTEs (absolute numbers and frequencies) throughout the 6-month study period, we found that GIR showed an increase in RTEs between T0 and T2 (P = 0.0025), whereas PIR increased their RTEs between T2 and T6 (P = 0.0320) (Fig. 2c and d). Importantly, we found that the absolute number of RTEs correlated with CD4+ gains (ΔCD4+) in GIR group (rho = 0.54, P = 0.0029) but not in the PIR group at the 6-month time point (Table 2). This association remained significant when analyzing CD4+ recovery continuously without subdividing the HIV+ cohort in GIR and PIR (rho = 0.486, P = 0.0013, Supplementary Table 3). However, when adjusting for pre-ART CD4+ T-cell counts, differences observed in the absolute number of RTEs in GIR and PIR at 2 and 6 months, respectively, were lost (unadjusted P = 0.009; 95% CI 89.700–13.392 and adjusted P = 0.763; 95% CI 14.035–10.316). This is most probably because of the fact that individuals with lower pre-ART CD4+ cell counts have a more robust CD4+ recovery.
Fig. 2.
Individuals with PIR have lower absolute number of recent thymic emigrants pre-ART and after 6 months on ART.
The absolute number of recent thymic emigrants (RTEs) was calculated as described elsewhere [34]. (a) Comparison of the absolute number (#) of RTEs in HIV− (blue rounds, n = 14), HIV+ (black squares, n = 41) individuals and in HIV− (blue rounds, n = 14), GIR (green squares, n = 28), PIR (red squares, n = 13) before antiretroviral treatment (baseline). Groups were compared using Mann--Whitney test (HIV− vs. HIV+) and Kruskal--Wallis test correcting for multiple comparisons using the Dunn's multiple comparisons test (HIV−, GIR and PIR). (b) Comparison of GIR (green squares, n = 28) and PIR (red squares, n = 13) at 2 and 6 months post-ART initiation. Groups were compared using Mann--Whitney test. Absolute number of RTEs could not be calculated for HIV− individuals at 3 and 6 months post-PrEP initiation as absolute CD4+ T-cell counts were not available to us. Scatter plots were used to represent the data. Horizontal lines indicate median values. Each symbol represents one individual. (c) Dynamics in the absolute numbers of RTEs (#) for GIR (green squares, n = 28) and PIR (red squares, n = 13) during the follow-up period is shown. (d) Dynamics in the frequencies of RTEs (#) for GIR (green squares, n = 28) and PIR (red squares, n = 13) during the follow-up period is shown. Each symbol and line represents one individual. Matched samples were compared using Friedman test correcting for multiple comparisons using Dunn's multiple comparisons test. Only significant corrected P values are shown in the graphs. ART, antiretroviral therapy; GIR, good immune reconstitution; HIV+, HIV-infected; HIV−, HIV-uninfected; NS, not significant; PIR, poor immune reconstitution; PrEP, preexposure prophylaxis.
Table 2.
Correlations between the absolute number of recent thymic emigrants, CD4+ gains and immune activation after 6 months on antiretroviral therapy.
GIR (rho and P) | PIR (rho and P) | ||
Absolute numbers of RTEs and CD4+ gains at T6 | |||
# RTEs | Rho = 0.542; P = 0.029 | ΔCD4 | Rho = −0.22; P = 0.461 |
Absolute number of RTEs and immune activation | |||
# RTEs | Rho = −0.486; P = 0.0087 | %CD38+ HLADR+ CD8+ | Rho = −0.802; P = 0.0016 |
# RTEs | Rho = −0.400; P = 0.0349 | %CD38+ HLADR+ CD4+ | Rho = −0.824; P = 0.0009 |
Correlations were performed using nonparametric Spearman test. #, absolute numbers, %, frequency; CD, cluster of differentiation; ΔCD4+, CD4+ gains between T6 and T0; GIR, good immune reconstitution; PIR, poor immune reconstitution; RTEs, recent thymic emigrants.
CD4+ and CD8+ T-cell activation inversely correlate with the absolute number of recent thymic emigrants
The lack of immune reconstitution has been linked to chronic immune activation. Next, we measured the level of immune activation by using CD38+ and HLADR on total CD4+ and CD8+ T cells. As expected, the frequency of activated total CD4+ and CD8+ T cells was higher in HIV+ individuals (both GIR and PIR) compared with HIV− (Supplementary Figure 8 A--F). After ART initiation, the frequency of activated total CD4+ and CD8+ T cells decreased in HIV+ individuals (both GIR and PIR), but not to levels comparable with HIV− (Supplementary Figure 8 A--F). Interestingly, when looking at T-cell activation over the entire follow-up period (6 months) within each group, we found that CD8+ T-cell immune activation decreases at T2 (P = 0.0012) and T6 (P < 0.0001) compared with baseline for GIR. For PIR, the decrease in CD8+ T-cell activation was only seen after 6 months on ART (P < 0.0001) (Supplementary Figure 9 A--F). We found that CD4+ and CD8+ T-cell immune activation were inversely correlated with the absolute number of RTEs for both GIR and PIR, and when analyzing CD4+ recovery continuously (Table 2 and Supplementary Table 3). When examining the relationship between RTEs and CD4+ recovery adjusting for CD8+ T-cell activation, we found that this relationship was not significantly attenuated (unadjusted P value: P < 0001; 95% CI: 0.250--0.315, adjusted P value: P < 0.0001; 95% CI 0.254--0.327). Also, we found no correlation between CD8+ T-cell activation and immune recovery (ΔCD4) in the GIR or PIR group or when analyzed continuously.
Recent thymic emigrants from HIV+ individuals with good immune reconstitution and poor immune reconstitution are cycling and expressing more programmed death-1 than HIV−
Next, we explored the phenotypic characteristics of RTEs, and we focused on the expression of four markers: Ki67 (cycling), CD57 (senescence), PD-1 (exhaustion) and CD38+ and HLADR (cellular activation). There were no significant differences in the level of expression for CD57+ and HLADR/CD38+ between GIR or PIR at T0, T2 nor T6 (Supplementary Figure 10). As shown in Fig. 3, at baseline (T0), the percentage of RTEs expressing Ki67 (cycling) is significantly higher in HIV+ compared with HIV− (P = 0.003) and in both GIR and PIR compared with HIV− (P = 0.0143, P = 0.0012. respectively) (Fig. 3a). After ART initiation, cycling remains high in GIR vs. HIV− at T2 (P = 0.0296) and between PIR and HIV− at T6 (P = 0.0167) (Fig. 3b and c). There is a significant increase in PD-1 expression at T0 and T6 in HIV+ compared with HIV− (T0 P = 0.0336; T6 P < 0.0001; Fig. 3d and f) and for GIR and PIR compared with HIV− at T6 (P = 0.0008, P = 0.0002, respectively, Fig. 3f). The proportion of RTEs expressing Ki67, PD-1, CD57 and HLADR/CD38 did not change over the period of follow-up (Supplementary Figure 11).
Fig. 3.
Recent thymic emigrants from individuals with good immune reconstitution and poor immune reconstitution are cycling and expressing more programmed death-1 than HIV−.
Frequencies (%) of peripheral blood RTEs (defined as CD3+ CD4+ CD45RO- CCR7+ CD31+) that express Ki67 (a--c) or PD-1 (d--f) were identified by flow cytometry in HIV- (blue rounds, n = 14), HIV+ (black squares, n = 41), GIR (green squares, n = 28) and PIR (red squares, n = 13) individuals, before ART (T0, a and d) and 2/3 months (b and e) and 6 months (c and f) after ART/PrEP initiation. Graphs scatter plots were used to represent the data. Horizontal lines indicate median values. Each symbol represents one individual. Groups were compared using Mann--Whitney test (HIV− vs. HIV+) and Kruskal--Wallis test correcting for multiple comparisons using the Dunn's multiple comparisons test (HIV−, GIR and PIR). Only significant corrected P values are shown in the graphs. ART, antiretroviral therapy; GIR, good immune reconstitution; HIV+, HIV-infected; HIV−, HIV-uninfected; NS, not significant; PIR, poor immune reconstitution; PrEP, preexposure prophylaxis.
Discussion
Antiretroviral therapy has one main goal, suppress HIV plasma viremia to undetectable levels; the second therapeutic goal is to reverse the damage incurred to the immune system at the hands of HIV. The lack of immune reconstitution is common among HIV+ treated individuals [3,35,36]. As previously reported [3,36], and as observed in our cohort, we found that one in three HIV+ individuals failed to achieve good immune reconstitution after 6 months on ART. Understanding the mechanisms associated with CD4+ T-cell recovery or the lack thereof, is important so that therapeutic options might be thought of. In this study, we aimed to evaluate early immune responses after ART initiation focusing on thymic output. Our results are in line with other studies [37,38] showing that HIV+ individuals have a skewed phenotype towards higher circulating levels of effector memory and TEMRA and lower circulating levels of naive and central memory CD4+ T cells, and that this skewed phenotype is not immediately normalized after ART initiation. Interestingly, HIV+ individuals with PIR had fewer naive CD4+ T cells at baseline and 2 months after ART, compared with HIV+ individuals with GIR when expressed as frequencies. Absolute numbers of naive CD4+ T cells were significantly lower in PIR compared with GIR at 2 and 6 months after ART.
As elegantly shown by others [19], the naive CD4+ peripheral T-cell pool is maintained by homeostatic proliferation of mature naive CD4+ T cells and the production of new naive CD4+ T cells by the thymus. Thymic export can be inferred by assessing naive CD4+ T cells expressing CD31+, known as RTEs. RTEs are phenotypically and functionally distinct from mature naive CD4+ T cells [14]. We found that HIV+ individuals had fewer absolute numbers of RTEs compared with the HIV− group, as previously reported [19–22,23,24]. As others have also shown [23,29,30], HIV+ with GIR have increased levels of circulating RTEs compared with those with PIR after ART initiation. Furthermore, our data shows that the increase in circulating RTEs can be detected as early as 2 months after ART initiation in the GIR group, whereas there seems to be a delay in thymic output in HIV+ individuals with PIR. Whether RTEs are a true reflection of thymic reactivation or a redistribution of RTEs from lymphoid tissues is unknown to us. RTEs have been shown to preferentially home to lymphoid tissues [39] with a greater bias for their retention in the tissues [40]. We found that the absolute number of RTEs was directly associated with the gain of CD4+ T cells at 6 months post-ART [41,42], further evidencing that RTEs are key participants in maintaining CD4+ T-cell pool homeostasis during treated HIV infection.
Immune activation is one of the main mechanisms driving CD4+ T-cell depletion, and although this decreases significantly after ART initiation, it rarely normalizes to levels comparable with those seen among HIV− [43–46]. Our data mirrors the previously established concepts, with both CD4+ and CD8+ T-cell activation remaining high after ART initiation. We also showed that both CD4+ and CD8+ T-cell activation was inversely correlated with the absolute number of RTEs. However, CD8+ T-cell activation did not correlate with immune recovery (ΔCD4), suggesting that factors others than immune activation might be influencing thymic output (#RTEs) and immune recovery (ΔCD4). Immune activation has also been shown to drive phenotypic alterations in both CD4+ and CD8+ T cells, with increased expression of senescence and exhaustion markers [47–49]. We found that the frequency of PD-1-expressing RTEs was significantly elevated in HIV+, with no differences between HIV+ with GIR and PIR. Indeed, RTEs are exposed to sustained levels of immune activation in the periphery and during passage through lymph nodes, and in order to downregulate this stimulatory environment, they express PD-1 [47,50–52].
Postthymic proliferation of RTEs is necessary for maintaining CD4+ naive T-cell homeostasis, especially during lymphopenic conditions, such as HIV infection [53,54]. We found that RTEs from HIV+ individuals cycled more (increased expression of Ki67) compared with HIV− group. With our current results, we cannot comment as to whether the observed increase in RTE cycling might be caused by compensatory response to an accelerated loss of the pool of naive CD4+ T cells [55–57], driven by continuous stimulation by cytokines or low-avidity T-cell receptor (TCR) antigens [58] or by direct cytopathic effect of HIV [21,55]. As immune reconstitution relies on the appropriate activation, clonal expansion and homeostatic proliferation of the naive CD4+ T-cell compartment, quantitative and qualitative alterations within this compartment, in particular RTEs, are likely to impact the ability of HIV+ individuals to successfully reconstitute their immune system.
We fully acknowledge that our study has several limitations, including a short follow-up period. Also, we didn’t assess thymic size by computed tomography scan nor did we quantify TCR excision circles (TREC) in sorted CD31+ naive CD4+ T cells to accurately define RTEs. To the best of our knowledge, surface expression of CD31+ on naive CD4+ T cells define a peripheral T-cell subset that recently completed thymic development and egress [59]. Our definition of poor versus good immune reconstitution was driven by our cohort characteristics and after reviewing the literature, and was based on CD4+ T cells gains rather than an absolute CD4+ T-cell count above a specific threshold. Currently, there is no consensus on what defines suboptimal immunological responses nor the specific period of time that has to pass on ART. When adjusting for pre-ART CD4+ cell counts, differences observed between GIR and PIR arm with regards to the absolute number of RTEs were lost, showing that early immune reconstitution is confounded by many factors. Conversely, our study is strengthened by the inclusion of longitudinal follow-up of both HIV+ and HIV− individuals and the inclusion of men only, eliminating the influence of sex on differences in both immune responses to ART and absolute CD4+ T-cell counts [60].
In conclusion, no differences in the expression of Ki67, CD57+, PD-1, CD38+ and HLADR were observed between HIV+ individuals with good and poor immune reconstitution. We also found that CD8+ T-cell immune activation decreased as early as 2 months post-ART initiation in individuals with GIR, and only at month 6 post-ART in individuals with PIR. We show that RTEs are linked to CD4+ T-cell recovery and that the degree of immune reconstitution is not directly linked to persistent immune activation.
Acknowledgements
Authors would like to thank all individuals for participating in this study. The authors would also like to thank QC. Ramón Hernández (Laboratorio de Diagnóstico Viral, CIENI-INER), QC. Edna Rodríguez (Blood collection team, CIENI-INER), QC. Silvia del Arenal (Sample manager, CIENI-INER), Psych. Manuel Becerril (Protocol liaison between CIENI-INER and Clínica Especializada Condesa, Cuidad de México, México). We would also like to thank Dr Michael Lederman, from Case Western Reserve University, Cleveland, Ohio, for critically revising the manuscript. The authors would also like to thank the two anonymous reviewers for their comments, which undoubtedly improved the manuscript.
Author contributions
Funding acquisition: G.R.T.; conception: G.R.T., S.P.C., O.B., A.P.P.; design: G.R.T., S.P.C., O.B., A.P.P.; project administration: A.P.P., S.P.C., M.C.T.; resources: G.R.T., A.P.P.; technical performance: O.B., S.P.C., M.C.T., D.G.R.; data curation: A.P.P., O.B., M.C.T., S.P.C., K.R., D.G.R.; analysis: O.B., S.P.C. D.G.R.; Writing: O.B., S.P.C.; writing – review and editing: S.P.C. and G.R.T.
This work was supported by grants from the Mexican Government (Comisión de Equidad y Género de las legislaturas LX-LXI and comisión de equidad y género de la legislatura LXII de la H. Cámara de Diputados de la República mexicana). The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish or preparation of the manuscript.
Conflicts of interest
There are no conflicts of interest.
Supplementary Material
References
- 1.Kelley CF, Kitchen CMR, Hunt PW, Rodriguez B, Hecht FM, Kitahata M, et al. Incomplete peripheral CD4+ cell count restoration in HIV-infected patients receiving long-term antiretroviral treatment. Clin Infect Dis 2009; 48:787–794. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 2.Marziali M, De Santis W, Carello R, Leti W, Esposito A, Isgrò A, et al. T-cell homeostasis alteration in HIV-1 infected subjects with low CD4 T-cell count despite undetectable virus load during HAART. AIDS 2006; 20:2033–2041. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 3.Moore DM, Harris R, Lima V, Hogg B, May M, Yip B, et al. Antiretroviral Therapy Cohort Collaboration. Effect of baseline CD4 cell counts on the clinical significance of short-term immunologic response to antiretroviral therapy in individuals with virologic suppression. J Acquir Immune Defic Syndr 2009; 52:357–363. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 4.Baker JV, Peng G, Rapkin J, Krason D, Reilly C, Cavert WP, et al. Poor initial CD4+ recovery with antiretroviral therapy prolongs immune depletion and increases risk for AIDS and non-AIDS diseases. J Acquir Immune Defic Syndr 2008; 48:541–546. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 5.Lewden C, Chene G, Morlat P, Raffi F, Dupon M, Dellamonica P, et al. Agence Nationale de Recherches sur le Sida et les Hepatites Virales (ANRS) CO8 APROCO-COPILOTE Study Group; Agence Nationale de Recherches sur le Sida et les Hepatites Virales (ANRS) CO3 AQUITAINE Study Group. HIV-infected adults with a CD4 cell count greater than 500 cells/mm3 on long-term combination antiretroviral therapy reach same mortality rates as the general population. J Acquir Immune Defic Syndr 2007; 46:72–77. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 6.Zeng M, Smith AJ, Wietgrefe SW, Southern PJ, Schacker TW, Reilly CS, et al. Cumulative mechanisms of lymphoid tissue fibrosis and T cell depletion in HIV-1 and SIV infections. J Clin Invest 2011; 121:998–1008. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 7.Fernandez S, Price P, McKinnon EJ, Nolan RC, French MA. Low CD4+ T-cell counts in HIV patients receiving effective antiretroviral therapy are associated with CD4+ T-cell activation and senescence but not with lower effector memory T-cell function. Clin Immunol 2006; 120:163–170. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 8.Gougeon M-L. Apoptosis as an HIV strategy to escape immune attack. Nat Rev Immunol 2003; 3:392–404. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 9.Deeks SG. HIV infection, inflammation, immunosenescence, and aging. Annu Rev Med 2011; 62:141–155. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 10.Douek DC, Betts MR, Hill BJ, Little SJ, Lempicki R, Metcalf JA, et al. Evidence for increased T cell turnover and decreased thymic output in HIV infection. J Immunol 2001; 167:6663–6668. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 11.Sauce D, Larsen M, Fastenackels S, Pauchard M, Ait-Mohand H, Schneider L, et al. HIV disease progression despite suppression of viral replication is associated with exhaustion of lymphopoiesis. Blood 2011; 117:5142–5151. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 12.Li T, Wu N, Dai Y, Qiu Z, Han Y, Xie J, et al. Reduced thymic output is a major mechanism of immune reconstitution failure in HIV-infected patients after long-term antiretroviral therapy. Clin Infect Dis 2011; 53:944–951. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 13.Mackall CL, Hakim FT, Gress RE. Restoration of T-cell homeostasis after T-cell depletion. Semin Immunol 1997; 9:339–346. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 14.Cunningham CA, Helm EY, Fink PJ. Reinterpreting recent thymic emigrant function: defective or adaptive?. Curr Opin Immunol 2018; 51:1–6. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 15.Lu I-N, Ahmad F, Jacobs R, Schmidt RE, Meyer-Olson D. Optimal gating strategy for determining CD4+ recent thymic emigrants in human immunodeficiency virus-1 infected patients. Viral Immunol 2014; 27:179–184. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 16.Kimmig S, Przybylski GK, Schmidt CA, Laurisch K, Möwes B, Radbruch A, et al. Two subsets of naive T helper cells with distinct T cell receptor excision circle content in human adult peripheral blood. J Exp Med 2002; 195:789–794. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 17.Zakhour R, Tran DQ, Heresi GP, Degaffe G, Bell CS, Donnachie E, et al. CD31 expression on CD4+ cells: a simple method for quantitation of recent thymus emigrant CD4 cells. Am J Trop Med Hyg 2016; 95:970–972. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 18.Douaisi M, Resop RS, Nagasawa M, Craft J, Jamieson BD, Blom B, Uittenbogaart CH. CD31, a valuable marker to identify early and late stages of T cell differentiation in the human thymus. J Immunol 2017; 198:2310–2319. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 19.Douek DC, McFarland RD, Keiser PH, Gage EA, Massey JM, Haynes BF, et al. Changes in thymic function with age and during the treatment of HIV infection. Nature 1998; 396:690–695. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 20.Hatzakis A, Touloumi G, Karanicolas R, Karafoulidou A, Mandalaki T, Anastassopoulou C, et al. Effect of recent thymic emigrants on progression of HIV-1 disease. Lancet 2000; 355:599–604. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 21.Hazenberg MD, Otto SA, Cohen Stuart JW, Verschuren MC, Borleffs JC, Boucher CA, et al. Increased cell division but not thymic dysfunction rapidly affects the T-cell receptor excision circle content of the naive T cell population in HIV-1 infection. Nat Med 2000; 6:1036–1042. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 22.Zhang L, Lewin SR, Markowitz M, Lin HH, Skulsky E, Karanicolas R, et al. Measuring recent thymic emigrants in blood of normal and HIV-1-infected individuals before and after effective therapy. J Exp Med 1999; 190:725–732. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 23.Lewin SR, Ribeiro RM, Kaufmann GR, Smith D, Zaunders J, Law M, et al. Dynamics of T cells and TCR excision circles differ after treatment of acute and chronic HIV infection. J Immunol 2002; 169:4657–4666. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 24.He S, Zhang Z, Fu Y, Qin C, Li S, Han X, et al. Thymic Function Is Most Severely Impaired in Chronic HIV-1 Infection, but Individuals With Faster Disease Progression During Early HIV-1 Infection Expressed Lower Levels of RTEs. J Acquir Immune Defic Syndr 2015; 70:472–478. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 25.Rubio A, Martínez-Moya M, Leal M, Franco JM, Ruiz-Mateos E, Merchante E, et al. Changes in thymus volume in adult HIV-infected patients under HAART: correlation with the T-cell repopulation. Clin Exp Immunol 2002; 130:121–126. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 26.Ruiz-Mateos E, de la Rosa R, Soriano N, Martinez-Moya M, Rubio A, Sánchez-Quijano A, et al. Comparison of thymic function-related markers to predict early CD4 T-cell repopulation in adult HIV-infected patients on HAART. Antivir Ther 2003; 8:289–294. [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 27.de la Rosa R, Leal M, Rubio A, Martinez-Moya M, Delgado J, Ruíz-Mateos E, et al. Baseline thymic volume is a predictor for CD4 T cell repopulation in adult HIV-infected patients under highly active antiretroviral therapy. Antivir Ther 2002; 7:159–163. [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 28.Molina-Pinelo S, Vallejo A, Díaz L, Soriano-Sarabia N, Ferrando-Martínez S, Resino S, et al. Premature immunosenescence in HIV-infected patients on highly active antiretroviral therapy with low-level CD4 T cell repopulation. J Antimicrob Chemother 2009; 64:579–588. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 29.Resino S, Galán I, Pérez A, León JA, Seoane E, Gurbindo D, Muñoz-Fernandez MA. HIV-infected children with moderate/severe immune-suppression: changes in the immune system after highly active antiretroviral therapy. Clin Exp Immunol 2004; 137:570–577. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 30.Di Mascio M, Sereti I, Matthews LT, Natarajan V, Adelsberger J, Lempicki R, et al. Naïve T-cell dynamics in human immunodeficiency virus type 1 infection: effects of highly active antiretroviral therapy provide insights into the mechanisms of naive T-cell depletion. J Virol 2006; 80:2665–2674. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 31.Lu I, Eberhard J, Ahmad F, Bhatnagar N, Behrens G, Jacobs R, et al. Elevated CD57 and CD95 expressions are associated with lower numbers of CD4+ recent thymic emigrants in HIV-1 infected immune responders following antiretroviral treatment. Immunol Lett 2014; 158:1–6. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 32.Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC). Update to interim guidance for preexposure prophylaxis (PrEP) for the prevention of HIV infection: PrEP for injecting drug users. MMWR Morb Mortal Wkly Rep 2013; 62:463–465. [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 33.Briceño O, Pinto-Cardoso S, Rodríguez-Bernabe N, Murakami-Ogasawara A, Reyes-Terán G. Gut homing CD4+ and CD8+ T-cell frequencies in HIV infected individuals on antiretroviral treatment. PloS One 2016; 11:e0166496. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 34.Aguilera-Sandoval CR, Yang OO, Jojic N, Lovato P, Chen DY, Boechat MI, et al. Supranormal thymic output up to 2 decades after HIV-1 infection. AIDS 2016; 30:701–711. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 35.Bouteloup V, Sabin C, Mocroft A, Gras L, Pantazis N, Le Moing V, et al. Standard Reference Distribution of CD4 Response to HAART Project Team for the Collaboration of Observational HIV Epidemiological Research Europe (COHERE) in EuroCoord. Reference curves for CD4 T-cell count response to combination antiretroviral therapy in HIV-1-infected treatment-naïve patients. HIV Med 2017; 18:33–44. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 36.Yotebieng M, Maskew M, Van Rie A. CD4+ gain percentile curves for monitoring response to antiretroviral therapy in HIV-infected adults. AIDS 2015; 29:1067–1075. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 37.Robbins GK, Spritzler JG, Chan ES, Asmuth DM, Gandhi RT, Rodriguez BA, et al. AIDS Clinical Trials Group 384 Team. Incomplete reconstitution of T cell subsets on combination antiretroviral therapy in the AIDS Clinical Trials Group protocol 384. Clin Infect Dis 2009; 48:350–361. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 38.Lederman MM, Calabrese L, Funderburg NT, Clagett B, Medvik K, Bonilla H, et al. Immunologic failure despite suppressive antiretroviral therapy is related to activation and turnover of memory CD4 cells. J Infect Dis 2011; 204:1217–1226. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 39.Nokta MA, Li X-D, Al-Harthi L, Nichols J, Pou A, Asmuth D, et al. Entrapment of recent thymic emigrants in lymphoid tissues from HIV-infected patients: association with HIV cellular viral load. AIDS 2002; 16:2119–2127. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 40.Diaz M, Douek DC, Valdez H, Hill BJ, Peterson D, Sanne I, et al. T cells containing T cell receptor excision circles are inversely related to HIV replication and are selectively and rapidly released into circulation with antiretroviral treatment. AIDS 2003; 17:1145–1149. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 41.Lecossier D, Bouchonnet F, Schneider P, Clavel F, Hance AJ. Centre de Recherche Integré sur le VIH Bichat-Claude Bernard. Discordant increases in CD4+ T cells in human immunodeficiency virus-infected patients experiencing virologic treatment failure: role of changes in thymic output and T cell death. J Infect Dis 2001; 183:1009–1016. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 42.Berzins SP, Godfrey DI, Miller JF, Boyd RL. A central role for thymic emigrants in peripheral T cell homeostasis. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 1999; 96:9787–9791. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 43.d’Ettorre G, Paiardini M, Ceccarelli G, Silvestri G, Vullo V. HIV-associated immune activation: from bench to bedside. AIDS Res Hum Retroviruses 2011; 27:355–364. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 44.Gandhi RT, Spritzler J, Chan E, Asmuth DM, Rodriguez B, Merigan TC, et al. ACTG 384 Team. Effect of baseline- and treatment-related factors on immunologic recovery after initiation of antiretroviral therapy in HIV-1-positive subjects: results from ACTG 384. J Acquir Immune Defic Syndr 1999 2006; 42:426–434. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 45.Piconi S, Trabattoni D, Gori A, Parisotto S, Magni C, Meraviglia P, et al. Immune activation, apoptosis, and Treg activity are associated with persistently reduced CD4+ T-cell counts during antiretroviral therapy. AIDS 2010; 24:1991–2000. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 46.Manjati T, Nkambule B, Ipp H. Immune activation is associated with decreased thymic function in asymptomatic, untreated HIV-infected individuals. South Afr J HIV Med 2016; 17:445. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 47.Cobos Jiménez V, Wit FWNM, Joerink M, Maurer I, Harskamp AM, Schouten J, et al. AGEhIV Study Group. T-cell activation independently associates with immune senescence in HIV-infected recipients of long-term antiretroviral treatment. J Infect Dis 2016; 214:216–225. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 48.Deeks SG, Tracy R, Douek DC. Systemic effects of inflammation on health during chronic HIV infection. Immunity 2013; 39:633–645. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 49.Al-Harthi L, Voris J, Patterson BK, Becker S, Eron J, Smith KY, et al. Evaluation of the impact of highly active antiretroviral therapy on immune recovery in antiretroviral naive patients. HIV Med 2004; 5:55–65. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 50.Lin S-J, Peacock CD, Bahl K, Welsh RM. Programmed death-1 (PD-1) defines a transient and dysfunctional oligoclonal T cell population in acute homeostatic proliferation. J Exp Med 2007; 204:2321–2333. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 51.Hassan J, Reen DJ. Human recent thymic emigrants--identification, expansion, and survival characteristics. J Immunol 2001; 167:1970–1976. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 52.Cockerham LR, Jain V, Sinclair E, Glidden DV, Hartogenesis W, Hatano H, et al. Programmed death-1 expression on CD4+ and CD8+ T cells in treated and untreated HIV disease. AIDS 2014; 28:1749–1758. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 53.Silva SL, Sousa AE. Establishment and Maintenance of the human naïve CD4+ T-cell compartment. Front Pediatr 2016; 4:119. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 54.Houston EG, Higdon LE, Fink PJ. Recent thymic emigrants are preferentially incorporated only into the depleted T-cell pool. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 2011; 108:5366–5371. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 55.Lempicki RA, Kovacs JA, Baseler MW, Adelsberger JW, Dewar RL, Natarajan V, et al. Impact of HIV-1 infection and highly active antiretroviral therapy on the kinetics of CD4+ and CD8+ T cell turnover in HIV-infected patients. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 2000; 97:13778–13783. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 56.Sauce D, Larsen M, Fastenackels S, Roux A, Gorochov G, Katlama C, et al. Lymphopenia-driven homeostatic regulation of naive T cells in elderly and thymectomized young adults. J Immunol 2012; 189:5541–5548. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 57.Goldrath AW, Bogatzki LY, Bevan MJ. Naive T cells transiently acquire a memory-like phenotype during homeostasis-driven proliferation. J Exp Med 2000; 192:557–564. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 58.Kilpatrick RD, Rickabaugh T, Hultin LE, Hultin P, Hausner MA, Detels R, et al. Homeostasis of the naive CD4+ T cell compartment during aging. J Immunol 2008; 180:1499–1507. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 59.Adams SP, Kricke S, Ralph E, Gilmour N, Gilmour KC. A comparison of TRECs and flow cytometry for naive T cell quantification. Clin Exp Immunol 2018; 191:198–202. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 60.Maskew M, Brennan AT, Westreich D, McNamara L, MacPhail AP, Fox MP. Gender differences in mortality and CD4 count response among virally suppressed HIV-positive patients. J Womens Health (Larchmt) 2013; 22:113–120. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
Associated Data
This section collects any data citations, data availability statements, or supplementary materials included in this article.